Difference between revisions of "Paper - Observations on the structure and development of bone"

From Embryology
Line 24: Line 24:
  
 
==Introduction==
 
==Introduction==
 +
The structure and development of bone is a subject which has occupied the attention of physiologists both of present and past times, and holds a prominent place in their writings. From the time of Clopton Havers, who was the first to point out the vascular canals in bone, and whose name they have since borne, to the year 1850, when M. Kolliker's elaborate work on Structural Anatomy appeared, physiological writers have dwelt at considerable length on this branch of their subject. All have, however, concluded with the admission that more remained to be learned before this important structure could be regarded as fully understood*.
  
The structure and development of bone is a subject which has occupied the
 
attention of physiologists both of present and past times, and holds a prominent
 
place in their writings. From the time of Clopton Havers, who was the first to
 
point out the vascular canals in bone, and whose name they have since borne, to the
 
year 1850, when M. Kolliker's elaborate work on Structural Anatomy appeared,
 
physiological writers have dwelt at considerable length on this branch of their
 
subject. All have, however, concluded with the admission that more remained to
 
be learned before this important structure could be regarded as fully understood*.
 
  
It is the purpose of the authors in this communication, to lay before the Royal  
+
It is the purpose of the authors in this communication, to lay before the Royal Society the results of an extended series of observations on the structure and development of bone. Such of these results as are novel might, perhaps, be de- scribed without reference to those points which are already well known. It will, however, be seen, in the subsequent pages, that they are in themselves, and in their relations to osseous tissue and its development, as well as to structural anatomy generally, of such a nature, as would hardly admit of an intelligible description apart from some consideration of the whole subject. Hence it will be necessary to point out the relations between that which is already known, and that which it is the special purpose of this paper to communicate, and it is proposed to consider the details of the subject as they present themselves in the progress of investigation with but little reference to authorities, adding in the form of notes, those statements which require acknowledgement, either as agreeing with, or as being opposed to, the views advanced in this paper.
Society the results of an extended series of observations on the structure and  
 
development of bone. Such of these results as are novel might, perhaps, be de-  
 
scribed without reference to those points which are already well known. It will,  
 
however, be seen, in the subsequent pages, that they are in themselves, and in their  
 
relations to osseous tissue and its development, as well as to structural anatomy  
 
generally, of such a nature, as would hardly admit of an intelligible description apart  
 
from some consideration of the whole subject. Hence it will be necessary to point  
 
out the relations between that which is already known, and that which it is the  
 
special purpose of this paper to communicate, and it is proposed to consider the  
 
details of the subject as they present themselves in the progress of investigation with  
 
but little reference to authorities, adding in the form of notes, those statements which  
 
require acknowledgement, either as agreeing with, or as being opposed to, the views  
 
advanced in this paper.  
 
  
In treating of the structure of bone, it is convenient to commence by describing
 
the appearances which a thin transverse section from the shaft of an adult long bone
 
presents when placed in the field of a microscope having a magnifying power of
 
from 200 to 300 linear. In addition to the large central space which corresponds
 
to the medullary cavity of the bone, the section is seen to be perforated by numerous
 
small apertures, each of which is surrounded by a series of laminae of osseous tissue
 
concentrically arranged. Lying amongst the laminae are many small cavities, from
 
which minute tubes radiate. These were called bone-corpuscles by Purkinje, who
 
  
* Mikroskopische Anatomie, von Dr. A. Kolliker. Leipzig, 1850,  
+
In treating of the structure of bone, it is convenient to commence by describing the appearances which a thin transverse section from the shaft of an adult long bone presents when placed in the field of a microscope having a magnifying power of from 200 to 300 linear. In addition to the large central space which corresponds to the medullary cavity of the bone, the section is seen to be perforated by numerous small apertures, each of which is surrounded by a series of laminae of osseous tissue concentrically arranged. Lying amongst the laminae are many small cavities, from which minute tubes radiate. These were called bone-corpuscles by Purkinje, who first described them ; but latterly, with a more correct appreciation of their nature, the name of lacunae has been substituted at the suggestion of Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman*, who have also described the Haversian canals, their surrounding laminae, and their lacunae, under the inclusive term of Haversian systems. The whole sub- stance of the bone is made up of Haversian systems, connected by irregularly-shaped patches of short laminae which occupy the spaces between the systems (Plate VI. fig. 1 b). These have received the name of interstitial laminae from Kolliker. In addition to the Haversian and interstitial laminae, we have in most instances others that surround, or partly surround the whole, and form the outer surface of the bone. These, from the position they occupy, are called the circumferential laminae. A similar series more or less perfect is found to form the wall of the medullary cavity.
  
MDCCCLIII. Q
 
  
 +
Mikroskopische Anatomie, von Dr. A. Kolliker. Leipzig, 1850,
  
no
 
  
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
+
If the section be taken from near the end instead of from the middle of the shaft of a long bone, the Haversian canals will appear much larger, and in the place of one great central opening we shall see numerous lesser ones, corresponding to the cancellous part of the bone. From whatever bone, or part of a bone, the section be taken, the arrangement of laminse and lacunse is substantially the same ; the differences between the compact and cancellous portions consisting in variations in the relative quantities of the bone tissue and the size and number of the canals, and not in any real difference in the structure.
  
  
first described them ; but latterly, with a more correct appreciation of their nature,
+
The elongated bones of some of the vertebrata, when cut transversely through their centres, are seen to be composed, at that part, of a single Haversian system. The rib of a Boa may be cited as an example.
the name of lacunae has been substituted at the suggestion of Dr. Todd and Mr.
 
Bowman*, who have also described the Haversian canals, their surrounding laminae,  
 
and their lacunae, under the inclusive term of Haversian systems. The whole sub-
 
stance of the bone is made up of Haversian systems, connected by irregularly-shaped
 
patches of short laminae which occupy the spaces between the systems (Plate VI. fig. 1 b).
 
These have received the name of interstitial laminae from Kolliker. In addition to  
 
the Haversian and interstitial laminae, we have in most instances others that surround,  
 
or partly surround the whole, and form the outer surface of the bone. These, from
 
the position they occupy, are called the circumferential laminae. A similar series
 
more or less perfect is found to form the wall of the medullary cavity.  
 
  
If the section be taken from near the end instead of from the middle of the shaft
 
of a long bone, the Haversian canals will appear much larger, and in the place of
 
one great central opening we shall see numerous lesser ones, corresponding to
 
the cancellous part of the bone. From whatever bone, or part of a bone, the section
 
be taken, the arrangement of laminse and lacunse is substantially the same ; the
 
differences between the compact and cancellous portions consisting in variations in
 
the relative quantities of the bone tissue and the size and number of the canals,
 
and not in any real difference in the structure.
 
  
The elongated bones of some of the vertebrata, when cut transversely through
+
Having drawn attention to the several parts which are recognised as entering into the composition of bone, the authors will now proceed to describe the results of their investigations under the subjoined heads :
their centres, are seen to be composed, at that part, of a single Haversian system. The
 
rib of a Boa may be cited as an example.
 
  
Having drawn attention to the several parts which are recognised as entering
+
1st. The Haversian canals and other spaces.
into the composition of bone, the authors will now proceed to describe the results of
 
their investigations under the subjoined heads : —
 
  
1st. The Haversian canals and other spaces.  
+
2nd. The laminse.
  
2nd. The laminse.  
+
3rd. The lacunae and canaliculi.
  
3rd. The lacunae and canaliculi.  
+
4th. The Haversian systems.
  
4th. The Haversian systems.  
+
5th. Ossified cartilage of joints.
  
5th. Ossified cartilage of joints.  
+
6th. Ossified cells.
  
6th. Ossified cells.  
+
7th. Bone tissue.
  
7th. Bone tissue.  
+
8th. Development of bone.
  
8th. Development of bone.  
+
9th. Growth of bone.
  
9th. Growth of bone.  
+
Haversian and other Canals of Bone. — The Haversian canals have been described by all recent writers on the subject of bone ; their variable size and not unfrequent anastomoses have been pointed out ; and the fact of the larger apertures in the spongy parts of bone being similar in the structure of their parietes to the smaller ones in the denser parts of the osseous tissue has not failed to be recognized. It may be remarked, that whether the canals are large or small, their section presents an oval or circular outline, and that the walls of such canals have a tolerably uniform surface. When examining sections of bone it is necessary to bear this fact in mind, for on a close inspection it will be seen that there are other spaces which possess a different character, although up to the present time, so far as the authors know, this difference has not been recognized.
  
Haversian and other Canals of Bone. — The Haversian canals have been described
 
by all recent writers on the subject of bone ; their variable size and not unfrequent
 
anastomoses have been pointed out ; and the fact of the larger apertures in the
 
spongy parts of bone being similar in the structure of their parietes to the smaller
 
ones in the denser parts of the osseous tissue has not failed to be recognized. It may
 
be remarked, that whether the canals are large or small, their section presents an
 
  
* The Physiological Anatomy and Physiology of Man, by Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman, vol. i. p. 109.  
+
The Physiological Anatomy and Physiology of Man, by Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman, vol. i. p. 109.
  
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.  
+
These spaces are irregular in shape, and have an irregular, festooned and often jagged outline, similar to that found on the surface of bone which has been removed by exfoliation, similar also to the surface left upon the fang of a tooth after a part has been absorbed. Such spaces correspond in shape to the peripheral outline of one or more of the Haversian systems, and are in fact subservient to the development of those systems, and necessarily precede their formation (Plate VI. figs. 2 a , 3 a, 4 a). It is proposed to call these spaces which are produced by absorption, Haversian spaces, as this name is indicative of their ultimate connection with the Haversian systems. In the Haversian canals we have surrounding laminae, but in the spaces the boundaries are formed by portions of several systems, each of which has been in part removed in the formation of the spaces, as shown in figures 2 and 3, and Plate V., which, on being compared with figure 1, will illustrate the difference between the spaces and canals ; allowance must, however, be made for the difference of size, as in figure 1 the parts are less magnified than in the other illustrations. In newly formed bone situated near ossifying cartilage, the Haversian spaces are exceedingly numerous and large, frequently affording room for the development of two or more systems (fig. 5, Plate VI. fig. 24, Plate VIII.), while in older bone they are far less numerous, and generally less in size. In no case, however, are they wholly absent. They are found even in the bones of old subjects, and in connection with them newly developed systems.
  
  
Ill
+
This is a very important fact, as it demonstrates that the old tissue is removed in masses, and a new one developed in its place. It has long been taught that the older particles of an internal tissue are removed by absorption and new ones substituted, and this throughout the life of the individual. But the authors believe that they have demonstrated it for the first time.
  
  
oval or circular outline, and that the walls of such canals have a tolerably uniform
+
On examining with care a series of sections, the Haversian spaces will be found in various conditions. In one place the space will have attained a large size, while in another part of the same section its commencement will be seen extending from one side of an Haversian canal. In a third instance, its occupation will have commenced, and its festooned margin will be lined by the peripheral lamina of an Haversian system. Then, again, examples may be found where one side of a space is becoming the seat of a new system, while the opposite one is undergoing further enlargement. In no case is there any difficulty in distinguishing between an enlarging Haversian space and a developing Haversian system. The authors have preparations which show that these conditions of absorption and reproduction take place in old as well as in young or middle-aged subjects ; but it would appear that the frequency diminishes with the increasing age of the individual. It may however be observed in the bones of those who have passed the sixtieth year. The more recently formed systems differ from those of older date in the somewhat larger size of their lacunee and canaliculi, and in the greater abundance of the latter, as shown in fig. 6, Plate VI.
surface. When examining sections of bone it is necessary to bear this fact in mind,
 
for on a close inspection it will be seen that there are other spaces which possess a
 
different character, although up to the present time, so far as the authors know, this
 
difference has not been recognized.  
 
  
These spaces are irregular in shape, and have an irregular, festooned and often
 
jagged outline, similar to that found on the surface of bone which has been removed
 
by exfoliation, similar also to the surface left upon the fang of a tooth after a part has
 
been absorbed. Such spaces correspond in shape to the peripheral outline of one or
 
more of the Haversian systems, and are in fact subservient to the development of
 
those systems, and necessarily precede their formation (Plate VI. figs. 2 a , 3 a, 4 a). It
 
is proposed to call these spaces which are produced by absorption, Haversian spaces,
 
as this name is indicative of their ultimate connection with the Haversian systems.
 
In the Haversian canals we have surrounding laminae, but in the spaces the boun-
 
daries are formed by portions of several systems, each of which has been in part
 
removed in the formation of the spaces, as shown in figures 2 and 3, and Plate V.,
 
which, on being compared with figure 1, will illustrate the difference between the
 
spaces and canals ; allowance must, however, be made for the difference of size, as
 
in figure 1 the parts are less magnified than in the other illustrations. In newly-
 
formed bone situated near ossifying cartilage, the Haversian spaces are exceedingly
 
numerous and large, frequently affording room for the development of two or more
 
systems (fig. 5, Plate VI. fig. 24, Plate VIII.), while in older bone they are far less
 
numerous, and generally less in size. In no case, however, are they wholly absent.
 
They are found even in the bones of old subjects, and in connection with them newly
 
developed systems.
 
  
This is a very important fact, as it demonstrates that the old tissue is removed in
+
==Laminae of Bone==
masses, and a new one developed in its place. It has long been taught that the
 
older particles of an internal tissue are removed by absorption and new ones substi-
 
tuted, and this throughout the life of the individual. But the authors believe that
 
they have demonstrated it for the first time.
 
  
On examining with care a series of sections, the Haversian spaces will be found in
+
Lamination is a tolerably constant character of mammalian bone, although the degree of its distinctness is subject to considerable variation. In the bones of young subjects it is less pronounced than in those of mature animals (fig. 4, Plate VI.); it is also much less observable in the cancellous than in the compact tissue. When lamination reaches its highest degree of development, each lamina is seen to be made up of two parts, an outer, which is highly granular, composed oftentimes of a single line of large granules or cells*, as shown in Plate VI. fig. 8 ; and an inner portion, which is singularly clear and transparent, and to all appearance without granulation or any recognizable structure.
various conditions. In one place the space will have attained a large size, while in  
 
another part of the same section its commencement will be seen extending from one
 
side of an Haversian canal. In a third instance, its occupation will have commenced,
 
and its festooned margin will be lined by the peripheral lamina of an Haversian
 
system. Then, again, examples may be found where one side of a space is becoming
 
the seat of a new system, while the opposite one is undergoing further enlargement.  
 
In no case is there any difficulty in distinguishing between an enlarging Haversian
 
space and a developing Haversian system. The authors have preparations which
 
show that these conditions of absorption and reproduction take place in old as well
 
as in young or middle-aged subjects ; but it would appear that the frequency dimi-
 
  
Q 2
 
  
 +
Kolliker has described and figured a somewhat similar appearance from a specimen treated with turpentine, but he does not seem to regard it as very readily discoverable in ordinary preparations; there is, however, no difficulty in exhibiting this arrangement of structure in well-made sections, either simply polished or (which is better) put up in hard Canada balsam.
  
112
 
  
 +
Very favourable views of lamination may be seen in transverse sections from the shafts of long bones ; some of the most striking illustrations in the possession of the authors were obtained from the tibia of a subject the whole of whose bones were slightly hypertrophied, and from the femur of a limb which had from infancy been atrophied and useless.
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
 
  
 +
Strongly marked laminae, with their transparent and granular portions, are however not always met with ; yet in their absence the observer will seldom fail to find laminae of more uniform granularity surrounding the Haversian canals in well-marked concentric rings.
  
nishes with the increasing age of the individual. It may however be observed in the
 
bones of those who have passed the sixtieth year. The more recently formed systems
 
differ from those of older date in the somewhat larger size of their lacunee and cana-
 
liculi, and in the greater abundance of the latter, as shown in fig. 6, Plate VI.
 
  
Lamince of Bone. — Lamination is a tolerably constant character of mammalian
+
On examining the Haversian systems, it will be seen that the peripheral lamina has its internal surface marked by an even line, while the external is subject to slight bulgings, which correspond with and accurately fit into the indentations that form the margin of a pre-existing Haversian space (Plate VI. fig. 1). Hence the outer lamina of a system will present on its external surface a certain number of alternating dilatations and contractions ; a peculiarity possessed by none of the more internal of the series. We may, however, find the whole of the laminae of a system presenting different degrees of thickness on the opposite sides of a canal, from the latter being a little eccentric in its position. But when the eccentricity is considerable, as in the case illustrated in Plate VI. fig. 7, the laminae are not all continued round the canal Hence,
bone, although the degree of its distinctness is subject to considerable variation. In
 
the bones of young subjects it is less pronounced than in those of mature animals
 
(fig. 4, Plate VI.); it is also much less observable in the cancellous than in the com-
 
pact tissue. When lamination reaches its highest degree of development, each
 
lamina is seen to be made up of two parts, an outer, which is highly granular, com-
 
posed oftentimes of a single line of large granules or cells*, as shown in Plate VI.  
 
fig. 8 ; and an inner portion, which is singularly clear and transparent, and to all
 
appearance without granulation or any recognizable structure.
 
  
Kolliker has described and figured a somewhat similar appearance from a specimen
 
treated with turpentine, but he does not seem to regard it as very readily discoverable
 
in ordinary preparations'!'; there is, however, no difficulty in exhibiting this arrange-
 
ment of structure in well-made sections, either simply polished or (which is better)
 
put up in hard Canada balsam.
 
  
Very favourable views of lamination may be seen in transverse sections from the  
+
The nature of these bodies will be more fully considered under the head of development and growth of bone.
shafts of long bones ; some of the most striking illustrations in the possession of the
+
f Kolliker, oper. cit. page 284. In ' The Microscopic Anatomy of the Human Body,' by A. H. Hassall, this appearance is indistinctly figured, but no description of it can be found in the letterpress.
authors were obtained from the tibia of a subject the whole of whose bones were
 
slightly hypertrophied, and from the femur of a limb which had from infancy been
 
atrophied and useless.  
 
  
Strongly marked laminae, with their transparent and granular portions, are how-
 
ever not always met with ; yet in their absence the observer will seldom fail to find
 
laminae of more uniform granularity surrounding the Haversian canals in well-
 
marked concentric rings.
 
  
On examining the Haversian systems, it will be seen that the peripheral lamina
+
J Kolliker, oper. cit. at page 283, states that in the eccentric systems the whole of the laminae generally in such a system, there are more laminae on one side than on the other, and those on the side occupied by the greatest number are thicker in their centres than at their extremities, where they become gradually thinner, and are ultimately lost. The inner lamina, whether the systems are eccentric or not, forms, when the development is completed,' a perfect ring, and not unfrequently presents a second peculiarity. The tissue of which it is composed is transparent, and affords, with our present means of investigation, little evidence of structure (Plate VI. figs. 6 and 7) It is transparent and glass-like, resembling that tissue which lines the Haversian canals in the antlers of the Cervidse before they are cast (Plate VII. fig. 9).
has its internal surface marked by an even line, while the external is subject to slight
 
bulgings, which correspond with and accurately fit into the indentations that form the  
 
margin of a pre-existing Haversian space (Plate VI. fig. 1). Hence the outer lamina of a  
 
system will present on its external surface a certain number of alternating dilatations
 
and contractions ; a peculiarity possessed by none of the more internal of the series.
 
We may, however, find the whole of the laminae of a system presenting different
 
degrees of thickness on the opposite sides of a canal, from the latter being a little  
 
eccentric in its position. But when the eccentricity is considerable, as in the case
 
illustrated in Plate VI. fig. 7, the laminae are not all continued round the canal Hence,
 
  
* The nature of these bodies will be more fully considered under the head of development and growth of bone.
 
  
f Kolliker, oper. cit. page 284. In ' The Microscopic Anatomy of the Human Body,' by A. H. Hassall,  
+
The interstitial laminse are abundant, and strongly marked in transverse sections of long bones, or in any sections of bone in which the Haversian systems are cut transversely. The laminse vary both as to their number and length, and are usually more or less curved. They are arranged throughout the bone in well-defined isolated groups, in each of which the constituent laminse are parallel (PlateVI. fig. 1 b). Professor Kolliker*, when treating of this subject, observes that it is difficult to account for the presence of the interstitial laminse, and suggests that the appearance may perhaps be produced by the Haversian systems being cut obliquely, but at the same time admits that this explanation is not satisfactory. M. Kolliker had not recognized the presence of the Haversian spaces and the manner of their production and subsequent occupation, otherwise he would have seen that the interstitial laminse are the remaining parts of Haversian systems, the larger portions of which had been removed by absorption. But that the term interstitial lamince is already in use and has a definite meaning, the authors would have proposed the substitution of partial Haversian systems, as being more descriptive of these parts.
this appearance is indistinctly figured, but no description of it can be found in the letterpress.  
 
  
J Kolliker, oper. cit. at page 283, states that in the eccentric systems the whole of the laminae generally
 
  
 +
In addition to the laminse of the perfect and imperfect Haversian systems, others that surround several linearly arranged systems are not uncommon, producing the appearance illustrated in Plate VI. fig. 5. In these instances a large oval system of laminse has become occupied by several lesser ones. The occurrence of one system within another is by no means rare. We may then see the characteristic einarginated outline of the older system, and within this a second similar outline marking the periphery of the younger system, as shown in Plate VI. fig. 6, in which the lamination of each is delineated.
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.
 
  
 +
The circumferential laminse are the most external, and where they exist form the surface of the bone. Their occurrence, however, is by no means so constant as is generally described, and even when present they seldom extend perfectly round the bone. The authors have scarcely seen an example in which the laminse have been continued without interruption around the shaft of a long bone, and in flat bones encircle the canal, but that they are individually thicker on the one than on the other side. Although this may be the case in some instances it has been hut rarely seen by the authors.
  
13
 
  
 +
Kolliker, page 289, oper. cit. This appearance is figured by M. Kolliker, but no reference is made to the peculiarity in the letterpress.
  
in such a system, there are more laminae on one side than on the other, and those on
+
they are even less constant. When present they appear to indicate that the bone is nearly stationary in its growth as regards thickness, for in the fast-growing bones of young animals these laminse are entirely absent, while in the bones of adults they are usually well-developed in some parts. In number they seem subject to considerable variation, and not unfrequently are arranged in different concentric series with three or four laminse in each division, separated from the adjacent series by a broad and transparent lamina, suggesting the idea of periods of greater activity of growth, alternating with others of less activity. Like those of the Haversian systems, the circumferential laminse are perforated by Haversian spaces and systems (Plate VII. fig. 10), and in many examples to such an extent that they are recognized only as interstitial laminse ; but their uniform direction parallel with the surface of the bone will satisfactorily indicate their previous existence as continuous circumferential laminse. In this part of a bone we may sometimes discover a peculiarity of character, in the presence of Haversian systems, consisting of two or three laminse, or of even a single lamina only, so small has been the preceding Haversian space.
the side occupied by the greatest number are thicker in their centres than at their
 
extremities, where they become gradually thinner, and are ultimately lost. The
 
inner lamina, whether the systems are eccentric or not, forms, when the development
 
is completed,' a perfect ring, and not unfrequently presents a second peculiarity. The
 
tissue of which it is composed is transparent, and affords, with our present means of  
 
investigation, little evidence of structure (Plate VI. figs. 6 and 7)- It is transparent
 
and glass-like, resembling that tissue which lines the Haversian canals in the antlers
 
of the Cervidse before they are cast (Plate VII. fig. 9).  
 
  
The interstitial laminse are abundant, and strongly marked in transverse sections
+
In the progress of development canals are sometimes formed which proceed from the surface of the bone into its substance, and around these the circumferential laminse are inflected, thereby forming systems, the laminse of which are continuous with those of the surface of the bone. On the other hand, Haversian spaces not unfrequently occur which are continued from the surface towards the centre of the bone, cutting the circumferential laminse abruptly across ; systems are subsequently developed in these spaces ; but in such instances the laminse of the systems are not continuous with those of the surface (the latter appearance is shown in Plate VII. fig. 10).
of long bones, or in any sections of bone in which the Haversian systems are cut
 
transversely. The laminse vary both as to their number and length, and are usually
 
more or less curved. They are arranged throughout the bone in well-defined isolated
 
groups, in each of which the constituent laminse are parallel (PlateVI. fig. 1 b). Professor
 
Kolliker*, when treating of this subject, observes that it is difficult to account for the  
 
presence of the interstitial laminse, and suggests that the appearance may perhaps be
 
produced by the Haversian systems being cut obliquely, but at the same time admits
 
that this explanation is not satisfactory. M. Kolliker had not recognized the pre-
 
sence of the Haversian spaces and the manner of their production and subsequent
 
occupation, otherwise he would have seen that the interstitial laminse are the remain-
 
ing parts of Haversian systems, the larger portions of which had been removed by
 
absorption. But that the term interstitial lamince is already in use and has a definite
 
meaning, the authors would have proposed the substitution of partial Haversian
 
systems, as being more descriptive of these parts.  
 
  
In addition to the laminse of the perfect and imperfect Haversian systems, others
 
that surround several linearly arranged systems are not uncommon, producing the
 
appearance illustrated in Plate VI. fig. 5. In these instances a large oval system of
 
laminse has become occupied by several lesser ones. The occurrence of one system
 
within another is by no means rare. We may then see the characteristic einarginated
 
outline of the older system, and within this a second similar outline marking the
 
periphery of the younger system, as shown in Plate VI. fig. 6, in which the lamination
 
of each is delineated -f-.
 
  
The circumferential laminse are the most external, and where they exist form the  
+
In young rapidly growing bone the circumferential laminse are replaced by a series, which, from the character of their course, might be termed the undulating laminse. The bone in its growth sends off outrunning processes between those vessels of the periosteum which lie nearest the surface of the bone. These processes are formed of reduplicated laminse which are continued from process to process, following the undulating surface of the bone for a considerable distance before they are lost. The growing processes as they increase in size and length arch over towards each other by the dilatation or bifurcation of the outer extremities. The salient points so formed come into contact and unite, thereby enclosing the vessels. The spaces enclosed in the manner described become the seat of Haversian systems. Hence we have at this period of growth, bone composed of Haversian systems with intervening undulating laminse, a character by which the observer cannot fail to recognise young growing bone as differing from that of adult animals. Over the points where the processes have met and united, laminse are extended which are continued outwards to form similar and more external processes ; these in their turn become united and inclose spaces. This mode of increase by the development of outgrowing processes is repeated again and again until the rate of growth becomes arrested, when the formation of ordinary circumferential laminae is assumed in some cases to be again replaced by the development of undulating laminae. It must however be remembered that in the rapidly growing bone of young subjects lamination is much less strongly pronounced than in the bones of the adult (Plate VI. fig. 4), and that in many cases it is indicated more distinctly by the arrangement of the lacunae than by the presence of well-marked outlines in the laminae themselves.
surface of the bone. Their occurrence, however, is by no means so constant as is
 
generally described, and even when present they seldom extend perfectly round the  
 
bone. The authors have scarcely seen an example in which the laminse have been
 
continued without interruption around the shaft of a long bone, and in flat bones
 
  
encircle the canal, but that they are individually thicker on the one than on the other side. Although this may
 
be the case in some instances it has been hut rarely seen by the authors.
 
  
* Kolliker, page 289, oper. cit.  
+
In addition to laminated tissue we sometimes find portions of superficial bone run in, as it were, between two or three Haversian systems, and without any appearance of lamination, but with a general transparency, and with lacunae scattered through it of indefinite form, and wanting in that arrangement which prevails in laminated bone*.
  
t This appearance is figured by M. Kolliker, but no reference is made to the peculiarity in the letterpress.
+
==Lacunas of Bone==
  
 +
In a transverse section of the Haversian systems the lacunae are seen as elongated oval spaces, lying amongst, and with their long axes in the direction of, the laminae ; numerous canaliculi proceed from them, the bulk of which in this view pass off towards either the Haversian canals or the outer surface of the systems. The lacunae are however somewhat different in appearance at different ages of the systems and of the subject. In youth they are large, numerous, and richly supplied with canaliculi ; on the other hand, in an old subject they are less numerous and have fewer canaliculi. Moreover, they vary a little in character in different parts of the same preparation, according to the age of the particular spot in which they are examined (Plate VI. fig. 6). Then, again, they frequently exist without canaliculi ; while in other cases they may be found, together with the canaliculi, in great part filled up with solid matter, leaving only a small round open space in their centre. This state of consolidation has not, so far as the authors are aware, been previously observed. It is however present to a considerable extent in the long bones of adults who have in infancy suffered from rickets, and whose bones have remained permanently distorted (Plate VII. fig. 12 a and b). More rarely a similar condition may be seen in the bones of those who have passed the middle period of life without having suffered from rickets in childhood. Hence consolidation must be regarded as a normal condition of the lacunae, of occasional occurrence, rather than as the result of disease.
  
114
 
  
 +
In favourable sections it may be shown that both the lacunae and canaliculi have parietes, which are manifested by appearances similar to those observed in the dentinal tubes. In lacunae which have no canaliculi the walls are well-marked, and in a transverse section of the latter the parietes are readily recognized, as shown in figure 11, Plate VII.
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
 
  
  
they are even less constant. When present they appear to indicate that the bone
+
Kolliker, oper. cit. p. 288, objects to the opinion of Arnold that the interstitial laminse have a different
is nearly stationary in its growth as regards thickness, for in the fast-growing bones
+
origin from the external and internal circumferential laminse, the former of which he believes to originate in the cartilage, the latter in the external and internal periosteum.
of young animals these laminse are entirely absent, while in the bones of adults they
 
are usually well-developed in some parts. In number they seem subject to consider-
 
able variation, and not unfrequently are arranged in different concentric series with
 
three or four laminse in each division, separated from the adjacent series by a broad
 
and transparent lamina, suggesting the idea of periods of greater activity of growth,
 
alternating with others of less activity. Like those of the Haversian systems, the
 
circumferential laminse are perforated by Haversian spaces and systems (Plate VII.
 
fig. 10), and in many examples to such an extent that they are recognized only as
 
interstitial laminse ; but their uniform direction parallel with the surface of the bone
 
will satisfactorily indicate their previous existence as continuous circumferential
 
laminse. In this part of a bone we may sometimes discover a peculiarity of character,  
 
in the presence of Haversian systems, consisting of two or three laminse, or of even
 
a single lamina only, so small has been the preceding Haversian space.  
 
  
In the progress of development canals are sometimes formed which proceed from
+
Kolliker' s views are inserted in the text, but it is seen above that the observations of the authors do not coincide with those of either Arnold or Kolliker.
the surface of the bone into its substance, and around these the circumferential
 
laminse are inflected, thereby forming systems, the laminse of which are continuous
 
with those of the surface of the bone. On the other hand, Haversian spaces not
 
unfrequently occur which are continued from the surface towards the centre of the
 
bone, cutting the circumferential laminse abruptly across ; systems are subsequently
 
developed in these spaces ; but in such instances the laminse of the systems are not  
 
continuous with those of the surface (the latter appearance is shown in Plate VII.
 
fig. 10).  
 
  
In young rapidly growing bone the circumferential laminse are replaced by a  
+
* This point will receive additional confirmation in a subsequent part of the paper, when the development of the lacunae and canaliculi is described.
series, which, from the character of their course, might be termed the undulating
 
laminse. The bone in its growth sends off outrunning processes between those vessels
 
of the periosteum which lie nearest the surface of the bone. These processes are
 
formed of reduplicated laminse which are continued from process to process, follow-
 
ing the undulating surface of the bone for a considerable distance before they are
 
lost. The growing processes as they increase in size and length arch over towards
 
each other by the dilatation or bifurcation of the outer extremities. The salient
 
points so formed come into contact and unite, thereby enclosing the vessels. The
 
spaces enclosed in the manner described become the seat of Haversian systems.  
 
Hence we have at this period of growth, bone composed of Haversian systems with
 
intervening undulating laminse, a character by which the observer cannot fail to
 
recognise young growing bone as differing from that of adult animals. Over the
 
points where the processes have met and united, laminse are extended which are
 
continued outwards to form similar and more external processes ; these in their turn
 
become united and inclose spaces. This mode of increase by the development of
 
outgrowing processes is repeated again and again until the rate of growth becomes
 
  
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.
 
  
 +
In a longitudinal section of Haversian systems we have the laminae on either side of the canals cut at right angles, or nearly so, while immediately over the canals they are exposed in their breadth ; in the one instance we look upon the cut edges, in the other upon the surface of the laminae. The lacunae in the two parts present differences in outline. In the former part they resemble those seen in the Haversian systems divided transversely, in the latter they approach a circular, or slightly oval figure, and send out canaliculi indifferently from all parts of their circumference. After examining the lacunae from these three different points of view, it will be manifest to the observer that the normal form is that of a greatly compressed hollow sphere or oval, from which numerous minute tubes are continued. To this prevailing form we find numerous exceptions, which, although of not unfrequent occurrence, form but a small part of the whole number that may be seen in an ordinary preparation. The outlines assumed by the exceptional lacunae are too varied and too irregular to admit of such a description as would embrace every departure from the ordinary form. It is however worthy of mention, that lacunae may sometimes be met with, normal in form, but of three times the usual dimensions.
  
115
 
  
 +
What has been said of the lacunae of the Haversian systems will of course apply also to those occupying parts of systems known under the name of interstitial laminae. In the circumferential laminae the lacunae are for the most part similar to those already described. But we have in this situation what may perhaps be regarded as modified lacunae, presenting themselves in the form of elongated tubes arranged in bundles, or occurring singly, and passing more or less obliquely from the surface towards the interior of the bone (Plate VII. fig. 13). When these tubes attain a considerable length they are commonly bent at a sharp angle once or twice in their course, and at each flexure change their direction, presenting sometimes a loose resemblance to the letter 2 . When these tubules are divided transversely they exhibit parietes. On tracing them in parts abounding with lacunae, it will be seen that they form lateral connections with the canaliculi, at the same time that they cross these as well as the lacunae and laminae obliquely. The presence of the oblique tubes is not however constant. In one part of the circumferential laminae they will be abundant, while in another they will be sparingly present or altogether absent. Then, again, they may be seen in one series of laminae, while in the contiguous set they are absent, but may reappear in a third and more deeply-seated series. They are, however, we believe, strictly confined to the limits of the circumferential laminae, and are seldom present unless these are tolerably abundant.
  
arrested, when the formation of ordinary circumferential laminae is assumed in some
 
cases to be again replaced by the development of undulating laminae. It must
 
however be remembered that in the rapidly growing bone of young subjects lamina-
 
tion is much less strongly pronounced than in the bones of the adult (Plate VI. fig. 4),
 
and that in many cases it is indicated more distinctly by the arrangement of the
 
lacunae than by the presence of well-marked outlines in the laminae themselves.
 
  
In addition to laminated tissue we sometimes find portions of superficial bone run
+
The lacunae situated in the transparent non-laminated bone, which is sometimes found on or near the surface, and to which we have before alluded, are less compressed in form than those hitherto described. They are subject to great irregularities of outline, and send off canaliculi equally from all parts of their circumference, thereby imparting a peculiarity to the tissue which cannot fail to be remarked. The presence of persistent nuclei in the lacunae has been questioned by recent authors ; some state that they may be detected at times, while others regard their presence as very problematical. Mr. Goodsir* describes the lacunae as containing a little mass of nucleated cells.
in, as it were, between two or three Haversian systems, and without any appearance
 
of lamination, but with a general transparency, and with lacunae scattered through it
 
of indefinite form, and wanting in that arrangement which prevails in laminated
 
bone*.  
 
  
Lacunas of Bone . — In a transverse section of the Haversian systems the lacunae are
 
seen as elongated oval spaces, lying amongst, and with their long axes in the direc-
 
tion of, the laminae ; numerous canaliculi proceed from them, the bulk of which in
 
this view pass off towards either the Haversian canals or the outer surface of the
 
systems. The lacunae are however somewhat different in appearance at different
 
ages of the systems and of the subject. In youth they are large, numerous, and
 
richly supplied with canaliculi ; on the other hand, in an old subject they are less
 
numerous and have fewer canaliculi. Moreover, they vary a little in character in
 
different parts of the same preparation, according to the age of the particular spot in
 
which they are examined (Plate VI. fig. 6). Then, again, they frequently exist without
 
canaliculi ; while in other cases they may be found, together with the canaliculi, in
 
great part filled up with solid matter, leaving only a small round open space in their
 
centre. This state of consolidation has not, so far as the authors are aware, been
 
previously observed. It is however present to a considerable extent in the long
 
bones of adults who have in infancy suffered from rickets, and whose bones have
 
remained permanently distorted (Plate VII. fig. 12 a and b). More rarely a similar
 
condition may be seen in the bones of those who have passed the middle period of
 
life without having suffered from rickets in childhood. Hence consolidation must
 
be regarded as a normal condition of the lacunae, of occasional occurrence, rather
 
than as the result of disease.
 
  
In favourable sections it may be shown that both the lacunae and canaliculi have  
+
M. KoLLiKER , after citing Schwann, Krause, Kohlrausch, Heischmann, Gunther and Donders, all of whom believe in the persistence of the nuclei in the lacunae, goes on to say that he has paid great attention to the subject. In the bones of an individual eighteen years old he found them after the sections had been treated with acid. The authors have had no difficulty in finding the nuclei in recent bone without the aid of chemical treatment. If a small fragment be taken from the spongy portion of a fresh bone and freed from adherent fat, the nuclei may be seen as small rounded bodies attached to the walls of the lacunae ; their appearance is shown in Plate IX. figs. 27 and 29. In dry sections of bone the nuclei are less readily recognized, although we may find them here and there. The authors have sections of a fossil bone from the Wealden (supposed to be Pterodactyle) in which all the lacunae have well-defined nuclei (Plate VII. fig. 14).
parietes, which are manifested by appearances similar to those observed in the den-
 
tinal tubes'}-. In lacunae which have no canaliculi the walls are well-marked, and in
 
  
  
* Kolliker, oper. cit. p. 288, objects to the opinion of Arnold that the interstitial laminse have a different
+
==Haversian Systems==
origin from the external and internal circumferential laminse, the former of which he believes to originate in the  
+
Having described the several parts entering into the formation of Haversian systems, it now remains to say a few words on the relations of these to each other, and to the other parts of bone which are not included under that term. The union of the Haversian and other systems of laminae is seen, in a transverse section of a long bone, to be effected by the interposition of a layer of transparent tissue. In a recently-formed system the canaliculi do not appear to pass through this layer, but in older ones they are seen to pass across from the external lacunae and to anastomose with those from the interstitial or circumferential laminae, or with those of adjoining Haversian systems (Plate VII. fig. 10). After these intercommuni- cations have been fully established, the connecting layer loses something of its original transparency, but not the whole, for in the bones of aged subjects it may still be distinguished.
cartilage, the latter in the external and internal periosteum.  
 
  
Kolliker' s views are inserted in the text, but it is seen above that the observations of the authors do not
 
coincide with those of either Arnold or Kolliker.
 
  
t This point will receive additional confirmation in a subsequent part of the paper, when the development
+
In Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman's ‘ Physiological Anatomy,' it is stated, on the authority of Mr. Tomes, that the canaliculi of adjoining systems anastomose but scantily. A more extended examination into the subject has shown this to be true of the more recently developed systems, but not of those of greater age. In addition to the con- nection of systems of laminae by the juxtaposition of their external members, instances not unfrequently occur where several Haversian systems, linearly arranged, are encircled by a series of laminae common to the whole. This is shown in Plate VI. fig. 5. But although we may find groups of systems thus bound together by enclosing laminae, in addition to the general or partial investment by circumferential laminae, such binding together is clearly not necessary to ensure the strength of the bone, as we see many bones altogether destitute of circumferential laminae, and very few with these laminae complete; while the encircling of several Haversian systems with laminae common to the whole is the exception rather than the rule.
of the lacunae and canaliculi is described.  
 
  
  
116
+
Anatomical and Pathological Observations, by John Goodsie and Henry D. S. Goodsie, 1845, t Kolliker, oper. cit. p. 296.
  
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
 
  
 +
In the progress of their investigations the authors have failed to discover any instances in which pre-existing laminae, partially absorbed, have become continuous with newly-developed ones, end to end ; indeed there seems good reason for supposing that such seldom, if ever occurs, otherwise the Haversian systems would not be so strongly marked, neither should we have the festooned outline to the systems lying against the cut ends of the laminae, in the manner shown in Plates VI. and VII. figs. 1 and 10.
  
a transverse section of the latter the parietes are readily recognized, as shown in
 
figure 11, Plate VII.
 
  
In a longitudinal section of Haversian systems we have the laminae on either side
+
In examining Haversian systems divided transversely, one will be occasionally found in which the canal has been completely obliterated by the development of a lacunal cell in its centre. This condition is illustrated in fig. 1 c.
of the canals cut at right angles, or nearly so, while immediately over the canals they
 
are exposed in their breadth ; in the one instance we look upon the cut edges, in the
 
other upon the surface of the laminae. The lacunae in the two parts present dif-
 
ferences in outline. In the former part they resemble those seen in the Haversian
 
systems divided transversely, in the latter they approach a circular, or slightly oval
 
figure, and send out canaliculi indifferently from all parts of their circumference.
 
After examining the lacunae from these three different points of view, it will be mani-
 
fest to the observer that the normal form is that of a greatly compressed hollow
 
sphere or oval, from which numerous minute tubes are continued. To this prevailing
 
form we find numerous exceptions, which, although of not unfrequent occurrence,
 
form but a small part of the whole number that may be seen in an ordinary prepara-
 
tion. The outlines assumed by the exceptional lacunae are too varied and too irre-
 
gular to admit of such a description as would embrace every departure from the
 
ordinary form. It is however worthy of mention, that lacunae may sometimes be
 
met with, normal in form, but of three times the usual dimensions.  
 
  
What has been said of the lacunae of the Haversian systems will of course apply
+
==Ossified Cartilage of Joints==
also to those occupying parts of systems known under the name of interstitial laminae.
 
In the circumferential laminae the lacunae are for the most part similar to those
 
already described. But we have in this situation what may perhaps be regarded as
 
modified lacunae, presenting themselves in the form of elongated tubes arranged in bun-
 
dles, or occurring singly, and passing more or less obliquely from the surface towards
 
the interior of the bone (Plate VII. fig. 13). When these tubes attain a considerable
 
length they are commonly bent at a sharp angle once or twice in their course, and
 
at each flexure change their direction, presenting sometimes a loose resemblance to
 
the letter 2 . When these tubules are divided transversely they exhibit parietes. On
 
tracing them in parts abounding with lacunae, it will be seen that they form lateral
 
connections with the canaliculi, at the same time that they cross these as well as the
 
lacunae and laminae obliquely. The presence of the oblique tubes is not however con-
 
stant. In one part of the circumferential laminae they will be abundant, while in
 
another they will be sparingly present or altogether absent. Then, again, they may
 
be seen in one series of laminae, while in the contiguous set they are absent, but may
 
reappear in a third and more deeply-seated series. They are, however, we believe,
 
strictly confined to the limits of the circumferential laminae, and are seldom present
 
unless these are tolerably abundant.
 
  
The lacunae situated in the transparent non-laminated bone, which is sometimes
+
Dr. Sharpe y has shown that beneath the articular cartilage lies a layer of bone produced by the gradual ossification of this tissue*. Professor KoLLiKER has observed this form of bone to be present in all the articu- lations, excepting that of the jaw and the hyoid bone, in which situations he has failed to detect it. The authors have numerous sections from the articular process of the lower jaw, in all of which it is present, and although in smaller amount than is usually found in corresponding parts of other bones, still it is sufficiently distinct. The pecu- liarity of the articular bone consists in the maintenance of the same arrangement of parts as existed in the cartilage prior to its conversion into bone. The cells for the most part are arranged in groups or in lines parallel with the long axis of the bone, each cell presenting a roundish mass surrounded by granules, and rendered rather indefinite in outline. Not uncommonly several cells become connected end to end, thus producing an elongated form. It is when in this condition that the cells and basement tissue may be restored to the appearance of cartilage by the use of hydro- chloric acid. Occasionally, however, a cell becomes converted into a well-developed lacuna, and near the ordinary bone the cells may be seen in more or less advanced stages towards their conversion (Plate VII. fig. 17).
found on or near the surface, and to which we have before alluded, are less com-
 
pressed in form than those hitherto described. They are subject to great irregularities
 
of outline, and send off canaliculi equally from all parts of their circumference, thereby
 
  
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.  
+
In the ossified cartilage, when the tissue attains a considerable thickness, broad and ill-defined lines or bands of opacity may generally be found running parallel with the articular surface, and giving a stratified character to the part in which they are situated, as shown in fig. 17 b. When seen by transmitted light, these lines appear of a deep rich brown colour, and as if possessed of a much higher degree of granularity than the surrounding parts. The cells of the tissue are not uncommonly surrounded by a similar granular condition of the matrix. This state of granularity is most con- spicuous near the bone, and less so near the cartilage, where the tissue becomes clear and transparent. The ossified cartilage is generally separated by a well-marked line from the subjacent bone. Exceptions to this, however, are not wanting, where the two pass, the one into the other, by insensible gradations. The bone at the line of junction is usually advanced into the ossified cartilage by rounded projections of variable size ; some of which reach nearly to the surface, while others are situated at some little depth. From this arrangement the articular bone is necessarily irregular in quantity. In one part it will dip to a considerable depth into the bone, while at another and perhaps contiguous part it will form but a thin layer. The external or articular surface is but slightly affected by the irregularities of the surface attached to the bone ; on the contrary, it presents an even surface, on which the articular cartilage is placed in a uniform layer.
  
  
117
+
Dr. Quain's Anatomy, fifth edition, by Mr. Quain and Dr. Sharpey, part ii. page 158. “ In the slow growth of bone which encroaches on the attached surface of articular cartilage, the ossification would almost seem to be produced merely by the impregnation of the cartilaginous matrix with earthy matter (corresponding with the first step of the ordinary process) ; and in this case, the cells and clusters of cells being surrounded by calcified matrix, may remain as little vacuities or lacunae in the bone ; but this as well as the formation of lacunae in the crusta petrosa of the teeth, and the production of adventitious bony deposits in different textures, requires further investigation.â€
  
 +
t Kolliker, page 318, oper. cit.
  
imparting a peculiarity to the tissue which cannot fail to be remarked. The presence
 
of persistent nuclei in the lacunae has been questioned by recent authors ; some state
 
that they may be detected at times, while others regard their presence as very pro-
 
blematical. Mr. Goodsir* describes the lacunae as containing a little mass of
 
nucleated cells.
 
  
M. KoLLiKER-f-, after citing Schwann, Krause, Kohlrausch, Heischmann, Gun-
 
ther and Donders, all of whom believe in the persistence of the nuclei in the lacunae,
 
goes on to say that he has paid great attention to the subject. In the bones of an
 
individual eighteen years old he found them after the sections had been treated with
 
acid. The authors have had no difficulty in finding the nuclei in recent bone with-
 
out the aid of chemical treatment. If a small fragment be taken from the spongy
 
portion of a fresh bone and freed from adherent fat, the nuclei may be seen as small
 
rounded bodies attached to the walls of the lacunae ; their appearance is shown in
 
Plate IX. figs. 27 and 29. In dry sections of bone the nuclei are less readily
 
recognized, although we may find them here and there. The authors have sections
 
of a fossil bone from the Wealden (supposed to be Pterodactyle) in which all the
 
lacunae have well-defined nuclei (Plate VII. fig. 14).
 
  
Haversian Systems . — Having described the several parts entering into the forma-
 
tion of Haversian systems, it now remains to say a few words on the relations of these
 
to each other, and to the other parts of bone which are not included under that term.
 
The union of the Haversian and other systems of laminae is seen, in a transverse
 
section of a long bone, to be effected by the interposition of a layer of transparent
 
tissue. In a recently-formed system the canaliculi do not appear to pass through
 
this layer, but in older ones they are seen to pass across from the external lacunae
 
and to anastomose with those from the interstitial or circumferential laminae, or with
 
those of adjoining Haversian systems (Plate VII. fig. 10). After these intercommuni-
 
cations have been fully established, the connecting layer loses something of its origi-
 
nal transparency, but not the whole, for in the bones of aged subjects it may still be
 
distinguished.
 
  
In Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman's ‘ Physiological Anatomy,' it is stated, on the au-
+
The absence of Haversian canals, and the unfrequency of lacunse with canaliculi in the articular bone, renders this tissue much less porous than ordinary bone, a condition which probably contributes to its strength, and to the strength of the part in which it occurs.
thority of Mr. Tomes, that the canaliculi of adjoining systems anastomose but scantily.
 
A more extended examination into the subject has shown this to be true of the more
 
recently developed systems, but not of those of greater age. In addition to the con-
 
nection of systems of laminae by the juxtaposition of their external members, instances
 
not unfrequently occur where several Haversian systems, linearly arranged, are encir-
 
cled by a series of laminae common to the whole. This is shown in Plate VI. fig. 5. But
 
although we may find groups of systems thus bound together by enclosing laminae, in
 
addition to the general or partial investment by circumferential laminae, such binding
 
together is clearly not necessary to ensure the strength of the bone, as we see many
 
  
* Anatomical and Pathological Observations, by John Goodsie and Henry D. S. Goodsie, 1845,
 
  
t Kolliker, oper. cit. p. 296.  
+
In the presence of this peculiar form of tissue at the articular extremities of bones we may perceive a striking instance of design.
  
MDCCCLIII. R
 
  
 +
It would appear that the articular cartilage must rest upon a firm and uniform surface, otherwise it would, under pressure, yield unequally, and the joint would probably be but imperfect in its action. Circumferential laminae are developed only on free surfaces, and do not present there a very level outer surface. A surface formed by Haversian systems would be irregularly fluted or nodulated, like that beneath the calcified cartilage. Neither of those forms of development, then, would effect a condition of surface similar to that attained by the ossified cartilage. A careful con- sideration of the foregoing facts will, we think, lead to the conviction, that the presence of ossified cartilage as a basis for articular cartilage must not be regarded simply as the result of a slowly progressing ossification of a tissue prone to ossify ; neither must it be regarded as an imperfectly developed tissue in which the formative process was arrested before the part had been perfected*; but it must be regarded as a constant element in the osseous system, having its special use, and necessary to the perfect organization of the skeleton in the higher forms of Vertebrata.
  
118
+
==Ossified Lacunal Cells==
 +
In addition to the parts already described, the authors have found a condition of bone which has hitherto escaped observation, or if seen, has not been recognized as a form of osseous tissue. The bones of aged people not unfrequently become extremely light and spongy, readily break, and from the diminished amount of compact tissue, may in the case of the flat bones, such as those of the pelvis, be indented by firm pressure with the finger. Such bones, after maceration, contain within the spaces enclosed by the cancelli, a white powder, which readily falls out if the bone be broken. If a little of this powder be mounted in Canada balsam, and placed in the field of the microscope, the observer will see that it is mainly composed of large nucleated cells, some of which are detached, others united into masses.
  
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
+
Kolliker, oper. cit. page 318, speaks of this tissue as imperfectly formed bone- substance.
  
  
bones altogether destitute of circumferential laminae, and very few with these laminae
+
The isolated cells have a spherical or oval form, and appear to consist of a granular nucleus surrounded by a very thick cell- wall, external to which we commonly find an aggregation of granular matter, indefinite in amount and presenting a ragged outline (Plate VII. fig. 15). The cells which are united into masses are connected by this granular matter, or ossified blastema, as it might perhaps be called. The cells them- selves are similar to the loose ones, excepting that in some cases their character is rendered more apparent by the nucleus assuming the form of a lacuna. If a section of the bone be examined, similar cells will be found adherent to the walls of the Haversian canals, with the canaliculi of contiguous lacunae advancing into them, while the nuclei of the adherent cells are assuming the form of lacunae and throwing out canaliculi.
complete; while the encircling of several Haversian systems with laminae common to
 
the whole is the exception rather than the rule.  
 
  
In the progress of their investigations the authors have failed to discover any
 
instances in which pre-existing laminae, partially absorbed, have become continuous
 
with newly-developed ones, end to end ; indeed there seems good reason for supposing
 
that such seldom, if ever occurs, otherwise the Haversian systems would not be so
 
strongly marked, neither should we have the festooned outline to the systems lying
 
against the cut ends of the laminae, in the manner shown in Plates VI. and VII. figs. 1
 
and 10.
 
  
In examining Haversian systems divided transversely, one will be occasionally
+
Again, in the substance of the bone, the outline of the formative cells, similar in size and shape to the loose ones, may be in places recognized, having lacunae and canaliculi as their centres. The recognition of these ossified cells in their isolated state will be followed by the observation of similar cells occupying the Haversian canals and eancellar spaces in the majority of microscopic preparations of adult bone (Plate VI. fig. 5 a ) ; and the same may sometimes be seen on the outer surface of bone (Plate VII. fig. 18). The appearance of the cells is, however, liable to be modified by the various circumstances which operate upon growing bone, such as the presence of a tendon, or of a large pulsating vessel, or in fact, by pressure from any cause. Thus if situated in the immediate neighbourhood of a tendon, they assume an elon- gated form ; while on the other hand they may be flattened by pressure.
found in which the canal has been completely obliterated by the development of a  
 
lacunal cell in its centre. This condition is illustrated in fig. 1 c.  
 
  
Ossified Cartilage of Joints. — Dr. Sharpe y has shown that beneath the articular
 
cartilage lies a layer of bone produced by the gradual ossification of this tissue*.
 
Professor KoLLiKER-f- has observed this form of bone to be present in all the articu-
 
lations, excepting that of the jaw and the hyoid bone, in which situations he has failed
 
to detect it. The authors have numerous sections from the articular process of the
 
lower jaw, in all of which it is present, and although in smaller amount than is usually
 
found in corresponding parts of other bones, still it is sufficiently distinct. The pecu-
 
liarity of the articular bone consists in the maintenance of the same arrangement of
 
parts as existed in the cartilage prior to its conversion into bone. The cells for the
 
most part are arranged in groups or in lines parallel with the long axis of the bone,
 
each cell presenting a roundish mass surrounded by granules, and rendered rather
 
indefinite in outline. Not uncommonly several cells become connected end to end,
 
thus producing an elongated form. It is when in this condition that the cells and
 
basement tissue may be restored to the appearance of cartilage by the use of hydro-
 
chloric acid. Occasionally, however, a cell becomes converted into a well-developed
 
lacuna, and near the ordinary bone the cells may be seen in more or less advanced
 
stages towards their conversion (Plate VII. fig. 17).
 
  
In the ossified cartilage, when the tissue attains a considerable thickness, broad and  
+
It has been thought desirable to describe the ossified lacunal cells at this place, on account of their frequent occurrence in adult bone (Plate VI. fig. 5 a, and Plate VII. figs. 16 and 18).
ill-defined lines or bands of opacity may generally be found running parallel with the
 
articular surface, and giving a stratified character to the part in which they are
 
situated, as shown in fig. 17 b. When seen by transmitted light, these lines appear of
 
  
* Dr. Quain's Anatomy, fifth edition, by Mr. Quain and Dr. Sharpey, part ii. page 158. “ In the slow
+
==Bone Tissue==
 +
Hitherto we have confined our description to the forms in which the bone substance is arranged, as into laminae, Haversian systems, &c. We have now to consider the ultimate structure of the tissue itself. But little has been said upon this point until within the last ten years. In the ‘Physiological Anatomy' of Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman*, it is stated that bone is made up of an aggregation of granules in a scarcely distinguishable matrix. Latterly, other views have been pro- posed. Dr. Sharpey has advanced the hypothesis, that although the bone developed in cartilage is at one period granular-^, a reticulate fibrous arrangement of the elements
  
growth of bone which encroaches on the attached surface of articular cartilage, the ossification would almost
+
* Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman, Physiological Anatomy, page 108.
seem to be produced merely by the impregnation of the cartilaginous matrix with earthy matter (correspond-
 
ing with the first step of the ordinary process) ; and in this case, the cells and clusters of cells being surrounded
 
by calcified matrix, may remain as little vacuities or lacunae in the bone ; but this as well as the formation of
 
lacunae in the crusta petrosa of the teeth, and the production of adventitious bony deposits in different textures,  
 
requires further investigation.”
 
  
t Kolliker, page 318, oper. cit.  
+
* Dr. Quain's Anatomy, edited by Mr. Quain and Dr. Sharpey, page 157.  - The primary osseous matter forming the original thin walls of the areolae is, as Mr. Tomes observes, decidedly granular, and has a of the tissue takes its place, and must be regarded as the general condition of bone*. Dr. Sharpey, when he formed this opinion, had directed his attention principally to thin fragments torn from the surface of bone macerated in hydrochloric acid. The authors have seen the appearance both in decalcified bone, and in sections which have not been chemically treated ; but they believe the fibrous appearance to be an optical effect produced by the canaliculi and granules when the light is unequally distributed, or the object-glass in bad adjustment. It will be shown in the subse- quent details, that the appearance can be produced and dispelled at pleasure by alterations in the direction of the transmitted light. If thin sections of bone are seen by transmitted light (passing through in the axis of the microscope,) the tissue will appear either granular or structureless, and in the laminae alternations of granular and structureless parts will be seen. But if the light be allowed to pass in one direction only, and with considerable obliquity through the specimen, then the appearance of extremely minute fibres will present itself ; and this not only in adult bone, but in the isolated cells of old and in developing young bone. They are most strongly marked over the lacunae ; to which, and to the canaliculi, a confused and broken outline is given. The fibres appear as though arranged in series of short and broken lengths, parallel, and without plaiting. If the specimen be a little out of focus there will be an appearance of reticulated fibres marked by nebulous outlines. On the other hand, if we have light passing from all sides obliquely through the preparation, that is, if the object be illuminated by a hollow cone of light, in the manner obtainable by Mr. Gillett's arrangement of achromatic condenser, or by rendering opake the centre of the lower lens of the ordinary achromatic condenser, the fibres disappear, and we see in their place a granular tissue, with a tendency here and there to a linear arrangement of the granules, and the lacunae and canaliculi clear and distinct, when well in focus, but with a fibre-like nebulosity when slightly out of focus, especially in those parts where the latter run obliquely through the specimen. This is more especially the case where the canaliculi are filled with fluid, or where they have become solid, a condition very common in the bones of old subjects. Indeed, in many specimens where the bone is not highly developed, a fibrous appearance at once strikes the eye, and it is only on careful exa- mination of the surface of the section that the illusion is dispelled by the orifices of the canaliculi appearing at the termination of the apparent fibres. Amongst a great many examples the authors have not seen an instance in which the fibrous appearance could not be traced to canaliculi, this effect being often increased by the presence of granules. If parallel dentinal tubes be viewed by a side light, in the manner we have described, each tube will throw two or three strong nebulous lines, which might be mistaken for fibres ; and if tubes cut transversly be inspected in a similar manner, each will appear to have several concentric lines extending half round it on the side opposite to that from which the light proceeds.
  
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.  
+
dark appearance ; the subsequent or secondary deposit, on the other hand, is quite transparent, and of a uni- form and homogeneous aspect, without obvious granules. This begins to cover the granular bone a very short distance (about the -g^th of an inch) below the surface of ossification, and, as already stated, increases further down. The lacunae first appear in this deposit ; there are none in the primary granular bone. In what further regards the nature and formation of the secondary deposit, my own observations lead me to differ considerably from the views of Mr. Tomes. He supposes that it is formed of cells which become impregnated with earthy matter, — the cartilage cells in the first instance, and afterwards the cells newly formed in the blastema. Now although certain appearances render it not improbable that there may be a layer of flattened and calcified cells next to the surface of the granular bone, I am nevertheless disposed to think that the subsequent and chief part of the deposit results from the calcification of successive layers of fibres generated in the blastema, and possibly derived from the granular cells, some cells being perhaps also involved along with the fibres, as in the ossifica- tion of the flat bones of the cranium : in short, it appears to me that the deposit in question is formed after the manner of intramembranous ossification already described (page 150). I infer that such is the process from the structure of the layers, for they are made up of fine reticulated fibres like the lamellae of perfect bone shown at page 143.
  
 +
On this point Kolliker, oper. cit. p. 289, observes, “ Die Grundsubstanz der Knochen besteht nach
 +
Sharpey und Hassall aus einem Netzwerk feiner Fasern mit rhombischen Maschen, von welchen Fasern ich weder an frischen, noch an mit Reagentien behandelten Knochen eine Spur habe entdecken konnen. Was Arnold neulich Primitiv-fasern der Knochen nennt, sind, wie seine Abbildungen lehren, nur die Granula der Grundsubstanz, an denen er eine lineare Aneinanderreihung zu erkennen glaubt, und seine Querstreifen auf Flachenschnitten, und radiaren Linien auf Querschliffen, wenigstens die letzteren sicher, nichts als die Auslaufer der Knochenhohlen. Sollten durch irgend ein Reagens in dem Knochengewebe deutliche Fibrillen nach- gewiesen werden konnen, was mir aber noch nicht gelungen ist, so konnten dieselben wohl keine anderen sein, als diejenigen, welche in ossificirenden Knorpel das streifige Ansehen bewirken und die von Sharpey und mir bei der Knochenbildung aus dem Periost beschriebenen.
  
119
 
  
  
a deep rich brown colour, and as if possessed of a much higher degree of granularity
+
That the presence of granules imbedded in a less refractive tissue may, when viewed by a side light, give an appearance of fibres, is shown on an examination of pus-globules under similar circumstances, when each globule will seem to have a striated surface ; and that slightly rounded prominences will produce a like effect is shown in the case of some species of Navicula. The surface of these latter objects is marked by rows of slight prominences, which, when the light is oblique and passes through the specimen from one point only, appear as lines or fibres, the direction of which will change with alteration in the direction of the light ; that is to say, shadows will extend from one eminence to another in the opposite direction to that from which the light enters. If we examine the projecting spiculae of bone forming in temporary cartilage under corresponding conditions as regards light, a similar fibrous appearance will be developed.
than the surrounding parts. The cells of the tissue are not uncommonly surrounded
 
by a similar granular condition of the matrix. This state of granularity is most con-  
 
spicuous near the bone, and less so near the cartilage, where the tissue becomes clear
 
and transparent. The ossified cartilage is generally separated by a well-marked line
 
from the subjacent bone. Exceptions to this, however, are not wanting, where the  
 
two pass, the one into the other, by insensible gradations. The bone at the line of  
 
junction is usually advanced into the ossified cartilage by rounded projections of  
 
variable size ; some of which reach nearly to the surface, while others are situated at
 
some little depth. From this arrangement the articular bone is necessarily irregular
 
in quantity. In one part it will dip to a considerable depth into the bone, while at
 
another and perhaps contiguous part it will form but a thin layer. The external or
 
articular surface is but slightly affected by the irregularities of the surface attached
 
to the bone ; on the contrary, it presents an even surface, on which the articular car-
 
tilage is placed in a uniform layer.  
 
  
The absence of Haversian canals, and the unfrequency of lacunse with canaliculi in
 
the articular bone, renders this tissue much less porous than ordinary bone, a condi-
 
tion which probably contributes to its strength, and to the strength of the part in
 
which it occurs.
 
  
In the presence of this peculiar form of tissue at the articular extremities of bones
+
Under these circumstances the authors are forced to the conclusion that bone substance, instead of being made up of minute reticulate fibres, is composed of granules or granular cells, imbedded in a more or less clear homogeneous or subgra- nular matrix. This subject will receive further elucidation under the head of deve- lopment. These views are supported by the appearances presented not only in deve- loping bone of young subjects, but also in the bone of adults.
we may perceive a striking instance of design.  
 
  
It would appear that the articular cartilage must rest upon a firm and uniform
 
surface, otherwise it would, under pressure, yield unequally, and the joint would pro-
 
bably be but imperfect in its action. Circumferential laminae are developed only on
 
free surfaces, and do not present there a very level outer surface. A surface formed
 
by Haversian systems would be irregularly fluted or nodulated, like that beneath
 
the calcified cartilage. Neither of those forms of development, then, would effect a
 
condition of surface similar to that attained by the ossified cartilage. A careful con-
 
sideration of the foregoing facts will, we think, lead to the conviction, that the
 
presence of ossified cartilage as a basis for articular cartilage must not be regarded
 
simply as the result of a slowly progressing ossification of a tissue prone to ossify ;
 
neither must it be regarded as an imperfectly developed tissue in which the forma-
 
tive process was arrested before the part had been perfected*; but it must be
 
regarded as a constant element in the osseous system, having its special use, and
 
necessary to the perfect organization of the skeleton in the higher forms of Verte-
 
brata.
 
  
Ossified Lacunal Cells . — In addition to the parts already described, the authors
+
Thus as regards the basement homogeneous tissue, it will be found that where lamination is highly developed, the laminae have a transparent and structureless, and a more opake and granular part, to which the former appears to be the matrix. The peripheral lamina of the Haversian systems is generally clear and free from granularity, and the internal lamina sometimes presents a similar structureless appearance. The matter which fills up the Haversian systems in the full-grown antlers of the Cervidse, affords another and a very striking example of transparent structureless osseous tissue, which in this instance is the more distinct from the absence of canaliculi in its sub- stance. Then, again, we have another instance in the clear tissue which is some- times found between the superficial Haversian systems of ordinary bone. It has already been described as a non-laminated element found on the surface of certain bones. In the instances already cited, and no doubt in many others which may be found in the skeletons of the lower vertebrata, we have bone tissue without obvious granularity and without obvious structure, and although it forms but a small part of the general mass, yet from its constant presence at all ages and in all subjects, it must be regarded as an integral and normal part of mammalian bone. The granular condition of bone tissue is tolerably obvious in all preparations, though it is much more strongly marked in some specimens than in others. The amount of the com- ponent granules varies in different parts of the same specimen, and in specimens taken from different parts of the skeleton. Thus in one situation we may see laminae with a highly granular part gradually merging into a transparent tissue, while in another the laminae may be granular throughout. Again in young bone developed in cartilage, the part between the cells becomes, highly granular ; fragments of which may be found in certain adult bones, as in the petrous portion of the temporal bone (Plate VII. fig. 16 b). Bone near the articular surface frequently presents a well-marked gra- nularity. Whether the granular and the transparent parts of bone contain different relative amounts of phosphate of lime is a question yet to be decided.
have found a condition of bone which has hitherto escaped observation, or if seen,  
 
has not been recognized as a form of osseous tissue. The bones of aged people
 
not unfrequently become extremely light and spongy, readily break, and from the  
 
diminished amount of compact tissue, may in the case of the flat bones, such as  
 
* Kolliker, oper. cit. page 318, speaks of this tissue as imperfectly formed bone- substance.  
 
  
R 2
+
==Development of Bone==
  
 +
Temporary cartilage, when it first appears in the embryo, consists of an aggregation of closely packed nucleated cells, which in the process of growth become separated by the development of a tissue external to them, usually designated the hyaline tissue of cartilage. At this stage of growth we have a granular cell occupying a cavity in the hyaline tissue ; at a previous period the granular cell was inclosed by an outer cell-wall, to which it formed the nucleus, but now the cell-wall has merged into the hyaline tissue, from which it can no longer be distinguished, while the granular cell contains itself one or more nuclei. In making sections of cartilage many of these granular cells escape from their cavities in the hyaline tissue, and may be seen detached and floating about in the field of the microscope. Some little confusion of terms has arisen in connexion with this part of the subject. The granular cells are not unfrequently described under the name of cartilage-nuclei containing nucleoli, while in fact they are cells capable of separation from the matrix, and are at one period the only recognisable cartilage cells. They occur singly or in groups, more frequently however two or three are extended in a line. It is proposed in the present communication to call these bodies granular cartilage cells , as distinguished from a form which the cells assume previous to ossification. Cartilage previous to its conversion into bone undergoes a rapid growth, which takes place principally in the direction of the long axis of the future bone. Each granular cell becomes divided into two by segmentation transverse to the line of ossific advance. These are again divided, and the process repeated from time to time, till in the place of a single granular cell we have a long line of cells extending from the unchanged cartilage to the point where ossification has taken place. Contemporaneously with this development of lines of cells, other changes are going on in the individual cells composing them. If we examine those situated near the advancing bone, it will be observed that the granular cells have enlarged, have become separated from each other by wide intervals, and that each has become in- vested with a thick pellucid cell-wall (Plate VIII. figs. 19 and 20). The increase in the size of the cells has occurred at the expense of the hyaline tissue, which, at those points where the rounded cells approach each other, is reduced to a thin film, although in the intervals left by the packing of the uncompressed cells it exists to a considerable amount. Here then we have a matrix containing cartilage cells composed of an outer pellucid coat, within which is a granular cell containing central nuclei, a cell consisting of three distinct parts. The nucleus existed previous to the segmentation of the granular cell, but the outer wall is the product of a subsequent development. It will be observed that growth is effected by two modes ; first, by the increase of the number of the cells ; and, secondly, by the increase of their size individually.
  
120
 
  
 +
While these changes are going on for lengthening the shaft of a long bone, cells are being added by a somewhat similar process of division to the surface, so as to increase the diameter of the cartilage. For the development of the epiphysis the cells become multiplied on a similar principle, but instead of occurring in lines they are accumulated in oval or rounded groups*.
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
 
  
 +
From this general view of the subject we will now proceed to consider in detail those conditions of cartilage which precede and prepare for its conversion into bone. These phenomena may be conveniently examined in the cartilage which connects the diaphysis and epiphysis of long bones, and we may take those of a lamb or calf, as they present the same conditions as are found in the human subject, and have the advantage over those of other domestic animals of being readily obtainable at all times without the necessity of destroying the animal for the sole purpose of physiolo- gical investigation.
  
those of the pelvis, be indented by firm pressure with the finger. Such bones, after
 
maceration, contain within the spaces enclosed by the cancelli, a white powder, which
 
readily falls out if the bone be broken. If a little of this powder be mounted in
 
Canada balsam, and placed in the field of the microscope, the observer will see that
 
it is mainly composed of large nucleated cells, some of which are detached, others
 
united into masses.
 
  
The isolated cells have a spherical or oval form, and appear to consist of a granular
+
At that point in the cartilage where the linear arrangement of cells commences, several of these bodies lie side by side in the same column, but by following the line downwards towards the advancing bone, it will be seen that the column usually divides, forming two or three distinct lines, in each of which the cells are arranged in single file. It does not appear that the number of cells entering into the formation of a series is at all limited ; hence the lines or columns vary in length. Neither does it appear that the consecutive lines are placed, as a rule, end to end, so as to form one long continuous straight line by the junction of several shorter ones. On the contrary, each series is complete in itself, and is generally placed a little to the one or other side of those above and below it. We have in fact interrupted lines of cells, each line the offspring of a single cell, the outer walls of which have merged into the intercellular or hyaline tissue.
nucleus surrounded by a very thick cell- wall, external to which we commonly find an
 
aggregation of granular matter, indefinite in amount and presenting a ragged outline
 
(Plate VII. fig. 15). The cells which are united into masses are connected by this
 
granular matter, or ossified blastema, as it might perhaps be called. The cells them-
 
selves are similar to the loose ones, excepting that in some cases their character is  
 
rendered more apparent by the nucleus assuming the form of a lacuna. If a section
 
of the bone be examined, similar cells will be found adherent to the walls of the
 
Haversian canals, with the canaliculi of contiguous lacunae advancing into them,
 
while the nuclei of the adherent cells are assuming the form of lacunae and throwing
 
out canaliculi.  
 
  
Again, in the substance of the bone, the outline of the formative cells, similar in
 
size and shape to the loose ones, may be in places recognized, having lacunae and
 
canaliculi as their centres. The recognition of these ossified cells in their isolated
 
state will be followed by the observation of similar cells occupying the Haversian
 
canals and eancellar spaces in the majority of microscopic preparations of adult bone
 
(Plate VI. fig. 5 a ) ; and the same may sometimes be seen on the outer surface of bone
 
(Plate VII. fig. 18). The appearance of the cells is, however, liable to be modified by
 
the various circumstances which operate upon growing bone, such as the presence
 
of a tendon, or of a large pulsating vessel, or in fact, by pressure from any cause.
 
Thus if situated in the immediate neighbourhood of a tendon, they assume an elon-
 
gated form ; while on the other hand they may be flattened by pressure.
 
  
It has been thought desirable to describe the ossified lacunal cells at this place, on
+
Previous to the ossification of the epiphysis the cartilage at the heads of the bone is increased in its bulk from additions to the surface, by a process somewhat similar to that through which the growth of bone is effected. This process will be described when the latter subject is considered.
account of their frequent occurrence in adult bone (Plate VI. fig. 5 a, and Plate VII.
 
figs. 16 and 18).  
 
  
Bone Tissue . — Hitherto we have confined our description to the forms in which
 
the bone substance is arranged, as into laminae, Haversian systems, &c. We have
 
now to consider the ultimate structure of the tissue itself. But little has been said
 
upon this point until within the last ten years. In the ‘Physiological Anatomy' of
 
Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman*, it is stated that bone is made up of an aggregation of
 
granules in a scarcely distinguishable matrix. Latterly, other views have been pro-
 
posed. Dr. Sharpey has advanced the hypothesis, that although the bone developed
 
in cartilage is at one period granular-^, a reticulate fibrous arrangement of the elements
 
  
* Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman, Physiological Anatomy, page 108.
 
  
t Dr. Quain's Anatomy, edited by Mr. Quain and Dr. Sharpey, page 157. “The primary osseous
+
When the destined number of cells forming a linear series has been developed, each cell becomes itself a centre of growth. The granular cell enlarges, together with its nucleus, and becomes invested with a cell-wall. In examining a line of these bodies extending from the forming bone of the diaphysis, we shall see them in various degrees of forwardness. Thus, if attention be directed to the end of the line furthest from the bone, the cells will be found small in size, granular, and with a perceptible nucleus, but without an outer wall, distinguishable from the hyaline substance, which is abundant between the contiguous lines, but small in quantity between the cells composing the lines. But if the other end of the line be examined, very different conditions will be observed. The granular cells will be seen to have become rounded in form, to have increased to three times their original bulk, and to possess well-marked circular nuclei ; in addition to which each granular cell will have acquired a thick pellucid outer wall, while the hyaline tissue between contiguous lines of cells will have dwindled down to a thin film, excepting in those parts where spaces are necessarily left in the approximation of spherical bodies (Plate VI. figs. 19, 20). The abundance of the hyaline tissue in the earlier condition of cartilage, affords space for the development of the cells in the breadth of the bone, but in the direction of the length of the bone we find but little of that tissue, yet each component cell of the almost innumerable lines of cells that exist, even in a bone of small size, is itself a centre of growth. At the osseous end of a line, a single cell occupies more space than four or five at the opposite extremity ; and as in each situation the cells are im- bedded in hyaline tissue, it is evident that there is a concurrent growth of the latter throughout each line of cells, and also of the cells and hyaline tissue in the breadth of the cartilage. But for this provision of nature, cells would grow at the cost of those in their neighbourhood, a condition which obtains wherever space for a secondary development of bone is required, a description of which will follow in the subsequent pages of this paper. Then, again, had we concurrent growth in each cell of a series without a similar growth in all the other series, throughout the breadth of the bone, the growing series would encroach upon the cartilage in which the linear arrangement had not commenced, and ultimately unite by osseous tissue the epiphysis and diaphysis before the bone had acquired its normal length. And supposing concurrent growth to take place over the one-half of the breadth of a bone and not in the other, the bone would become curved and the limb distorted.
matter forming the original thin walls of the areolae is, as Mr. Tomes observes, decidedly granular, and has a  
 
  
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.  
+
We have traced in temporary cartilage those changes which occur preparatory to its conversion into bone : it now remains for the authors to describe the results of their researches on the mode in which that conversion is effected, and concerning which there hitherto has been a great diversity of opinion.
  
  
121
+
Preceding ossific deposit, the intercolumnar tissue, which may not only be seen between the columns of cells, but also passing more or less perfectly between the individual cells, becomes in some cases slightly fibrous in appearance, and of a light brown colour; this condition speedily gives way to a highly granular state; in fact it has become bone, and encloses, in osseous cavities or crypts, the cartilage cells. For reasons which will hereafter be sufficiently obvious, we shall in future call these lacunal cells. If thin sections be made with a very sharp knife through ossifying cartilage, and placed in water or albumen under the quarter or eighth object-glass, we shall occasionally find lacunal cells which have escaped from their osseous crypts, floating loose in the fluid, and offering a favourable opportunity for the examination of their characters. It may then be seen that the thick pellucid outer investment has become granular, and that the enclosed granular cell has lost its regular outline, and become angular or ragged, while the nucleus has become obscured by the changes in the more external parts of the cell, an early stage of which is seen in Plate VIII. fig. 19 and 22 a. Such are the appearances presented in some of the detached lacunal cells, but they may be seen in both earlier and later stages of development than that described. Thus instances may be found where the outer coat has only a few granules on the surface, in which case the granular cell may be seen more di- stinctly, and minute elongated processes traced, extending from its surface (Plate VIII. figs. 19 and 20). In a favourable section we sometimes find such a cell with its outer coat torn, exposing to full view the granular cell, with numerous and well- marked processes extending from it. Dr. Sharpey kindly placed at the disposal of the authors the rickety bone of a child who died during the active condition of the disease. In this specimen granular cells with radiating processes can with great readiness be detached by tearing a thin section, for in this case cartilage assumed the arrangement of bone without the impregnation of earthy ingredients (Plate VIII. fig. 23)*.
  
  
of the tissue takes its place, and must be regarded as the general condition of bone*.
+
The third condition, in which we may find isolated lacunal cells detached from the osseous crypts of the intercellular tissue, differs from those already described in their greater solidity. The whole mass has become highly granular, and the granular cell with its processes has united to the outer coat, so that the two can no longer be separated the one from the other, and are no longer to be recognized as distinct parts. If accidentally broken across, we see that they have a hollow centre, in fact, a lacuna ; but when loose and entire, they appear as rounded dense masses, project- ing from the surface of which we may not unfrequently detect a few short needle- like processes. Lacunal cells of the latter kind are not, however, very easily de- tached, for when they have advanced thus far in development, their union with ossified intercolumnar tissue is too strong to admit of ready separation ; indeed, after this period their separation is impossible. It has been stated that the granular cells of cartilage previous to the formation of lacunal cells send out processes. There are, however, a certain number of granular cells that do not appear to undergo this change, but preserve their state of granulation and their external figure, and show the round nucleus even after they are surrounded by and imbedded in ossified tissue. Indeed, we may find perfectly ossified crypts of intercolumnar tissue at some little depth within the forming bone, containing several of these granular cells in an unaltered condition, and this without the cavities having been enlarged by absorption of their walls (Plate VIII. fig. 19 d ). It is important to bear this point in mind, as it will sub- sequently be shown that similar granular cells lie loose in the large cavities formed by absorption, and that they are concerned in the formation of bone when that tissue is not preceded by ordinary cartilage.
Dr. Sharpey, when he formed this opinion, had directed his attention principally to
 
thin fragments torn from the surface of bone macerated in hydrochloric acid. The  
 
authors have seen the appearance both in decalcified bone, and in sections which
 
have not been chemically treated ; but they believe the fibrous appearance to be an
 
optical effect produced by the canaliculi and granules when the light is unequally
 
distributed, or the object-glass in bad adjustment. It will be shown in the subse-
 
quent details, that the appearance can be produced and dispelled at pleasure by
 
alterations in the direction of the transmitted light. If thin sections of bone are seen
 
by transmitted light (passing through in the axis of the microscope,) the tissue will
 
appear either granular or structureless, and in the laminae alternations of granular
 
and structureless parts will be seen. But if the light be allowed to pass in one
 
direction only, and with considerable obliquity through the specimen, then the
 
appearance of extremely minute fibres will present itself ; and this not only in adult
 
bone, but in the isolated cells of old and in developing young bone. They are  
 
most strongly marked over the lacunae ; to which, and to the canaliculi, a confused
 
and broken outline is given. The fibres appear as though arranged in series of  
 
short and broken lengths, parallel, and without plaiting. If the specimen be
 
a little out of focus there will be an appearance of reticulated fibres marked by  
 
  
  
dark appearance ; the subsequent or secondary deposit, on the other hand, is quite transparent, and of a uni-
+
* Kolliker, oper. cit. at p. 360, describes accurately the formation of lacunae from cartilage cells in a rickety
form and homogeneous aspect, without obvious granules. This begins to cover the granular bone a very short
+
bone, and although he has not observed the changes with equal distinctness in normal bone, appears to have satisfied himself that in the ossification of cartilage the cells of the latter become converted into lacunae. M. Kolliker does not however seem to have recognized the relation of the lacunal cells as such to the inter- cellular tissue, neither does he mention the fact that the granular cells with their long stellated processes can be separated from the investing cell-wall in the manner described in the text.
distance (about the -g^th of an inch) below the surface of ossification, and, as already stated, increases further
 
down. The lacunae first appear in this deposit ; there are none in the primary granular bone. In what further
 
regards the nature and formation of the secondary deposit, my own observations lead me to differ considerably
 
from the views of Mr. Tomes. He supposes that it is formed of cells which become impregnated with earthy
 
matter, — the cartilage cells in the first instance, and afterwards the cells newly formed in the blastema. Now
 
although certain appearances render it not improbable that there may be a layer of flattened and calcified cells
 
next to the surface of the granular bone, I am nevertheless disposed to think that the subsequent and chief part
 
of the deposit results from the calcification of successive layers of fibres generated in the blastema, and possibly
 
derived from the granular cells, some cells being perhaps also involved along with the fibres, as in the ossifica-  
 
tion of the flat bones of the cranium : in short, it appears to me that the deposit in question is formed after
 
the manner of intramembranous ossification already described (page 150). I infer that such is the process
 
from the structure of the layers, for they are made up of fine reticulated fibres like the lamellae of perfect bone
 
shown at page 143.”
 
  
* On this point Kolliker, oper. cit. p. 289, observes, “ Die Grundsubstanz der Knochen besteht nach
 
Sharpey und Hassall aus einem Netzwerk feiner Fasern mit rhombischen Maschen, von welchen Fasern ich
 
weder an frischen, noch an mit Reagentien behandelten Knochen eine Spur habe entdecken konnen. Was
 
Arnold neulich Primitiv-fasern der Knochen nennt, sind, wie seine Abbildungen lehren, nur die Granula der
 
Grundsubstanz, an denen er eine lineare Aneinanderreihung zu erkennen glaubt, und seine Querstreifen auf
 
Flachenschnitten, und radiaren Linien auf Querschliffen, wenigstens die letzteren sicher, nichts als die Auslaufer
 
der Knochenhohlen. Sollten durch irgend ein Reagens in dem Knochengewebe deutliche Fibrillen nach-
 
gewiesen werden konnen, was mir aber noch nicht gelungen ist, so konnten dieselben wohl keine anderen sein,
 
als diejenigen, welche in ossificirenden Knorpel das streifige Ansehen bewirken und die von Sharpey und mir
 
bei der Knochenbildung aus dem Periost beschriebenen.”
 
  
 +
If a section of developing bone, including a little of the cartilage, be dried, and mounted in Canada balsam, we shall be able to recognize, first the cartilage with the cells greatly contracted, then the ossified intercolumnar tissue full of little crypts, from which, in the process of drying, the lacunal cells have disappeared (Plate VIII. fig.24 a ) ; and lastly, we shall see bone in which ossified lacunal cells run in lines correspond- ing to the preceding lines of cartilage cells (fig. 24 b). The latter appearance is, however, interrupted by the presence of numerous large spaces produced by the absorption of both the intercolumnar tissue and the lacunal cells (fig. 24 c), the process for the removal of which commences concurrently with the impregnation of the lacunal cells with the earthy salt.
  
122
 
  
 +
These conditions can be also very favourably observed in sections of the long bones of a foetal lamb, taken previous to the commencement of ossification of the epiphysis, and examined in the liquor amnii ; water will not answer as a substitute for this fluid, as the cartilage cells are speedily altered in character by its presence. And we may here observe that the examination of developing bone should be con- ducted on perfectly fresh subjects, and that care should be taken to keep the knives, glass, &c., which are used in preparing the sections, perfectly free from extraneous matter; otherwise the results will be unsatisfactory. Thus a small quantity of spirits of wine or of acid will produce changes of character in the specimen, and thereby lead the observer into an erroneous conception of the normal characters of the tissue.
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
 
  
 +
Hitherto the authors of this communication have spoken principally of those ap- pearances which are presented in sections made parallel with the advancing bone ; attention must now be directed to sections made across the bone, so as to cut trans- versely the lines of cartilage cells.
  
nebulous outlines. On the other hand, if we have light passing from all sides
 
obliquely through the preparation, that is, if the object be illuminated by a hollow
 
cone of light, in the manner obtainable by Mr. Gillett's arrangement of achromatic
 
condenser, or by rendering opake the centre of the lower lens of the ordinary achro-
 
matic condenser, the fibres disappear, and we see in their place a granular tissue,
 
with a tendency here and there to a linear arrangement of the granules, and the
 
lacunae and canaliculi clear and distinct, when well in focus, but with a fibre-like
 
nebulosity when slightly out of focus, especially in those parts where the latter run
 
obliquely through the specimen. This is more especially the case where the cana-
 
liculi are filled with fluid, or where they have become solid, a condition very common
 
in the bones of old subjects. Indeed, in many specimens where the bone is not highly
 
developed, a fibrous appearance at once strikes the eye, and it is only on careful exa-
 
mination of the surface of the section that the illusion is dispelled by the orifices of
 
the canaliculi appearing at the termination of the apparent fibres. Amongst a great
 
many examples the authors have not seen an instance in which the fibrous appear-
 
ance could not be traced to canaliculi, this effect being often increased by the pre-
 
sence of granules. If parallel dentinal tubes be viewed by a side light, in the manner
 
we have described, each tube will throw two or three strong nebulous lines, which
 
might be mistaken for fibres ; and if tubes cut transversly be inspected in a similar
 
manner, each will appear to have several concentric lines extending half round it on
 
the side opposite to that from which the light proceeds.
 
  
That the presence of granules imbedded in a less refractive tissue may, when
+
If, then, we take a thin section through the cartilage where ossification of the inter- cellular tissue is advancing, the following appearances will be seen. The intercellular tissue will present itself in the form of more or less perfect septa lying between and enclosing the lacunal cells, in such a manner as to produce a uniform pattern over the surface of the section (Plate VIII. fig. 20). On close inspection it will be seen that the intercellular tissue is granular, and that in each enclosure it encircles one or two lacunal cells, which in the latter case lie in contact, with the contiguous sides flattened, while the peripheral surface of the two form together a tolerably perfect circle in close contact with the intercellular tissue.
viewed by a side light, give an appearance of fibres, is shown on an examination of
 
pus-globules under similar circumstances, when each globule will seem to have
 
a striated surface ; and that slightly rounded prominences will produce a like
 
effect is shown in the case of some species of Navicula. The surface of these latter
 
objects is marked by rows of slight prominences, which, when the light is oblique
 
and passes through the specimen from one point only, appear as lines or fibres, the  
 
direction of which will change with alteration in the direction of the light ; that is  
 
to say, shadows will extend from one eminence to another in the opposite direction
 
to that from which the light enters. If we examine the projecting spiculae of bone
 
forming in temporary cartilage under corresponding conditions as regards light, a
 
similar fibrous appearance will be developed.  
 
  
Under these circumstances the authors are forced to the conclusion that bone
 
substance, instead of being made up of minute reticulate fibres, is composed of
 
granules or granular cells, imbedded in a more or less clear homogeneous or subgra-
 
nular matrix. This subject will receive further elucidation under the head of deve-
 
lopment. These views are supported by the appearances presented not only in deve-
 
loping bone of young subjects, but also in the bone of adults.
 
  
Thus as regards the basement homogeneous tissue, it will be found that where
+
The lacunal cells are beautifully shown in the kind of section under consideration. Their circumference is becoming granular, and frequently may be seen as a perfect ring of granules in close contact with the intercellular tissue, while in the centre we see the granular cell with a well-defined nucleus, and with numerous rudimentary canaliculi, extending from the circumference of the inner cell towards the surface of the outer cell-wall. Where two cells lie in contact, the rudimentary canaliculi may sometimes be found running across from the one cell to the other. If after exami- ning such sections as may be made with a knife, we take one through the bone imme- diately below the partially ossified cartilage, rendered thin by grinding, and mount it in Canada balsam, the various points described as existing in ossifying cartilage will be seen in that which has been converted into bone. Thus we shall see the in- tercellular tissue preserving its original form, and highly granular, and that while the outer walls of the lacunal cells have become calcified, the granular cells will have assumed the form of perfect lacunae and canaliculi, the latter freely intercommu- nicating where the surface of the lacunal cells is in contact, but seldom extending into the ossified intercellular tissue. These conditions are shown in Plate VII. fig. 25.
lamination is highly developed, the laminae have a transparent and structureless, and
 
  
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.  
+
The ossified lacunal cells, and the intercellular tissue which have existed in the temporary cartilage, and have there served their part in forming the skeleton of the foetus, are destined to have but a short existence, for we find that no sooner is the bone formed than large spaces are produced by absorption. Whole lines of ossified lacunal cells with the enclosing intercellular tissue disappear, to be replaced by more or less perfectly developed Haversian systems, which also last but for a time, when they by a similar process are removed to give place to others, or to contribute to the formation of permanent cavities. It has been well stated by Dr. Sharpey, that the long bones of the foetus are not equal in size to the medullary cavities of the correspond- ing bones of the adult. Hence as growth takes place, gradually comes the necessity for the removal of parts to make way for the development of others upon an enlarged scale.
  
  
123
+
It has been shown that primary bone, if we except two or three of the cranial bones, is merely calcified cartilage which has previously assumed the structural arrangement of bone. It is proposed to restrict the term primary bone to tissue so formed, as it will be subsequently shown that the development of Haversian systems in the spaces formed in primary bone, is effected by processes similar to those which are concerned in the growth of bone generally, and in the extension of the flat cranial bones. Age and situation no doubt modify the conditions of growth, or development of secondary bone, as it may be called, but the processes in either case are alike.
  
  
a more opake and granular part, to which the former appears to be the matrix. The
+
Hence, in describing the manner in which a long bone increases in diameter, we shall in fact be describing the process by which a flat cranial bone is extended. Before however going to this point the authors will state the results of their observa- tions on the subject of the absorption of bone, on that interesting and important pro- cess by which the Haversian spaces are formed out of the solid tissue of bone.
peripheral lamina of the Haversian systems is generally clear and free from granularity,
 
and the internal lamina sometimes presents a similar structureless appearance. The
 
matter which fills up the Haversian systems in the full-grown antlers of the Cervidse,
 
affords another and a very striking example of transparent structureless osseous tissue,
 
which in this instance is the more distinct from the absence of canaliculi in its sub-
 
stance. Then, again, we have another instance in the clear tissue which is some-
 
times found between the superficial Haversian systems of ordinary bone. It has
 
already been described as a non-laminated element found on the surface of certain
 
bones. In the instances already cited, and no doubt in many others which may be
 
found in the skeletons of the lower vertebrata, we have bone tissue without obvious
 
granularity and without obvious structure, and although it forms but a small part of
 
the general mass, yet from its constant presence at all ages and in all subjects, it
 
must be regarded as an integral and normal part of mammalian bone. The granular
 
condition of bone tissue is tolerably obvious in all preparations, though it is much
 
more strongly marked in some specimens than in others. The amount of the com-  
 
ponent granules varies in different parts of the same specimen, and in specimens taken
 
from different parts of the skeleton. Thus in one situation we may see laminae with a
 
highly granular part gradually merging into a transparent tissue, while in another the
 
laminae may be granular throughout. Again in young bone developed in cartilage,
 
the part between the cells becomes, highly granular ; fragments of which may be
 
found in certain adult bones, as in the petrous portion of the temporal bone (Plate VII.
 
fig. 16 b). Bone near the articular surface frequently presents a well-marked gra-
 
nularity. Whether the granular and the transparent parts of bone contain different
 
relative amounts of phosphate of lime is a question yet to be decided.  
 
  
Development of Bone . — Temporary cartilage, when it first appears in the embryo,
 
consists of an aggregation of closely packed nucleated cells, which in the process
 
of growth become separated by the development of a tissue external to them,
 
usually designated the hyaline tissue of cartilage. At this stage of growth we
 
have a granular cell occupying a cavity in the hyaline tissue ; at a previous period
 
the granular cell was inclosed by an outer cell-wall, to which it formed the nucleus,
 
but now the cell-wall has merged into the hyaline tissue, from which it can no
 
longer be distinguished, while the granular cell contains itself one or more nuclei.
 
In making sections of cartilage many of these granular cells escape from their
 
cavities in the hyaline tissue, and may be seen detached and floating about in the
 
field of the microscope. Some little confusion of terms has arisen in connexion
 
with this part of the subject. The granular cells are not unfrequently described
 
under the name of cartilage-nuclei containing nucleoli, while in fact they are cells
 
capable of separation from the matrix, and are at one period the only recognisable
 
cartilage cells. They occur singly or in groups, more frequently however two or
 
three are extended in a line. It is proposed in the present communication to call
 
  
 +
During the present winter it became necessary to remove a portion of the femur which protruded from a stump six weeks after the removal of the limb. From the medullary cavity a granulating mass projected and covered the surface of the bone left by the saw, and as the bone was rapidly wasting from the inner or medullary surface, we had in this specimen a favourable opportunity of examining the tissue which lay in immediate contact with the surface of the wasting bone. On cutting through this piece of femur in its length with a very fine jeweller's saw, it was found that a dense pale pink tissue lay in contact with the inner surface of the bone, which was hollowed with numerous minute cavities, into which the soft tissue accurately fitted, but from which it could be detached without tearing. The outer surface of the bone had been deprived of membrane many days before its removal from the limb.
  
124
 
  
 +
The examination of the tissue thus closely applied to the fast wasting bone, offered as favourable an opportunity for learning something of the means by which absorp- tion is effected as we could reasonably expect to obtain, the more so since the outer surface having been for some time exposed and covered only by dried peri- osteum, the actions had been confined to the inner surface of the bone. A careful examination showed that the surface of this tissue was composed of minutely granular nucleated cells, which lay in close and immediate contact with the bone, and increased in an exact ratio with its diminution. What the bone lost in bulk the cells gained, the cellular mass presenting a perfect cast of the surface of the bone, suggesting to the mind that the soft was growing at the cost of the hard tissue, or at all events that the former was instrumental in the removal of the latter. The cellular mass was tolerably vascular, but the vessels did not reach the surface in contact with the bone ; hence they could not be regarded as having any immediate action in the process of absorption. Section of the bone showed that the medullary cavity had been greatly enlarged by absorption, and no doubt had sufficient time been allowed the femur at that part would have been reduced to a thin scale. A transverse section showed that in many, though not in all instances, the Haversian canals had been enlarged and rendered irregular in shape, but it was evident that the process of removal had been less active in this situation than on the medullary surface of the bone.
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
 
  
 +
If we examine the fangs of temporary teeth when they are undergoing removal, similar states to those described as existing in the portion of femur will be found to obtain. A similar cellular mass will be seen to be closely applied to that surface of the tooth which is in process of removal, and the surface itself will present the characteristic emargination observed in the bone. When we connect these conditions with the fact that the nucleated cells which form the embryo have the power of appropriating the material which lies about them to the purpose of their own growth and their conversion into the various animal tissues, it is difficult to resist the belief that the cells which lie in contact with wasting bone and dentine, take up those tissues and use all or part of their element for the purposes of their own increase or multiplication, or else form a medium through which they are passed into the cir- culation. But as the process of absorption with concurrent development of cells is most active in primary bone where but few vessels exist, the former hypothesis seems the more probable. An objection may be raised to the supposition, that the bone is absorbed by the cells, on the ground of the density of the former; but it must be borne in mind, that as the density is gradually imparted to the bone through the agency of the adjoining soft parts, there seems no good reason for disbelieving that they may also be instrumental in its removal.
  
these bodies granular cartilage cells , as distinguished from a form which the cells
+
==Growth of Bone==
assume previous to ossification. Cartilage previous to its conversion into bone under-
+
Under this head will be described the extension of flat bones, the increase in the diameter of cylindrical bones, and the development of Haversian systems.
goes a rapid growth, which takes place principally in the direction of the long axis
 
of the future bone. Each granular cell becomes divided into two by segmentation
 
transverse to the line of ossific advance. These are again divided, and the process
 
repeated from time to time, till in the place of a single granular cell we have a long
 
line of cells extending from the unchanged cartilage to the point where ossification has
 
taken place. Contemporaneously with this development of lines of cells, other changes
 
are going on in the individual cells composing them. If we examine those situated
 
near the advancing bone, it will be observed that the granular cells have enlarged, have
 
become separated from each other by wide intervals, and that each has become in-
 
vested with a thick pellucid cell-wall (Plate VIII. figs. 19 and 20). The increase in
 
the size of the cells has occurred at the expense of the hyaline tissue, which, at those
 
points where the rounded cells approach each other, is reduced to a thin film, although
 
in the intervals left by the packing of the uncompressed cells it exists to a consider-
 
able amount. Here then we have a matrix containing cartilage cells composed of an
 
outer pellucid coat, within which is a granular cell containing central nuclei, a cell
 
consisting of three distinct parts. The nucleus existed previous to the segmentation
 
of the granular cell, but the outer wall is the product of a subsequent development.
 
It will be observed that growth is effected by two modes ; first, by the increase of
 
the number of the cells ; and, secondly, by the increase of their size individually.  
 
  
While these changes are going on for lengthening the shaft of a long bone, cells
 
are being added by a somewhat similar process of division to the surface, so as to
 
increase the diameter of the cartilage. For the development of the epiphysis the cells
 
become multiplied on a similar principle, but instead of occurring in lines they are
 
accumulated in oval or rounded groups*.
 
  
From this general view of the subject we will now proceed to consider in detail
+
If the advancing edge of a parietal bone be taken either from a human foetus or a foetal lamb, and the pericranium and dura mater be carefully removed from their respective surfaces, we shall find the growing bone still invested with soft tissue both on the outer and inner surface, which is prolonged from the free edge. When exa- mined under a favourable light this tissue will show differences of character in dif- ferent parts, varying with the distance from the bone at which the observations are made. Thus, if attention be directed to the part furthest removed from the bone, it will be seen that the membrane-like mass is composed of oval cells with slight prolongations from the extremities, which are frequently arranged in the form of bands of fibrous tissue (Plate VIII. fig. 26). Dr.SHARPEY has observed that the membrane into which the bone extends is like fibrous tissue in an early stage of development*, and this observation is strictly true when confined to the part indicated, but the analogy ceases as we extend our examination towards the bone. Here in the place of cells witheiongated processes, or cells arranged in fibre-like lines, we find cells aggregated into a mass, and so closely packed as to leave little room for intermediate tissue. The cells appear to have increased in size at the cost of the processes which existed at an earlier stage of development, and formed a bond of union between them. Everywhere about growing bone a careful examination will reveal cells attached to its surface, while the surface of the bone itself will present a series of similar bodies ossified (Plate IX. figs. 27, 28 and 29). To these we propose to give the name of osteal cells, as distinguished from lacunal and other cells.
those conditions of cartilage which precede and prepare for its conversion into bone.
 
These phenomena may be conveniently examined in the cartilage which connects the  
 
diaphysis and epiphysis of long bones, and we may take those of a lamb or calf, as  
 
they present the same conditions as are found in the human subject, and have the  
 
advantage over those of other domestic animals of being readily obtainable at all
 
times without the necessity of destroying the animal for the sole purpose of physiolo-
 
gical investigation.  
 
  
At that point in the cartilage where the linear arrangement of cells commences,
 
several of these bodies lie side by side in the same column, but by following the line
 
downwards towards the advancing bone, it will be seen that the column usually
 
divides, forming two or three distinct lines, in each of which the cells are arranged
 
  
* Previous to the ossification of the epiphysis the cartilage at the heads of the bone is increased in its bulk
+
* Mr. Quain and Dr. Sharpey, oper. cit. cxlix. and page clix. Dr. Sharpby says, “ When further examined
from additions to the surface, by a process somewhat similar to that through which the growth of bone is effected.  
+
with a higher magnifying power, the tissue or membrane in which ossification is proceeding, appears to be made up of fibres and granular corpuscles, with a soft amorphous or faintly granular uniting matter. The fibres have the character of the white fibres, or rather fasciculi of the cellular or fibrous tissue, and are similarly affected by acetic acid. The corpuscles are for the most part true cells with an envelope and granular contents ; some about the size of blood-particles, but many of them two or three times larger. In certain parts the fibres, but in most the corpuscles predominate, and on the whole the structure may be said to be not unlike that of fibrous tissue in an early stage of development.” Kolliker, oper. cit. p. 289, confirms Dr. Sharpey's statement, but denies that a fibrous arrangement can be traced in formed bone.
This process will be described when the latter subject is considered.  
 
  
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.
 
  
 +
In microscopic characters the osteal cells closely resemble the granular cells of temporary cartilage, so closely indeed, that the latter when detached from the car- tilage could not well be distinguished from them. They are for the most part sphe- rical or oval in form, and lie on the surface of the growing bone in a crowded mass, held together by an intervening and apparently structureless matrix (Plate IX. fig. 27 b). Here and there we find a cell which has accumulated about itself an outer investment of transparent tissue, and has in fact become developed into a lacunal cell destined to become a lacuna*. These points are illustrated in fig. 29 b.
  
125
 
  
 +
The process of growth may be thus described. In the meshes of the fibrous tissue on the surface of the bone osteal cells are developed and gradually take its place ; a few cells become developed into lacunal cells ; the earthy salts are added, and con- currently lacunae and canaliculi are formed ; we then have bone presenting the usual characters of that tissue*. In bone developed in the foregoing manner, we find the canaliculi not merely extending to the surface of the cell-wall, or anastomosing with the canaliculi of lacunal cells lying in contact with it, but extending freely in all direc- tions and passing through or amongst the ossified cells, and establishing rich plexuses of anastomosis. Indeed we see the boundary of the original lacunal cells only in those cases where the lacunae have but few, or are entirely devoid of canaliculi. It would appear to be a law, to which there are few if any exceptions, that when anastomosis is established between adjoining lacunae, the lacunal cells blend with the contiguous parts, and are no longer recognisable as distinct bodies. The process by which the cylindrical bones are increased in diameter is in all essential points similar to that described as pertaining to the growth of flat bones. Similar osteal and lacunal cells are present, but the relative amount of the matrix is greater ; moreover the osteal cells have a disposition to assume a linear arrangement corresponding to the direction of the laminse of the contiguous bone. In these lines the cells are placed so close to each other as to leave but little room for intervening tissue, but between the lines an appreciable amount may be recognized (Plate IX. fig. 31). This appearance however varies in different specimens. In one the cells predominate, in another the transparent tissue is the more abundant. Generally the younger the animal the greater will be the amount of the intervening transparent tissue, and the smaller the number of the osteal cells. But in all cases, whatever the age of the subject, or from whatever part of the skeleton the specimen be taken, the cells and the intermediate tissue become blended in the process of ossification, and the whole presents a uniform granular appearance, excepting in the instances in which lamination is strongly developed, or in those which have been noticed in the previous part of the paper. We frequently find portions of bone where the osteal cells, lacunal cells, and intermediate tissue are so perfectly fused together that neither can be recognized, but in their place we have a minutely granular mass, divisible only into lacunae and canaliculi and the tissue in which they lie imbedded. In Plate IX. fig. 32, taken from the tibia of a foetal lamb, the osteal and lacunal cells have become blended to a considerable extent, but without the occurrence of lamination. The lamina which is represented at the margin is com- posed of still uncalcified cells. It shows the mode in which the undulating laminae are formed. Fig. 33 also, taken from the fibula of a calf, shows ossified lacunal and osteal cells without any tendency to lamination.
  
in single file. It does not appear that the number of cells entering into the formation
 
of a series is at all limited ; hence the lines or columns vary in length. Neither
 
does it appear that the consecutive lines are placed, as a rule, end to end, so as to
 
form one long continuous straight line by the junction of several shorter ones. On
 
the contrary, each series is complete in itself, and is generally placed a little to the
 
one or other side of those above and below it. We have in fact interrupted lines of
 
cells, each line the offspring of a single cell, the outer walls of which have merged
 
into the intercellular or hyaline tissue.
 
  
When the destined number of cells forming a linear series has been developed,  
+
* The various views which have been entertained regarding the formation of the lacunae and canaliculi have
each cell becomes itself a centre of growth. The granular cell enlarges, together with
+
been concisely stated by Dr. Sharpey, oper. cit. p. 158. He observes, that “ they are generally supposed to be derived from the cells of the soft tissue involved in the ossification hy some sort of metamorphosis which has been variously conceived. Some suppose that the cells become the lacuna and send out branches (like the pigment cells) to form the canaliculi (Schwann 1 )- Others think that it is not the cell but its nucleus that undergoes this change, and that the substance of the nucleus is afterwards absorbed, leaving the lacuna (Todd and Bowman 2 ).” The nucleus described by Todd and Bowman is identical with that which in this communication is called the granular cell, and from which the authors have shown the lacuna is formed. “Henle 3 thinks that the lacuna is a cavity left in the centre of a cell which has been partially filled up by calcification, and that the canaliculi are branched passages, also left in consequence of the unequal deposition of the hard matter, as in the instance of the pore cells of plants.” “ It rather appears to me as if the lacunae and canali- culi were little varieties left in the tissue during the deposition of the reticular fibres, as open figures are left out in the weaving of some artificial fabrics (but not within a cell, as Henle imagined), and that thus the appo- sition of the minute apertures existing between the reticulations of the lamellae gives rise to the canaliculi.” “ At the same time it seems not unlikely that a cell or a cell-nucleus may originally lie in the lacuna or central cavity, and may perhaps determine the place of its formation.” Hassall 4 agrees with Schwann, while Gerber 5 and Bruns 5 appear to hold the views of Todd and Bowman. With the exception of Dr. Sharpey, the above- named authorities may perhaps differ more in the use of terms than in matter of fact. The appearances represented in figs. 14 and 27 would at first view seem to justify the opinion expressed by Dr. Sharpey, but a careful examination of the tissue during its development, the unquestionable fact that in the development from cartilage the granular cell becomes converted into a lacuna, together with the circumstance that lacunal cells are frequently found in the Haversian canals and cancellated structure, especially in the bones of old sub- jects, and at times imbedded in the structure of the bone, have left no room for doubt in the authors' minds that the lacunae are formed from' special nucleated cells, in the manner described in the text.
its nucleus, and becomes invested with a cell-wall. In examining a line of these
 
bodies extending from the forming bone of the diaphysis, we shall see them in various
 
degrees of forwardness. Thus, if attention be directed to the end of the line furthest
 
from the bone, the cells will be found small in size, granular, and with a perceptible
 
nucleus, but without an outer wall, distinguishable from the hyaline substance, which
 
is abundant between the contiguous lines, but small in quantity between the cells
 
composing the lines. But if the other end of the line be examined, very different
 
conditions will be observed. The granular cells will be seen to have become
 
rounded in form, to have increased to three times their original bulk, and to possess
 
well-marked circular nuclei ; in addition to which each granular cell will have  
 
acquired a thick pellucid outer wall, while the hyaline tissue between contiguous
 
lines of cells will have dwindled down to a thin film, excepting in those parts where
 
spaces are necessarily left in the approximation of spherical bodies (Plate VI. figs. 19,  
 
20). The abundance of the hyaline tissue in the earlier condition of cartilage, affords
 
space for the development of the cells in the breadth of the bone, but in the direction
 
of the length of the bone we find but little of that tissue, yet each component cell of
 
the almost innumerable lines of cells that exist, even in a bone of small size, is itself
 
a centre of growth. At the osseous end of a line, a single cell occupies more space
 
than four or five at the opposite extremity ; and as in each situation the cells are im-
 
bedded in hyaline tissue, it is evident that there is a concurrent growth of the latter
 
throughout each line of cells, and also of the cells and hyaline tissue in the breadth
 
of the cartilage. But for this provision of nature, cells would grow at the cost of  
 
those in their neighbourhood, a condition which obtains wherever space for a
 
secondary development of bone is required, a description of which will follow in
 
the subsequent pages of this paper. Then, again, had we concurrent growth in each
 
cell of a series without a similar growth in all the other series, throughout the breadth
 
of the bone, the growing series would encroach upon the cartilage in which the linear
 
arrangement had not commenced, and ultimately unite by osseous tissue the epiphysis
 
and diaphysis before the bone had acquired its normal length. And supposing
 
concurrent growth to take place over the one-half of the breadth of a bone and not
 
in the other, the bone would become curved and the limb distorted.  
 
  
s
+
1 Mikroscopische Untersuchungen. 2 Physiological Anatomy. 3 Anatomie Generate.
  
 +
4 Microscopic Anatomy of the Human Body, p. 310. 5 Allgemeine Anatomie.
  
MDCCCLIII.
 
  
  
126
+
When speaking of the growth of cartilage, it was stated that the bulk of that tissue at the epiphysis increased laterally by the division of the cells, but the fact that it also increased on the free surface of the greatly enlarged cartilaginous epiphysis of the fcetus by a process similar to that by which the diameter of bones is increased, was reserved to be described in connection with the latter subject. If a longitudinal section be taken from the epiphysis of a foetal long bone, including some portion of the perichondrium, it will be seen that the cartilage passes gradually into a more or less fibrous tissue, which forms the exterior of the part. Amongst the fibres will be found numerous elongated cells, which on tracing the specimen inwards will be seen to be similar to the cartilage cells at and near the surface of the tissue, while the fibres will be seen to give way to or become converted into hyaline tissue, as shown in Plate IX. fig. 30, in which the cartilage is indicated at a, and the cells included in the fibrous tissue at b.
  
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
 
  
 +
The manner in which the Haversian spaces become gradually occupied by Haver- sian systems is peculiarly interesting. To obtain a good view of the process, it is necessary to make a transverse section of the developing systems. It may then be seen that osteal cells arrange themselves in single file within the Haversian space with intermediate lines of transparent tissue, and here and there a lacunal cell ; the process commencing at the surface of the Haversian space, and extending gradually inwards till the system is completed. In fact the soft tissue takes the permanent form previous to the addition of the salts of bone, much in the same manner and to the same degree as occurs in temporary cartilage before the earthy ingredients are deposited. Lamination is nothing more than a definite linear arrangement of the osteal cells with their outlines permanently retained in the perfected bone ; a character much more strongly marked in the bones of adult than in those of young animals.
  
We have traced in temporary cartilage those changes which occur preparatory to
 
its conversion into bone : it now remains for the authors to describe the results of
 
their researches on the mode in which that conversion is effected, and concerning
 
which there hitherto has been a great diversity of opinion.
 
  
Preceding ossific deposit, the intercolumnar tissue, which may not only be seen
+
In pursuing their inquiries into the growth of bone, the authors found it necessary to take sections of perfectly fresh bone and to examine them in albuminous fluid; spirits of wine, whether diluted or not, obscures the normal appearances, and water is not more favourable as a medium.
between the columns of cells, but also passing more or less perfectly between the
 
individual cells, becomes in some cases slightly fibrous in appearance, and of a light
 
brown colour; this condition speedily gives way to a highly granular state; in fact it
 
has become bone, and encloses, in osseous cavities or crypts, the cartilage cells. For
 
reasons which will hereafter be sufficiently obvious, we shall in future call these
 
lacunal cells. If thin sections be made with a very sharp knife through ossifying
 
cartilage, and placed in water or albumen under the quarter or eighth object-glass,
 
we shall occasionally find lacunal cells which have escaped from their osseous crypts,
 
floating loose in the fluid, and offering a favourable opportunity for the examination
 
of their characters. It may then be seen that the thick pellucid outer investment
 
has become granular, and that the enclosed granular cell has lost its regular outline,
 
and become angular or ragged, while the nucleus has become obscured by the changes
 
in the more external parts of the cell, an early stage of which is seen in Plate VIII.
 
fig. 19 and 22 a. Such are the appearances presented in some of the detached
 
lacunal cells, but they may be seen in both earlier and later stages of development
 
than that described. Thus instances may be found where the outer coat has only a
 
few granules on the surface, in which case the granular cell may be seen more di-
 
stinctly, and minute elongated processes traced, extending from its surface (Plate
 
VIII. figs. 19 and 20). In a favourable section we sometimes find such a cell with
 
its outer coat torn, exposing to full view the granular cell, with numerous and well-
 
marked processes extending from it. Dr. Sharpey kindly placed at the disposal of
 
the authors the rickety bone of a child who died during the active condition of the
 
disease. In this specimen granular cells with radiating processes can with great
 
readiness be detached by tearing a thin section, for in this case cartilage assumed
 
the arrangement of bone without the impregnation of earthy ingredients (Plate VIII.
 
fig. 23)*.  
 
  
The third condition, in which we may find isolated lacunal cells detached from
 
the osseous crypts of the intercellular tissue, differs from those already described in
 
their greater solidity. The whole mass has become highly granular, and the granular
 
cell with its processes has united to the outer coat, so that the two can no longer be
 
  
 +
Sections permanently mounted in dilute spirit lose a good deal of their character; still the appearances are preserved with more or less of their original distinctness. Sections mounted in Canada balsam show some of the points remarkably well. For instance, the partially ossified osteal and lacunal cells are tolerably well preserved, but unfortunately those cells which have not received any of the indurating salts are repre- sented only by a transparent mass, in which but little structure can be recognized ; thus, the part b in fig. 32 would have appeared but as a transparent line had the specimen been mounted in Canada balsam. In addition to the necessity for care in the examination of osseous structures, under the most favourable circumstances, as regards the selection of specimens and the fluid used in their preparation, it is equally necessary to have the more recent appliances for the illumination of the objects.
  
* Kolliker, oper. cit. at p. 360, describes accurately the formation of lacunae from cartilage cells in a rickety
 
bone, and although he has not observed the changes with equal distinctness in normal bone, appears to have
 
satisfied himself that in the ossification of cartilage the cells of the latter become converted into lacunae.
 
M. Kolliker does not however seem to have recognized the relation of the lacunal cells as such to the inter-
 
cellular tissue, neither does he mention the fact that the granular cells with their long stellated processes can
 
be separated from the investing cell-wall in the manner described in the text.
 
  
 +
Mr. Gillett's achromatic condenser, with what is called the white cloud illuminator, renders it very easy to demonstrate points which with the ordinary miscroscopic apparatus are shown with difficulty. It need not however be urged, that it is desirable in pursuing structural anatomy to avail ourselves of the most perfect instru- ments that can be obtained. It is proper that the authors should, before leaving this part of the subject, draw some comparison between the development of bone in cartilage and in the softer tissues.
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.
 
  
 +
Temporary cartilage, previous to the development of bone, affords a mechanical support and protection to the surrounding or enclosed softer tissues. These offices could not be rendered by a mere aggregation of soft cells, but are efficiently per- formed by the dense intercellular substance, which forms so characteristic a feature of the cartilage. Hence in the mechanical function of cartilage the intercellular element of the tissue must be regarded as the most important.
  
127
 
  
 +
A second, and scarcely less important purpose effected by temporary cartilage, is that of affording a medium for which a more solid tissue may be substituted, without the mechanical support being withdrawn from the adjoining parts during the process of change. It affords also a means by which the long bones are gradu- ally increased in length, without any interference with the functions of the limb. These changes are brought about by the gradual increase in the number of the carti- lage cells, at those parts only where ossification is about to commence, and by the conversion of the cells into lacunal cells, at the cost of the intercellular tissue, which, whilst its bulk is diminishing, becomes impregnated with the earthy salts ; so that although the quantity is lessened, the strength of that which remains is increased. Now, in examining the process by which growing bones are enlarged, it must be borne in mind that the mechanical function of the cartilage is performed by the bone which has replaced it, and that no such office is required of the new tissue which is gradually adding to the bulk of the bone. The necessity for a dense inter- cellular tissue no longer exists. Hence we have an aggregation of osteal cells with so much only of intercellular tissue as will serve to connect them into a mass. A certain number of these cells, by additions to their exterior, become lacunal cells. We have then in the place of lacunal cells and dense intercolumnar tissue, lacunal and osteal cells united by a small and almost imperceptible amount of a semifluid intercellular medium ; the relative proportions of these several parts varying a little with differences of age. Thus in aged subjects aggregations of lacunal cells may here and there be found with but few osteal cells and but little intercellular tissue, while in a young subject osteal cells will preponderate.
  
separated the one from the other, and are no longer to be recognized as distinct
 
parts. If accidentally broken across, we see that they have a hollow centre, in fact,
 
a lacuna ; but when loose and entire, they appear as rounded dense masses, project-
 
ing from the surface of which we may not unfrequently detect a few short needle-
 
like processes. Lacunal cells of the latter kind are not, however, very easily de-
 
tached, for when they have advanced thus far in development, their union with ossified
 
intercolumnar tissue is too strong to admit of ready separation ; indeed, after this
 
period their separation is impossible. It has been stated that the granular cells of
 
cartilage previous to the formation of lacunal cells send out processes. There are,
 
however, a certain number of granular cells that do not appear to undergo this change,
 
but preserve their state of granulation and their external figure, and show the round
 
nucleus even after they are surrounded by and imbedded in ossified tissue. Indeed,
 
we may find perfectly ossified crypts of intercolumnar tissue at some little depth
 
within the forming bone, containing several of these granular cells in an unaltered
 
condition, and this without the cavities having been enlarged by absorption of their
 
walls (Plate VIII. fig. 19 d ). It is important to bear this point in mind, as it will sub-
 
sequently be shown that similar granular cells lie loose in the large cavities formed
 
by absorption, and that they are concerned in the formation of bone when that tissue
 
is not preceded by ordinary cartilage.
 
  
If a section of developing bone, including a little of the cartilage, be dried, and
+
In all cases a direction may be given to the cells of a growing part, by their being in relation with the insertion of a tendon.
mounted in Canada balsam, we shall be able to recognize, first the cartilage with the
 
cells greatly contracted, then the ossified intercolumnar tissue full of little crypts, from
 
which, in the process of drying, the lacunal cells have disappeared (Plate VIII. fig.24 a ) ;
 
and lastly, we shall see bone in which ossified lacunal cells run in lines correspond-
 
ing to the preceding lines of cartilage cells (fig. 24 b). The latter appearance is,
 
however, interrupted by the presence of numerous large spaces produced by the
 
absorption of both the intercolumnar tissue and the lacunal cells (fig. 24 c), the
 
process for the removal of which commences concurrently with the impregnation of  
 
the lacunal cells with the earthy salt.  
 
  
These conditions can be also very favourably observed in sections of the long
 
bones of a foetal lamb, taken previous to the commencement of ossification of the
 
epiphysis, and examined in the liquor amnii ; water will not answer as a substitute
 
for this fluid, as the cartilage cells are speedily altered in character by its presence.
 
And we may here observe that the examination of developing bone should be con-
 
ducted on perfectly fresh subjects, and that care should be taken to keep the knives,
 
glass, &c., which are used in preparing the sections, perfectly free from extraneous
 
matter; otherwise the results will be unsatisfactory. Thus a small quantity of spirits
 
of wine or of acid will produce changes of character in the specimen, and thereby
 
lead the observer into an erroneous conception of the normal characters of the tissue.
 
  
Hitherto the authors of this communication have spoken principally of those ap-
+
A consideration of the foregoing facts will, we think, lead to a conviction that the two different forms in which bone is developed, are designed to meet the require- ments of the animal at different periods of life, and that bone developed by means of osteal and lacunal cells is the higher form of the tissue. In early embryonic life a soft cartilaginous skeleton is laid down, which is hard as compared with the sur- rounding parts, and capable of affording them the required amount of mechanical support. As the various tissues advance in development the cartilage increases in density by the elaboration of its hyaline tissue, and after awhile those changes occur which precede its conversion into bone. But in the bone so formed, it has been shown that the canaliculi anastomose only at those points where the lacunal cells come into contact (Plate VIII. fig. 25). In bone formed from osteal and lacunal cells, the ana- stomosis of the canaliculi prevails throughout the tissue, while the outline of the formative cells is almost entirely lost in the general blending of the whole into a subgranular mass subject to lamination, in the manner already described.
pearances which are presented in sections made parallel with the advancing bone ;
 
  
s 2
 
  
 +
It will therefore be in accordance with the preceding views, to regard the inter- columnar tissue present in primary bone, rather as an accessory element calculated to give support during the ossification of the lacunal cells, than as an integral and necessary element of osseous tissue ; for it has been shown that it offers an obstruc- tion to the anastomosis of the canaliculi, and that the lacunal cells preserve their outline so long as they are enclosed within it, instead of becoming lost in the sur- rounding tissue, as occurs in secondary bone. It must not, however, be forgotten that small patches of ossified intercolumnar tissue may here and there be found between the Haversian systems, even in the bone of old subjects (Plate VII. fig. 16) ; so that its presence in a small amount, (as accidentally left when the Haversian spaces are forming), is not incompatible with the normal condition of perfect bone.
  
128
 
  
 +
It may also be stated in this place, that the undulating laminse formed on the sur- face of growing bone, although for the most part removed to make way for Haversian systems, are also found here and there in small patches in the bones of adults.
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
 
  
 +
The subject of absorption, as it relates to the removal of bone, has already been partly discussed, but something more remains to be said. Although the process of absorption has not, and probably cannot be seen in actual operation, yet a con- sideration of the relative position of the increasing and wasting parts, and of then- conditions, will, in the authors' opinion, justify the conclusion that the bone is re- moved through the agency of cells.
  
attention must now be directed to sections made across the bone, so as to cut trans-
 
versely the lines of cartilage cells.
 
  
If, then, we take a thin section through the cartilage where ossification of the inter-
+
In seeking to find the circumstances under which the absorption of bone takes place most rapidly, and to the greatest extent, the authors have been led to examine bones which had been placed in various conditions, both of health and disease. It has been already stated that bone developed in cartilage is speedily removed ; but it does not seem that bone formed by osteal and lacunal cells is absorbed with equal rapidity, although in the course of a short time it not less surely disappears. This difference in the rate of absorption is probably the result of the vascularity and higher state of development of the latter tissue. In bone developed in cartilage Haversian spaces have to be formed before it can be permeated by vessels; hence in this tissue absorption proceeds rapidly, the process being established as soon as the bone is formed. In adult bone, when in a normal condition, we find here and there an Haversian space ; but if a bone around which the soft parts are in a state of inflam- mation be examined, numerous Haversian spaces will be seen. If we examine the same bone in the neighbourhood of that part where the inflamed is merging into the healthy investing texture, we shall find new osseous matter in the process of depo- sition on the surface of the pre-existing bone. Examples of this may frequently be found in the vicinity of diseased joints.
cellular tissue is advancing, the following appearances will be seen. The intercellular
 
tissue will present itself in the form of more or less perfect septa lying between and  
 
enclosing the lacunal cells, in such a manner as to produce a uniform pattern over
 
the surface of the section (Plate VIII. fig. 20). On close inspection it will be seen that
 
the intercellular tissue is granular, and that in each enclosure it encircles one or two
 
lacunal cells, which in the latter case lie in contact, with the contiguous sides
 
flattened, while the peripheral surface of the two form together a tolerably perfect
 
circle in close contact with the intercellular tissue.  
 
  
The lacunal cells are beautifully shown in the kind of section under consideration.
 
Their circumference is becoming granular, and frequently may be seen as a perfect
 
ring of granules in close contact with the intercellular tissue, while in the centre we
 
see the granular cell with a well-defined nucleus, and with numerous rudimentary
 
canaliculi, extending from the circumference of the inner cell towards the surface of
 
the outer cell-wall. Where two cells lie in contact, the rudimentary canaliculi may
 
sometimes be found running across from the one cell to the other. If after exami-
 
ning such sections as may be made with a knife, we take one through the bone imme-
 
diately below the partially ossified cartilage, rendered thin by grinding, and mount
 
it in Canada balsam, the various points described as existing in ossifying cartilage
 
will be seen in that which has been converted into bone. Thus we shall see the in-
 
tercellular tissue preserving its original form, and highly granular, and that while the
 
outer walls of the lacunal cells have become calcified, the granular cells will have
 
assumed the form of perfect lacunae and canaliculi, the latter freely intercommu-
 
nicating where the surface of the lacunal cells is in contact, but seldom extending
 
into the ossified intercellular tissue. These conditions are shown in Plate VII. fig. 25.
 
  
The ossified lacunal cells, and the intercellular tissue which have existed in the
+
We have here an instance of the development of new tissue, and the removal of a pre-existing one being set in operation, by what would appear to be a different degree only of the same action. Hence a more particular examination of the cellular mass, by which bone appears to be absorbed in the one case and deposited in the other, naturally suggests itself, and attention has been directed to this point as frequently as favourable opportunities for observation have presented themselves. The differ- ences, however, in microscopic characters between the two tissues, have not been so strongly marked, as to admit of any definite description being given, by which the one may, in all instances, be distinguished from the other, when removed from their natural positions, as is almost necessarily the case with regard to the absorbent cells, from the readiness with which they separate from the wasting bone (Plate IX. figs. 27 and 34).
temporary cartilage, and have there served their part in forming the skeleton of the
 
foetus, are destined to have but a short existence, for we find that no sooner is the  
 
bone formed than large spaces are produced by absorption. Whole lines of ossified
 
lacunal cells with the enclosing intercellular tissue disappear, to be replaced by more
 
or less perfectly developed Haversian systems, which also last but for a time, when
 
they by a similar process are removed to give place to others, or to contribute to the  
 
formation of permanent cavities. It has been well stated by Dr. Sharpey, that the long
 
bones of the foetus are not equal in size to the medullary cavities of the correspond-
 
ing bones of the adult. Hence as growth takes place, gradually comes the necessity
 
for the removal of parts to make way for the development of others upon an enlarged
 
scale.  
 
  
It has been shown that primary bone, if we except two or three of the cranial
 
bones, is merely calcified cartilage which has previously assumed the structural
 
  
 +
Lacunal cells moreover will not be found in the absorbing tissue ; but it is not easy to recognize them, even in the tissue from which bone is developing, as they are frequently obscured by the osteal cells ; so that their presence, although a good ground of distinction, cannot in all instances be demonstrated. When, however, developmental cells are seen in situ, their character is readily distinguished. They are closely applied to the surface of the increasing bone, which loses the festooned and assumes an even outline, to which the osteal cells adhere.
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.
 
  
 +
The source from which the cells destined for effecting absorption arise is at present unknown to the authors, any further than that they arise in connection with soft tissues, the three situations in which they occur being beneath the periosteum or medullary membrane, or within an Haversian canal. These are no doubt the points from which the development of the cells starts, but the law which regulates their occurrence at one part rather than another, and gives to them their peculiar function, is at present unexplained. Neither is it more easy to understand why, at a parti- cular period, the process of absorption is arrested and development of new tissue com- mences ; the new bone may, for anything we have seen to the contrary, be formed from the same cells that have been concerned in the removal of the old. The organ by which the fangs of teeth are absorbed offers a very favourable object for examination.
  
129
 
  
 +
This we find to commence within or beneath the periosteum which covers the fang of the tooth, and increases with the wasting of the tooth, until it comes in contact with the pulp, which then assumes a similar function and becomes an absorbing organ, increasing gradually in size, till, if the tooth be left undisturbed, but little of the crown remains excepting the enamel. If, when in this condition, the crown of the tooth be carefully removed, we shall see the absorbent papillae projecting a little above the gum, firm in substance, and not disposed to bleed unless rudely handled. Within two or three days it becomes covered with epithelium, either by the exten- sion of the epithelial membrane from the surrounding parts, or from a change in character in the superficial cells of the part itself*. Gradually the papilla loses its distinctness of outline and merges into the surrounding gum, from which it can no longer be distinguished. Here then we have a second instance in which an ab- sorbent tissue has its function finally suspended, and a new one substituted. In the place of increasing at the cost of pre-existing tissue, growth is suspended, and it unites with and assumes a similar office to that of the surrounding gum.
  
arrangement of bone. It is proposed to restrict the term primary bone to tissue so
 
formed, as it will be subsequently shown that the development of Haversian systems
 
in the spaces formed in primary bone, is effected by processes similar to those which
 
are concerned in the growth of bone generally, and in the extension of the flat cranial
 
bones. Age and situation no doubt modify the conditions of growth, or development
 
of secondary bone, as it may be called, but the processes in either case are alike.
 
  
Hence, in describing the manner in which a long bone increases in diameter, we
 
shall in fact be describing the process by which a flat cranial bone is extended.
 
Before however going to this point the authors will state the results of their observa-
 
tions on the subject of the absorption of bone, on that interesting and important pro-
 
cess by which the Haversian spaces are formed out of the solid tissue of bone.
 
  
During the present winter it became necessary to remove a portion of the femur
+
* In the 26th volume of the Medico-Chirurgical Transactions, there is a short paper by Mr. Dalrymple, in which he describes a small tumour from the eyelid, consisting essentially of epithelial cells, in which the ordinary contents had been replaced by ossific matter.
which protruded from a stump six weeks after the removal of the limb. From the
 
medullary cavity a granulating mass projected and covered the surface of the bone left
 
by the saw, and as the bone was rapidly wasting from the inner or medullary surface,  
 
we had in this specimen a favourable opportunity of examining the tissue which lay
 
in immediate contact with the surface of the wasting bone. On cutting through this
 
piece of femur in its length with a very fine jeweller's saw, it was found that a dense
 
pale pink tissue lay in contact with the inner surface of the bone, which was hollowed
 
with numerous minute cavities, into which the soft tissue accurately fitted, but from
 
which it could be detached without tearing. The outer surface of the bone had been  
 
deprived of membrane many days before its removal from the limb.  
 
  
The examination of the tissue thus closely applied to the fast wasting bone, offered
 
as favourable an opportunity for learning something of the means by which absorp-
 
tion is effected as we could reasonably expect to obtain, the more so since the
 
outer surface having been for some time exposed and covered only by dried peri-
 
osteum, the actions had been confined to the inner surface of the bone. A careful
 
examination showed that the surface of this tissue was composed of minutely granular
 
nucleated cells, which lay in close and immediate contact with the bone, and increased
 
in an exact ratio with its diminution. What the bone lost in bulk the cells gained,
 
the cellular mass presenting a perfect cast of the surface of the bone, suggesting to
 
the mind that the soft was growing at the cost of the hard tissue, or at all events that
 
the former was instrumental in the removal of the latter. The cellular mass was
 
tolerably vascular, but the vessels did not reach the surface in contact with the bone ;
 
hence they could not be regarded as having any immediate action in the process of
 
absorption. Section of the bone showed that the medullary cavity had been greatly
 
enlarged by absorption, and no doubt had sufficient time been allowed the femur at
 
that part would have been reduced to a thin scale. A transverse section showed that
 
in many, though not in all instances, the Haversian canals had been enlarged and
 
rendered irregular in shape, but it was evident that the process of removal had been
 
less active in this situation than on the medullary surface of the bone.
 
  
  
130
+
In conclusion, the authors may allude to an interesting fact, with reference to the subject of absorption, which has been recently observed by Mr. Stanley and subse- quently by Mr. Bowman. In the treatment of ununited fracture, the practice has of late been successfully adopted of drilling cylindrical holes into the bone in the neigh- bourhood of the injury, and of driving in pegs of ivory, accurately fitted to the per- forations, for the purpose of setting up action in their vicinity. These pegs, after remaining in the bone several weeks, have been removed, and have been found on inspection to present erosions similar to those which are seen on absorbing bone or tooth. In fact, they closely resemble the fangs of temporary teeth recently attacked by absorption. Mr. Bowman kindly placed at the disposal of the authors one of the pegs which had been used for this purpose, a section of which presents, at the parts eroded, in its microscopic characters, the usual emarginated outline so frequently alluded to in the foregoing pages. They have not however had the opportunity of investigating the condition of the tissues around the pegs; but it is exceedingly probable that absorption has in these cases been effected by processes similar to those which occur in the formation of Haversian spaces.
  
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
+
==Explanation of the Plates==
  
 +
===Plate VI===
  
If we examine the fangs of temporary teeth when they are undergoing removal,
+
Fig. 1. Transverse section of compact bone, showing the ordinary appearances.
similar states to those described as existing in the portion of femur will be found
 
to obtain. A similar cellular mass will be seen to be closely applied to that surface
 
of the tooth which is in process of removal, and the surface itself will present the
 
characteristic emargination observed in the bone. When we connect these conditions
 
with the fact that the nucleated cells which form the embryo have the power of
 
appropriating the material which lies about them to the purpose of their own growth
 
and their conversion into the various animal tissues, it is difficult to resist the belief
 
that the cells which lie in contact with wasting bone and dentine, take up those
 
tissues and use all or part of their element for the purposes of their own increase or
 
multiplication, or else form a medium through which they are passed into the cir-
 
culation. But as the process of absorption with concurrent development of cells is
 
most active in primary bone where but few vessels exist, the former hypothesis seems
 
the more probable. An objection may be raised to the supposition, that the bone is
 
absorbed by the cells, on the ground of the density of the former; but it must be
 
borne in mind, that as the density is gradually imparted to the bone through the  
 
agency of the adjoining soft parts, there seems no good reason for disbelieving that
 
they may also be instrumental in its removal.  
 
  
Growth of Bone . — Under this head will be described the extension of flat bones,  
+
a. Haversian system, b. Interstitial laminae, c. A new Haversian system within an older one, the Haversian canal obliterated by the development of a lacunal cell.
the increase in the diameter of cylindrical bones, and the development of Haversian
 
systems.  
 
  
If the advancing edge of a parietal bone be taken either from a human foetus or a
+
Fig. 2. Transverse section of compact bone, showing an Haversian space, with its characteristic emarginated outline.
foetal lamb, and the pericranium and dura mater be carefully removed from their
 
respective surfaces, we shall find the growing bone still invested with soft tissue both
 
on the outer and inner surface, which is prolonged from the free edge. When exa-
 
mined under a favourable light this tissue will show differences of character in dif-
 
ferent parts, varying with the distance from the bone at which the observations are
 
made. Thus, if attention be directed to the part furthest removed from the bone,  
 
it will be seen that the membrane-like mass is composed of oval cells with slight
 
prolongations from the extremities, which are frequently arranged in the form of bands
 
of fibrous tissue (Plate VIII. fig. 26). Dr.SHARPEY has observed that the membrane into
 
which the bone extends is like fibrous tissue in an early stage of development*, and
 
this observation is strictly true when confined to the part indicated, but the analogy
 
  
* Mr. Quain and Dr. Sharpey, oper. cit. cxlix. and page clix. Dr. Sharpby says, “ When further examined
+
Fig. 3. The same, from a less compact part of the bone, from a man aged fifty-six.
with a higher magnifying power, the tissue or membrane in which ossification is proceeding, appears to be made
 
up of fibres and granular corpuscles, with a soft amorphous or faintly granular uniting matter. The fibres have
 
the character of the white fibres, or rather fasciculi of the cellular or fibrous tissue, and are similarly affected by
 
acetic acid. The corpuscles are for the most part true cells with an envelope and granular contents ; some
 
about the size of blood-particles, but many of them two or three times larger. In certain parts the fibres, but
 
in most the corpuscles predominate, and on the whole the structure may be said to be not unlike that of fibrous
 
tissue in an early stage of development.” Kolliker, oper. cit. p. 289, confirms Dr. Sharpey's statement, but
 
denies that a fibrous arrangement can be traced in formed bone.  
 
  
 +
Fig. 4. Transverse section from the fibula of a child two years old, showing the general characters of bone in young subjects, a. Haversian space.
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.  
+
Fig. 5. Section of compact bone, showing several Haversian systems enclosed within a single series of laminee. a. A lacunal cell attached to the surface of an Haversian canal.
  
 +
Fig. 6. Section showing the characters of a new Haversian system, developed within an older one.
  
131
 
  
 +
Fig. 7- An excentric Haversian system, illustrating the arrangement of the laminae. Fig. 8. a. Lamination of bone, as it appears under a low power, b. The same highly magnified, showing the lines of osteal cells and the intermediate transpa- rent tissue.
  
ceases as we extend our examination towards the bone. Here in the place of cells
 
witheiongated processes, or cells arranged in fibre-like lines, we find cells aggregated
 
into a mass, and so closely packed as to leave little room for intermediate tissue.
 
The cells appear to have increased in size at the cost of the processes which existed
 
at an earlier stage of development, and formed a bond of union between them.
 
Everywhere about growing bone a careful examination will reveal cells attached to
 
its surface, while the surface of the bone itself will present a series of similar bodies
 
ossified (Plate IX. figs. 27, 28 and 29). To these we propose to give the name of
 
osteal cells, as distinguished from lacunal and other cells.
 
  
In microscopic characters the osteal cells closely resemble the granular cells of
+
===Plate VII===
temporary cartilage, so closely indeed, that the latter when detached from the car-
 
tilage could not well be distinguished from them. They are for the most part sphe-
 
rical or oval in form, and lie on the surface of the growing bone in a crowded mass,
 
held together by an intervening and apparently structureless matrix (Plate IX. fig.
 
27 b). Here and there we find a cell which has accumulated about itself an outer
 
investment of transparent tissue, and has in fact become developed into a lacunal
 
cell destined to become a lacuna*. These points are illustrated in fig. 29 b.
 
  
The process of growth may be thus described. In the meshes of the fibrous tissue  
+
Fig. 9. Transverse section of a stag's antler, after shedding, showing the transparent tissue which lines the Haversian canals.
  
* The various views which have been entertained regarding the formation of the lacunae and canaliculi have
+
Fig. 10. Section showing the circumferential laminae, perforated by an Haversian system.
been concisely stated by Dr. Sharpey, oper. cit. p. 158. He observes, that “ they are generally supposed to be
 
derived from the cells of the soft tissue involved in the ossification hy some sort of metamorphosis which has
 
been variously conceived. Some suppose that the cells become the lacuna and send out branches (like the
 
pigment cells) to form the canaliculi (Schwann 1 )- Others think that it is not the cell but its nucleus that
 
undergoes this change, and that the substance of the nucleus is afterwards absorbed, leaving the lacuna (Todd
 
and Bowman 2 ).” The nucleus described by Todd and Bowman is identical with that which in this communi-
 
cation is called the granular cell, and from which the authors have shown the lacuna is formed. “Henle 3
 
thinks that the lacuna is a cavity left in the centre of a cell which has been partially filled up by calcification,
 
and that the canaliculi are branched passages, also left in consequence of the unequal deposition of the hard
 
matter, as in the instance of the pore cells of plants.” “ It rather appears to me as if the lacunae and canali-
 
culi were little varieties left in the tissue during the deposition of the reticular fibres, as open figures are left
 
out in the weaving of some artificial fabrics (but not within a cell, as Henle imagined), and that thus the appo-
 
sition of the minute apertures existing between the reticulations of the lamellae gives rise to the canaliculi.” “ At
 
the same time it seems not unlikely that a cell or a cell-nucleus may originally lie in the lacuna or central cavity,
 
and may perhaps determine the place of its formation.” Hassall 4 agrees with Schwann, while Gerber 5 and
 
Bruns 5 appear to hold the views of Todd and Bowman. With the exception of Dr. Sharpey, the above-
 
named authorities may perhaps differ more in the use of terms than in matter of fact. The appearances
 
represented in figs. 14 and 27 would at first view seem to justify the opinion expressed by Dr. Sharpey,
 
but a careful examination of the tissue during its development, the unquestionable fact that in the development
 
from cartilage the granular cell becomes converted into a lacuna, together with the circumstance that lacunal
 
cells are frequently found in the Haversian canals and cancellated structure, especially in the bones of old sub-
 
jects, and at times imbedded in the structure of the bone, have left no room for doubt in the authors' minds that
 
the lacunae are formed from' special nucleated cells, in the manner described in the text.  
 
  
1 Mikroscopische Untersuchungen. 2 Physiological Anatomy. 3 Anatomie Generate.  
+
Fig. 11. Section showing the orifices of the canaliouli, with their parietes.
  
4 Microscopic Anatomy of the Human Body, p. 310. 5 Allgemeine Anatomie.  
+
Fig. 12. Sections from rickety bone. a. Consolidated lacunae, b. Laeunal cells, from which no canaliculi have proceeded.
  
 +
Fig. 13. Section showing circumferential laminae, with elongated canals passing amongst the lacunae and canaliculi.
  
132
+
Fig. 14. Section of fossil bone, from the Wealden, supposed to be Pterodactyle, in which the nuclei have been preserved by fossilization.
  
 +
Fig. 15. Ossified laeunal cells, from the spongy portion of a bone of an old subject.
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
+
Fig. 16. Section from the petrous portion of a temporal bone of an adult, a. Laeunal cells, containing lacunae and canaliculi. b. Intercellular granular tissue, similar to that found in bone developed in cartilage.
  
 +
Fig. 17. Section showing ossified articular cartilage, a. Lacuna developed from a cartilage cell. b. Lines of granules.
  
on the surface of the bone osteal cells are developed and gradually take its place ; a
+
Fig. 18. Section from an incus in a subject aged seventy-five, showing osteal and laeunal cells on the surface.
few cells become developed into lacunal cells ; the earthy salts are added, and con-
 
currently lacunae and canaliculi are formed ; we then have bone presenting the usual
 
characters of that tissue*. In bone developed in the foregoing manner, we find the
 
canaliculi not merely extending to the surface of the cell-wall, or anastomosing with
 
the canaliculi of lacunal cells lying in contact with it, but extending freely in all direc-
 
tions and passing through or amongst the ossified cells, and establishing rich plexuses
 
of anastomosis. Indeed we see the boundary of the original lacunal cells only in those
 
cases where the lacunae have but few, or are entirely devoid of canaliculi. It would
 
appear to be a law, to which there are few if any exceptions, that when anastomosis
 
is established between adjoining lacunae, the lacunal cells blend with the contiguous
 
parts, and are no longer recognisable as distinct bodies. The process by which the
 
cylindrical bones are increased in diameter is in all essential points similar to that
 
described as pertaining to the growth of flat bones. Similar osteal and lacunal cells  
 
are present, but the relative amount of the matrix is greater ; moreover the osteal
 
cells have a disposition to assume a linear arrangement corresponding to the direction
 
of the laminse of the contiguous bone. In these lines the cells are placed so close to
 
each other as to leave but little room for intervening tissue, but between the lines an
 
appreciable amount may be recognized (Plate IX. fig. 31). This appearance however
 
varies in different specimens. In one the cells predominate, in another the transparent
 
tissue is the more abundant. Generally the younger the animal the greater will be the
 
amount of the intervening transparent tissue, and the smaller the number of the osteal
 
cells. But in all cases, whatever the age of the subject, or from whatever part of the
 
skeleton the specimen be taken, the cells and the intermediate tissue become blended
 
in the process of ossification, and the whole presents a uniform granular appearance,
 
excepting in the instances in which lamination is strongly developed, or in those
 
which have been noticed in the previous part of the paper. We frequently find portions
 
of bone where the osteal cells, lacunal cells, and intermediate tissue are so perfectly
 
fused together that neither can be recognized, but in their place we have a minutely
 
granular mass, divisible only into lacunae and canaliculi and the tissue in which they
 
lie imbedded. In Plate IX. fig. 32, taken from the tibia of a foetal lamb, the osteal
 
and lacunal cells have become blended to a considerable extent, but without the
 
  
* When speaking of the growth of cartilage, it was stated that the bulk of that tissue at the epiphysis
 
increased laterally by the division of the cells, but the fact that it also increased on the free surface of the
 
greatly enlarged cartilaginous epiphysis of the fcetus by a process similar to that by which the diameter of
 
bones is increased, was reserved to be described in connection with the latter subject. If a longitudinal section
 
be taken from the epiphysis of a foetal long bone, including some portion of the perichondrium, it will be seen that
 
the cartilage passes gradually into a more or less fibrous tissue, which forms the exterior of the part. Amongst
 
the fibres will be found numerous elongated cells, which on tracing the specimen inwards will be seen to be
 
similar to the cartilage cells at and near the surface of the tissue, while the fibres will be seen to give way to
 
or become converted into hyaline tissue, as shown in Plate IX. fig. 30, in which the cartilage is indicated
 
at a, and the cells included in the fibrous tissue at b.
 
  
 +
===Plate VIII===
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.  
+
Fig. 19. Longitudinal section of ossifying temporary cartilage, showing — a. Ossified intercolumnar tissue, b. Laeunal cells, c. Granular cells in process of conversion into lacunae, d. Laeunal cells imbedded in ossified interco- lumnar tissue, without conversion into lacunae.
  
 +
Fig. 20. Transverse section of ossifying cartilage from femur of a child, fourteen days old. a. Intercolumnar tissue, b. Laeunal cell. c. Similar cell, with granular cell in process of conversion into a lacuna.
  
133
+
Fig. 21. Section from femur of same subject, taken a little way below the ossifying cartilage.
  
 +
Fig. 22. A longitudinal section of new bone, a little further advanced than in fig. 19.
  
occurrence of lamination. The lamina which is represented at the margin is com-
+
a. A detached laeunal cell, showing the three parts of which these bodies are composed.
posed of still uncalcified cells. It shows the mode in which the undulating laminae
 
are formed. Fig. 33 also, taken from the fibula of a calf, shows ossified lacunal
 
and osteal cells without any tendency to lamination.  
 
  
The manner in which the Haversian spaces become gradually occupied by Haver-
 
sian systems is peculiarly interesting. To obtain a good view of the process, it
 
is necessary to make a transverse section of the developing systems. It may then be
 
seen that osteal cells arrange themselves in single file within the Haversian space
 
with intermediate lines of transparent tissue, and here and there a lacunal cell ; the
 
process commencing at the surface of the Haversian space, and extending gradually
 
inwards till the system is completed. In fact the soft tissue takes the permanent
 
form previous to the addition of the salts of bone, much in the same manner and
 
to the same degree as occurs in temporary cartilage before the earthy ingredients
 
are deposited. Lamination is nothing more than a definite linear arrangement of the
 
osteal cells with their outlines permanently retained in the perfected bone ; a cha-
 
racter much more strongly marked in the bones of adult than in those of young
 
animals.
 
  
In pursuing their inquiries into the growth of bone, the authors found it necessary
 
to take sections of perfectly fresh bone and to examine them in albuminous fluid;
 
spirits of wine, whether diluted or not, obscures the normal appearances, and water
 
is not more favourable as a medium.
 
  
Sections permanently mounted in dilute spirit lose a good deal of their character;
+
Fig. 23. Fig. 24.
still the appearances are preserved with more or less of their original distinctness.  
 
Sections mounted in Canada balsam show some of the points remarkably well. For
 
instance, the partially ossified osteal and lacunal cells are tolerably well preserved, but
 
unfortunately those cells which have not received any of the indurating salts are repre-
 
sented only by a transparent mass, in which but little structure can be recognized ;
 
thus, the part b in fig. 32 would have appeared but as a transparent line had the
 
specimen been mounted in Canada balsam. In addition to the necessity for care in
 
the examination of osseous structures, under the most favourable circumstances, as
 
regards the selection of specimens and the fluid used in their preparation, it is equally
 
necessary to have the more recent appliances for the illumination of the objects.  
 
  
Mr. Gillett's achromatic condenser, with what is called the white cloud illuminator,
 
renders it very easy to demonstrate points which with the ordinary miscroscopic
 
apparatus are shown with difficulty. It need not however be urged, that it is
 
desirable in pursuing structural anatomy to avail ourselves of the most perfect instru-
 
ments that can be obtained. It is proper that the authors should, before leaving
 
this part of the subject, draw some comparison between the development of bone in
 
cartilage and in the softer tissues.
 
  
Temporary cartilage, previous to the development of bone, affords a mechanical
+
Fig. 25. Fig. 26.
support and protection to the surrounding or enclosed softer tissues. These offices
 
  
MDCCCLIII. t
 
  
 +
Fig. 27.
  
134
+
Fig. 28. Fig. 29. Fig. 30.
  
 +
Fig. 31.
  
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
+
Fig. 32.
  
  
could not be rendered by a mere aggregation of soft cells, but are efficiently per-
+
Fig. 33. Fig. 34.
formed by the dense intercellular substance, which forms so characteristic a feature
 
of the cartilage. Hence in the mechanical function of cartilage the intercellular
 
element of the tissue must be regarded as the most important.  
 
  
A second, and scarcely less important purpose effected by temporary cartilage,
 
is that of affording a medium for which a more solid tissue may be substituted,
 
without the mechanical support being withdrawn from the adjoining parts during
 
the process of change. It affords also a means by which the long bones are gradu-
 
ally increased in length, without any interference with the functions of the limb.
 
These changes are brought about by the gradual increase in the number of the carti-
 
lage cells, at those parts only where ossification is about to commence, and by the
 
conversion of the cells into lacunal cells, at the cost of the intercellular tissue, which,
 
whilst its bulk is diminishing, becomes impregnated with the earthy salts ; so that
 
although the quantity is lessened, the strength of that which remains is increased.
 
Now, in examining the process by which growing bones are enlarged, it must be
 
borne in mind that the mechanical function of the cartilage is performed by the
 
bone which has replaced it, and that no such office is required of the new tissue
 
which is gradually adding to the bulk of the bone. The necessity for a dense inter-
 
cellular tissue no longer exists. Hence we have an aggregation of osteal cells with
 
so much only of intercellular tissue as will serve to connect them into a mass. A
 
certain number of these cells, by additions to their exterior, become lacunal cells.
 
We have then in the place of lacunal cells and dense intercolumnar tissue, lacunal
 
and osteal cells united by a small and almost imperceptible amount of a semifluid
 
intercellular medium ; the relative proportions of these several parts varying a little
 
with differences of age. Thus in aged subjects aggregations of lacunal cells may
 
here and there be found with but few osteal cells and but little intercellular tissue,
 
while in a young subject osteal cells will preponderate.
 
  
In all cases a direction may be given to the cells of a growing part, by their being
+
From rickety bone. a. Lacunal cells, b. A detached granular cell in process of conversion into a lacuna.
in relation with the insertion of a tendon.  
 
  
A consideration of the foregoing facts will, we think, lead to a conviction that the
+
Longitudinal section of developing bone from the tibia of a calf, mounted in Canada balsam, a. Intercolumnar tissue, from which the lacunal cells have disappeared, b. Ossified intercolumnar tissue and lacunal cells, c. Space produced by absorption, d. Haversian system in process of formation.
two different forms in which bone is developed, are designed to meet the require-
 
ments of the animal at different periods of life, and that bone developed by means
 
of osteal and lacunal cells is the higher form of the tissue. In early embryonic life
 
a soft cartilaginous skeleton is laid down, which is hard as compared with the sur-
 
rounding parts, and capable of affording them the required amount of mechanical
 
support. As the various tissues advance in development the cartilage increases in
 
density by the elaboration of its hyaline tissue, and after awhile those changes occur
 
which precede its conversion into bone. But in the bone so formed, it has been shown
 
that the canaliculi anastomose only at those points where the lacunal cells come into
 
contact (Plate VIII. fig. 25). In bone formed from osteal and lacunal cells, the ana-
 
stomosis of the canaliculi prevails throughout the tissue, while the outline of the
 
  
 +
Transverse section of same, taken at level of b in fig. 24. a. Intercolumnar tissue, b. Ossified lacunal cell. c. Secondary bone.
  
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.  
+
Arrangement of cells and fibres in the neighbourhood of developing parietal bone.
  
 +
===Plate IX===
  
135
+
Advancing spicula of bone, from parietal bone of foetal lamb. a. Developed bone, showing its cellular character, b. Osteal cells arranged around the bone previous to their calcification.
  
 +
From the epiphysis of the long bone of a calf, showing osteal and lacunal cells.
  
formative cells is almost entirely lost in the general blending of the whole into a  
+
From the parietal of a human foetus, showing osteal and lacunal cells, occu- pying the space betwixt two advancing spiculse of bone.
subgranular mass subject to lamination, in the manner already described.  
 
  
It will therefore be in accordance with the preceding views, to regard the inter-
+
Longitudinal section of cartilage with epichondrium attached, a. The developed cartilage, b. Fibres of perichondrium, with cells of a similar character to those of the cartilage.
columnar tissue present in primary bone, rather as an accessory element calculated
 
to give support during the ossification of the lacunal cells, than as an integral and
 
necessary element of osseous tissue ; for it has been shown that it offers an obstruc-
 
tion to the anastomosis of the canaliculi, and that the lacunal cells preserve their
 
outline so long as they are enclosed within it, instead of becoming lost in the sur-
 
rounding tissue, as occurs in secondary bone. It must not, however, be forgotten
 
that small patches of ossified intercolumnar tissue may here and there be found
 
between the Haversian systems, even in the bone of old subjects (Plate VII. fig. 16) ;
 
so that its presence in a small amount, (as accidentally left when the Haversian spaces
 
are forming), is not incompatible with the normal condition of perfect bone.  
 
  
It may also be stated in this place, that the undulating laminse formed on the sur-
+
Circumferential laminae of human tibia, showing the manner in which the laminae are developed from osteal cells, b. A compound cell, the origin ? of the osteal cells.
face of growing bone, although for the most part removed to make way for Haversian
 
systems, are also found here and there in small patches in the bones of adults.  
 
  
The subject of absorption, as it relates to the removal of bone, has already been
+
From the tibia of a foetal lamb. a. Developed bone, showing the cellular character, b. Undulating lamina in process of development, and con- taining lacunal cells, c. Osteal cells, not yet arranged. At d is shown an Haversian space, enclosed in the advancing ossification, while at e the laminae are approaching towards one another to enclose a space.
partly discussed, but something more remains to be said. Although the process of  
 
absorption has not, and probably cannot be seen in actual operation, yet a con-  
 
sideration of the relative position of the increasing and wasting parts, and of then-
 
conditions, will, in the authors' opinion, justify the conclusion that the bone is re-
 
moved through the agency of cells.  
 
  
In seeking to find the circumstances under which the absorption of bone takes
+
Fig. 20. From the fibula of a calf, showing growth on the external surface.
place most rapidly, and to the greatest extent, the authors have been led to examine
 
bones which had been placed in various conditions, both of health and disease. It
 
has been already stated that bone developed in cartilage is speedily removed ; but it
 
does not seem that bone formed by osteal and lacunal cells is absorbed with equal
 
rapidity, although in the course of a short time it not less surely disappears. This
 
difference in the rate of absorption is probably the result of the vascularity and higher
 
state of development of the latter tissue. In bone developed in cartilage Haversian
 
spaces have to be formed before it can be permeated by vessels; hence in this tissue
 
absorption proceeds rapidly, the process being established as soon as the bone is
 
formed. In adult bone, when in a normal condition, we find here and there an
 
Haversian space ; but if a bone around which the soft parts are in a state of inflam-
 
mation be examined, numerous Haversian spaces will be seen. If we examine the
 
same bone in the neighbourhood of that part where the inflamed is merging into the
 
healthy investing texture, we shall find new osseous matter in the process of depo-
 
sition on the surface of the pre-existing bone. Examples of this may frequently be
 
found in the vicinity of diseased joints.
 
 
 
We have here an instance of the development of new tissue, and the removal of a
 
pre-existing one being set in operation, by what would appear to be a different degree
 
 
 
t 2
 
 
 
 
 
136
 
 
 
 
 
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
 
 
 
 
 
only of the same action. Hence a more particular examination of the cellular mass,
 
by which bone appears to be absorbed in the one case and deposited in the other,
 
naturally suggests itself, and attention has been directed to this point as frequently
 
as favourable opportunities for observation have presented themselves. The differ-
 
ences, however, in microscopic characters between the two tissues, have not been so
 
strongly marked, as to admit of any definite description being given, by which the
 
one may, in all instances, be distinguished from the other, when removed from their
 
natural positions, as is almost necessarily the case with regard to the absorbent cells,
 
from the readiness with which they separate from the wasting bone (Plate IX.
 
figs. 27 and 34).
 
 
 
Lacunal cells moreover will not be found in the absorbing tissue ; but it is not easy
 
to recognize them, even in the tissue from which bone is developing, as they are
 
frequently obscured by the osteal cells ; so that their presence, although a good
 
ground of distinction, cannot in all instances be demonstrated. When, however,
 
developmental cells are seen in situ, their character is readily distinguished. They
 
are closely applied to the surface of the increasing bone, which loses the festooned
 
and assumes an even outline, to which the osteal cells adhere.
 
 
 
The source from which the cells destined for effecting absorption arise is at present
 
unknown to the authors, any further than that they arise in connection with soft
 
tissues, the three situations in which they occur being beneath the periosteum or
 
medullary membrane, or within an Haversian canal. These are no doubt the points
 
from which the development of the cells starts, but the law which regulates their
 
occurrence at one part rather than another, and gives to them their peculiar function,
 
is at present unexplained. Neither is it more easy to understand why, at a parti-
 
cular period, the process of absorption is arrested and development of new tissue com-
 
mences ; the new bone may, for anything we have seen to the contrary, be formed from
 
the same cells that have been concerned in the removal of the old. The organ by
 
which the fangs of teeth are absorbed offers a very favourable object for examination.
 
 
 
This we find to commence within or beneath the periosteum which covers the fang
 
of the tooth, and increases with the wasting of the tooth, until it comes in contact
 
with the pulp, which then assumes a similar function and becomes an absorbing
 
organ, increasing gradually in size, till, if the tooth be left undisturbed, but little of
 
the crown remains excepting the enamel. If, when in this condition, the crown of
 
the tooth be carefully removed, we shall see the absorbent papillae projecting a little
 
above the gum, firm in substance, and not disposed to bleed unless rudely handled.
 
Within two or three days it becomes covered with epithelium, either by the exten-
 
sion of the epithelial membrane from the surrounding parts, or from a change in
 
character in the superficial cells of the part itself*. Gradually the papilla loses its
 
 
 
* In the 26th volume of the Medico-Chirurgical Transactions, there is a short paper by Mr. Dalrymplb,
 
in which he describes a small tumour from the eyelid, consisting essentially of epithelial cells, in which the
 
ordinary contents had been replaced by ossific matter.
 
 
 
 
 
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.
 
 
 
 
 
137
 
 
 
 
 
distinctness of outline and merges into the surrounding gum, from which it can no
 
longer be distinguished. Here then we have a second instance in which an ab-
 
sorbent tissue has its function finally suspended, and a new one substituted. In the
 
place of increasing at the cost of pre-existing tissue, growth is suspended, and it
 
unites with and assumes a similar office to that of the surrounding gum.
 
 
 
In conclusion, the authors may allude to an interesting fact, with reference to the
 
subject of absorption, which has been recently observed by Mr. Stanley and subse-
 
quently by Mr. Bowman. In the treatment of ununited fracture, the practice has of
 
late been successfully adopted of drilling cylindrical holes into the bone in the neigh-
 
bourhood of the injury, and of driving in pegs of ivory, accurately fitted to the per-
 
forations, for the purpose of setting up action in their vicinity. These pegs, after
 
remaining in the bone several weeks, have been removed, and have been found on
 
inspection to present erosions similar to those which are seen on absorbing bone or
 
tooth. In fact, they closely resemble the fangs of temporary teeth recently attacked
 
by absorption. Mr. Bowman kindly placed at the disposal of the authors one of the
 
pegs which had been used for this purpose, a section of which presents, at the parts
 
eroded, in its microscopic characters, the usual emarginated outline so frequently
 
alluded to in the foregoing pages. They have not however had the opportunity of
 
investigating the condition of the tissues around the pegs; but it is exceedingly
 
probable that absorption has in these cases been effected by processes similar to those
 
which occur in the formation of Haversian spaces.
 
 
 
 
 
Explanation op the Plates.
 
 
 
PLATE VI.
 
 
 
Fig. 1. Transverse section of compact bone, showing the ordinary appearances.
 
 
 
a. Haversian system, b. Interstitial laminae, c. A new Haversian system
 
within an older one, the Haversian canal obliterated by the development
 
of a lacunal cell.
 
 
 
Fig. 2. Transverse section of compact bone, showing an Haversian space, with its
 
characteristic emarginated outline.
 
 
 
Fig. 3. The same, from a less compact part of the bone, from a man aged fifty-six.
 
 
 
Fig. 4. Transverse section from the fibula of a child two years old, showing the
 
general characters of bone in young subjects, a. Haversian space.
 
 
 
Fig. 5. Section of compact bone, showing several Haversian systems enclosed within
 
a single series of laminee. a. A lacunal cell attached to the surface of an
 
Haversian canal.
 
 
 
Fig. 6. Section showing the characters of a new Haversian system, developed within
 
an older one.
 
 
 
 
 
138
 
 
 
 
 
MESSRS. J. TOMES AND C. DE MORGAN ON THE
 
 
 
 
 
Fig. 7- An excentric Haversian system, illustrating the arrangement of the laminae.
 
Fig. 8. a. Lamination of bone, as it appears under a low power, b. The same highly
 
magnified, showing the lines of osteal cells and the intermediate transpa-
 
rent tissue.
 
 
 
 
 
PLATE VII.
 
 
 
Fig. 9. Transverse section of a stag's antler, after shedding, showing the transparent
 
tissue which lines the Haversian canals.
 
 
 
Fig. 10. Section showing the circumferential laminae, perforated by an Haversian
 
system.
 
 
 
Fig. 11. Section showing the orifices of the canaliouli, with their parietes.
 
 
 
Fig. 12. Sections from rickety bone. a. Consolidated lacunae, b. Laeunal cells,
 
from which no canaliculi have proceeded.
 
 
 
Fig. 13. Section showing circumferential laminae, with elongated canals passing
 
amongst the lacunae and canaliculi.
 
 
 
Fig. 14. Section of fossil bone, from the Wealden, supposed to be Pterodactyle, in
 
which the nuclei have been preserved by fossilization.
 
 
 
Fig. 15. Ossified laeunal cells, from the spongy portion of a bone of an old subject.
 
 
 
Fig. 16. Section from the petrous portion of a temporal bone of an adult, a. Laeunal
 
cells, containing lacunae and canaliculi. b. Intercellular granular tissue,
 
similar to that found in bone developed in cartilage.
 
 
 
Fig. 17. Section showing ossified articular cartilage, a. Lacuna developed from a
 
cartilage cell. b. Lines of granules.
 
 
 
Fig. 18. Section from an incus in a subject aged seventy-five, showing osteal and
 
laeunal cells on the surface.
 
 
 
 
 
PLATE VIII.
 
 
 
Fig. 19. Longitudinal section of ossifying temporary cartilage, showing — a. Ossified
 
intercolumnar tissue, b. Laeunal cells, c. Granular cells in process of
 
conversion into lacunae, d. Laeunal cells imbedded in ossified interco-
 
lumnar tissue, without conversion into lacunae.
 
 
 
Fig. 20. Transverse section of ossifying cartilage from femur of a child, fourteen days
 
old. a. Intercolumnar tissue, b. Laeunal cell. c. Similar cell, with
 
granular cell in process of conversion into a lacuna.
 
 
 
Fig. 21. Section from femur of same subject, taken a little way below the ossifying
 
cartilage.
 
 
 
Fig. 22. A longitudinal section of new bone, a little further advanced than in fig. 19.
 
 
 
a. A detached laeunal cell, showing the three parts of which these bodies
 
are composed.
 
 
 
 
 
STRUCTURE AND DEVELOPMENT OF BONE.
 
 
 
 
 
139
 
 
 
 
 
Fig. 23.
 
Fig. 24.
 
 
 
 
 
Fig. 25.
 
Fig. 26.
 
 
 
 
 
Fig. 27.
 
 
 
Fig. 28.
 
Fig. 29.
 
Fig. 30.
 
 
 
Fig. 31.
 
 
 
Fig. 32.
 
 
 
 
 
Fig. 33.
 
Fig. 34.
 
 
 
 
 
From rickety bone. a. Lacunal cells, b. A detached granular cell in
 
process of conversion into a lacuna.
 
 
 
Longitudinal section of developing bone from the tibia of a calf, mounted in
 
Canada balsam, a. Intercolumnar tissue, from which the lacunal cells
 
have disappeared, b. Ossified intercolumnar tissue and lacunal cells,
 
c. Space produced by absorption, d. Haversian system in process of
 
formation.
 
 
 
Transverse section of same, taken at level of b in fig. 24. a. Intercolumnar
 
tissue, b. Ossified lacunal cell. c. Secondary bone.
 
 
 
Arrangement of cells and fibres in the neighbourhood of developing parietal
 
bone.
 
 
 
PLATE IX.
 
 
 
Advancing spicula of bone, from parietal bone of foetal lamb. a. Developed
 
bone, showing its cellular character, b. Osteal cells arranged around the
 
bone previous to their calcification.
 
 
 
From the epiphysis of the long bone of a calf, showing osteal and lacunal
 
cells.
 
 
 
From the parietal of a human foetus, showing osteal and lacunal cells, occu-
 
pying the space betwixt two advancing spiculse of bone.
 
 
 
Longitudinal section of cartilage with epichondrium attached, a. The
 
developed cartilage, b. Fibres of perichondrium, with cells of a similar
 
character to those of the cartilage.
 
 
 
Circumferential laminae of human tibia, showing the manner in which the
 
laminae are developed from osteal cells, b. A compound cell, the origin ?
 
of the osteal cells.
 
 
 
From the tibia of a foetal lamb. a. Developed bone, showing the cellular
 
character, b. Undulating lamina in process of development, and con-
 
taining lacunal cells, c. Osteal cells, not yet arranged. At d is shown an
 
Haversian space, enclosed in the advancing ossification, while at e the
 
laminae are approaching towards one another to enclose a space.
 
 
 
From the fibula of a calf, showing growth on the external surface.
 
 
 
From an inflamed femur, showing absorption, with the cells contained in
 
the Haversian space.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
TM. Trans. 1® CCCLIE . Flab
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
ThiL. TrcmjMDC(XZHL?laie7JL.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Jy. S3.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
-Fig. 29.
 
 
 
 
 
Fig. 20.
 
 
 
 
 
JPML Irons. MDCCCLUI. JSatfVHL
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
JM. Irons. MD CCCLm. Plate I X .  
 
  
 +
Fig. 29. From an inflamed femur, showing absorption, with the cells contained in the Haversian space.
  
  
Line 1,764: Line 491:
  
  
 +
{{Footer}}
 
[[Category:Historic Embryology]][[Category:1800's]][[Category:Bone]]
 
[[Category:Historic Embryology]][[Category:1800's]][[Category:Bone]]

Revision as of 15:40, 14 March 2018

Embryology - 24 Jun 2021    Facebook link Pinterest link Twitter link  Expand to Translate  
Google Translate - select your language from the list shown below (this will open a new external page)

العربية | català | 中文 | 中國傳統的 | français | Deutsche | עִברִית | हिंदी | bahasa Indonesia | italiano | 日本語 | 한국어 | မြန်မာ | Pilipino | Polskie | português | ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਦੇ | Română | русский | Español | Swahili | Svensk | ไทย | Türkçe | اردو | ייִדיש | Tiếng Việt    These external translations are automated and may not be accurate. (More? About Translations)

Tomes J. and De Morgan C. Observations on the structure and development of bone. (1853) : 109-139.

Online Editor  
Mark Hill.jpg


Modern Notes: Bone Development | Skull Development

Musculoskeletal Links: Introduction | mesoderm | somitogenesis | limb | cartilage | bone | bone timeline | bone marrow | shoulder | pelvis | axial skeleton | skull | joint | skeletal muscle | muscle timeline | tendon | diaphragm | Lecture - Musculoskeletal | Lecture Movie | musculoskeletal abnormalities | limb abnormalities | developmental hip dysplasia | cartilage histology | bone histology | Skeletal Muscle Histology | Category:Musculoskeletal
Historic Embryology - Musculoskeletal  
1853 Bone | 1885 Sphenoid | 1902 - Pubo-femoral Region | Spinal Column and Back | Body Segmentation | Cranium | Body Wall, Ribs, and Sternum | Limbs | 1901 - Limbs | 1902 - Arm Development | 1906 Human Embryo Ossification | 1906 Lower limb Nerves and Muscle | 1907 - Muscular System | Skeleton and Limbs | 1908 Vertebra | 1908 Cervical Vertebra | 1909 Mandible | 1910 - Skeleton and Connective Tissues | Muscular System | Coelom and Diaphragm | 1913 Clavicle | 1920 Clavicle | 1921 - External body form | Connective tissues and skeletal | Muscular | Diaphragm | 1929 Rat Somite | 1932 Pelvis | 1940 Synovial Joints | 1943 Human Embryonic, Fetal and Circumnatal Skeleton | 1947 Joints | 1949 Cartilage and Bone | 1957 Chondrification Hands and Feet | 1968 Knee
Historic Disclaimer - information about historic embryology pages 
Mark Hill.jpg
Pages where the terms "Historic" (textbooks, papers, people, recommendations) appear on this site, and sections within pages where this disclaimer appears, indicate that the content and scientific understanding are specific to the time of publication. This means that while some scientific descriptions are still accurate, the terminology and interpretation of the developmental mechanisms reflect the understanding at the time of original publication and those of the preceding periods, these terms, interpretations and recommendations may not reflect our current scientific understanding.     (More? Embryology History | Historic Embryology Papers)

IV. Observations on the Structure and Development of Bone

By John Tomes, F.R.S., Surgeon-Dentist to the Middlesex Hospital, and Campbell De Morgan, Surgeon to the Middlesex Hospital.

John Tomes (1815-1895) Campbell De Morgan (1811-1876)

Received April 22, Read June 10, 1852.

Introduction

The structure and development of bone is a subject which has occupied the attention of physiologists both of present and past times, and holds a prominent place in their writings. From the time of Clopton Havers, who was the first to point out the vascular canals in bone, and whose name they have since borne, to the year 1850, when M. Kolliker's elaborate work on Structural Anatomy appeared, physiological writers have dwelt at considerable length on this branch of their subject. All have, however, concluded with the admission that more remained to be learned before this important structure could be regarded as fully understood*.


It is the purpose of the authors in this communication, to lay before the Royal Society the results of an extended series of observations on the structure and development of bone. Such of these results as are novel might, perhaps, be de- scribed without reference to those points which are already well known. It will, however, be seen, in the subsequent pages, that they are in themselves, and in their relations to osseous tissue and its development, as well as to structural anatomy generally, of such a nature, as would hardly admit of an intelligible description apart from some consideration of the whole subject. Hence it will be necessary to point out the relations between that which is already known, and that which it is the special purpose of this paper to communicate, and it is proposed to consider the details of the subject as they present themselves in the progress of investigation with but little reference to authorities, adding in the form of notes, those statements which require acknowledgement, either as agreeing with, or as being opposed to, the views advanced in this paper.


In treating of the structure of bone, it is convenient to commence by describing the appearances which a thin transverse section from the shaft of an adult long bone presents when placed in the field of a microscope having a magnifying power of from 200 to 300 linear. In addition to the large central space which corresponds to the medullary cavity of the bone, the section is seen to be perforated by numerous small apertures, each of which is surrounded by a series of laminae of osseous tissue concentrically arranged. Lying amongst the laminae are many small cavities, from which minute tubes radiate. These were called bone-corpuscles by Purkinje, who first described them ; but latterly, with a more correct appreciation of their nature, the name of lacunae has been substituted at the suggestion of Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman*, who have also described the Haversian canals, their surrounding laminae, and their lacunae, under the inclusive term of Haversian systems. The whole sub- stance of the bone is made up of Haversian systems, connected by irregularly-shaped patches of short laminae which occupy the spaces between the systems (Plate VI. fig. 1 b). These have received the name of interstitial laminae from Kolliker. In addition to the Haversian and interstitial laminae, we have in most instances others that surround, or partly surround the whole, and form the outer surface of the bone. These, from the position they occupy, are called the circumferential laminae. A similar series more or less perfect is found to form the wall of the medullary cavity.


Mikroskopische Anatomie, von Dr. A. Kolliker. Leipzig, 1850,


If the section be taken from near the end instead of from the middle of the shaft of a long bone, the Haversian canals will appear much larger, and in the place of one great central opening we shall see numerous lesser ones, corresponding to the cancellous part of the bone. From whatever bone, or part of a bone, the section be taken, the arrangement of laminse and lacunse is substantially the same ; the differences between the compact and cancellous portions consisting in variations in the relative quantities of the bone tissue and the size and number of the canals, and not in any real difference in the structure.


The elongated bones of some of the vertebrata, when cut transversely through their centres, are seen to be composed, at that part, of a single Haversian system. The rib of a Boa may be cited as an example.


Having drawn attention to the several parts which are recognised as entering into the composition of bone, the authors will now proceed to describe the results of their investigations under the subjoined heads :

1st. The Haversian canals and other spaces.

2nd. The laminse.

3rd. The lacunae and canaliculi.

4th. The Haversian systems.

5th. Ossified cartilage of joints.

6th. Ossified cells.

7th. Bone tissue.

8th. Development of bone.

9th. Growth of bone.

Haversian and other Canals of Bone. — The Haversian canals have been described by all recent writers on the subject of bone ; their variable size and not unfrequent anastomoses have been pointed out ; and the fact of the larger apertures in the spongy parts of bone being similar in the structure of their parietes to the smaller ones in the denser parts of the osseous tissue has not failed to be recognized. It may be remarked, that whether the canals are large or small, their section presents an oval or circular outline, and that the walls of such canals have a tolerably uniform surface. When examining sections of bone it is necessary to bear this fact in mind, for on a close inspection it will be seen that there are other spaces which possess a different character, although up to the present time, so far as the authors know, this difference has not been recognized.


The Physiological Anatomy and Physiology of Man, by Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman, vol. i. p. 109.


These spaces are irregular in shape, and have an irregular, festooned and often jagged outline, similar to that found on the surface of bone which has been removed by exfoliation, similar also to the surface left upon the fang of a tooth after a part has been absorbed. Such spaces correspond in shape to the peripheral outline of one or more of the Haversian systems, and are in fact subservient to the development of those systems, and necessarily precede their formation (Plate VI. figs. 2 a , 3 a, 4 a). It is proposed to call these spaces which are produced by absorption, Haversian spaces, as this name is indicative of their ultimate connection with the Haversian systems. In the Haversian canals we have surrounding laminae, but in the spaces the boundaries are formed by portions of several systems, each of which has been in part removed in the formation of the spaces, as shown in figures 2 and 3, and Plate V., which, on being compared with figure 1, will illustrate the difference between the spaces and canals ; allowance must, however, be made for the difference of size, as in figure 1 the parts are less magnified than in the other illustrations. In newly formed bone situated near ossifying cartilage, the Haversian spaces are exceedingly numerous and large, frequently affording room for the development of two or more systems (fig. 5, Plate VI. fig. 24, Plate VIII.), while in older bone they are far less numerous, and generally less in size. In no case, however, are they wholly absent. They are found even in the bones of old subjects, and in connection with them newly developed systems.


This is a very important fact, as it demonstrates that the old tissue is removed in masses, and a new one developed in its place. It has long been taught that the older particles of an internal tissue are removed by absorption and new ones substituted, and this throughout the life of the individual. But the authors believe that they have demonstrated it for the first time.


On examining with care a series of sections, the Haversian spaces will be found in various conditions. In one place the space will have attained a large size, while in another part of the same section its commencement will be seen extending from one side of an Haversian canal. In a third instance, its occupation will have commenced, and its festooned margin will be lined by the peripheral lamina of an Haversian system. Then, again, examples may be found where one side of a space is becoming the seat of a new system, while the opposite one is undergoing further enlargement. In no case is there any difficulty in distinguishing between an enlarging Haversian space and a developing Haversian system. The authors have preparations which show that these conditions of absorption and reproduction take place in old as well as in young or middle-aged subjects ; but it would appear that the frequency diminishes with the increasing age of the individual. It may however be observed in the bones of those who have passed the sixtieth year. The more recently formed systems differ from those of older date in the somewhat larger size of their lacunee and canaliculi, and in the greater abundance of the latter, as shown in fig. 6, Plate VI.


Laminae of Bone

Lamination is a tolerably constant character of mammalian bone, although the degree of its distinctness is subject to considerable variation. In the bones of young subjects it is less pronounced than in those of mature animals (fig. 4, Plate VI.); it is also much less observable in the cancellous than in the compact tissue. When lamination reaches its highest degree of development, each lamina is seen to be made up of two parts, an outer, which is highly granular, composed oftentimes of a single line of large granules or cells*, as shown in Plate VI. fig. 8 ; and an inner portion, which is singularly clear and transparent, and to all appearance without granulation or any recognizable structure.


Kolliker has described and figured a somewhat similar appearance from a specimen treated with turpentine, but he does not seem to regard it as very readily discoverable in ordinary preparations; there is, however, no difficulty in exhibiting this arrangement of structure in well-made sections, either simply polished or (which is better) put up in hard Canada balsam.


Very favourable views of lamination may be seen in transverse sections from the shafts of long bones ; some of the most striking illustrations in the possession of the authors were obtained from the tibia of a subject the whole of whose bones were slightly hypertrophied, and from the femur of a limb which had from infancy been atrophied and useless.


Strongly marked laminae, with their transparent and granular portions, are however not always met with ; yet in their absence the observer will seldom fail to find laminae of more uniform granularity surrounding the Haversian canals in well-marked concentric rings.


On examining the Haversian systems, it will be seen that the peripheral lamina has its internal surface marked by an even line, while the external is subject to slight bulgings, which correspond with and accurately fit into the indentations that form the margin of a pre-existing Haversian space (Plate VI. fig. 1). Hence the outer lamina of a system will present on its external surface a certain number of alternating dilatations and contractions ; a peculiarity possessed by none of the more internal of the series. We may, however, find the whole of the laminae of a system presenting different degrees of thickness on the opposite sides of a canal, from the latter being a little eccentric in its position. But when the eccentricity is considerable, as in the case illustrated in Plate VI. fig. 7, the laminae are not all continued round the canal Hence,


The nature of these bodies will be more fully considered under the head of development and growth of bone. f Kolliker, oper. cit. page 284. In ' The Microscopic Anatomy of the Human Body,' by A. H. Hassall, this appearance is indistinctly figured, but no description of it can be found in the letterpress.


J Kolliker, oper. cit. at page 283, states that in the eccentric systems the whole of the laminae generally in such a system, there are more laminae on one side than on the other, and those on the side occupied by the greatest number are thicker in their centres than at their extremities, where they become gradually thinner, and are ultimately lost. The inner lamina, whether the systems are eccentric or not, forms, when the development is completed,' a perfect ring, and not unfrequently presents a second peculiarity. The tissue of which it is composed is transparent, and affords, with our present means of investigation, little evidence of structure (Plate VI. figs. 6 and 7) It is transparent and glass-like, resembling that tissue which lines the Haversian canals in the antlers of the Cervidse before they are cast (Plate VII. fig. 9).


The interstitial laminse are abundant, and strongly marked in transverse sections of long bones, or in any sections of bone in which the Haversian systems are cut transversely. The laminse vary both as to their number and length, and are usually more or less curved. They are arranged throughout the bone in well-defined isolated groups, in each of which the constituent laminse are parallel (PlateVI. fig. 1 b). Professor Kolliker*, when treating of this subject, observes that it is difficult to account for the presence of the interstitial laminse, and suggests that the appearance may perhaps be produced by the Haversian systems being cut obliquely, but at the same time admits that this explanation is not satisfactory. M. Kolliker had not recognized the presence of the Haversian spaces and the manner of their production and subsequent occupation, otherwise he would have seen that the interstitial laminse are the remaining parts of Haversian systems, the larger portions of which had been removed by absorption. But that the term interstitial lamince is already in use and has a definite meaning, the authors would have proposed the substitution of partial Haversian systems, as being more descriptive of these parts.


In addition to the laminse of the perfect and imperfect Haversian systems, others that surround several linearly arranged systems are not uncommon, producing the appearance illustrated in Plate VI. fig. 5. In these instances a large oval system of laminse has become occupied by several lesser ones. The occurrence of one system within another is by no means rare. We may then see the characteristic einarginated outline of the older system, and within this a second similar outline marking the periphery of the younger system, as shown in Plate VI. fig. 6, in which the lamination of each is delineated.


The circumferential laminse are the most external, and where they exist form the surface of the bone. Their occurrence, however, is by no means so constant as is generally described, and even when present they seldom extend perfectly round the bone. The authors have scarcely seen an example in which the laminse have been continued without interruption around the shaft of a long bone, and in flat bones encircle the canal, but that they are individually thicker on the one than on the other side. Although this may be the case in some instances it has been hut rarely seen by the authors.


Kolliker, page 289, oper. cit. This appearance is figured by M. Kolliker, but no reference is made to the peculiarity in the letterpress.

they are even less constant. When present they appear to indicate that the bone is nearly stationary in its growth as regards thickness, for in the fast-growing bones of young animals these laminse are entirely absent, while in the bones of adults they are usually well-developed in some parts. In number they seem subject to considerable variation, and not unfrequently are arranged in different concentric series with three or four laminse in each division, separated from the adjacent series by a broad and transparent lamina, suggesting the idea of periods of greater activity of growth, alternating with others of less activity. Like those of the Haversian systems, the circumferential laminse are perforated by Haversian spaces and systems (Plate VII. fig. 10), and in many examples to such an extent that they are recognized only as interstitial laminse ; but their uniform direction parallel with the surface of the bone will satisfactorily indicate their previous existence as continuous circumferential laminse. In this part of a bone we may sometimes discover a peculiarity of character, in the presence of Haversian systems, consisting of two or three laminse, or of even a single lamina only, so small has been the preceding Haversian space.

In the progress of development canals are sometimes formed which proceed from the surface of the bone into its substance, and around these the circumferential laminse are inflected, thereby forming systems, the laminse of which are continuous with those of the surface of the bone. On the other hand, Haversian spaces not unfrequently occur which are continued from the surface towards the centre of the bone, cutting the circumferential laminse abruptly across ; systems are subsequently developed in these spaces ; but in such instances the laminse of the systems are not continuous with those of the surface (the latter appearance is shown in Plate VII. fig. 10).


In young rapidly growing bone the circumferential laminse are replaced by a series, which, from the character of their course, might be termed the undulating laminse. The bone in its growth sends off outrunning processes between those vessels of the periosteum which lie nearest the surface of the bone. These processes are formed of reduplicated laminse which are continued from process to process, following the undulating surface of the bone for a considerable distance before they are lost. The growing processes as they increase in size and length arch over towards each other by the dilatation or bifurcation of the outer extremities. The salient points so formed come into contact and unite, thereby enclosing the vessels. The spaces enclosed in the manner described become the seat of Haversian systems. Hence we have at this period of growth, bone composed of Haversian systems with intervening undulating laminse, a character by which the observer cannot fail to recognise young growing bone as differing from that of adult animals. Over the points where the processes have met and united, laminse are extended which are continued outwards to form similar and more external processes ; these in their turn become united and inclose spaces. This mode of increase by the development of outgrowing processes is repeated again and again until the rate of growth becomes arrested, when the formation of ordinary circumferential laminae is assumed in some cases to be again replaced by the development of undulating laminae. It must however be remembered that in the rapidly growing bone of young subjects lamination is much less strongly pronounced than in the bones of the adult (Plate VI. fig. 4), and that in many cases it is indicated more distinctly by the arrangement of the lacunae than by the presence of well-marked outlines in the laminae themselves.


In addition to laminated tissue we sometimes find portions of superficial bone run in, as it were, between two or three Haversian systems, and without any appearance of lamination, but with a general transparency, and with lacunae scattered through it of indefinite form, and wanting in that arrangement which prevails in laminated bone*.

Lacunas of Bone

In a transverse section of the Haversian systems the lacunae are seen as elongated oval spaces, lying amongst, and with their long axes in the direction of, the laminae ; numerous canaliculi proceed from them, the bulk of which in this view pass off towards either the Haversian canals or the outer surface of the systems. The lacunae are however somewhat different in appearance at different ages of the systems and of the subject. In youth they are large, numerous, and richly supplied with canaliculi ; on the other hand, in an old subject they are less numerous and have fewer canaliculi. Moreover, they vary a little in character in different parts of the same preparation, according to the age of the particular spot in which they are examined (Plate VI. fig. 6). Then, again, they frequently exist without canaliculi ; while in other cases they may be found, together with the canaliculi, in great part filled up with solid matter, leaving only a small round open space in their centre. This state of consolidation has not, so far as the authors are aware, been previously observed. It is however present to a considerable extent in the long bones of adults who have in infancy suffered from rickets, and whose bones have remained permanently distorted (Plate VII. fig. 12 a and b). More rarely a similar condition may be seen in the bones of those who have passed the middle period of life without having suffered from rickets in childhood. Hence consolidation must be regarded as a normal condition of the lacunae, of occasional occurrence, rather than as the result of disease.


In favourable sections it may be shown that both the lacunae and canaliculi have parietes, which are manifested by appearances similar to those observed in the dentinal tubes. In lacunae which have no canaliculi the walls are well-marked, and in a transverse section of the latter the parietes are readily recognized, as shown in figure 11, Plate VII.


Kolliker, oper. cit. p. 288, objects to the opinion of Arnold that the interstitial laminse have a different origin from the external and internal circumferential laminse, the former of which he believes to originate in the cartilage, the latter in the external and internal periosteum.

Kolliker' s views are inserted in the text, but it is seen above that the observations of the authors do not coincide with those of either Arnold or Kolliker.

  • This point will receive additional confirmation in a subsequent part of the paper, when the development of the lacunae and canaliculi is described.


In a longitudinal section of Haversian systems we have the laminae on either side of the canals cut at right angles, or nearly so, while immediately over the canals they are exposed in their breadth ; in the one instance we look upon the cut edges, in the other upon the surface of the laminae. The lacunae in the two parts present differences in outline. In the former part they resemble those seen in the Haversian systems divided transversely, in the latter they approach a circular, or slightly oval figure, and send out canaliculi indifferently from all parts of their circumference. After examining the lacunae from these three different points of view, it will be manifest to the observer that the normal form is that of a greatly compressed hollow sphere or oval, from which numerous minute tubes are continued. To this prevailing form we find numerous exceptions, which, although of not unfrequent occurrence, form but a small part of the whole number that may be seen in an ordinary preparation. The outlines assumed by the exceptional lacunae are too varied and too irregular to admit of such a description as would embrace every departure from the ordinary form. It is however worthy of mention, that lacunae may sometimes be met with, normal in form, but of three times the usual dimensions.


What has been said of the lacunae of the Haversian systems will of course apply also to those occupying parts of systems known under the name of interstitial laminae. In the circumferential laminae the lacunae are for the most part similar to those already described. But we have in this situation what may perhaps be regarded as modified lacunae, presenting themselves in the form of elongated tubes arranged in bundles, or occurring singly, and passing more or less obliquely from the surface towards the interior of the bone (Plate VII. fig. 13). When these tubes attain a considerable length they are commonly bent at a sharp angle once or twice in their course, and at each flexure change their direction, presenting sometimes a loose resemblance to the letter 2 . When these tubules are divided transversely they exhibit parietes. On tracing them in parts abounding with lacunae, it will be seen that they form lateral connections with the canaliculi, at the same time that they cross these as well as the lacunae and laminae obliquely. The presence of the oblique tubes is not however constant. In one part of the circumferential laminae they will be abundant, while in another they will be sparingly present or altogether absent. Then, again, they may be seen in one series of laminae, while in the contiguous set they are absent, but may reappear in a third and more deeply-seated series. They are, however, we believe, strictly confined to the limits of the circumferential laminae, and are seldom present unless these are tolerably abundant.


The lacunae situated in the transparent non-laminated bone, which is sometimes found on or near the surface, and to which we have before alluded, are less compressed in form than those hitherto described. They are subject to great irregularities of outline, and send off canaliculi equally from all parts of their circumference, thereby imparting a peculiarity to the tissue which cannot fail to be remarked. The presence of persistent nuclei in the lacunae has been questioned by recent authors ; some state that they may be detected at times, while others regard their presence as very problematical. Mr. Goodsir* describes the lacunae as containing a little mass of nucleated cells.


M. KoLLiKER , after citing Schwann, Krause, Kohlrausch, Heischmann, Gunther and Donders, all of whom believe in the persistence of the nuclei in the lacunae, goes on to say that he has paid great attention to the subject. In the bones of an individual eighteen years old he found them after the sections had been treated with acid. The authors have had no difficulty in finding the nuclei in recent bone without the aid of chemical treatment. If a small fragment be taken from the spongy portion of a fresh bone and freed from adherent fat, the nuclei may be seen as small rounded bodies attached to the walls of the lacunae ; their appearance is shown in Plate IX. figs. 27 and 29. In dry sections of bone the nuclei are less readily recognized, although we may find them here and there. The authors have sections of a fossil bone from the Wealden (supposed to be Pterodactyle) in which all the lacunae have well-defined nuclei (Plate VII. fig. 14).


Haversian Systems

Having described the several parts entering into the formation of Haversian systems, it now remains to say a few words on the relations of these to each other, and to the other parts of bone which are not included under that term. The union of the Haversian and other systems of laminae is seen, in a transverse section of a long bone, to be effected by the interposition of a layer of transparent tissue. In a recently-formed system the canaliculi do not appear to pass through this layer, but in older ones they are seen to pass across from the external lacunae and to anastomose with those from the interstitial or circumferential laminae, or with those of adjoining Haversian systems (Plate VII. fig. 10). After these intercommuni- cations have been fully established, the connecting layer loses something of its original transparency, but not the whole, for in the bones of aged subjects it may still be distinguished.


In Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman's ‘ Physiological Anatomy,' it is stated, on the authority of Mr. Tomes, that the canaliculi of adjoining systems anastomose but scantily. A more extended examination into the subject has shown this to be true of the more recently developed systems, but not of those of greater age. In addition to the con- nection of systems of laminae by the juxtaposition of their external members, instances not unfrequently occur where several Haversian systems, linearly arranged, are encircled by a series of laminae common to the whole. This is shown in Plate VI. fig. 5. But although we may find groups of systems thus bound together by enclosing laminae, in addition to the general or partial investment by circumferential laminae, such binding together is clearly not necessary to ensure the strength of the bone, as we see many bones altogether destitute of circumferential laminae, and very few with these laminae complete; while the encircling of several Haversian systems with laminae common to the whole is the exception rather than the rule.


Anatomical and Pathological Observations, by John Goodsie and Henry D. S. Goodsie, 1845, t Kolliker, oper. cit. p. 296.


In the progress of their investigations the authors have failed to discover any instances in which pre-existing laminae, partially absorbed, have become continuous with newly-developed ones, end to end ; indeed there seems good reason for supposing that such seldom, if ever occurs, otherwise the Haversian systems would not be so strongly marked, neither should we have the festooned outline to the systems lying against the cut ends of the laminae, in the manner shown in Plates VI. and VII. figs. 1 and 10.


In examining Haversian systems divided transversely, one will be occasionally found in which the canal has been completely obliterated by the development of a lacunal cell in its centre. This condition is illustrated in fig. 1 c.

Ossified Cartilage of Joints

Dr. Sharpe y has shown that beneath the articular cartilage lies a layer of bone produced by the gradual ossification of this tissue*. Professor KoLLiKER has observed this form of bone to be present in all the articu- lations, excepting that of the jaw and the hyoid bone, in which situations he has failed to detect it. The authors have numerous sections from the articular process of the lower jaw, in all of which it is present, and although in smaller amount than is usually found in corresponding parts of other bones, still it is sufficiently distinct. The pecu- liarity of the articular bone consists in the maintenance of the same arrangement of parts as existed in the cartilage prior to its conversion into bone. The cells for the most part are arranged in groups or in lines parallel with the long axis of the bone, each cell presenting a roundish mass surrounded by granules, and rendered rather indefinite in outline. Not uncommonly several cells become connected end to end, thus producing an elongated form. It is when in this condition that the cells and basement tissue may be restored to the appearance of cartilage by the use of hydro- chloric acid. Occasionally, however, a cell becomes converted into a well-developed lacuna, and near the ordinary bone the cells may be seen in more or less advanced stages towards their conversion (Plate VII. fig. 17).


In the ossified cartilage, when the tissue attains a considerable thickness, broad and ill-defined lines or bands of opacity may generally be found running parallel with the articular surface, and giving a stratified character to the part in which they are situated, as shown in fig. 17 b. When seen by transmitted light, these lines appear of a deep rich brown colour, and as if possessed of a much higher degree of granularity than the surrounding parts. The cells of the tissue are not uncommonly surrounded by a similar granular condition of the matrix. This state of granularity is most con- spicuous near the bone, and less so near the cartilage, where the tissue becomes clear and transparent. The ossified cartilage is generally separated by a well-marked line from the subjacent bone. Exceptions to this, however, are not wanting, where the two pass, the one into the other, by insensible gradations. The bone at the line of junction is usually advanced into the ossified cartilage by rounded projections of variable size ; some of which reach nearly to the surface, while others are situated at some little depth. From this arrangement the articular bone is necessarily irregular in quantity. In one part it will dip to a considerable depth into the bone, while at another and perhaps contiguous part it will form but a thin layer. The external or articular surface is but slightly affected by the irregularities of the surface attached to the bone ; on the contrary, it presents an even surface, on which the articular cartilage is placed in a uniform layer.


Dr. Quain's Anatomy, fifth edition, by Mr. Quain and Dr. Sharpey, part ii. page 158. “ In the slow growth of bone which encroaches on the attached surface of articular cartilage, the ossification would almost seem to be produced merely by the impregnation of the cartilaginous matrix with earthy matter (corresponding with the first step of the ordinary process) ; and in this case, the cells and clusters of cells being surrounded by calcified matrix, may remain as little vacuities or lacunae in the bone ; but this as well as the formation of lacunae in the crusta petrosa of the teeth, and the production of adventitious bony deposits in different textures, requires further investigation.â€

t Kolliker, page 318, oper. cit.



The absence of Haversian canals, and the unfrequency of lacunse with canaliculi in the articular bone, renders this tissue much less porous than ordinary bone, a condition which probably contributes to its strength, and to the strength of the part in which it occurs.


In the presence of this peculiar form of tissue at the articular extremities of bones we may perceive a striking instance of design.


It would appear that the articular cartilage must rest upon a firm and uniform surface, otherwise it would, under pressure, yield unequally, and the joint would probably be but imperfect in its action. Circumferential laminae are developed only on free surfaces, and do not present there a very level outer surface. A surface formed by Haversian systems would be irregularly fluted or nodulated, like that beneath the calcified cartilage. Neither of those forms of development, then, would effect a condition of surface similar to that attained by the ossified cartilage. A careful con- sideration of the foregoing facts will, we think, lead to the conviction, that the presence of ossified cartilage as a basis for articular cartilage must not be regarded simply as the result of a slowly progressing ossification of a tissue prone to ossify ; neither must it be regarded as an imperfectly developed tissue in which the formative process was arrested before the part had been perfected*; but it must be regarded as a constant element in the osseous system, having its special use, and necessary to the perfect organization of the skeleton in the higher forms of Vertebrata.

Ossified Lacunal Cells

In addition to the parts already described, the authors have found a condition of bone which has hitherto escaped observation, or if seen, has not been recognized as a form of osseous tissue. The bones of aged people not unfrequently become extremely light and spongy, readily break, and from the diminished amount of compact tissue, may in the case of the flat bones, such as those of the pelvis, be indented by firm pressure with the finger. Such bones, after maceration, contain within the spaces enclosed by the cancelli, a white powder, which readily falls out if the bone be broken. If a little of this powder be mounted in Canada balsam, and placed in the field of the microscope, the observer will see that it is mainly composed of large nucleated cells, some of which are detached, others united into masses.


Kolliker, oper. cit. page 318, speaks of this tissue as imperfectly formed bone- substance.


The isolated cells have a spherical or oval form, and appear to consist of a granular nucleus surrounded by a very thick cell- wall, external to which we commonly find an aggregation of granular matter, indefinite in amount and presenting a ragged outline (Plate VII. fig. 15). The cells which are united into masses are connected by this granular matter, or ossified blastema, as it might perhaps be called. The cells them- selves are similar to the loose ones, excepting that in some cases their character is rendered more apparent by the nucleus assuming the form of a lacuna. If a section of the bone be examined, similar cells will be found adherent to the walls of the Haversian canals, with the canaliculi of contiguous lacunae advancing into them, while the nuclei of the adherent cells are assuming the form of lacunae and throwing out canaliculi.


Again, in the substance of the bone, the outline of the formative cells, similar in size and shape to the loose ones, may be in places recognized, having lacunae and canaliculi as their centres. The recognition of these ossified cells in their isolated state will be followed by the observation of similar cells occupying the Haversian canals and eancellar spaces in the majority of microscopic preparations of adult bone (Plate VI. fig. 5 a ) ; and the same may sometimes be seen on the outer surface of bone (Plate VII. fig. 18). The appearance of the cells is, however, liable to be modified by the various circumstances which operate upon growing bone, such as the presence of a tendon, or of a large pulsating vessel, or in fact, by pressure from any cause. Thus if situated in the immediate neighbourhood of a tendon, they assume an elon- gated form ; while on the other hand they may be flattened by pressure.


It has been thought desirable to describe the ossified lacunal cells at this place, on account of their frequent occurrence in adult bone (Plate VI. fig. 5 a, and Plate VII. figs. 16 and 18).

Bone Tissue

Hitherto we have confined our description to the forms in which the bone substance is arranged, as into laminae, Haversian systems, &c. We have now to consider the ultimate structure of the tissue itself. But little has been said upon this point until within the last ten years. In the ‘Physiological Anatomy' of Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman*, it is stated that bone is made up of an aggregation of granules in a scarcely distinguishable matrix. Latterly, other views have been pro- posed. Dr. Sharpey has advanced the hypothesis, that although the bone developed in cartilage is at one period granular-^, a reticulate fibrous arrangement of the elements

  • Dr. Todd and Mr. Bowman, Physiological Anatomy, page 108.
  • Dr. Quain's Anatomy, edited by Mr. Quain and Dr. Sharpey, page 157. - The primary osseous matter forming the original thin walls of the areolae is, as Mr. Tomes observes, decidedly granular, and has a of the tissue takes its place, and must be regarded as the general condition of bone*. Dr. Sharpey, when he formed this opinion, had directed his attention principally to thin fragments torn from the surface of bone macerated in hydrochloric acid. The authors have seen the appearance both in decalcified bone, and in sections which have not been chemically treated ; but they believe the fibrous appearance to be an optical effect produced by the canaliculi and granules when the light is unequally distributed, or the object-glass in bad adjustment. It will be shown in the subse- quent details, that the appearance can be produced and dispelled at pleasure by alterations in the direction of the transmitted light. If thin sections of bone are seen by transmitted light (passing through in the axis of the microscope,) the tissue will appear either granular or structureless, and in the laminae alternations of granular and structureless parts will be seen. But if the light be allowed to pass in one direction only, and with considerable obliquity through the specimen, then the appearance of extremely minute fibres will present itself ; and this not only in adult bone, but in the isolated cells of old and in developing young bone. They are most strongly marked over the lacunae ; to which, and to the canaliculi, a confused and broken outline is given. The fibres appear as though arranged in series of short and broken lengths, parallel, and without plaiting. If the specimen be a little out of focus there will be an appearance of reticulated fibres marked by nebulous outlines. On the other hand, if we have light passing from all sides obliquely through the preparation, that is, if the object be illuminated by a hollow cone of light, in the manner obtainable by Mr. Gillett's arrangement of achromatic condenser, or by rendering opake the centre of the lower lens of the ordinary achromatic condenser, the fibres disappear, and we see in their place a granular tissue, with a tendency here and there to a linear arrangement of the granules, and the lacunae and canaliculi clear and distinct, when well in focus, but with a fibre-like nebulosity when slightly out of focus, especially in those parts where the latter run obliquely through the specimen. This is more especially the case where the canaliculi are filled with fluid, or where they have become solid, a condition very common in the bones of old subjects. Indeed, in many specimens where the bone is not highly developed, a fibrous appearance at once strikes the eye, and it is only on careful exa- mination of the surface of the section that the illusion is dispelled by the orifices of the canaliculi appearing at the termination of the apparent fibres. Amongst a great many examples the authors have not seen an instance in which the fibrous appearance could not be traced to canaliculi, this effect being often increased by the presence of granules. If parallel dentinal tubes be viewed by a side light, in the manner we have described, each tube will throw two or three strong nebulous lines, which might be mistaken for fibres ; and if tubes cut transversly be inspected in a similar manner, each will appear to have several concentric lines extending half round it on the side opposite to that from which the light proceeds.


dark appearance ; the subsequent or secondary deposit, on the other hand, is quite transparent, and of a uni- form and homogeneous aspect, without obvious granules. This begins to cover the granular bone a very short distance (about the -g^th of an inch) below the surface of ossification, and, as already stated, increases further down. The lacunae first appear in this deposit ; there are none in the primary granular bone. In what further regards the nature and formation of the secondary deposit, my own observations lead me to differ considerably from the views of Mr. Tomes. He supposes that it is formed of cells which become impregnated with earthy matter, — the cartilage cells in the first instance, and afterwards the cells newly formed in the blastema. Now although certain appearances render it not improbable that there may be a layer of flattened and calcified cells next to the surface of the granular bone, I am nevertheless disposed to think that the subsequent and chief part of the deposit results from the calcification of successive layers of fibres generated in the blastema, and possibly derived from the granular cells, some cells being perhaps also involved along with the fibres, as in the ossifica- tion of the flat bones of the cranium : in short, it appears to me that the deposit in question is formed after the manner of intramembranous ossification already described (page 150). I infer that such is the process from the structure of the layers, for they are made up of fine reticulated fibres like the lamellae of perfect bone shown at page 143.

On this point Kolliker, oper. cit. p. 289, observes, “ Die Grundsubstanz der Knochen besteht nach Sharpey und Hassall aus einem Netzwerk feiner Fasern mit rhombischen Maschen, von welchen Fasern ich weder an frischen, noch an mit Reagentien behandelten Knochen eine Spur habe entdecken konnen. Was Arnold neulich Primitiv-fasern der Knochen nennt, sind, wie seine Abbildungen lehren, nur die Granula der Grundsubstanz, an denen er eine lineare Aneinanderreihung zu erkennen glaubt, und seine Querstreifen auf Flachenschnitten, und radiaren Linien auf Querschliffen, wenigstens die letzteren sicher, nichts als die Auslaufer der Knochenhohlen. Sollten durch irgend ein Reagens in dem Knochengewebe deutliche Fibrillen nach- gewiesen werden konnen, was mir aber noch nicht gelungen ist, so konnten dieselben wohl keine anderen sein, als diejenigen, welche in ossificirenden Knorpel das streifige Ansehen bewirken und die von Sharpey und mir bei der Knochenbildung aus dem Periost beschriebenen.


That the presence of granules imbedded in a less refractive tissue may, when viewed by a side light, give an appearance of fibres, is shown on an examination of pus-globules under similar circumstances, when each globule will seem to have a striated surface ; and that slightly rounded prominences will produce a like effect is shown in the case of some species of Navicula. The surface of these latter objects is marked by rows of slight prominences, which, when the light is oblique and passes through the specimen from one point only, appear as lines or fibres, the direction of which will change with alteration in the direction of the light ; that is to say, shadows will extend from one eminence to another in the opposite direction to that from which the light enters. If we examine the projecting spiculae of bone forming in temporary cartilage under corresponding conditions as regards light, a similar fibrous appearance will be developed.


Under these circumstances the authors are forced to the conclusion that bone substance, instead of being made up of minute reticulate fibres, is composed of granules or granular cells, imbedded in a more or less clear homogeneous or subgra- nular matrix. This subject will receive further elucidation under the head of deve- lopment. These views are supported by the appearances presented not only in deve- loping bone of young subjects, but also in the bone of adults.


Thus as regards the basement homogeneous tissue, it will be found that where lamination is highly developed, the laminae have a transparent and structureless, and a more opake and granular part, to which the former appears to be the matrix. The peripheral lamina of the Haversian systems is generally clear and free from granularity, and the internal lamina sometimes presents a similar structureless appearance. The matter which fills up the Haversian systems in the full-grown antlers of the Cervidse, affords another and a very striking example of transparent structureless osseous tissue, which in this instance is the more distinct from the absence of canaliculi in its sub- stance. Then, again, we have another instance in the clear tissue which is some- times found between the superficial Haversian systems of ordinary bone. It has already been described as a non-laminated element found on the surface of certain bones. In the instances already cited, and no doubt in many others which may be found in the skeletons of the lower vertebrata, we have bone tissue without obvious granularity and without obvious structure, and although it forms but a small part of the general mass, yet from its constant presence at all ages and in all subjects, it must be regarded as an integral and normal part of mammalian bone. The granular condition of bone tissue is tolerably obvious in all preparations, though it is much more strongly marked in some specimens than in others. The amount of the com- ponent granules varies in different parts of the same specimen, and in specimens taken from different parts of the skeleton. Thus in one situation we may see laminae with a highly granular part gradually merging into a transparent tissue, while in another the laminae may be granular throughout. Again in young bone developed in cartilage, the part between the cells becomes, highly granular ; fragments of which may be found in certain adult bones, as in the petrous portion of the temporal bone (Plate VII. fig. 16 b). Bone near the articular surface frequently presents a well-marked gra- nularity. Whether the granular and the transparent parts of bone contain different relative amounts of phosphate of lime is a question yet to be decided.

Development of Bone

Temporary cartilage, when it first appears in the embryo, consists of an aggregation of closely packed nucleated cells, which in the process of growth become separated by the development of a tissue external to them, usually designated the hyaline tissue of cartilage. At this stage of growth we have a granular cell occupying a cavity in the hyaline tissue ; at a previous period the granular cell was inclosed by an outer cell-wall, to which it formed the nucleus, but now the cell-wall has merged into the hyaline tissue, from which it can no longer be distinguished, while the granular cell contains itself one or more nuclei. In making sections of cartilage many of these granular cells escape from their cavities in the hyaline tissue, and may be seen detached and floating about in the field of the microscope. Some little confusion of terms has arisen in connexion with this part of the subject. The granular cells are not unfrequently described under the name of cartilage-nuclei containing nucleoli, while in fact they are cells capable of separation from the matrix, and are at one period the only recognisable cartilage cells. They occur singly or in groups, more frequently however two or three are extended in a line. It is proposed in the present communication to call these bodies granular cartilage cells , as distinguished from a form which the cells assume previous to ossification. Cartilage previous to its conversion into bone undergoes a rapid growth, which takes place principally in the direction of the long axis of the future bone. Each granular cell becomes divided into two by segmentation transverse to the line of ossific advance. These are again divided, and the process repeated from time to time, till in the place of a single granular cell we have a long line of cells extending from the unchanged cartilage to the point where ossification has taken place. Contemporaneously with this development of lines of cells, other changes are going on in the individual cells composing them. If we examine those situated near the advancing bone, it will be observed that the granular cells have enlarged, have become separated from each other by wide intervals, and that each has become in- vested with a thick pellucid cell-wall (Plate VIII. figs. 19 and 20). The increase in the size of the cells has occurred at the expense of the hyaline tissue, which, at those points where the rounded cells approach each other, is reduced to a thin film, although in the intervals left by the packing of the uncompressed cells it exists to a considerable amount. Here then we have a matrix containing cartilage cells composed of an outer pellucid coat, within which is a granular cell containing central nuclei, a cell consisting of three distinct parts. The nucleus existed previous to the segmentation of the granular cell, but the outer wall is the product of a subsequent development. It will be observed that growth is effected by two modes ; first, by the increase of the number of the cells ; and, secondly, by the increase of their size individually.


While these changes are going on for lengthening the shaft of a long bone, cells are being added by a somewhat similar process of division to the surface, so as to increase the diameter of the cartilage. For the development of the epiphysis the cells become multiplied on a similar principle, but instead of occurring in lines they are accumulated in oval or rounded groups*.


From this general view of the subject we will now proceed to consider in detail those conditions of cartilage which precede and prepare for its conversion into bone. These phenomena may be conveniently examined in the cartilage which connects the diaphysis and epiphysis of long bones, and we may take those of a lamb or calf, as they present the same conditions as are found in the human subject, and have the advantage over those of other domestic animals of being readily obtainable at all times without the necessity of destroying the animal for the sole purpose of physiolo- gical investigation.


At that point in the cartilage where the linear arrangement of cells commences, several of these bodies lie side by side in the same column, but by following the line downwards towards the advancing bone, it will be seen that the column usually divides, forming two or three distinct lines, in each of which the cells are arranged in single file. It does not appear that the number of cells entering into the formation of a series is at all limited ; hence the lines or columns vary in length. Neither does it appear that the consecutive lines are placed, as a rule, end to end, so as to form one long continuous straight line by the junction of several shorter ones. On the contrary, each series is complete in itself, and is generally placed a little to the one or other side of those above and below it. We have in fact interrupted lines of cells, each line the offspring of a single cell, the outer walls of which have merged into the intercellular or hyaline tissue.


Previous to the ossification of the epiphysis the cartilage at the heads of the bone is increased in its bulk from additions to the surface, by a process somewhat similar to that through which the growth of bone is effected. This process will be described when the latter subject is considered.


When the destined number of cells forming a linear series has been developed, each cell becomes itself a centre of growth. The granular cell enlarges, together with its nucleus, and becomes invested with a cell-wall. In examining a line of these bodies extending from the forming bone of the diaphysis, we shall see them in various degrees of forwardness. Thus, if attention be directed to the end of the line furthest from the bone, the cells will be found small in size, granular, and with a perceptible nucleus, but without an outer wall, distinguishable from the hyaline substance, which is abundant between the contiguous lines, but small in quantity between the cells composing the lines. But if the other end of the line be examined, very different conditions will be observed. The granular cells will be seen to have become rounded in form, to have increased to three times their original bulk, and to possess well-marked circular nuclei ; in addition to which each granular cell will have acquired a thick pellucid outer wall, while the hyaline tissue between contiguous lines of cells will have dwindled down to a thin film, excepting in those parts where spaces are necessarily left in the approximation of spherical bodies (Plate VI. figs. 19, 20). The abundance of the hyaline tissue in the earlier condition of cartilage, affords space for the development of the cells in the breadth of the bone, but in the direction of the length of the bone we find but little of that tissue, yet each component cell of the almost innumerable lines of cells that exist, even in a bone of small size, is itself a centre of growth. At the osseous end of a line, a single cell occupies more space than four or five at the opposite extremity ; and as in each situation the cells are im- bedded in hyaline tissue, it is evident that there is a concurrent growth of the latter throughout each line of cells, and also of the cells and hyaline tissue in the breadth of the cartilage. But for this provision of nature, cells would grow at the cost of those in their neighbourhood, a condition which obtains wherever space for a secondary development of bone is required, a description of which will follow in the subsequent pages of this paper. Then, again, had we concurrent growth in each cell of a series without a similar growth in all the other series, throughout the breadth of the bone, the growing series would encroach upon the cartilage in which the linear arrangement had not commenced, and ultimately unite by osseous tissue the epiphysis and diaphysis before the bone had acquired its normal length. And supposing concurrent growth to take place over the one-half of the breadth of a bone and not in the other, the bone would become curved and the limb distorted.


We have traced in temporary cartilage those changes which occur preparatory to its conversion into bone : it now remains for the authors to describe the results of their researches on the mode in which that conversion is effected, and concerning which there hitherto has been a great diversity of opinion.


Preceding ossific deposit, the intercolumnar tissue, which may not only be seen between the columns of cells, but also passing more or less perfectly between the individual cells, becomes in some cases slightly fibrous in appearance, and of a light brown colour; this condition speedily gives way to a highly granular state; in fact it has become bone, and encloses, in osseous cavities or crypts, the cartilage cells. For reasons which will hereafter be sufficiently obvious, we shall in future call these lacunal cells. If thin sections be made with a very sharp knife through ossifying cartilage, and placed in water or albumen under the quarter or eighth object-glass, we shall occasionally find lacunal cells which have escaped from their osseous crypts, floating loose in the fluid, and offering a favourable opportunity for the examination of their characters. It may then be seen that the thick pellucid outer investment has become granular, and that the enclosed granular cell has lost its regular outline, and become angular or ragged, while the nucleus has become obscured by the changes in the more external parts of the cell, an early stage of which is seen in Plate VIII. fig. 19 and 22 a. Such are the appearances presented in some of the detached lacunal cells, but they may be seen in both earlier and later stages of development than that described. Thus instances may be found where the outer coat has only a few granules on the surface, in which case the granular cell may be seen more di- stinctly, and minute elongated processes traced, extending from its surface (Plate VIII. figs. 19 and 20). In a favourable section we sometimes find such a cell with its outer coat torn, exposing to full view the granular cell, with numerous and well- marked processes extending from it. Dr. Sharpey kindly placed at the disposal of the authors the rickety bone of a child who died during the active condition of the disease. In this specimen granular cells with radiating processes can with great readiness be detached by tearing a thin section, for in this case cartilage assumed the arrangement of bone without the impregnation of earthy ingredients (Plate VIII. fig. 23)*.


The third condition, in which we may find isolated lacunal cells detached from the osseous crypts of the intercellular tissue, differs from those already described in their greater solidity. The whole mass has become highly granular, and the granular cell with its processes has united to the outer coat, so that the two can no longer be separated the one from the other, and are no longer to be recognized as distinct parts. If accidentally broken across, we see that they have a hollow centre, in fact, a lacuna ; but when loose and entire, they appear as rounded dense masses, project- ing from the surface of which we may not unfrequently detect a few short needle- like processes. Lacunal cells of the latter kind are not, however, very easily de- tached, for when they have advanced thus far in development, their union with ossified intercolumnar tissue is too strong to admit of ready separation ; indeed, after this period their separation is impossible. It has been stated that the granular cells of cartilage previous to the formation of lacunal cells send out processes. There are, however, a certain number of granular cells that do not appear to undergo this change, but preserve their state of granulation and their external figure, and show the round nucleus even after they are surrounded by and imbedded in ossified tissue. Indeed, we may find perfectly ossified crypts of intercolumnar tissue at some little depth within the forming bone, containing several of these granular cells in an unaltered condition, and this without the cavities having been enlarged by absorption of their walls (Plate VIII. fig. 19 d ). It is important to bear this point in mind, as it will sub- sequently be shown that similar granular cells lie loose in the large cavities formed by absorption, and that they are concerned in the formation of bone when that tissue is not preceded by ordinary cartilage.


  • Kolliker, oper. cit. at p. 360, describes accurately the formation of lacunae from cartilage cells in a rickety

bone, and although he has not observed the changes with equal distinctness in normal bone, appears to have satisfied himself that in the ossification of cartilage the cells of the latter become converted into lacunae. M. Kolliker does not however seem to have recognized the relation of the lacunal cells as such to the inter- cellular tissue, neither does he mention the fact that the granular cells with their long stellated processes can be separated from the investing cell-wall in the manner described in the text.


If a section of developing bone, including a little of the cartilage, be dried, and mounted in Canada balsam, we shall be able to recognize, first the cartilage with the cells greatly contracted, then the ossified intercolumnar tissue full of little crypts, from which, in the process of drying, the lacunal cells have disappeared (Plate VIII. fig.24 a ) ; and lastly, we shall see bone in which ossified lacunal cells run in lines correspond- ing to the preceding lines of cartilage cells (fig. 24 b). The latter appearance is, however, interrupted by the presence of numerous large spaces produced by the absorption of both the intercolumnar tissue and the lacunal cells (fig. 24 c), the process for the removal of which commences concurrently with the impregnation of the lacunal cells with the earthy salt.


These conditions can be also very favourably observed in sections of the long bones of a foetal lamb, taken previous to the commencement of ossification of the epiphysis, and examined in the liquor amnii ; water will not answer as a substitute for this fluid, as the cartilage cells are speedily altered in character by its presence. And we may here observe that the examination of developing bone should be con- ducted on perfectly fresh subjects, and that care should be taken to keep the knives, glass, &c., which are used in preparing the sections, perfectly free from extraneous matter; otherwise the results will be unsatisfactory. Thus a small quantity of spirits of wine or of acid will produce changes of character in the specimen, and thereby lead the observer into an erroneous conception of the normal characters of the tissue.


Hitherto the authors of this communication have spoken principally of those ap- pearances which are presented in sections made parallel with the advancing bone ; attention must now be directed to sections made across the bone, so as to cut trans- versely the lines of cartilage cells.


If, then, we take a thin section through the cartilage where ossification of the inter- cellular tissue is advancing, the following appearances will be seen. The intercellular tissue will present itself in the form of more or less perfect septa lying between and enclosing the lacunal cells, in such a manner as to produce a uniform pattern over the surface of the section (Plate VIII. fig. 20). On close inspection it will be seen that the intercellular tissue is granular, and that in each enclosure it encircles one or two lacunal cells, which in the latter case lie in contact, with the contiguous sides flattened, while the peripheral surface of the two form together a tolerably perfect circle in close contact with the intercellular tissue.


The lacunal cells are beautifully shown in the kind of section under consideration. Their circumference is becoming granular, and frequently may be seen as a perfect ring of granules in close contact with the intercellular tissue, while in the centre we see the granular cell with a well-defined nucleus, and with numerous rudimentary canaliculi, extending from the circumference of the inner cell towards the surface of the outer cell-wall. Where two cells lie in contact, the rudimentary canaliculi may sometimes be found running across from the one cell to the other. If after exami- ning such sections as may be made with a knife, we take one through the bone imme- diately below the partially ossified cartilage, rendered thin by grinding, and mount it in Canada balsam, the various points described as existing in ossifying cartilage will be seen in that which has been converted into bone. Thus we shall see the in- tercellular tissue preserving its original form, and highly granular, and that while the outer walls of the lacunal cells have become calcified, the granular cells will have assumed the form of perfect lacunae and canaliculi, the latter freely intercommu- nicating where the surface of the lacunal cells is in contact, but seldom extending into the ossified intercellular tissue. These conditions are shown in Plate VII. fig. 25.


The ossified lacunal cells, and the intercellular tissue which have existed in the temporary cartilage, and have there served their part in forming the skeleton of the foetus, are destined to have but a short existence, for we find that no sooner is the bone formed than large spaces are produced by absorption. Whole lines of ossified lacunal cells with the enclosing intercellular tissue disappear, to be replaced by more or less perfectly developed Haversian systems, which also last but for a time, when they by a similar process are removed to give place to others, or to contribute to the formation of permanent cavities. It has been well stated by Dr. Sharpey, that the long bones of the foetus are not equal in size to the medullary cavities of the correspond- ing bones of the adult. Hence as growth takes place, gradually comes the necessity for the removal of parts to make way for the development of others upon an enlarged scale.


It has been shown that primary bone, if we except two or three of the cranial bones, is merely calcified cartilage which has previously assumed the structural arrangement of bone. It is proposed to restrict the term primary bone to tissue so formed, as it will be subsequently shown that the development of Haversian systems in the spaces formed in primary bone, is effected by processes similar to those which are concerned in the growth of bone generally, and in the extension of the flat cranial bones. Age and situation no doubt modify the conditions of growth, or development of secondary bone, as it may be called, but the processes in either case are alike.


Hence, in describing the manner in which a long bone increases in diameter, we shall in fact be describing the process by which a flat cranial bone is extended. Before however going to this point the authors will state the results of their observa- tions on the subject of the absorption of bone, on that interesting and important pro- cess by which the Haversian spaces are formed out of the solid tissue of bone.


During the present winter it became necessary to remove a portion of the femur which protruded from a stump six weeks after the removal of the limb. From the medullary cavity a granulating mass projected and covered the surface of the bone left by the saw, and as the bone was rapidly wasting from the inner or medullary surface, we had in this specimen a favourable opportunity of examining the tissue which lay in immediate contact with the surface of the wasting bone. On cutting through this piece of femur in its length with a very fine jeweller's saw, it was found that a dense pale pink tissue lay in contact with the inner surface of the bone, which was hollowed with numerous minute cavities, into which the soft tissue accurately fitted, but from which it could be detached without tearing. The outer surface of the bone had been deprived of membrane many days before its removal from the limb.


The examination of the tissue thus closely applied to the fast wasting bone, offered as favourable an opportunity for learning something of the means by which absorp- tion is effected as we could reasonably expect to obtain, the more so since the outer surface having been for some time exposed and covered only by dried peri- osteum, the actions had been confined to the inner surface of the bone. A careful examination showed that the surface of this tissue was composed of minutely granular nucleated cells, which lay in close and immediate contact with the bone, and increased in an exact ratio with its diminution. What the bone lost in bulk the cells gained, the cellular mass presenting a perfect cast of the surface of the bone, suggesting to the mind that the soft was growing at the cost of the hard tissue, or at all events that the former was instrumental in the removal of the latter. The cellular mass was tolerably vascular, but the vessels did not reach the surface in contact with the bone ; hence they could not be regarded as having any immediate action in the process of absorption. Section of the bone showed that the medullary cavity had been greatly enlarged by absorption, and no doubt had sufficient time been allowed the femur at that part would have been reduced to a thin scale. A transverse section showed that in many, though not in all instances, the Haversian canals had been enlarged and rendered irregular in shape, but it was evident that the process of removal had been less active in this situation than on the medullary surface of the bone.


If we examine the fangs of temporary teeth when they are undergoing removal, similar states to those described as existing in the portion of femur will be found to obtain. A similar cellular mass will be seen to be closely applied to that surface of the tooth which is in process of removal, and the surface itself will present the characteristic emargination observed in the bone. When we connect these conditions with the fact that the nucleated cells which form the embryo have the power of appropriating the material which lies about them to the purpose of their own growth and their conversion into the various animal tissues, it is difficult to resist the belief that the cells which lie in contact with wasting bone and dentine, take up those tissues and use all or part of their element for the purposes of their own increase or multiplication, or else form a medium through which they are passed into the cir- culation. But as the process of absorption with concurrent development of cells is most active in primary bone where but few vessels exist, the former hypothesis seems the more probable. An objection may be raised to the supposition, that the bone is absorbed by the cells, on the ground of the density of the former; but it must be borne in mind, that as the density is gradually imparted to the bone through the agency of the adjoining soft parts, there seems no good reason for disbelieving that they may also be instrumental in its removal.

Growth of Bone

Under this head will be described the extension of flat bones, the increase in the diameter of cylindrical bones, and the development of Haversian systems.


If the advancing edge of a parietal bone be taken either from a human foetus or a foetal lamb, and the pericranium and dura mater be carefully removed from their respective surfaces, we shall find the growing bone still invested with soft tissue both on the outer and inner surface, which is prolonged from the free edge. When exa- mined under a favourable light this tissue will show differences of character in dif- ferent parts, varying with the distance from the bone at which the observations are made. Thus, if attention be directed to the part furthest removed from the bone, it will be seen that the membrane-like mass is composed of oval cells with slight prolongations from the extremities, which are frequently arranged in the form of bands of fibrous tissue (Plate VIII. fig. 26). Dr.SHARPEY has observed that the membrane into which the bone extends is like fibrous tissue in an early stage of development*, and this observation is strictly true when confined to the part indicated, but the analogy ceases as we extend our examination towards the bone. Here in the place of cells witheiongated processes, or cells arranged in fibre-like lines, we find cells aggregated into a mass, and so closely packed as to leave little room for intermediate tissue. The cells appear to have increased in size at the cost of the processes which existed at an earlier stage of development, and formed a bond of union between them. Everywhere about growing bone a careful examination will reveal cells attached to its surface, while the surface of the bone itself will present a series of similar bodies ossified (Plate IX. figs. 27, 28 and 29). To these we propose to give the name of osteal cells, as distinguished from lacunal and other cells.


  • Mr. Quain and Dr. Sharpey, oper. cit. cxlix. and page clix. Dr. Sharpby says, “ When further examined

with a higher magnifying power, the tissue or membrane in which ossification is proceeding, appears to be made up of fibres and granular corpuscles, with a soft amorphous or faintly granular uniting matter. The fibres have the character of the white fibres, or rather fasciculi of the cellular or fibrous tissue, and are similarly affected by acetic acid. The corpuscles are for the most part true cells with an envelope and granular contents ; some about the size of blood-particles, but many of them two or three times larger. In certain parts the fibres, but in most the corpuscles predominate, and on the whole the structure may be said to be not unlike that of fibrous tissue in an early stage of development.” Kolliker, oper. cit. p. 289, confirms Dr. Sharpey's statement, but denies that a fibrous arrangement can be traced in formed bone.


In microscopic characters the osteal cells closely resemble the granular cells of temporary cartilage, so closely indeed, that the latter when detached from the car- tilage could not well be distinguished from them. They are for the most part sphe- rical or oval in form, and lie on the surface of the growing bone in a crowded mass, held together by an intervening and apparently structureless matrix (Plate IX. fig. 27 b). Here and there we find a cell which has accumulated about itself an outer investment of transparent tissue, and has in fact become developed into a lacunal cell destined to become a lacuna*. These points are illustrated in fig. 29 b.


The process of growth may be thus described. In the meshes of the fibrous tissue on the surface of the bone osteal cells are developed and gradually take its place ; a few cells become developed into lacunal cells ; the earthy salts are added, and con- currently lacunae and canaliculi are formed ; we then have bone presenting the usual characters of that tissue*. In bone developed in the foregoing manner, we find the canaliculi not merely extending to the surface of the cell-wall, or anastomosing with the canaliculi of lacunal cells lying in contact with it, but extending freely in all direc- tions and passing through or amongst the ossified cells, and establishing rich plexuses of anastomosis. Indeed we see the boundary of the original lacunal cells only in those cases where the lacunae have but few, or are entirely devoid of canaliculi. It would appear to be a law, to which there are few if any exceptions, that when anastomosis is established between adjoining lacunae, the lacunal cells blend with the contiguous parts, and are no longer recognisable as distinct bodies. The process by which the cylindrical bones are increased in diameter is in all essential points similar to that described as pertaining to the growth of flat bones. Similar osteal and lacunal cells are present, but the relative amount of the matrix is greater ; moreover the osteal cells have a disposition to assume a linear arrangement corresponding to the direction of the laminse of the contiguous bone. In these lines the cells are placed so close to each other as to leave but little room for intervening tissue, but between the lines an appreciable amount may be recognized (Plate IX. fig. 31). This appearance however varies in different specimens. In one the cells predominate, in another the transparent tissue is the more abundant. Generally the younger the animal the greater will be the amount of the intervening transparent tissue, and the smaller the number of the osteal cells. But in all cases, whatever the age of the subject, or from whatever part of the skeleton the specimen be taken, the cells and the intermediate tissue become blended in the process of ossification, and the whole presents a uniform granular appearance, excepting in the instances in which lamination is strongly developed, or in those which have been noticed in the previous part of the paper. We frequently find portions of bone where the osteal cells, lacunal cells, and intermediate tissue are so perfectly fused together that neither can be recognized, but in their place we have a minutely granular mass, divisible only into lacunae and canaliculi and the tissue in which they lie imbedded. In Plate IX. fig. 32, taken from the tibia of a foetal lamb, the osteal and lacunal cells have become blended to a considerable extent, but without the occurrence of lamination. The lamina which is represented at the margin is com- posed of still uncalcified cells. It shows the mode in which the undulating laminae are formed. Fig. 33 also, taken from the fibula of a calf, shows ossified lacunal and osteal cells without any tendency to lamination.


  • The various views which have been entertained regarding the formation of the lacunae and canaliculi have

been concisely stated by Dr. Sharpey, oper. cit. p. 158. He observes, that “ they are generally supposed to be derived from the cells of the soft tissue involved in the ossification hy some sort of metamorphosis which has been variously conceived. Some suppose that the cells become the lacuna and send out branches (like the pigment cells) to form the canaliculi (Schwann 1 )- Others think that it is not the cell but its nucleus that undergoes this change, and that the substance of the nucleus is afterwards absorbed, leaving the lacuna (Todd and Bowman 2 ).” The nucleus described by Todd and Bowman is identical with that which in this communication is called the granular cell, and from which the authors have shown the lacuna is formed. “Henle 3 thinks that the lacuna is a cavity left in the centre of a cell which has been partially filled up by calcification, and that the canaliculi are branched passages, also left in consequence of the unequal deposition of the hard matter, as in the instance of the pore cells of plants.” “ It rather appears to me as if the lacunae and canali- culi were little varieties left in the tissue during the deposition of the reticular fibres, as open figures are left out in the weaving of some artificial fabrics (but not within a cell, as Henle imagined), and that thus the appo- sition of the minute apertures existing between the reticulations of the lamellae gives rise to the canaliculi.” “ At the same time it seems not unlikely that a cell or a cell-nucleus may originally lie in the lacuna or central cavity, and may perhaps determine the place of its formation.” Hassall 4 agrees with Schwann, while Gerber 5 and Bruns 5 appear to hold the views of Todd and Bowman. With the exception of Dr. Sharpey, the above- named authorities may perhaps differ more in the use of terms than in matter of fact. The appearances represented in figs. 14 and 27 would at first view seem to justify the opinion expressed by Dr. Sharpey, but a careful examination of the tissue during its development, the unquestionable fact that in the development from cartilage the granular cell becomes converted into a lacuna, together with the circumstance that lacunal cells are frequently found in the Haversian canals and cancellated structure, especially in the bones of old sub- jects, and at times imbedded in the structure of the bone, have left no room for doubt in the authors' minds that the lacunae are formed from' special nucleated cells, in the manner described in the text.

1 Mikroscopische Untersuchungen. 2 Physiological Anatomy. 3 Anatomie Generate.

4 Microscopic Anatomy of the Human Body, p. 310. 5 Allgemeine Anatomie.


When speaking of the growth of cartilage, it was stated that the bulk of that tissue at the epiphysis increased laterally by the division of the cells, but the fact that it also increased on the free surface of the greatly enlarged cartilaginous epiphysis of the fcetus by a process similar to that by which the diameter of bones is increased, was reserved to be described in connection with the latter subject. If a longitudinal section be taken from the epiphysis of a foetal long bone, including some portion of the perichondrium, it will be seen that the cartilage passes gradually into a more or less fibrous tissue, which forms the exterior of the part. Amongst the fibres will be found numerous elongated cells, which on tracing the specimen inwards will be seen to be similar to the cartilage cells at and near the surface of the tissue, while the fibres will be seen to give way to or become converted into hyaline tissue, as shown in Plate IX. fig. 30, in which the cartilage is indicated at a, and the cells included in the fibrous tissue at b.


The manner in which the Haversian spaces become gradually occupied by Haver- sian systems is peculiarly interesting. To obtain a good view of the process, it is necessary to make a transverse section of the developing systems. It may then be seen that osteal cells arrange themselves in single file within the Haversian space with intermediate lines of transparent tissue, and here and there a lacunal cell ; the process commencing at the surface of the Haversian space, and extending gradually inwards till the system is completed. In fact the soft tissue takes the permanent form previous to the addition of the salts of bone, much in the same manner and to the same degree as occurs in temporary cartilage before the earthy ingredients are deposited. Lamination is nothing more than a definite linear arrangement of the osteal cells with their outlines permanently retained in the perfected bone ; a character much more strongly marked in the bones of adult than in those of young animals.


In pursuing their inquiries into the growth of bone, the authors found it necessary to take sections of perfectly fresh bone and to examine them in albuminous fluid; spirits of wine, whether diluted or not, obscures the normal appearances, and water is not more favourable as a medium.


Sections permanently mounted in dilute spirit lose a good deal of their character; still the appearances are preserved with more or less of their original distinctness. Sections mounted in Canada balsam show some of the points remarkably well. For instance, the partially ossified osteal and lacunal cells are tolerably well preserved, but unfortunately those cells which have not received any of the indurating salts are repre- sented only by a transparent mass, in which but little structure can be recognized ; thus, the part b in fig. 32 would have appeared but as a transparent line had the specimen been mounted in Canada balsam. In addition to the necessity for care in the examination of osseous structures, under the most favourable circumstances, as regards the selection of specimens and the fluid used in their preparation, it is equally necessary to have the more recent appliances for the illumination of the objects.


Mr. Gillett's achromatic condenser, with what is called the white cloud illuminator, renders it very easy to demonstrate points which with the ordinary miscroscopic apparatus are shown with difficulty. It need not however be urged, that it is desirable in pursuing structural anatomy to avail ourselves of the most perfect instru- ments that can be obtained. It is proper that the authors should, before leaving this part of the subject, draw some comparison between the development of bone in cartilage and in the softer tissues.


Temporary cartilage, previous to the development of bone, affords a mechanical support and protection to the surrounding or enclosed softer tissues. These offices could not be rendered by a mere aggregation of soft cells, but are efficiently per- formed by the dense intercellular substance, which forms so characteristic a feature of the cartilage. Hence in the mechanical function of cartilage the intercellular element of the tissue must be regarded as the most important.


A second, and scarcely less important purpose effected by temporary cartilage, is that of affording a medium for which a more solid tissue may be substituted, without the mechanical support being withdrawn from the adjoining parts during the process of change. It affords also a means by which the long bones are gradu- ally increased in length, without any interference with the functions of the limb. These changes are brought about by the gradual increase in the number of the carti- lage cells, at those parts only where ossification is about to commence, and by the conversion of the cells into lacunal cells, at the cost of the intercellular tissue, which, whilst its bulk is diminishing, becomes impregnated with the earthy salts ; so that although the quantity is lessened, the strength of that which remains is increased. Now, in examining the process by which growing bones are enlarged, it must be borne in mind that the mechanical function of the cartilage is performed by the bone which has replaced it, and that no such office is required of the new tissue which is gradually adding to the bulk of the bone. The necessity for a dense inter- cellular tissue no longer exists. Hence we have an aggregation of osteal cells with so much only of intercellular tissue as will serve to connect them into a mass. A certain number of these cells, by additions to their exterior, become lacunal cells. We have then in the place of lacunal cells and dense intercolumnar tissue, lacunal and osteal cells united by a small and almost imperceptible amount of a semifluid intercellular medium ; the relative proportions of these several parts varying a little with differences of age. Thus in aged subjects aggregations of lacunal cells may here and there be found with but few osteal cells and but little intercellular tissue, while in a young subject osteal cells will preponderate.


In all cases a direction may be given to the cells of a growing part, by their being in relation with the insertion of a tendon.


A consideration of the foregoing facts will, we think, lead to a conviction that the two different forms in which bone is developed, are designed to meet the require- ments of the animal at different periods of life, and that bone developed by means of osteal and lacunal cells is the higher form of the tissue. In early embryonic life a soft cartilaginous skeleton is laid down, which is hard as compared with the sur- rounding parts, and capable of affording them the required amount of mechanical support. As the various tissues advance in development the cartilage increases in density by the elaboration of its hyaline tissue, and after awhile those changes occur which precede its conversion into bone. But in the bone so formed, it has been shown that the canaliculi anastomose only at those points where the lacunal cells come into contact (Plate VIII. fig. 25). In bone formed from osteal and lacunal cells, the ana- stomosis of the canaliculi prevails throughout the tissue, while the outline of the formative cells is almost entirely lost in the general blending of the whole into a subgranular mass subject to lamination, in the manner already described.


It will therefore be in accordance with the preceding views, to regard the inter- columnar tissue present in primary bone, rather as an accessory element calculated to give support during the ossification of the lacunal cells, than as an integral and necessary element of osseous tissue ; for it has been shown that it offers an obstruc- tion to the anastomosis of the canaliculi, and that the lacunal cells preserve their outline so long as they are enclosed within it, instead of becoming lost in the sur- rounding tissue, as occurs in secondary bone. It must not, however, be forgotten that small patches of ossified intercolumnar tissue may here and there be found between the Haversian systems, even in the bone of old subjects (Plate VII. fig. 16) ; so that its presence in a small amount, (as accidentally left when the Haversian spaces are forming), is not incompatible with the normal condition of perfect bone.


It may also be stated in this place, that the undulating laminse formed on the sur- face of growing bone, although for the most part removed to make way for Haversian systems, are also found here and there in small patches in the bones of adults.


The subject of absorption, as it relates to the removal of bone, has already been partly discussed, but something more remains to be said. Although the process of absorption has not, and probably cannot be seen in actual operation, yet a con- sideration of the relative position of the increasing and wasting parts, and of then- conditions, will, in the authors' opinion, justify the conclusion that the bone is re- moved through the agency of cells.


In seeking to find the circumstances under which the absorption of bone takes place most rapidly, and to the greatest extent, the authors have been led to examine bones which had been placed in various conditions, both of health and disease. It has been already stated that bone developed in cartilage is speedily removed ; but it does not seem that bone formed by osteal and lacunal cells is absorbed with equal rapidity, although in the course of a short time it not less surely disappears. This difference in the rate of absorption is probably the result of the vascularity and higher state of development of the latter tissue. In bone developed in cartilage Haversian spaces have to be formed before it can be permeated by vessels; hence in this tissue absorption proceeds rapidly, the process being established as soon as the bone is formed. In adult bone, when in a normal condition, we find here and there an Haversian space ; but if a bone around which the soft parts are in a state of inflam- mation be examined, numerous Haversian spaces will be seen. If we examine the same bone in the neighbourhood of that part where the inflamed is merging into the healthy investing texture, we shall find new osseous matter in the process of depo- sition on the surface of the pre-existing bone. Examples of this may frequently be found in the vicinity of diseased joints.


We have here an instance of the development of new tissue, and the removal of a pre-existing one being set in operation, by what would appear to be a different degree only of the same action. Hence a more particular examination of the cellular mass, by which bone appears to be absorbed in the one case and deposited in the other, naturally suggests itself, and attention has been directed to this point as frequently as favourable opportunities for observation have presented themselves. The differ- ences, however, in microscopic characters between the two tissues, have not been so strongly marked, as to admit of any definite description being given, by which the one may, in all instances, be distinguished from the other, when removed from their natural positions, as is almost necessarily the case with regard to the absorbent cells, from the readiness with which they separate from the wasting bone (Plate IX. figs. 27 and 34).


Lacunal cells moreover will not be found in the absorbing tissue ; but it is not easy to recognize them, even in the tissue from which bone is developing, as they are frequently obscured by the osteal cells ; so that their presence, although a good ground of distinction, cannot in all instances be demonstrated. When, however, developmental cells are seen in situ, their character is readily distinguished. They are closely applied to the surface of the increasing bone, which loses the festooned and assumes an even outline, to which the osteal cells adhere.


The source from which the cells destined for effecting absorption arise is at present unknown to the authors, any further than that they arise in connection with soft tissues, the three situations in which they occur being beneath the periosteum or medullary membrane, or within an Haversian canal. These are no doubt the points from which the development of the cells starts, but the law which regulates their occurrence at one part rather than another, and gives to them their peculiar function, is at present unexplained. Neither is it more easy to understand why, at a parti- cular period, the process of absorption is arrested and development of new tissue com- mences ; the new bone may, for anything we have seen to the contrary, be formed from the same cells that have been concerned in the removal of the old. The organ by which the fangs of teeth are absorbed offers a very favourable object for examination.


This we find to commence within or beneath the periosteum which covers the fang of the tooth, and increases with the wasting of the tooth, until it comes in contact with the pulp, which then assumes a similar function and becomes an absorbing organ, increasing gradually in size, till, if the tooth be left undisturbed, but little of the crown remains excepting the enamel. If, when in this condition, the crown of the tooth be carefully removed, we shall see the absorbent papillae projecting a little above the gum, firm in substance, and not disposed to bleed unless rudely handled. Within two or three days it becomes covered with epithelium, either by the exten- sion of the epithelial membrane from the surrounding parts, or from a change in character in the superficial cells of the part itself*. Gradually the papilla loses its distinctness of outline and merges into the surrounding gum, from which it can no longer be distinguished. Here then we have a second instance in which an ab- sorbent tissue has its function finally suspended, and a new one substituted. In the place of increasing at the cost of pre-existing tissue, growth is suspended, and it unites with and assumes a similar office to that of the surrounding gum.


  • In the 26th volume of the Medico-Chirurgical Transactions, there is a short paper by Mr. Dalrymple, in which he describes a small tumour from the eyelid, consisting essentially of epithelial cells, in which the ordinary contents had been replaced by ossific matter.


In conclusion, the authors may allude to an interesting fact, with reference to the subject of absorption, which has been recently observed by Mr. Stanley and subse- quently by Mr. Bowman. In the treatment of ununited fracture, the practice has of late been successfully adopted of drilling cylindrical holes into the bone in the neigh- bourhood of the injury, and of driving in pegs of ivory, accurately fitted to the per- forations, for the purpose of setting up action in their vicinity. These pegs, after remaining in the bone several weeks, have been removed, and have been found on inspection to present erosions similar to those which are seen on absorbing bone or tooth. In fact, they closely resemble the fangs of temporary teeth recently attacked by absorption. Mr. Bowman kindly placed at the disposal of the authors one of the pegs which had been used for this purpose, a section of which presents, at the parts eroded, in its microscopic characters, the usual emarginated outline so frequently alluded to in the foregoing pages. They have not however had the opportunity of investigating the condition of the tissues around the pegs; but it is exceedingly probable that absorption has in these cases been effected by processes similar to those which occur in the formation of Haversian spaces.


Explanation of the Plates

Plate VI

Fig. 1. Transverse section of compact bone, showing the ordinary appearances.

a. Haversian system, b. Interstitial laminae, c. A new Haversian system within an older one, the Haversian canal obliterated by the development of a lacunal cell.

Fig. 2. Transverse section of compact bone, showing an Haversian space, with its characteristic emarginated outline.

Fig. 3. The same, from a less compact part of the bone, from a man aged fifty-six.

Fig. 4. Transverse section from the fibula of a child two years old, showing the general characters of bone in young subjects, a. Haversian space.

Fig. 5. Section of compact bone, showing several Haversian systems enclosed within a single series of laminee. a. A lacunal cell attached to the surface of an Haversian canal.

Fig. 6. Section showing the characters of a new Haversian system, developed within an older one.


Fig. 7- An excentric Haversian system, illustrating the arrangement of the laminae. Fig. 8. a. Lamination of bone, as it appears under a low power, b. The same highly magnified, showing the lines of osteal cells and the intermediate transpa- rent tissue.


Plate VII

Fig. 9. Transverse section of a stag's antler, after shedding, showing the transparent tissue which lines the Haversian canals.

Fig. 10. Section showing the circumferential laminae, perforated by an Haversian system.

Fig. 11. Section showing the orifices of the canaliouli, with their parietes.

Fig. 12. Sections from rickety bone. a. Consolidated lacunae, b. Laeunal cells, from which no canaliculi have proceeded.

Fig. 13. Section showing circumferential laminae, with elongated canals passing amongst the lacunae and canaliculi.

Fig. 14. Section of fossil bone, from the Wealden, supposed to be Pterodactyle, in which the nuclei have been preserved by fossilization.

Fig. 15. Ossified laeunal cells, from the spongy portion of a bone of an old subject.

Fig. 16. Section from the petrous portion of a temporal bone of an adult, a. Laeunal cells, containing lacunae and canaliculi. b. Intercellular granular tissue, similar to that found in bone developed in cartilage.

Fig. 17. Section showing ossified articular cartilage, a. Lacuna developed from a cartilage cell. b. Lines of granules.

Fig. 18. Section from an incus in a subject aged seventy-five, showing osteal and laeunal cells on the surface.


Plate VIII

Fig. 19. Longitudinal section of ossifying temporary cartilage, showing — a. Ossified intercolumnar tissue, b. Laeunal cells, c. Granular cells in process of conversion into lacunae, d. Laeunal cells imbedded in ossified interco- lumnar tissue, without conversion into lacunae.

Fig. 20. Transverse section of ossifying cartilage from femur of a child, fourteen days old. a. Intercolumnar tissue, b. Laeunal cell. c. Similar cell, with granular cell in process of conversion into a lacuna.

Fig. 21. Section from femur of same subject, taken a little way below the ossifying cartilage.

Fig. 22. A longitudinal section of new bone, a little further advanced than in fig. 19.

a. A detached laeunal cell, showing the three parts of which these bodies are composed.


Fig. 23. Fig. 24.


Fig. 25. Fig. 26.


Fig. 27.

Fig. 28. Fig. 29. Fig. 30.

Fig. 31.

Fig. 32.


Fig. 33. Fig. 34.


From rickety bone. a. Lacunal cells, b. A detached granular cell in process of conversion into a lacuna.

Longitudinal section of developing bone from the tibia of a calf, mounted in Canada balsam, a. Intercolumnar tissue, from which the lacunal cells have disappeared, b. Ossified intercolumnar tissue and lacunal cells, c. Space produced by absorption, d. Haversian system in process of formation.

Transverse section of same, taken at level of b in fig. 24. a. Intercolumnar tissue, b. Ossified lacunal cell. c. Secondary bone.

Arrangement of cells and fibres in the neighbourhood of developing parietal bone.

Plate IX

Advancing spicula of bone, from parietal bone of foetal lamb. a. Developed bone, showing its cellular character, b. Osteal cells arranged around the bone previous to their calcification.

From the epiphysis of the long bone of a calf, showing osteal and lacunal cells.

From the parietal of a human foetus, showing osteal and lacunal cells, occu- pying the space betwixt two advancing spiculse of bone.

Longitudinal section of cartilage with epichondrium attached, a. The developed cartilage, b. Fibres of perichondrium, with cells of a similar character to those of the cartilage.

Circumferential laminae of human tibia, showing the manner in which the laminae are developed from osteal cells, b. A compound cell, the origin ? of the osteal cells.

From the tibia of a foetal lamb. a. Developed bone, showing the cellular character, b. Undulating lamina in process of development, and con- taining lacunal cells, c. Osteal cells, not yet arranged. At d is shown an Haversian space, enclosed in the advancing ossification, while at e the laminae are approaching towards one another to enclose a space.

Fig. 20. From the fibula of a calf, showing growth on the external surface.

Fig. 29. From an inflamed femur, showing absorption, with the cells contained in the Haversian space.





Cite this page: Hill, M.A. (2021, June 24) Embryology Paper - Observations on the structure and development of bone. Retrieved from https://embryology.med.unsw.edu.au/embryology/index.php/Paper_-_Observations_on_the_structure_and_development_of_bone

What Links Here?
© Dr Mark Hill 2021, UNSW Embryology ISBN: 978 0 7334 2609 4 - UNSW CRICOS Provider Code No. 00098G