Talk:Paper - The Maturation of the Human Ovum: Difference between revisions

From Embryology
(Created page with "{{Header}} Thomson, A. The Maturation of the Human Ovum. J Anat. 1919 Apr;53(Pt 2-3):172-208.5. PMID 17103860 :'''Links:''' O...")
 
mNo edit summary
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Header}}
Nature 135, 295-295 (23 February 1935) | doi:10.1038/135295a0


Thomson, A. [[Paper_-_The Maturation of the Human Ovum|The Maturation of the Human Ovum]]. J Anat. 1919 Apr;53(Pt 2-3):172-208.5. PMID 17103860
Prof. Arthur Thomson


Abstract


:'''Links:''' [[Oocyte Development]] | [[:Category:Oocyte|Category:Oocyte]]
ON his retirement in 1933, Prof. Arthur Thomson, whose death on February 7 will be widely regretted, had completed a somewhat unusual record of academic service. He was born on March 21, 1858, and for forty-eight years he represented human anatomy at the University of Oxford, first as University lecturer in human anatomy and afterwards as Dr. Lee’s professor of anatomy. After serving an apprenticeship in the famous school of anatomy at Edinburgh under Sir William Turner, Thomson went to Oxford in 1885. Unlike many of his later contemporaries, he did not enjoy the advantage of stepping into a department already equipped for teaching and research. On the contrary, the task fell to him of building up a new department from its very foundations. It will readily be appreciated that Thomson’s energies were fully employed for a number of years in developing the teaching side of his department to a level appropriate to the medical faculty of the University of Oxford, a task which was rendered very laborious at first by the criticism and opposition of some members of the University who were less ready to appreciate the importance of catering for an extensive and detailed medical curriculum.
 
 
'''Note''' - ''discus proligerus'' is an historic term for granulosa cells surrounding the oocyte and forming the cumulus oophorus.
 
{{Historic Disclaimer}}
 
=The Maturation of the Human Ovum=
 
By Arthur Thomson
 
 
Professor of Human Anatomy, University of Oxford
 
:The expenses of illustrating this paper were defrayed by the Medical Research Committee.
 
 
The Human Anatomist is handicapped by the nature of the material with
which he has to deal. More particularly is this the case when the problem
attacked involves the recognition of delicate changes in cellular structure.
It is only exceptionally, as in operation cases, that he can get his tissues
fresh. Under ordinary circumstances a considerable period must have elapsed,
amounting in some cases to days, before the organ or tissue desired can be
obtained post-mortem.
 
 
Further, the time and manner of death may exercise important influences
on the condition of the parts to be examined, for it will be obvious that if
death occur during the warm summer months the putrefactive changes that
ensue Will be more rapid than those occurring in a cold season. Similarly the
processesinvolved in death after prolonged illness a.re likely to produce changes
in the tissues of an abnormal kind, differing in this respect from those met
with in sudden death either by accident or acute disease.
 
 
From all, or most of these conditions, the zoologist is happily free. Engaged in a like or similar enquiry, he can kill the animal selected whilst still
in a normal condition, and thus obtain its tissues and organs fresh. Subjected
alike to similar processes of fixation and staining, the results obtained from
these two different sources of supply, human, as distinct from animal, must
necessarily vary iii the refinement and delicacy of the appearances observed
though what the resulting differences may be when comparing the “fresh”
with the “stale” tissue, is still a matter of doubt.
 
 
In such an enquiry as that here involved, we must be content with What
We can get. In the present instance the specimens examined have all been
obtained from women who died suddenly or were accidentally killed, but the
necessary delay incurred in obtaining and performing a post-mortem examination must militate against the freshness of the material examined. Of the
possible changes that may intervene during the period of death and fixation
we are ignorant, and Whilst admitting that some such changes may affect
the more delicate structures involved, such as the fibrillar appearance of the
asters and-the arrangement of the chromosomes, there is sufficient evidence
to justify us in assuming that the grosser phenomena involved in the division
of the egg, such as the position of the nucleus, the presence or absence of a
nuclear membrane, the occurrence of centrospheres and the presence of polar bodies can all be identified, though possibly in a form differing somewhat
from those met with in the fresher material.
 
The utmost care has been exercised in the fixing, cutting, mounting and
staining of the tissues examined. Where possible complete serial sections of
the eggs examined have been reproduced, on a reduced scale, so that in the
plates provided a complete conspectus of the contents of the egg is available.
 
Thanks to the great industry and skill of my Laboratory Assistant,
Mr W. Chesterman, to whose ability and enthusiasm I am greatly indebted,
the sections obtained are as good as the conditions permit.
 
A word or two as to the method of illustration adopted. As the result of
our united efforts, Mr Chesterman has acquired a high degree of skill in the
production of photomicrographs, these I have utilised without exception in
the present paper, for, though laying claim to some experience as a draughtsman, I have come to the conclusion that well executed microphotographs are
of much more value than elaborately executed drawings; in the latter the
draughtsman is unwittingly led to emphasise those details which he thinks
of importance, whilst at the same time he may omit features which for the
 
' time being he considers of little moment. In numerous instances a structure
 
which at first appeared of no account has been found subsequently to form a
link in the chain of evidence.
 
The production of such microphotographs is tedious and tiresome, and
demands an intimate knowledge of the technique required, b11t the results, in
my opinion, justify the amount of labour and expense involved. In the present
instance the illustrations may be relied upon as affording an accurate record
of the appearances described. They are a record of the facts, the reader may
deduce from them such conclusions as he thinks justifiable—I ask no more.
 
In work of this kind, where delicate measurements are involved, I have
departed somewhat from the approved method, as I found it so irksome and
in some instances so difficult of application——I mean the use of the eyepiece
micrometer in conjunction with a stage micrometer. W hat has been done in
every case where a photomicrograph was taken was to introduce at the same
time and under similar conditions of the optical arrangement a stage micrometer, so that the degree of magnification could be accurately gauged on the
ground glass of the camera. In this way the amplification of the image on
the positive or negative photograph was accurately known, and by a simple
calculation in reduction, the magnification being known, the precise measurements of the various details exhibited in the sections were readily deduced
from their measurement on the print.
 
In regard to the present enquiry — the maturation stages of the human egg
— no observations, so far as I know, have yet been published. It may be that
like or similar appearances have been seen, but hitherto no attempt has been
made to arrange them in their order of sequence.
 
Our conception of what occurs in the human female has hitherto been
based on our knowledge of what takes place in lower forms. So extensive is the literature of that subject that no reference need here be made to it, other
than to accept the general conclusions based upon it as set forth in the various
text-books on Human Anatomy, in which a general description of the changes
presumably involved, is set forth. It is assumed that the reader is familiar
with one or other of these accounts, and consequently space has been economised by taking such information for granted. It may be stated broadly
that the results obtained conform to the general plan of the descriptions given
as applicable to the mammalian type, the only point of difference, as will be subsequently explained, depending on the solution of the question asto
whether or no the oocyte in man is mature, i.e. has passed through the stages
of its first and second division, before it leaves the ovary. It appears on the
authority of numerous observers that this is not the rule in’ Vertebrates, and
that the sperm enters the ovum during the stage of the second maturation
division. If this be so, it will appear on the evidence adduced that man is an
exception to the rule. The details, however, on which this and other conclusions are based, had better be postponed until the eggs have been fully
examined. We will therefore proceed forthwith with their description.
 
 
[[File:Thomson1919 fig01.jpg|600px]]
 
 
'''Fig. 1.''' Human ovum in discus proligerus in early part of prophase of first division. 1x 600.
 
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 
the literature of that subject that no reference need here be made to it, other
than to accept the general conclusions based upon it as set forth in the various
text-books on Human Anatomy, in which a general description of the changes
presumably involved, is set forth. It is assumed that the reader is familiar
with one or other of these accounts, and consequently space has been economised by taking such information for granted. It may be stated broadly
that the results obtained conform to the general plan of the descriptions given
as applicable to the mammalian type, the only point of difference, as will
 
Fig. 1. Human ovum in discus proligerus in early part of prophase of first division. 1x 600.
 
be subsequently explained, depending on the solution of the question as to
whether or no the oocyte in man is mature, i.e. has passed through the stages
of its first and second division, before it leaves the ovary. It appears on the
authority of numerous observers that this is not the rule in’ Vertebrates, and
that the sperm enters the ovum during the stage of the second maturation
division. If this be so, it will appear on the evidence adduced that man is an
exception to the rule. The details, however, on which this and other conclusions are based, had better be postponed until the eggs have been fully
examined. We will therefore proceed forthwith with their description. Here let me say how much I am indebted to my friends holding pathological appointments for their ever ready help in providing me with suitable
material.
 
The first figure is that of a section, 0-007 mm. thick, stained with Mallory’s
Connective Tissue Stain, of an ovum in the discus proligerus of a Graafian
follicle from a woman aged 22 who died from a femoral hernia.
 
The egg including the Zona pellucida measures 0-1 x 0-09 1nm., measured
from the inner surface of the Zona pellucida its diameters are 0-097’ >< 0-08 mm.
 
It will be obvious from the figure and from the measures given that the
egg is not a sphere as so frequently described but as will be seen later exhibits
an oval form.
 
The cells of the Corona radiata are adherent to the external surface of the
Zona pellucida by slender filaments with spaces between.
 
The structure of the Zona pellucida is not homogeneous but shows a concentric lamination particularly towards the inner edge, it measures from
0-005 to 0-006 mm. in thickness.
 
At one point just opposite the centrosphere there is evidence of cellular
structure. 0 i
 
The cytoplasm, fairly uniform in character, is separated from the inner
wall of the Zona by what may be possibly a retraction cavity, some of the
cytoplasm remaining adherent to the inner surface of the Zona.
 
The nucleus, of size approximately 0-03 x 0-022 mm., is fairly central in
position, and has a faint a11d ill-defined nuclear membrane.
 
The arrangement of the chromatin is best realized by reference to the figure.
 
What appears to be the nucleolus breaking up is seen towards one end of
the nucleus.
 
The nucleus is in part separated from the surrounding cytoplasm by a
narrow cleft probably a retraction cavity though possibly it may be a space
filled with fluid derived from the karyoplasm.
 
At one extremity of the nucleus lying within the cytoplasm _jia.s-t 0-ut.s-7,'de
the falnt nuclear membrane is a small granule.
 
Lying to one side of the nucleus and in contact with the nuclear membrane,
which is here only faintly indicated, is a small sphere, 0-013 ><0-011 mm.,
consisting of a material so clear that it might be mistaken for a vacuole; it
 
has, however, an obvious structure and contains near its poles two more
darkly stained granules. ‘
 
' This object I take to be the Centrosphere, Attraction Sphere (Quain),
Archoplasm Sphere (McMurrich), Centrosome (Robinson), Microcentrum
(Heidenhain), Microsphere (Siedlecki), in the young oocyte sometimes called
the Idiosome (corresponding to the attraction sphere of other cells). Van
der Stricht identifies this with the Yolk nucleus or Body of Balbiani, as does
Jenkinson<ref>Vertebrate Embryology, Oxford, 1913, p. 72.</ref>, see also Wilson<ref>The Cell in Development and Inhcritancc, New York, 1900, p. 156.</ref>.
 
 
 
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 
 
but faint indications of structure, the fibrillar arcades being conspicuous by
their absence and the tissue intervening, between the outer surface of the
Zona pellucida and the innermost row of the cells of the Corona radiata on
one side of the egg, appears but faintly striated and granular, whereas on the
opposite side of the ovum the interval appears clearer as if occupied with
fluid—further, there is a breach in the continuity of the girdle of surrounding
coronal cells, as if by the penetration of the liquor folliculi, a stage, possibly,
in the liberation of the oocyte from the cells of the discus proligerus immediately around it. It may reasonably be assumed that the arcading of the tissue
connecting the cells of the Corona ra.diata with the Zona pellucida exhibited
in the previous figures is part of the same process, brought about by the
permeation of fluid (liq11or folliculi?) in between.
 
 
The Zona pellucida on the two sides of the egg exhibits a marked difference
in section, varying from 0-007 mm. on one side to 0-003 mm. on the opposite
side of the ovum, a difference due no doubt to the obliquity of the section.
 
 
The innermost, more homogeneous and ovular (‘?) layer of the Zona
pellucida alone remains, the external fibrillar or ovarian layer having now all
but disappeared on one side, whereason the other side it is reduced to a faint
reticulum. The Zona pellucida left exhibits traces of concentric lamination
with a suggestion at one point of cellular structure. In this specimen I can
see no evidence of radial striation.
 
 
Within the Zona the cytoplasm has shrunk excentrically from the inner
wall of the Zona pellucida, leaving on one hemisphere a considerable interval
between the two, whereas on the opposite side it forms a linear cleft. This
space is occupied by a fine clear granular material (coagulum?) exhibiting
three large vacuoles. In the substance of this material at the point where
the cavity is widest is a collection of chromatin grains arranged in nuclear
form and associated on one side with a small sphere of granular matter, undoubtedly both combined being the first (?) polar body.
 
 
If this be so, and there can be little doubt of it, then the question arises
whether this perivitelline space is an artefact or is a normal condition during
life, in which a fluid liberated from the cytoplasm fills the space. If this be so,
then the polar body, as seen in the section, will lie free in this fluid, and as it
is presumably of greater weight than the liquid by which it is surrounded,
this offers an explanation of how it sinks to one or other pole of the egg.
As to which, there is some difference of opinion, for whilst most observers
assign to it a position near the animal pole, Van der Strieht (see Quainl, p. 11)
on the other hand states that in the bat the polar bodies occupy a position
which afterwards becomes the vegetative pole. If, as we are led to believe,
the position of the vegetative pole is determined by the greater weight of the
deutoplasm rotating the egg in that direction, then, if the explanation of the
position of the polar bodies now offered be accepted, we have to some extent
a confirmation of Van der Stricht’s views, for the rotation of the egg and the
 
1 Quain’s Anatomy, vol. I. “Embryology," T. H. Bryce, London.
 
180 Arthur Thomson
 
position of the polar bodies may both result from the same cause, viz. the
action of gravity. There seems no evidence to show that the polar body always
remains in the position in which it is extruded from the cytoplasm, and there
is ground for supposing that the extrusion in an egg which is not truly spherical
may take place at some considerable distance from the polar axis, the‘ subsequent disposal of the polar body towards one or other pole of this axis being
possibly determined in the manner suggested.
 
In this specimen the cytoplasm exhibits remarkable characters. We may
assume that the appearance presented corresponds to the period immediately
after the expulsion of the first (?) polar body, and that the contents of the
oocyte display the phenomena associated with the anaphase condition of the
first division and the commencement of the metaphase condition of the second
division.
 
Three spheres are seen (the section was 0-01 mm. thick), lying, as may be
seen from the overlap of their outlines, one in front of the other.
 
The anterior one, if such a term may be used in this connexion, is a relatively large vesicle (0~03 x0-O26 mm.) containing a clear I faintly granular
material, the only appearance of definite structure being two faint thread-like
filaments of. granular appearance lying close to and parallel with each other.
The circumference of the vesicle is clearly defined from the surrounding
cytoplasm. Behind this, and in part overlapped by it, is another spherical
mass of approximately the same size. It consists of a mass of granular matter
of darker tint than that contained in the vesicle just described, yet lighter
than that of the surrounding cytoplasm. Scattered throughout its substance
are numerous chromatin granules, not, however, so far as one can-see, exhibiting any definite arrangement.
 
If this be the nuclear material of the daughter cell or Oocyte II, and there
is every reason to believe it is, then it appears at this stage to be absolutely
larger than the nuclei seen in figs. 1 and 2. The circumference of the nucleus,
though clearly defined from the surrounding cytoplasm, exhibits no evidence
of a nuclear membrane.
 
To the further side of the nuclear sphere, and in part covered by it, is a
third spherical body of approximately half the size. The difference in size
is misleading, for here it is cut unequally, as may be seen on examining
Fig. 4, which is the next section in series with it. In the present section this vesicle is only faintly differentiated from the surrounding cytoplasm, and A little if any details of structure are observable.
 
There can be little doubt but that the structures here described are the
nuclear material of the daughter cell in the middle with the two centrospheres
on either side of it, though, as will have been gathered from the description
given, these latter bodies exhibit no evidence of the fibrillation which one
would expect to see at this stage; that, however, may be a very transient
feature and one which does not militate against this assumption. The fact
that the first (?) polar body is seen immediately outside these active changes within the cytoplasm and nucleus, justifies us in thinking that the specimen
has been sectioned immediately after the extrusion of the first polar body,
and prior to the formation of the second polar body, the nuclear mass not
having meanwhile undergone the changes associated with the resting condition
which will succeed the extrusion of the second polar body.
 
Unfortunately the serial sections of this specimen are incomplete, so that
it is well nigh impossible to form any opinion as to the position or direction
of the plane of section, consequently it is difficult to determine whether the
section passes through the ovum close to the equator or nearer one or other
pole. For this reason the amount of the cytoplasm displayed in the section
may consist of but a proportion of that contained in the widest diameter of
the cell. ‘ i
 
As displayed in the figure it will be seen that the cytoplasm on the two
sides of the egg, at right angles to the position of the extruded polar body,
differs in character and appearance, this may be due possibly to the unequal
thickness of the section. On one side it appears darker, the granules appear
more deeply stained, particularly along thecircumference of the nuclear mass,
whereas on the other side, the cytoplasm is less dense, though still darker than
the substance of ‘the nuclear mass, and exhibits a cloudy appearance.
 
In the substance of the cytoplasm between the smaller centrosphere and
the periphery of the cytoplasm there is a small mass of more deeply stained
substance at the other end of the axis of which the polar body forms one
extremity. ,
 
As to whether this has any significance I must leave an open question. ‘
 
Fig. 4, thickness of section 0-01 mm., stained with Weigert’s Iron Haematoxylin and Van Giesen. This represents the appearance displayed by the
contiguous section to Fig. 3; it calls for less detailed description since it
represents many of the same details of structure already referred to in Fig. 3.
 
The essential points of difference are: first, that the section has passed
above or below the position of the polar body, thus giving us a clue to its size.
As the sections are 0-01 mm. thick it follows that the largest diameter of the
polar body cannot exceed that measure; second, the material (coagulum?)
filling the space between the cytoplasm and the Zona pellucida is uniform in
structure, and the large vacuoles have disappeared; third, the size of the three
spherical vesicles within the cytoplasm is more nearly equal, suggesting that
they have been cut in the axis of the amphiaster. Associated with each lateral
sphere, which, as we have already noted, is to be regarded as a centrosphere,
may be seen a darkly stained granule, occupying a position, if not quite in
the centre, at least near it. ’
 
These centrospheres are not so precisely defined from the surrounding
cytoplasm as in Fig. 3, nor are their contents so clear; but these are appearances which may be due to the density of the staining, or to the slight variation
in the thickness of the sections.
 
The nuclear material of the daughter cell, which lies intermediate in position between the two centrospheres, exhibits a granular appearance due to
the presence of chromatin grains, some of which are arranged in thread-like
fashion.
 
At one point in this mass there is however a definite clearly defined shieldshaped body, containing some highly refractive material, in the substance of
which are a few more deeply stained granules. What the significance of this
structure is I am not in a position to suggest. A
 
The cytoplasm around the centrospheres and nuclear mass appears darker
 
 
 
Fig. 4. Human ovum in discus proligerus in anaphase of first division and commencement of
metaphase of second division. x600.
 
on one side than the other, the darkest part lying in immediate relation to
the nuclear mass on that side where the clear body within the nuclear substance is situated. On the opposite side of the nuclear mass there is a fairly
large deeply stained granule. Around the centrospheres the cytoplasm
appears more deeply stained, thus helping to define clearly the circumference
of the spheres. '
 
In the lighter hemisphere of the cytoplasm, three or four more distinctly
stained granules may be seen towards the circumference of the cytoplasm.
 
The appearance of this section confirms in every respect the opinion set forth in respect of Fig. 3, that the specimen represents the anaphase condition of Oocyte II and the commencement of the metaphase condition and the
formation of the second polar body.
 
Plate X provides a conspectus of a complete series of sections of an oocyte
within the discus proligerus iii a Graafian follicle from the ovary of a woman,
aged 38, who died of heart failure, one day after admission to hospital.
 
There are 15 sections, each of 0-007 mm. thick, stained with Kernschwarz.
In these the egg or its covering appears in 13 sections, so that from this the
“ thickness” of the egg at right angles to the plane of section may be estimated
at 0-091 mm. The greatest diameter of the egg is met with in sect. 8, where
including the Zona pelluci(la it measures 0-11 x 0-1 mm. In this section the
diameters taken from the inner surface of the Zona pellucida measure
0-093 >< 0-083 mm.
 
The cells of the Corona radiata are separated from the outer surface of
the Zona pellucida by a clear space averaging about 0-006 mm. in width.
Stretching across this space, numerous groups of fine fibres, with clear intervals in between them, are seen connecting the bases of the inner row of cells
of the Corona radiata with the external surface of the Zona pellucida. The
intervals between the bundles of fibres are apparently caused by the permeation of fluid (liquor fo1liculi?), and as will be seen in Plate X, the cells of
the discus proligerus are being so separated up by the infiltration of the
liquor folliculi, that the Corona radiata, so-called, is reduced to but a single
row of cells in many parts of the sections shown.
 
The Zona pellucida, of an average thickness of about 0-008 mm., is seen
to consist mainly of the inner or ovular layer, the superficial layer, that
formed by the felting of the fibrils derived from the deep row of cells of the
Corona radiata, and consequently ovarian in origin, is now much reduced
in thickness, and is apparently undergoing disintegration owing to fluid infiltration throughout it.
 
The inner layer of the Zona pellucida does not new exhibit any evidence
of concentric lamination, but, as seen in sections 7, 8, 9 a.nd 10, shows marked
indications of radial striation. The change in the appearance of the Zona
pellucida is so marked in this specimen, as contrasted with the earlier figure,
as to suggest that some change i11 its structure is now taking place. It is
worthy of note that the innermost layer of it is more dense or deeply stained,
and in sections 7, 8 and 9, exhibits a clearly defined double outline. This
appears to be due to no optical effect, but seems to be clearly structural.
If this be so, we have to consider whether this is to be regarded as a distinct
egg envelope—a vitelline membrane.
 
There is much confusion regarding the description given of the envelopes
surrounding the egg. Bryce in Quainl mentions only the Zona pellucida.
Robinsonz in his diagram of the ovum and its coverings on p. 13, there indicates the vitelline membrane, as distinct from the Oolemma or Zona pellucida,
 
1 Quain, 1909, vol. I. “Embryology.”
2 Cunningham, Textbook of Avmtomy/y 1913.
 
184 T Arthur Thomson
 
but he makes no mention of a vitelline membrane in the text, and consequently
we are at a loss to know exactly What his attitude is regarding this layer.
McMurrich1 makes no mention of any layer other than the Zona pellucida,
 
whilst Jenkinson2 (p. 45) speaks of the ovum of vertebrates as “always.
 
immediately surrounded by a vitelline membrane, frequently termed a Zona
pellucida,” thereby implying that the two membranes are one and the same thing. Wilson3 evidently regards the vitelline membrane as the equivalent of the Zona pellucida, Whilst Paterson4 defines the vitelline membrane as the proper cell Wall of the ovum—“It is a clear, structureless membrane enveloping the protoplasm of the ovum, underneath the Zona pellucida.”
The appearance here represented would seem to confirm the separate identity of these coverings of the egg. As we see it in this series of sections,
 
 
 
 
Fig. 5. Human ovum in discus proligerus exhibiting process of extrusion of the second polar
body. x 600.
 
 
1 The Development of the Human Body, 5th Edition, Philadelphia.
2 Vertebrate Embryology, Oxford, 1913.
 
3 The Cell in Development and Inheritance, New York, 1900.
 
4 Manual of Embryology. ‘
 
The M aturatton of the Human Ovum 185
 
in some positions the vitelline membrane, if we reserve that name for the ,
 
innermost covering of the egg as distinct from the Zona pellucida, is revealed
by a double outline. In some sections its independent nature is clearly shown
by its being stripped off from the inner surface of the Zona, whilst in places
there seems evidence of cellular structure associated with it. It is from the
inner surface of this layer that the cytoplasm retracts, forming, as we have
suggested, a space occupied by fluid, and leaving on the inner surface of this
membrane some small fragments of cytoplasm. This perivitelline space is
of varying width, in places quite clear as if it had contained a fluid, and occupied here and there by what appear as extrusions from the cytoplasm. These
points will of course be better seen in figs. 5, 6 and 7, where the structures
are exhibited on a scale of magnification of 600 diameters.
 
The most remarkable feature exhibited within the body of the ovum is
 
the excentric position of the nucleus or nuclear mass, as seen in section 8,
 
of which a separate figure (Fig. 5) is given.
 
In Fig. 5, thickness of section 0-007 mm., stained with Kernschwarz, the
nuclear mass abuts against theinner surface of the Zona pellucida, the
vitelline membrane, if this be regarded as a separate structure, alone intervening. In this section the nucleus appears as if possessed of a distinct
membrane, but this appearance is most probably an optical effect due to
the difference in the refractive index of the material lying within the nucleus
(the karyoplasm) and the cytoplasm. The karyoplasm, which is paler and
less granular than the surrounding cytoplasm, is retracted, leaving a narrow
space around it, this may be an artefact (the specimen was hardened in formol)
or it may contain what has been described as the karyo-lymph or nuclear
juice. Within the nuclear vesicle is a deeply stained granule measuring about
0-008 mm. i11 diameter, this exhibits a definite structure, having within it a
paler sphere, to the side of which nearest the Zona pellucida is a more highly
refractive granule. The whole nuclear vesicle measures 0-024 >< 0-020 mm.
The cytoplasm of the egg exhibits a remarkable appearance. Around its
periphery it appears darker and more compact. Centrally, however, it becomes looser in texture, and the mitochrondrial grains stain deeper and stand
out more clearly. Near its centre is a spherical granule possibly the centriole,
and what seems like vacuoles occur Within the substance of this less compact
cytoplasm. The significance of this arrangement will be better understood,
if now we examine the sections before and after this example.
 
 
 
 
Fig. 6 is a photomicrograph of section 7, of a thickness of 0-007 mm.,
stained with Kernschwarz. The central cytoplasm here exhibits a radial
arrangement of its constituent elements which appear to converge towards
the nuclear mass or vesicle, this appearance is emphasised by the disposition
of the granules in filamentous threads, the extremities of these threads often
seem to end peripherally in one or more deeply stained grains, frequently
surrounded by a vacuole-like space, or clear interval, as if they were centres
of some fluid secretion.
 
 
In this figure, these collections of clearer material are also seen to invade
the more compact peripheral cytoplasm. As already stated, the filamentous
granules converge towards the nuclear mass, in approaching which they form
a denser or more compact zone in contact with the nuclear Vesicle.
 
The nuclear mass consists of a paler, less granular material than the
cytoplasm, within it are two deeply stained granules, whilst a third, of nearly
similar size, lies on the circumference of the nuclear mass where it blends
with the cytoplasm. There is no surrounding membrane, but the nuclear
 
Fig. 6. Human ovum in discus proligerus exhibiting appearances associated with the extrusion
of the second polar body. x 600.
 
material is pretty clearly defined from the surrounding cytoplasm. As seen
in the figure the nuclear mass is placed on one side close to the inner surface
of the Zona pellucida in contact with what I take to be the Vitelline membrane;
the surface of the nuclear material, so placed, appears clearly limited by a
thin interrupted dark line.
 
There are one or two other details associated with the cytoplasm which
may be noted. The circumference of the cytoplasm is here and there emphasised by what are evidently flattened layers of denser material which on section show up as linear thickenings. That they are not optical in their
origin is proved by their recurrence in the same situation in several sections.
One of these is seen in Fig. 6 a short distance above the n11clear mass. It
recurs again in Fig. 5 and again in Fig. 7. A similar condensation of the
cytoplasm on its periphery is similarly seen in these three sections on the
side of the cytoplasm opposite the nuclear mass.
 
 
Fig. 7. Human ovum in discus proligerus showing the second polar body in process of
extrusion. x600.
 
In Fig. 6 there appear two rounded bodies lying in the perivitelline space, one of which, the left, as is proved by an inspection of the section before
Fig. 6 (not here represented but seen in the plate showing the whole series)
is evidently a part of the cytoplasm which has become separated off from the
main mass. The other, the right, on localising it by the dial of the watch
placed between 12 and 1, I am not so clear about. I am inclined to think that
it is a cell of the Corona radiata which has got floated out of position in the
mounting of the section.
 
Fig. 7 thickness of section 0-007 mm. stained with Kernschwarz is a representation of the appearance of the section‘ following Fig. 5. I have
placed them in this order for the sake of clearness and convenience of
description. Here, the nuclear mass is seen in part piishing its way into the
.perivitelline space, it presents the same pale granular appearance already described, and contains in its substance two darkly stained granules, the '
 
one larger and more compact than the other. The part of the nuclear mass
which is being forced beyond the periphery of the cytoplasm is clearer and
paler in character, and exhibits distinct evidence of structure, there being
a number _of faint granules surrounded by clear spaces. Just as it passes the
line of what we may regard as the circumference of the cytoplasm, this clearer
mass is constricted so that the part of it pushed against the egg envelope is
dumb-bell shaped in appearance, the remainder of this material, of somewhat
spherical form, is bedded in the substance of the nuclear mass. The extruded
part is accompanied by a small amount of cytoplasm. There can be little
doubt that the appearance here observed corresponds to a stage in the extrusion of the second polar body. ,I say this with some ‘confidence, for, as I
shall presently show, there is evidence of the existence of the first polar body
undergoing a state of division in this same oocyte.
 
The cytoplasm, as in the other figures, shows evidence of the same activity
in the arrangement of its substance centrally, though here the radial arrangement is not so distinct, probably owing to the fact that it is cut tangentially,
there does, however, appear to be some evidence that the darker granules
are arranged in spherical form. About the position of .1 on the watch dial
there is, near the periphery of the cytoplasm, a vacuole with a fairly large,
deeply stained granule within it. The same vacuole is seen in the preceding
and succeeding section; whether this has any significance, I know not,
I note its presence, for now-a-days so many cytoplasmic inclusions are de
scribed that possibly it is well that the presence of this particular structure 4
 
should be recorded.
 
As will be seen, the Zona pellucida in this figure has apparently been
slightly damaged in the sectionising, but this is not without its advantages,
for in the position of 7-8 on the watch dial there seems distinct evidence that,
though there is a breach in the continuity of the Zona pellucida, its innermost
layer is stripped off undamaged, a circumstance which would seem to confirm
the -belief in a vitelline membrane as distinct from the Zona pellucida.
 
From the description given——the figures must speak for themselves—there
can be little doubt but that the appearances displayed correspond to the
 
metaphase condition in the second division of the oocyte, and the phenomena
 
associated with the extrusion of the second polar body.
 
The central mass within the cytoplasm corresponds to the mother centrosphere and spindle, the clearer material with its accompanying small amount
of cytoplasm forced outwards against the egg envelopes is the daughter
centrosphere, whilst, in between, we have the nuclear mass in process of
undergoing division, though it must be confessed that the arrangement
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
++++++++++++++++++
 
 
displayed by the chromatin gives little clue to any definite arrangement of
the chromosomes.
 
 
 
The Maturation of the H aman Ovam 175
 
Here let me say how much I am indebted to my friends holding pathological appointments for their ever ready help in providing me with suitable
material.
 
The first figure is that of a section, 0-007 mm. thick, stained with Mallory’s
Connective Tissue Stain, of an ovum in the discus proligerus of a Graafian
follicle from a woman aged 22 who died from a femoral hernia.
 
The egg including the Zona pellucida measures 0-1 x 0-09 1nm., measured
from the inner surface of the Zona pellucida its diameters are 0-097’ >< 0-08 mm.
 
It will be obvious from the figure and from the measures given that the
egg is not a sphere as so frequently described but as will be seen later exhibits
an oval form.
 
The cells of the Corona radiata are adherent to the external surface of the
Zona pellucida by slender filaments with spaces between.
 
The structure of the Zona pellucida is not homogeneous but shows a concentric lamination particularly towards the inner edge, it measures from
0-005 to 0-006 mm. in thickness.
 
At one point just opposite the centrosphere there is evidence of cellular
structure. 0 i
 
The cytoplasm, fairly uniform in character, is separated from the inner
wall of the Zona by what may be possibly a retraction cavity, some of the
cytoplasm remaining adherent to the inner surface of the Zona.
 
The nucleus, of size approximately 0-03 x 0-022 mm., is fairly central in
position, and has a faint a11d ill-defined nuclear membrane.
 
The arrangement of the chromatin is best realized by reference to the figure.
 
What appears to be the nucleolus breaking up is seen towards one end of
the nucleus. _
 
The nucleus is in part separated from the surrounding cytoplasm by a
narrow cleft probably a retraction cavity though possibly it may be a space
filled with fluid derived from the karyoplasm.
 
At one extremity of the nucleus lying within the cytoplasm _jia.s-t 0-ut.s-7,'de
thefalnt nuclear membrane is a small granule.
 
Lying to one side of the nucleus and in contact with the nuclear membrane,
which is here only faintly indicated, is a small sphere, 0-013 ><0-011 mm.,
consisting of a material so clear that it might be mistaken for a vacuole; it
 
has, however, an obvious structure and contains near its poles two more
darkly stained granules. ‘
 
' This object I take to be the Centrosphere, Attraction Sphere (Quain),
Archoplasm Sphere (McMurrich), Centrosome (Robinson), Microcentrum
(Heidenhain), Microsphere (Siedlecki), in the young oocyte sometimes called
the Idiosome (corresponding to the attraction sphere of other cells). Van
der Stricht identifies this with the Yolk nucleus or Body of Balbiani, as does
Jenkinsonl, see also Wilsonz.
 
1 Vertebrate Embryology, Oxford, 1913, p. 72.
2 The Cell in Development and I nhcritancc, New York, 1900, p. 156.
 
176 Arthur Thomson
 
Its contents are variously termed the Centroplasm or Archoplasm, whilst
the granules are known as the Centrioles.
 
Other sections of this egg a.re available, but they exhibit nothing worthy
of note. The appearance indicated in the figure, however, justifies us in
assuming that the specimen represents the prophase condition in the Human
Ooeyte prior to the formation of the first polar body.
 
Fig. 2. Human ovum in discus proligerus in propnase of first. division. x 600.
 
Fig. 2 shows an ovum in discus proligerus in Graafian follicle. Section
0-007 mm. thick. Stained with Ehrlich’s acid haematoxylin and eosin.
 
Size including Zona 0-117 ><0-1 mm.; inside Zona 0-1 ><0-08 mm.
 
From a woman aged 22. Died of a femoral hernia. Same ovary as Fig. 1.
 
The figure shows that the egg is not spherical.
 
The cells of the Corona radiata are here adherent to the outer side of
the Zona pelluci(la by broader protoplasmic processes than in Fig. 1, with
arcaded spaces in between them, the summits of the arcades being directed
to the Zona pellucida.
 
The Maturation of the Human Ovum 177
 
The Zona pellucida consists clearly of two layers, the combined thickness
of which amounts to from O-008 to 0-O11 mm.
 
The three deeply stained bodies seen overlying the Zona pellucida are
nuclei which have got floated over it in the process of mounting.
 
The inner zone is more homogeneous than the outer, it exhibits here and
there evidence of a lamellar arrangement and at one or two points there
seems to be distinct proof of the presence of cellular elements in its substance.
At one pole it appears to be faintly striated radially.
 
This layer of the Zona pellucida I have reason to believe is the ovular
layer.
 
The outer layer, continuous with the processes which pass to the cells of
the Corona radiata is more open and fibrillar in structure. This I believe to be
the ovarian layer of the Zona pellucida, the Zona thus‘ being a compound
structure made up of ovular and ovarian elements.
 
The cytoplasm, of granular appearance, is fairly uniform in density
throughout. It is retracted from the inner surface of the Zona pellucida,
the retraction cavity being slit-like for the most part, but increased in width
towards one end, where it forms a considerable cavity, which is in part
occupied by a ‘faintly granular translucent material capping the substance
of the cytoplasm at this end of the egg. This is possibly of the nature of a
coagulum.
 
The nucleus measures roughly O-O2 ><O-017 mm. and occupies a position
nearly central in the section of the cytoplasm. The nuclear membrane has
disappeared, and the arrangement__of the chromatin in scattered granules is
best realised by reference to the figure. Some of these granules appear to fall
in line parallel to the equatorof the nucleus.
 
There is no evidence of a nucleolus, unless the presence of a larger chromatin granule denotes its presence.
 
The contents of the nucleus (karyoplasm) are everywhere confluent with
the cytoplasm.
 
‘On either side of, and near, the nucleus are two small clear spots, each
containing a highly refractive granule. In the specimen, these lie in line with
the greatest diameter of the egg, but it is diflicult to determine whether this
corresponds with the true polar axis of the oocyte, since the example is taken
from aspecimen in which the serial sections are not complete.
 
These bodies, I take it, represent the divided centrosphere shown in Fig. 1,
each half containing its accompanying centriole. The divided centrosphere
has now shifted its position so that its two halves come to lie on either side
of thenucleus.
 
Other cytoplasmic inclusions. With the , exception of a deeply stained
granule lying some little distance to one side of the nucleus there is no apparent
feature in the cytoplasm which calls for comment. I must leave it to those
better versed in cytology to determine what the nature of this particle may be.
 
From the evidence before us we may, I think, assume that Fig. 2 represents
 
Anatomy LIII 12
 
17 8 Arthur Thomson
 
a further stage in the prophasc condition of the formation of the first polar
body exhibited in Fig. 1, the centrosphere there displayed having now divided
into the two clear spheres each with a eentriole and placed so as to lie on
 
opposite sides of the nucleus, which now devoid of its membrane is approaching
the stage when it divides.
 
_ x.
 
F IG. 3. Human ovum in discus proligerus in anaphase of first division and commencement of
metaphase of second division. x 600.
 
()vu1n in discus proligerus in Graafian follicle.
 
Thickness of section 0-01 mm., stained with \Veigcrt’s Iron Hzcmatoxylin
and Van Giesen.
 
Size including Zona 0-097 ><0-088 mm.; inside Zona 0-083 ><0-08 mm.
 
From a woman whose ovary was forwarded without any history, in the
same case a morula and an ovarian blastula were found; these will be described
in a subsequent paper. In this case the Fallopian tubes were much twisted
and bound down by adhesions——presumably impervious to the descent of an
ovum though apparently permitting the passage of spermatozoa.
 
The section here displays a more spherical appearance.
 
The cells of the Corona radiata are neither so discrete nor so clearly seen
as in the previous figures (1 and 2). They are separated from the outer surface
of the Zona pellucida by a zone about 0-001 mm. in width, which exhibits
 
 
 
 
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 
I have not hesitated to assume that the conditions here described are the
changes associated with the extrusion of the second polar body, for, if now
we turn to look at the plate of the entire series of sections we will there be
able to note the presence in sections 3 and 4 of certain structures which we
have every confidence in believing is the first polar body undergoing division.
 
Fig. 8. Human ovum in discus proligerus, shows first polar body undergoing division in the ovum
in which the second polar body is in process of being extruded. x 900.
 
In order to render this clearer I have introduced figs. 8 and 9 showing
the details under a higher power of magnification. Before describing these,
however, let me call attention to a. point of some importance. Be it noted
that the point of extrusion of the second polar body does not correspond to
the position occupied by the first polar body. If we assume that the first
polar body is polar in position (be it animal or vegetative pole) then the
point of extrusion of the second polar body’ corresponds fairly closely to the
equator of the egg, which fact helps to confirm the belief that the polar bodies, once extruded, sink, by their own weight, in the pcrivitelline fluid to occupy
the most dependent position within the egg envelope.
 
In Fig. 8, which is a photomicrograph of section 4 of the entire series,
0-007 mm. thick, stained with Kernschwarz, magnified 900 diameters, there
will be seen lying in the perivitelline space, which is here cut very obliquely,
since it lies close to one of the poles of the egg, two distinct bodies in the
 
position of 11 on the watch dial. One of these, the more external, is oval in
 
Fig.  8. Human ovum in discus proligerus showing first polar body undergoing division in the
ovum in wl1iel1 the second polar body is in process of extrusion. x 900.
 
shape, rests on the "egg envelope, and consists of a granular material containing
fairly well marked deeper stained grains; at either extremity of the oval may
be seen some of the chromatin aggregated together to form little spots of
more compact granules. In this section, the oval body is separate and distinct
from a darker mass lying between it and the cytoplasm, which in part overlaps
it. This collection of deeply stained matter exhibits denser granules Within
it. If now we examine Fig. 9, which is a photomicrograph of section 3 of the
entire series, 0-007 mm. thick, stained with Kernschwarz, the section im
’1’he M CLt’Ll/7'61/l’i0’I’l, of the H mncm Ovum, 191
 
mediately preceding that which is shown in Fig. 8, we will see, in exact
correspondence with the structures previously described in Fig. 8, two deeply
stained bodies containing chromatin granules arranged in such a way as to
suggest that these are chromosomes; further the two bodies so described
are seen to be connected by a bridge, which indicates their incomplete separation at this point. If these facts are admitted, and no other explanation seems
possible, then I hold we have clear evidence that the structure we are dealing
with is the first polar body undergoing division, coincident with the extrusion
of the second polar body.
 
If this be so, we have in the series of sections of this oocyte a complete
demonstration of the stages effected in the egg at the time of the extrusion
of the second polar body. Further we have clear proof that in this oocyte,
at least, the maturation stage associated with the discharge of the first and
second polar bodies is completed within the ovary whilst the egg still lies
within the discus proligerus of the Graafian follicle.
 
In Plate XI is reproduced the complete series of 16 sections (0-008 mm.
thick, stained with Ehrlich’s acid haematoxylin and eosin) of an oocyte
within the discus proligerus, inside a. Graafian follicle, obtained from the
ovary of a woman aged 38, who died of heart failure twenty-four hours after
admission to hospital. It was from the same subject that the examples already
described under Plate X were obtained.
 
What strikes one at first is the size and shape of the egg.
 
The largest diameters are displayed in section 9 of the series, and are
estimated as 0-113 >< 0-1 mm. The corresponding diameters measured inside
the Zona pellucida are as follows: 0-1 >< 0-084 mm.
 
The egg and its envelopes 11111 through 14 out of the 16 sections figured.
As each section was 0-008 mm. thick, the total “thickness ” of the egg sectionised amounts to 0-112 m1n., so that the oocyte has evidently been cut transverse to its long axis, the two extremities of the egg as seen in the serial
sections will correspond therefore to the poles, if these are determined by
its longest diameter, a point of some importance in regard to the disposition
of the polar bodies, and one concerning which Jenkinson1 makes the definite
statement that “ In cases where the egg is ovoid or ellipsoid (Myxinoids, Amia)
the egg axis is the major axis.”
 
The diameters given for this oocyte, which is in a very perfect state of
preservation, preclude the possibility of it being described as spherical. A
matter worth drawing attention to is that this oocyte exceeds by an appreciable amount the diameters given for those already described.
 
The cells of the discus proligerus or cumulus, which immediately surrounds
the egg to form the Corona radiata, are closely packed, only at one point is
there a breach in their continuity shown in sections 6, 7, 8 and 9. Here
the liquor folliculi, shown in the photomicrographs as a pale granular looking coagulum, is free to enter, and has evidently bathed the external
 
1 Vertebrate Embryology, Oxford, 1913, p. 40.
 
 
 
mediately preceding that which is shown in Fig. 8, we will see, in exact
correspondence with the structures previously described in Fig. 8, two deeply
stained bodies containing chromatin granules arranged in such a way as to
suggest that these are chromosomes; further the two bodies so described
are seen to be connected by a bridge, which indicates their incomplete separation at this point. If these facts are admitted, and no other explanation seems
possible, then I hold we have clear evidence that the structure we are dealing
with is the first polar body undergoing division, coincident with the extrusion
of the second polar body.
 
If this be so, we have in the series of sections of this oocyte a complete
demonstration of the stages effected in the egg at the time of the extrusion
of the second polar body. Further we have clear proof that in this oocyte,
at least, the maturation stage associated with the discharge of the first and
second polar bodies is completed within the ovary whilst the egg still lies
within the discus proligerus of the Graafian follicle.
 
In Plate XI is reproduced the complete series of 16 sections (0-008 mm.
thick, stained with Ehrlich’s acid haematoxylin and eosin) of an oocyte
within the discus proligerus, inside a. Graafian follicle, obtained from the
ovary of a woman aged 38, who died of heart failure twenty-four hours after
admission to hospital. It was from the same subject that the examples already
described under Plate X were obtained.
 
What strikes one at first is the size and shape of the egg.
 
The largest diameters are displayed in section 9 of the series, and are
estimated as 0-113 >< 0-1 mm. The corresponding diameters measured inside
the Zona pellucida are as follows: 0-1 >< 0-084 mm.
 
The egg and its envelopes 11111 through 14 out of the 16 sections figured.
As each section was 0-008 mm. thick, the total “thickness ” of the egg sectionised amounts to 0-112 m1n., so that the oocyte has evidently been cut transverse to its long axis, the two extremities of the egg as seen in the serial
sections will correspond therefore to the poles, if these are determined by
its longest diameter, a point of some importance in regard to the disposition
of the polar bodies, and one concerning which J enkinsonl makes the definite
statement that “ In cases where the egg is ovoid or ellipsoid (Myxinoids, Amia)
the egg axis is the major axis.”
 
The diameters given for this oocyte, which is in a very perfect state of
preservation, preclude the possibility of it being described as spherical. A
matter worth drawing attention to is that this oocyte exceeds by an appreciable amount the diameters given for those already described.
 
The cells of the discus proligerus or cumulus, which immediately surrounds
the egg to form the Corona radiata, are closely packed, only at one point is
there a breach in their continuity shown in sections 6, 7, 8 and 9. Here
the liquor folliculi, shown in the photomicrographs as a pale granularlooking coagulum, is free to enter, and has evidently bathed the external
 
1 Vertebrate Embryology, Oxford, 1913, p. 40.
 
surface of the Zona pellucida, though as yet in this specimen it does not
appear to have extended much by infiltration between the outer surface of
the Zona pellucida and the deeper row of cells of the Corona radiata. In
consequence, the fibrillar substance, cementing the innermost cells of the
Corona radiata to the outer surface of the Zona pellucida, and forming by
its “felting”. the outer or ovarian layer of that membrane, is more compact,
and not so broken up by fluid infiltration as that described in the previous
examples.
 
The Zona pellucida, of an average thickness of from 0-O06 to O~OO8. mm.
is very well seen in many of the sections, particularly in Nos. 7 and 8, where
its separation into an inner and an outer layer is very clearly seen, the outer
being obviously of a different character from the inner and being formed by
the felting of the basal fibres of the innermost cells of the Corona radiata andtherefore ovarian in derivation, whilst the inner layer, clearer and more homo
‘ geneous, and derived, as I have reason to believe from a study of the growth
 
period of the oogonium, from the ovum itself (I hope to publish this series
of observations later), is limited internally by a well defined line, which on
careful examination is seen to be double. This, I take it, is confirmatory of
the View that internal to the Zona pellucida, and in contact with it, there is
another egg membrane, the true vitelline membrane of which I have already
spoken. The ovular or inner layer of the Zona pellucida proper exhibits
appearances here and there which suggest concentric lamination; in other
situations, in some’ of the sections, there is an appearance of radial striation,
but I have not been able to observe any of the fibrillae derived from the inner
cells of the-« Corona radiata traversing the substance of the Zona pellucida.
In one or two instances, notably in section 7, there are evidences of cellular
formation or cell inclusions within the substance of the inner or ovular layer
of the Zona pellucida.
 
As has been already suggested, there appears to be evidence of a layer
within the Zona and adherent to it, which is possibly a true vitelline membrane, but in these sections it must be admitted that the evidence is not very
convincing, for it is extremely diflicult to make out whether the appearance
is due to an optical effect or no.
 
The cytoplasm in all the sections exhibits an evenly granular appearance,
increasing in density in the centre and around the nucleus. This central
darker mass is separated, here and there, from the surrounding lighter cytoplasm by a more open grain in the granular material, amounting in places
to definite irregular clefts, whether this appearance is due to the influence
of the hardening agent (formol) or is a natural condition induced by excess
of fluid is a moot point.
 
In most of the sections the cytoplasm appears to fill completely the egg
envelope, but if the middle sections of the series, viz. those near the equator
of the egg, be carefully examined there is definite evidence of a narrow interspace between what Waldeyer has called the ooplasm cortex, i.e. a narrow zone of finely granular material surrounding the cytoplasm, and the inner
side of the egg envelope. This space, the perivitelline space, for such it would
appear to be, is probably filled with a fluid extrusion from the cytoplasm,
for in it appear two or three bodies which will now be described.
 
In sections 13 and 14 of the series, close to the pole at that end of the egg,
are seen to be certain conspicuous features. In section 14, here shown in
Fig. 10, there are two distinct nuclear granules surrounded by an irregular
 
Fig. 10. Section of a. mature human ovum in the discus proligerus showing near one of its poles
the now divided first polar body. x 600.
 
mass of slightly darker material than the adjacent cytoplasm. This substance
is also faintly indicated in the previous section (not here figured).
 
From a careful study of this object I think there can be little doubt but
that we have the first polar body in a divided condition. It will be noticed
that so far as its site is concerned it is distinctly polar in position, that is to
say it lies at one extremity of the greatest diameter of the egg.
 
Having thus accounted for the first polar body it remains to determine
the existence of the second polar body. In doing this considerable difficulty
was experienced, as there were sundry objects which might be taken for it, but after careful examination I am inclined to believe that the structure
exhibited in section 7 of the series, opposite 11 of" the watch dia.l, is the object
we arein search of——the second polar body (Fig.';11). Here is seen a darkly
stained granule of chromatin which on high magnification resolves itself into
more or less distinct groups of chromatin particles apparently connected
together, the whole being surrounded  an envelope of a substance identical
with that of the adjacent cytoplasm. If this be the second polar body, it
 
 
 
Fig. 11. Section of a. mature human ovum in the discus proligerus showing in the direction of
11 of the Watch dial the second polar body within the zona pellucida. x 600.
 
should be noticed that its position does not correspond to that of the first
polar body. As to whether it may ultimately sink to the same position as
that occupied by the first polar body is a matter of surmise, evidently, like
that described in the last figure, it is extruded from the cytoplasm at a very
different level from that now occupied by the first polar body.
 
All the other deeply stained bodies, which one might have associated with
a polar body, have been eliminated, for the reason that they are evidently
Washed granules in the process of mounting. There still remains the fact,
however, that, here and there, along the inner surface of the envelope covering but after careful examination I am inclined to believe that the structure
exhibited in section 7 of the series, opposite 11 of the watch dial, is the object
we are in search of——the second polar body (Fig.';11). Here is seen a darkly
stained granule of chromatin which on high magnification resolves itself into
more or less distinct groups of chromatin particles apparently connected
together, the whole being surrounded  an envelope of a substance identical
with that of the adjacent cytoplasm. If this be the second polar body, it
 
 
Fig. 11. Section of a. mature human ovum in the discus proligerus showing in the direction of
11 of the Watch dial the second polar body within the zona. pellucida. x 600.
 
should be noticed that its position does not correspond to that of the first
polar body. As to whether it may ultimately sink to the same position as
that occupied by the first polar body is a matter of surmise, evidently, like
that described in the last figure, it is extruded from the cytoplasm at a very
different level from that now occupied by the first polar body.
 
All the other deeply stained bodies, which one might have associated with
a polar body, have been eliminated, for the reason that they are evidently
Washed granules in the process of mounting. There still remains the fact,
however, that, here and there, along the inner surface of the envelope covering believe, on the evidence of those familiar with the changes occurring in other
mammalian ova, that there is no resting stage between the first and second
maturation divisions, hence the necessity for a search for the second polar
body. If the present assumption be true, all these facts seem to harmonise
and amply justify us in establishing the identity of the second polar body
already referred to. Herein we have therefore to deal with a mature oocyte
provided with what is now the female pronucleus. The nucleus, so described,
as it appears in the figure (Fig. 12) has a deeply stained spherical nucleolus
0-007 mm. in diameter, lodging a more refractive granule within it. The
nucleus contains, besides, in the finely granular karyoplasm a number (about
15 in this figure) of small chromatin granules mainly disposed around the
nucleolus, and lying, too, along the inner side of the nuclear membrane.
 
The karyoplasm is traversed by irregular clefts, whether artefacts or vital features it is impossible to determine.
 
In the preceding and succeeding sections in which the nucleus is cut and
appears, the nuclear membrane in the photographs is faint but distinctly
traceable.
 
In the section just before Fig. 12, the nucleolus is also represented by a
thin slice, and scattered through the karyoplasm of the three sections are
chromatin granules to the approximate total number of 45 to 50. Some of
these appear to be isolated grains, some linked together in threads, and others
arranged in groups.
 
Around the nucleus, externally, and lying either near, or in close contact
With, its membrane, are sundry vacuole-like bodies. Three of these," of varying
size, each with a faint granule in it, lie opposite to the upper right quadrant
of the nucleus. Another, not so clear, lies in the direction of 5 of the dial face.
 
In section 9 of the Series Plate XI(shown in Fig. 13‘)a larger vesicle,0-O12 x
0-008 mm. in size, lies in the direction of 3 of the Watch dial, in contact with
the nuclear membrane. Its contents are clearer than the surrounding cytoplasm, and more finely granular, possibly this may be the remains of a centrosphere. '
 
What the significance of the other structures may be, I know not, but
their constant recurrence in other ova which I have studied suggest that they
are normal features associated in some way with the nutrition or activity of
the egg.
 
There can be little doubt, I think, that the oocyte above described has
reached its mature condition. All the facts seem to justify this assumption.
 
The presence of a divided first polar body, the withdrawal of the nucleus
to a central position, the reappearance of the nuclear membrane and the
nucleolus, the probable identity of the secon’d polar body, and the disappearance of all activity on the part of the centrospheres, all point to the correctness
of this conclusion. It may further be added that judging by the thinness of
the overlying ovarian layer, this oocyte was found in a Graafian follicle at a
stage which must have been close to the period of rupture.
 
 
Plate XII represents a complete series of 12 sections (0-008 mm. thick,
stained with Weigert’s Iron Haematoxylin and Van Giesen) of an oocyte in the
discus proligerus, inside a Graafian follicle, from the ovary of a woman aged 38
who died of heart failure one day after admission to hospital. This is the same
subject as that from which the specimen figured in Plate XI was obtained.
 
  The largest diameters, 0°111><0°09 mm., are seen in section 5 of the series.
Measured from Within the inner surface of the Zona pellucida the corresponding diameters are 0'10x0°08 mm. '
 
 
 
Fig. 13. Section through a mature human ovum in the discus proligerus, the vesicle to the right
 
of the nucleus may possibly be the remains of a centrosphere. x 600.
 
The egg and its envelopes run through 10 of the 12 sections,‘and as each
section was cut to a thickness of 0-008 mm., the total diameter of the egg as
estimated by taking the total thickness of the 10 sections amounts to 0-080 mm.,
so that the inference is that the sections displayed in the plate have been cut
in a plane parallel to the long axis of the egg.
 
In this instance, also, the egg, which is in a good state of preservation,
can in no sense be described as typically spherical.
 
 
 
 
==Description of Plates==
 
===Plate X===
[[File:Thomson1919 plate10.jpg|800px]]
 
Reproduction of complete series of sections of a human ovum in the discus proligerus (No. 453, Series A) exhibiting the extrusion of the second polar body, indicated by an arrow to the left side of the first section in the third row. The arrow in the fourth section of the first row points to the first polar body. x 150 (reduced from the photomicrographs taken with a magnification of 600 diameters).
 
===Plate XI===
[[File:Thomson1919 plate11.jpg|800px]]
 
Reproduction of a complete series of sections of a mature human ovum in the discus proligerus (No. 453, Series A). The arrows in the plate point to the polar bodies: the lower to the now divided first polar body, the upper to the second polar body.
 
===Plate XII===
[[File:Thomson1919 plate12.jpg|800px]]
 
Reproduction of a complete series of sections through a mature human ovum. The lower arrow points to the divided first polar body, the upper arrow indicates the position of the second polar body.
 
 
Magnification 150 diameters.
===Figures===
 
<gallery>
File:Thomson1919 fig01.jpg|Fig. 1. Human ovum in discus proligerus in early part of prophase of first division
</gallery>

Latest revision as of 13:09, 6 August 2015

Nature 135, 295-295 (23 February 1935) | doi:10.1038/135295a0

Prof. Arthur Thomson

Abstract

ON his retirement in 1933, Prof. Arthur Thomson, whose death on February 7 will be widely regretted, had completed a somewhat unusual record of academic service. He was born on March 21, 1858, and for forty-eight years he represented human anatomy at the University of Oxford, first as University lecturer in human anatomy and afterwards as Dr. Lee’s professor of anatomy. After serving an apprenticeship in the famous school of anatomy at Edinburgh under Sir William Turner, Thomson went to Oxford in 1885. Unlike many of his later contemporaries, he did not enjoy the advantage of stepping into a department already equipped for teaching and research. On the contrary, the task fell to him of building up a new department from its very foundations. It will readily be appreciated that Thomson’s energies were fully employed for a number of years in developing the teaching side of his department to a level appropriate to the medical faculty of the University of Oxford, a task which was rendered very laborious at first by the criticism and opposition of some members of the University who were less ready to appreciate the importance of catering for an extensive and detailed medical curriculum.