Difference between revisions of "Journal of Morphology 20 (1909)"

From Embryology
Line 112: Line 112:
===No. 3.— November, 1909===
===No. 3.— November, 1909===
I. William A. Hilton.
I. William A. Hilton. General Features of the Early Development of Desniognathns Fnsca .... 533-548
General Features of the Early Development of
Desniognathns Fnsca .... 533-548
Tlie (Columella A avis in Amphihia. Second Con trihntiou 549-628
II. B. r. KiNGSRURY AND LI. D. ReEI). The (Columella A avis in Amphihia. Second Contrihntiou 549-628

Latest revision as of 20:21, 21 May 2020

Embryology - 7 Jun 2020    Facebook link Pinterest link Twitter link  Expand to Translate  
Google Translate - select your language from the list shown below (this will open a new external page)

العربية | català | 中文 | 中國傳統的 | français | Deutsche | עִברִית | हिंदी | bahasa Indonesia | italiano | 日本語 | 한국어 | မြန်မာ | Pilipino | Polskie | português | ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਦੇ | Română | русский | Español | Swahili | Svensk | ไทย | Türkçe | اردو | ייִדיש | Tiếng Việt    These external translations are automated and may not be accurate. (More? About Translations)

A personal message from Dr Mark Hill (May 2020)  
Mark Hill.jpg
I have decided to take early retirement in September 2020. During the many years online I have received wonderful feedback from many readers, researchers and students interested in human embryology. I especially thank my research collaborators and contributors to the site. The good news is Embryology will remain online and I will continue my association with UNSW Australia. I look forward to updating and including the many exciting new discoveries in Embryology!
Historic Disclaimer - information about historic embryology pages 
Mark Hill.jpg
Pages where the terms "Historic" (textbooks, papers, people, recommendations) appear on this site, and sections within pages where this disclaimer appears, indicate that the content and scientific understanding are specific to the time of publication. This means that while some scientific descriptions are still accurate, the terminology and interpretation of the developmental mechanisms reflect the understanding at the time of original publication and those of the preceding periods, these terms, interpretations and recommendations may not reflect our current scientific understanding.     (More? Embryology History | Historic Embryology Papers)

Journal of Morphology 20 (1909)

J Morphol. : 1 - 1887 | 2 - 1888-89 | 3 - 1889 | 4 - 1890 | 5 - 1891 | 6 - 1892 | 7 - 1892 | 8 - 1893 | 9 - 1894 | 10 - 1895 | 11 - 1895 | 12 - 1896 | 13 - 1897 | 14 - 1897-98 | 15 - 1898 | 16 - 1899-1900 | 17 - 1901 | 18 - 1903 | 19 - 1908 | 20 - 1909 | 21 - 1910 | 22 - 1911 | 23 - 1912 | 24 - 1913 | 25 - 1914 | 26 - 1915 | 27 - 1916 | 28 - 1916-17 | 29 - 1917 | 30 - 1917-18 | 31 - 1918 | 32 - 1918 | 33 - 1919-20 | 34 - 1920 | 35 - 1921 | 36 - 1921-22 | 40 - 1928 | 47 - 1929 | 51 - 1931 | 52 - 1931 |
Historic Journals: Amer. J Anat. | Am J Pathol. | Anat. Rec. | J Morphol. | J Anat. | J Comp. Neurol. | Johns Hopkins Med. J | Ref. Handb. Med. Sci. | J Exp. Zool.
Links: Historic Journals | Historic Embryology Papers


EuwARD Phelps Allis, Jr. Milwaukee

Edwin G. Conklin

Princeton University

Henry H. Donaldson

Tlie Wistar Institute

Milton J. Greenman

The Wistar Institute

Koss G. Harrison

Yale University

G. Carl Huber

University of Michigan

Horace Jayne

The Wistar Institute

Frank R. Lillie

University of Chicago

Franklin P. Mall

Johns Hopkins University

Charles S. Minot

Harvard University

Thomas H. Morgan

Columbia University

George H. Parker

Harvard University

Charles O. AVhitman

University of Chicago

p]DMUND B. Wilson

Columbia University





No. 1.— APRIL, 1909

I. Mary Blount. The Early Development of the Pigeon s Egg, with Especial Reference to Polyspermy and the Origin of the Perihlast Nuclei 1-64

II. J. Trios. Patterson. Gastrulation in the Pigeons Egg. A Morphological and Experimental Study 65-124

III. William A. Kepnee. Nutrition of the Ovum of Scolia Diihia 125-144

IV. Inez WmrPLE Wilder. The Lateral Nasal Glands of Aniplbiuma 145-170

No. 2.— July, 1909

I. O. P. Dellingee. The Cilium as a Key to the Structure of Contractile Protoplas)n 171-210

II. Chaeles Lincoln Edwards. The Development of Ilolothuria Floridana, Pourtales, ivith Especial Reference to the Amhulacral Appendages 211-2:^)0

III. Robert William ITegnee. The Origin and Early History of the Germ-Cells in Some ChrysomeUd Beetles 231-296

IV. Tiios. II. MoNTGO]\rERY^ Jr. The Development of Theridium, an Ara)iead, up to the Stage of Reversion 297-;352

No. 3.— October. 1909

I. Naohide Yatsu. Observations on Ookinesw in Cerehratalus Lacteus 353-402

II. Walter Meek. Structure of Li in ut us Heart Muscle 403-412

III. A. E. Lambert. History of the Proceplicdic Lohes of Epeira Cinerea 413-460

IV. M. Louise Nichols. Comparative Studies in Crustacean Spermatogenesis 461-478

V. Howard Edwiis^ Enders. A Study of the Life History and Habits of ChMopterus Variopedatus, Benier et Claparede . . 479-532

No. 3.— November, 1909

I. William A. Hilton. General Features of the Early Development of Desniognathns Fnsca .... 533-548

II. B. r. KiNGSRURY AND LI. D. ReEI). The (Columella A avis in Amphihia. Second Contrihntiou 549-628



With 54 Figures.



Introduction 2

Value of the Material 2

Amount of Material 2

Acknowledgments 3

I. Methods 3

II, Distribution of nuclei during the lirst fourteen hours after fertiliza tioin. Illustrated by charts 4

III. Polyspermy 19

(a) Polyspermy in Bryozoa, and Bonnevie's explanation of Poly spermy 19

(b) Polyspermy in Holothuroidea 21

(c) Polyspermy in Insects 21

(d) Polyspermy in Selachians 21

Eiickert's explanation for the migration of the supernumerary

sperms 22

(e) Polyspermy in the Newt 23

(f ) Polyspermy in Reptiles 23

(g) Polyspermy in Birds 23

(h) Tlie cause of the migration of the supernumerary sperm nuclei

in the pigeon 24

(i) Polyspermy in Plants, — Ephedra 26

(j) Accessory cleavage and segn)entatiou of egg fragments 27

(Iv) "luwandering Follicular Cells" 27

(1) Evidence of the disappearance of the supernumerary nuclei in the

pigeon and comparison with other meroblastic vertebrate eggs 30

(m) Function of the supernumerary sperms 33

IV. Area of Primary Cleavage 35

(a) Maturation Stage 35

(b) Direction of the First Cleavage Plane 35

(c) The 4-celled stage 37

Asymmetry 37

(d) The 8-celled and later stages 41

V. The Segmentation Cavity 46

Description by Duval 46

Description by Kolliker 47

^A dissertation submitted to the faculty of the Ogden Graduate School of Science, University of Chicago, in candidacy for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy.

Tlie SesiiK'ntiitioii (":ivil.v in the pi.ixcon's cks" is hoinologons with that

of other vertebrate egj?s 48

VI. Tht> I'eriblast of the Bird's E^jl; compared with the vegetative pole of

holohlastio vertebrate eggs 49

►Smmiiary 52

Literature 58


The history of the early development of the bird's egg has been obscure because of the difficulty of obtaining abundant material in a close series of consecutive stages. On account of the regular egg laying habits of pigeons and because they breed readily in confinement, they offer invaluable material to the student of bird embryology.

The pigeon lays two eggs. The first is laid about 4.30 or 5.00 o'clock in the afternoon. About eight o'clock in the evening of the same day the second egg leaves the ovary and is fertilized at that time. It is laid about 1.00 or 1.30 p. m. of the second day following the time of laying of the first egg; that is, it is laid about forty -one hours after fertilization. It is evident that after the first egg is laid, the pigeon may be killed and the second egg obtained in any desired stage.

These facts were published by Dr. E. TI. Harper ('04) in his thesis on The Fertilization and Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg." In regard to ovulation, Dr. Harper says (p. 352), "In all cases observed, this has taken place between seven and nine o'clock." In this paper I shall refer to eight o'clock in the evening as the ai)proximate time of fertilization, although the exact time for any particular egg is not known.

Some of the results of my research were published in a preliminary paper in the Biological Bulletin, October, 1907.

For this research, one hundred and forty-four eggs have been obtained, covering the period required for the egg to pass through the oviduct. Of these, there is an egg for every hour, with more abundant material at critical stages. The present thesis refers especially to the first fifteen hours after fertilization. Problems in later oviducal development are reserved for publication at some future time.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 3

My thanks are dne to Professor Whitman and other members of the Department of Zoology for a fellowship and an assistantship, which has made it possible for me to carry on this research. Professor F. R. Lillie, who suggested the problem, has followed the work with helpful interest, and I am particularly indebted to him. Professor W. L. Tower has given indispensable help in the technique of photography, and Professor C. M. Child has helped me with some literature. Figs. 5, 6, 9, 11 and 14 are the work of Mr. Kenji Toda.

I. Methods. Following the methods of workers who have preceded me, the blastoderm has been killed and hardened on the yolk and the orientation marked with a bristle. Immediatelv after a window has been

b Fig. 1. — Diagram to show the method of marking the orientation. The

arrow indicates the direction of the axis of the future embryo, b, bristle.

made through the shell, a bristle is inserted in the side of the yolk toward the blunt pole of the shell. Later (usually when the egg is in 70 per cent alcohol) a iive-sided piece, including the blastoderm, is cut out from the yolk. One side of the five-sided area is perpendicular to the chalazal axis and is toward the large pole of the egg. Two sides are parallel to each other and to the chalazal axis, and the last two sides meet in a sharp angle pointed toward the small pole of the egg. Fig. 1 explains this orientation, the anterior side of the blastoderm being toward the point of the arrow. This fivesided block is easily seen in the paraffin cake for orientation in cutting. In some eggs there is little difference between the blunt and sharp poles of the shell, and in these the orientation is uncertain after the egg has been taken out of the oviduct. While the egg

4 Mary Blount.

is passing tliroiigh tlie oviduct, the small end is directed posteriorly. I have taken the precaution to indicate by a pencil mark on the shell the orientation of the egg in the oviduct. Or, if it was obtained before the formation of the shell, the orientation was marked with a bristle inserted into the yolk before the egg was removed from the oviduct.

As for killing fluids, I have used Kleinenberg's picro-sulphuric acid (strong solution) plus ten per cent acetic acid more than any other. Flemming's fluid is good for surface views, but not for material which is to be sectioned.

Most of my material has been imbedded in paraffin according to the ordinary method, but there has been great difficulty in cutting. In the last part of my work, I have had better success with rubber paraffin — the method described by Johnston ('03). The sections have been cut usually 6 microns.

Formalin (three or five per cent) has been favorable for killing those eggs that were to be used as whole mounts. With Conklin's hsematoxylin stain they present considerable differentiation in different regions of the blastoderm.

In photograi^hing the eggs, an arc light has ])een used for illumination. Sometimes the eggs have been removed from the shell and albumen and placed in a dish of salt solution. Others have been photographed in formalin after having been, removed from the egg envelopes. In a few cases the egg was left in the shell, through which a window was made in order to expose the blastoderm. Of course, when the egg is in this position, it is difficult to get sufficient light directed down into the egg and onto the blastoderm. One cannot be sure that such a photograph shows all of the accessory cleavage, and other details. The magnification was obtained by photographing through a microscope with ISTo. 1 Leitz ocular, and No. 2 Leitz objective.

II. Distribution of jSTuclei During the First Fourteen Hours After Fertilization.

In the surface view of a pigeon egg in the maturation stage, two areas are more or less distinct. They were figured by Harper ('04,

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg.




taken from the oviduct at

(?$ CO nP

—Transverse section of a pigeon's egg

m., about 3l^ hours after fertilization. Reference marks are the

for Fig. 3. Leitz, 4/2. Tube length, 140 mm.

Fig. 3. — Diagram of Fig. 2. A central transverse section of pigeon's egg obtained at 11 :?>0 p. m., SV2 hours after fertilization. The nuclei are reconstructed from seven successive sections.

1 pb, first polar body; 2 pb, second polar body; ^, male pronucleus; 9 , female pronucleus ; sn, supernumerary sperm nuclei ; mp, marginal periblast ; cp., central periblast ; wy, white yolk ; n P, nucleus of Pander.

2 cp wy

Fig. 4. — Transverse section througli about the center of the blastoderm of a pigeon's egg obtained at 2 :(X) a. m., about six hours after fertilization. The same egg is shown in Chart II. n, nucleus of one of the blastomeres. mp, marginal periblast, cp, central periblast, wy, white yolk, ac, a cell in the accessory cleavage. 1, a sperm nucleus in the marginal periblast, and 2, a sperm nucleus in the central periblast. Leitz, 4/2. Tube length, 140 mm.

Fig. 5. — Transverse section of the pigeon egg whose surface view is shown in Fig. 37. a, b, c, d, cells of primary cleavage. 1, accessory cleavage. 2, sperm nuclei.

6 Mary Blount.

Fig. 6) and were described by liim as follows: "The slightly oval disc has a greater diameter of 3.5 mm. It is divided into two zones quite clearly distinguished in opacity, the outer zone being due to the abrupt thinning out of the fine granular matter of the disc." Tliese two areas are the blastodisc and the periblast. In an egg obtained at 11 p.m., about three hours after fertilization, the blastoderm was 2.96 mm. in transverse and 3.08 mm. in longitudinal diameter. These measurements were taken on the living egg. Fig. 45 shows the surface view of such an egg.

The central transverse section of another egg gives the diameter of the blastodisc about 2.5 mm. This egg was taken from the oviduct at 11.30 p.m. (three and one-half hours after fertilization). In the sections I found the male and female pronuclei and a number of supernumerary sperm nuclei. The latter had migrated peripherally from their place of entrance and occupied a circle at the inner margin of the periblast. Several nuclei were peripheral to those at the inner margin of the periblast. They are probably not nuclei of the original migration, but may be sisters to those just central to them, if we may suppose that a nuclear division has taken place since the migration into the periblast. Fig. 2 shows a central transverse section of this egg, but the nuclei were in several successive sections. See also a diagram traced from this figure, Fig. 3.

The distribution of the sperm nuclei, their disappearance, and later the distribution of the periblast nuclei are illustrated in seven charts. The figure lettered A in each chart represents the surface view of the egg. The orientation is the same for all the surface views presented in this thesis. The anterior side of the blastoderm is away from the observer, and the axis of the future embryo is ill a diagonal position, as indicated in Fig. 1. These fig-ures (A of the charts) were drawn from the living eggs in salt solution to the same scale as nearly as possible in free hand work. \Vlien a dotted circle occurs in A or B of any chart, it represents the apparent peripheral limit of the marginal periblast. The supernumeraiy sperm nuclei, and later the periblast nuclei, may migrate peripherally to this distance. How much further the cytoplasm of the periblast extends I do not know : for I cannot demonstrate the existence of

The Early Dcvclopinoiit of the Pigeon's Egg. 7

cytoplasm in the mass of yolk granules except by the presence of nuclei and except in a few places where cytoplasmic islands and strands appear. The periblastic zone, as shown by a dotted circle in the charts, appears in the surface view of the living eggs at certain








C ---^-t.

Chart I.

C t

"o~~r 6

Chart II.

stages and is shown in several photographs. Fig. B is a diagram reconstructed from a st-iidy of transverse sections, and Fig. C is a diagram of a central transverse section. The sperm nuclei and the periblast nuclei represented in Fig. B of the several charts are

8 Mary Blount.

in superficial positions in the marginal periblast, but those within the circle bounding the blastodisc are in the region recognized as the central periblast. They are therefore deep and are not confused with the nuclei of primary cleavage. The following characters are used in the charts :

(^, male pronucleus. 9, female pronucleus. o, primary cleavage nucleus.

6, periblast nucleus. +, sperm nucleus, bl., blastodisc. per., periblast.

Chart I. From a study of the sections, then, it becomes evident that before the appearance of the first cleavage plane the supernumerary sperm nuclei migrate into the periblast and occupy a circle which is later characterized by accessory cleavage. This is illustrated in Chart I. A central transverse section of the same egg is shown in Fig. 2.

Chart II.

Chart II A represents the surface view of an egg in the fourcelled stage. It was taken from the oviduct at 2 a.m., or about six hours after fertilization. The blastodisc is incompletely divided into four blastomeres which are continuous at their outer margins. They are also continuous below with the yolk, see Chart II C and Fig. 4.

The blastodisc is surrounded by the periblast, the peripheral limit of which as it appears in surface view, is indicated here by a dotted circle. At the inner margin of the periblast there is an incomplete zone of accessory cleavage. Where the accessory cleavage does not appear, the blastomeres are continuous peripherally with the periblast. This fact will be noted again in the description of later stages. (Chart III A, Figs. 9, and 10 A and B.)

In the sections fewer sperm nuclei were found than in the maturation stage, which indicates that a varying number enter the egg (Harper '04, p. 362). A number of sperm nuclei had migrated in superficial positions to the outer margin of the zone which the periblast presents in surface view and others were in the central periblast. Although the central periblast is not at this stage separated from the blastomeres, it may be identified with the finely granular region below the blastodisc, and the thickness of the latter

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 9

is determined by the depth of the vertical cleavage plane. The latter measures 0.12 mm. in this egg, and the first horizontal cleavage (Fig. 5) which marks the position of the future segmentation cavity occurs later at the same depth. Compare Figs. 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 11,

"^ +■■■-.....

which are drawn to the same scale from central transverse sections of different eggs.

Five primary cleavage nuclei were found in this egg, Chart II B, the nucleus of the cell at the left having divided without a cleavage plane being yet formed.

10 Mary Blount.

Chaet III.

The next stage illustrated in the charts is that of eight (or perhaps nine) cells, Chart III. The egg was taken from the shell gland at 4.45 a.m., about eight and three-fourths hours after fertilization. The area of primary cleavage presents seven (or eight) large marginal cells, which are continuous with each other at their outer borders, and a smaller central cell which is limited on all sides superficially. This cleavage pattern presents the beginning of the differentiation of the primary area into central and marginal regions, as is more completely illustrated in the sixteen-celled stage (see Fig. 48). The accessory cleavage forms an incomplete circle at the inner margin of the periblast (Chart III A). The marginal cells at the left and posterior side of the blastodisc are definitely limited peripherally by a line just inside of a zone of accessory cleavage. At the anterior and right sides there are three gaps in the accessory cleavage, and no peripheral limit to the marginal cells. In sections, sperm nuclei are not found in this region. This condition of open marginal cells will be referred to in the discussion of later stages, and particularly in the discussion of the periblast. The sperm nuclei have increased in number as compared with the four-celled stage. Compare Charts II B and III B. They occupy superficial positions in the marginal periblast and many of them have migrated to the peripheral edge of the zone which is recognized as the periblast in surface view. They have also migrated deeper into the central periblast and form a submarginal circle.

Chart III C is a diagram of a central transverse section which is shown in detail in Fig. 5. It is taken along the line X Y (Chart III A) and the blastomeres are indicated by corresponding letters in the two figures.


The next chart (IV) presents the last stage in the nuiltiplication of the sperm nuclei in an egg of about thirty-two cells. The surface view (A) is incompletely represented. The blastomeres seemed to show shrinkage in the salt solution and the egg was hurried on into the killing fluid without taking time to complete the drawing. Enough

Tlie Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg.


of the cells of the central area are drawn, however, to show their size in relation to the marginal cells, and the accessory cleavage was just


^ +•--...

..- '+

+ + + ■

■■+ ^


+ +




V + 4. , +



+ J



+ + A

4- *




+ Q +*s<h_ +

o o ^""^

o O -flZ

4- \







+ + \

+ +


+ o




o o ^ ^

4 O 4




+ ° o

./■■^ ^-••■'







-♦ ^+ +


•-,+ +


+ + +



.+.+ +t -'•

Chart IV.

as ahnndant on all sides as is represented in the part of the figure completed. The small cells of accessory cleavage were lying one above another in two or in some places three layers (Fig 6).


Mary Blount.

Fig. 6. — Transverse section of a pigeon's egg at the end of ttie period of multiplication of tlie sperm nuclei. Egg taken 6:30 a. m., about 10 hours after fertilization and 31 hours before laying. Note that all cells are still continuous with the yolk. 1. Accessory cleavage around the sperm nuclei. 2. Marginal cells sharply separated from the sperm nuclei. 3. Central cells. 4. Sperm nuclei.

Fig. 7. — The left side of the section shown in Fig. 6. ac, accessory cleavage, cp, central periblast, mp, marginal periblast, mc, marginal cell, sn, sperm nucleus. Leitz, 5/4. Tube length, 140 mm.

Fig. 8. — Diagram of Fig. 7. The nuclei are reconstructed from eight successive sections. The nuclei in the accessory cleavage and in the marginal and central periblast are derived from supernumerary sperm nuclei, ac, accessory cleavage, cp, central periblast, mc, marginal cell, mp, marginal periblast.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 13

No attempt was made to count the supernumerary sperm nuclei in this egg. They were very abundant, so that in almost any section of the blastoderm several were found in both the marginal and central periblast. They had evidently multiplied by repeated divisions. In earlier stages, the cells of the primary area were separated from the sperm nuclei merely by the cleavage planes enclosing the small accessory cells (see Fig. 5). But in this stage, when the sperm nuclei have become so numerous, the cytoplasm of the blastodisc is definitely separated from the periblast, i. e., there are diagonal or submarginal cleavage planes ventral to the marginal cells of the primary area. See Chart IV C and Figs. 6, 7, and 8. The subgerminal supernumerary nuclei are found as far centrally as the margins of the nucleus of Pander.

Chaet V.

Chart V, Fig. A, presents an incomplete drawing of the surface of an egg taken from the oviduct at 7 a.m. — about eleven hours after fertilization. There ds no accessory cleavage. The marginal cells are all open peripherally, and only a few of the central cells are drawai to show their relative size. This chart presents a strikingcontrast to all those that have preceded ; for in this Qgg there was not a single supernumerary sj)erm nucleus. The nuclei that were found in the sections were all in the cells of primary cleavage with no nuclei in either the marginal or central periblast. There is not usually such an abrupt change as that indicated between the Charts IV and V. Sections of other eggs of about this stage show a diminishing number of sperm nuclei. They do not usually disappear simultaneously on all sides of the blastoderm as seems to have happened in this egg (Chart V). And I have not been able to discover that there is any particular side where they regularly persist longest. Of course, their original position in the egg is variable. But wherever the sperm nuclei do persist, the marginal cells are limited peripherally and ventrally in such a manner as is shown in Chart IV A and C, and Figs. 6, 7, 8, and 10 D to H. And where the sperm nuclei have disappeared, the marginal cells are open peripherally and ventrally, as in Chart V A and C, and Fig. 10 A and B.


Mary Blount.

Chart VI. Tlie egg illustrated in Chart VI was taken from the oviduct at 10.30 a. m., fourteen and one-half hours from the estimated time of fertilization. Only a few cells of the surface view 'were drawn to show relative sizes.


-!3=r^:^^^':Ec- :

Chart V. Chart VI.

There seems to be a return to accessory cleavage like that shown in Chart IV A. But sections of the egg (Chart VI) demonstrate a relation between the marginal cells and tlie periblast diflFerent

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg.


Fig. 9. — Longitudinal section of pigeon's egg at the time of disappearance of tlie sperm nuclei; on the left (anterior), the marginal cell has become open, *. c, continuous with the marginal periblast. On the right the marginal cell is slightly separated from the periblast at the surface. Surface view of the egg showed traces of accessory cleavage ; note continuity of the central cells with central periblast. 1. Marginal cells. 2. Cone of protoplasm. 3. Marginal periblast. 4. Neck of latebra (white yolk). 5. Yellow yolk. Egg tak€Mi 7 a. m.. about 11 hours after fertilization (estimated).


Mary Blount.

mc -^ p


Fig. 10. — Diagrams of the posterior side of longitudinal sections through a pigeon egg about the time of the disappearance of the sperm nuclei. A longitudinal median section of the same egg is shown in Fig. 9. In 10 A, the marginal cell is continuous with the periblast, as also at the left of Fig. 9. Fig. 10 B is ten sections beyond A, and here an indentation occurs which in the second section beyond (Fig 10 C) deepens into a cleavage furrow. In the next section (Fig. 10 D) there are two sperm nuclei in the accessoiy cleavage. They are small and stain very faintly. The wall separating one of the sperm nuclei from the marginal cell has begun to disappear. The other figures (Fig. 10 E, F, G and H) show sperm nuclei either in cells of accessory cleavage or in the marginal periblast, and in either case they are separated from the marginal cell. Through all the sections of this egg, the marginal cells are continuous with the periblast except where sperm nuclei occur. All the nuclei in this figure are sperm nuclei.

a, cells of accessory cleavage.

mc, marginal cell.

p, mai'ginal periblast.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 17

from that which exists in earlier stages, in which the supernumerary sperm nuclei are the cause of the accessory cleavage. This is a stage after the disappearance of the sperm nuclei. The marginal cells are continuous with the periblast; the nuclei in the periblast are sisters to the nuclei of the marginal cells, i. e., they are derived from the cleavage nucleus ; and the small cells resembling accessory cleavage are mere bud-like and evanescent projections from the periblast. In no section of this egg are there found the diagonal, submarginal cleavage planes like those which separate the primary area from the region of sperm nuclei as shown in Chart IV.

Fig. 11. — Transverse section through the center of the blastoderm of a pigeon's egg taken at 10.30 a. m., 14i^ hours after fertilization. 1. Marginal cell. 2. Marginal periblast. 3. Nuclei in the central periblast, derived from the nucleus of the marginal cell.

Chart VII.

An egg taken from the bird at 10.30 a.m., fourteen and one-half hours from the estimated time of fertilization, furnishes the data for Chart VII. Although obtained at the same hour as the egg for Chart VI, it was probably fertilized earlier ; for it shows a later stage of development. Chart VII A is a free hand drawing, but a photograph of another egg of about the same stage is shown in Fig. 54. At this stage the peripheral limit of the periblast does not show in surface view. In sections of the egg, however, nuclei are found in marginal and central periblast — see Chart VII B and C, and also Fig. 11, which represents a central transverse section of the egg of this chart. From this figure it is plain that the marginal cells constitute a "zone of junction" between the blastodisc and the periblast Agassiz and Whitman, '84).

18 Mary Blount.

Summary of the Facts Illustrated by the Charts.

1. During the maturation stage, the supernumerary sperm nuclei migrate from the blastodisc into the periblast.

2. The supernumerary sperm nuclei multiply by division in the periblast and migrate peripherally in the marginal periblast. In sub

Chart VII.

germinal positions they arc found as far centrally as the margins of the nucleus of Pander.

3. As the supernumerary sperm nuclei increase in number, the cells of the primary cleavage are definitely separated from the region of the sperm nuclei by cleavage planes that limit the marginal cells peripherally and ventrally.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 19

4. Between ten and twelve hours after fertilization, the sperm nuclei disappear. This does not occur at any fixed stage of development, but is soon before or soon after the thirty-two celled stage. Certain figures and photographs in this thesis show eggs with fewer than thirty-two cells in which the sperm nuclei are lacking from some sides of the blastoderm, and yet in an egg of thirty-two cells (shown in Chart IV) they are still numerous,

5. After the disappearance of the sperm nuclei, the marginal cells become open peripherally and ventrally, and continuous with the yolk. N^uclei from the marginal cells pass into the periblast and the latter is, therefore, organized with nuclei derived from the cleavage nucleus, and is exactly comparable with the periblast of the bony fish, as described by Agassiz and Whitman ('84).


Among those plants and animals whose fertilization has been studied, the condition of monospermy is by far the more frequent, so that the idea became prevalent tliat polyspermy was possible only under pathological conditions. And many investigators have endeavored to solve the problem of why a spermatozoon, and usually only one, enters an egg. It is quite possible that monospermy is secured by different means in different species. But the most satisfactory and most widely applicable explanation of this phenomenon is that a physiological change takes place in the cytoplasm of the egg immediately after the entrance of one spermatozoon, so that conditions are not favorable for other spermatozoa. But polyspermy as a normal condition has been described in a number of animals and in at least one species of plants. Only one sperm nucleus, however, unites with the egg nucleus, and there is no conclusive evidence that the supernumerary nuclei enter into the structure of the embryo in any form, or take part in the formation of the germ layers.

Polyspermy in Bryozoa. — Last year an interesting paper was published by Dr. Kristine Bonnevie on "Physiologische Polyspermie bei Bryozoen." Dr. Bonnevie ('OY) found compound spermatozoa, or "Spermazeugmen." She argues that these compound structures are not necessary to secure the power of locomotion for the sperms,

20 Mary Blount.

and neither do they facilitate the entrance of the spermatozoon into the egg. Therefore, since the ^'Spermazeugmen" are not necessary to secure fertilization itself, their function must be to insure polyspermy. "Wir sind so darauf hinge wiescn, in der Weiterentwickclung des Eies die Bedeutung dieser eigentiimlichen Anpassung zu suchen" (p. 589). She finds in the cytoj^lasm of the young oocytes of Membranipora pilosa a great quantity of granules and rods containing chromatin. But with the further developmenJ; of the oocyte, the chromidial apparatus disappears. Finally, with fertilization, the supernumerary spermatozoa provide the somatic chromatin in order to restore the proper nucleo-plasmar relations in the cell.

^'Bei der polyspermen Befruchtung wird eine normale Kernplasmarelation wiederhergestellt, indem hierdurch der Oocyte ein neuer Chromidialapparat zugefiihrt wird. Jedes Spermium enthalt ja namlich in seinem winzig kleinen Kopf eine ahnliche Chromatinmenge wie diejenige, die vor der Befruchtung in der grossen Oocyte vorhanden war. Und wahrend nun, allem Anschein nach, ein Spermakern den miinnlichen Vorkern liefert, sind die ubrigen als die Trager des fiir den Stoffwechsel der Zelle notigen somatischen Chromatins zu betrachten und haben als solche, auch wenn sie sich nicht zu Kernen entwickeln, eine wichtige Rolle auszufiihren.

"Die physiologische Polyspermie bei Membranipora (moglicherweise auch bei anderen Formen) wiirde nach der hier vertretenen Auffassung nicht als ein isoliertes Phanomen dastehen, sondern sie ware zwischen den vielen verschiedenen Anpassungen einzuordnen, die in einer giinstigen Ausbildung der somatischen Telle des Eies ihr Ziel zu haben scheinen.

"In den allgemein bekannten Fallen solcher Anpassungen werden eine Anzahl junger Eizellen zu Gunsten einer ihrer Schwesterzellen, der heranwachsenden Oocyte, geopfert, entweder indem sie als Nahrzellen in dieselbe aufgenommen werden, oder indem sie, wie bei Dytiscus (Giardina, 1901,), einen Teil ihres Chromatins zu derselben abgeben. In unserem Fall, bei der physiologischen Polyspermie, wird die harmonische Weiterentwickelung des befruchteten Eies in ganz ahnlicher Weise gesichert, nur geschieht es diesmal auf Kosten von Zellen des anderen Geschlechtes." (Bonnevie, '07, p. 592.)

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 21

Polyspermy in IlolotJtiu-oldca. — Korschelt and Heider ('03) report a publication by Iwanzoflt' ('98) on polysj)ermy in the Holothuroidea. He found that the egg sends out radiating protoplasmic processes through the canals of the zona radiata. The swarming spermatozoa are caught in these processes and are drawn into the egg plasm, and assimilated by it, as Iwanzoff thinks. "Das Ei frisst und verdaut die Spermatozoen." But Iwanzoff observes that when the egg has lost a part of its nuclear substance, in the polar bodies "die Spermatozoon konnen nicht mehr von der Eizelle bewaltigt werden," and only one sperm nucleus can unite with the egg nucleus in fertilization. Here is one more attempt at a teleological explanation of the maturation process.

Polyspermy in Insects. — Among the insects, Henking ('92) found polyspermy in certain of the Hemiptera, Coleoptera, and Hymenoptera. In the egg there is a varying number of micropyles (4 to 7). Each one permits the entrance of a spermatozoon. After fertilization, the spermatozoa are found in the marginal protoplasm, where they degenerate, bvit they are also found in the yolk where the sperm head changes over into a nucleus.

Polyspermy in Selacliiajis. — Polyspermy has been described in every class of vertebrates except the mammalia. In the selachians, this phenomenon was discovered in an attempt to determine the origin of the free nuclei in the yolk. For a long time it was supposed that these nuclei were derived from nuclei of the blastomcres of early cleavage, or else that they arose in a still earlier stage by a rapid division of the cleavage nucleus. But further research demonstrated these nuclei in maturation stages before the union of the pronuclei, and thus disproved their descent from the cleavage nucleus. Moreover, sperm heads were found in the egg in transitional stages in their process of change into nuclei, and these nuclei in their early mitotic division have the reduced number of chromosomes.

But while there is now agreement as to the origin of the supernumerary nuclei, their fate is still a question for research.

Riickert ('99) identifies the merocyte nuclei of late cleavage stages with those of early cleavage which are derived from supernumerary spermatozoa. But he finds the merocyte nuclei in cells

22 Marj Blount.

which are added to the germinal area. They are in such positions as would make it possible for them to enter into the structure of the embryo. Rlickert thinks tliat the cells containing mcrocyte nuclei may soon degenerate, or if they play any part in the development, it must be only subordinate. (Rlickert '99, p. 677). Upon general principle, he is unwilling to admit that nuclei derived from supernumerary spermatozoa enter into the structure of the embryo, and so he finally leaves it an open question whether the merocytes of late cleavage degenerate in the germ layers, or whether their nuclei are not genetically related to merocyte nuclei of early cleavage but are a new set derived from the cleavage nucleus (Rlickert, '99, p. 677).

Ruckert's Explanation for the migration of the supernumerary sperms. — Rlickert presents a theory for the cause of the migration of the supernumerary sperm nuclei. He considers that the sperm nucleus entering first, or the one lying nearest to the female pronucleus, becomes the male pronucleus. With the copulation of the pronuclei, the a^ntrosomes and asters of the male nucleus pass over to the cleavage nucleus. The supernumerary sperm nuclei are repelled from the cleavage nucleus and from each other by the influence of their astral rays. These fibers reach out from the nuclei and when they touch each other, they respond to a stimulus somewhat like thigmotaxis — but in this case, the fibers touch others like themselves instead of a firmer object. When the fibers thus come in contact, the nuclei recoil. The cleavage nucleus being better endowed, drives the other nuclei away from it. The succeeding generations of cleavage nuclei are armed with the protective apparatus ("Schutzvorrichtung"), their inheritance from the male pronucleus, and as cleavage advances, there is therefore a progressive combat between the cleavage nuclei and the supernumerary sperm nuclei for the possession of the germinal area. The cleavage nuclei are stronger and therefore triumph over the weaker, which are continually "driven to the wall." This behavior, Rlickert thinlvs, accounts not only for the expulsion of the supernumerary nuclei (merocyte nuclei) from the central area, but it explains the somewhat equal spacing of them around the periphery and in the deeper parts.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 23

Polyspei-my in the Neiut. — In the egg of the newt, supernumerary sperms degenerate early. Jordan ('93) found them in the fourcelled stage, but not later.

Polyspermy in Reptiles. — Oppel ('92) found the reptile agreeing with the Selachian in respect to the sperm origin of the supernumerary nuclei, but in the Selachian they lead to the merocytes, and in the reptile after a few divisions they remain rudimentary (Oppel, '92, p. 282). Oppel agrees with Eiickert that on general principles he cannot believe that the "ISTebenspermakerne" enter into the structure of the future embryo (Oppel, '92, p. 283).

In the Kreuzotter (Pelias berus Merr) Ballowitz ('03) found "Nebenspermiumkenie" in the maturation stages. He believes that they give rise to the "Paraspermiumkerne" of later cleavage, and these correspond to Eiickort's merocyte nuclei. But Ballowitz says that Eiickert's merocytes are derived from sperm nuclei, and that he regards as periblast nuclei only those in the marginal cells remaining in contact with the yolk. Ballowitz, on the other hand, derives the periblast nuclei from daughter nuclei remaining in the yolk and derived from blastomeres. He designates them as "oogenetisch." But he thinks it possible that one of the deep parasperm nuclei may turn back to the floor of the cleavage cavity and remain there as a "spermogenetischen Periblastkern" (Ballowitz, '03, p. 84). The usual origin of the periblast nuclei is the cleavage nuclei. He thinks the parasperm nuclei play no considerable role in the development of the germ. But if they come into the coarse yolk under better conditions of nourishment, they may divide and in certain circumstances be added to the germ layers.

Polsypermy in Birds. — Harper ('04) established the fact of polyspermy in the pigeon, but did not determine the fate of the supernumerary sperm nuclei. It has been shown in an earlier part of this paper (p. 13) that in the pigeon's egg, the supernumerary sperm nuclei disappear about ten or twelve hours after fertilization, before or soon after the 32-celled stage. In maturation stages they migrate out of the blastodisc into the periblast, and the longer they remain there, the more definitely they become separated from the blastodisc by planes of cleavage. This fact suggests that they do not enter

24 Mary Blount.

into the formation of the germ layers. But they disappear in such an early stage of cleavage, that their participation in the structure of the embryo is out of the question.

Cause of Migration of Supernumerary Sperm Nuclei in the Pigeon, The conditions in the pigeon's egg are not well explained by Riickert's theory of expulsion. Harper ('04) suggests that the "sperm nuclei migrate so early to the periphery of the germinal disc, that it is difficult to believe that they do this under the influence of the cleavage nuclei." I have shown in Chart I and Eigs. 2 and 3 that beforethe union of the pronuclei the supernumerary sperm nuclei have migrated into the periblast. In speaking further of the early migration of the sperm nuclei,- Harper says, "This seems to point to the independent activity of the sperm nuclei rather than to any mechanical driving of them from the inner region. ^Vhat chemotactic influences there may be present, we, of course, have no means of knowing" (p. 3T8). In another place (p. 372), Harper says: "As an active cause for the migration of the sperm nuclei it might be assumed- that the activity is but the continued expression of the labile nature of the protoplasm, which gives the sperm its motile character during the period of its independent existence." I am willing to accept for the pigeon Riickert's theory for the cause of polyspermy in the selachian, namely, the want of protection against it. Harper speaks of the "thinness of the egg membrane when it leaves the tough ovarian capsule." It is commonly accepted among biologists that the egg exerts a chemotactic influence on spermatozoa. Monospermy is secured in many eggs by the cessation of the attractive influence the moment that a spermatozoon enters the egg, i. e., the cytoplasm that is fertilized no longer attracts spermatozoa. Wilson ('03, p. 418) found that spermatozoa enter enucleated fragments of the unfertilized nemertine egg, but they do not enter enucleated fragments obtained after fertilization even in the absence of an egg membrane.

I wish to use this theory of the attractive influence of the egg not only to explain the entrance of the spermatozoa, but their migration into the periblast. A varying number of spermatozoa (Harper found from 12 to 25 in fertilization stages) enter the pigeon's egg in the vicinity of the egg nucleus. The cytoplasm, then, in this

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 25

vicinity is fertilized, but we may suppose that the cytoplasm in the peripheral and deeper parts of the germinal area retains its influence and attracts the supernumerary sperm nuclei into itself just as the cytoplasm of the unfertilized egg attracted the spermatozoa at the time of fertilization.

All of the reported cases of polyspermy in animals are for eggs containing a large amount of yolk, or else those whose peculiar form places much of their cytoplasm at some distance from the egg nucleus. The union of the germ-cells calls forth profound changes in both" (Wilson, '00, p. 200). Many monospennic eggs are so small that the profound physiological change caused by the entrance of a spermatozoon is almost immediately effective in every part of the egg. Or, indeed, the immediateness of the effect of fertilization may be due in some cases to the character of the protoplasm rather than to the small size of the egg. The germinal area of the pigeon's egg in a state of maturation presents a diameter of about 3 mm. on the surface, and is 0.25 mm. deep in the central part. (These measurements are from sections of the egg shown in Chart I and Figs. 2 and 3). Considering the size, and expanded form of the germinal area, and possibly also some peculiarity inherent in the protoplasm of the pigeon's egg, one may suppose that the peripheral and deeper parts of the cytoplasm retain their attractive power for an appreciable time after the entrance of the spermatozoa into the central superficial region of the germinal area.

If we may then accept these two hypotheses: (1) of the attractive influence of unfertilized cytoplasm upon spermatozoa, and (2) the temporary retention of that influence in parts of the pigeon egg distant from the egg nucleus after the entrance of the spermatozoa ; then we may conclude: (1) that the supernumerary sperm nuclei migrate because of the attraction of the cytoplasm on them, and (2) the path of migration of each nucleus is the resultant of the attractive forces acting upon it. These two conclusions will, I think, explain the position of the supernumerary sperm nuclei in the pigeon and selachian.

The spermatozoa enter the egg in the vicinity of the egg nucleus. Since their number varies, their distribution also varies in different

26 Mary Blount.

eggs. But each nucleus is attracted by the entire mass of cytoplasm outside of the central fertilized area. Since the germinal area of the pigeon's egg is shallow, the attractive force towards the central, deeper part is less than that towards the periphery, and, therefore, the sperm nuclei are drawn out to the periphery, i. e., into the marginal periblast. But each nucleus, as it goes, leaves behind it a fertilized path. This path, or radius, is then eliminated from the attractive influence on any other nucleus. Another nucleus in its original position near the first one referred to would pass out along another radius, but since radii diverge toward the circumference, the nuclei would take positions in the periblast further from each other than they were in their original positions near the center. This explains the more or less regular spacing of the nuclei around the periphery. The application of this principle of attraction also explains the position of the supernumerary nuclei in the central periblast. If the cytoplasm near the surface was fertilized by other migrating nuclei, the attractive influence of the remaining cytoplasm would lead these nuclei into positions further below the surface. Of course, I do not mean that the nuclei migrate successively. They pass simultaneously each one along the resultant of the ' attractive forces which act upon it. As they go, the influence of fertilization emanates in all directions from each nucleus and so eliminates the attraction from all directions, except the line of migration which the nucleus is to follow.

If these hypotheses are applied to the selachian egg, the positions of the merocyte nuclei there are easily explained. The germinal area of the selachian egg is proportionally much deeper than that of the pigeon. It approaches the shape of a hemisphere with the convex side toward the yolk. There is, therefore, a proportionally greater attraction toward the deeper cytoplasm in the selachian egg than in the pigeon egg, and the "merocyte" nuclei are found deep. See Eiickert ('99), Figs. 37, 39 and others. Judging from descriptions by Oppel and Ballowitz, I think this explanation will also serve for the conditions in the reptilian egg.

Polyspermy in Plants. — There remains yet to mention the case of polyspermy in plants. Land ('07) found that the second male

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 27

nucleus enters the cytoplasm of the egg of Ephedra trifurca. "As it disintegrates, minute cells appear, which are believed to be the joint product of the chromatin of the second male nucleus and the chromatin of some of the jacket cells; these minute cells at least foreshadow the endosperm of angiosperms, and may be called physiological endosperm" (p. 290).

This case of the second male nucleus in the cytoplasm of the egg of Ephedra is exactly parallel with the case of supernumerary sperm nuclei in the cytoplasm of the pigeon's egg. The case of "double fertilization" or triple fusion" in the Angiosperms which is often compared with polyspenny in animals, is not a parallel case ; for in the "triple fusion" the second male nucleus unites with two polar nuclei, one of which is sister to the egg. From this fusion the endosperm is fonned which is believed to nourish the embryo. Henneguy ('02) described the entrance of spermatozoa into the yolk cells of Distomum hepaticum, and he regarded the yolk cells as abortive Qgg cells. These are offered for the nourishment of the egg and the condition is quite parallel to the "triple fusion" of Angiosperms.

Accessory Cleavage and Segmentation of Egg Fragments. — The division of the supernumerary sperm nuclei and the "accessory cleavage" present a problem of interest. In spermatogenesis, there is no division of the nucleus after the formation of the spermatid. So far as we know, the spermatozoa do not divide in any medium in which they are normally found, except in the cytoplasm of the egg. But in the case of physiological polyspermy, the spermatozoa are in a medium where any of them that becomes the successful male pronucleus will divide after union wi'th the female pronucleus. Therefore, the supernumerary sperm nuclei in the egg cytoplasm may divide. The accessory cleavage of the selachian's and bird's Qgg is certainly comparable to the division of fertilized enucleated fragments of the sea urchin's egg or nemertian egg.

"Inwandering Follicular Cells." — Harper ('04) illustrates an "inwandering follicular cell." (Harper, '04, PI. II, Eig. Y i). I have found a large number of cells in the perivitelline fluid in the egg represented in Chart II. Harper's figure does not show the

28 ■ Mary Blount.

environment of the structure, and I cannot be sure that it is homologous with those illustrated in Figs. 12a and b, and 13. I think the latter are supernumerary sperms. Riickert ('99, p. 671) discusses the question of inwandering female elements, and while he thinks there is no absolute proof against such a phenomenon, he has nothing to present in its favor.

Fig. 12a. — A mass of spenu nuclei in tlie region of accessory cleavage in the egg shown in Chart II A. Transverse section. The center of the blastoderm is toward the right, a., thin layers of albumen atUiering to the egg. acp., planes of accessory cleavage, vit. vitelline membrane. 1. Spermatozoen caught between two layers of albumen. 2. A sperm nucleus in the deepest part of the plane of accessory cleavage. Leitz 4 j yV- *^rube length 140 mm.

Fig. 12b. — From the same section as Fig. 12a. From the marginal periblast to the left of Fig. 12a. vit., vitelline membrane, pvf., perivitelline fluid, sp., sperm nucleus. Leitz 4/yV. Tube length 140 mm.

Fig. 12a is taken from a transverse section of the egg shown in Fig. 4 and Chart II. It is in the accessory cleavage, the right hand side of the figure being toward the center of the blastoderm. Fig. 12b is from the same section, but further peripheral in the periblast. There were other cells between these two places. This particular group of nuclei continued through ten sections (each section 10 microns) with similar conditions in other parts of the

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 29

same egg, but I have not found such a mass of them in any other egg. The nuclei are in the perivitelline fluid and at the place shown in Fig. 12a they have collected in the furrows of accessory cleavage, and one of them (2) has followed a furrow to its deepest limit. In this furrow some of the nuclei seem to be in a syncytium without definite cell boundaries, while others are in entire and separate cells. One such cell is enclosed between two delicate layers of egg albumen (Fig. 12a, 1). Its nucleus has divided — perhaps amitotically.

There are two suggestions for the origin of these peculiar cells. They may be :

1. inwandering follicular cells, or

2. supernumerary spermatozoa.


Fig. 13. — From a longitudinal section of a pigeon's egg, eleven and threefourths hours after fertilization, 7.15 a. m. vm., vitelline membrane, pv., perivitelline fluid, s, one of the supernumerary spermatozoa, y, yolk. Leitz 4 / j\ Tube length 140 mm.

If they are follicular cells, we should expect to find them occurring quite constantly in all of the eggs of the pigeon. These structures occur in 331/3 per cent of the eggs that I have studied, from four to fifteen hours after fertilization. They occur in only 25 per cent of my pigeon eggs from fifteen to thirty-nine hours after fertilization, and not at all in later stages. Degeneration is their fate. In the stages later than fifteen hours from fertilization, these cells were very, scarce, — perhaps only 'one or two in an egg (Fig. 13). If the follicular cells wander into the egg, there must be some quite regularly occurring cause for their leaving the follicular epithelium. We would not expect them to leave a compact epithelium amless they are by nature wandering cells. Von Brunn ('82) describes the entrance of follicular cells into ovarian eggs that are in the process of resorption, but' says in a footnote, p. G, "Ueberhaupt ist ja wohl

30 Mary Blount.

kein Fall bekannt, dass die Wanderkorper ins Innere normaler vegetationsfahiger Zellen eingedrungen waren und dieselben zerstort batten."

Are these cells supernumerary spermatozoa ? Their inconstant appearance argues for this origin. Possibly they are sperms that have entered late. The influence of the egg which otherwise would have drawn them into the granular cytoplasm may have ceased just after they had gone through the vitelline membrane, and they may have migrated peripherally in the perivitelline fluid to the region of the periblast. Or they may have entered late in the region where they are now found. They are usually in the region of the periblast. Their entrance directly into the periblast without migration from the blastodisc would make them comparable with the spermatozoa which enter the vegetative pole of the amphibian egg, or those which Ballowitz ('03) has described as entering directly into the yolk of the adder. Their usual degeneration at about the time when the supernumerary sperm nuclei degenerate in the periblast also argues for their sperm origin.

Moreover, we can hardly believe that so many follicular cells would enter at one place as to give such a large mass as is found in Fig. 12a. Even by repeated division until the time when this egg was killed, six hours after fertilization, two or three follicular cells which might enter together could not form so many as are in this mass.

Evidence of the Disappearance of the Supernumerary Nuclei in the Pigeon and Comparison with Other Meroblastic Vertebrate Eggs. — As I follow the figures and descriptions of the reptilian and selachian eggs, I must believe that in those forms, as in the pigeon, the supernumerary nuclei degenerate early, and that the "yolk nuclei" of later cleavage are periblast nuclei derived from the cleavage nucleus. Kiickert's ('99) Figs. 2, 3, 4 and 8, Tab. LII, give surface views of successive stages of Torpedo eggs. With the progress of development, the accessory cleavage disappears. In the pigeon's egg, with the disappearance of the accessory cleavage at the surface, there is also the absence of supernumerary nuclei in the sections. But it may be suggested that the egg in which I saw no

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 31

accessory cleavage on the surface, and in the sections no nuclei outside of the blastomeres (the egg of Chart V) was monospermic. I cannot prove the contrary in the case of this particular egg. My argument for the disappearance of the supernumerary sperm nuclei, the establishment of a zone of junction and the organization of the periblast with nuclei from the marginal blastomeres does not rest upon this alone. The presence of the well marked line of cleavage separating the blastodisc from the periblast where the sperm nuclei exist and the absence of those cleavage planes from other parts of the same egg where there are no sperm nuclei, and the constant continuity between blastodisc and periblast after about twelve or fourteen hours after fertilization, are facts which argue strongly for the difference in character of the free nuclei in early and late stages.

My argument for the disappearance of the supernumerary sperm nuclei and the subsequent opening of the marginal cells to become continuous with the periblast, is further supported by observations of a living egg through about eight hours of development. I saw the egg first at 2.15 a. m. and made a free hand sketch of the surface view (Fig. 16 A). Fig 16 B is a sketch of the same egg at 2.50 a.m. The accessory cleavage has increased slightly. The cleavage planes have become more distinct. A little later, I saw white spots appearing in the periblast. They probably marked the position of the supernumerary sperm nuclei. I watched one particular spot, and saw it elongate and divide into two. As the supernumerary nuclei multiplied, the peripheral outlines of the marginal cells became more distinct, but where there were no nuclei in the periblast, the marginal cells were continuous with it. At 5.15 a. m. the lines of accessory cleavage had become indistinct, and finally, at 10.00 a. m. (when the egg was killed) there were only faint traces of accessory cleavage, although some white spots remained, indicating the presence of supernumerary nuclei. They disappeared more slowly in this egg, perhaps, than in normal conditions, at any rate there was little change in the egg during the last three hours that it was under observation. (The egg has not yet been sectioned).

I have placed no emphasis on the histological characters of the nuclei, because there is great danger of misinterpretation here.


Mary Blount.


Fig. 14. — Posterior side of a longitucliual section of a pigeon's egg about twenty-five liours after fertilization, 8.50 p. m. 1. Nests of periblast nuclei. 2. Periblast nucleus. 3. Syncytial mass derived from the periblast, organizing into cells w^hicli will be added to the blastodisc. 4. Vacuoles.

!•• • -j'^ r ft-'*

Fig. 14a. — From the section as shown in Fig. 14. vm., vitelline membrane, pv., perivitelline fluid, y, yolk granules in the marginal periblast, n, the nuclear nest numbered 1 and nearest to the cleavage in Fig. 14. Leitz 4/t'2- Tube length 140 mm.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 33

Harper found eight chromatin vesicles in what he supposed were sperm nuclei in a late cleavage stage. But they were periblast nuclei, and the number of vesicles is not significant. See Figs, 14 and 14a. Riickert finds merocytes among the cells of the germ layers, and admits that it is impossible to distinguish their nuclei from others whose origin is the cleavage nucleus. But if the merosyte nuclei of the selachian are derived from the marginal blastomeres, they naturally do resemble other nuclei in the germ layers. If the reptiles and selachians would breed in confinement, so that the approximate time of fertilization could be determined, and if a close series of stages could be obtained from them as has been done from the pigeon, the material would probably demonstrate the early disappearance of the supernumerary sperm nuclei and the subsequent organization of a periblast homologous with that already described for the teleost (Agassiz and Whitman, '84,) and for the bird (Blount, '07). The homology of the periblast with the vegetative pole of the holoblastic vertebrate eggs will be discussed in another part of this paj^er (p. 49).

Function of the Supernumerary Sperms. — There still remains the question of the function of the supernumerary sperm nuclei. Bonnevie suggested that they provide the somatic chromatin and that they are offered for "die harmonische Weiterentwickelung des befruchteten Eies." But the variation in the number of spermatozoa does not support this suggestion. In the pigeon. Harper found from 12 to 25 supernumerary sperms. Elickert found in fertilization stages among nineteen areas of Pristiurus from 7 to 47, and in twenty germ areas of Torpedo in the same stages from 1 to 56 supernumerary nuclei. In the stage of the first cleavage nucleus of the adder, Ballowitz found in nine germ areas a variation from 8 to 36 supernumerary nuclei. In one-fifth of all cases, Oppel could not prove the presence of merocyte nuclei. Henking found forty-seven monospermic and forty-eight polyspermic eggs of one of the hemiptera. If one supernumerary spermatozoon is enough to restore the nucleoplasmar balance in the egg of Torpedo, fifty-six are too many. If half of the eggs of one of the hemiptera develop after the entrance of only one spermatozoon, more than one is not

34 Mary Blount.

necessary for "die harmonisclie Weiterentwickelung des befruchteten Eies." And Henking is satisfied that both the monospermic and polyspermic eggs proceed to normal development.

Riickert has suggested that perhaps the merocyte nuclei favor the division of the marginal blastomeres. In the pigeon, the primarycleavage in early stages is far from what we must suppose to be the sphere of influence of the supernumerary nuclei. It is not until after the disappearance of the latter that there is much division of the marginal blastomeres,

A nutritive function has often been assigned to these nuclei, as if they digest the yolk and pass the products on to the developing

Fig. 15. — A nucleus derived fi'om one of the supernumerary spermatozoa, and its surroundings. This is the more central of the two nuclei at the right-hand side of Fig. 2. sn., sperm nucleus, vit., vitelline membrane, y, yolk granules showing signs of digestion. Leitz 4/i\. Tube length 140 mm.

germ. Fig. 15 shows a sperm nucleus in a maturation stage (one of the nuclei in Fig. 2). It seems to be digesting the yolk around it. Riickert insists that even if they do degenerate later, they may be indispensable for nutrition in the early stages. I cannot prove that they do not function in this way. However, since the entrance of the supernumerary spermatozoa into the egg is more or less a matter of chance (in the sense that anything can be chance) and since their number varies, I cannot believe that their presence is essential to normal development. I believe that if but one spermatozoon entered the pigeon's egg, normal development might ensue.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 35

Unfortunately, this cannot be demonstrated experimentally. It seems to me that the entrance of more than one spermatozoon is a casual event. The same condition in the egg that secures fertilization (the attractive influence) also takes care of the supernumeraryspermatozoa, be they many or few. I do not consider it a protective device ( Schutzvorrichtung) .

IV. Area of Primary Cleavage.

. Maturation Stage. — The surface view of the pigeon's egg before the ai^pearance of the first cleavage plane has been previously described (p. 4, Chart I A, and Eig. 45). The periblastic zone is not conspicuous in all eggs in the maturation stage. What causes the differentiation between periblast and blastodisc, I cannot explain at present. Possibly the two areas are not distinguished from each other until the migrating sperm nuclei come to rest at the inner margin of the periblast.

Direction of the First Cleavage Plane. — The first cleavage plane may appear about 1 a. m., five hours after fertilization. Its position, and direction in relation to the axis of the future embryo seem not to be constant. There are, of course, occasional variations in the orientation of the embryo. I have found pigeon eggs in which the primitive streak was nearly parallel to the chalazal axis, and others in which the angle with the chalazal axis was about 60°, but the anterior end was toward the left instead of the right (see Fig. 1). These abnormalities in orientation are comparatively rare. But it may be that some of the eggs which I have studied in the two-celled stage which present variations in direction of the first cleavage plane, would have shown an abnormal orientation of the embryo. One egg obtained about 1.15 a. m., 51/4 hours after fertilization, had the first cleavage plane makijig an angle of about 7° with the chalazal axis. Another egg (Fig. 18) apparently has the first cleavage plane parallel to the longitudinal axis of the embryo, although this may be the second cleavage, and the first may have nearly disappeared.

I watched the development in another egg (Egg 404) (Fig. 17). When I first saw this egg at 3 a. m., there was one cleavage plane


Mary Blount.

(l-f-2) parallel to the axis of the embryo^ hut in an excentric position. In another egg (Egg 420, Fig. 16 A) in which I watched the development, there was one cleavage plane (l-j-S) visible at 2.15 a. m. and it was transverse to the axis of the future embryo. But these lines are not constantly in view. As the blastomeres of the

Fig. 16. — Two views of a living pigeon egg. A was drawn at 2.15 a. m., six and one-fourtli liours after the estimated time of fertilization. B was drawn about forty-five minutes later, between 2.50 and 3.05 a. m.

living egg separate from each other, the furrow between them is widened and is then easily seen. But when the cells press closely together, the cleavage furrow fades from view. Thus it may be that when I first saw Egg 404 (Fig. lY) the plane 3 + 4 may have heen temporarily invisible, but may have been really the first cleavage furrow, and 1+2 the second.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 37

Kolliker ('76, Fig. 16) gives a figure of a lien's egg in the twocelled stage, in which the first cleavage plane is transverse to the longitudinal axis of the embryo. He describes it as follows: "Die Keimscheibe war weiss, nahezu 3 mm. gross, von einem schmalen dunklen Ilofe umgeben und durch eine mittlcre bogenformigo Furche unvollstandig in zwei Halften geschieden." The "dunklen Hofe" is, I think, the periblast.

The Four-celled Stage. — I present a series of figures (18 to 26) of pigeon eggs in approximately the four-celled stage. The orientation is the same as indicated in Fig. 1. (Compare Fig. 25 with Kolliker ('76) Fig. 17.) In these two figures, the cleavage planes are in exactly the same relation to the chalazal axis, but in the

Fig. 17. — A living pigeou egg. When tlie egg was obtained, the cleavage furrow 1+2 was the only one in view. 3 appeared at 3.30 a. m., and 4 came at 3.3.j a. ni. The egg was obtained abont five hours after fertilization.

hen's egg the axis of the embryo is at right angles to the chalaza, and in the pigeon's egg the embryo is diagonal (Fig. 1). A comparison of all these figures suggests that the early cleavage planes of the pigeon's egg bear no constant relation to the axis of the future embryo.

Asymmetry. — These figures also suggest what is confirmed in later stages (see Figs. 27 to 40 and see photographs), that the cleavage is not always excentric, as represented by Kolliker, "Die Furchung geht immer asymmetrisch vor sicli, so dass oline Ausnahme die eine Halfte der Keimscheibe in der Zerklilftung dor andern voran ist und die Haui^tmasse der Kugeln und ebenso die kleineren Segmente


Mary Blount.

Fig. 18. — Surface view of a pigeon's egg taken from the oviduct at 11.35 p. m., 7 hours and 40 minutes after the bird had laid another egg. The longer cleavage plane is parallel to the axis of the future embryo. There was no accessory cleavage, but the periblast and blastodisc were differentiated.

Fig. 19. — Surface view of a pigeon egg taken from the oviduct at 1.00 a. m., about 5 hours after fertilization. Notice the blastodisc and periblast, and the excentric position of the cleavage.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg.






^ J^

Fig. 21.

Fig. 20.

Fig. 20. — Surface view of pigeon egg as it appeared at 3.00 a. m., about seven hours after fertilization.

Fig. 21. — Surface view of pigeon egg obtained at 3.30 a. m., seven and onehalf hours after the estimated time of fertilization.

Fig. 22. — Pigeon egg taken at 2.00 a. m., six hours after the estimated time of fertilization. The same egg is shown in Chart II A.


Mary Bloniit.

Fig 23.

Fig. 24.

Fig. 23. — Pigeon egg obtained at tliree o'clock a. m., about seven liours after fertilization.

Fig. 24. — Pigeon egg obtained at 4.00 a. m., eiglit liours after the estimated time of fertilization.

Fig. 25.— Pigeon egg taken from oviduct at 3.15 a. m., about seven and onefourth hours after fertilization.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 41

und kleinercn KngX'ln der einen Hiilfte der Keimscheibe angehoren und der Mittelpunkt des Feldes mit Eurchnngskugeln excentrisch liegt." (Kollikcr ('7G), p. Y9.)

Fig. 26. — Pigeon egg six and one-Iialf hours after tlie estimated time of fertilization, 2.30 a. m.

Fig. 27. — .Surface view of a pigeon egg at 3.15 a. m., about seven and.onefourtli liours after fertilization. Compare witli Figs. 28, 20 and 30. Tlie numbers suggest homologies in cells, but have no reference to order of cleavage.

The EigJd-celled and Later Stages. — Eggs in approximately the eight-celled stage are shown in Figs. 27 to 37. There is here quite a variety in the cleavage pattern. Fig. 27 lacks only one plane


Mary Blount.

Fig. 28.

Fig. 29.

Fig. 30.

Fig. 28. — Pigeon egg at 4.30 a. m., eight and one-tialf liours after fertilization. Compare Figs. 27, 29 and 30.

Fig. 29. — Pigeon egg at 4.45 a. m., eight and three-fourths hours after fertilization. Compare Figs. 27, 28 and 30.

Fig. 30. — Diagram of the teleost egg in the 8-celled stage. Compare with Figs. 27, 28 and 29.

Fig. 31.

Fig. 32.

Fig. 31. — Pigeon egg at 3 a. m., seven hours after fertilization. Fig. 32. — Pigeon egg obtained at 4.30 a. m., eight and one-half hours from fertilization.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 43

Fig. 33. — Pigeon egg at 4.00 a. m., eight hours after fertilization.

Fig. 34.

Fig. 35.

Fig. 34. — Pigeon egg at 2.30 a. m., six and one-half hours after fertilization. Fig. 35. — Pigeon egg at five o'clock a. m., nine hours after fertilization.


Mary Blount.

Fig. 36. — Pigeon egg at 4.15 a. in., eight and one-fourth hours after fertilization.

Fig. 37.

Fu:. 38.

Fig. 37. — I'igeon ogg at 4.45 a. ni., eight and three-fourths Iiours after the estimated time of fertilization. 1. Accessory cleavage. 2. Periblast, a, b, c, d, cells of the primary cleaA'age which are indicated by corresponding letters in Fig. 5. The section represented in Fig. 5 is taken along the line xy.

Fig. 38. — Pigeon egg at 5.00 a. ni., nine hours after fertilization.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 45

Fig. 39. — Pigeon egg at 5.1.5 a. m., nine and one-fourth hours from fertilization.

Fig. 40. — Pigeon egg at 4.4.5 a. ni., eight and three-fourtlis hours after fertilization.

46 Mary Blount.

from being identical with Harjier's ('04) Fig. 43, and these both resemble the eight-celled stage of the teleost (Wilson, II. V., '91, Fig. G, and Agassiz and Whitman, '89, PI. xx. Fig. 19). Fig. 30 is a diagram of the teleost egg in the eight-celled stage. It is numbered for comparison with certain pigeon eggs. Fig. 27, 28, 29. The numbers merely indicate the homologies of the cells and are not intended to signify the order of segmentation.

Following the eight-celled stage, cells are cut off from the central ends of the large blastomeres and there are then established three principal regions, as I have described in my preliminary paper: (1) the central area, (2) the marginal cells, (3) the periblast. The cells of the central area are Kolliker's "Furchungskugeln." The marginal cells are his Segmenten." As cleavage proceeds, cells are cut off centrally from the marginal cells and added to the central area, and thus the latter grows at the expense of the former. Radial cleavage planes divide the marginal cells, and increase their number while the central cells are constantly becoming smaller by division. This is well illustrated in photographs of a number of different eggs (Figs. 46 to 54) and especially in two photographs of the same egg (358), (Figs. 50 and 51).

Finally, the marginal cells are all used up and we recognize only two regions in the blastoderm: (1) the central area, and (2) the periblast. In early stages, all of the cells are continuous with the yolk (see Fig. 4), but as development proceeds the central cells become complete below and separate from the yolk (see Figs. 5, 6, 11) and only the marginal cells are open below. Thus the marginal cells constitute a "zone of junction" (see Agassiz and Wliitman, '84, Figs. 2, 3, 4, and 5) between the segmented and unsegmented parts of the egg.

V. The Segmentation Cavity. Description by Duval. — The position of the segmentation cavity in the bird's egg has been a subject of considerable discussion. Duval ('84) gives two figures (Figs. 4 and 5) of longitudinal sections of just laid, unfertilized hen's eggs, in which he identifies the segmentation cavity as a small space just below the upper layer

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg.


of cells. Below the segmentation cavity there is a layer of cells continuous with the yolk. Stages of later cleavage of the pheasant and the canary are shown in Duval's Figs. 7 and 8 respectively. Here again the segmentation cavity is below the upper layer of cells, i. e., it is between the upper layer and a mass of cells which has been added to the germinal area from the syncytial yolk.

Description hy Kolliher. — Kolliker ('76) describes the blastoderm of the hen's egg as increasing in depth by additions from the "Bildungsdotter." His Fig. 18 presents the surface view of the germ area of a hen's egg in which there are twenty-one cells, and his Fig. 19 gives a vertical section through the same egg. This section shows one layer of four cells in which there are two central "Furchungskugeln" and the two marginal "Segmenten." Below this layer of cells is the unsegmented "Bildungsdotter" and below that is the funnel-shaped white yolk (Fig. 41). He describes the blastoderm as increasing in depth as cleavage progresses. None of the







-. A

- -





Fig. 41. — Copy of Kolliker's ('76) Fig. 19. gd.. Gelber Dotter. wd., weisser Dotter. bd., ungefiircliter Bildungsdotter. s', grosses Segment, s, kleines Segment, k, Kugeln.

cells is completely cut off from the "Bildungsdotter." They fonn a layer 0.14 mm. in depth in the center. A section through a later stage in the development of the hen's egg is shown in Kolliker's Figure 22, (Fig. 42) where "die Dicke der durchfurchten Stelle in der Mitte des Keimes gerade noch einmal so dick war, als in dem friiher beschriebenen Falle (Fig. 19 ), namlich 0.28-0.30 mm." "Somit greift die Durchfu.rchung indem sie weiterschreitet in der Mitte der Keimschicht immer mehr in die Tiefe, wie schon Oellacher dies vermuthet hat, und erreicht am Ende nahezu die Grenze der Lage die in der Fig. 10 mit bd als ungefurchter Bildungsdotter bezeichnet ist." (Kolliker, '76, p. 74.)

48 Mary Blount.

Kolliker suggests that the adding of cells from below may be by a process similar to the adding of cells to the central part from the marginal segments, i. e., the nucleus of a marginal segment divides and the central end of the segment containing one of the daughter nuclei is cut off and becomes a "Furchungskugel." The other daughter nucleus passes into the marginal segment, and so on until finally the part of the marginal segment left over changes into a "Furchungskugel." And so, according to Kolliker, the first appearing "Furchungskugeln" are never completely cut off from the unsegmented "Bildungsdotter" below, but nuclei, sisters to those in the first layer of cells, pass down into the "Bildungsdotter." Here nuclear division takes place, and cells are organized around the upper daughter nuclei, thus forming the second layer of cells in the center of the blastodisc, while the lower daughter nuclei are left deeper


Fig. 42.— Copy of Kolliker's ('76) Fig. 22. Senkrecliter Schnitt durcb die Furcbungsstelle eines Hiihiiereies aus dem Uterus, s, grosses Segment; s', kleines Segment ; k, grosse einschichtige Randkugeln ; k', kleinere Kugelu aus der Mitte geschichtet ; wd, weisser Dotter.

in the "Biildungsdotter." And thus cleavage proceeds downward until finally the last remaining nucleated portions of the "Bildungsdotter" change over into "Furchungskugeln."

The Segmentation Cavity of the Pigeon's Egg is homologous with that of other vertebrate eggs. — But in the pigeon's egg, I do not find any such deepening of the center of the blastodisc. The change from one to several layers of cells is by a process exactly like that of the teleost egg. (See Agassiz and Whitman, '84, Fig. 2, and Wilson, H. W.-, '91, Figs. 16, 17, 18, and 19.) The blastodisc of the pigeon's egg becomes stratified by horizontal cleavage planes arising above the first horizontal cleavage, i. e., above the level of the plane which limits the cell h below (Fig. 5). Nuclei are never found in the central part below the level of the horizontal cleavage under tlie cell h, — at least not until a much later stage.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 49

In the description of the early development as given in the first part of this paper, it was pointed out that the position of the seg-mentation cavity may be indicated as early as the maturation stage, and certainly by the depth of the first vertical cleavage. And a comparison of sections of eggs of successive stages as represented by Figs. 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 11 (these figures are drawn to the same scale) shows the depth of the blastodisc to be constant in cleavage stages.

VI. The Periblast of the BrRD's Egg Compared With the Vegetative Pole of Holoblastic Vertebrate Eggs.

The position of the segmentation cavity as I have found it in the pigeon's egg, presents an exact parallel of the bird's egg, in this respect, with other vertebrate eggs. And it supports the conception that the unsegmented part of the bird's egg (periblast plus yolk) is homologous with the cells at the vegetative pole or holoblastic vertebrate eggs. To the unsegmented part of the bird's egg His ('00) applied the physiological term "Lecithoblast." "In den dotterarmen Eiem der Siiugethiere geht nach Ablauf der Furchung der gesammte Eiinhalt in der Bildung von Keimzellen auf. Anfangs zeigen die Blastomeren gewisse Unterschiede der Grosse und des Deutoplasmagehaltes, indessen kommt es nicht zur Bildung besonderer Dotteransammlungen. In Eiern mit reichlicherem Dotter sind die Vorgiinge complicirter : Entweder greift die Furchung trotz des Dotterreichthums durch den gesammten Eiinhalt durch, oder es vollzieht sich eine raumliche Scheidung zwischen dem Keimplasma und dem unorganisirten Dotter.

"Die durchgreifende Furchung dotterreicher Eier kennen wir bei Amphibien, Ganoiden und Cyklostomeii. Sie vollzieht sich in den verschiedenen Abschnitten der Eier ungleich rasch, in der oberen Hiilfte rascher als in der unteren. Letztere, in der vom Anfang ab die Dotterplattchen reichlicher angehauft sind, besteht noch aus grosseren Blastomeren, wenn die in der oberen Halfte entstandenen kleinen Zellen sich bereits anschicken, Keimblatter zu bilden und in zunehmender Fliichenausdehnung die untere Halfte zu umwachsen. Die umwachsene Blastomeren


Mary Blount.

masse betheiligt sicli nicht an der Keimblattbildung, sie erhalt sich als ein mehr oder minder compacter, mit dem Hypoblast in Verbindung bleibender Klumpen, der zunachst eine Dotterreserve

bildet. Bei den genannten Eiformen ist iibrigens von Anfang

ab die Scheidung von Plasma und Dotter eine unvollkommene. Daher

Fig. 43. — Diagrams of sections of tliree vertebrate eggs. 1. Amphioxus. 2. Frog. 3. Pigeon.

sind die Keimblatt- und die Organzellen noch wahrend geraumer Zeit mit grosseren oder kleineren Dotterplattchen beladen.

"Zu einer raumlichen Scbeidung von Keimplasma und unorganisirtem Dotter kommt es bei den sog, meroblastischen Eiem der Knochenfische, Selachier, Reptilien und Vogel. Am reinlichsten

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg.


vollzieht sie sich bei denen der Knochenfische, deren Blastomeren friihzeitig von korperlichen Dotterbestandtheilen frei erscheinen." (His, '00, p. 187.)

Three diagrams (Fig. 43) represent median vertical sections of the egg of amphioxus, the frog, and the pigeon. In amphioxus, the cells at the vegetative pole are but slightly larger than those at the animal pole, and the segmentation cavity is nearly central. In the amphibia, the segmentation cavity is nearer the animal pole, and the vegetative cells are large, but are separated from each other.


c p

Fig. 44. — Diagrams of transverse sections of tlie eggs of (a) ctenolabrns, and (b) the pigeon. A is copied from Agassiz and Wliitmau ('84) Fig. 2. I tiave inserted tlie dotted lines to indicate the region from which cells are added from the periblast to the blastodisc. mc, marginal cell ; cc, central cell ; mp, marginal periblast; cp, central periblast; sc, segmentation cavity.

In the bird, the segmentation cavity is much further removed from the vegetative pole, and in relation to the size of the egg it is too small for comparison with the homologous cavity in the other eggs. The cells of the vegetative pole are not separated from each other, but they are the syncytial periblast. The cytoplasmic portion of the cells is confined to the animal pole, while their yolk contents occupy the entire remaining part of the egg. In Ctenolabrns cells are added to the central area from the marginal cells until the end of the period of cleavage (Agassiz and Whitman, '84, Fig. 5). The

52 Mary Blount.

dotted lines in the diagram (Fig. 44a) indicate the region of the periblast from which cells are added to the blastodisc. In the pigeon, however, this region is of greater extent (Fig. 44b) and cells are added to the blastodisc from the central periblast. Only the central part of the latter does not contain nuclei, and does not proliferate cells upward. I must explain Kolliker's description of the deepening of the blastodisc in this way. According to his description, it is impossible to homologise the cleavage of the bird's egg with that of other vertebrate eggs. Probably the deeper cells of the germinal area of Duval's ('84) Figs. 7 and 8 are derived from the periblast, and are to be regarded as holding the same relation to the cleavage of the blastoderm as those added from the zone of junction to the blastodisc in the teleost egg.


A summary of the behavior of the supernumerary sperm nuclei during the first twelve hours after fertilization was given on page 18 and need not be repeated here.

1. Polyspermy. — Polyspermy has been reported in the Bryozoa, Holothuroidea, Insects, Selachians, Amphibians, Reptiles, Birds, and in one of the Gnetales. Polyspermy seems to take place because of the lack of protection against it. The migration of the supernumerary sperm nuclei in the pigeon (and perhaps in other forms) is a response to the attractive influence of the unfertilized cytoplasm in parts of the egg distant from the egg nucleus. The supernumerary sperm nuclei perform no important function in the egg ; their presence is a matter of chance ; and they are not essential to normal development. The accessory cleavage is comparable to the segmentation of fertilized enucleated egg fragments.

2. Area of Primary Cleavage. — The blastodisc and periblast are differentiated in the surface view in the maturation stage. The early cleavage planes bear no constant relation to the axis of the future embryo. Cleavage is not always asymmetrical. In the surface view there are three concentric areas: (1) the central, (2) the marginal area, and (3) the periblast. Cells are cut off centrally from the marginal cells and are added to the central area until the former

The Early DcvGloi)mcnt of the Pigeon's Egg. 53

are used up, and then there are only the central area and the periblast. The marginal cells constitute a zone of junction between the blastodisc and the periblast.

3. The Segmentation Cavity. — The first horizontal cleavage plane marks the position of the segmentation cavity. The blastodisc becomes stratified by horizontal })lanes arising above this one, and the bird's egg in this respect is homologous with other vertebrate eggs.

4. The periblast of the bird's egg is the homologue of the cells of the vegetative pole of holoblastic vertebrate eggs.

LITERATURE. Agassiz, a., and Whitman, C. O., '84. On the Development of some Pelagic

Fisb Eggs. Preliminary Notice. Proc. Amer. Acad. Arts and Sciences,

XX. Agassiz, A., and Whitman, C. O., 'St). The Development of Osseus Fishes.

Memoirs of the Museum of Comparative Zoology at Harvard College.

XIV, p. 1. Ballowitz, Emil, '03. Die Entwickelungsgeschichte der Kreuzotter (Pelia»

berus Merr). Tell I. Die Entwickelung vom Auftreten der ersten

Furche bis zum Schluss des Amnios. Jena. Blount, Mary, '07. The early Development of the Pigeon's Egg with especial reference to the Supernumerary Sperm Nuclei, the Periblast and

the Germ Wall. A preliminary paper. Biological Bulletin, Vol. XIII,

No. 5. BoNNEViE, Kristine, '07. Untersuchung iiber Keimzellen Bryozoen. Jena ische Zeitschrift fiir Naturwissenschaft. Vol. XLII, 1907. von Brunn, a., '82. Die Riickbildung uicbt ausgestossener Eierstockeier

bei den Vogeln. Beitriige zur Anat. u. Embr. als Festgabe. J. Ilenle,

1882. Duval, '84. De la Formation de Blastoderm dans I'Oeuf d'Oiseau. Ann.

des Scienc. natur. Zoologie. Series 6. Tome XVIII. Harper, E. H., '04. The Fertilization and early Development of the Pigeon's

Egg. Amer. Jour, of Anat., Vol. Ill, No. 4. Henning, H., '92. Untersuchung iiber die ersten Entwicklungsvorgange in

den Eiern der Insekten. III. Zeitschrift fiir wissenschaftliche Zoologie, Bd. LIV. Henneguy. F., "02. Sur la formation de I'oeuf, la maturation et la feconda tion de I'oocyte chez le Distomum hepaticum. Compt. rend. Acad. Sc, Paris. T. 134, p. 123.5. IIis, Wm., '00. Lecithoblast und Angioblast der Wirbelthiere. Abhand lungen der Konigl. SJichs. Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften. 45. Math. Phys., Classe 26. Leipzig.

54 Mary Blount.

IWANZOBT, '98. Ueber die physlologische Bedeutung des Processes der Eirei fung. Bull. Soc. Imp. Nat. Mosc, T. II, 1897 ('98). Johnston, J. B., '03. An Imbedding Medium for Brittle Objects. Journal

of Applied Microscopy, Vol. VI, No. 12, p. 2662. Jordan, E. O., '93. The Habits and Development of the Newt. Jour. Morph.,

Vol. VIII. KoLLiKEE, AxBERT VON, '76. Eutwicklungsgeschichte des Menschen und der

hoheren Thiere. Leipzig. Korschelt-Heideb, '08. Eutwicklungsgeschichte der wirbellosen Thiere.

Allgemeiner Theil. Jena, 1902, p. 696. liAND, W. J. G;, '07. Fertilization and Embryogeny in Ephedra trifurca.

Botanical Gazette, October, 1907, Vol. XLIV, No. 4. Oppel, Albert, '92. Die Befruchtung des Reptilieneies. Archiv fiir Mikro skopische Anatomie, Vol. XXXIX. RtJCKEBT, '99. Die erste Entwickelung des Eies der Elasmobranchier. Festschrift zum Sieb. Geb. von Carl von Kupffer. Jena. Wilson, E. B., '00. The Cell in Development and Inheritance. New York,

1900. Wilson, E. B., '03. Experiments on Cleavage and Localization in the Nemer tine egg. Archiv fiir Entwickelungsmechauik der Organismen, Vol. 16.

1903. Wilson, H. V., '91. The Embryology of the Sea Bass (Serranus Atrarius).

Bull. U. S. F. C, Vol. 9, pp. 209-277.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg.


Fig. 45. — Pliotograpli of a i)igeuu egg iu the maturation stage. 11.30 p. ni., 3% hours after fertilization. The photograph was taken with reflected light from the whole mount, per, perihlast. bl, blastodisc.


Mary Bloimt.

Fig. 4G. — I'liotugruyli ul' u iii^^'oii egj,% eight and one fourlh hours after fertilization. 4.15 a. m. Killed and pliotographed in 5 per cent, formalin in normal salt solution.

The Early Devclopiiieut of the Pigeon's Egg,


Fig. 47. — I'hotograpli of pigeon egg at 2.30 a. ni., aliout six and one-half hours after fertilization. Killed and photographed in 5 per cent formalin in normal salt solution. Notice the vacuoles in the yolk surrounding the blastoderm.


Mary Blount.

Fig. 48. — Photograph of a pigeon egg seven and three-fourths hours after fertilization, 3.45 a. m. The anterior side of the blastoderm is toward the point of the arrow.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 59

Fig. 49. — Photograph of pigeon egg. Bird killed at 5 a. ui., nine hours after the estimated time of fertilization. Egg was in salt solution when photographed.


Mary Blount.

Fig. 50. — Photograph of a living pigeon egg. The bird was Ivilled at 6 a. m., ten hours after fertilization of the egg. The photograph was taken through a window in the shell at 6.45 a. m. Then the egg was incubated until 11 a. in., when it was killed. A photograph from the whole mount of the later stage of the egg is shown in Fig. 47.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg.


Fig. 51. — Photograpli of a pigeon egg at 11.00 a. m., fifteen hours after fertilization. An earlier stage of the same egg is shown in Fig. 50. This photograph is taken from a whole mount, with reflected light. The light areas at the anterior and right side are due to breaks in the yolk. The light irregular circle is caused by a crack in the material.


Mary Blount.

Fig. 52. — Photograph of pigeon egg, eleven hours after fertilization, 7.10 a. m. The point of the arrow indicates the anterior side.

The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg. 63

Fig. 53.— Photograph of a pigeon's egg at 7.00 a. m., about eleven hours after fertilization.


Mary Blount.

Fig. 54. — I'liotograph of pigeon's egg thirteen and one-half hours after fertilization, 9.30 a. m. Anterior side of blastoderm toward point of arrow.




I. lutrodiiction — Statement of Problem 65

II. Material and Methods G7

III. Gastrulation 73

A. Study of the Developing Egg 73

B. Study of Sections 78

a. Pregastrular Stages 78

b. Gastrulation Stages 80

( 1 ) Invagination 8G

Experiment I 88

(2) Middle and Late Gastrulation Stages 92

Experiment II 93

Closing of the Blastopore 100

Interruption of the Posterior Zone of Junction 103

c. Postgastrular Stages 103

IV. Experimental Studies 108

Set A. On Early Gastrular Stages 109

Experiments III-V 110

Set B. On Late Gastrular Stages 112

Experiments VI-VIII 112

Set C. On Unincubated and Early Incubated Stages 113

Experiments IX-XIII 114-116

V. Discussion and Summary 116

Discussion 116

Summary ll<j

Literature Cited 121

C'ommon Reference lietters Used in the Figures 123

Plates, I-X.

I. Introduction.

In view of the- fact that the bird has long been the classic type

in the field of embryological research, it is surprising that the question of the origin of the entoderm^ in this form should have

'From the Department of Zoology, University of Chicago.

^The terms entoderm, gut-entoderm, and invaginated-entoderm will be used synonymously throughout this paper.

TiTE .TouRNAL OF MoRrnoLOOY — Vol. XX, No. 1.

GQ J. Thos. Patterson.

remained unsatisfactorily answered. Nearly all recent writers acknowledge that the problem is far from being solved. Thus Nowack, writing in 1902, admits that he has failed to make clear the exact manner in which the entoderm takes its origin. He says, "Ich bin leider nicht in der Lage, auf Grund meiner Praparate eine absolut sichere Erkliirung liber die Entstehung des inneren Keimblattes zu geben. Das aber kann ich mit aller Bestimmtheit behaupten, dass das Entoderm nicht als eine Einstiilpung am Rande des Blastoderms entsteht, wie es nach Duval der Fall sein soll."^ The study of comparative embryology, nevertheless, would lead us to expect to find this germ layer arising by a process of gastrulation. Aside from a few descriptions of isolated stages, however, the theory of gastrulation is supported, by actual observations, only in the work of Duval ('84) ; but Duval's interpretation has been disputed on the ground that he was probably misled through the use of pathological material (Kionka, '94, Barfurth, '95, Schauinsland '99) ; and, as I have previously pointed out ('07, 6), this author's work tends to support the idea of delamination. In this connection the statement of Hertwig ('03) is of special interest, in that he has often quoted Duval in support of gastrulation, but now says, "Der Darstellung Duval's war ich in meinem Lehrbuch liingere Zeit gefolgt, halte sie aber jetzt nicht mehr fiir richtig und glaube, dass die in Fig. 482'* am hinteren Rand der Keimhaut abgebildete Spalte zwischen Embryonalzellen und peripherem Dottersyncytium durch die Hartung oder beim Schneider kiinstlich erzeugt ist und mit einer Gastrulation nichts zu thun hat."^

Before a complete history of the early development of the bird can be written, therefore, it is necessary to give a detailed account, not only of gastrulation itself, but also of the stages preceding and immediately following it. Such an account is rendered possible by the fact that the writer has been able to secure a close series of stages covering this period of development.

The results recorded here are the outcome of a line of investiga ^Loc. cit., p. 27.

^Hertwig bere refers to Fig. 8, Piute I, of Duval ('84).

^Loc. cit., p. 8G1.

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg. 67

tion suggested to me by Professor Whitman, to whom I am indebted, not only for scholarly criticism, but also for his inspiring ideals of research. This paper is one of the series designed by Professor Whitman for the purpose of giving an account of the Natural History of Pigeons.^ I also wish to express my gratitude to Professor F. R. Lillie for his assistance, and to the other members of the department for their interest in the work.

II. Material and Methods.

For the purpose of these studies the egg of the common pigeon offers several advantages over that of any other bird. (1) Its small size makes it especially easy to handle in preparing sections. (2) The fact that this bird breeds readily in confinement renders it possible to secure absolutely fresh material. (3) Undoubtedly the greatest advantage, however, is that of being able to secure all the early stages of development in definite sequence. This is made possible by the regularity of the laying habits of the pigeon, which ordinarily lays two eggs for each sitting. The first is laid late in the afternoon, usually between four and six p. m., and the second between one and two p. m. on the second day following. Harper ('04) has shown that fertilization in the latter egg occurs shortly before it enters the oviduct, about four hours after the first egg is laid, that is, at about eight p. m. The second egg is, therefore, forty-one hours in passing down the oviduct. Hence, by killing birds at various hours in the interval between the two eggs a close series of developmental stages can be secured. Such a series is indispensable to the discovery of demonstrative evidence of gastrulation and to a correct interpretation of the attendant phenomena.

In fixing the egg I have followed the method employed by Harper, in that the whole yolk is fixed and hardened before any attempt is made to cut out an oriented block of yolk containing the blastoderm. For fixing, various reagents have been employed, but the picro-acetic mixtures have proved superior to all others and during

•The series so far embraces the following: Guyer ('00), Harper ('04), Blount ('07), Patterson ('07 b), Riddle ('08).

68 J. Thos. Patterson.

the past year have been used almost exclusively. It was found advisable to vary the percentage of acetic acid with the age of the blastoderm.

For the most part, Delafield's ha^matoxylin has been used for staining, although iron hsematoxylin and carmine have been employed. In connection with the cytological work I have used the anilin dyes to good advantage.

In stages prior to the appearance of the primitive streak it is necessary to determine the orientation of the blastoderm before using the fixing fluid. Fig. I, the scheme for orienting, shows that the axis of the embrj^o meets the chalazal axis at an angle of 45° instead of at right angles, as is the case in the chick. For experi

FiG. I. Scheme for orienting the blastoderm of the pigeon's egg in cutting sections, a, shell ; b, blastoderm at the first appearance of the primitive streak ; c, chalaza, which is sometimes double at the pointed end of the egg ; V, vitelline membrane ; e, wedge-shaped block of yolk containing the blastoderm which is cut out and embedded for sections.

mental work it is very important to know whether or not this angle is constant, particularly in experiments designed to demonstrate the movement of materials in the blastoderm. In order to determine this point, the record of about 200 eggs was kept, from which it was found that eight per cent show abnormal chalazee. Of those with normal chalaza?, ninety per cent show the angle to be 45°, while in the remaining ten per cent it varies 1-5° from this angle. In the case of abnormalities the defect is usually found at the broad end of the egg, where the chalaza is either rudimentary or entirely' wanting, or else its place of attachment to the vitelline membrane varies. In any of these cases the angle may vary greatly, e\en as much as 180°.

Gastriilatioii in the Pigeon's Ec-ff. 69


In most cg'gs the attaclmicnt of tlic cbalaza to the membrane at the pointed end of the egg is much more intimate than at the opposite end. This, together with the fact that the position of the embryo upon the bhistoderm is constant, has led the writer to believe that the chahiza3 phij an important role in maintaining the orientation of the egg in the oviduct. It seems very probable that the place for the attachment of the chalazse to the vitelline membrane, nt least at the small end of the egg, is determined in the ovary. ^

From what has just been said it is obvious that eggs with abnormal chalazse can be used neither for experimental work nor for sections, because the plane of section can not be determined. Consequently the utmost care has been taken in this work to detect and discard such eggs.

Special attention has been given to methods and means of experimentation, for it became increasingly apparent as the work progressed that there was need of a much more refined technique than that used by previous workers in this field. I have, in sterilization and in opening and closing the window in the shell, employed, in the main, the methods described in a previous paper (Patterson, '07, a), and they therefore need little explanation. A one tenth per cent solution of bichloride of mercury is used for sterilizing all instruments, except the operating needle, which is sterilized in alcohol. The wandow in the shell is made by the aid of a fine pair of forceps, and after the operation is performed, this opening is sealed with a piece of shell from a fresh egg, and a piece of sterilized cotton is placed over the closed window. The egg is then revolved until it is completely inverted, and thus, as the yolk turns, the blastoderm is brought uppermost into a nonnal environment. "Control" eggs show that by this method, not only is infection re<luced to the minimum but also that the retardation in development which ordinarily accompanies this kind of work, is greatly reduced. After the operated egg has been developed for the desired time, it is taken from the incubator and the upper half of the shell removed. This allows one to determine the relation existing between the axis

'The writer has made observations and experiments to determine tliis point, but as yet they are incomplete.


J. Thos. Patterson.

of the embryo and that of the chalazse, and consequently enables one to decide whether or not it is necessary to discard the egg.

For making the injury a No. 16 bead" needle is employed. Although the diameter of this needle is small, yet it is entirely too large for very fine work, and so it was ground down to the desired diameter on an emery stone and then polished on a fine water-stone. By this means I have been able to secure a needle-point with a fineness of about 0.04 mm.

Fig. II. Apparatus used in operating.

By the aid of a special piece of apparatus, which is, in part, a modification of the one described by McClendou ('06), the needle is inserted in the blastoderm at the desired point. This apparatus is attached to a binocular and consists of an upright post fastened to the left end of the sliding bar of a Spencer mechanical-stage. Within the post the vertical end of an elbow is moved up and down by means of a rack and pinion. On the free end of the horizontal part of the elbow is a clamp which works on a universal joint. In operating, the needle-holder, which is connected with two dry battery

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg.


cells (see Fig. II), is held in the clamp, and by means of the universal joint the point of the needle is brought to bear directly over the blastoderm. To make the injury, the operator observes the magnified blastoderm (magnified 12.6 diameters) through the binocular, and with the right hand moves the needle horizontally by the mechanicalstage until the needle-point is directly above the place to be injured. The point is then inserted- by adjusting the rack and pinion with the left hand, and the circuit is completed immediately by touching the second needle to the albumin. The extent of the injury can be regulated either by the number of battery cells included in the circuit, or by the length of time the current is allowed to run.

4 3 2 10 1 2 3 4

Fig. III. Eye-piece micrometer whicli is placed in one of the oculars of the binocular, and thus the blastoderm appears to the observer as plotted into small squares.

In order not to expose the blastoderm unduly while operating on early stages, it is highly desirable to have some quick and easy method for locating the place to be injured. This is done by using a netmicrometer, which is placed in one of the oculars, and thus the blastoderm is plotted into small squares. Two grades of micrometers are used, one ruled into 0.1 mm. and the other 0.5 mm. squares. A drawing of the latter kind is shown in Fig. III. In practice, the egg is placed in a depression at the top of a large cork, which, with the egg, can then be moved about on the stage of the binocular. In this way


J. Thos. Patterson.

the center of the blastoderm can be made to coincide with that of the micrometer. The numbers at the sides of the ruled area allow one to determine quickly the dimensions of the blastoderm, and at the same time the record of an injury in any quadrant is easily read in the terms of its co-ordinates.

In operating with this instrument there is a three-fold advantage

Fig. IV. Microscope-stage incubator used in studying the living egg

over the free hand method: (1) the place to be injured is easily located; (2) the injury is made with mechanical precision; and (3) consequently the results obtained for any given set of operations are practically constant.

In connection with the experimental work as well as with the study of sections it is important to make direct observations on the

Gastriilatiun in the Pigeon's Egg. 73

developing egg. In order to do this it was necessary to devise a microscope-stage incubator, a photograph of which is shown in Fig. IV. This apparatus is so constructed that it can be used with either a binocular or compound microscope, and, in case the latter is employed, camera drawings can be made of the object under observation.

The water in the incubator is heated by an incandescent lamp (I) controlled by an electric thermoregulator (7-), which can be adjusted so that any constant temperature may be maintained in the region of the egg-cell (e).^

To study the developing egg, a hole is made in the shell and the blastoderm thus exposed is covered with fresh albumin. It is then placed in the egg-cell and nearly surrounded with sterile physiological salt solution, and the whole dish is cohered with a thin glass plate. In this moist chamber eggs develop normally at least for several hours (in one case for thirty-three), and I have been al)le to study them, not only during the entire period of gastrulation, but also during many cleavage stages.

III. Gastrulation. A. Study of the Developing Egg.

The individual variation in the development of pigeon eggs amounts ordinarily to about two hours, although in some cases it may reach as high as five hours. Owing to this variation it is difficult to set exact time limits to the process of gastrulation. In general, however, it may be said to occur between thirty-four and thirty-seven hours after fertilization. This conclusion is based on the fact that the youngest and oldest stages of gastrulation are usually found in eggs taken thirty-four and thirty-seven hours respectively after fertilization, and is further supported by t\ie data gathered from a study of the developing egg. This does not mean that gastrulation in a given egg lasts for three hours. Indeed, in all probability not oveT two and a half hours elapse between the involution of the posterior margin and the closing of the l)lastopore.

For a description of tliis incuhator, see the Biol. Bull, for May, 1908, Vol. XIV, No. 6.

Y4 J. Thos. Patterson.

In order to understand fully the process of gastrulation, it will be necessary to consider somewhat in detail a series of stages covering a period of at least thirteen hours preceding the involution of the margin. Indeed, a knowledge of the entire history of cleavage is necessary ; for all these early stages may be said to be preparatory to gastrulation. It does not fall within the scope of this paper, however, to consider these earlier periods. They have been studied and described by Miss Blount ('07). According to her account the supernumerary sperm nuclei disappear between ten and twelve hours after fertilization, and the marginal cells then "open peripherally and the periblast becomes organized with nuclei derived from the cleavage nucleus." From this time on the blastodisc increases in diameter by the addition of cells from the marginal and central periblast, cells which are "individualized" about the periblastic nuclei.

In the study of surface views of the developing egg, the changes observed between twenty and twenty-eight hours after fertilization are not very noticeable, for during the greater part of this period the blastoderm appears as a white opaque disc, there being no differentiation into areas opaca and pellucida. The disc, however, is not of equal opacity in all places, for the central region is more opaque than the marginal zone, these two parts gradually merging into each other. From the twentieth to the twenty-fifth hour^ the margin of the disc is very irregular and gradually fades out into the surrounding zone of white yolk, which, for the most part, constitutes the "marginal periblast." From the twenty-fifth to the twentyeighth hour the margin gradually becomes more regular and distinct, and at the same time the central opaque region increases rapidly, almost doubling its diameter. By the twenty-ninth hour the margin is still more regular and distinct, and the circumference of the disc is almost a circle (Fig. V, A).

Between the twenty-ninth and thirty-first hours the entire disc becomes more uniformily opaque, that is, the marginal region becomes thicker. This condition lasts but a few minutes, for almost immediately a small area lying just posterior to the center of the disc

'Throughout this paper the age of the egg will be designated by the number of hours that have elapsed after fertilization has taken place.

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg. Y5

gradually becomes less opaque (Fig. V, B). This eccentrically lying region is the beginning of the area pellucida, and is brought about by the development of the subgerminal cavity, together with the thinning-out of that portion of the disc lying directly above this cavity. At first the boundary between the areas opaca and pellucida is very indistinct. In fact, this is more or less true throughout the entire period of gastrulation, and it is not until just a few hours before the egg is laid that a sharp differentiation between these two areas is established — a condition characteristic of the nnincubated blastoderm.

Within forty-five minutes after its appearance, the area pellucida has practically doubled its diameter (Fig. V, C), this expansion taking place most rapidly toward the posterior margin. During the next two hours and a half the changes consist in an extension of the processes just described (Fig. V, D-F). In some eases the area pellucida extends almost to the posterior edge of the blastodisc, while in others it is difficult to determine from surface views the exact condition of this margin. Under high magniificatiou, however, the posterior edge of the disc is seen to differ from the rest of the margin, in that it does not blend into the surrounding yoIJv, hut eiuis rather distinctly.

At about thirty-four hours there occurs the most significant change yet observed. It is the appearance of an indentation at the posterior edge of the blastodisc. This bay is the beginning of the gastrulainvagination , and often takes the form of a distinct marginal notch (Fig. V, G). The edge of the disc included within the limits of the bay is to be regarded as the dorsal lip of the blastopore, and, owing to a slight opacity in this region, stands out in sharp contrast to the rest of the margin. During the next half hour the blastoporic margin changes from that of a uotch to that of a broad shallow bay (Fig. V, 77), finally becoming straight (Fig. V, I). This straight margin then becomes slightly rounded and less opaque (Fig. V, J), and at the same time the rest of the blastodermic edge is sharply defined. This change in the contour of the margin is duo to the origin of the region of overgrowth, a structure that will be understood better from a study of sections.




Fig. V.

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg. 77

Except in "rare" cases, all traces of the blastoporic bay are lost by the thirty-seventh hour, and the circumference of the blastoderm is again a circle. The only difference between the anterior and posterior halves of the blastoderm is found in the slightly opaque area lying between the areas opaca and pellucida at the middle of the latter half (Fig. V, K), and even this opacity usually disappears by the time the egg is laid, that is, by the forty-first hour. Hence the surface view of a freshly laid egg will give one no indication of the morphological difference existing between these two regions of the blastoderm.

Throughout the period of gastrulation the entire blastoderm grows less opaque — a change due to the progress made by the thinning-out of the blastodisc.

In Fig. V, L is shown one of two cases that have been observed in these studies, and that are of the greatest interest. Both of these blastoderms show a white opaque streak extending across the dorsal lip of the blastopore from the area pellucida to the posterior margin. This streak is narrow next the pellucid area, but posteriorly it becomes broader and its lateral edges are continuous with the right and left margins of the dorsal lip. The streak represents the line of fusion of the halves of the dorsal lip, for, as we shall see, tliese halves are moving from a lateral into a median position and

Fig. V. This figure shows a series of drawings made by the aid of camera outlines from the developing egg. A-D are all from a single egg, and E-K from another. L is from a free hand sketch of a blastoderm taken about thirty-six hours after fertilization. The other drawings were made at the following periods: A, 29 hours; B, 31 hours; C, 31 hours 45 minutes; D, 32 hours 25 minutes ; E, 33 hours 30 minutes ; F, 34 hours ; G, 34 hours 15 minutes ; E, 34 hours 45 minutes ; I, 35 hours 30 minutes ; J, 36 hours 15 minutes ; K, 37 hours 15 minutes. Owing to the individual differences in the development and size of various blastoderms at a given time, any one of the above surface views would not necessarily correspond to that of another egg taken at the time indicated. The two eggs from which these sketches were made were selected because they gave the appearance ordinarily met with at these times, as determined by the continuous study of several eggs throughout the period covered. It is not unusual to find a blastoderm, taken as much as five hours earlier than that figured in B, showing a pellucid area. All the sketches are X 12.

78 J. Thos. Patterson.

uniting along the middle line of the future embryo. This process of "concrescence" is operative in all cases, even though there is no perceptible streak in the majority of blastoderms. The question of concrescence will be considered in connection with the section on experimental studies.

B. Study of Sections. a. Pregastrular Stages.

In the study of sections, it will suffice to begin by describing a blastodisc in what I shall term a late cleavage stage. A median longitudinal section (Fig. 1, PI. I) shows that the blastodisc is thinner directly above the "Nucleus of Pander" than in other regions, except at the margin where it may be but one cell thick (Fig. 1, a). This thin marginal condition corresponds to the less opaque marginal zone seen in surface views from the twentieth to the twenty-eighth hours, and is brought about, as Aliss Blount has shown, by the manner in which the blastodisc is increasing in diameter. External to the margin are periblastic nuclei about which cells are formed and added to the edge of the disc (anterior end of Fig. 1). This process may continue to such an extent that a row of several cells will be seen in section. This is not always the case, for periblastic nuclei are also present in the yolk lying directly beneath the thin margin ; and about these nuclei, cells are organized and added upward to the disc, so that the margin may become more than a cell thick (posterior end of Fig. 1). Directly above the Nucleus of Pander, between the white yolk and the deeper cells of the disc, is the fissure-like segmentation cavity (sc), and between the edge of this cavity and the margin of the disc is a zone, in which the cells are open below to the white yolk. This region is more or less of a syncytium, in which cell boundaries are either wanting or very indistinct. It exists around the entire margin of the disc, and constitutes the zone of junction.^^

^"In my preliminary paper I used the term germ wall to designate this zone, but for the sake of unity it has seemed advisable to employ the term zone of junction instead. There is no objection to using this term to designate ';he entire zone at this stage, at least so long as one bears in mind the fact that the inner part of this zone is potential germ wall.

Gastruliitiun in the Pigeon's Egg. 79

In connection with this stage (Fig. 1) it remains only to call attention once more to the thinness of the blastodisc above the segmentation cavity (sc). While there is some evidence in favor of the view that this thin condition existed from an early cleavage stage, yet, in the light of subsequent events, it lends itself to another interpretation, namely, that it is the beginning of a thinning-out process which will eventually succeed in producing a one-layered condition of the segmentation cells. In other words, all the cells of the segmented disc finally arrange themselves into an epitheliallike structure, the primary ectoderm. This interpretation for Fig. 1 receives support also from a study of several slightly younger stages, which show the disc to be from three to five cells thick in the central region.

As we have seen in surface views, the thinning-out does not begin exactly in the center of the disc (Fig. 1), but slightly posterior to this place, and then spreads in all directions but with more rapidity toward the posterior margin. This thinning-out evidently brings about a rapid centrifugal expansion of the disc, for there is no other period in the early history of the blastoderm in which there is such a rapid increase in the surface area, as occurs during the time when the thinning is at its maximum.

Coincident with the thinning-out, but not connected with it, another important process makes its appearance, that of the interruption of the posterior zone of junction. This interruption is associated with the degeneration of the periblastic nuclei beneath the zone of junction. The presentation of the facts upon which this conclusion is based must be deferred until more advanced stages have been described.

Let us consider next a scries in which the progress of the thinningout as well as that of the interruption of the zone of junction can clearly be seen. A median longitudinal section of such a stage is shown in Fig. 29, PI. IV. The blastoderm from which this photograph was made is considerably in advance of that of Fig. 1 and would correspond to stage D, Fig.V. In addition to the progress made in the thinning-out and the interruption of the posterior zone of junction, the more important changes are (1) the great increase in the number of cells, and (2) the extension of the segmentation


J. Thos. Patterson.

cavity, which we may now call the subgerminal cavity. ^^ At the posterior end (Fig. 29, p.) the blastoderm is only a single cell thick, but towards the anterior it gradually increases in depth. Although the anterior fourth of the disc is at least six cells deep, yet distinct layers can not be made out, but the cells are more or less loosely arranged. In the enlarged drawing of the anterior end the details

Fig. VI. A diagrammatic reconstruction from camera drawings of the sections of a blastoderm talcen about tbirty-tliree hours after fertilization. The lines CR, 'NF and UK are the planes of sections of Figs. 29 (or 2 and 3), 4 and 5 respectively. The zone of junction {z) is all but completely interrupted at the posterior margin, x 27.2.

of the zone of junction are shown (Fig. 2, PL I, z). Cells in every stage of formation are present, and at ce is one completely formed about a periblastic nucleus, and toward the ccmter are several others undergoing the same process. The whole region from the letter z to the left end of the drawing is a syncytium — a region containing many periblastic nuclei.

"Although the term subgerminal cavity is here used in the sense in which it is usually employed, namely, to designate an enlarged segmentation cavity, yet it should he said that from the standpoint of comparative embryology, it has little or no significance.

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg. 81

At the posterior end of this same section (Fig. 3) an entirely different condition is found. Aside from the thinness of the margin, the almost entire disappearance of the zone of junction is the most characteristic feature. The only remnants of it are the degenerating periblastic nucleus {pn) and the single cell which is about to arise from the yolk (ce). For a considerable distance on either side of the posterior portion of this section the only normal periblastic nuclei visible are the few w^hich are in the last stages of acquiring distinctly outlined cell limits. All other nuclei are in some phase of degeneration. About twenty-five sections to either side of the median line, however, the uninterrupted zone of junction is again found. In Fig. 4, which is taken twenty sections to the right of the center, two normal nuclei are forming cells about them (ce), and to the left of these there is a completed cell. Two degenerating nuclei are also present {pn). Five sections farther to the right, the first indication of a true zone of junction is found (Fig. 5). The zone here is very narrow, but still farther to the side it becomes much w'ider (see Fig. VI).

From this time on the thinning-out of the blastoderm and the interruption of the posterior zone of junction make rapid progress, until about thirty-one to thirty-three hours after fertilization, when the zone is completely interrupted for a distance of 70-80 degrees (Fig. VII) (cf Fig. V, F). Comparing Fig. 29 with that of a longitudinal section of such a blastoderm (Fig. 30), it is apparent that the condition of the latter has been brought about as the result of processes already described in connection with the former, and consequently, the section ends posteriorly in a thin free margin (Fig. 14), with the zone of junction entirely wanting. In passing forward, however, one finds a gradual increase in the thickness of the lilastoderm (Fig. 30). The subgerminal cavity, which has increased l)otli in depth and extent, is occupied by many segmentation cells, which, for the most part, lie in a row near the floor of the cavity. The position of the cells is purely an artifact — a condition produced during fixation ; for a study of this section under high power reveals the fact that the upper contour of every nucleated cell or group of cells lying in th^ cavity exactly corresponds to the under


J. Thos. Patterson.

contour of the overlying cells. This is especially clear in the photograph at the point marked x as well as in other parts of the blastoderm. Hence, if it were possible to view this section in the living condition, the subgerminal cavity would be seen to contain few or no nucleated cells; for all these cells would then be crowded up

Fig. VII. A diagrammatic reconstruction of a blastoderm taken thirtyone hours after fertilization. It is farther advanced than the majority of eggs at this time. Numbers 1, 2, 3, etc., represent the regions of the blastoderm which are one, two, three, etc., cells deep, respectively. The broken line around "1" indicates the region where the depth is approximately one cell. The plane of the section for Fig. 30 is slightly to the left of line CD. X 27.2.

against the under surface of the blastoderm. Their present position within the cavity shows that they have loosened and sunk down during fixation. There would be, however, in the living condition, a few large non-nucleated yolk masses (m), as the present position of these bodies indicates that they have arisen out of the yolk iying beneath the floor of the cavity.

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg. 83

Since, in preparing sections, it is impossible to avoid entirely this artifact, it is important to recognize its significance/" A failure to do so might easily lead one to believe that after the completion of the primary ectoderm there would be many cells within the subgerminal cavity to form a loose layer," and thus to attribute to this latter a possible origin of the gut-entoderm (delamination theory) .

It is at about this stage of development (Fig. VII) that the initial step in gastrulation occurs, but before taking up that part of the description I must digress in order to make clear the probable significance of the method by which the avian blastodenn thins out. In this connection one naturally turns to the field of comparative embryology for suggestions, and here, if I mistake not, much evidence is found for an explanation of this interesting process. It will be necessary, however, to call attention to some well known facts in embryology, even at the risk of being somewhat tedious.

First of all, Ave may refer back to a holoblastic egg such as that of the primitive vertebrate Amphioxus. Here blastulation consists merely in an epithelial arrangement of the blastomeres to form a hollow sphere, and only the slightest difference in size exists between the blastomeres of the vegetative and those of the animal hemisphere — a difference, perhaps, anticipatory of a meroblastic condition.

In the egg of Petromyzon, which has greater meroblastic tendencies than the preceding but is still holoblastic, Hatta ('07) describes and figures a thinning-out of the upper hemisphere that begins approximately in the region where gastrulation is soon to appear and proceeds anteriorly, thus finally resulting in a one-layered condition of this hemisphere. The process, however, is not finished until just before the completion of gastrulation. He believes that this differentiation is brought about by the deeper cells pushing in between

"Many fixing fluids have been tried in an endeavor to overcome this artifact, but even in the best fixed series a few cells drop down, showing that they were not tightly wedged in between the upper cells. In one case I have succeeded in fixing an egg in an inverted position, and in this the subgerminal cavity is practically free from nucleated cells.

84 J. Thos. Patterson.

the more superficial ones. He says, in the part where differentiation is going on, the cells of the outer row and those of the inner rows are found pushing between one another, and the layer of such condition passes over gradually into the part which has already become a true epithelium."^- The expansion of the upper hemisphere necessarily brought about by this differentiation plays an important role in gastrulation.

Hatta points out the homology existing between the blastulation of Amphioxus and the differentiation of the micromeric layer into an epithelium in Petromyzon. He contends that since it is incorrect to speak of a "blastula" stage in Amphioxus before the blastomeres are converted into the form of an epithelium," so in Petromyzon it is correct to speak of blastulation only when differentiation of blastomeres into an epithelium has begun. In regard to the latter form he writes, "In this case blastulation, as indicated by differentiation of the blastomeres into an epithelium, should be looked upon as being much delayed; it is still being carried on during the whole period of the gastrulation and is finished only a little earlier than the latter process. In other words, the two processes, blastulation and gastrulation, overlap each other to a great extent in the period of their occurrence. The prime cause of this belated mode of development is indisputably due to delay of segmentation on account of an enormous accumulation of yolk within the ovum."^'^

Without referring to the various eggs showing intermediate conditions, we may consider next the thinning-out in an egg in which the accumulation of yolk within the ovum is carried almost to the extreme, that is, in a meroblastic egg such as that of the Selachian Torpedo (Zieglers, '92), or Pristiurus (Riickert, '99). In Torpedo Ziegler figures and describes a "blastula" stage in which the posterior portion of the blastodisc is differentiated into a single-layered epithelium, while anteriorly it gradually increases in depth and the cells are not arranged in the form of an epithelium. At this stage, invagination of the thin posterior margin begins and soon after, the differentiation (thinning-out) extending both anteriorly

^^Loc. cit., p. 24. "Loc. cit., p. 35.

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg. 85

and laterally reduces the entire central region of the blastodisc to a single layered epithelium. Concerning this extension of the differentiation, he writes as follows : "Die epitheliale Schichte ist jetzt in ziemlich gleichmassiger Weise an der ganzen Oberflache des Blastoderms zur Ausbildung gekommen (Fig. 2). Offenbar sind also die Zellen, welche in dem friiheren Stadium (Fig. 1) den dickeren Theil des Blastoderms bildeten, in dieses epitheliale Blatt eingetreten, indem die tieferen Zellen sich aufwarts nach der Peripherie bewegten und sich dem Epithel einordneten ; daher nahm die epitheliale Schicht betrachtlich an Ausdehnung zu und in Folge dessen hat das Blastoderm jetzt eine grossere Liinge und Breite und ist ein Umstiilpungsvorgang am Hinterrande des Blastoderms eingeleitet worden."^^

Almost the same words could be employed in describing the changes which occur in a pigeon's blastoderm after it has reached a stage corresponding to that shown in Fig. VI. Hence, the process of thinning-out of the avian blastoderm, as well as that of the selachian, is to be regarded as homologous with the process of blastulation in Amphioxus and Petromyzon. There will be, undoubtedly, a "wide difference of opinion as to the advisability of using the term "blastulation" to describe this process ; for the term blastula has been employed for stages which cover a wide period of development. Ordinarily, however, it is used to designate that stage of development just preceding the gastrula-invagination — a stage in which the segmentation cavity is more or less enlarged. The result is that the so-called blastulse of the various vertebrates have not the same morphological value.

As to when one should call the pigeon's egg a blastula, will depend on the criteria adopted. Using the term as it is variously applied among the different vertebrates, one might speak of a blastula from the eight-cell stage to the beginning of invagination, and, adopting Hatta's suggestion, even to the end of gastrulation. It is obvious, therefore, that the term could be used only in the most general way. I prefer to avoid it altogether, and for that reason, shall

^^Loc. cit., p. 58,

86 J. Thos. Patterson.

simply speak of the thinning-out process, by which I mean the (iifferentiation of the cleavage cells into a single layered epithelium above the enlarged segmentation cavity (subgerminal cavity).

In this connection I must speak of the probable reason why the thinning-out process affects the posterior region of the blastoderm first. I have come to regard this as signifying that the posterior region is farther advanced in its differentiation than other parts. This interpretation is in harmony with the general law for the early development of the embryo, namely, that differentiation progresses from the head end backward. As we shall see later, it is in the posterior central part of the blastoderm that the head of the embryo will arise.

h. Gastrulation Stages. (1) Invagination.

If the thinning-out were completed before the invagination began, the interpretation of the steps of gastrulation would be greatly facilitated. But such is not the case, for immediately following a stage such as shown in Fig. 30, the initial step in gastrulation occurs. This consists in the rolling under of the free posterior margin of the blastoderm. The reconstruction of a blastoderm in which the involution has just taken place is shown in Fig. VIII, and a surface view of a corresponding stage is seen in Fig. V, G. In this egg (Fig. VIII) the zone of junction is not essentially different from that seen in Fig.' VII, except at the anterior inner margin, Avhere a portion of it has given rise to a partial germ-wall (gw). The numbers scattered over the figure indicate the relative depths of the various regions. Thus in the central area, the blastoderm is thinned-out to one or two cells, while the marginal parts are much thicker, varying from two to four cells. In the extreme posterior is shown the region covered by the invaginated entoderm (E).

The posterior portion of an oblique section passing through the region of invagination is represented in Figs. 32 and 15. At the extreme posterior is a cavity (Fig. 15, c) which is bounded above by the vitelline membrane and below by the yolk, or ventral lip of the blastopore. In reality the cavity is but a portion of the blasto

Gastriilatioii in the Pigeon's Egg. 87

pore (b), which passes beneath the dorsal lip (d) to become the archenteron (ac). Directly above the archenteron is the invaginated entoderm (e), and just in front of the anterior limit of this is a portion of the subgerminal cavity (sg), above which the blastoderm is two cells thick, but anterior to which it is three thick. Owing to the obliquity of the plane of section, the wrong impression is given as to the condition of the blastoderm directly in front of the central

Fig. VIII. A diagrammatic reconstruction of a blastoderm taken thirtyfour hours after fertilization, or seven hours before laying. Invagination has just talien place and the entoderm (E), a tongue-lilie process, is starting to grow forward through the subgerminal cavity. As indicated by the numbers, the blastoderm is thinned out to one or two cells deep in the central part, while around the anterior and lateral margins it varies from two to four deep. The anterior inner edge of the zone of junction is differentiated into a germ wall. In this, as in the other reconstructions, the ectoderm is not represented.

part of the invaginated region. If the series had been cut parallel to tlio longitudinal axis of the future embryo, a median section would have been diagrammatic in clearness, that is, it would show what we should expect to find in case of a true involution. The condition of the central part of the blastoderm, however, can be inferred from the photograph shown in Fig. 49. On either side of the invaginated region the post<^n'ior ends of the sections terminate with thin free margins (Fig. 16), and differ from those in the invaginated area, therefore, in having no cavity posteriorly.

88 J. Thos. Patterson.

I have said above that invagination takes place by a turning or rolling nnder of the free margin. It is important to show that there is a plain rolling under, and the following facts are offered as proof. First, as regards the morphological evidence ; I think it is clear from the above description that this line of proof strongly supports the conclusion. There is no other explanation for the appearance of a cavity just beyond the posterior margin (Fig. 15, c) than that it was brought about as the result of the rolling under of the edge and of the simultaneous forward growth of the involuted cells.

This conclusion can be tested experimentally; for an injury made on the edge of the thin posterior margin (Fig. IX) just previous

Fig. IX. Scheme for the operation in Experiment I.

to gastrulation ought to be carried down beneath the blastoderm during the course of further development, that is, it ought to be found in the entoderm.

Experiment I.

The operation was made thirty-three and one-fourth hours after fertilization, and the egg was then incubated for three and threefourths hours. The result of the injuiy is shown in the posterior end of the median section (Fig. 66). There is a distinct dorsal lip, in which the deeper portion shows the cells affected by the operation. In the vitelline membrane, a short distance posterior to the dorsal lip, is the break made by the operating needle (at op). All of the injured cells are found in the entoderm, while the ectoderm is well differentiated almost back to the end of the section. Just ante

Gastmlation in the Pigeon's Egg.


rior to the dorsal lip the entoderm is almost wanting (Fig. 67). In an uninjured blastoderm at a corresponding stage of development the entoderm in this region is very thick (see Fig. 37). It is clear




Antero-post. diameter.

Trans, diameter.


31 hrs.

2.857 mm.

2.857 mm.

Late pre-gastrular stages. ....


31 "

3.333 "

3.333 "


32 "

3.428 "

3.428 "


33 "

3.411 "

3.411 "


34 "

3.809 "

3.809 "


34 "

3.333 "

3.619 "


34 "

3.285 "

4.238 "


34 "

2.571 "

2.667 "


34- "

3.428 "

3.524 "


34 "

2.761 "

3.142 "


35 "

2.860 "

3.333 "


35 "

2.400 "

2.857 "

Gastrulation stages


36 "

2.860 "

3.333 "


36 " 36 "

2.857 "

3.333 "


2.860 "

3.048 "


36 "

2.857 "

3.048 "


36 "

2.952 "

3.333 "


36 "

3.000 "

3.500 "


36 "

2.400 "

2.857 "


37 " .

2.660 "

2.857 "


37 "

3.247 "

3.333 "


37 "

3.333 "

3.429 "


37 "

3.333 "

3.429 "

Early post-gastrular stages. . '


38 "

3.428 "

3.428 "


39 "

2.762 "

2.762 "


40 "

3.524 "

3.524 "

1 382

40 "

3.524 "

3.524 "

therefore, that while such an operation destroys most of the cells that are to give rise to the entoderm, ^^ct the posterior margin is still capable of forming a rounded dorsal lip.


J. Thos. Patterson.

Measurements taken on the living eggs also can be interpreted in support of this view ; for such data show that previous to and following gastrulation the blastoderm is approximately circular, while during gastrulation the antero-posterior diameter is always shorter than that of the transverse (Table I). This is what we should expect in case the margin actually involuted.

Owing to individual variation in the size of different blastoderms at the same stage of development, it is impossible to determine, from the above table, whether the antero-posterior diameter is actually shorter after the beginning of gastrulation than just preceding the




1 '1

Egg 448.

Egg 440.


Ant. Post.



Ant. Post.


Pre-gastrular stages


2.S.57 nun.

2.762 " 2.8.57 " 2.953 " 3.142 "

3.242 "

2.857 111111.

2.9.53 " 3.047 " 3.095 " 3.238 "

3.242 "


6:15 6:45 7:30 8:15

3.510 111111.

3.333 " 3.451 " 3.510 " 3.570 "

3.808 "

3.510 mm.



6..30 7.00 7.30 8.30

3.570 " 3.689 ' 3.748 " 3.748 "

Post-gastrular stages



3.808 "

same, or whether it is only relatively shorter in comparison with the transverse diameter. If it can be shown that the former alternative is the true one, then the evidence for a "plain rolling under" of the margin will be well nigh conclusive. This I have been able to do by studying the living egg and taking measurements of the same blastoderm at different periods of its development. In the above table are given the data from such measurements taken on two eggs. Finally, the above interpretatioTi for the origin of the entoderm is in harmony with the views of a large majority of the investigators who have worked on other groups of vertebrates. It is with the fish, however, that the most interesting and instructive comparisons are to be drawn. The large size of the selachian ovum,

Gastnilation in the Pigeon's Egg. 91

together with the fact that this form is a more generalized type, would seem to indicate that the development of the avian egg ought more nearly to approach that of the selachian than that of the teleostean ovum, and so far as the thinning-out is concerned, it does; but as regards the involution of the margin it more closely resembles the teleostean type. Thus, Agassiz and \Vhitman ('84) state that in Ctenolabrus there is a "plain rolling under, or involution, as an initiatory step in the formation of the ring." However, they regard it more correct to describe the process "as an ingrowth, due both to a rapid multiplication of cells, and also to the centrifugal expansion of the ectoderm. "^^ The ingrowing under layer in the pigeon's blastoderm with its free inner edge is in many respects comparable to the "ring" in the teleostean blastoderm, and is, therefore, to be regarded as a highly modified germ-ring. It is, of course, only a partial ring, in that but a small part (at most an arc of 70-80 degrees) of the margin invaginates, while in the ordinary teleost an invagination occurs around the entire margin. In the egg of the Toad-fish (Batrachus tau), however, we have an interesting modification of the germ-ring, a condition which can be understood best by quoting a part of the summary of Miss Wallace ('99), who has described the development of this ring. She writes as follows: "In the egg of Batrachus there is a centripetal growth of cells at the embryonic pole, the ingrowth having a voluted outline in sections. Around the remainder of the blastoderm there is not even the appearance of an invagination, but only a slight thickening due to an ingrowth of cells from the ectoderm, and a few loose cells which may represent a true germ-ring found as a layer in ordinary forms. The peripheral thickening gradually fades out, first at the anterior pole, until the last remnant is found in a few cells lying beneath the ectoderm, forming a linear streak from the posterior end of the embryo to the lip of the closing blastopore.'"'^

We have in the egg of the Toad-fish a condition intermediate between such a form as Ctenolabrus and the Pigeon. The eggs of these three forms represent a series in which the differences in

^^Loc. eit., p. 68. "Loc. cit., p. 12.

92 J. Thos. Patterson.

development are measured by the relative quantities of yolk accumulated within the ovum. Thus in the Ctenolabrus egg, which contains the least amount of yolk, invagination occurs around the entire margin of the blastoderm, but stronger at the embryonic pole ; in the Batrachus egg, which contains much more yolk than the preceding, there occurs only a slight thickening about the greater part of the margin as the initiatory step" in invagination, this thickening soon disappears, and at the embryonic pole alone is there a true germ-ring formed ; and finally, in the Pigeon egg, which is loaded to the extreme with yolk, invagination occurs at the "embryonic pole" only, the greater part of the margin lacking even "the initiatory step."

(2) Middle and Late Gastrulation Stages.

The entoderm after reaching a stage such as shown in Fig. 32 continues to grow forward through the subgerminal cavity as a tongue-like process. At the same time the thinning-out progresses anteriorly and laterally, ordinarily with sufficient rapidity to keep ahead of the advancing entoderm. This results in most blastoderms in the formation of a space just in front of the anterior limit of the entoderm. This space is but a part of the subgerminal cavity that is free from segmentation cells, the latter having passed upward into the differentiating ectoderm. In some few cases, however, no space is found and in such it is impossible to determine the anterior limit of the entoderm.

The posterior end of a median longitudinal section, in which the length of the invaginated layer equals about one third of the diameter of the blastoderm, is shown in Pig. 34. Only a part (about onethird) of the above mentioned space is included in the photograph. The ectoderm above the space, as well as posterior to it, is not yet differentiated into a single layer, but here and there the lower segmentation cells are seen apparently crowding in between the upper ones. A group of such cells is shown at s. The dorsal lip of the blastopore is much thicker than in Pig. 32, and the method by which it increases will be discussed in another connection. It

Gastnilation in the Pigeon's Egg. 93

is sufficient to state here that in all probability it is not brought about alone by the multiplication of cells in situ.

A section lateral to the median line shows essentially the same conditions as Fig. 34, except that the entoderm does not extend so far anteriorly (Fig. 33, e).

The question must naturally arise in the reader's mind as to whether or not the upper layer is still rolling under at the posterior margin to give rise to the lower layer. The appearance of sections would seem to indicate that it is (e. g.. Fig. 33). The question can be tested, however, by experimentation, for if a rolling under is occurring, cells disturbed by an injury made on the extreme posterior margin of the dorsal lip, ought to be found later in the entoderm.


Fig. X. Scheme for operating in Experiment II.

Experiment II. — The scheme for such an operation is shown in Fig, X, and the result in Fig. 50. The injured cells are found immediately associated with the entoderm. This is especially clear in a transverse section through the affected region (Fig. 51). There is no evidence of an injury either in the ectoderm or mesoderm, and hence we must conclude that the affected cells have been brought to their present position by an actual rolling under of the posterior margin. Although this operation has been repeated several times with the above result, yet the position of the injury in the entoderm may vary in an antero-posterior direction ; but this variation is easily accounted for by the fact that one can tell in the living egg only approximately the extent to which invagination has progressed.

If an injury be made in the same manner as above on slightly

94 J. Thos. Patterson.

older blastoderms the affected region is not found in the entoderm, but in the ectoderm and mesoderm, showing that the involution has ceased, and the further extension of the entoderm is now brought about bj an ingrowth, in which cell division and the centrifugal expansion of the ectoderm play an important role. The latter two processes are doubtless factors in the extension of the entoderm throughout the entire jDeriod of involution, but they are not so conspicuous during the earlier stages of invagination.

We must now pass to a series in which gastrulation may be said to have reached its height, and one in which several structures and processes hitherto unnoted must be considered. The reconstruction of this series aj)pcars in Fig. XI. The tongue-like process of entoderm (-£'), the dorsal lip of the blastopore (-D), the germ-wall {GW), and the zone of junction (z) were considered in connection with Fig. VIII, but they have all undergone important changes. Thus, the germ-wall extends almost around the whole inner margin of the zone of junction, and on the lateral margins its cells extend into the subgerminal cavity, within the edge of the area pellucida. This extension of cells is not due to an ingrowth from the inner edge of the germ-wall, but rather to the spreading of the subgerminal cavity by the liquefaction and fragmentation of the underlying yolk.

The changes in the dorsal lip consist in the growth of the right and left halves toward each other and their simultaneous fusion in the middle line, that is, in the plane of the longitudinal axis of the future embryo. A blastoderm in which the line of fusion was seen in surface view is shown in Fig. V, L. The movement of material is participated in by the more lateral parts of the margin, namely, the horns of the zone of junction, and as they move toward the median line they are at the same time being carried centrifugally by the expansion of the blastoderm, and in this way the fused halves of the lip are gradually being enclosed within the inner edge of the zone. The question of this movement of material will be fully discussed in connection with the description of experiments performed to throw light on the method by which the embryo arises.

The region of overgrowth (0), which is represented in the figure

Gastnilation in the Pigeon's Egg.


as a crescent-shaped area extending around the anterior and lateral margins, is a structure hitherto not noted. It arises, however, at an earlier period than this, and consists in the outgrowth of the marginal cells beyond the zone of junction.

Besides the entoderm and the germ-wall cells (at the sides) there are many large yolk masses within the subgerminal cavity, and also a few of the lower segmentation cells that have sunk down from the

Fig. XI. A diagraiumatic reconstruction of a blastoderm taken thirtysix hours after fertilization, or five hours before laying. It represents the ectoderm as transparent. O, region of overgrowth ; Z, zone of junction ; Y, germ-wall cells beneath which the subgerminal cavity has spread ; D, dorsal lip of the blastopore ; PA, outer boundary of the area pellucida ; E, region covered by the invaginated or gut-eutoderm. Lines drawn through GR, KF, and GH represent the planes of the sections illustrated in Figs. 35, 40, and 41 respectively. The anterior margin of the entoderm as here represented is only the average for the different lengths of entoderm as measured in the sections, from which the reconstruction was made. The arrows at the posterior margin indicate the direction of movement of the halves of the dorsal lip. x 27.2.

96 J. Thos. Patterson.

under surface of the differentiating ectoderm. That part of the subgerminal cavity lying beneath the entoderm (E) is to be regarded as the archenteron, which communicates with the blastopore by a narrow passage situated just below the dorsal lip (D). At its union with the deeper cells of the lip, the entoderm is very thick, but gradually thins out anteriorly, ending with a thin irregular margin slightly beyond the center of the blastoderm.

The changes described above can be made clearer by a study of longitudinal sections. Thus in the photograph of a median section (Fig. 35) the various regions are easily recognized, and in the enlarged drawing of the posterior end (Fig. 19) the dorsal lip is seen to be composed of compact cells, all of which are completely delimited by cell-walls. Directly above the lip there is no distinct ectoderm, but anterior to the point u it is well differentiated and in only a few places (s) are lower segmentation cells crowding upward into it. The entoderm at its union with the deeper cells of the lip is five cells thick, but anteriorly gradually decreases, finally ending with a free margin (Fig. 35, e — to the left). At this stage the entoderm can not be said to be a distinct layer, for its cells are arranged more or less into groups. In the archenteric cavity (ac), which lies between the entoderm and the yolk, are several large yolk masses, some of which are in the act of rising from the floor. Posteriorly the archenteron communicates by a narrow passage with the blastopore.

The conditions presented in this section very much resemble those of a corresponding section from a teleostean blastoderm in which invagination is well advanced. Thus Miss Wallace's ('99) Fig.5, PI. Ill, not only compares very favorably with Fig. 19 in the appearance of the dorsal lip, but also as regards the method by which the entoderm grows forward; for I consider it better to" describe the entoderm as now advancing anteriorly by a multiplication of its cells and their gradual arrangement into a single layer. This view is in accord with the account for Ctenolabrus as given by Agassiz and Whitman ('84). At this stage the main difference between the teleostean and pigeon blastoderms is that in the former the ectoderm is from three to five cells thick at the embryonic pole, while in the latter it is but one cell thick (Fig. 37). This difference

Gastriilatioii in the Pigeon's Egg. 97

is doubtless to be accounted for by the fact that the teleostean embryo is precociously formed, that is, as compared with the formation of the avian embryo.

The conditions at the anterior end of this section (Fig. 18) are entirely different from those at the opposite end. First of all, the differentiation of the ectoderm into a single layered epithelium is not complete, for in many places the lower segmentation cells are crowding upward against its under surface, although some of them have sunk down into the cavity (s), but aside from these few the subgerminal cavity is entirely free from nucleated cells anterior to the fore end of the entoderm (e). There are found in the cavity only large yolk masses, some of which are disintegrating (dm).

The germ-w^all is not well differentiated in this section, but in the sections to either side it is clearly defined.

The region of overgrowth (o) is a wedge-shaped process extending out from the zone of junction. The earliest stage in which this region has been observed is illustrated in Fig. 27, and is characterized by having no periblastic nuclei either beneath it or external to it, and by having a fine granular area just beneath its under surface. ^^ This region arises when the thinning-out is at its maximum and at first is three or four cells thick, but later becomes reduced to a single layer of cells (Fig. 28).

The phyletic significance of this region is not clear. On the one hand, it might be compared to the overhanging margin of the selachian blastoderm, and thus be regarded as showing a tendency toward a "peripheral gastrulation." Its appearance in an unincubated chick blastoderm would favor this view (Fig. 65). On the other hand, the fact that it first arises at the anterior margin and is not a continuation of a dorsal lip (Fig. XI), would indicate that it was not comparable to the margin of the selachian blastoderm. The answer to this question, however, turns upon the view one takes as to the extent of the blastopore. I cannot agree with those in "In the series shown in Fig. 10 hut a single nucleus was found beneath the overgrowth (Fig. 2.")), and this one had doubtless arisen from the nucleus lying below the zone of junction when that region formerly occupied the margin of the blastoderm.

98 J. Thos. Patterson.

vestigators (Hacckel, Balfour, Goette, and others), who have maintained that the entire margin of the avian blastoderm is to be regarded as the blastopore, for the evidence furnished hj my material is conclusively in favor of the view that but a small part of the margin is the. blastoporic region. The rest of the margin (overgrowth region) I regard therefore as a specialized region, rather than as a place where the upper germ-layer bends under to become continuous with the lower layer.

The three regions, overgrowth, zone of junction, and germ-wall, are all concerned in the spreading of the blastoderm over the yolk. Since the region of overgrowth has no periblastic nuclei either beneath or external to it, its spreading over the yolk can not be due to the addition of cells from the periblast, unless it be indirectly from the zone of junction. However, the fact that its cells are undergoing rapid division makes it almost certain that the spreading of the overgrowth is due to the multiplication of its own cells. This conclusion is strengthened by the fact that the cells are digesting the underlying yolk as indicated by the fine granular area.

As the overgrowth travels peripherally over the yolk, it is followed by the zone of junction, which in turn is differentiating, from its inner edge, ectoderm above and genn-wall below (see anterior end of Fig. 35). The first two regions seldom have greater widths than those in this series (cf. Figs 18 and 28), and hence the germ-wall is continually increasing in width. The suligerminal cavity is also increasing in diameter, but at a slower rate, and in this widening of the cavity there are left around its margin cells which were previously embedded in the yolk. These cells (Fig. XI, I') constitute the under loose layer of the area opaca, and later enter into the formation of the yolk-sac entoderm, and, according to Ruckert, '06, also contribute to the vascular tissues. The inner edge of this lower layer becomes united to the free margin of the invaginated entoderm, when the latter spreads over the subgerminal cavity sufficiently to meet it. The first place for this union to occur is necessarily at the posterolateral regions, and the last place is at the anterior end of the cavity.

Sections taken slightly to either side of the median line are of interest, in that they have vacuoles or cavities in the dorsal lip

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg.


(Figs. 38 and 39). The position of the cavities suggests that they are probably to be regarded as the remains of the cavity that was formed between the upper and lower layers when the former turned under to give rise to the latter. I might suggest that there is another possibility, namely, that such cavities are the homologue of "Kupffer's Vesicle."

Fig. 40, which is from a section taken through the plane KF of Fig. XI shows the tip of the right horn of the zone of junction

Fig. XII. Reconstruction of a blastoderm taken thirty-six and one-fourth hours after fertilization. Lettering is the same as in Fig. XI, FH, plane of section represented in Figs. 20 and 21. The numbers within the areas formed by the four intersecting lines indicate the number of degenerating periblastic nuclei in these areas, x 27.2.

and the lateral part of the dorsal lip. The length of the lip in section becomes less and less in passing laterally, finally disappearing altogether. Thus in Fig. 41 it is no longer present, and the margin is occupied by the zone of junction, inside of which is a region whose position would lead one to call it germ-wall, but it is probably more correct to regard it as a portion of the lip that has already been enclosed within the horns of the zone. Passing still farther to the


J. Thos. Patterson.

side one finds the posterior margin becoming less thick and gradually taking on the syncytial condition characteristic of the anterior and lateral parts of the zone of junction. However, it is not until one has reached about 45 degrees to either side of the median line that the posterior margin is found to be reduced to the average thickness of the rest of the edge.

Closing of the Blastopore. — It was stated above that the entoderm grows forward through the subgerminal cavity. The source from

Fig. XIII. Reconstruction of a blastoderm taken thirty-five and onefourth hours after fertilization. The blastopore has just closed, and the zone of junction completely encircles the blastoderm. D, is the enclosed dorsal lip. vv', w\v', and xx' are the planes of the sections illustrated in Figs. 24, 23, and 22 respectively, x 27.2.

which it draws its material for this forward growth is, of course, the thick dorsal lip. This results in producing either one of two conditions in the lip at the time the blastopore is closed. On the one hand, the entoderm may have grown forward to such an extent as to have produced a very perceptible diminution in the lip before the closing occurs. Such is the case in the blastoderm represented in Fig. XII, as is apparent from the median section (Figs. 20 and

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg. 101

On the other hand, in the majority of blastoderms there is no apparent reduction in the lip preceding the closing, but it remains quite as thick as that of Fig. 37, even after being entirely enclosed Avithin the zone of junction. This can be made out from a series of transverse sections of the blastoderm shown in Fig. XIII. Thus in the section taken through xx' the entoderm is at least five cells thick, and passes over gradually into the region of the zone of junction (Fig, 22). Above the entoderm a distinct ectoderm is differentiated, but slightly posterior to this it can no longer be distinguished, and still farther back is found the zone of junction, which completely encircles the blastoderm (Fig. XIII, Z). Anteriorly the entoderm rapidly thins out, the cells being arranged in groups (Fig. 23), which become less and less thick, finally disappearing altogether, so that only a few cells are found (Fig. 24).

Interruption of the Posterior Zone of Junction. — We are now in a position to consider the interruption of the zone of junction. It was stated above that the interruption was associated with the degeneration of the periblastic nuclei in the region of the posterior zone. Abundant evidence is found for this statement in the study of any egg taken either just before or during gastrulation. Thus in Figs. 8-13 is shown a series of nuclei in various stages of degeneration. The first indication of the breaking down process is found in the increase in the size of the nucleus. In this condition the nuclei do one of two things. In some cases, they stain intensely (Fig.* 8) and apparently the nuclear membrane breaks down directly, leaving the chromatin lying free within the yolk (Fig. XIV, A). In the large majority of cases, however, they continue to increase in size and at the same time their capacity for stains gradually diminishes, until it is difficult to study them at all after the use of hematoxylin. When they have increased to a volume equal to many times that of an average normal nucleus, they begin to divide (rarely into equal parts — as in Fig. 10), or rather portions are pinched off from the sides of the nucleus (Figs. 9 and 11) — the process continuing until the entire nucleus is reduced to small fragments (Figs. 12 and 13). Finally one sees among the yolk spherules only clear spaces, which indicate the places previously occupied by these fragmenting nuclei.

102 J. Thos. Patterson.

Abnormal yolk or periblastic nuclei arc found in many meroblastic eggs, especially those of the fish. Several of the nuclei figured by Raifsele, '98, for Belone, greatly resemble what I have observed in the Pigeon, and in the eggs of Squalus also are found many such nuclei. So far as I am aware, no one has described the complete fragmentation of the periblastic nuclei in the bird's egg, although Harper, '04, observed abnormal ones in early stages of the pigeon's egg. He regarded these as spei*m nuclei, but in the light of Miss Blount's, '07, work, they are doubtless to be considered as periblastic nuclei, and are therefore undergoing this disintegrating process.

Fig. XIV. A is from the blastoderm shown iu Fig. XII. It shows the chromatin lying free in a finely grannlar area among the yolk spherules — the nuclear membrane having disappeared. B is a yolk mass in which are two fragmenting nuclei. This mass had arisen from the yolk lying beneath the archenteron, and doubtless had taken up two degenerating nuclei which were in the central periblast. X 250..

The position of these nuclei within the egg is of importance ; for in the main they are located in the region where the zone of junction is being interrupted. In the blastoderms illustrated in Figs. VI and VII they are found mainly in the yolk lying beneath the posterior margin — the rest of the edge being almost wholly free from them, in some cases entirely so. Later, when invagination begins, they are found around the greater portion of the margin (e. g., in the series shown in Fig. VIII), and still later, they may be seen in all parts of the edge, but not in such abundance in the anterior half of the blastoderm as in the posterior, except during late gastrulation, when practically all of the nuclei beneath the archenteron have completely disappeared. In some few cases, however, even in late gastrulation.

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg. 103

there arc many degenerating nuclei found in the yolk lying beneath the floor of the arehenteron, but in such the nuclei are in the very last stages of disintegration (Fig. XIII). The absence of yolk nuclei beneath the archenteron is not characteristic of the birds alone, for in some of the Selachians also the same condition is found (e. g., in Torpedo and Squalus).

In the interruption of the posterior zone of junction we have another line of comparison with the teleostean development ; for this process is but the separation of the blastoderm from the underlying periblast. The comparison will become all the more obvious when we shall have shown experimentally that approximately that portion of the margin of the avian blastoderm, beneath which the zone of junction has disappeared, enters into the formation of the embryo. In other words, in the teleost the entire margin of the blastoderm separates from the periblast, and this whole margin (germ-ring) concresces to form the embryo; whereas, in the case of the bird, only about seventy to eighty degrees of the margin of the blastoderm parts company with the periblast, and just about this portion of the posterior edge is concerned in the process of concrescence.

Since abnormal nuclei are found as early as fifteen hours after fertilization (Harper, '04), there would seem to be some doubt regarding the possibility of such nuclei being instrumental in bringing al)Out the interruption of the posterior zone of junction. Furthermore, I have found degenerating yolk nuclei in eggs taken several hours after gastrulation. JSTeverthelcss, there is certainly no period, aside from that of gastrulation, in which they are in such abundance ; and in addition to this, they are present mainly where the interruption takes place. The fact that such nuclei later are found gradually extending anteriorly around the margin, would only indicate that there was a tendency for the entire margin of the blastoderm to separate from the periblast.

c. Postgastrular Stages. In eggs taken slightly later than the preceding, the entoderm is found not only to have grown farther forward, but also to have spread to the sides, so that its lateral margins have become united with the


J. Thos. Patterson.

inner edge of the germ-wall (Fig. XV). Hence, in transverse sections of the majority of blastoderms taken at this time, the entoderm will appear to be an outgrowth from the inner edge of the germwall. Fortunately, in not a few blastoderms the union between the invaginated entoderm and the germ-wall does not take place until about the time the egg is laid, and in such deferred cases it is easy to distinguish the lateral edge of the entoderm (Fig. 48), and thus to demonstrate that the gut-entoderm, at least in its lateral parts, does not receive elements from the germ-wall. Can the same be said

Fig. XV. Reconstruction of a blastoderm taken thirty-eight hours after fertilization. This blastoderm is approximately in the same stage of development as that of an unincubated hen's egg. x ^^.2.

of its anterior and posterior parts ? In regard to the former we can answer in the affirmative without hesitation ; for in every blastoderm taken from the time of midgastrulation until three or four hours after incubation, there is found between the anterior limit of the entoderm and the germ-wall, a portion of the subgerminal cavity in which there are practically no nucleated cells. Indeed, in many blastoderms there are no cells, not even yolk masses (Fig.

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg.


45), and yet it is clear from measurements of sucli that the distance between the inner edge of the anterior germ-wall and the entoderm is growing less at the same time that the entoderm is increasing in length (Table III).

Concerning those cases in which cells (other than entoderm) and yolk masses are found in the cavity, more must be said. Many writers have described these elements in the chick blastoderm, and as far back as 1874 Goette figured them as arising from the yolk lying beneath the floor of the cavity, that is, from the central periblast. Recently Hertwig ('03) has described them, and in speaking of those that lie between the entoderm and the floor, he writes as




Length of Blastoderm.

Length of p. area.

Length of Entoderm.

Length of "Space."*



2.190 mm.

1.547 mm.

0.119 mm.

1.428 mm.


34 "

2.261 "

1 . 666 "

0.595 "

1.071 "


36 "

2.667 "

2.071 "

1.476 "

0.595 "


37 "

2.976 "

2.262 "

1.786 "

0.476 "


38 "

3.190 "

2.215 "

1 . 786 "

0.429 "


40 "

3.219 "

2.310 "

1 . 905 "

0.405 "


44 "

4.048 "

2.238 "

2.143 "

0.095 "


46 "

4.809 "

2.619 "

2.619 "

0.000 "

By the term space is meant the distance from the anterior limit of the entoderm to the inner edge of the exterior germ-wall.

follows: Zwischen ihm und dem Dotterboden liegen in der Urdarmliohle zerstreut einzelne kugelige Embryonalzellen, darunter auch grossere, dotterlialtige Kugeln, die Megasphiiren von His. Letztere haben nicht den Formwert einer Zelle, da Kerne auf keine Weise in ihnen sichtbar zu machen sind, wie von Gasser ('84) und anderen Beobachtern festgestellt Avorden ist. Sie sind daher nur vom darunter liegenden Dotter losgeloste, kugelige Ballen, die wohl allmahlich zur Ernahrung der Zellen der Keimblatter aufgebraucht werden. Auch im Ttnum zwischen den ])eiden Keimblattern kommen

lOG J. Thos. Patterson.

wenige vereinzelte Zellen vor."^° I fully concur with Hertwig's views regarding the fate of the non-nucleated yolk masses, for one can examine scarcely a series in which some evidence of their disintegration is not found. The manner in which these masses break up is of interest, in that the fragments often resemble cells. Thus, above and to the left of the mass at dm. Fig. 47, are smaller masses that have broken off and become spherical — a process probably comparable to the phenomena of surface tension. These smaller masses in turn continue to subdivide until the cavity may become crowded with very fine particles (Fig. 44) which in this state are doubtless taken up by the cells. The yolk masses therefore play no role in the formation of the primary germ layers, except, of course, indirectly as nutriment. The contention of Balfour ('73) that they may become nucleated by the formation of nuclei de novo from yolk spherules would scarcely accord with the views of modern cytologists.

Again, in regard to the significance of the nucleated elements within the cavity, I agree with Hertwig, who thinks that in numbers they are far too few to be of any importance in the formation of the germ layers. On making counts of these elements, I was surprised to find that in blastoderms such as shown in Fig. 47, less than two per cent of them are nucleated, and that even in this small number many of the nuclei show signs of degeneration (Fig. XIV, B). !N^ot infrequently the cytoplasmic portion of such elements disintegrate, leaving the nucleus lying free within the cavity (Fig. 52, n). In other cases neither the cytoplasm nor nucleus breaks down at first, but the latter multiplies at the expense of the former until a solid mass of nuclei is formed (Fig. 55). Sooner or later these nuclei go to pieces.

These abnormal nuclei are to be accounted for by the fact that some of the yolk masses in arising from the central periblast (Fig. 46) naturally take up the periblastic nuclei, which, as was shown above, are degenerating. Their presence is in no way necessary to the formation of the masses, as is evident from the fact that the large majority of the masses are non-nucleated.

The phenomenon of yolk mass formation is only an index to the

'^Loc. cit., p. 858.

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg. 107

process of digestion, by which the blastoderm is securing its nourishment, and is doubtless similar to the phenomena of degeneration or fragmentation of the yolk that has been described by many workers on practically all of the vertebrate ova (Barfurth in the Teleosts; Dean in the Chimaeroids ; Stahl in the Reptiles ; Ruge and Born in the Amphibians ; Pf liiger in the Mammals ; Brunn and others in the Birds).

There are a few small cells within the cavity that are still to be accounted for (Fig. 53). These may come from two sources: either they are lower segmentation cells that have failed to get into the differentiating ectoderm, or they are wandering entoderm cells (Gasser, '82). If they come from the latter source and are later taken into the entoderm, no further consideration is necessary ; but if they are to be regarded as coming from the former source, we may justly ask. Why is it that' when an egg is fixed in an inverted position during the differentiation of the ectoderm, no cells are found in the cavity ? Whatever be their source, they are too insignificant in numbers to be of any great importance.

So far, we have considered the question of whether or not the invaginated or gut-entoderm receives cells from the anterior or lateral parts of the germ-wall, and on the whole the evidence favors the negative ; but in regard to the relation of the entoderm to the posterior germ-wall, further considerations arc necessary. It was stated above that as a result of the manner in which the blastopore closes, the dorsal lip comes to lie within the margin of the blastoderm. Hence, in longitudinal sections, the entoderm, while ending anteriorly with a free margin (Fig. 42), appears to arise directly from the posterior germ-wall. This apparent union of the entoderm with the posterior wall is only secondary, and the greater part of the mass of cells here l)elongs to the dorsal lip. This is most obvious immediately after the closing of the blastopore, when the ectoderm is not differentiated from the underlying mass (Fig. 26).

Although Balfour ('82) and many other investigators, working on the uniycubated hen's eggs, have noted that the entoderm is incomplete anteriorly and united to the germ-wall posteriorly, yet Nowack ('02) was the first to clearly state that the entoderm was

108 J. Thos. Patterson.

to be regarded as growing forward. He, however, not having studied the earlier stages, naturally supposed that the entoderm was an outgrowth from the posterior germ-wall, and thus missed the key to the origin of this germ-layer.

During the course of further development the entoderm completely penetrates the subgerininal cavity (Fig. XV, SG), and at the same time the mass of cells (lower cells of the dorsal lip) at its posterior border thins out to a single layer, thus showing that these cells contribute to the entoderm in its forward growth.

IV. Experimental Studies.

While many of the foregoing conclusions were first deduced from data gathered in a study of sections, yet they are of such a nature that experimental tests can be applied readily. Only a few of the many experiments that have been performed can be offered at this time, and these are selected, not because they are of any more interest than the others, but rather because they throw light on that mooted question, "How does the vertebrate embryo arise ?" The two views that have been held by students of vertebrate embryology in regard to this question are too well known to need any discussion here. Both theories have been defended by able workers, but too often the attempt has been made to support the one to the exclusion of the other. This has been especially true of those who hold to the theory of differentiation.

The results obtained by experimental investigators have not been uniform. In the main, writers have been willing to admit that only a modified form of concrescence is found in the formation of the embryo. In the few desultory experiments (Assheton, '96, Kopsch, '02) that have been made on the chick blastoderm only negative results have been found. This failure to secure positive evidence is due to two causes. In the first place, the technique has not been sufficiently refined. Thus, Assheton used sable hairs which he inserted in the unincubated blastoderm on either side of the axial line on the boundary between the areas opaca and pellucida. The results were negative, as one might expect; for who would suppose that the force exerted by the movement of materials in the delicate

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg. 109

blastoderm could be sufficient to overcome the resistance offered by the hair held above by the vitelline membrane and below by the yolk, even, indeed, if such material did not merely flow around the obstructing hair. In the second place, both Kopsch and Assheton were operating at a time when concrescence either had ceased altogether, or its influence was waning. Thus in Kopsch's ('02) experiment VII the operation was made after twelve hours of incubation, at a time when the bulk of the axial material had been marshalled from a lateral into a median position for a period of at least twelve to fifteen hours. It is obvious, from the above morphological data, that any experiments from which we could hope to gain any insight into the part played by concrescence, must be made during gastrulation, for concrescence and gastrulation are but different phases of the same process.

If the avian embryo is the product of concrescence and the right and left parts of the dorsal lip represent the homotypical halves of the future embryo, then injuries made on the posterior margin at different distances from the median line during early gastrulation, ought later to appear at different levels in the embryo, that is, an injury made at 10° from the median line ought to appear nearer the head region than one made at 45°. Furthermore, such injuries ought to affect only that half of the embryo which corresponds to the side of the dorsal lip injured. The progress of concrescence can be tested by operating on successively older stages. Thus, the following sets of operations will be described : Set A, on early gastrular stages; Set B, on late gastrular stages; and Set C, on unincubated and early incubation stages.

Set a — On Eaely Gastrulae Stages. Experiment III. An injury made in the middle of the dorsal lip slightly within the margin (Fig. XVI, a) is later found in the cephalic region of the embryo, greatly disturbing the material of what is later to become the primary fore-brain (Fig. 59, op). While the section through this injured region shows the affected cells to be situated slightly to the right of the median line, yet the entire head-fold is disturbed

110 J. Thos. Patterson.

(Fig. 57). The result of such an operation leaves but two alternatives with reference to the position of the embryonic primordium at the time when the injury was made. Either we must suppose that this primordium was situated in the exceedingly small space between the operated region and the posterior margin (Fig. XVI, a), or that its right and left halves lay along the lateral margins, and were gradually brought together by concrescence. That the latter alternative is the correct one will become obvious from the results of the following experiments.

Experiment IV. In this experiment the operation was made ten degrees to the right of the median line, the needle being set so that the outer edge

Fig. XVI. Scheme for operating in Experiments III, IV, and V.

of the resulting injury coincided with the margin of the blastoderm (Fig. XVI, &). After thirty-six and three-fourths hours of incubation the injury was found on the right neural fold in the mid-brain region (Fig. 63). Although the left neural fold is slightly distorted, yet the section shows with great clearness that the affected cells are found only on the right side (Fig. 62), All the structures characteristic of this region in a normal embryo, are here found well developed. As we should expect, the mesoderm and chorda are uninjured, for when the operation was performed these structures were not yet present in the head region.

Experiment Y. Passing now to the experiment in which the operation was made forty-five degrees to the right of the middle line (Fig. XVI, c), we

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg. Ill

find that the injury is situated seven sections anterior to the posterior end of the resulting embryo (Fig. 71 op), that is, the injured cells 'have been moved from a lateral into a median position. In the sketch of the transverse section through the affected region (Fig. XVII) the mass of cells is seen to be located slightly to the right side. While the needle destroyed a considerable portion of the primitive streak material, yet the blastoderm has apparently recovered from the injury, with the mass of affected cells separated from the blastoderm proper.

The apparent recovery of the blastoderm from the operation is to be explained by the fact that the injury, being made so far to the side, affected a region less highly differentiated than in the case of the operation at ten degrees. That is what one would expect.

Fig. XVII. Transverse section through the injured region of the embryo shown in Fig. 71. See text for description, x ^^■

for just as at any given period of the early development, the anterior portion of the embryo (or primordium) is in a higher state of differentiation than the posterior.

The results of the above experiments (III-V) show very clearly that the axial portion of the embryo arises from material previously situated in the right and left halves of the dorsal lip, material brought together by the process of concrescence. These experiments have been repeated several times, both in the manner described above, and with certain variations. Thus an operation made on the lip at twenty degi'ees either to the right or to the left of the axial line, 19 later found at the level of the anterior somites. In this paper we are not concerned, however, in analyzing the exact morphological value of the different parts of the blastoporic lip, but rather in showing that the avian embryo is the product of concrescence.

If the theory of concrescence is correct, it is obvious from these

112 J. Thos. Patterson.

experiments that similar operations made at a later period of development should be found located more posteriorly in the resulting embryo. Thus in a late gastrnlation stage, an injury made in the middle of the dorsal lip just anterior to the posterior margin, should be found later not in the fore-brain, as in Experiment III, but at a point situated more posteriorly to that region. Furthermore, if an injury be made on the margin to the side of the axial line at such a stage, it ought later to appear in the corresponding side toward the posterior end of the embryo. The results of such operations are shown in the following set of experiments.

Set B. On Late GasteUlar Stages.

Experiment VI.

The scheme for this operation appears in Fig. XVIII, a. It

would be equivalent to injuring the posterior margin of such a

blastoderm as that shown in Fig. V, /. The result of the operation

is shown in Fig. 54, in which the injury is seen to lie at the level

Fig. XVIII. Scheme for operating in Experiments VI, VII and VIII.

of the tenth paii; of somites. Posterior to the affected region there is found a normal primitive streak, which has not yet differentiated into the posterior axial portion of the embryo. The transverse section (Fig. XIX) shows a mass of dead cells lying between the separated halves of the neural tube, and a few scattered dead cells lying just above the entoderm, which is intact. The notochord is situated on the right side.

It would seem from this result that although the halves of die dorsal lip have been unable to coalesce in the region of the injury,

Gastrulatiou in the Pigeon's Egg. 113

yet they are capable of giving rise to the normal structures characteristic of this region. Posterior to the injury, however, they have succeeded in fusing and forming the primitive streak material.

Experiment VII. If an operation he made similar to the preceding, but at a slightly later period, it is not found in the body of the embryo, but at the extreme posterior end (Fig. 64, op).

Experiment VII I. In this experiment the injury was made twenty degrees to the right of the axial line (Fig. XVIII, &) at thirty-six hours after fertilization, that i§, at a stage corresponding to the one shown in Fig. V. J. The egg was then incubated for forty-eight hours. The injury is

Fig. XIX. Ti-ansverse section through the injured region of the embryo shown in Fig 54. X 95.

located on the right neural fold, at about one-third the distance from the posterior end to the first mesoblastic somite (Fig. XX, op). The left neural fold is uninjured. The result of such an experiment admits certainly of no other explanation than that the mass of affected cells has moved from a marginal into an axial position.

Set C. On Unincubated and Early Incubated Stages.

In this set of experiments I shall endeavor to show that not all of the embryonic material has been brought into a median or axial position at the time when the egg is laid ; but that it lies to either side, on the boundary between the areas opaca and pellucida. The presence of a slightly more opaque spot in this region has already been noted in connection with the study of surface views (Fig. V,/^),


J. Thos. Patterson.

as well as in the study of sections (Fig. 43.) Furthermore, Koller ('79 and '81) has figured and described for the unincubated chick blastoderm a thickening in this region.

Experiment IX. If a very small injury be made on the boundary between the two areas in line with the axis of the future embryo (Fig. XXI,&), it is

Fig. XX. A photograph of the eiiibiio described iii Experiment VIII. The injured cells are seen at op on' the right neural fold in the region of the open myelon. The primitive streak is bifurcated at the posterior end.

found later some distance from the posterior end of the embryo (Fig. 60, op). Such an operation destroys a considerable portion of the primitive streak material in the region over which it extends (Fig. 58), but for twenty-five sections posterior to the injury a normal primitive streak is found. Tlic point of interest in this experiment lies in the question regarding the source of the material from which the tail of the embryo is developed. The material must lie just posterior to the pellucid area, or to either side of the axial line on

Gastrulation in the Pigeon's Egg. 115

the boundary between the two areas. If from the former source, the material would be disturbed by an injury made in the area opaca just posterior to the pellucid area ; but if from the latter source, it would be affected only by operations made to the side of the axial line on the boundary between the two areas.

Experiment X. The operation was made just posterior to the pellucid area (Fig. XXI,a). The injury has in no way affected the embryo (Fig. 56), but lies posterior to it in the. area opaca. Assheton ('96) has performed a similar experiment on the chick blastoderm, using a sable hair instead of the needle. lie also found the embryo uninjured. From the result of tliis operation it is evident that the material out of which the tail of the eml)ryo is differentiated does not lie just posterior to the pellucid area.

Fig. XXI. Scheme for operating in Experiments IX-XIII.

Experiment XI. If the injury be made on the boundary between the two areas twenty degrees to the right of the middle line (Fig. XXI,c), it is found later drawn into the side of the embryo (Fig. 68) a short distance from the posterior end. In the transverse section through the operated region, it is seen that just half of the axial material is affected (Fig. 61). This is of the greatest importance, because it shows that the tail end of the embryo is formed by the concrescence of material lying to either side of the middle line. The limit to which material extends laterally is shown in the following experiments.

116 J. Thos. Patterson.

Experiment XII. This experiment is similar to the preceding, except that the operation was made 30 degrees to the right instead of twenty (Fig. XXI,e), and in the resulting embryo the injury is found in the right side of the posterior end of the primitive streak (Fig. 69).

Experiment XIII.

An injury made still farther laterally (Fig. XXI,(i) does not affect the embryo (Fig, 70), but is found in relatively the same position as that in which it was performed.

The results obtained from this set of experiments can leave no doubt concerning the presence of portions of the dorsal lip which lie between the boundary of the two areas, and which have not yet completely fused together at the time when the egg is laid. The manner by which this region is established has been considered in connection with an earlier stage (Fig. XV). It is this structure doubtless that Koller ('79) has described for the unincubated chick blastoderm, and which is often called Roller's crescent. In the pigeon I have never observed a "erescentric groove" as described by Koller,^° and furthermore this region does not give rise to the entire primitive streak, but only to the posterior part. Even then it usually completely disappears three or four hours before the primitive streak becomes visible.

V. Discussion and Summary. Discussion. Throughout the foregoing pages the term gastrulation is employed to designate the process of invagination by which the gut-entoderm takes its rise, together with the concomitant phenomenon of concrescence. It may therefore seem to be used in a sense that does not

="1 refer here to the presence of a groove cluriiig the early hours of incubation. It is true that in later stages (e. g., Fig. 20) one sometimes finds the posterior end of the primitive strealv bifurcated, but these must be regarded as much delayed cases, and are similar to those figured by Schaninsland ('03) for the sparrow.

Gastrulatioii in the Pigeon's Effg;. 117


accord with general usages; as, e. g., in the case of the lower vertebrates, Amphioxiis and the fishes, where the gut-entoderm, mesoderm, and chorda are all said to be involuted at the same time in the form of the primary entoderm.

This objection, however, completely disappears if the primitive streak formation is regarded as a part of the gastrular phenomenon. That such an explanation for the primitive streak formation is fully justified is obvious when considered in the light of comparative embryolog}\ Thus in Amphioxus all of the chorda and mesoderm are derived from the primary invaginated layer. In Amphibians the posterior part of the mesoblast is formed about the lips of the blastopore, and is often spoken of as the peristomal mesoblast," in contrast to the more anterior portion, or "gastral" mesoblast. In this case, no one hesitates to consider the whole process in Amphibians as that of gastrulation, because the "•gastral" and "peristomal" meso])last are directly continuous with one another. In the case of l)irds, all of the mesoblast is derived from the primitive streak, that is, it is all peristomal mesoblast. In the bird, therefore, the transition from a gastral to a peristomal mesoblastic formation has gone a step farther than in the case of the Amphibians. We have shown experimentally that as the gut-entoderm is being involuted, the concrescence of the halves of the dorsal lip is also taking place. Furthermore, there arises later from this fused region the primitive streak, or mesoblast. It is evident, therefore, that the invagination of the gut-entoderm and the primitive streak formation are but different parts of the same process, namely, that of gastrulation. The occurrence of a short period (from shortly after the closing of the blastopore to the appearance of the primitive streak), during which one cannot distinguish, either by sections or by surface views, the primitive region, in no wise invalidates the above comparison.

Hertwig ('03) has divided the process of gastrulation in the amniota into two parts or phases. He, however, had little else to offer for his first phnse in the bird other than Duval's work — a work over which he himself casts a shadow of doubt as to correctness, as is evident from the citation given in the first part of this paper.

It is not my purpose to enter into a discussion of the whole ques

118 J. Thos. Patterson.

tion of concrescence, for several able papers dealing with the problem have appeared from time to time since His first clearly stated the theory (Semper, '7G ; AVhitman, '78 and '83 -Kanbor, '76 ; Kollmann, '85; Ryder, '85; Minot, '90, and others). It is sufficient to state here my conclusion, that concrescence is the method by which the avian embryo takes its rise. The conclusion is supported not only by experimental evidence, but also by the structure of such blastoderms as showm in Fig. N,L, as well as by that of the rare ones (Whitman, '83). In fact, it matters not from what angle we approach the problem, the conclusion is the same, namely, that the axial material of the avian embryo is derived from the fused lateral parts of the blastoporic lip.

The anterior limit to which concrescence is operative in the formation of the avian embryo is another problem, but it would seem, from the result of Experiment IV, that at least that portion of the embryo which lies posterior to the primary fore-brain is formed by concrescence. This is in accord with the experimental results of Peebles ('04) and Kopsch ('02) ; especially those of the latter, who maintains that all of the embryo except the pre-chordal head area arises directly from the primitive streak material (that is, from material that is formed by concrescence) .

In this paper I have endeavored to establish two main points with reference to avian development: (1) that the gut-entoderm is formed by invagination; (2) that concrescence is the method of embryo formation. If I have been successful in establishing these two points, it follows that the early development of the birds can be brought into complete hannony with that of other vertebrates ; for although differences do exist, yet they are those for which comparative embryology has an explanation. Indeed, in the avian development the differences have been brought about very largely as a result of the enormous accumulation of yolk within the ovum. Even concrescence itself has been made necessary as a result of this accumulation, and for that reason it is a process that is to be regarded as coenogenctic rather than as palingenetic. If concrescence is considered as a secondary process, we ought not to expect to find it in the embryo formation of those vertebrates that have ova practically

Gastrulatiou in the Pigeon's Egg. 119

wanting in jolk ; and as matter of fact a majority of the investigators on the development of Amphioxns maintain that there is no concrescence, as does Conklin ('05) also for the Ascidians. Eycleshymer ('02), as a result of his experimental studies on the Amphibian egg, concludes also that concrescence is a secondary process. He says, "that in those Amphibia which approach most nearly the holoblastic type, as Rana, Bufo, Acris, and Chorophilus, the greater portion of the embryo is formed through differentiation in situ and overgrowth, concrescence being confined to a limited region at the caudal end of the embryo. In those "forms like l^ccturus in which there is a marked meroblastic tendency, due to the relative increase in the amount of yolk, a lesser extent of the embryo is formed through differentiation m situ, while there is a corresponding increase in the extent of the embryo formed through concrescence, or coalescence of the lateral margins of the blastopore." Again, in his concluding paragraph he writes that "there is every reason for maintaining that differentiation in situ is the primitive method of embryo formation, concrescence being a secondaiy process which has progressed pari passu with the increase of yolk material."^^

Owing to the close affinities existing between birds and reptiles, we should expect to find many points of comparison in their modes of development. Although many Avriters have pointed out the similarities existing between the two modes, yet, judging from the results obtained in the study of the pigeou, it would be of the greatest interest to be able to trace the origin of the "Primitive Plate of Will" to the margin of the blastoderm, and thus to establish a more exact comparison between the two forms.

Summary. The main points brought out in this paper may be stated in the following brief summary :

1. Gastrulatiou in the pigeon's egg is preceded by the thinning out of the thickened blastodisc. The thinning-out process begins at about twenty-one hours after fertilization, and consists in the crowd '^Loc. cit., p. 353.

120 J. Thos. Patterson.

ing upward of the lower segmentation cells in l^etween the superficial ones, finally reducing the entire central region to a single layer — the primary ectoderm. The thinning-out begins slightly posterior to the center of the disc and then spreads in all directions, but with more rapidity toward the posterior margin. The thinned-out central region is the beginning of the area pellucida.

2. Between thirty and thirty-three hours after fertilization the zone of junction, or the region where the marginal cells are open to the white yolk or periblast, becomes interrupted for a distance of seventy to eighty degrees at the posterior margin. Hence, this margin of the blastoderm now ends with a free edge. The interruption is but the separation of the blastodisc from the underlying periblast, and has associated with it the degeneration of periblastic nuclei.

3. At about thirty-four hours after fertilization (or seven hours before the egg is laid) there occurs the gastrula-invagination. This consists in the rolling under of the free posterior edge of the blastoderm, together with the simultaneous fonvard growth of the involuted cells. The invaginated cells are arranged in the form of a tonguelike process, which finally penetrates the subgerminal cavity (enlarged segmentation cavity). It does not reach the anterior limit of this cavity until from three to four hours after the beginning of incubation.

4. Immediately after the gastrula-invagination occurs, the rounded posterior margin thickens up ; in part by the multiplication of the cells in situ, but mainly by the movement of material from the right and left halves of the dorsal lip, which come together and coalesce in the middle line — a process to be regarded as a form of "concrescence."

5. The median region formed by the coalescence of the lips of the blastopore is the primordium out of which the primitive streak develops. Since the primitive streak gives rise to the mesoderm and chorda, its formation is to be considered as a part of gastrulation.

University of Chicago, June, 1908.

Gastriilation in the Pigeon's Egg. 121

LITERATURE CITED. Agassiz, L., and Whitman, C. O., '84. On the Development of some Pelagic

Fish Eggs. Preliminarj' notice. Proc. of the Amer. Acad, of Arts

and Sci., Vol. XX, pp. 23-7.5. AssHETON, R.. '9G. An Experimental Examination into the Growth of the

Blastoderm of the Chicle. Proc. Roy. Soc. London, Vol. LX, pp. 349-356. Balfour, F. M., '73. The Development and Growth of the Germ Layers

of the Blastoderm. Quart. Jour. Mic. Sci., Vol. XIII, pp. 266-276. Balfoltb and Deiciiton, '82. Renewed study of the KC'i'ni layers of the

Chick. Quart. Jour. Micr. Sci., N. S., Vol. 22, pp. 176-188. Bakfubth, I)., "86. Biologische Untersuchungen iiher die Bachforelle. Arch.

f. mikr. Anatomic, Bd. 27, pp. 128-179. Babfubth, D., '95. Versuche iiher die parthenogenetische Furchung des

Hiihnereies. Arch. f. Entw. Mech., Bd. II, pp. 303-351. Blount, Maby, '07. The Early Development of the Pigeon's Egg, with especial reference to the Supernumerary Sperm Nuclei, the Periblast and

the Germ-wall. A Preliminary Paper. Biol. Bull., Vol. XIII, pp. 231 250. Born, G., '92. Diskussion zu Strahl, Die Riickbildung reifer Eierstockseier.

etc. Verhandl. d. anat. (iesellschaft in Wlen, p. 195. Brunn, a. von, '82. Die Riickbildung nicht ausgestossener Eierstockseier

bei den Vogeln. Bonn, 1882. CoNKLiN, E. G. The Organization and Cell-lineage of the Ascidian Egg.

Jour. Acad. Nat. Sci. of Philadelphia, Vol. XIII, pp. 1-119. Dean, B., '06. Chimaeroid Fishes and their Development. Carnegie Pub.,

32, pp. 1-194. Duval, M., '84. De la Formation du Blastoderme dans I'oeuf d'oiseau.

Annales des Sci. Nat, 6 Series, Vol. XVIII, pp. 1-208. Eycleshymeb, a. C, '02. The Formation of the Embryo of Necturus, with

Remarks on the Theory of Concrescence. Anat. Anz., Vol. 21, pp. 341 353. Gasser, E., '82. Beitriige zur Kenntnis der Vogelkeimscheibe. Arch. f.

Anat. u. Phsiol., pp. 300-398. Gasseb, E., '84. Eierstosksei und Eiereiterei des Vogels. Sitz. Ber. d. Ges.

z. Beford. d. Ges.. Naturw. zu Marburg. Goette, a., '74. Beitriige zur Entwickelungsgeschichte der Wirbelthiere.

Arch. f. Mikr. Anat, Bd. X, pp. 145-199. Guyeb, M. F.. '00. Spermatogenesis of Normal and Hybrid Pigeons. University of Chicago Pi*ess, pp. 1-61. Habpeb, E. H., '04. The Fertilization and Early Development of the Pigeon's

Egg. The American Journal of Anatomy, Vol. Ill, pp. 349-386. Hatta, S., '07. On Gastrulation in Petromyzon. Journ. of Coll. of Sci.,

Vol. XXI, No. 2, Tokyo, Japan, pp. 1-44.

122 J. Thos. Patterson.

Hesjtwig, O., '03. Die Lebre von deu Keimblattern. Ilandbuch, Jeua. KiONKA, H., '94. Die Furcbung des Hiibnereies. Anat. Ilefte, Bd. Ill, pp.

395-443. KoLLER, C, '79. Beitrage zur Kenntnis des Hiibnerlieims im Beginue der

Bebrtitung. Sitzungsber. d. K. Akad. d. Wisseuscb, zu Wien, Bd. LXXX,

pp. 316-329. KoLXMAN, J., '85. Gemeinsame Entwiclvelungsbahnen der Wilbelthiere.

His. Arch., 1885, pp. 279-306. KopscH, Fr., '02. Ueber die Bedeuntiing des Primitivstreifens beim Hiibner embryo. Leipzig, pp. 1-44. McClendon, J. F., '06. Experiments on tbe eggs of Cbfetopterus and Aste rias in wbich tbe Cbromatin was removed. Biol. Bull., Vol. XII, pp.

141-145. MiNOT, C. S., '90. The CJoncrescence Theory of the Vertebrate Embryo. Amer.

Nat, Vol. XXIV, Nos. 282, 283 and 2M, pp. 501-516; 617-629; 702-719. NowACK, K., '02. Neue Untersucbungen iiber die Bildung der beiden pri maren KeimblJitter und die Ensteluing des Primitivstreifens beim Hiibner embryo. Inaug. Diss., Berlin, pp. 1-45. Patterson, J. Thos., '07a. The order of appearance of tbe Anterior Somites

in tbe Chick. Biol. Bull., Vol. XIII, No. 3, pp. 121-133. Patterson, J. Thos., '07b. On Gastrulation and tbe Origin of the Primitive

Streak in the Pigeon's Egg. Preliminary Notice. Biol. Bull., Vol. XIII,

No. 5, pp. 251-271. Peebles, Fujrence, '98. Some Experiments on tbe Primitive Streak of the

Chick. Archiv f. Ent. Meek. Organ., Bd. VII, Heft 2 u. 3, pp. 405-429. Pfltjger, E. F. W., '63. Ueber die Eierstocke der Saugethiere und des Men scben. Leipzig, 1863. Raffaele, F., '98. Osservazioni intorno al sincizio perilecitico delle uova

dei Teleostei. Boll. d. Soc. di Nat. in Napoli, Vol. XII, pp. 33-66; 67-69. Rauber, a., '76. Primitivrinne und Urmimd. Beitrag zur Entvvicklungsge schichte des Hiinchens. Morpbol, Jahr., II. pp. 550-576. Rauber, A., '83. Nocb ein Blastoporus. Zool. Anz., Jabrg. VI, 1883, pp.

143-148. Riddle, Oscar, '08. The Genesis of Fault-bars in Feathers and tbe cause

of alternation of Light and Dark Fundamental Bars. Biol. Bull., Vol.

XIV, No. 6, pp. 328-370. RiJCKERT, J., '99. Die erste Entwickelung des Eies der Elasmobranchier.

Festschrift von C. von Kupffer. Jena, pp. 580-704. RtJCKERT, J., '06. Entwickelung der extrtembryonalen Gefasse der Vogel.

Handbuch der Entwickelungslehre. Vergleicbeude und Experimentelle

Entwickelungslehre der Wirbeltiere. Jena, 1906, pp. 1203-1244. Ryder, J. A., '85. On the formation of the embryonic axis of the Teleostean

embryo of the blastoderm. Amer. Nat., Vol. XIX, pp. 614-615.

Gastriilatioii in the Pigeon's Egg. 123

Semper, Carl, '70. Die Verwaiischaftsbeziehuugeu der gegliederten Thiere,

III, Strobilation und Segmentation. Semper's Arbeit, zool. Inst. Wtirz burg, III, pp. 115-404. ScHAuiNSLAND, 11., '99. Beitrage zur Biologic und Entwickelung der Hatteria

nebst Bemerkungen iiber die Entwickelung der Sauropsiden. Ana. Anz.,

Bd. XV, pp. 309-334. SCHAUINSLAND, H., '03. Beitriige zur Entwicklungsgesebicbte und Anatomie

der Wirbeltiere. II. Zoologica, Vol. 10, pp. 99-168. Strahl, II., '92. Die Riickbildung reifer Eierstockseier am Ovarium von

Lacerta agilis. Abbandl. d. anatoui. Gesellscbaft in Wien, pp. 190-195. Wallace, Louise B., '99. Tbe Germ-ring in tbe Egg of tbe Toad-fisb (Batra clius tau). Journal of Morpliology, Vol. XV, pp. 9-16. Whitman, C. O., '78. Tbe Embryology of Clepsine. Quart. Jour, of Micro.

Sci., Vol. XVIII, pp. 215-315. Whitman, C. O., '83. A Rare Form of tbe Blastoderm of tbe Cbick. Quart.

Jour, of Micro. Sci., Vol. XXIII, pp. 375. ZiEGLER, II. E. and F., '92. Beitriige zur Entwickelungsgescbicbte von Torpedo. Scbultze's Arcbiv, Vol. XXXIX, pp. 56-102.


a, anterior end of tbe blastoderm.

ac, arcbenteric cavity.

ft, blastopore.

ce, individualizing cells.

d, dorsal lip of tbe blastopore.

c, invaginated or gut-entoderm.

E, region covered by gut-entoderm.

cc, ectoderm.

gw, germ-wall.

m, yolk masses.

np, Nucleus of Pander.

0, region of overgrowtb.

p, posterior end of tbe blastoderm.

pn, periblastic nucleus.

s, segmentation cells.

sc, segmentation cavity.

sg, subgorminal cavity.

3, zone of junction.


Fig. 1. A median loiigitiuliiuvl section of a blastoderm talven twenty-one hours after fertilization, or twenty hours before laying, x H^.

Fig. 2. A portion of the anterior half of a median longitudinal section from a blastoderm taken about thirty-three hours after fertilization, or eight hours before laying. It is not so far advanced in its development as blastoderms usually are when taken at this time. See text for description. X 161. (See also Figs. 29 and VI).

Fig. 3. A portion of the posterior half of the same section as preceding. Compare these two figures as to the condition of the zone of junction, x 161 Fig. 4. Posterior end of a section, twenty sections to the right of the pi > ceding. Note especially the cells organizing about the periblastic nuclei at "ce," and also the two degenerating periblastic nuclei dm), x 365.

Fig. 5. Posterior end of a section, five sections to the right of the preceding. This shows the tip of the right horn of the zone of junction, x 365 (see also Fig. VI).

Fig. 6. A group of six (three shown in the section) cells organized . ^t periblastic nuclei, which are in the central periblast, x 657.

Fig. 7. A normal periblastic nucleus which was introduced for comparison with the following figures (8-13). X 886.

Figs. 8-13. Various stages of degenerating periblastic nuclei, x 886.

Fig. 14. Posterior end of a longitudinal section taken slightly to the left of the median line. It shows the thin epithelial-like margin just before invagination occurs. At "iii" is one of the few yolk masses that are found at this stage, x 259. (See also Figs. 30 and VII).

Gastrulatioii in the Pi//roiis Egg. , ./ T. Patterson .


„„ nn z pn &

'• •



Joiirnul of Morphfihgy. Vol. XX

Wtmrr i WMtr FrMifjn *M

Plate II.

Fig. 15. Posterior end of an oblique section from a blastoderm taken thirty-four hours after fertilization, or seven hours before laying. The yolk is cracked and as a result granules are found in the cavity (c) just posterior to the dorsal-lip. Sec text for description, and also Fig. VIII. X 339.

Fig. IC— Posterior end of a section taken through y-y'. Fig. VITT. The section ends with a thin free marghi. x 259.

Fig. 17. Posterior end of a section slightly to the right of the one represented in Fig. 14. It shows how a considerable cavity may develop beneath the margin before invagination begins, x 259.

Fig. 18. Anterior third of a section taken in the plane passing through CR of Fig. XI. The thinning-out is in the last stages, and at the points marked "s" a few cells have loosened and sunk down. Otherwise the subgerminal cavity contains no nucleated cells — only large yolk masses are present, some of which are disintegrating (dm). See text for description, and also Figs. 35 and 36. x 259.

Fig. 19. Posterior third of the same section as preceding, w, union between the deeper cells of the dorsal-lip and the entoderm. See text and Figs. 35 and 37 for description, x 259.

Fig. 20. Anterior part of a section taken in the plane passing through FH of Fig. XII. Three large degenerating periblastic nuclei are shown {pn), and at "y" are the cells whicli constitute the inner margin of the germ-wall. The zone of junction is too far to the left to be seen in the figure. X 259.

Fig. 21. Posterior part of the preceding section. See text, x 259.

(lastrulation i/i Ifie Piffeorti Egg. -J-T Patterson

.loKiiiiil (if Morphology. Vol.X.X


Plate III.

' Fig. 22. Right half of a ti'aiisverse section tliroiigti tlie plane xx' of Fig. XIII. X 259.

Fig. 23. A portion of the right side of a section passing through wW of Fig. XIII. X 259.

Fig. 24. A portion of the central part of a section passing through vv' of Fig. XIII. X 259.

Fig. 25. A part of the region of overgrowth from the series which is reconstructed in Fig. XI. It shows a large periblastic nucleus which has moved down from the edge of the blastoderm. This is the only periblastic nucleus in the series that was found either beneath or external to the region of overgrowth, x ^57.

Fig. 2G. Posterior portion of a median longitudinal section from a blastoderm taken thirty-seven hours after fertilization, or four hours before laying. At "rf" is shown the dorsal-lip of the blastopore, which has been enclosed within the zone of junction. It is doubtful whether the region marked "gw should be regarded as germ-wall, x 152.

Fig. 27. Left side of a median transverse section from a blastoderm taken about thirty-five hours after fertilization, or six hours before laying. It shows the beginning of the region of overgrowth at "o." x 138.

Fig. 28. Posterior end of a longitudinal section from a blastoderm taken four hours after incubation. Introduced to show the condition of the region of overgi'owth at this time, x 138.

Gnslrutation in the Pigeoiis Egg.^J.T.Palferson.





Journal of Morphology. Vol. XX.

Plate IV.

All the photographs in Plates IV-VI are from the sections of the blastoderms, and the prints were made directly from these negatives without any retouching. The Zeiss apo., 8 and IG mm. lenses, and compensating ocular 4 were used with camera draw varying from 12 to 20 inches. The magnification is given in each case.

All of the photographs in Plates VII-X were made directly either from the whole mount preparations or from the sections, with various combinations of lenses. In each case the magnification is given.

Fig. 29. A median longitudinal section taken through CR of Fig. VI. Note especially the gradual increase in the depth of the blastoderm in passing from the right (posterior) to left (anterior), x 143.

Fig. 30. Longitudinal section taken slightly to the left of the line CD of Fig. VII. The thiiming-out is farther advanced than in the preceding section, and at the point marked "x" is clearly shown the cells that have loosened and sunk down during fixation. Otherwise the subgermiual cavity would contain only a few non-nucleated yolk masses, x H^ Fig. 31. An enlarged portion of the posterior end of the preceding photograph. X 301.

Fig. 32. Posterior end of a section taken through plane x-x' of Fig. VIII. See text for description, x 3G6.

Fig. 33. Posterior end of a longitudinal section, seven sections to the left of the median line, from a blastoderm taken thirty-four hours after fertilization, or seven hours before laying. The anterior limit of the entoderm is shown at "e." x 1^3.

Fig. 34. The median section of the same blastoderm as the preceding. The length of the invaginated entoderm is necessarily greater than in Fig. 33. X 193.

Gasikli.atio.v in the Tigeon's Egg


Plate IV.

The JofiiN'AL OF MoiiPHfji.oGv — Vor,. XX, No. 1,

Plate V.

Fig. 35. A median longitudinal section taken in the plane CR of Fig. XI. See text for description, x 1^7.

Fig. 36. Enlarged anterior end of the preceding, x 245.

Fig. 37. Enlarged posterior end of Fig. 35. X 245.

Fig. 38. From a section, four sections to the left of the one represented in Fig. 35. The cavity in the thick dorsal lip is, perhaps, the remains of the space that was formed between the upper and lower layers when the former turned under to give rise to the latter, x 245.

Fig. 39. From a section, two sections to the right of the one represented in Fig. 35. It shows the same conditions as the preceding, x 245.

Fig. 40. Posterior end of a section taken through KF of Fig. XI. The tip end of the zone of junction («) is shown, and also the lateral portion of the dorsal lip of the blastopore. X 245.

Pig. 41. Posterior end of a section taken through OH of Fig XI. There is no overhanging margin (dorsal lip) in this section, x 245.

Gastbvlation^ in the Pigeon's Egg. J. Thos. Patterson

Plate V.


zM '*r^isE,»*


/? ac


The Jol-kxal of Mohphology,— Vol. XX, No. 1

Plate VI.

Fig. 42. A portion of the anterior half of a median longitudinal section from the blastoderm represented in Fig. XV. At "e" is the anterior limit of the entoderm. Xl20.

Fig. 43. A portion of the posterior half of the preceding section, x 120.

Fig. 44. The enlarged central portion of a section from the same blastoderm as Figs. 42 and 43. Note especially the epithelial character of the ectoderm, the grouping of the entoderm cells, and the granular contents of the cavity. X 184.

Fig. 45. From a median longitudinal section of an unincubated egg. It shows the anterior limit of the entoderm in its forward growth. The remains of the subgerminal cavity (sg) is entirely free from yolk mass, x 245.

Fig. 4G. The central part of a longitudinal section from a blastoderm taken three hours after incubation. It shows the fragmentation of the yolk lying beneath the floor of the cavity. These yolk masses {m) are nonnucleated. X 246.

Fig. 47. The anterior portion of a longitudinal section from a blastoderm taken forty hours after fertilization. The remains of the subgerminal cavity not yet penetrated by the entoderm (e) is full of yolk masses, some of which are undergoing fragmentation ((?m). X 245.

Fig. 48. The right side of a median transverse section taken one hour after incubation. The lateral edge of the entoderm is shown at "e" and the inner margin of the germ-wall at "y." The space between these two points can be followed along the entire right side, showing that the fusion between the lateral margin of the entoderm and the inner edge of the germwall had not yet taken place. X 245.

Fig. 49. The central part of a section taken through v-v' of Fig. VIII. At "s" is shown a segmentation cell that has loosened and sunk down from the underside of the ectoderm, x 245.


Gastrulation in the Pioeon's Egg. J. Thos. Patterson.

Plate VI.

The Journal of Morphology — Vnr.. xx. No. 1. '

Plate VII.

Fig. 50. This embryo shows the result of the operation described in Experiment II (page 93). The injury was made on the posterior edge of the dorsal lip, thirty-five and three-fourths hours after fertilization. The egg was then incubated for forty-nine hours. The anterior end of the embryo is normal in every way, and nineteen pairs of somites are developed. The depth to which it was necessary to focus the microscope in order to obtain an image of the injured material in the entoderm can be seen by the fact that the somites are out of focus, x 30.

Fig. 51. A transverse section through the injured region of the preceding embryo (Fig. 50, op). The affected cells lie in the entoderm, x 95

Figs. 52, 53, and 55 are all from an unincubated blastoderm. Fig, 52 shows the entoderm and part of the ectoderm above, and a "free nucleus" at n lying on the floor of the cavity, which contains many small granules, x 688.

Fig. 53. It shows two small nucleated cells (at s and s), which are doubtless wandering entoderm cells. There are also ma^ny large yolk masses in the cavity, x 500.

Fig. 54. This shows the result of the operation in Experiment VI. The injury was made thirty-five hours after fertilization, and the egg then incubated for forty-eight hours. There are twelve pair of mesoblastic somites present, the development being slightly retarded, x 20.

Fig. 55. This shows a large multinucleated yolk mass, in which most of the nuclei are degenerating, x 500.

Fig. 56. This shows the result of the operation in Experiment X. The injury was made on an unincubated blastoderm, and the egg was then incubated for twenty-three hours. The embryo is normal in every way. X 25.


J. Thos. Patterson.

Plate VII.

Journal of Morphology — Vol. XX, No. 1.

Plate VIII.

Fig. 57. Transverse section through the injured head-fold of the embryo shown in Fig. 59. The main group of injured cells is at op. X ^^^

Fig. 58. Transverse section through the injured region of the eml)ryo shown in Fig. 60. The needle has destroyed a considerable portion of the primitive streak material, and has also disturbed the underlying entoderm. The folding of the lateral poitions of the entoderm is an artifact, x 95.

Fig. 59. This embryo was operated on thirty-four and one-third hours after fertilization, and then incubated for thirty-four hours. The injury ,\^riS made in . the center of the dorsal lip at a distance from the posterior margin equal to about half the width of the needle (see Fig. XVI, a). Posterior to the head fold the embryo is normal in every way. x 21.

Fig. go. The operation was performed on a freshly laid egg, w^hich was then incubated for twenty-six and three-fourth hours. The injury was made on the boundary between the areas opaca and pellucida, in line with the axis of the future embryo (see Fix. XVI, l)). There are twenty-five sections posterior to the injury that show a characteristic primitive streak structure. X 21.

Fig. 61. Transverse section through the injured region of the embryo shown in Fig. 68, PI. X. Just one-half of the embryo has been affected by injury, x 95.


J. Thos. Pattersox.

Plate VIIT.




IE Journal of Morphology — Vol. XX, No. 1.

Plate IX.

Fig. 62. Transverse section through the injured region (mid-brain) of the embryo shown in Fig. 63. Only the right neural fold is affected by the operation, x 87.5.

Fig. 63. This embryo shows the result of an operation made ten degrees to the right of the median line, in the margin of the dorsal lip. The injury was made thirty-four and three-fourth hours after fertilization, and then incubated for thirty-six and three-fourth hours. X 20.

Fig. 64. This shows the result of the operation for Experiment VII. The injury was made thirty-six and three-fourth hours after fertilization, and the egg was then incubated for thirty-six hours. The operation was made just after the closing of the blastopore (see Fig. Y, K). X 21.

Fig. 65. This shows the left side of a transverse section of an unincubated hen's blastoderm. The figure is introduced to show the rounded condition of the region of overgrowth, which is raised up from the yolk. I am indebted to Professor George Lefevre for his generosity in sending me the series from which this photogi'aph was made. X 128.

Fig. 66. Posterior end of a median section from the blastoderm described in connection with Experiment I (see text for description). X 120.

Fig. 67. A portion of the same section taken just anterior to the preceding. X 120.

GSastrvi.atiox IX THE PiGEOJs^'s Egg. J. Thos. Pattersox.

Plate IX.

'0 23

>u ^'


'J-'. V.

/» 7



HE Journal of MuiiniOLOGr — Vol. XX. No. 1.

Plate X.

Fig. G8. This embryo shows the result of au iujury made ou au uuincubated blastoderm, at about twenty degrees to the right of the median line on the boundary between the areas opaca and pellucida. The egg was incubated for forty hours. The arrow shows the path traversed by the mass of injured cells, as indicated by the small groups of dead cells. The posterior end of the embryo is bent to the right. The curvature is due doubtless to unequal growth of the cells on the tvi^o sides. (For a transverse section through the injured region of this embryo, see Fig. 61). X20.

Fig. G9. The operation was of the same nature as the preceding, except that it was made about thirty degrees to the right of the axial line instead of twenty. The egg was incubated for twenty-four and one-half hours, and the injury is situated slightly more posteriorly than in the preceding experiment. X 25.

Fig. 70. In this embryo the injury was made between three and four hours after incubation had begun, at about forty-five degrees to the right of the axial line on the boundary between the areas opaca and pellucida. The egg was then incubated for thirty-six hours. The embryo is normal in every way and the injured spot is in the vascular area, about half way between the shvus tcrminalis and the pellucid area. X 18.

Fig. 71. The injury in this blastoderm was made on the posterior margin forty-five degrees to the right of the median line. The operation was performed thirty-three and one-half hours after fertilization, and the egg was then incubated for thirty-six hours. The group of injured cells has been brought into the axis of the embryo, x 21.


.1. Tllos. !' \ II !■ |;s(,\

Flate X.

e Jouexal of Monrnor.nnY,- -Vol. XX, \o. 1




With 2 Plates.

In SeiDtember, 1906, many larvae of Allorhina nitida were working in the sandy soil and sparse sod of a certain part of the University campus. These larvaj ^\ere being attacked by the very few female Scolia dnbia attended by the more numerous males. Specimens of both the larvae and the wasp were then collected and later sent to Dr. L. O. Howard, Chief of Bureau of Entomology, Washington, D. C, where they were identified by Dr. F. H. Chittenden as Scolia dubia and its host the %rub-worm' or white grub, Allorhina nitida, commonly known as the 'green June beetle' or 'fig eater.' "

In September, 1907, the larvae of Allorhina nitida were very scarce, but in their place an extensive swarm of Scolia dubia appeared. Of these the females, as they crept over the soil or burrowed into it, were caught and various tissues fixed for future study. The material for this work was all taken from adults. The exoskeleton of the adult is so thick as to make it impossible to section the ovaries in place. The ovaries were, therefore, removed from the body cavity with care and fixed. Certain ovaries were fixed in aceto-sublimate two hours, others in chrom-aceto-formalin one hour, and a third supply in Flemming's stronger fluid five hours. All sectioning was done in paraffin. The sections were made 5, 10 and 15 microns thick and mounted in series. All staining was done on the slide. Borax carmine, iron haematoxylin, safranin, thionin and methylen green were used in staining. Tissues fixed in chrom-aceto-formalin or in Flemming's stronger fluid and stained with iron haematoxylin gave the best results.

The ovary of Scolia dubia is a paired structure. Each member of the pair consists of four ovary, tubules which lead into a common oviduct. The histological structure of these tubules is characteristic

The Journal op Morphology — Vol. XX, No. 1.

126 William A. Kepner.

of the ovary tubules of many insects. Each tubule is anchored with a terminal filament to the peritoneal wall. This filament abuts against a region filled with certain primordial cells. This region of the tubule is called the terminal chamber (Fig. 1). Leading from the terminal chamber is a chain of follicles composed of nurse-cell follicles alternating with egg follicles. In the adult this chain of follicles extends from terminal chamber to the common oviduct.

The terminal filament is composed of spindle-shaped cells which tend to lie parallel to the axis of the filament. Their outline is not well defined. The cytoplasm is densely granular, which makes them conspicuously different from the cells of the terminal chamber (Figs. 1, t. £., and 7, t. f.). The nuclei are oval and have an evident reticular structure ; they measure 6 to 8 microns long.

While it is the writer's opinion that the terminal filament is but a peritoneal process serving as an anchorage to the ovary tubule, and having nothing to do with either the origin or the nutrition of the oocytes, certain early writers have held it to be a more important structure and that by a repeated division of its cellular elements it gives rise to groups of cells which form the primitive elements from which the cells of follicle epithelium, nurse cells and ova were differentiated. The results of more recent investigators point decidedly away from this view. Kohler, '07, deals with this particular feature of the insect ovary and claims that "Bei den Hemipteren ist der Endfaden meist von der Endkammer durch die Tunica propria getrennt. Auch dort, wo dies nicht dar Fall ist, wo sich der Endfaden als Fortsetzung der die Endkammer ausscheidenden Epithelzellen zeigt, besteht eine sharfe Abgrenzung der Epithelzellen des Endfadens gegen die Geschlechtszellen der Endkammer. Der dient ausschliesslich als Aufhangeband."

In Scolia dubia the tunica propria does not completely separate the terminal filament from the cells of the terminal chamber. There is, however, a rather distinct differentiation between the two regions. The cells of the tenninal filament stain more deeply than those of the terminal chamber. Between the two regions there can be found no intermediate zone marked by mitotic divisions or other transitional features. (Fig. 7.)

l^utrition of the Ovum of Scolia Dubia. 127

A marked feature of the region in the vicinity of the terminal filament is that peculiar structures appear within the terminal chamber. There are here to be seen oval cells, deeply staining, measuring 10 by 15 microns. Their nuclei are oval and their cytoplasm dense and finely granular. Except for rounded bodies within it the cytoplasm appears homogeneous (Fig. 7 a).^ At b, Fig. 7, is seen an irregular space containing what may be the remains of one of these peculiar cells broken down. At places smaller cells with what appear to be two, three or more nuclei within each may be found. These figures suggest quite strongly the series shown in Figs. 3 to 19, Taf. I of Will, '86, which this author has interpreted as phases in the development of nurse cells, ova and follicle cells from "ooblasts." The phenomena pictured by Will were at once taken up in dispute by Korschelt, '87. Stuhlmann, Blochmann and Schneider also denounced Will's theory. Among the later writers to dispute Will's interpretation was De Bruyne, '98, who records that some of the cells of the "germigene" undergo a histological transformation characterized by the appearance in the protoplasm of spheres of compact structure serving to support chromophilous fragments more or less numerous. These transformed cells lose their boundaries and their products of degeneration scatter in the cavity of the terminal chamber between the cells which have preserved their general aspect. "Ces produits serres entre les cellules restees intactes, penetrent ou arrivent par engiobement jusque dans celles que I'on reconnait deja comme etant les futurs elements ovulaires et vont y contributor a leur accroissement : il s'agit d'une degenerescence spontanee, debutant et s'achevant sans 1' intervention de cellules sanguines et d'une disparition subsequent par englobenment de la part de la cellule-oeuf, qui joue ainsi le role de phagocyte. Les boules du protoplasme nees dans les cellules nutritives correspondent done aux produits des ooblasts (Will) et leur partie chromatique est le noyau ne, d'apres cet auteur, par bourgeonnement de ces memos ooblasts. Non seulement des cellules nutritives peuvent, en degenerant, donner lieu a des substances d'accroissement pour I'ovule, mais repithelium aussi pent secreter de ces boules."

Giardina, '01, shows convincingly that the origin of the nurse cells

128 William A. Kepuer.

and oocytes are quite unlike what Will believed it to be. Giardina describes and figures clearly that an oocyte and its attending group of nurse cells arise by a series of differential mitoses from a primordial reproductive element of the terminal chamber.

The peculiar features shown in Fig, 7 are found only at the distal end of the terminal chamber. They suggest different stages in the degeneration of certain cells (Fig. 7, a and b). The oocytes in this region tend to be vacuolated about the periphery and are unusually large. (Compare Figs. 2 and 7.)

The specimens of Scolia dubia were taken very late in their breeding season. It is not probable that all the contents of the terminal chamber would be demanded by the rapidly closing season. Thi^ would lead us to expect degeneration phenomena within the distal end of the terminal chamber.

Fig. 7 shows an apparent relation of position existing between one of the unusually large oocytes and a mass of degeneration products. This is but accidental ; for many such bodies are found lying remote from any oocyte. These products in Scolia dubia, therefore, are considered to have nothing to do with the nutrition of the oocyte as De Bruyne in the above quotation suggests, but to be mere degeneration products concomitant with the close of the season.

Besides the degeneration cells the terminal chamber contains the primordial elements of future follicle epithelium, young nurse cells and young ova or oocytes.

Throughout the history of the ovum within the ovary tubule its size increases greatly. The smallest and youngest egg cells within the terminal chamber are about 25 microns long and 20 microns thick. They rapidly grow during their passage down the tubule until they become 1,000 microns long by 350 microns wide. They are throughout this growth highly plastic and readily conform to any irregularities of surface.

During this remarkable growth of the cell body the nucleus remains, so far as comparative measurements of different nuclei show, constant in size. The nuclear contents are highly achromatic except for an irregular mass of chromatin which is always eccentrically situated. This mass is least assembled in the youngest nuclei.

Nutrition of the Ovmn of Scolia Diibia. 129

It is interesting to note that tlie nuclear pattern shows little or no change throughout the entire nutrition of the egg cell.

The terminal chamber of Scolia dubia is limited by a well defined tunica propria, which is composed of a layer of flattened cells similar to the cells of the terminal iilament except that they stain less. A similar tunica propria extends throughout the extent of the ovary tubule.

Beneath this layer within the terminal chamber are found the irregularly disposed primordial follicle cells. These cells are crowded within the interstices between the other elements of the terminal chamber. They are the smallest elements within the terminal chamber, their oval nuclei measure about 7 to 9 microns in length. These cells are more or less polygonal in outline and not clearly defined. They are rapidly proliferated l)y mitoses and as they thus become crowded toward the proximal end of the chamber they assume a spindle shape and lie at right angles to the length of the terminal chamber (Fig. 1, f. c).

Here they are assembled about an ovum or its attending group of nurse cells to form the follicle epithelium of an egg follicle or the epithelium and scaffolding of a nurse follicle. Wlien entering the formation of the scaffolding of a nurse follicle they have irregular shapes ; but in all follicle epithelia the cells are columnar and stand at right angles to the surface of the ovum or nurse cell mass.

Distal to each nurse follicle, follicle cells assemble to separate the newly formed nurse follicle from the egg follicle about to form. In this manner the follicle epithelium develops as a continuous epithelium from the terminal chamber to the end of the ovary tubule ; at this latter region it abruptly becomes a much taller columnar epithelium that is more or less convoluted to form the thickened wall of the proximal end of the tubule just as it passes into the structure of the common oviduct. To this thickened region the French give the name "calycule" and the Germans "^Wandverdickung."

In the growing follicle cell proliferation continues by mitosis. The nuclei of such follicle cells are oval to spherical and do not

130 William A. Kepner.

staiu deeply. About the follicles they elaborate a homogeneous substance called the chorion. Within the folds between the follicles the chorion forms a partition (Fig. 5). As the egg follicle nears its ultimate size, the entire epithelium elaborates a clearly defined cuticle. The cells now become much shorter. The chromatin of each nucleus becomes assembled into four or six irregular masses which stain very deeply. The process continues until the epithelium is reduced to a very thin cytoplasmic layer with greatly flattened deeply staining nuclei.

In Scolia dubia the follicle epithelium is concerned chiefly in the production of the chorion and does not secrete food products for the egg cell ; though in the ultimate breaking down of the nurse follicle their disintegration products are most probably taken into the egg cytoplasm for food. Its chief function, therefore, appears to be the formation of the chorion.

The follicle epithelium is, however, in a secondary manner concerned with the nutrition of the egg cell. Bambeke, '97, found that the egg nucleus of Pholcus, at the time yolk is being elaborated out of the material entering the egg cytoplasm from the nurse follicle becomes irregular in contour and at the side nearest the deposit of yolk gives out many slender pseudopods, as if to increase the nuclear surface that many take part in the elaboration of deutoplasm. De Bruyne, '98, quotes Korschelt as saying that the products secreted by the nurse cells are carried to the germinal vesicle and completely transformed by it. Babes, '00, in speaking of the egg of Bhizetragus solstitialis L., says : " Jedenf alls unterliegt es keinem Zweifel, dass in der Eizelle besonders in der Zeit ihres Wachstums, eine ungemein innige Wechselbeziehung zwischen Kern und Zellplasma besteht, die sich am auffallendsten in den Form- und Lageveranderungen des ersteren zu erkennen giebt."

As over against the apparent remarkable nuclear activity observed in the forms studied by the above investigators, the egg nucleus of Scolia dubia shows no change of contour; its chromatin pattern is comparatively constant throughout the complete nutrition series, and except for its position there is indicated no relation between the egg nucleus and the handling of the food substances from the nurse cells.

Nutrition of the Ovum of Scolia Dubia. 131

In this connection it is interesting to note that there are present at the distal pole of the egg cell a number of smaller nuclei than the egg nucleus, which have a conspicuous nuclear net-work and nucleolus. Their position is a strong indication that they have a role to play in the elaboration of deutoplasm or yolk as the secretion of the nurse cells is passed into the egg cell.

Similar nuclei are described by Gross, '01, for the ovum of Vespa vulgaris. The following is quoted from this paper: "In alten Eiern findet sich ausser dem Keimblaschen constant eine Anzahl kleiner Kerne. Dieselben sind zuerst von Blochmann (1886) bei Ameisen und Wespen beobachtet worden. Sie liegen Anfangs in der Nahe des Keimblaschens, entfernen sich aber bald von ihm, riicken an die Peripherie des Eies und bilden hier eine Lage um den grossern Theil des Dotters (Fig. 186). Blochmann nahm an, dass diese Kerne von Keimblaschen abstammen. Korschelt (1886) der ahnliche Gebilde von Musca beobachtete, lasst die Frage nach ihrer Herkunft offen. Bei Hymenopteren, die ich untersuchen konnte, ist die Abstammung der genannten Kerne eine andere und weniger auffallende als- die von Blochmann augenommene." * * "Beginnen nun die Xahrzellen ihren Inhalt in das Ei zu entleeren, so gelangen auch die Epithelkerne in den Dotter und bleiben hier, nachdem sie die eben erwahnten Ortsveranderungen durchgemacht haben, noch lange erkennbar. Korschelt (1886) meint, dass diese Vorgange mit der Dotterbildung zusammenhangen. Au.ch mir scheint dies sehr warscheinlich zu sein. Die Keimblaschen der Hymenopteren sind auffallend klein. Da nun aber, wie Korschelt (1891) gezeigt hat, dem Eikern der Insecten eine wichtige Rolle bei der Umwandlung des dem Ei zustromenden Nahrmaterials im Dotter zugeschrieben werden muss, so konnten die ins Ei gelangten Epithelkerne dem • Keimblaschen zu Hiilfe kommen und sich mit ihm in die erwahnte Function theilen."

By a careful study including many measurements of egg nuclei no evidence w^as obtained in support of the above view of Blochmann that these nuclei were given off by the egg nucleus. On the other hand several cases have been found, in which certain follicle nuclei had assumed the appearance of these nuclei and appeared to have

132 William A. Kepiier.

been just about to enter the egg cytoplasm. It appears quite probable, therefore, that these migrated nuclei, or as Gross, '01, calls them, "einwandernde Ei)ithelkerne," have been furnished bv the follicle epithelium.

The migration suggests the observations made by Metcalf on the ova of Salpa ; but the two phenomena differ functionally. In Salpa the nuclei of the follicle epithelium are taken into the egg cytoplasm primarily as a supply of food for the ovum. In Scolia dubia, on the other hand, they have migrated primarily to become the handlers of food material and only when this primary function is terminated do they function in the same manner as the migrated nuclei of Salpa.

At the beginning of the second phase of nutrition when the nurse cells are about to send food material into the cs^g cell, but one or two of these migrated nuclei are present (Fig. 6). As the egg cell grows and the elaboration of yolk is begun, these greatly increase in number. Along the distal periphery of the egg cell they then form a closely packed layer of clearly defined, rounded to oval nuclei, each of which has a definite nuclear reticulum and a conspicuous nucleolus. They lie in less numbers about the entire periphery of the egg cytoplasm. Those found below the distal fourth of the egg cell are smaller and stain more readily. Have all of these many nuclei come from the follicle epithelium ?

In Scolia dubia during the early stages and in favorable places within older egg cells, groups of ova are met with in which one or two large migrated nuclei are found surrounded by smaller ones (Fig. 8). In many other cases large nuclei are found, on which there is a partial constriction which divides the nucleus into a large and a small lobe. In all such cases two nucleoli are present ; while only few nuclei with two nucleoli and with no constriction were observed (Fig. 9.) These observations have led to the interpretation that the migrated follicle nuclei propagate within the egg cytoplasm by means of amitosis, which results in each case in daughter nuclei of unequal size. In any cases where the egg nucleus is unaided by other nuclei Dotterkerne or yolk nuclei are found. These are so frequent that to give examples in this connection is uncaUed for. In the ovum of Vcspa vulgaris described by Gross, '01, as

]^utritioii of the Ovnm of Scolia Dubia. 133

having the migrated nuclei, no yolk nucleus is described. Similar conditions are met with the ova of ants and wasps described by Blochmann, '86, and in the ova of Musca described by Korschelt, '86. That ova with these migrated nuclei fto aid them in the handling of food material entering them from the nurse cells have in no case a yolk nucleus is significant. It indirectly suggests that the yolk nuclei of other ova are but accumulations of food material that has entered the ovum more rapidly than the cytoplasm with a single nucleus was able to transform it into yolk.

These nuclei are the preparers of the food and are concerned in but a secondary manner with the nutrition of the ovum in Scolia dubia.

We believe that we are warranted in recognizing two phases in the nutrition of the ova of this wasp. The first phase runs its course within the terminal chamber. The second involves the complete history of "the nurse follicle after it leaves the terminal chamber. The second phase, therefore, lies entirely outside the temiinal cliaml>er.

The follicle cells and theiV derivatives are now considered somatic cells. Kohler, '07, writes : "Die Zusammengehorigkeit der einzelnen Zellen regelt sich f olgendermassen : Als gemeinsamen TJrspnings sind anzusehen : die Zellen des Peritonealepitheles, des Endf adens, des Eirohrenstieles, des Endkammer- und Follikelepithels. Diesen somatischen Zellen stehen gegeniiber die Geschlechtszellen, d. h., die l^ahrzellen und Keimzellen."

I^urse cells and egg cells have long been known to be the chief cells of insect ovaries. Stein, '47, first recognized them as two distinct elements ; but considered them to be masses of homogeneous protoplasm. Meyer, '-iO, recognized the cellular nature of nurse cells and egg cells.

Folsom, '06, uses a diagram from Lang's Lehrbuch to illustrate his description of three types of ovaries of insects. The first type is represented by ovary tubules composed of a chain of egg follicles without nurse cells. The second type includes the tubules composed of alternating egg and nurse follicles which arise out of a terminal chamber. To the third type belong such ovary tubules as are com

134 William A. Kepner.

posed of a series of egg follicles remaining in connection with certain nurse cells, that do not leave the terminal chamber, by means of a protoplasmic strand, which the Germans have called Dotterstrange or Dottergange and which Lubbock has named yolk ducts. The third type involves, therefore, only the nurse cells as they lie within the terminal chamber. Later it will be shown that Scolia dubia in its nutrition combines the second and third types.

Leuckart, '53, and Lubbock, 'GO, were the earliest writers to describe the nutrition of the ovum by means of yolk ducts connecting the ovum with the nurse cells of the terminal chamber. Claus,C., '64, describes for Apis platanoides a very characteristic "Dotterstrang" leading from groups of three to six nurse cells to the ovum. Gross, '01, describes for Asopus bidens yolk ducts between the follicle ova and nurse cells within the terminal chamber. Wielowieyski, '06, in describing the ovary of the hemipter Pyrrhocoris apteris says : Die Dotterzellen sind in einer Endkammer vereinigt und werden mittelst feiner, im Karkraume derselben verlaufender plasmatischer Auslaufer mit ebensolchen plasmatischen Auslaufern der Eizellen verbunden, so dass ein Ernahrungssystem entsteht, in welchem dei einzelnen Dotterzellen mit den Eizellen direkt kommuniziren." Kohler, '07, in the ovary of Xepa cinerea describes large yolk ducts which lead from the terminal chamber and give off lateral branches to individual ova.

All the above forms show a nutrition involving nothing but yolk ducts and occurring only through the yolk duct. In Scolia dubia there are two phases of nutrition. The first phase is accomplished within the terminal chamber through short yolk ducts of a peculiar type. Not all the nurse cells take part in this first nutrition phase. The second phase takes place from the nurse follicles and involves all the nurse cells.

The presence of extensive yolk ducts between nurse cells and ova have in the past been taken as sufficient evidence that this was a feature pertaining to the nutrition of the ova. The inference that a nutrition phase of the ovum of Scolia dubia ensues within the terminal chamber is based upon (a) the presence of short yolk ducts, and (h) the condition of the nuclei of such nurse cells as are attached by these ducts to the ova.

Nutrition of the Ovum of Scolia Dubia. 135

Throughout the extent of the terminal chamber ova are distributed. Except for the one or two at the distal end of the terminal chamber, which are surrounded by apparent degeneration products, all the ova show extremely short yolk ducts which connect them with certain of their attending nurse cells. These yolk ducts have a wall, which appears as a ring formed by the blending or coalescing of a region of the cell membranes of nurse and egg cells, and a central core of cytoplasm. The wall when seen in profile is extremely short, measuring in the youngest stages .25 micron and at its maximum size 1 micron (Figs. 2 to 5). When seen in transverse section it appears as a ring with a comparatively wide body and a diameter of from 2.5 to 4 microns. The wall of the duct stains intensely with all the stains employed as mentioned above. In all the preparations it reveals a homogeneous structure and shows no constituent granules such as Giardina, '01, describes. The cytoplasmic core is not conspicuous except in the late phases of its duration when it becomes greatly elongated (Fig. 5). Unlike the similar structure described by Giardina for Dytiscus this core showed no affinity for particular stains which would give a differential stain.

As the ovum develops and passes proximally through the terminal chamber, the ring-like yolk ducts become more prominent and their core of connecting cytoplasm may be seen. The maximum development is reached before the nurse follicle is formed.

The yolk ducts appear first on all sides of the ovum. After their maximum development is attained, the proximal ones separate from the ovum, and the nurse cells thus freed take a position distal to the ovum which they attend, and enter the cell group of the developing nurse follicle. Thus with the near approach of the complete formation of the nurse follicle, only a few of the nurse cells — the distal ones — retain their yolk ducts (Fig. 5). These few ducts are eventually severed by the crowding of all the nurse cells away from the ovum into .the completed nurse follicle (Fig. 6).

The nurse cells may be considered gland cells which secrete material for the ovum. The nuclear pattern of the cells having yolk ducts differs strikingly from that of the other nurse cells. These chromatin differences furnish additional evidence that the yolk ducts above described have to do with a nutrition phase.

1'>C) William A. Kcpner.

Korschelt, '91, indicated a difference between the nuclei of gland cells that were actually secreting and those that were at rest. lie says: "Nach seiner Darstellung enthaltcn die Kerne secretgefiillter Driisenzellen zienilich grobe Chromatinkorner, welche dnrch Faden unter einander verbunden sind. Es ist ein derbes Chromatinnetz vorhanden, Avie Hermann es bezeichnet. Mit der Entleeiiing des Secrets findet eine Aendernng der Structurverhaltnisse des Kernes insofern statt, als die derlien Chromatinbrocken aufgelost werden nnd an ihrer Stelle ein feines zierliches C^iromatinnetz tritt, das je nach dem Stadium der Secretausstossung noch eine geringe Menge verkleinerter Chromatinbrocken beherberge, bis dieselben in der volkommen secretleeren Zelle ganzlich verschwninden sind, Diese Beobachtungen lassen auf die anschaulichste Weise eine Beziehung der Kerne zu der Thiitigkeit der Zelle erkennen." Woltereck, '98, De Bruyne, '99, Habes, '00, Gross, '01, and others have followed Korschelt in this interpretation. Gross says: ^'Korschelt (1891) hat entschieden Recht, wenn er diese Erscheinimgen als Anzeichen ciner starken Betheiligung des Kernes an der secret ionschen Thatigkeit der Zelle betrachtet."

In tliis connection, therefore, it is of interest to note that the nuclei of those nurse cells not attached to the ovum by means of yolk ducts have their chromatin ccmcentrated (Figs. 3, 4, 5). The nurse cells in the distal region of the terminal chamber which have yolk ducts have their chromatin distributed upon a more or less definite, open, reticular net-work (Fig. 2). As the ovum passes down the terminal chamber carrying with it the nurse cells the chromatin in the attached nurse cells becomes finely granular and evenly distributed throughout the nuclear cavity (Figs. 3, 4). In this way the chromatin of these nurse cells behaves in a manner characteristic of numy secreting gland cells.

During this phase of nutrition vacuoles a])pear within the cytoplasm of the ovum together with deeply staining granules. These are held to be nutrition products.

The first phase of nutrition ends with the breaking of the last yolk d\u;ts and the formation of the complete egg and nurse follicles.

The nurse cells of the completed follicles, except for an occasional


l^iitritioii of the Ovum of Scolia Diibia. 137

follicle cell, lie against each other in a compact mass. At the proximal base of the follicle is found a core of follicle epithelial cells. Into this eelhilar core the ovnm sends a cytoplasmic process. The nurse cells have in the meantime undergone an intermediate period of rest and growth (Fig. G).

With the approach of the second phase of functional or secreting activity the migrated follicle nuclei (described at p. 132) appear within the cytoplasm of the ovum (Fig. 0). The chromatin of the nuclei of the nurse cells becomes evenly distributed. This chromatin feature remains little changed in those cells that have functioned through yolk ducts. In the others the charge of chromatin distribution travels as a wave from the i)roximal region distally throughout the follicle. The distal nuclei, therefore, are the last to show this chromatin feature.

The nurse cells continue to grow. Their nuclei become more or less irregular in contour. Vacuoles appear in their cytoplasm. Within the ovum the migrated nuclei become abundant and lie at the pole next to the nurse follicle. A large irregidar vacuole appears within the egg cytoplasm as the evident recipient of the secretion of the nurse cells (Fig. 10). With these appearances the second phase of nutrition may be considered well under way.

The secretion continues at the expense of the nurse cells. The cytoplasm of some of the proximal cells breaks down. The remaining cells become loosely disposed within the follicle. As the process continues, a wave of cytoplasmic disintegration passes more or less regularly distally through the nurse follicle which is closely followed by the disintegration of the nuclei. In the meantime the nurse follicle collapses (Fig. 10).

The follicle epithelium cells between ovum and nurse cells become loosely arranged so that the secretions of the nurse cells pass freely into the greatly enlarged ovum. These secretions continue to form a vacuole in the multinuclear cytoplasm at the distal pole of the egg cell. By the interaction of the contained nuclei and cytoplasm the material thus taken up is transformed into yolk spherules which are deposited in the proximal half at the periphery of the ovum (Fig. 10? !/• U-)- The deposition of yolk continues until all the cytoplasm

138 William A. Kepner.

has become a reticular mesliwork supporting many yolk spherules and the egg nucleus.

The migrated nuclei finally disintegrate to form part of the food supply of the ovum. About the ovum the follicle epithelium builds a complete chorion. These phenomena mark the end of the second phase of nutrition.

The final disintegration of the nurse cells takes place wholly within the nurse follicle. De Bruyne, '98, observed in Dytiscus that after the cytoplasm of the nurse cells had disintegrated the nuclei of these same cells were taken in toto into the cytoplasm of the ovum to be consumed by it. Paulcke, '01, discovered a like fate of the nurse cell nuclei in the ovaries of Apis mellifica. In these cases the disintegration of the nurse cell nuclei is similar to that of the migrated follicle nuclei of Scolia dubia.

With this the second phase of nutrition is completed and the ovum with its cytoplasm completely charged with yolk is delivered into the oviduct.

The insect ovary has been a subject of so much scientific investigation during recent years, that except for his observations confirming Giardina's interesting observation, the writer would not be justified in adding to the extensive bibliography. Giardina, '01, was the first to clearly define two phases of nutrition in the ovum of an insect. His observations on Dytiscus has hitherto stood without confirmation. Concerning his priority in this observation he says: "E giustizia notare che, gia nel 1880, Tichomiroff descrisse nelBombyx mori un' aperture centrale di communicazione nella parete divisoria tra I'uova e la camera nutrice, e che da questa apertura vedeva penetrare nell' uova sostanza granulosa, simile alia sostanza delle cellule vitellogene. Quantunque la descrizione non sia perfettamente corrispondente alia realta, pure non vi puo esserdubbio che essa si riferisca alle communicazioni protoplasmatiche ova descritte. Anche il Korschelt (1889) non dubitava che delle communicazione tra I'oocite e le cellule nutrici dovessero esistere, ma gli argomenti da lui adotti non erano molto convincenti."

Simili connessione attivamente alia nutrizione dell' uovo, e reiidono poco verosimile 1' opinione del De Bruyne (1898), che esse vi

Nutrition of the Ovum of Scolia Dubia. 139

partecipino solo passivamente, lasciandosi divorare dell' oocyte per via di fagocitosa."

Fundamentally tlie writer's observations on the ovary of Scolia dubia during the first phase of nutrition are in accord with the findings of Giardina in the ovary of Dytiscus. The heavy walls of the yolk ducts w^iich Giardina describes as being composed of a series of granules were homogeneous structures in Scolia dubia. Within the cytoplasmic core there were no traces of fibrillation, nor could any differential stain be made of this part of the cytoplasm. In these structural details Giardina's Dytiscus material differs from the specimens of Scolia dubia.

Giardina is content to establish the presence of a first phase of nutrition. In Scolia dubia, as showm above, the two phases are distinct ; one occurs within the terminal chamber, the other involves only the follicles.

Giardina says that the origin of the yolk ducts is in the unsevered protoplasm and cell membranes of the last differential cell-divisions which result in the formation of a '^rosette" of nurse cells attached to an ovum or oocyte. "L' origine delle connessioni tra 1' oocyte e le cellule nutrici e da ricercasi nella gia noto origine del rosette." Conditions in Scolia dubia indicate that this is a correct interpretation.


1. The terminal filament does not take part in the supply of the primordial cells from which oocytes and nurse cells are differentiated.

2. The follicle epithelium is not directly concerned with the nourishment of the ovum.

3. Nuclei within a cytoplasm to which they are exotic may divide amitotically.

4. There are two clearly defined stages of nutrition of the egg.

The writer is indebted to Prof. T. H. Tuttle for kindly interest sho-wn and help given in the work which was done in his laboratory, to the Biological Staff of Johns Hopkins University for the privilege of using their library, and to Dr. L. O. Howard and Dr. F. H.

140 William A. Kepiier.

Chittenden for the identification of the species concerned in this work, and he thanks these gentlemen for their valuable assistance.

LITERATURE. VON Bambeke. Reclierches sur roocyte de Pliolcus phalangiodes. Arch, de

Biol., T. 15, 1897. Blochmann, F. Ueber die Reifuiig der Eier bei den Ameisen und Wespen.

Verb, iiaturw. Yer. Heidelberg, 1886. DE Bruyne, C Recbercbes an sujet de I'intervention de la pbagocytose dans

le developpement des Invertebres. Arcb. Biol., 1898. BuGNiON, E. Les cents pedicnles et la tariere de Rbyssa persnasoria. Conipt. Rend, du 6me Congres intern, de Zoiil. Ses. de Beiiie, 1904. Les oeufs pedicnles du Cynips Tozae et du Synergus Relnbardi. Bull, de la Soeiete Vandoise des sciences natnrelles, Vol. XLII, No. 150, 190G. V BuTTEL Reepen, II. Siud die Blenen Reflexmascbinen? Biol. Centralb.,

Bd. 20, 1900. Cholodkovsky,. W. Zur Frage iiber den Gescblecbtsapparat von Cbermes.

Trav. Soc. Imp. Natnr. St. Petersbourg, V. 30, 1899. Ci-Aus, C. Beobacbtungen iiber die Bildnng der Inseeteneier. Z. fiir wiss. Zool., Bd., 14, 18VA. Enibryologiscbe Studien an Insekten. Z. fiir wiss. Zool., Bd. 10, 18(^>0. Gross, J. Untersucbnngen iiber das Ovarium der Hemipteren, zugleiob ein

Beitrag zur Amitosenfrage. Z. fiir wiss. Zool., Bd. 09, 1901. GiARDiNA, A. Origine dell' oocite e delle cellule untrici nel Dytiseus. Internal, Monatscbr. Anat. Pbysiol., Bd. 18, 1901. Untersnebungen iiber die Histologie des Insectenovariums. Zool. Jabrb. Abth. Anat Out., Bd. 18, 1903. Kohler, a. Untersnebungen iiber das Ovarium der Hemipteren. Z. fiir wiss

Zool., Bd. 87, 1907. KoRSCHELT, E. Ueber die Entstebung und Bedeutung der verscbiedenen Zellelemente des Insectovariums. Z. fiir wiss. Zool., Bd. 44, 1880. Ueber einge interessante Vorgiinge bei der Bildung der Inseeteneier. Z.

fiir wiss. ZoiW., Bd. 45, 1887. BeitrJlge zur Morpbologie und Pbysiologie der Zellkerne. Zoljl. Jabrb., Bd. 4, Heft 1, 1891. LiTBROCK. On the Reproduction and Morphology of Apis. Trans. Lin. Soc, London, XXII, 1859. On the Ova and Pseudoova of Insects. Philos. Ti'ans., 1800. Metcalf, M. M. The Follicle Cells of Salpa. Zool. Anz., Bd., 20. Meyer, H. Ueber Entwicklung des Fettkorpers der Tracbeen und der Geschlecbtsdriisen bei den Lepidopteren. Z. fiir wiss. Zool., Bd. 1, 1849 Paulcke, William. Ueber die Differenzirung der Zellelemente im Ovarium der Bienenkihiigin. Zo()l. Jabrb., Bd. XIV, Abth. of Morpb., 1901.

!N"iitrition of the Ovum of Scolia Diibia. 141

Pbeuss, F. Ueber die amitotische Keriitbeilung im Ovariiiiii der Ileuiiptereu.

Z. fiir wiss. Zool.. Bd. 59, 1895. Prowazek, S. Bau uud Eutwicklung der Collenibolen. Arb. Zool. Inst. Wien,

Bd., 12. Kabes, O. Ziu' Keimtniss dei" Eibildung bei Rbizotrogus solstitialls, L. Z. fiir

wiss. Zool., Bd. G7, 1900. DE SiNETY, R. Recberc-lies sur la biologie et I'aiiatoniie des Pbasmes. La

Cellule, T. 19, 1901. Stein. Vergleichende Anatoniie xind Physiologie der Insekten, in Mono graphieu bearbeitet. Die weibl. Gescblecbtsorgane d. Kilter. Berlin, 1847. Stitz, H. Der Genitalapparat der Milvrolepidopteren. 2 Der Weibliehe Geni talapparat. Zool. .Tahrb., Bd. 15, Anat, 1902. Strand, E. Studien iiber Bau luid Entwioklung der Spinnen I-III. Z. fiir

wiss. Zool., Bd. 80, 190.5. VON Wielowieyski, R. Ueber die Elbildung bei der Feuerwanze. Zool. Anz.,

1885. Zur Morpliologie des Insektenovarlums. Zool. Anz., 1880. Morpbologie und Entwicklungsgescliichte des Insektenovarlums. Arb.

aus dem Zoiil. Inst, der Univ. Wien, Tom. XVI, Heft 1, 1900. Wiix, L. Bildungsgescbicbte und ^lorpbol. Wert des Eies von Nepa cinerea

L. und Notonecta glauoa, L. Z. fiir wiss. Zool., Bd. 42, 1885. Oogenetiscbe Studien. I Die Entstehung des Eies von Colymbetes fuscus.

Z. fiir wiss. Zool., Bd. 43, 188G. Entwicklungsgescbicbte der viviparen Apbiden. Zool. Jalirb., Bd. 3, Anat. WoLTERECK, R. Zur Bilduug und Entwieklung des Ostrakodeueies. Z. fiir

wiss. Zool., Bd. 64, 1898.

Plate I.

Fig. 1. Terminal chamber, t. f., sections of terminal filament ; a., degeneration space ; e., egg cell ; n., nurse cell ; y. d., yolk duct ; f. c, follicle cells. X 500.

Fig. 2. Two egg cells from distal end of terminal chamber. The lower one shows two nurse cells in a chain of yolk duct attachment. The nurse cells so attached to the egg cell do not indicate secretion activity, y. d., yolk ducts. X 10<^0.

Fig. 3. An older egg cell. The chromatin of the nurse cell having a yolk duct now shows a marked contrast with other nurse cells, v., vacuole. X 1,000.

Fig. 4. Later stage than preceding, x 1,000.

Fig. 5. The yolk duct about to break permitting the final nurse cell to enter the nurse follicle, ch., chorion, x 1,000.

Fig. 6. Completed nurse and egg follicles, e. n., egg nucleus ; m. n., migrated nuclei. X 500.

Fig. 7. Distal end of terminal chamber showing degeneration features, a. and b. ; t. f., cells of terminal filament, x 1,000.

Fig. 8. Group of migrated nuclei. X 1,000.

Fig. 9. Amitoses of migrated nuclei, x 1,000.

Note. — Figs. 2-9 drawn with Zeiss camera lucida, Zeiss comp, eye-piece No. 6, Zeiss apochrom. 1.5. Figs. 1 and 10 were drawn with Bausch & Lomb camera lucida ; B. & L. eye-piece No. 1 and 1-6 and 2-3 objectives.


William A. Kepker.

Plate I.

The Journal of MourHoLOGV-VoL. XX, No. 1.

Plate II.

Fig. 10. Late stage in the second nutrition pliase of ovum. e. n., egg nucleus ; m. u., migrated nucleus ; y. g., yolk granules ; v., vacuole. X l^^


William A. Kepxer.

Plate II.


.;,,!;;;.?^^|if'^^'^i'^x;; '^'


» «

i it- f

i-" f





In describing the nasal region of Amphiuma tridactylum, H. H. Wilder '91b, mentions eine laterale Driisenmasse die ausserhalb des Cavum nasale liegt." This gland, he says, bildet eine compacte ovale Masse und liegt subcutan in einer Vertiefung zwischen den Rtindern des ISTasale, Pramaxillare und Maxillare." He further adds, "so weit ich constatiren konnte, miindet die Driise nach vorn durch zwei Ausfiihrungsgange in den Vorhof der Nasenhohle ein." At Dr. Wilder's suggestion I began, several y.ears ago, a study of the structure and development of this gland and a comparison of the gland with similarly located ones of other urodeles. This suggestion, however, led me incidentally to the study of certain peculiarities of structure in the nasal region of lungless salamanders (Plethodontidie and Desmognathidse), the results of which I have already published (Whipple '06) ; the results of the original line of research have, therefore, been deferred for treatment in this paper.

I. Description of the Structuees in the Adult.

In the adult Amphiuma the lateral nasal gland is readily exposed by the removal of the skin and subcutaneous tissue from the dorsal surface of the head (Plate I, Fig. A). Superficially it has the appearance of a compound alveolar gland extending from near the tip of the snout about half-way back to the eye. It lies, as the above quotation indicates, wholly outside of the nasal capsule, lateral and slightly dorsal to it. It is bounded mesially by the nasal bone and latero-ventrally by the premaxillary and maxillary. The posteriorportion of the gland, however, becomes partially enclosed between the maxillary bone and the cartilaginous nasal capsule. The Journal of Morphology — Vol. XX, No. 1.

144 Inez Whipple Wilder.

From near the anterior end of the gland, in all of the specimens which I have examined, a single duct was found to extend over the posterior margin of the fenestra rostralis (Bruner's nomenclature) of the cartilaginous capsule, from whence it passes through a noticeable thickening in the wall of the nasal cavity, and opens upon its inner surface. I had the opportunity to study the same series of transverse sections of the adult head from which Wilder drew his conclusions above quoted, as to the existence of two ducts to the gland, and I examined these sections with especial reference to the relation of these ducts to the glandular mass. One duct could be definitely

Fig. 1. — Transverse section through the introductory nasal passage of a small adult Amphiuma tridactyluni. x ^^ 2/3. This section and those shown in Figs. 2, 3, and 4 are taken from the same series from which the reconstructions given on Plate I., Figs. B, C, and D were made. The locations of the sections are indicated upon Fig. D by lines correspondingly numbered. Abbreviations : ci, insertion of the constrictor naris muscle into the nasal epithelium ; in, introductory nasal passage ; na, nasal capsule ; P, portion of the premaxillary bone. *

traced to the alveoli of the gland; the second duct, however, when traced back from its orifice, which was slightly posterior and ventral to that of the first, was found to end blindly in close proximity to the gUmdular mass, but without actual connection with it (cf. Fig. 2, and Plate I, Figs. C and D, ad).

In connection with the opening of the duct of the gland the conformation of the nasal cavity must be understood. From the external naris the nasal passage extends at first somewhat mesially, then almost directly posteriorly for a short distance, the longer diameter of its lumen having in this region a horizontal position. In the

The Lateral Nasal Glands of Amphiuma.


region where the dnct of the lateral gland oj^ens into it, however, the nasal passage makes an abrupt twist, so that the longer diameter of the lumen takes a vertical position (cf. Figs. 1 and 2). A short distance posterior to this point the olfactory epithelium begins, the portion of the passage anterior to this point serves, then, as an introductory passage comparable to that described by Bruner '01, and Seydel '95, in larvaB of various urodeles (e. g., Triton and Amblystoma), by Wilder 'Ola, in Siren, and by Hinsberg '01, in larval anurans and in urodeles.


Fig. 2. — Transverse section somewliat posterior to Fig. 1. x 1^ 2/3. Abbreviations : ad, atrophied duct ; ci, cross section of the constrictor muscle near its insertion ; co, cross section of the constrictor muscle near its origin ; cdl, cross section of the dilatator muscle ; d, duct of the lateral nasal gland ; Ic, longitudinal section through the body of the constrictor muscle ; Ig, lateral gland ; na, nasal capsule ; ne, nasal epithelium ; n, nerves ; P, portion of the premaxillary bone ; v, blood vessels.

The twisting of the nasal passage in its transition from introductory to olfactory regions involves a thickening in the wall of the passage. This thickening begins anteriorly in the mesial wall and, gradually increasing, extends spirally around the cavity, ending in the lateral wall. It results in the occurrence upon the inner surface of the cavity of a spiral fold or ridge following the course of the thickening. Upon the forward directed surface of this fold the duct of the lateral gland opens. Thus by the very conformation of the nasal passage the secretion of the gland is directed outward.


Inez Whipple Wilder.

The spiral thickening in the wall of the nasal cavity is shown by histological examination to be composed of a mass of involuntary muscle fibers, which, although somewhat interlaced, reminding one of the relation of muscle fibers in the mammalian tongue, may be resolved into two distinct sets plainly to be identified as the constrictor naris and dilatator narls, which have been so fully worked out by Bruner '96 and '01, in various genera of the Salamandrida (cf. Figs. 1, 2, 3, also Plate I, Fig. C).

The constrictor naris of Amphiuma is especially well developed. It arises from the inner surface of the nasal cartilage near the

Fig. 3. — Transverse section posterior to Fig. 2. X 16 2/3. Abbreviations: CO, cross section of the constrictor muscle. Other abbreviations as in previous figures.

fenestra rostralis and extends first posteriorly and dorsally, then, after making a loop which partially encircles the nasal passage, it passes anteriorly and mesially to its insertion into the epithelium covering the dorsal and mesial portions of the spiral fold. The duct of the lateral gland lies in the concavity of this horseshoe-shaped muscle, the muscle itself constituting the thickening in the wall of the cavity through which the duct was described as passing. (Cf. Figs. 1, 2, 3, and Plate I, Fig. C.)

The second muscle, the dilatator nans, arises posterior to the loop of the constrictor naris, from the inner surface of the cartilaginous

The Lateral Nasal Glands of Amphiuma. 147

capsule, and from the premaxillary bone, which upon the ventral side supplies the deficiency of the latter. From this origin it passes anteriorly to a somewhat extensive insertion into the nasal epithelium posterior and ventral to the opening of the duct. Many of its fibers appear, however, to end within the belly of the constrictor muscle.

The function of these muscles is very evidently the closing and opening of the nasal passage. The constrictor muscle, since its origin is anterior to its insertion, pulls forward and downward upon the spiral fold causing this fold to approach the opposite wall of the nasal passage, which at this point has a very narrow lumen. Moreover, the increase in thickness of the whole muscle mass incident to the very act of contracting causes the mass to press inward and forward, and thus helps to close the lumen. The dilator muscle, on the other hand, pulls posteriorly upon both the spiral fold and the belly of the constrictor muscle itself, and thus by its contraction opens the passage again.

The spiral fold is thus in structure and function like the crescentic fold which closes the external naris of the Salamandrida (Bnmer '96 and '01), differing only in the fact that it lies, not at the external orifice, but at the inner end of the introductory passage. Because of this location, the movements of the spiral fold of Amphiuma cannot normally be observed, as can those of the crescentic fold of the salamandrids ; however, in a living specimen which was in my possession there was a slight malformation of one external naris (probably due to an injury), so that the introductory passage was rendered funnel-shaped, and the movements of the spiral fold at the inner end of the funnel could be readily observed; As in the lunged salamandrids, the closure of the nasal passage of Amphiuma occurs during pulmonary respiration, and the function of the constrictor and dilatator muscles is undoubtedly associated with this act.

As to the gland itself, it presents superficially, as has been said, an acinous appearance (Plate I, Fig. D). The posterior portion particularly, shows a surface made up of numerous rounded eminences, very compactly massed together in definite lobes. However, serial sections through the gland, particularly in immature specimens, prove that it is fundamentally tubular in structure, but with modifi


Inez Whipple Wilder.

cations of the usual tubular type, of such a nature as to give the effect of an acinous gland.

Each lobe of the gland possesses a somewhat 'convoluted tubular axis, variable in diameter, but often of much larger size than the other tubules of the lobe. These central tubules possess a characteristically low epithelium and wide lumina (Fig. 4, In) ; into them open, often in clusters but with apparently no regularity, many con

FiG. 4. — Detail showing trausverse section of the lateral gland posterior to the section given in Fig. 3. Abbreviations : alb, somewhat isolated anterior lobe of the gland, sectioned through its extreme posterior end ; In, lumen of the expanded central tubule of one lobe of the gland ; N, nasal bone. Other abbreviations as in previous figures.

voluted branches, each one of which, may in its turn exhibit much irregular branching. The branches often extend anteriorly as well as posteriorly from the point where they join the central tubule; at their convolutions there are usually acinous enlargements, and the smaller branches are frequently spherical in shape, thus forming true acini. It is the presence of these acinous enlargements and branches in the peripheral region that gives the acinous appearance to the gland. In contrast to the low epithelium and the wide lumina

The Lateral iSTasal Glands of Amphiiima. 149

of the central tubules of the lobes the branches are characterized by a tall columnar epithelium and, for the most part, very narrow lumina. They are evidently the actively secreting portions of the glands, while, judging from the large amount of coagulated material in the lumina of the central tubules, the latter serve as the reservoirs in which the secretion is held.

The central tubules of the various lobes gradually come together as they approach the orifice of the gland ; but, so far as I have been able to determine, there is no single collecting tubule into which all the others open. The number is gradually reduced, however, by the confluence of the central tubules of the various lobes until a single one remains to make its way to the orifice as the duct of the gland. Although somewhat smaller in diameter than many portions of the central tubules, this duct has a large lumen lined with a low epithelium.

Several of my dissections and serial sections show a small anterior lobe, somewhat apart from the larger mass of the gland ; this lobe connects with the duct of the glandular mass immediately posterior to the point where it bends to make its way across the constrictor muscle to its orifice. The method of development of the gland, to be discussed later, offers a possible explanation of the existence of this lobe.

A dense layer of connective tissue invests the entire gland while each lobe has a thinner investment. The gland is well supplied with blood-vessels. I have been unable to determine with certainty the iimervation of the gland. A large nen^e bundle, ramus glandularis opthalmici profimdi II (Wilder), passes through a foramen of the maxillary bone, and issues in close proximity to the gland, in fact, the tubules of one lobe of the gland extend a short distance into this nerve canal. Althougfi this nerve lies beside the gland throughout the remaining extent of the latter, I have been unable to demonstrate that any of these nerve fibers actually enter the gland. A branch of this nerve does, however, go to the spiral fold, and it is possible that some fibers of this branch innerve the gland also. The anatomical association of the gland and the nerve may, at any rate, be explained by the fact that the gland tubules in their development

0) 0)






' Lateral gland tubules of right side.

Lateral gland tubules of left side.

Ratio of length of






c o


> o

a> 3


"o J3


.S "3

Xi 3






is 1°




j3 C

wliole glandular mass to length of head from the tip of the snout to the eye.

Designation Length of



Trans. Larva.

30 mm.




1.84 mm.



.465 mm. (See Fig. 5, a.)


.435 mm.

.25 .30






Ant. and dorsal.



Ant. and dorsal.



Post, and ventral :




Post, and ventral. .195 (See Fig. 5, b.)


Long. Right Half.





(See series G.)


Trans. Left Half.



(See series F.)





Middle Post.



Trans. Left

150 iQn



Ant. and dorsal. •




Post. (SeeF

1.276 ig. 5, e.)





(See series E.)


1.86 (whole







Ant. and dorsal.



Post, and ventral.


1.665 ig. 5, f.)

(See sc

ries D.)

The Lateral Nasal Glands of Amphiuma. 151

take the paths of least resistance, and would naturally work their way along the larger nerve bundles. A more probable source of innervation of the gland is from the ramus glandularis opthalmici profundi I, the branches of which spread out in the connective tissue of the snout dorsal and lateral to the gland; some of these fibers may be traced to the skin of the snout, but several intermingle with the anterior portion of the gland and seem to lose themselves within its mass.^

II. The Development of the Lateral Glands.

As the accompanying table shows, my study of the development of the lateral gland has been based upon serial sections of six specimens ranging in total length from 30 mm. to 190 mm. To this list may be added a single specimen 80 mm. in length in which the glands were studied by dissection. This latter method, while not absolutely trustworthy as to the exact relationships of the individual tubules, furnishes an extremely satisfactory corroboration of the results obtained by the more laborious method of reconstruction from serial sections. The dissections were made 'by slicing off with a sharp scalpel the lateral portion of the head of a specimen well hardened in alcohol, the cut passing obliquely through the nasal cavity in such a way that the whole of the external naris was included in the portion removed. This detached portion was then pinned out in a small dissecting pan and the work of exposing the gland was completed by dissecting from within the nasal cavity, since the only parts to be removed were the nasal epithelium and the cartilaginous capsule.

In the smallest specimen sectioned, a larva 30 mm. long, there is no trace of a lateral nasal gland or of nasal muscles.

The next stage, a 60 mm. specimen in adult form, shows a single tubular gland (Fig. 5 a) upon each side. Towards the posterior end, the lumen of the tubule becomes much enlarged and ultimately divides into two lumina, although in the external wall there is no evidence

An article by Norris, '08, on the Cranial Nerves of Amphiuma has appeared since this manuscript left our hands, in which it is stated that neither of these branches innervate the lateral gland, and that the name ramus glandularis is therefore a misnomer.




Fig. 5. — Developmeutal stages of the lateral nasal gland of Ampbiuma. Although some of these are from the right and others from the left side, the drawings are so reversed as to give in each case the effect of a lateral view of the glands of the right side, i. e., the dorsal region of the drawing is on the right hand side, and the ventral on the left. X 45. Abbreviations are explained in the text.

a. 60 mm. specimen, lateral view of gland of the right side, based on millimeter paper reconstruction from transverse serial sections.

b. 78 nun. specimen, lateral view of glands of left side (reversed), based on millimeter paper reconstructions from transverse serial sections.

c. 80 mm. specimen, internal view of glands of right side (reversed), from dissection. ,

d. 80 mm. specimen, internal view of glands of the left side, from dissection.

e. 150 mm. specimen, lateral view of glands of left side (reversed), based on reconstruction by the millimeter paper method from transverse serial sections.

f. 190 mm. specimen, lateral view of glands of the right side, based upon reconstructions by various methods. The posterior half of the larger gland possesses several tubules which are hidden from view.

The Lateral ISTasal Glands of Amphiuma. 153

of this division. The constrictor and dilatator muscles are already well developed and each tubule opens anteriorly into its respective nasal passage through a slender duct which has the same relationship to the nasal muscles as described above in the large adult.

A slightly older stage, 78 mm. long, shows a larger number of tubules and an increase in the complexity of structure of the gland. This specimen has two independent tubules upon the right side and three upon the left (Fig. 5 b), all opening in close proximity upon the anterior surface of the spiral fold. In each group the tubule having the most anterior and dorsal orifice is the shortest. In the group of three the middle one is by far the longest. All of the tubules exhibit convolutions, and the long tubule of each side has one or more branches.

An 80 mm. specimen studied by dissection shows very similar conditions on both right and left sides (Fig. 5, c and d). Here there are two independent tubules upon each side, one, the more ventral, being in each case much shorter than the other. The longer gland shows a considerable complexity of structure, the development of alveolar-like swellings, and the tendency toward a longitudinal splitting of various regions being noticeable features. The result of the latter process is the very curious condition in which the whole gland ajipears to be splitting longitudinally into two main parts. Thus in d four regions indicated by x show complete separation, while the other parts still remain in communication.

A 125 mm. specimen shows upon the right and left sides two and three tubules respectively. Upon the right side the more dorsal gland is the extensive, complicated one; upon the left side the middle and the ventral (posterior) one form a complicated glandular mass, while the more dorsal tubule is short. The series is not sufficiently perfect to allow one to work out accurately the course of the middle and ventral tubules. As nearly as I can determine, however, the middle one contributes by far the longer and more complicated portion of the glandular mass.

One side only, the left, of a 150 mm. specimen was sectioned (Fig. 5, e). In this there are two independent glands; the shorter one has the more anterior and dorsal orifice, but it bends about in such a

154 Inez Whipple Wilder.

direction tliat the larger portion of the gland lies ventral to the larger giand. This shorter gland is somewhat convoluted and has one branch ; it exhibits several alveolar distensions and in one region (x) is split for a short distance into two tubules, which communicate with each other posteriorly as well as anteriorly. At one point (y) this gland lies in such close proximity to one of the branches of the larger gland as to suggest that a secondary intercommunication is about to arise between two originally independent tubules, a condition which was actually found to exist in a still more advanced stage.

The larger gland in this specimen shows a great advance in complexity of structure. Marked distensions and convolutions occur throughout the gland. The splitting of the entire gland into two parts, already well begun in the 125 mm. specimen, is here almost completely accomplished, while secondary longitudinal splittings seem to be in progress in other regions (z). Many parts show not only alveolar swellings at points of convolutions, but the formation of true alveolar branches. The extreme posterior end shows a peculiar doubling of the gland upon itself, a condition possibly arrived at by a simple convolution, but more probably by an incomplete longitudinal splitting.

The condition shown by a 190 mm. specimen indicates a rapid advance of the developmental processes. Here the right side (Fig. 5, f ) shows two glands. The shorter (ventral) one is convoluted and possesses an enormous lumen throughout the middle third of its course ; although by tracing the tube anteriorly, its connection with the epithelium of the introductory nasal passage may be demonstrated, its anterior portion seems to be in a state of atrophy and consists merely of a slender cord of cells with no trace of a lumen. However a secondary communication with the nasal passage has been established in that the distended middle region of the tubule joins a slender branch of the larger gland, to the complicated mass of which it has thus become annexed.

The larger gland has a slender duct which divides almost immediately into two tubules, one being the relatively simple and short one which, after making a few convolutions, communicates at its terminus with the distended portion of the other gland as above described ;

The Lateral Nasal Glands of Amphiuma. 155

the other makes a few abrupt convolutions and then divides into three subdivisions. Of these two are hardly more than simple, slightl;^ convoluted tubules which have not more than half the length of the third (and middle) division. The latter at about the middle of its course becomes suddenly greatly complicated, showing convolutions, distensions, longitudinal splitting, branching and alveolar swellings, and is apparently dividing up into tlie anlagen of the lobes of the posterior half of the adult gland, while the anterior half will be formed from the other shorter branches.

The left side of the same specimen possesses a glandular mass equal in extent to that of the right side. This opens into the nasal passage by three separate orifices, but, owing to the fact that the series is somewhat imperfect, it is impossible to trace out the relationship of the individual tubules.

A comparison of the above facts shows that the lateral nasal gland and the nasal muscles with which it is associated are structures characteristic of adult life. The gland makes its first appearance, as two or three closely associated evaginations of the lateral wall of the nasal cavity near the inner end of the introductory nasal passage, while the muscles arise from the connective tissue underlying the nasal epithelium immediately posterior to this point.

. That the development of the tubules takes place with great rapidity is shown, not so much by comparison of -the proportionate length of the glandular mass in the successive stages studied, although this comparison shows on the whole a gradual increase, as by the rapidly increasing complexity of structure of the tubules. Moreover, one of the tubules (the middle one when there are three) undergoes a development so much more rapid and complicated than the others that I shall designate it the main gland of the group. In its development several distinct processes occur. The tubule shows an early tendency to become convoluted, often making abrupt curves. Further, there is much branching not only by the simple process of evagination, but even more conmionly by the longitudinal splitting of a distended portion of a tubule into two tubules which remain in communication at one or more points. All of this branching seems to be in its details quite irregular, although carrying out a certain underlying plan of

156 Inez Whipple Wilder.

development which results in laying down the anlage of a glandular mass consisting of many compact lobes. As development continues, the tubular nature becomes more and more masked by the appearance of alveolar distensions ; these appear first at the numerous bends in the tubules and at the termini of the branches, and finally by a direct foraiation of alveolar outpushings from the sides of the main tubules. The resulting compact glandular mass thus acquires a pseudo-alveolar structure, consisting of many complicated lobes, each with a central tubule.

In this process of development there occurs a gradual differentiation of epithelial regions. Only the anterior portion, the duct of the gland, retains the original low cubical epithelium which is characteristic of the entire gland in its early stage. The remaining portions of the glandular regions first seem to undergo throughout a gradual change to a columnar form of epithelium. Then with the development of regions with large lumina, the anlagen of the central tubules of the adult gland, the epithelium of these distended regions tends to become cubical again while the smaller branches retain their columnar form of epithelial cells.

While the main tubule is undergoing this complicated process of development, the other tubules of the group are passing through a more restricted development, often failing to exceed the condition of simple tubules. They show, however, m their development, the same tendencies that the main gland exhibits and in some cases become somewhat complicated.

As to the fate of these accessory tubules, we find in the example given in Fig. 5, f, one case Avhere an accessory gland which has attained a considerable size, becomes, by means of a secondarily established communication, a part of the main glandular mass, while at the same time its own duct suffers atrophy. It is possible, of course, that accessory tubules may sometimes persist as independent glands ; but inasmuch as in no case have I found more than a single functional duct in any large adult specimen, I am of the opinion that the more usual course is for the ducts, at least, of these accessory glands to atrophy, the process extending also, possibly, to the glandidar portion when this is small, while those which arrive at a considerable

The Lateral Nasal Glands of Amphiuma. 157

size (perhaps generally one in each set) become annexed to the main gland. In this process of annexation we have an explanation of the somewhat isolated anterior lobe of the adult gland already alluded to (Plate I, Fig. D, alb), a lobe which probably arises separately and only secondarily becomes connected with the main gland. The atrophy of another accessory duct explains, also, the existence in this case of an additional short duct (ad) ending blindly with no connection with the ghmdular mass.

This atrophy of ducts of accessory tubules and their secondary connection with the main gland indicates a physiological demand for concentration of the secretion at a single point; on the other hand, there should be mentioned, as a possible cause for this atrophy, the fact that a Trematode parasite (as yet unidentified) is frequently found lodged in close proximity to, or even within, the lucts of the glands. This parasite is not confined to this region, for it has been found lodged in the muscles of various parts of the head, and in the connective tissue underlying the skin and the epithelium of the mouth and nasal cavities. So far as I know, the structure and lifehistory of this Trematode have not been worked out. It is possible, however, that the ducts of the lateral gland are vulnerable points through which the parasite frequently gains entrance; the presence of such a parasite within or near one of the ducts would be very likely to cause its atrophy, while the glandular region of the tubule would establish a secondary communication with the exterior through a neighboring branch of another tubule and would thus continue its functional activity.

III. The Homology of the Lateeal Nasal Gland and Its


In both the Salamandrida and the Anura there are certain tubular glands which open in close association with the external naris and are known as the external nasal glands. The number of these glandular tubules associated with each naris varies in different species from two to fifteen. These structures have long been recognized and their relationships have been worked out in various species by Wiedersheim '76, Seydel- '95, Kiese '91, Born '76, and Bruner '96 and '01.

158 Inez Whipple Wilder.

The latter author has not only described the glands themselves but has shown that they have a definite association with the constrictor and dilatator muscles of the external naris, since the ducts of the glands pass through the loop of the former muscle. Moreover, he emphasizes the importance of this anatomical relationship by showing that in Triton and Amblystoma (the genera in which he investigated the development of these organs) the muscles and glands arise simultaneously, the former from the connective tissue in the walls of the larval introductory nasal passage, the latter by evaginations of its epithelial lining; and a similar mode of origin which he finds in the Anura further establishes the general homology of these structures.

In an article already referred to (Whipple '06) I have shown that the external nasal glands of the Desmognathidse and Plethodontidse belong to a series of tubular glands which I have collectively termed the naso-labial glands ; some of these, the external nasal glands, have their orifices near the margin of the naris, the remainder open along the border of the naso-labial groove, a structure which is peculiar to these lungless forms and extends from the latero-ventral angle of the naris to the edge of the upper lip. Many of the naso-labial glands are short, simple tubes ; a few, however, particularly those associated with the naris itself, attain enormous proportions in their development, often extending even posterior to the orbit. Moreover, they become much complicated by the formation of branches and alveolar convolutions. Their great extent and complexity has been shown by Wiedersheim, but seems to have been overlooked by Bruner, who describes the external nasal glands in general as exceeding but little in extent the fenestra i-ostro-lateralis of the cartilaginous nasal capsule.

Ontogenetically the naso-labial glands of Desmognathus make their first appearance in the larva as it approaches its transformation to the adult stage, at the time when the only indication of a naso-labial groove is a slight ventral prolongation of the external nasal orifice. At this time two glands appear, the first an evagination of the epithelium at the inner edge of the incipient groove, the second a lateral evagination of the lining of the introductory nasal passage. As

The Lateral ISTasal Glands of Amphiuma, 159

development continues, the groove becomes prolonged ventrallj by an infolding of the epidermis, and other glands make their appearance along its mesial border. In a large adult I have found as many as twelve glands connected with a single naris and its groove.

Comparing, now, these naso-labial glands of the Desmognathidae and Plethodontidse and the external nasal glands of other salamandrids with the lateral nasal gland of Amphiuma, it is very evident that we are dealing with homologous structures. This homology is shown by the time of origin of the lateral gland during transition from the larval to the adult form ; by the derivation of the gland from the epithelium of the introductoi-y nasal passage ; by its close association, not only in location but in time of origin, with the constrictor and dilatator muscles ; and finally, by its first appearance, not as a single gland, but as a group of several distinct tubules. In fact those developmental changes which result in the final pseudo-alveolar nature of the gland in Amphiuma are foreshadowed by the conditions shown by many of the salamandrids. The chief difference in anatomical relationships between the lateral gland of Amphiuma and the external nasal glands of other forms is in the location of the glandular orifice within the nasal passage rather than upon its margin. This difference is evidently due to the retention of the introductory nasal passage by the adult Amphiuma, whereas in other forms it is a larval organ and disappears in transition into the adult form. Thus the inner end of the introductory nasal passage of Amphiuma is the real homologue of the external naris of the Salamandrida, and the spiral fold which closes the lumen at this point corresponds to the creseentic fold which closes the external naris of other forms.

We come now to the question of possible homologies among the other Derotremata and the Perennibranchiata. The tubular glands of Proteus, described by Oppel '89, offer some interesting points for comparison with the external nasal glands of Salamandrida and the lateral nasal gland of Amphiuma. Oppel apparently examined four specimens of Proteus in regard to this point. The facts given in his description of these four individuals I have tabulated as follows :


Inez Whipple Wilder.



No. OF Tubules

Length of Tubules.


















0.57 (medial) 0.83 (lateral)






0.63-0.84^(four shortest tubules)

1.545 (the longest of the lateral grouja oi three)

2.535 (middle)

0.315 (longest of the three short tubules)

1.303 (the longer of the lateral group of two)

1.335 (middle)





0.21 (medial) 0.6 (lateral) 2.835 (middle)

0.285 (medial) 0.945 (lateral) 3.09 (middle)

From these statistics we see that the iiiiniber of tubules upon one side varies from one to six, the number upon the two sides of one individual being, however, approximately equal. Moreover, the tubules, where more than one are present, vary much in length, as do also the longest and the shortest tubules of different individuals. Thus the range of length in three individuals of approximately the same size (Nos. 1, 2 and 4) is from 0.21 mm. to 3.09 mm. and the extremes are found in the same individual. The longest tubules in these three individuals vary from 0.83 mm. to 3.09 mm. It is noticeable, moreover, that when there are only two tubules the more lateral is the longer ; while in a set of three or more the longest one is the middle one (or one of the middle ones) of the group. For example, the set of six on the right side of specimen No. 3 is disposed in three groups, the medial group consisting of two short ones, the lateral group of three, two short and one much longer, while between these two groups lies the middle tubule which is the longest of the six. There is a noticeable symmetry in the approximate length of the tubules on the two sides of an individual. Although the shortest specimen (No. 1) has the smallest number of tubules, and also

The Lateral ISTasal Glands of Amphiunia. 161

relatively short ones, it does not appear from the whole set of observations that the variation either in number or in length of tubules is in any way proportionate to the size of the individual (cf. ISTos. 2 and 4).

In the single specimen of Proteus examined hj me (a series of transverse sections of an adult head, length of specimen unknown) there are two tubules upon the right side and three upon the left. Of the group of three the lateral is the shortest and measures 0.3008 mm. ; the medial one measures 1 mm., and the middle one of the group 1.203 mm. There is, however, a disconnected tubule ending blindly at both extremities, about 1 mm. long and beginning 2.106 mm. posterior to the blind end of the middle (longest) tubule, Assuming that this detached portion was originally connected with the longest tubule and tliat from some cause the intennediate region has atrophied, the total length of this tubule would be 1.203 + 1.0 -f 2.106, or 4.309 mm. The two tul)ules on the right side measure respectively 3.008 (medial), and 3.7r>9 (lateral).

As to the orifices of the tubules my observations practically agree with those of Oppel, who says "Diese ist fiir alle gemeinsam die Stelle, an welcher die aussere l!^asenoffnung, d. h. der von einem niedrigen Plattenepithei ausgekleidete Vorraum ausserhalb der mit dem Riechepithel gekleideten ^ase an die aussere Tlaut angrenzt. Von der hintern Seite dicser Oeffnung entspringend ziehen die Canale zum Theil medial, zum Theil lateral unterhalb der im Bogen nach hinten steigenden !Nasenhohle gieichfalls nach hinten, um, ohne sich zu verzweigen, blind zu endigen."

Oppel offers no theory as to the homology of these glands. He assumes, however, that the longest tubule, which in one specimen extends nearly to the eye, is the "Thranencanal," a conclusion which has been overthrown ])y the later researches of Born '76. So far as I know, the development of these tubules has never l)een studied, but their general structure and location show that they are homologous with the lateral gland tubules of Amphiunia and with the external nasal glands of other amphibians. A point which would, at first, seem important in the establishment of this homology is, however, lacking in that, unlike the other forms in which external nasal glands are present, there is no trace in Proteus of either con


Inez Whipple Wilder.

Fig. 6. — Transverse section throngli the anterior nasal region of an adult Cryptobranchus allegheniensis. Abbreviations as in previous figures.

Fig. 7. — Frontal section through the anterior portion of the nasal cavity of an adult Cryptobranchus allegheniensis. Abbreviations : ant, external naris ; cc, cross section of the constrictor naris muscle- dlo, origin of the dilatator muscle; Idl, longitudinal section of the dilatator muscle. Other abbreviations as in previous figures.

The Lateral Nasal Glands of Amphiuma. 163

stricter or dilatator nasal muscles. On the other hand, the extensive range of variation in both the number and the length of the gland tubules, as well as the actual evidence of atrophy which was found in the case of one of the tubules, indicates that the glands have lost their functional importance in Proteus, and that they are in a more or les? degenerate state. If, now, this function was originally associated with that of the constrictor and dilatator muscles, the failure of the latter in Proteus is quite consistent with the condition of the glands. The absence of the muscles and the degenerate state of the glands are both facts which will prove of importance in the final consideration of the functions of these parts.

As to the other pcrennibranchs, in both Necturus and Siren there is complete failure of both the external nasal glands and the constrictor and dilatator muscles ; and Axolotl, if indeed this permanent larva is to be considered in this group, is described by Bruner as possessing the rudiments of both glands and muscles, but, as is the case with other salamandrids, these do not ap*pear until the animal has nearly arrived at the adult stage. Typhlomolge, another form which has been classed with the pcrennibranchs, was shown quite conclusively by Miss Emerson, '05, to be a permanent larva of some lungless form, probably closely related to the genus Spelerpes. In view of this fact, one would hardly expect to find external nasal glands or constrictor and dilatator muscles except, possibly, in the very rudimentary condition which is characteristic of that stage of the larva immediately preceding the transition into the adult form. As a matter of fact, the single series of sections through the head of a Typhlomolge which, through the kindness of Miss Emerson, I had the privilege of examining, showed no evidence whatever of any of these structures. Too much dependence should not be placed upon this observation, however, as the specimen from which the series was made was somewhat imperfect in the region of the ex^rnal nares.

Cryptobranchus allegheniensis possesses well developed constrictor and dilatator muscles (Figs. 6 and Y), as may be readily demonstrated either by dissection or by microscopic sections ; I have, however, been unable to find the slightest trace of any external nasal glands. , '

164 Inez Whipple Wilder.

To summarize, among the lower urodelcs Proteus and Amphiuma alone possess the homologues of external nasal glands, while the occurrence of nasal constrictor and dilatator muscles is limited to Cryptobranchus and Amphiuma.

IV. The Function of the Lateral Gland.

Because of the apiDarentlj constant anatomical and developmental association of the external nasal glands with the constrictor and dilatator muscles of the naris in the salamandrids, Bruner drew the logical conclusion that there is also an intimate physiological relationship between these structures. Following out this line of reasoning, he concluded that, as the function of the muscles is to alternately close and open the external nares during the act of pulmonary respiration, the glands, the orifices of which are upon the margin of the nares, probably sen^e the function of lubricating the edges of the crescentic fold to insure tight closure ; and he suggested, further, the probability that the mechanical device by means of which the secretion is discharged is the pressure exerted upon the gland tubules by the contractions of the constrictor muscle which closes the naris.

With regard to the embarrassment to this theory presented by the lungless salamandrids, in which the entire apparatus, both glands and muscles, is found, although, of course, there is no pulmonary respiration, Bruner suggested that the function of closing and opening the nares must here subserve some other purpose, such as, for example, the exclusion of foreign substances, particularly water, from the nasal passages. He thought the muscles in these forms less strongly developed than in the lunged forms, and apparently did not recognize the extreme degree of development which the glands have attained in the lungless species.

My own recent studies of the breathing habits of both lunged and lungless salamandrids (Wliipple, '06) have led me to believe that the function of excluding water and other foreign substances from the nasal passages is the more generalized and therefore the primpry function of the nasal muscular apparatus. The muscles are on the whole about equally well developed in both lunged and lungless

The Lateral Nasal Glands of Amphiiima. 165

forms. Moreover, the contact of any foreign body with the snont is followed at once by the closure of the nares. As a general means for protecting the delicate nasal epithelium from dirt and other foreign matter in forms such as Desmognathus and Plethodon, which are burrowing in hal)it, this device must be invaluable. Further, in all the luugless forms (Plethodontidse and Desmognathidne) I have found that the exclusion of water from the nasal passages is an absolutely fixed habit, so much so that even when they are forced to remain under water for days, the nares are kept closed and aquatic bucco-phar>'ngeal respiration, such as occurs in the lunged forms under similar conditions, is never established. So great is the importance of this exclusion of water from the nasal passages, that in connection with each external naris a highly specialized device, the naso-labial groove, has developed, which acts as a gutter through which the tiny drop of water which naturally lodges in the nasal depression is drained off before the naris opens, and is thus prevented from being drawn into the nasal passage.

Even in the case of the lunged salamandrids a temporary submersion is accompanied by closure of the nares, and thus the animal is spared the physical inconvenience incident to a change of respiratory medium, although a prolonged stay in the water involves, in all the lunged species that I have experimented with, a transition from aerial to aquatic bucco-pharyngeal respiration.

Undoubtedly this device for excluding foreign substances from the nasal cavities has become of use in pulmonary respiration as a means for preventing the escape of air during that phase of the respiratory act when the mouth is used as a pump to force air into the lungs. But that closure of the nares for this purpose is not essential is shown by the fact that jSTecturus, Siren, and Proteus all effect pulmonary respiration in the absence of these muscles, and frequently (in ISTecturus at least) Avith the escape of air through not only the nares, but also the gill slits. Even in Amphiuma, in which the nasal muscles are present, there is frequently some loss of air through the gill slits during the act of filling the lungs. This escape of air can be readily observed in both l^ecturus and Amphiuma when the animals are in the water. In the case of lunged salamandrids, also, I

166 Inez Whipple Wilder.

have several times noted that the closure of the nares during the act of filling the lungs is not perfect, although usually it is so.

It should be noted that the function of the nasal muscles is primarily associated with the attainment of a terrestrial mode of life. Even Cryptobranchus allegheniensis may not prove to be so decided an exception to this statement as vi'ould at first appear in view of its aquatic mode of life. I have not had the opportunity to study the function of the nasal muscular apparatus in living Cryptobranchus. Smith '07, reports however, that this species is somewhat burrowing in its habits, and thus its power to close the nares must at such times be of great value. Further, the species shows tendencies toward adaptation to terrestrial life. The streams in which it lives are liable to become almost dry. I have known specimens to live several days entirely out of water during transportation, not even surrounded by a wet packing, and to be normal and active at the end of the journey. Since the systematic position of Cryptobranchus is more or less of a problem, it is even possible that the presence of the nasal muscles may be due to an ancestral terrestrial foi-m.

As to the external nasal glands, their function also seems to be a more generalized one than that suggested by Bruner, namely, the lubrication of the edges of the nasal orifice to insure tight closure during respiration. There is in terrestrial air-breathing forms a great necessity for some device for keeping the thin delicate skin' which covers the crescentic fold moist and pliable ; for this skin is, owing to its location, constantly exposed to the drying effects of the air as it moves in and out of the nasal cavity during bucco-pharyngeal as well as pulmonary respiration. The acinous glands which are abundantly developed for moistening the skin in other regions, are wholly lacking here, probably because their large size would require a greater thickness of skin than is consistent with the necessary flexibility; but these external nasal glands with their large extent of secreting surface are so deeply embedded that they cannot interfere with the free movements of the skin, and their secretion is discharged through slender ducts upon the surface of the fold, thus keeping the region so thoroughly moist as to counteract the excessive drying effect incident to the location. *

The Lateral Nasal Glands of Amphiuma. 167

The larger number and greater extent of such tubules in Amblystoma as compared with their very limited development in secondarily aquatic forms such as Diemictylus emphasizes the association of their function with aerial respiration under terrestrial conditions ; and their complete absence in the aquatic forms, liecturus, Siren, and Cryptobranchus, adds further corroboration. That the secretion of these glands, or of their homologues, may come to subserve, secondarily, a more specialized function, I have showm elsewhere in the case of the naso-labial group of glands of the Plethodontidae and Desmognathidse, but the primary function seems certainly to be this more generalized one of protecting the delicate skin of the crescentic fold from the drying effects of the atmosphere.

Here Proteus seems to be an exception, for it is a wdiolly aquatic form which possesses external nasal glands. Their rudimentary nature must be remembered, however. This fact show^s that whatever the environmental condition may have been to which the glands were an adaptation, this condition no longer exists. If, as seems probable, this condition was one of terrestrial life, the present form must be looked upon not as primitive, but as either a degenerate form or a permanent larva. The absence of nasal muscles is quite in accord with either view.

Turning now to Amphiuma, we find ourselves confronted by the problem of external nasal glands which have not only reached a high degree of complexity of development, thus bearing witness to the importance of their function, but which in their development have concentrated their secretion at a single point, although they begin tlieir development as do the external nasal glands of other urodeles as several separate tubules. To explain the special function which this glandular mass has in Amphiuma I have considered in what respects the needs and adaptations of Amphiuma differ from those of other urodeles, and have directed my observations along those lines.

In habit the Amphiuma is teri'estrial as well as aquatic. Even under aquatic conditions it spends much of its time burrowing in the mud at the bottom of the water; and in its terrestrial habitat it is described as living in the soft mud and burrowing through it almost like an earthworm. The whole form and structure are well suited

1G8 Inez Whipple Wilder.

to tins environment; the attenuated body, reduced legs, and prolonged pointed snont are evidently adaptations to such a mode of life. Moreover, it is terrestial in its egg-laying habits. O. P. Hay '88, gives an interesting account of his observations of a large female Amphiuma found guarding a mass of eggs at a considerable distance from any water. Among other observations of this specimen, he calls attention to the fact that the overlapping and interlocking lips afford a very tight closure of the mouth against dirt while the animal is burrowing, and that the gill slits are also capable of tight closure against the entrance of foreign matter.

Table Giving the Pkoportions of the Snouts of Various Urodeles.

Triton alpestris

Diemyctylus viridescens

Dcsmognathus fusoa

Cryptobranchus alleghenicTisis . Aniphiuina tridactylum

Ratio of length

of snout to width of head from eye to eye.

.82 .75 .87 .59 1.21

ISTot only, however, is the mouth thus perfectly protected, but, througli the action of the constrictor muscle of the naris, the delicate nasal epithelium is also protected from the entrance of dirt. It will be remembered, however, that the spiral fold which is dra^vn across the nasal passage by the contraction of the constrictor naris muscle is located not at tlie external orifice, but at the inner end of an introductory passage. Undoubtedly the persistence of this passage, which in the salamandrids seems to be a larval organ disappearing with the transition to the adult form, is correlated with the enormous elongation of the snout as an adaptation to burrowing. The relative proportions of the heads of various urodeles are shown by the indices in the accompanying table, Avhich serves Avell to emphasize the peculiarly

The Lateral Nasal Glands of Amphiiima. 169

elongated snout of Amphiuma. This adaptation, however, involving as it does the persistence of the introductory passage, possesses the disadvantage of affording no protection against the entrance of dirt into this portion of the nasal passage, while, on the other hand, the very pressure incident to the act of burrowing tends to force the dirt into these introductory passages. Moreover, this lengthened passage gives an additional area exposed to the drying effects of air as it passes in and out with the respiratory act when the animal is out of water and is not actually burrowing. Here we have a clue to the function of the lateral or external nasal gland. The single orifice through which the gland discharges is located, as has been said, upon the forward directed surface of the spiral fold. The secretion is therefore, by the very conformation of the parts, directed outward. Thus during the respiration of air, in the long journeys which these animals are said to make under the loose leaves and sticks covering the ground of the swamps which they inhabit, the copious secretion must serve its primary function of keeping the lining of the introductory passage from drying; and when the animal is burrowing the secretion is undoubtedly used as a means for flushing out the fine particles of dirt which tend to plug up the introductory passage ; but for some such device as this the dirt would, with the reopening of the inner end of the introductory passage and the resumption of respiration, be dra^vm into the nasal cavity and thus defeat the purpose of the constrictor muscle.

This latter function of the gland I was able to demonstrate experimentally by first carefully drying with filter paper the whole external nasal region of a living Amphiuma, and then filling the introductory passages with dry dirt. After a few moments the dirt became very moist and was soon forcibly expelled, leaving the passage quite clear and clean. A forcible expiratory act seemed to assist the glands in their final effort at expelling the obstruction.

Thus we see both in the very strongly developed condition of the constrictor and dilatator muscles and in the highly specialized state of the external nasal glands of Amphiuma further adaptations to the burrowing habit which in other respects has had such a decided effect upon the form and structure of the animal.

Smith College, Northampton, Mass., July 20, 1908.

170 Inez Whipple Wilder.


Born, G., '70. Ueber die Nasenhohle iind den Thriiiiennasengang der Am phibien. Morpb. Jahrb., Bd. 2. Bkuner, H. L., '96. Ein neuer Muskelapijarat zum Scbliessen und OefEiien

der Naseulocber bei den Salamandriden. Arcbiv fiir Anat. und Pbysiol.,

Anat. Abt., pp. 395-412. Bbuneb, H. L., '01. Tbe smooth facial muscles of Anura and Salamandrina.

Morpb. Jabrb., Bd. 29, pp. 317-303. Emerson, Ellen T., '05. General Anatomy of Typblomolge ratbbuni. Proc.

Boston Soc. Nat. Hist, Feb., 1905, pp. 43-76. Hay, O. p., '88. Observations on Ampbluma and its Young. Am. Nat.,

Vol. XXII, pp. 315-321. HiNSBERG, v., '01. Die Entwickelung der Nasenhohle bei Amphibien. Telle

1 und 2, Anuren und Urodelen. Arcbiv fiir mikr. Anat., Bd. 58, pp. 411-482. NoBBis, H. W., '08. The cranial nerves of Amphiuma Means. Jour, of Comp.

Neur. and Psych., Vol. XVIII, pp. 527-559. Oppel, A., '89. Beitriige zur Anatomie des Proteus anguineus. Arcbiv fiir

mikr. Anat., Bd. 34, pp. 511-572. RiESE, H., '91. Beitriige zur Anatomie des Tylototriton verrucosus. Zool.

Jahrbiicher, Bd. 5. Seydel, O., '95. Ueber die Nasenhohle und das Jacobson'scbe Organ der

Amphibien. Morpb. Jahrb., Bd. 23, pp. 453-543. Smith, B. G., '07. Tbe life history and habits of Cryptobranchus allegheni ensis. Biol. Bui., Vol. XIII, pp. 5-39. Whipple, I. L., '06. The naso-lablal groove of lungless salamanders. Biol.

Bull., Vol. XI.

Wiedersheim, R., '7(!. Die Kopfdriisen der geschwanzteu Amphibien, und

die Glandula intermaxillarls der Anuren. Zeitscbr. fiir wissen. Zool.,

Bd. 27, pp. 1-50. Wilder, H. II., '91. Die Nasengegend von Menopoma allegheniensls und

Amphiuma tridactyluni. Zool. Jahrbiicher, Bd. 5, pp. 155-176. Wilder, H. H., '91. A contribution to the anatomy of Siren lacertina. Zool.

Jahrbiicher, Bd. 5, pp. 654-696.


ad, atrophied duct of lateral gland.

alb, somewhat isolated anterior lobe of gland.

ant, external naris.

c, constrictor muscle.

ci, insertion of constrictor into the nasal epithelium.

CO, origin of constrictor, cut from the inner surface of the nasal capsule.

d, the duct of the lateral gland, dl, the dilatator muscle.

dlo, the origin of the dilatator muscle cut from the inner surface of the nasal capsule.

fr, fenestra rostralis.

g, lateral gland.

in, introductory nasal passage.

M, maxillary bone.

N, nasal bone.

na, nasal capsule.

ne, nasal epithelium.


Fig. a. Dissection of snout of adult Amphiuma showing the relation of the laternal or external nasal gland to siu"rounding parts.

Fig. B. Drawing, based on a millimeter paper reconstruction, showing a lateral view of the anterior portion of the left cartilaginous nasal capsule of an adult Amphiuma.

Fig. C. Drawing, based on a millimeter paper reconstruction, showing the relationship of the constrictor and dilatator muscles to the walls of the introductory nasal passage of an adult Amphiuma, left lateral view.

Fig. D. Drawing, based upon a millimeter paper reconstruction, showing the anterior nasal region of Amphiuma, lateral view of left side.

Lateral Nasal Glands of Amphiuma. Inez Whipple Wilder.

Plate 1



ad 'c

..ne _,dl


Journal ok Moki-hology — Vol. XX, No. 1.



Coiitrihiitioti from the Biological Luhoratonj of Clark rnircrsit!/.



Introduction : Statement of Problem 172

Historical : Literature on the Structure of Protoplasm 173

Sources 17?,

Early views.

Contractile protoplasm reticular or fibrillar 17^

Englemann's Inotagmas 17S

Strasburger's Kino — and Trophoplasm 178

Leydig's Ilyloplasm 17'.t

Objections to the Contractile theory ISO

Protoplasm a complex fluid or foam ISO

Study of Cilia 182

Point of view 182

Observations on the tiner structure of cilia IS?.

Theories of the structure of cilia 188

My own observations on cilia 18.S

Comparative study of the effect of reagents 18."»

Other work ; Fischer, Hardy, and others 18r>

Experiments 18G

Conclusions 1*8

Structure revealed by teasing 189

Flagella of Euglena 190

Cilia of Stylonychia 192

Application of Methods to Other Contractile Tissues 193


Amoeba 193

Actinosphaerium 194

Stentor 197

Smooth muscle 198

Stem of vorticella. Striped muscle.

Conclusions 203

The Journal of Morphology. — Vol. XX, No. 2.

172 0. P. Bellinger.

Introduction : Statement of Problem.

A complete title for this paper would be : The Cilium studied comparatively as a test of microscopical methods and a key to the structure of contractile protoplasm.

The attempts of recent investigators to resolve the activities of contractile structures into phenomena due to alterations in the surface tension of a complex fluid are proving as unsatisfactory as the older attempts to identify contractility with chemical and electrical processes. Those who approached the problem from this standpoint — Berthold, Quinckne, Biitschli, Rhumbler, Jensen and others — used the Amoeba with its activities as Ausgangspunkt" for their researches. Unfortunately they did not determine the real character of the movements here, and, therefore, their theories of protoplasmic movement based on the supposed activities of the protoplasm of the Amoeba have little value. The work of Jennings (1904) and Dellinger (1906) has shown their position to be untenable.

Instead of seeking in the movements of the Amoeba for a key to the structure of contractile protoplasm, the present study turns to the cilium. Here we find contractile tissue, microscopically speaking, in its simplest form. As the cilia are outgrowths of the cell protoplasm, there is every reason to suppose that exactly similar structures may exist within the cell body. Until we have applied to the protoplasm of the cell the methods best adapted to preserve and demonstrate the character of cilia, we are not justified in appealing to indefinite and undemonstrable fluids to do the work of solids.

The investigation falls naturally into two parts. The first is concerned with the best methods of preserving and demonstrating the structure of cilia. The second is the apj)lication of these methods to contractile protoplasm as represented in the Protozoa, smooth muscle and striped muscle.

I wish to acknowledge my indebtedness to Dr. C. F. Hodge, under whose direction the work has been done, for many helpful suggestions and criticisms ; to Mr. L. N. Wilson, Librarian of the University, for aid in securing the literature, and to Dr. F. N. Duncan fojpermission to use part of his unpublished manuscript.

The Cilium. 173

Historical: Literature on the Structure of Protoplasm. Sources.

Reference will be given to special papers at the end of this work. There have been a number of comprehensive treatises devoted to different phases of the subject that should, however, be mentioned at this time.

1. Haller, Elementa Physiologiae," Vol. IV, P. 514, gives a summary of the old theories of muscular contraction.

2. Herman, in the Handbuch der Physiologic," reviews the theories from Haller's time up to 1879.

3. Cornoy, "La Biologic Cellulaire," gives an excellent review of the conceptions of protoplasm between 1665 and 1865.

4. Blitschli, in his "Mikroskopische Schaume und das Protoplasma," gives an exhaustive review of the works on protoplasmic structure between 1860 and 1892.

5. The theories of the structure of protoplasm are briefly summed up by Deiage, "L'Heredite," 1903, pp. 23-33.

6. Davis, "Studies on the plant cell," covers the literature on the botanical side.

7. Flemming, in Merkel and Bonnet's Ergebnisse, Vols. II, III, IV, V and VI, gives the recent literature on the cell. Few papers of any import are omitted from his exhaustive treatment.

8. The literature on the cilium is admirably brought together by Putter in Asher and Spiro's Ergebnisse, Vol. II, ISTo. 2, pp. 1-102.

9. Fischer, "Fixirung, Farbung and Ban des Protoplasmas," presents a criticism of the methods of cytology.

10. Heidenhain in Asher and Spiro's Ergebnisse, Vols. VIII and X, gives a full review of the literature on the muscle.

Early Views. Protoplasm WitJiout Visible Organization and Coniractile.^ The first to postulate an internal framework to explain the movements of protoplasm was Briicke (1861). Previous observers and

'The first conceptions of the nature of protoplasm were developed between »<)65, the date of the discovery of the cell by Robert Hooke, and 1839, the date of Schwann's publication. We find it variously spoken of at this time as "matiere ou substance organisa trice, matiere formatrice, mati

174 O. P. Bellinger.

most of the investigators of his time conceived protoplasm to be semifluid, viscid substance vrithout visible organization. Among those vv^ho did much to establish this view are to be mentioned Max Schultz (1855-1863), Haeckel (1862) and Kiihne (1864). The first two worked with the protozoa, Schultz especially with the Rhizopods, Haeckel with the Radiolarians, Kiihne upon protoplasm. All writers were, however, united in ascribing to protoplasm or ^'Sarcode" the property of contractility. Under these circumstances one is not surprised that they sought in this fundamental property the explanation of all protoplasmic movements. Although many investigators have opposed this view, it has had at all times a goodly number of supporters and at present seems to be gaining in favor. Besides Schultz, Haeckel and Kiihne, referred to above, we should mention Reichert (1863), Briicke (1861), Cienkowsky (1863) and de Bary (1862 and 1864) as early holding this conception.

If protoplasmic movements were to be explained on the basis of contractility of protoplasm, it was necessary to assume some organization for this substance. Although Briicke did postulate a contractile

ere germinale," etc. (Cornoy, 18S4, p. 176). In 1835, Dujardiu designated it as "sarcode" in tlie infusoi'ia. With Schleiden it was, "Schleim." (Beitrage zur Phytogenesis. Miiller's Arcli., 1838). The advances in microscopical anatomy during the years 1839 and 1840 gives Purkinje the credit of first using tlie term "protoplasm." Later, von Mohl ("On the Movements of Sap in the Interior of the Cell," Bot. Zeitung, 1846, p. 73) says, "The remainder of the cell is more or less densely filled with an opaque, viscid fluid of a white color, having granules intermingled in it, which fluid I call protoplasm."

The first to speak definitely of its properties was Dujardin. (Sur les Organismes inferieurs, Ann. Sc. Nat. 1835, p. 367.) In speaking of the sarcode he says, ".Te propose de nommer ainsi ce que d'autres ohservateurs ont appele une gelee vivant, cette matiere glutineuse, diaphane, insoluble dans I'eau, se conti-actaut en masses globuleuses. . . . enfin se trouvant dans tons les animaux inferieurs interposee aux autres elements de structure." Between 1840 and 1865 the work of Schultz, Haeckel, Williamson, and among the botanists, Naegeli, Cohn, de Bary, Cienkowsky, and many others did much to give us clear conceptions of protoplasm. Cornoy sums up the general notion of its properties at the end of this period in the following sentence : "Une masse diaphane, semi-liquide et visqueuse, extensible mais non elastique, homogene, c"est-a-dire sans structure, sans organisation visible, parsemee de nombreux granules et enfin essentiellement dou§e d'irritabilit§ et de contractility."

The Cilium. 175

framework, which was the beginning of our reticular theory of the structure of protoplasm, most of the investigators of his time were simply content to refer in a general way to contractility as an ultimate factor, not attempting further analysis.

Contractile Protoplasm Reticular or FiJirHlar.

Although the early writers were united in ascribing to protoplasm the property of contractility, it was first with Briicke that this contractile substance took on organization. It is not very clear just what his views were, but it is evident he thought that protoplasm was made up of a firm, contractile i*eticulum bathed in a fluid. Two years later Cienkowsky assumed a similar structure for the plasmodia of the myxomycetes.

It was perfectly natural, therefore, for Heitzmann when he found a reticular framework in the protoplasm of Amoebae and the white corpuscles of a number of animals (Flusskeckers, Tritons and Menschen) to ascribe to this reticulum contractility, anl to see in it an explanation of all protoplasmic movements. (Heitzmann, 1S73.) He also agreed with Briicke and Cienkowsky in that he thought this reticulum bathed by a non-contractile fluid. Biitschli (1892, p. 105) questions Heitzmann's observations, and thinks we should attach little value to them. However this may be, it is quite possible he came much nearer divining the true structural character of protoplasm than did Biitschli himself. A large number of investigators since Heitzmann's time have, in the main, agTced with him that protoplasm has a reticular or fibrillar structure and that it is the framework or fibrillae that is contractile, referring all phenomena of movement (locomotion, change of form, ciliary movement, etc.) to these structures.^ Among those holding this point of view are to be

"We can trace back to an early date observations on the reticular or fibrillar structure of certain cells. Thus for the muscle, according to Heindenhain, we find Lauth (1834), Schwann (1839), Henle (1841) and Hoist (1840). spealving of "feiuere und parallele Fibi'illen." Later the extensive works of Wagner (18(13) and Rouget (1863) in the Gastropods, Nematodes, Lumbricus, and various higher animals, brought out beautiful fibrillae in the smooth muscles of these forms. Heidenhain has recently gone over the literature covering the muscle and I refer the reader to him for further history of this subject.

176 O. P. Bellinger.

mrntionod Schmitz (ISSO),^ Eeinke and Rodewald (1881-2), Cornoj

The fibrillar nature of certain nervous elements was first called to our attention by Reuiak (1837, 1843 and 1844). Tliis doctrine was further developed by the works of Remak (1852), Stilling (1856), Leydig (1862 and 1864), Walter (1863), Deiters (1865), Arnold (1865 and 1866), Schultz (1868 and 1871), and Frommann (1867 and later), Biitschli.

Ciliated and non-ciliated epithelial cells were also shown by the work of Friedrich (1859), Eberth and Marchi (1866), Stuart (1867), Arnold (1875), Eimer (1877), and Nussbaum (1877) to contain fibrous or striated structures, Englemann (1880) for the ciliated epithelium and Leydig (1856), Henle (1866), Pfliiger (1866, 18C9, 1871) and Heidenhain (1868 and 1875) for the non-ciliated epithelial cells, describe similar structures. Frommann was first to advance the theory that some such structure is universally present in protoplasm, and, according to Biitschli, to him is due the credit of suggesting a possible reticular structure for protoplasm.

^Schmitz made his observations on plant tissues that were killed in a saturated solution of picric acid. He is convinced of the reticular nature of protoplasm and disputes the interpretation sometimes given that reticular structures are coagula.

In the years 1878 and 1879 Klein came forward in two publications as a supporter of the reticular structure of protoplasm. According to him cilia may be a continuation of fibrils within the cell.

Reinke and Rodewald and later Reinke and Katschmar, working with Aethalium septicum, expressed themselves as favoring the net-like structure of protoplasm. Their method was (somewhat) unique and deserves more attention than it has received. They subjected cakes of the plant to pressure and succeeded in pressing out about 66 per cent, of the fluid. From this they concluded that what remained behind was the substance of the framework. This framework is arranged in a spongy reticulum and is contractile. The fluid "Enchylema" fills the intertrabecular spaces and is kept from escaping from them by an enveloping layer of the same substance as the framework. Reinke's views are much more fully developed later (1899 and 1905). He argues very strongly against the conception of the active protoplasm being of a fluid nature and his comparison "fluid oars of a boat to flagellar" is exactly to the point. Movements are always due, according to him, to the contraction of protoplasmic fibers.

The following quotation from Cornoy gives his point of view. "On pent admettre que le reticulum est seul doue d'irritabilitS et de contractilite. C'est done lui qui preside aux movements physiques, I'euchylema demeurant passif, ou a pu pres, dans cette categorie de phenomenes." It is thus seen that he thinks the protoplasm organized into a definite network, his reticulum, which is bathed in a fluid, the "Enchylema." Of these the reticulum alone is active. His reticulum corresponds to the "mitom" of Flemming and the "protoplasma" of Kupffer. Rabl (1869) held the view that the systems of rays found in connection

The Cilium. 177

with cell division are coutractile fibrillae. These flbrillae arise from the reticulum of the protoplasm, during division, by the breaking down of the cross connections. After division they return to the reticular condition by anastomosing.

Van Beneden (1876 and 1883) held that the protoplasm contained a coutractile reticulum and that it was a modification of this that formed the asters in ova.

Apathy (1891) holds to the fibrillar structure for nerves and muscles. He supports his views by later investigations.

Ballowitz, through numerous investigations between 1880 and 1890, gave very strong support to the fibrillar theory. Working with the spermatozoa he found evidence that convinced him of the fibrillar nature of contractile protoplasm. He believes that wherever we have contractility, flbrillae are to be found.

To go on through the list of contributions favoring this theory would take too much space. I will mention, however, some of the more recent papers bearing on this conception.

Schenck (1897 and 1900) came forward as an opponent to the fluid theory of protoplasm and as an advocate of fibrillar protoplasm. He thinks that Verworn's contractile fluids are not sufficient to explain protoplasmic movements and that contractile protoplasm (in the amoeba as well as elsewhere) "muss eine bestimmte Structur habcn, darf nicht als Flussigkeit angesehcn iccrden." And at another place "die contractile Suhstanz fest ist."

The drawings of Arnold (1898) show beautiful fibrills in a large number of cells. He holds that this is the true structural character of protoplasm.

Allen (1903) working with the dividing pollen mother-cells of Larix holds that the fibers of the spindle arise from fibrills already present in the cell. That these fibers are contractile and that they control the activities of the cell. He argues against the view that they are precipitations as the result of killing.

Parker (1905) sees no reason why cilia might not be fibrillar and believes that their activities are best explained on the basis of such a structure.

Kunstler (1906) shows a beautiful reticular network in bacteria.

Hartmann (1906) thinks the active contractile part of protoplasm is fibrillar.

Duncan, working in this laboratory, has come to the conclusion (held by a number of writers) that the contractile elements in smooth muscle are fibrillar. Although he has not published his work the examination of a large number of forms has already been made and in every case he is able to demonstrate such structures.

In two investigations from this laboratory on the Amoeba, one published jointly with Dr. C. F. Hodge, the author is of the opinion that the movements of this form are only to be explained by the presence of a contractile framework and the last paper (Functions and Structures in A. proteus) collects the evidence for such structure.

178 O. P. Bellinger.

(1884-5-6), Ballowitz (1881 and later, 1888 and 1890), Rabl (1889), Schneider (1891 and later), Klein (1878 and 1879), Apathy (1891), and, more recently, Heitzmann (1894), Schenk (1897 and 1900), Arnold (1898), Allen (1903), Schneider (1903 and 1905), Reinke (1905), Parker (1905), Dellinger (1906), Hodge and Dellinger (unpublished), etc.

Although in recent years the results of many investigations have been opposed to this theory of the structure of protoplasm, the last two researches just mentioned have taken away much of the foundation on which opposition was based, and there is little doubt that it will prove nearer correct than any developed to take its place.

Englemann's Inotagmas. A modification of the fibrillar theory was brought forward by Englemann in 1868 and further developed by him in 1879 and '80. According to him, protoplasm is an aggregate of minute contractile and ^'reizbar Formelemente." The phenomena of movement are the result of the change of form of these minute elements. Englemann names these contractile elements "Inotagmen." He thinks of them as molecular in size, spherical in form when contracted, and threadlike when at rest. The reasons for these assumptions are : First, that protoplasm in however small masses takes on a spherical form when contracted. Second, that when relaxed protoplasm shows often fine fibrillar striations and is, in its finest division in contractile structures, a "langgestrecl-te FormJ^ Contraction is brought about by a change of turgidity, as the element would i)robably shorten with an increased turgidity and would stretch out again after giving oft' fluid.

Strashurger's Kinoplasm and T rophoplasm. Strasburger (1892 and later) and many other botanists who have followed him divide protoplasm into two substances, his kinoplasm and trophoplasm. Of these the kinoplasm is active, entering into the formation of the fibrillae of the spindle and other active organs of the cell, such as the cilia, centrospheres, centrosomes and the cell membranes, while the trophoplasm is nutritive. The above classification implies a physiological difference in the two substances.

The Cilium. 179

According to Davis (1904, p. 712), the kinojjlasm is homogeneous in structure, either minutely granular or consisting of delicate fibrillae composed of very small granules placed end to end. Its homogeneous character is shown in the cell membranes, while the fibrous condition appears during cell activity and then disappears. On page 449 Davis says : "Kinoplasm runs through cycles in which the structure passes from a granular condition to a fibrillar and back again into a granular state." He admits that the fibrillae may noh disappear, but simply be arranged in a closely packed network which is invisible under the microscope. All protoplasmic movements are due to the contraction of the kinoplasmic fibrillae. Although there is much about the kinoplasmic structure that is not understood, there is much in this theory of the structure of protoplasm that is attractive.

Hyaloplasm Active, Spongioplasm Inert.

One of the most peculiar theories developed to explain protoplasmic movements appeared in the year 1883. In this theory Brass (1883 and '84) and, soon after, Leydig (1885) exactly reverse the conception of the adherents of the reticular theory. Instead of the reticulum, the spongioplasm, according to these two writers, it is the fluid part, the hyaloplasm, that is contractile. In its activities is to be found an explanation of all protoplasmic movements. Few investigators have been inclined toward Leydig's hypothesis. Rhode (1890 and '91), Griesbach (1801) and Schiifer (1887, '91, '93 and 1904) about complete the list. Schafer's views have been criticized by Blitschli (1892) and recently by Putter (1903), especially in its application to the cilium. Although Schiifer (1904) answers Putter's criticism, we find little in his discussion that warrants us in accepting his view. Recent investigations seem to prove conclusively that his position is untenable.

Schafer's view may be summed up briefly as follows : Protoplasm is composed of two distinct substances, spongioplasm and hyaloj^lasm. "Spongioplasm has a reticular or sj)onge-like arrangement, an affinity for staining fluids, is firmer than hyaloplasm, but perhaps not actually solid, and is in all probability highly extensible and elastic. Hyaloplasm, on the other hand, is structureless, has little or no affinity for stains and is highly labile and fluent. It is by the active flowing of

180 O. P. Dellinger.

the hyaloj^lasm, not by the contraction of the spongioplasm (as conceived by Cornoy), that the movements of cells are produced. Of the two substances, the hyaloplasm is the more active, the sj^ongioplasm the more inert. The spongioplasm forms, in fact, a sort of frameAvork supporting the hyaloplasm and into which, under the influence of stimuli, the hyaloplasm becomes wholly withdrawn" (Schiifer On the Structure of Amoeboid Protoplasm," 1891, p. 195).

Ohjecfluiis to the Coniraction Theory.

Observations, principally on the movements of the protoplasm in Amoebae ^nd in plant cells, caused many observers to reject the coutraction theory of the movements of protoplasm. In an advancing Amoeba the supposed currents which gave rise to the objections to contractility as a cause of protoplasmic movement were those beginning at the point of advance and extending backward. Wallich (18G3) and Biltschli (1873) for Amoebae, and Hofmeister (1865 and '67) for the plant cell called attention to such currents. Since then many investigators have either thought they observed or else have assumed the presence of surface currents of this kind and have based their theories of protoplasmic movement on them.

Among those who took this standpoint were Hofmeister (1865 and 1867), Biltschli (1873), Quincke (1870 and later), Berthold (1872), and more recently Biltschli (1892), Rhumbler (1898, 1902, '03, '04 and '05), Gurwitsch (1901) and many others.

Unfortunately for the adherents of these theories, the recent investigations of Jennings (1901) and Dellinger (1906) have shown that the backward currents do not exist. It further appears that the real character of the movements in the Amoeba was not at all divined.

Protoplasm a Complex Fluid.

Berthold, Quincke, Schwartz, Rhumbler and others.

Although the doctrine of the fluid nature of protoplasm fell much into discredit during the seventies, it was taken up again in the eighties by a number of investigators.

Thus, Berthold, in his work published in 1886, came forwa^-d with arguments in favor of this conception which was universally

The Ciliiim. 181

held earlier. He did not, however, try to support it by direct proof, but laid it down, rather, as a hypothesis upon which to base his observations and speculations upon the structure and moA^ements of protoplasm. According to him, protoplasm is an emulsion ; that is, it is a mixture of two or more complex fluids (Der Plasmakorper in seiner Gesammtheit als eine Emulsion von mehr odor woniger fliissiger Consistenz aufzufassen ist." (Berthold 1886, p. (54.)

Quincke (1870 and later) also held that protoplasm was a fluid, but after Biitschli's publication seemed to favor the foam theory. It was from Quincke that liiltschli got the idea of foams which figure so prominently in his conceptions of protoplasm, but Quincke does not seem to have made the application of his foams to protoplasm until after Biitschli published.

Schwartz, another writer of this period (1897), seems to hold to the view of protoplasm as fluid, but, as Biitschli points out, it is difficult to understand just what his position is.

In recent years Verworn, Rhumbler, Jensen, Loeb, Gurwitch and many others have supported this view.


Very early Biitschli, as has been noted above, objected to the contraction theory of protoplasmic movements, and in 1887 we find him advocating the fluid nature of the endosarc of the Infusoria. Later (1892) he came out with a definite theory of the structure of protoplasm. According to him, the key to its structure is to be found in the microscopic oil-foams. The first fifty-seven pages are given up to the investigation of foams of different kinds. After an extensive study of the protoplasm of a large number of protozoa, of bacteria and of cells of many animal tissues, he concludes that its structure corresponds to that of the minutest microscopic foams. ('^ISTach meiner Auff'assuug entsprach der Aufbau des Plasmas den microskopischen Schaiimen mit dem TJnterschied, dass der Wabeninlialt gewohnlicher Schaume liingegen eine wiisserige Fllissigkeit sei." Biitschli, p. 3.) In the application of this concei^tion to the explanation of protoplasmic movements he admits that, while it is satisfactory for amoeboid movement in the strict sense, modifications of it, especially

182 0. P. Bellinger.

the formation of the fine pseudopods of many ^'Sarcodina," find no explanation. (Biitschli, p. 198.) He suggests (p. 208) that muscular contraction may possibly be explained by the above hypothesis. The fibrils are there composed of a row of alveoli instead of being simple threads.

Since Biitschli's publication many observers have described protoplasm as a "Schaum." Thus, Andrews (1897), after a most extensive microscopic study of living protoplasm, decides that all the phenomena observed finds an explanation in Biitschli's Schaumstructure. Crato, in 1892, '95 and '96, finds the foam structure to hold for plant protoplasm. Erlanger (1897) expresses himself in favor of this theory. Degen (1905), after a series of investigations on the action of the contractile vacuole, is of the opinion that protoplasm is alveolar. The alveoli of his photographs, it seems, however, might be interpreted as meshes of a reticulum.

Study of Cilia. Point of Vieiu. ■

A number of eminent investigators, Biitschli, Rhumbler, Jensen and others, have taken Verworn's standpoint, that "Die lebendige Substanz der rhizopodoiden Zelle mit ihrer Bewegung muss Aiisgangspunkt fiir die Untersuchungen der Contractionserscheinung sein. Es heisst die Losung des Contractionsproblems unnothig erschweren, wenn man die Behandlung bei der quergestreiften Muskelzelle beginnt, wo die Differenzirung der lebendigen Substanz und ihre einseitige Anpassung an eine bestimmte Leistung ihren hoclisten Entwicklungsgrad und ihre grosste Complication erreicht hat," and have approached the problem from this point of vieM\ Yet the outcome of their investigations in complex fluids and microscopic foams has been unsatisfactory and has led to widespread confusion of our notions of contractile structures. For pure contractile tissue, microscopically speaking, our simplest structure is the cilium. Here, with the protoplasm accessible for experiments with all kinds of reagents, if anywhere, we should find the key to the structure of contractile protoplasm. If, in applying the methods for the demonstration oi cilia to the protoplasm of the cell, structural elements are demon

The Cilium. 183

strafed, we may assume that these structures are real. It is from this point of view that the present investigation is pursued.

Finer Structure of Cilia. - Ueber den feineren Ban aller genannten Organellcn sind die Angaben iiberaus sparlich, die meisten Beobachter sahen nichts als hyalines Plasma" (Putter, 1903, p. 15). This is a fair statement of recent views. Although a study of ciliary action has led to certain fairly well-founded conclusions as to their probable structure, few direct observations of their finer anatomy have been made.

Englemann (1881, p. 511) points out that all large cilia, ciliary membranes, etc., are made up of fine fibrils. These fibrils correspond to those of all contractile structures.

Kliennenberg (1886) took the ground that the large "Geiseln der Wimperringe (bei Lopadorhynchus, Polycha) aus 20 bis 30 Cilien bestehen" (Putter).

Jensen (1887) figures, for the tail of sperms, fibrils that were brought out by pressure on the cover glass. Judging from his drawings the fibrillar structure is very evident.

Ballowitz (1886 and later), in a series of contributions to the structure of spermatozoa, gives some strong evidence for fibrillar structure in these organoids. In another paper (1890) he holds that contractile tissues, wherever found, are fibrillar. There is no doubt from his drawings that this is true, at least in the sperms.

Schuberg (1891) describes the "Zusammensetzung der Membranellen" of Stentor coeruleus and bursaria and of some hypotrichous infusorias. They consist, according to him, of two Reihen" of fibrils.

Stevens (1901) asserts that the aboral membrane of Licnophora macfarlandii, Stevens, consists of fine long cilia, which are visible in the living animal under high magnification. (Putter.)

Theories of the Structure of Cilia.

Although there are a few direct observations on the finer anatomy of cilia, a number of theories of their probable structure have been advanced. These are admirably summed up by Putter, pages 27-29.

They are, in l)rief : First, that the cilia are lifeless processes attached to the cell. They are somewhat stiff and are moved by active

184 O. P. Delliiigcr.

elements in the cell body. That is, tliey arc Beweg'bar, niclit bevveglieli." This was the conception of the earliest observers and has been recently revived by Benda (1891). Althongh it has at all times had occasional supporters, Stuarf^ (1867), Xiissbamn (1877), Claparedes (1875) and Kraft (1890), it has not, as a rule, appealed to investigators.

Second, that cilia are hollow elastic sheaths into which a fluid is injected and withdrawn. This is the hypothesis advanced by Schafer in 1891 and supported by him recently against an attack by Putter. So far as I know, it has found practically no support among investigators, most of them agreeing with Parker that there is little in recent work to justify it. In fact, the continued activity of cilia after complete isolation indicates that they contain within themselves their own. contractile material.

Third, that cilia are complex fluids. This is the view of Verworn (1890 and later), also of Jensen. This conception has been criticized, Schenke (1890), in which criticism he gives the reasons why contractile substance cannot be fluid. So far as cilia are concerned, Reinke jDossibly expressed the objections to this view best when he said : "Als fliissig oder halbfliissig konnen diese Geisseln unmoglich gelten. Sie wiiren dann so wenig imstande, die mechanische Arbeit der Portbewegimg der Spore zu leisten wie est moglich ist, ein Boot zu bewegen mit Rudern die aus einer Fliissigkeit bcstehen."

Fourth, that cilia hav^e a fibrillar structure and that the movements are due to the contraction of these fibrils. The fibrils may be only temporary arrangements of the molecules of an otherwise homogeneous substance. This is Putter's view. He thinks himself forced to it by lack of structure in the flagellum. T do not think his position is well taken, and if, as will be shown later in this paper, the flagella are really fibrillar, he has no ground for it whatever. ,

Tn Engiemann's theory, first advocated by him in 1868 and devel "Stuart bases bis view on observations made on ciliated cells of "Aolidenlarven." He saw running tbi-ough the cells parallel fibers some of which went to the nucleus. During cell activity, he observed that when the cilia were in motion the nucleus was also affected, and concluded that the structures in question were contractile fibers by which the cilia and nucleus were moved.

The Ciliiim. 185

oped further in 1879, the fibers are permanent structures. Cilia are, according to him, composed of fine elements, "Inotagnien," which in their resting condition are fibril like and when contracted are more or less rounded. They are arranged with their long axis parallel to that of the cilium. Parker (1905) has expressed himself as in favor of the fibrillar hypothesis, and thinks it the most consistent thus far advanced as an explanation of the more usual types of ciliary movement." He does not agree in any way with Putter's objections, and suggests that even in the apparently homogeneous flagella there may be fibrillae.

Ballowitz (1886, '88 and '90), Jensen (1887) and others conceive tlie fibrillae as running the full length of the cilia. They have gathered much evidence which supports this view.

Effect of Killing Reagents on Cilia. Int7'oduction.

Although many writers have dealt with the effects of killing reagents on protoplasm, Berthold (1886), Fischer (1894 and 1899), Biitschli (1892), Hardy (1899), Tellyesniczky (1898), Wasitlewski (1899) and others, none so far as I have known have approached the question from the standpoint of visible structural elements of the living tissue. They have, rather, dealt with structures that appear after the application of the reagent. For that reason there has always been a question as to the reality of such elements. In selecting the cilium as a structure already present, which is as delicate as the finest structures demonstrated in the cell, it has been the thonght of the writer that reagents which produce no change in it would likewise leave the elements in the cell undisturbed, and thus the structures found in the cell could be considered normal.

Methods and Mntericds.

Paramecium caudatum, Stylonychia pustulata and Actinosphaeriuni eichhornii were used. Probably all the cilia of Stylonychia are compound; that is, composed of a number of fibrils coiled together spirally (PI. T, Fig. 1.) For this reason the effect of the reagents on its cilia are more easily observed, and it was used entirely for the

18G O. P. Dellinger.

photographs. Actinosphaerium was chosen because of its long, finely drawn out pseudopods, which have a central core of fibrillae. In taking the records only the fibrillae were considered.

In all, twenty-eight different agents were tested. They represent the killing fluids generally used in cytological studies. For convenience I have arranged them in seven groups according to some one reagent they contain. Some reagents are found in more than one group.

All observations were made under a 1.5 mm. (Spencer Lens Co.) Objective and No. 1 eye-piece.

Osmic Acid Group.

This group contains osmic acid, 4 per cent., 1 per cent, and 2 per cent.; osmic acid 2 per cent., 95 per cent, alcohol, equal parts; 2 per cent, osmic acid mercuric bichloride saturated in normal salt, equal parts; 2 per cent, osmic acid, 10 per cent, formol, equal parts, and strong and weak Flemming. (If two or more reagents enter into a solution it was made up just before using. This holds for all reagents in all groups.) These reagents prove to be the more satisfactory in preserving cilia than those of any other group. In most cases the cilia are well fixed in nearly normal condition. Strong and weak Flemming are the exceptions.

Osmic acid: — Cilia treated with osmic acid in solutions of A per cent., 1 per cent, and 2 per cent, strength seem entirely normal. They are full length and straight. (PI. I, Fig. 2). After making many tests with the three solutions the author favors the 2 per cent, solution as the most reliable.

Two per cent, osmic, 95 jier cent, alcohol : — This combination is a fair killing agent.

Two per cent, osmic -f- mercuric bichloride : — This solution next to osmic acid gave the best results. Cilia treated with it are full length and straight.

vStrong and weak Flemming: — These two solutions so universally used in cytological studies gave the most unsatisfactory results of any in this group. Cilia are apparently broken or twisted into what appears to be short, crinkled threads. (PI. I, Fig. 3.) These threads

The Cilium. 187

resemble the mitoins of Flemming, also those so often figured bj botanists whenever a fibrillar structure is represented.

Two per cent, osmic + formol : — Cilia treated with this solution are straight and entire. In stylonychia the fibrils seem broken up, but the cilium, as a whole, is well preserved.

Mercuric Bichloride Group.

Saturated solution of HgCL in normal salt, HgCL and 2 per cent, osmic acid, equal parts Mann's Fluid, Rabl's Fluid, and HgCl + 95 per cent, alcohol. Mercuric bichloride gives better results when used alone than when used in any combination with other agents except osmic acid. In most cases the cilia are twisted, shrunken and broken. HgCl in combination with alcohol gave the poorest results. Fig. 4, PI. I, shows a group of cilia killed with Rabl's Fluid. They are tyi^ical for the cilia killed with any reagent of this group.

AlcoJiol Group.

This group contains besides alcohol absolute, 95 per cent., and 50 per cent, alcohol in combination with HgCL, osmic acid and acetic acid. Alcohol with the exception of acetic acid gave the most unsatisfactory preparations of all the reagents tested. Cilia were often entirely destroyed. The animal was shrunken and in case of Stylonychia broken up. It was often difficult to find pieces for record. PI. I, Fig. 5, shows one of the best groups of cilia found after treatment with absolute alcohol. Out of twenty animals only three or four showed any cilia.

Potassium Bicliromaic Group.

This agent enters into Mliller's, Zenker's and Tellyesniczky's fluids. Cilia treated with these reagents are shortened. In Stylonychia the fibrills are much crinkled and twisted, in Actinosphaerium the fibrills are granulated. Zenker's fluid, which is used more than any other of the group, gives the best results, but with it the ends of the cilia are rounded and fused. (PI. I, Fig. 1.)

188 0. P. Dellinffer


Chromic and Acetic Acid. These two agents enter into strong and weak Flenmiing and the common chromo-acetic acid solution. Chromic acid shrinks and fuses cilia. (PI. I, Fig. 10.) Acetic acid melts them down into a mass of granules. (PI. I, Figs. S, 9.) The combination of the two fuse the cilia so that they appear matted. (PI. I, Fig. 11.) The action of Flemming's solutions has been discussed above.

Picric Acid. Picric acid enters into Mann's and Rabl's fluid, which I have placed in the HgCl group, and is used with acetic acid. Cilia treated with it are fairly well preserved. The ends are fused, but in some cases the fibrils remain quite distinct nearer the base. (PI. I, Fig. 12.)


Formol in 4 per cent, and 10 per cent, solutions and in a 1 per cent, solution of osmic acid in 5 per cent, formol was used. It is difficult to interin-et the action of this agent. The body of the animal was poorly preserved. In the case of Stylonychia it was broken into fragments. The fibrils of the cilia attached to these fragments seemed well preserved, but the cilia themselves had their identity destroyed. The stronger solution gave the best results. (PI. I, Fig. 13.)

Platinum Cliloride.

A 1 per cent, solution of Platinum chloride was tested. It yielded no results to recommend it.


Cilia treated with different reagents show a marked difference in structure. Of the twen.ty-eight agents tested osmic acid (.4 per cent, to 2 per cent. ) is the only one that preserves the cilia in normal condidition. Wherever it enters into a killing fluid its influence can be seen. All other reagents produce marked changes in cilia Avhich are characteristic for each reagent.

In interpreting the structures revealed in tissues killed with these reagents their action on fibrillar structures should be taken into

The Ciliuin. 189

account. We should not expect the fibriUar structure to remain normal in tissue treated with most of them. Fibril! ae in the cell should show the same structure that cilia show after treatment with any one reagent. Thus, osmic acid would leave the fibrillae normal, strong and weak Flemming would break them up into short twisted threads, mercuric bichloride would in some cases leave them almost normal (HgCl sat. in nornuil salt), and in others fuse them so they entirely disappear. Alcohol would break them up in densely granulated masses, acetic acid would leave them more granular than alcohoJ, chromo-acetic and })icric acid would leave them fused masses, while formol would show them as threads.

Structure of Flaget.la as Demonstrated by Teasing. Introduction. There is almost universal agreement in the literature on the Flagellum that this organ is "Ein homogener diinner Faden, der keinerlei besondere Anhangsel tragt." This is the view of Kunstler, Loffler, Biitschli, Ivlebs, Hertwig and, more recently. Putter. Tn 1894 Fischer came forward with the view that a number of flagella, the Flimmergeissel (Euglena viridis and Monas guttula), "Besteht aus einem homogenen Faden, der mit einer oder mehreren Reihen kurzer, diinner, zugespitzter Hiirchen (Cilien) besetzt ist." On the other hand, another class of Flagella, the '^Peitschengeissel," consists of a homogeneous thread that often shows fibrillae clinging to it. So far as I know, Fischer's results have not been confirmed; and my own observations have yielded nothing approaching his figures or descriptions. Putter, because of the structure of the flagellum, rejected the fibrillar theory of the structure of cilia. 1 hope to show that in its structure is really the best justification for his theory.

MefJtod and Materials. For this investigation the flagella of Euglena, Chilomonas Paramecium and Spirillum (Sp. ?) were used. Mounts from infusions containing the first two of these forms were i)laced under a 1,5 mm. oil immersion and subjected to pressure.


O. P. Dellinger.

Euglcna. The flagellum of Eugleiia is composed of four fibrils which extend its entire length. Thev are twisted abont one another in a spiral of two and one-half turns. (Figs. 1, 2 and 3.) This structure (PL II, Figs. 1 and 2) is demonstrated with ease by subjecting a flagellum to slight pressure. The fibers gradually untwist or separate so that each is distinctly seen. They can be traced into the animal, where they branch out into a system of rootlets. (Fig. 3.) These fibers probably explain Fischer's thread-like appendages to his Peitschen

FiGS. 1 and 2. — The uncoiled fibrils of the flagella of Eugleua. Fig. 3. — Euglena witli the fibrils of the flagellum branching out into a system of rootlets in the protoplasm of the body.

Figs. 4 and 5. — Flagella of Chilomonas Paramecium.

geissel." What he really saw was some of the uncoiled fibers. Although I have used his methods, I have been unable to demonstrate any other structure. I am inclined to think that the fine cilia along the flagellum of Euglena veridis, which he describes, were artifacts. Possibly he may have worked with different species.

Chilomonas Paramecium. This form has two flagella, which are much smaller than the flagellum of Euglena. The structure was therefore more difficult to make out. Under the same treatment, however, they were demon

The Cilium. . 191

strated to consist of four fibrills which had a spiral arrangement. (Fig. 4 and 5.) They were not traced into the cell and their relation to the cell body was not determined.

Spirillum. With flagella of bacteria we descend the scale to still more minute forms which are not visible by ordinary histological methods. Still, no question can exist as to their active contractions. Thus, in any tissue cell there may be contractile elements or fibrillae which are invisible by ordinary methods. If simple, single-fibril, cilia or flagella exist, we should expect to find them among these most minute organs of bacteria. It is j)roposed to devote a special research to this point. At present I am able to ofi^er the evidence from a single type. A large Spirillum common in stagnant water when stained by Loeffler's method shows unmistakably that its long, apparently simple flagellum consists again of four spirally-wound fibrillae. "While not demonstrated alive by the teasing method used for Euglena and chilomonas, it is not difficult to find among the stained specimens a complete series from the apparently solid, simple flagellum through all stages of uncoiling to four distinct fibrillae. (PI. IV, Fig. 8 and Text Fig. 5a.)

Theoretical Considerations.

As mentioned above. Putter (1903), after a discussion of the fibrillar theory of the structure of cilia, rejected it because of the difiiculties met with in applying it to the movements of the flagellum. Parker (1905), in a discussion of the probable structure of cilia, does not agree with Putter and prophesies that even flagella may be fibrillar. From the above observations it is evident that this is true, at least, for three flagella. In these observations Putter's objections to the fibrillar theory become groundless, and the scant attention paid Schafer's tube theory of ciliary structure is also justified.

Although only three have been demonstrated to be fibrillar, these make it probable that all flagella have a similar structure. The work on cilia to follow proves that they are constructed on the same general plan, though diiferent cilia vary in the number of their component fibrillae.


O. P. Dellinger.

Structure of Cilia Demonstrated hy Teasing. It has long been known that the large cilia of the Hypotrichia (Fig. 6) are composed of many fine fibrils twisted together.^ In a


^?- ^^i



^^"^-t '"7

'r^:^i^m ' ^0'fm;S\!::^ii^ii -'^'"^'^


Fig. 5a. — Spirillum dnnvn from photograph of Plate IV, Fig. 8. Fig. 6. — Stylonychia showing types of cilia. (From Conn.). Fig. 7. — A of Fig. 6 much enlarged.

Fig. S. — Pseudopod of Actinosphaerium Eich. showing axil filament. (From Calkins' Protozoa, p. SO).

study of these fonns the author became convinced that all their cilia had a similar structure. Using the same methods which brought out the structure of flagella, the fibrillar nature of these cilia was easily demonstrated.

The Ciliiim. 193

The structure of the large cilia (Fig. 7) is that shown in Fig. o, PI. II*. ' It is seen that they are composed of a large number of tine tibrils. In life these fibrils are wound together so that the whole a])i)cars perfectly homogeneous. In animals subjected to pressure or killed in 2 per cent, osniic acid the se^Darate fibrils appear. In an animal that is breaking to pieces under pressure their fibrillar nature is best seen. (Fig. G.) All the cilia of the Hypotrichs are made up in a similar way. They are composed of several fibrils which separate under pressure. (PI. II, Fig. 4.) These cilia vary greatly in size and in the number of fibrils they contain. In many of them it is impossible to distinguish the fibrils that formed each individual after they have become separated. It is only on account of the size and arrangement of the cilia that it is possible to be sure the fibrils are not separate cilia.

The bearing of these observations on the theories of ciliary structure is evident. If in the Hypotrichia we have a series of cilia growing smaller and smaller, all composed of definite fibrils which can be separated, where are we to assume that this fibrillar structure ceases and cilia become homogeneous fibers or tubes of fluid ? At the place where we are unable to demonstrate a fibrillar structure ? This does not seem reasonable, for our means of demonstrating these structures are by far too gross. The simplest theory is that fibrillar structure extends on down the scale, although we are unable to demonstrate it. What we know of flagella makes this probable.

Applicatiox of Methods to Other Contractile Tissues.


The Amoeba has been used by many recent investigators, Blitschli, Berthold, Quincke, Verworn, Rhumbler and others, as the starting ])oint for their studies on contractile protoplasm. Unfortunately, in their investigations they did not apply modern histological technique to demonstrate structure in this form, hence the outcome of their work in microscopical foams, colloidal fluids, etc., as an explanation of amoeboid movement has resulted in widespread confusion in all our theories of protoplasmic structure.

Application of the methods and reagents which give the best j^repa

194 O. P. Bellinger.

rations of cilia show in the Amoeba a definite framework of tissue. This framework is a finely meshed structure, essentially the same for the "endosarc" and "ectosarc." It is so woven as to form trabeculae with large iuter-trabecular spaces in the interior, and, without essential differentiation, forms the outer (PI. II, Figs. 5 and 6) membrane, the wall of the contractile vacuole, the walls of all food vacuoles, and the nuclear membrane. This structure is constant in all these relations and cannot be considered an artifact.

In a recent paper, ^'Locomotion of Amoeba and Allied Forms," the author has shown that the movements of Amoebae in no way correspond to the movements of complex fluids. On the contrary, it is pointed out that Flertwig's contention, that "Das Protoplasma ist kein Gemengsel zweier nicht mischbarer Fllissigkeiten, wie Wasser und Oel, sondern besteht aus einer Verbindung fester, organischer Substanzteilchen mit reichlichem Wasser," holds at every point. In this paper it is suggested that a reticulum of contractile tissue would explain all the facts of amoeboid movement. Since an application of the methods best adapted to preserve cilia, which we know to be contractile tissue, demonstrates a reticulum in Amoebae, and since the presence of a contractile reticulum is the simplest explanation of all the facts of amoeboid movement, I think we are justified in assuming that the reticulum demonstrated is contractile.

In a paper, "Functions and Structures in Amoeba Proteus," Hodge and Bellinger, which is soon to appear from this laboratory, a full report of the work on Amoeba is given, hence this brief reference to the part that bears upon my subject :

Actinosphaerium. The literature on the structure of the Ileliozoa is extremely limited. Biitschli (1892) speaks briefly of the protoplasm of Actinosphaerium and Actinophyrs. According to him, their protoplasm shows a finelymeshed structure in the ectoplasm, endoplasm and the pseudopods. This structure is not altered in killing with Flemming's fluid, from which he concludes that it is normal. In speaking of the ectoplasm, he says : "After treatment with the osmic mixture already mentioned the meshed structure is everywhere easily recognizable in the ecto

The Cilium. 195

sarc. Whether or not the ultimate structure of the axil thread is similar was a point not successfully determined, though it occasionally aj)peared to be so." The axil thread is the apparently solid core of the pseudopod. According to Calkins (Protozoa, p. 81), this thread is composed of some unknown substance," which is "Probably stiffened protoplasm similar to the central axis of the reticulate pseudopodia." Tig. 8, taken from Calkin's Protozoa," shows this axil filament and the surrounding protoplasm according to his view. My own work shows that the filament is really a bundle of fibrils which are probably contractile.


In this investigation Actinosphaerium eichornii was used. Animals killed in 2 per cent, osmic acid and studied in dilute glycerine show a definite reticular network which forms the substance of the trabecule that surround the large inter-trabecular spaces. (PL II, Fig. 7.) The fibers of the trabeculae often unite to form larger fibers, which in a few cases were traced to the axil filament of the pseudopodia.

That we are dealing with a reticulum and not alveoli, as held by Biitschli, is evident from the following observations. The fibrillae of the j)seudopods could in a few cases be traced into the reticulum and evidently furnished some of its fibers. (PL II, Fig. 10). Fibrillae could be found that were branching into smaller fibrils, and in these cases alveoli were often found in the angles. (PL II, Fig. 9 ; PL III, Fig. 1.) Sometimes the angle was completely rounded out by the alveolus. (PL II, Fig. 9, and PL III, Fig. 4.)

In the course of this investigation an explanation was suggested to me by Dr. Hodge which accounts for. all the observations of alveolar protoplasm. It was this : If a viscid fluid bathing a reticulum would tend to form alveoli in the meshes of the reticulum and round out their angles, a perfect alveolar appearance would obtain. That such alveoli do tend to form on the angles is seen in Fig. 1, PL III.

Acting on this suggestion, experiments were made to determine to what extent this would hold in oil foams. Silk thread was teased into its idtimate fibers in an oil foam and mounted under a cover

196 0. P. Bellinger.

glass. PI. Ill, Fig. 2, shows the form the alveoli took. They are seen to be in the angles of the crossed threads, and their general arrangement is governed by the fibers. Another preparation was made in which no threads were placed. PL III, Fig. 3, shows the form of the alveoli in this case. PL III, Fig. 4, is the protoplasm of Actinosphaerium. It is evident that Figs. 2 and 4 are structurally alike, and one is convinced that there is fibrillar structure present in the protoplasm of Actinosphaerium, which controls the arrangement of the alveoli. The arrangement of alveoli in definite lines was often remarked upon by Biitschli. This definite arrangement finds an explanation in the above observations. Protoplasm, then, may be a mixture of fibrillae with foams, the arrangement of the alveoli being governed by the fibrillae.

. So far as I know, there is nothing in this hypothesis that is contradictory to what we know. On the other hand, it would explain the presence of alveoli where a reticulum is demanded. It remains for investigation to show how far this explanation holds good. The above observations tend to strongly support it. In a later section other evidence will be adduced.

Probably more interest attaches to the work on the pseudopods than to that on the body of the animal. As mentioned above, the pscudopod has an axil filament that has generally been supposed to be simply a supporting mechanism. This filament runs through the ectosarc and ends near a nucleus in the endosarc. It is usually figured as if it were perfectly homogeneous (Fig. 8), but according to this conception it is difficult to see how it is formed and how, under stimuli, it is dravm into the body.

While studying the pseudopods of Actinosphaerium to determine the effects of different reagents it was noticed that the axil filament was almost always more or less fibrillar. Following out this suggestion, I made a careful study of j)seudopodia killed in 2 per cent, osmic acid. By teasing such specimens, the fibrillar nature of the axil thread becomes quite distinct. (PL III, Figs. 5, 6, 7, 8.) Although it was difficult to trace the relations of these fibrillae inside the body, examples were found which seemed to indicate that they, in part at least, branch out into the meshwork of the trabeculae.

The Cilium. 197

(PI. II, Fig. 10.) These observations are in agreement with those of Biitschli on the psendopodia of Actiuophjrs. He says: "The protoplasm of the pseudopodia apj)eared in part composed of distinct longitudinal fibers. Moreover, this fibrillar modification of the protoplasm could be followed through the coarsely vesicular ectoplasm into the finely meshed endoplasm, and at the same time it could be demonstrated that the fibrous tracts pass in^) the meshwork of the endosarc."

Whether or not the fibrillae of the pseudopodia and of the body reticulum are contractile was not determined with certainty. However, one set of observations indicates that it is. Throughout the entire series of studies Ehrlich's blood stain in dilute glycerine (one drop of stain to one cc. of 10 per cent, glycerine) was used to stain the tissues. It was found that this stain picked out the contractile stalk of Vorticella, the ciliary bands of Vorticella and Stentor with their cilia, and the fibrillae of smooth and striped muscle. It is admitted that these are the contractile elements in these forms. This same stain picked out the fibrils of the pseudopodia of Actinosphaerium and the reticulum of the body, which indicates that we have here, also, contractile tissue.


The contractile elements of Stentor have been described by a number of writers (Metschnikoff, Johnson and Biitschli). They are easily recognized as the cilia and myonemes in the living animal, but require special methods to demonstrate their nature.

The cilia are of two kinds, those surrounding the peristome, and the body cilia. The former are complex; that is, composed of a large number of delicate fibrils. PI. IV, Figs. 1 and 2, show the cilia after treatment with osmic acid and strong Flemming. From PI. IV, Fig. 2, and Text Fig. it is seen that they are extended into the body as an apparently solid mass. The relations or meaning of this part of the cilia were not determined. It is much like the solid ends of the fibrous core of the pseudopods of Actinosphaerium. The finer structure of the body cilia could not be demonstrated, but in many cases of partly melted down cilia they showed every indication

198 O. P. Bellinger.

of being composed of fibrils. However, I am not ready to say that this is the ease. It remains to be seen what a more powerful magnification will show.

The myonemes in specimens partially teased and killed in 2 per cent, osmic acid show a definite fibrillar structure after staining with the Ehrlich-glycerine mixture. (PL IV, Figs. 3 and 4.) PI. IV, Fig. 3, which is a smal] section of a myoneme teased away from the body, indicates that they send branches into the body. Other observations led me to think that is the case. The body cilia are all outgrowths from myonemes. Stentor thus supports the theory that contractile tissue is fibrillar.


This form was killed and stained by the same methods as given above. The stain quickly picks out the contractile elements. These are the cilia, the ciliary bands around the peristome and the myonemes which extend from the outer peristomal band to the point of attachment at the stalk. (Fig. 10.) The definiteness with which the stain picks out these structures leaves no doubt as to their identity. The presence of the contractile elements in these positions explain all the movements of the animal.

ISTo data was obtained as to the finer structure of the cilia or the peristomal bands. In a teased specimen the finer structure of the myonemes was demonstrated. They are distinctly fibrillar, as shown in Fig. 11, probably send fibrillae into the body. Their relation to the outer peristomal band is also shown in the above figure. In epistylis the myonemes end at the junction of the l)ody with the non-contractile stalk.

Smooth Muscle. The major part of the work on smooth muscle was done by Duncan in this laboratory at the same time I was working with the contractile tissue in other forms. Reference will be made to his paper later. He did not investigate the stalk of vorticella, which is generally recognized as the starting point for investigations on smooth muscle. Although there are two well-established views as to the seat of contractility in the stalks of vorticella, I think there is no doubt that

The Cilium.


the miiscle-like spasmoneme is the contractile element. It is picked out immediately by the above Ehrlich-glycerine mixture and, with the myonemes and the cilia, is stained bright red when there is no stain in the rest of the animal.

Fig. O.^Oral cilia of Stentor killed in stroujt Fig. 10. — Contractile elements of Epistylis. Fig. 11. — Teased Myonome of Epistylis.


No structure could be demonstrated in the spasmoneme itself. PI. IV, Fig. G, is a microphotograph taken with an Ultraviolet Microscope. In this photograph the spasmoneme appears perfectly homogeneous; on the other hand, its relation to the myonemes indicates


O. P. Dellinger.

tliut it is fibrillar. It is in reality the eontiimatioii of these myoneraes into the stalk, and we shonld ex])e('t thein to retain their structnre, as they retain their fnnction in this position. (Fig. 12.) Although no structure has been demonstrated, I do not think we are justified in assuming that it is homogeneous. It is probable that when a method is found to demonstrate it the structure will be found to be fibrillar.

As mentioned above, the major part of the work on smooth muscle was done by Dr. Duncan in this laboratory, and his results are ready



Fig. 12. — Myonoiues of Carcesiniu.

Fig. 13. — Smooth inuscle fiber taken from earthworm.

(After Duncan.)

for publication. He used the same stain and, in many cases, the same killing reagents that I have used. His results are in agreement with Avhat I have found in my studies. He finds that the smooth muscle in all the places he examined it (Hydra, sea anemone, star fish clam, Tubifex, Lumbricus, and cat) is distinctly fibrillar. Fig. 13, copied from his drawing of the muscle of an earthworm, shows the fibrillar structure in a portion of one of its fibers. The following quotation gives his general conclusions: "All of the structures that we have observed in contractile tissue force upon one the conviction

The Cilium. 201

that it is coniijoscd of fibrillae and interfibrillar substance. However they may have arisen, they are a fact in the structure and not an ■^Accident of structure,' as Biitschli maintains. In every case in which I have studied contractile tissue it has been comj^osed of fibrillae or a single fibril running out from a cell."

Discussion of Results.

Present authorities are perhaps about equally divided on the question of the fibrillar, alveolar or colloidal-fluid nature of contractile protoplasm. In the cilium we have this most interesting substance in not only its purest, but also its simplest form. It is thus the natural point from which to begin the study of its structure ; and by taking advantage of the natural path afforded by a comparative series of typical cilia, it seems possible to gain clearer conceptions than those attained through any other line of approach. The general conclusion is that contractile protoplasm is fibrillar in all the forms studied.

The fibrillar structure is preserved in its normal appearance by but few of the ordinary killing reagents. The great majority so alter the fibrillae that they are no longer recognizable. This fact goes far toward explaining the confusion in current ideas of protoplasmic structure. Before we deny fibrillar structure in any tissue we clearly must determine whether the reagent used preserves fibrillae. The beginning which has been made in my investigation of the effects of killing reagents on cilia leads us to conclude that osmic acid alone can be depended upon to preserve fibrillae in their normal appearance. Anyone who will watch cilia dissolve or change into granujes during a second's contact with an unfavorable reagent will require no further argument on this point. ISTaturally, some fibrillae are more resistant than others. Thus, the fibrillae in the pseudopods of Actinosphaerium were left intact by reagents which completely destroy their identity in the cilia of Stylonychia.

A point of special importance is the result gained by teasing flagella fresh under high powers of the microscope. Structures revealed by this method arc in no wise open to the criticism that they are artifacts produced by killing reagents. The ease with which the flagella studied are resolved into their component fibrils and the clear

202 O. P. Dellinger.

iiess with which the method demonstrates the fibrillae of the axil filament in the pseudopod of Actinosphaerium leads one to think that this line of approach, or some modification of it, might yield valuable evidence as to the structure of the neurite and axis cylinder of nerve fibers. My observations on flagella and cilia as they pass under different reagents from fibrillar to meshed or granular debris leads us to conclusions as to the action of killing reagents on protoplasm different from those arrived at by Fisher and Hardy. Instead of considering all fibrillar structures as artifacts, it would seem that few investigators have divined the true fibrillar nature of protoplasm, because they have used reagents that destroy or modify the fibrils.

Alveoli exist in protoplasm, but reagents which preserve cilia never yield completely alveolar structures that could possibly be interpreted as Biitschli's "Schaume." The comparison of the alveolar protoplasm of Actinosphaerium, or of any of Biitschli's Schaume, as he figures them, with simple emulsions and with emulsions permeated with delicate fibers, leaves little doubt that the alveoli of protoplasm have their arrangement determined by fibrillae. This compromise interpretation uniting the fibrillar and alveolar theories of the structure of protoplasm has been offered by other writers, and is rather a matter for further investigation than for discussion in this paper.

The resolution of the flagellum of Euglena, Chilomonas and spirillum into four distinct fibrils and the demonstration of the fibrillar structure of the cilia of Stylonj^chia leaves the way clear for acceptance of not only the fibrillar theory of the structure of cilia, but also i^or the conception of fibrillae as a component of any protoplasm. With its acceptance, all theories which regard cilia as tubes or complex fluids appear gratuitous complications, and hence untenable.

In cilia or flagella capable of movement in all directions there should be at least four contractile fibrils. I have succeeded in demonstrating these in a typical series of forms. The presence of these four fibrils not fused or cemented together, but coiled in a long spiral , accounts for all their complex movements. Parker ('05) has pointed out that in cilia incapable of reversing only one contractile filamert is necessary, if this is attached to an elastic supporting rod. With

The Cilium. 203

reversible cilia both fibrils must possess the power of contracting, each alternately or under different stimuli, acting as elastic support for the other.

As I have watched and studied cilia and other contractile fibrillae for the past four years, comparing at every step the living with the fixed structure, I have observed many things that cannot be detailed in this paper, but I have seen nothing which contradicts the fibrillar theory of contractile protoplasm. 'No one who has watched the basal cilia of Vorticella protrude and be absorbed, often within a few seconds, can deny great plasticity to the contractile fibril ; but, while it contracts and lashes the water or pulls hard enough to pinch a paramoecium in two, formed it must be, and to think of it as a strand of fluid baffles imagination. No one who has watched an amoeba divide can deny to the fibrils the power of auto-section or amputation, probably the power to liquefy at certain points ; nor can one who has watched a Vorticella attach itself and grow its stalk question that the contractile fibrils have the power to cement themselves to foreign substances, and this, it would seem, must carry the conclusion that they fuse with one another. On the other hand, those who hold that contractile protoplasm is a complex fluid and that all fibrillar structure demonstrated in it is the result of fixing reagents, must explain why a reagent which preserves fibrillae outside the cell might not preserve them within the cell, and also why a reagent that destroys the fibrillae outside might not be expected to change those inside the cell. They must also bring forward a satisfactory explanation for the fibrillae which can be so clearly demonstrated in cilia and flagella of the living cell.


1. Osmic acid is a satisfactory fixing reagent for the contractile structures investigated.

2. To interpret structures inside a cell after fixing with any reagent we must take into account alterations produced by it in fibrillar structures outside the cell.

3. Absence of fibrillar structure may mean that the fixing reagent used has destroyed the fibrillae.

4. The cilia of Stylonychia are comj)osed of spirally coiled fibrils;

204 O. P. Dellinger.

and the flagclla of Eiiglciia, Cliilomonas and Spirillum are composed of four spiral filaments.

5. The axil filament in the pseudopod of Actinosphaerium is fibrillar.

6. The protoj^lasm of Actinosphaerium is reticular as well as alveolar. The definite arrangement of alveoli in any protoplasm is probably due to the presence of fibrils.

7. The contractile elements of tissues investigated are in every case fibrillar or reticular.

Clark Uni\'ersity, May 31, 1907.


Allen, 1903. The early stages of spindle formation in the pollen motlier

cell of Larix. Ann. of Bot.', Vol. 17, p. 281. Andrews, G. F., 1S97. Living substance as such : and as organism. Jour.

of Morph., Vol. 12, pp. 1-176. Apathy, S., 1891. Ueber die Schaumstructur, hauptsachlich bei Muskel- und

Nerveufasern. Biolog. Centralblatt, Bd. XI, pp. 78-88.

1891. Kontractile und leitende Priniitivfibrillen. Mitt. Zool. Stat.

Neapel. Bd. 10.

Arnold, J., 1867. Ein Beitrag zu der feineven Structur der Ganglienzelle.

Archiv f. patholog. Anat. Bd. 41, p. 178. ■ • 1879. Ueber feinere Structur der Zellen unter normalen und

pathologischen Bedingungen. Virchow's Archiv. Bd. 77. 1898. Structur und Architektur der Zellen. Archiv f. M. Anat. Bd.

52, pp. 134-151. Ballowitz, E., 1886. Zur Lehre von der Struktur der Spermatozoen. Anat.

Anzeiger, p. 363. Untersuchungen iiber die Struktur der Spermatozoen, zugleich ein

Beitrag zur Lehre vom feineren Bau der contractilen Elemenfe.

Archiv f. M. Anat. Bd. 32, p. 401. 1889. Ueber Verbreitung und Bedeutung feinfaseriger Strukturen

in den Geweben und Gewebselementen des tierischeu Koi'pers. Bio logisches Centralblatt. Bd. IX, pp. 650-670.

1890. Fibrillare Struktur und Contraktilitiit. Pfliiger's Archiv.

Bd. 46, pp. 433-464.

DE Bary, II., 1862. Ueber den Bau und das Wosen der Zelle. Flora, pp. 243-251.

1864. Die Mycetozoen. 2 Aufl. Leipzig.

Benda, C, 1901. Ueber neue Darstellungsmethoden der Centralkorperchen und die Verwandschaft der Basalkiirper der Cilien mit Centralkorperchen. Arch. f. Anat. u. Physiologie. Supplement. Pts. 1-2, pp. 147-157.

The Cilium. 205

Bernstein, J., 1002. Die Kriifte cler Bewegmig iu cler lebenden Substauz.

Braunscli\Yeig. Berthold, G., 1SS6. Studieu iiber rrotoplasmamechauik. Leipzig. Brucke, E., 1861. Die Elementarorganismem. Sitzb. d. K. Akad. Wien.

Bd. 44. II Abtli. pp. 381-407.

1885. Vorlesungeu iiber Pbysiologie. Wien.

Brass, A., 1883-4. Biologiscbe Stiidieu. I. Die Organisation der tbieri schen Zelle. 1. n. 2. Heft. Hallo. BiJTSCHLi, O., 1873. Einiges iiber Infusorien. Arcbiv f. Mic. Anat. Bd. 9,

p. 658. 1892. Untersndningen iiber mikroscopische Scbannie und das Pro toplasma. Leipzig. Calkins, G. N., 1901. The Protozoa. Columbia Univ. Biol. Series, p. 80,

New York.

CoRNOY, J. B., 1884. La Blologie Cellulaire, pp. 169-270, Lierre.

CoNKLiN E. G., 1896. Protoplasmic moA^ement as a factor iu differentiation.

Biol. Lect. Mar. Biol. Lab. Woods Hole. Also Science, 1899. CiENKowSKY, L., 1863. Zur Entwicklungsgeschichte der Myxomyceten. Jabrb.

f. wiss. Botanik. Bd. 3, pp. 325-337.

Das Plasmodium. Ibid., pp. 400-441 Crato, 1892. Beitrag 'zur Kenntuis der Plasmastruktur. Ber. d. Deutsch.

Bot. Ges. 1895-6. Bau des Pi'otoplasmas, etc. Cohn's Beitrag zur Biologie der

Pflanzen. Davis, B. M., 1904. Studies on the Plant Cell. American Nat., Vol. 38. Degen, a., 1905. Untersuchungen iiber die kontractile Vakuole und die

Wabenstruktur des Protoplasmas. Bot. Ztg. I. Abth. Heft. I. u. II.,

pp. 160-226. Delage, T., 1895. La structure du protoplasme et les theories sur I'he redite et les grandes problemes de la biologie generale, pp. 23-33.

Paris. Dellinger, O. p., 1906. Locomotion in Amoebae and allied Forms. The

Journal of Experimental Zool., Vol. 3, pp. 337-358. Dreich, H., 1905. Der Vitalismus als Geschichte und als Lehre. Leipzig. DuJARDiN, F., 1835. Sur les Organismes infusorieurs. Analos Scien. Nat.,

pp. 343-376.

1841. Observations sur les Rhizopodes et les infusoires. Paris.

Duncan, F. N. Unpublished. Comparative study of contractile tissues.

Work done in Biol. Lab. of Clark University. Eberth, C. J., 1866. Zur Kenntuis des feiueren Baues der Flimmerepithelien.

Archiv f. patliiolog. Anat. Bd. 35, pp. 447-8. Eimer, Th., 1872. Untersuchungen iiber die Eier der Reptilien. Archiv f.

M. Anat. Bd. 8, pp. 226-243.

206 0. P. Dellinger.

EiMEB, Th., 1877. Weitere Nachrichten liber den Bau cles Zellkerns uiid liber Wiiuperepitlielien. Ibid. Bd. 14, pp. 94.

Engelmann, Th. W., 1868. Ueber die Flimmerbewegung. Jena. Zeitscbr. f. Naturwiss. Bd. 4, pp. 321-479.

1879. Physiologie der Protoplasma- und Flimmerbewegung. Herman's Handbucb der Pbysiologie. Bd. I, pp. 344-408.

1880. Znr Anatomie und Pbysiologie der Flimmerzellen. Pfliiger's

Arcbiv. Bd. 23, pp. 505-535.

1881. I'eber den faserigen Ban der Ivontractilen Substanzen bei

besonderer Berticksigbtigung der glatten und doppelt gestreiften Mnskelfasern. Pfliiger's Arcbiv. Bd. 25, pp. 538-565.

Fischer, A., 1894. Ueber die Geisseln einiger Flagellaten.

Neuer Beitrag zur Kritili der Fixiruugsmetboden. Anat. Anzeiger.

Bd. 9, p. 678 ; Bd. 10, p. 769.

— 1899. Fixirung, Farbung, und Ban des Protoplasmas. Jena.

1901. Feber Protoplasmastruktur. Areb. f. Entwiclvelungsmecbanik.

Bd. 13.

Flemming, W., 1882. Zellsubstanz, Kern und Zelltbeilung. 8 PL, 424 pp.

Leipzig. Die Zelle. Ergebnisse d. Anat. u. Entwickelungsgescbicbte. Bd. 1.

pp. 42-82, 1892; Bd. 2, pp. 37-82, 1893; Bd. 4, pp. 355-448, 1895.

Bd. 5, pp. 233-328, 1896; Bd. 6, p. 184-277. GuRWiTSCH, A., 1901. Studien iiber Flimmerzellen. Arcliiv f. M. Anat.,

Vol. 57, p. 184.

1904. Morpbologie und Biologie der Zelle, pp. 317. Jena.

Haeckel, E., 1862. Die Radiolarien. Berlin.

Heidenhain, M., 1899-1901. Struktnr der kontractilen Materie. Merkel

and Bonnet's Ergebnisse. Bd. 8, pp. 3-111 and Bd. 10, pp. 115 214. Hardy, W. B., Structure of Cell Protoplasm. Jour, of Pbysiology. Vol. 24,

pp. 159-208. Hartmann, E., 1906. Das Problem des Lebens. Heitzmann, J., 1873. Untersucbungen iiber das Protoplasma. I. Bau des

Protoplasmas. Sitzber. der K. Akad. d. Wiss. Wien. Bd. 67,

Abtb. 3.

Hermann, L., 1879. Allgemeine Muskelpbysik. Herman's Handbucb der Pbysiologie.

Hertwig, O., 1892. Die Zelle und die Gewebe. Jena.

HooKE, Robert, 1865. Micrograpbia, or some physiological descriptions of minute bodies by magnif. glasses, etc.

Jennings, M. S., 1904. Contributions to tbe study of tbe bebavior of lower organisms. Carnegie Inst. Wasbington, pp 129-230.

Jensen, Paul. 1901. Untersucbungen iiber Protoplasiiiamecbanik. Pfliiger's Arcbiv. Bd. 87, pp. 361-417.

The Cilium. 207

Jensen, Paul, 1902. Die Protoplasiuabewegung. Asher and Spiro. Ergebnisse

der Physiologie. Bd. 1, No. 2. Jensen, O., 1S87. Uiitersucliiingen ilbev die Saiuenkru-per der Saugethiere.

Arch. f. M. A. Bd. 30. Kassowitz, Max, 1899. Allgemeine Biologie. Wien. Bd. 1, p. 134. Klein, E., 1878. Observations on the Structure of Cells and Nuclei. Part I,

Quart. Jour. Micr. Sc. (N. S.), Vol. 18, pp. 315-339, PI. IG. Part II,

ibid., Vol. 19, pp. 125-175, PL 7.

On the Granular Epithelium and Division of Nuclei iu the 8kin

of the Newt. Ibid., p. 477, PI. 18.

Kleinenbeeg, N., 1886. Die Entstehung des Annelids aus der Larve von Lepa dorhynchus. Zeitscbr. f. wissen. Zool. Bd. 44, pp. 1-228. KuHNE, W., 1864. Unters. iiber das Protoplasina u. die Coutractilitiit.

Leipzig. KuNSTLER. J., AND GuESTE, Cii.. 1906. Structiu'e Fibrillaire chez les Bae teriae. G. R. Acad. Sc. T. 143, pp. 84-87. LoEB, J., 1906. Yorlesuugen iiber die Dynamik der Lebenserscheiuungeu.

Leipzig. Meves, Fr., Struktur und Histogenese der Spermien. Ergebnisse d. Anat. u.

Eutvvickelungsgeschichte. Bd. 11, pp. 437-516.

1897. Ueber Strukfur und Histogenese des Sanienfadens von Salamander. A. f. M. A. Bd. 50.

Meyen. Neues System der Pflanzenphysiologie, Vol. I, 1837; Vol. II, 1838;

Vol. Ill, 1839. MoiiL, Hugo von, 1846. L'eber die Saftbewegung im Inneru der Zellen.

Bot. Zeitung. p. 73. Naegeli, K., 1849. Zeitschrift fiir wissenscbaftlicbe Botanik. Heft. I-IV,

Ziirich, 1S44-1S46.

Gattungen einzelliger Algeii. Ziirich.

— ■ • Theorie des Micelles, im Sitzimgsb. d. k. bayer. Akad. d. Wiss. zu

Miinchen, 1862 and 1864. NussBAUM, 1877. Ein Beitrag zuv Lehre von der Flinuuerbeweguug. Arch.

f. M. Anat. Bd. 14. Prowazek, S., Protozcenstudien II. Arb. aus d. Zool. Inst. d. Uni. Wien.

Bd. 12, p. Parker. G. H., The Reversal of Ciliary Movements in Metazoaus. Amer.

Jour, of Physiology, Vol. XIII, No. 1, pp. 1-16. Penard, Eug., 1902. Faune Rhizopodique du hassin du Leman. Geneva. Rabl, C, 1889. Ueber Zelltheilung. Anat. Anzeiger. Bd. 4, pp. 21-30. Reichert, R. B., 1841. Berichte iiber d. Fortsch. d. Mik. Anat. in d. Jahr.

1839 u. 1848. Miiller's Archiv, p. 162. Reinke, J., 1905. Die Welt als Tat. Berlin.

208 O. P. Bellinger.

Khumbler, L., 189G. Versuch zu eiuer mecliaiiischen Erklarung der indi recten Kern- und Zelltlieilung. Ai-cb. f. Entwickelungsmechanik. Bd.

3, H. 4. 1895. Beitriige zur Keuutnis des Rbizopoden (Beitr. Ill, IV, V).

Zeitscbr. f. Wiss. Zool. Bd. 61. 1898. Pbysikalisclie Aiialj^se von Lebeusei'scheinungen dev Zelle.

Ai'cbiv f. Entwickelungsmecbanik der Zelle. Bd. 7, pp. 103-3.50.

Allgemeine Zellmechanlk in Merkel and Bonnet. Ergebnisse der

Anat. u. Entwic'kelungsgescbicbte, Vol. 8, pp. 543-625.

1902. Der Aggregatzustand und die pbysikaliscben Besouderbeiten

des lebenden Zelliubalts. Zeitsc. f. allg. Pbysioliogie. Bd. I, pp. 279-388.

1904. Zellenmecbanik und Zellenleben, p. 43. Leipzig.

1905. Zur Theorie der Oberfliicbenkrafte der Amoebas. Z. f. wiss.

Zool. Bd. 83, pp. 1-52. Bost. Soc. of Nat. Hist.

ScHAEFER, E., 1891. On tbe Structure of Amoeboid Protoplasm. Proc. R.

Soc, Vol. 49, pp. 193-198. 1904. Tbeories of Ciliary Movement. Anat. Anz. Bd. 24, pp.

497-511. ScHENK, Fr., 1897. Kritiscbe und experimentelle Beitrage zur Lebre von

der Protoplasmabewegung und Kontraktion. Pfliiger's Arcb. Bd. 66,

pp. 247-284. 1900. Ileber den Aggregatzustand der lebendigen Substanz, be sonders des Muskels. Pfliiger's Arcb. Bd. 81. ScHUEiDEN, M. J., 1838. Beitrage zur Pbytogenesis. Miiller's Arcbiv, pp.

137-176. Schneider, K. C, 1905. Protoplasmastruktur und Bevvegung an Protozoeu

und Pflanzenzellen.

— ■ 1903. Vitalismus. I^ipzig and Wien.

ScHULTz, M., 1854. Ueber den Organismus der Polytbalamien, etc., Leipzig. ■ 1861. Ueber Muskelkorpercben und das was man eine Zelle zu

nenneu babe. Arcb. de Reicb. und du Bois-Reym.

1863. Protoplasma der Rbizopoden. Leipzig.

ScHUBERG, A., 1891. Zur Kenntniss des Stentor coeruleus. Zool. Jabrb.

Bd. 4, pp. 197-238. Schwann, Th., 1839. Mikroskopiscbe Untersucb. iiber die Uebereinst. in der

Struktur luid das Wacbstum der Tiere und der Pflauzen. Berlin. Smith, G., 1906. Tbe Eyes of Certain Pulmonate Gasteropods witb Special

Reference to tbe Neurofibrillae of Limax maximus. From tbe Bull.

o. M. C. Zool., Vol. 58, p. 233. Stevens, 1901. Studies on ciliate infusoria. Proc. of tbe Cal. Acad, of Sc,

3d series, Zool., Vol. 3. Strassburger, E., 1907. Die Ontogeuie der Zelle seit 1875. In Progressus

Rei Botanicae, Jena, pp. 1-138.

The Cilium. 209

Strasburger, E., 1892. Scbwannsporen, Gameten, pflanzenlicben Spermato zoiden, Hist. Beitr. 4, 49. Stkicker, 1890. Reticular Slructure in White Blood Corpuscles. Wiener Med.

Jalirb., 1S90. Stuart, A., 1807. I'eber die Flimmerbewegung. Zeitscbr. f. Rationelle Med.

Bd. 29. N'ALENTiNE, M., 1892. Fliuimerbeweguug. In Wagner's Handworterbucb der

Pbysiologie. Bd. I, pp. 484-576. Verworn, M., 1892. Lebeudige Substanz. Jena.

1892. Die Bevveguug der Lebendigen Substanz. Jena.

1890. Studien zur Pbysiologie der Flimmerbewegung. Pfluger's

Arcbiv. Bd. 48, pp. 149-1 SO.

1903. Die Biogenbypotbese. Jena, pp. 1-114.

ViGNON, P., 1901. Recbercbes de Cytologie generale sur les Epitbeliums.

Arcb. De Zool. Exp. et Gen, Series III. T. IX, pp. 371-715. Williams, L. W., 1907. Tlie Structure of Cilia, Especially in Gastropods.

Tbe American Naturalist, Vol. 41, pp. 545-551. Wilson, E. B., 1904. Tbe cell in development and inberitance. New York. • 1898. Tbe Structure of Protoplasm. Biol, lectures from Marine

Biological Laboratory at Wood's Hole, pp. 1-20.

DESCRIPTION OF PLATES. Plates I, II, III, and IV are photographs taken with Spencer Lens 1.5 mm. objective and No. 3 eyepiece.

PLATE I. Fig. 1 to 13 Cilia of Stylonychia. Fig. 1 and 2.— Cilia killed with 2 per cent, cosmic acid. Fig. 3. — Cilia killed with Strong Flemming. Fig. 4. — Cilia killed with Eabl's fluid. Fig. 5. — Cilia killed with Absolute alcohol. Fig. 6. — Cilia killed with Tellyesniczky's fluid. Fig. 7. — Cilia killed with Zenlier's fluid. Figs. S and 9. — Cilia killed with Acetic acid. Fig. 10. — Cilia killed with Chromic acid. Fig. 11. — Cilia killed with Chromo-acetic acid. Fig. 12. — Cilia killed with Picric acid. Fig. 13.— Cilia killed with Formol.




Fig. 1. — Flagellum of Euglena.

Figs, la and 2. — Flagella of Euglena which have been teased.

Fig. 3. — Large cilia of Stylonychia.

Fig. 4. — Ordinary cilia of Stylonychia.

Fig. 5. — Section of Amoeba showing the reticulum of the trabeculae. Killed in 2 per cent, osmic acid. Stained in gentian violet.

Fig. 6. — Portion of amoeba killed in 2 per cent, osmic acid and stained in gentian violet.

Fig. 7. — Small part of a section of Actinosphaerium showing the reticulum of the trabeculae.

Fig. 8. — Trabeculae of the reticulum of the "ectosarc" of Actinosphaerium.

Fig. 9. — Alveoli in the angles of branched fibrillae. From Actinosphaerium.

Fig. 10. — Fibrillae of the pseudopods of Actinosphaerium branching into the reticulum of the body.



'HE Journal of Mokphologt. — Vol. XX, No. 2.


Fig. 1. — Fibril teased from the protoplasm of Actiuosphaerium showing the alveoli at the angles.

Fig. 2. — An emulsion permeated with fibrils showing how the form and arrangement of the alveoli is conditioned by the presence of the fibers.

Fig. 3. — A part of the above emulsion without fibers.

Fig. 4. — Protoplasm of Actiuosphaerium.

Figs. 5, 6, 7. and S. — Fibrillae of the pseudopods of Actiuosphaerium.












The Journal of Morphology. — Vol. XX, No. 2.


Fig. 1. — Oral cilia of Steutor.

Fig. 2. — Section of stentor at the point of attachment of the oral cilia showing their attachment to the body.

Fig. 3 and 4. — Teased myonemes of steutor showing their fibrillar nature.

Fig. 5.— Myonomes of Stentor.

Fig. 6. — Contractile stalk of Vorticella. Photographed by Dr. C. F. Hodge with Ultraviolet microscope.

Fig. 7. — Ultraviolet microphotograph of striped muscle. Photographed by Dr. C. F. Hodge.




Journal of MonrnoLOGT. — Vol. XX, No. 2.






Trinity College, Hartford, Connecticut.



I. Introduction 211

II. Notes on the General Embryology 213

III. Tentacles 216

A. Discussion of Literature 221

IV. Pedicels and Papillae 222

A. Discussion of Literature 227

V. Literature Cited 228

VI. Explanation of the Plates 230

I. Inteoduction. During the summer of 1888, at Green Turtle Cay, Bahamas, 1 studied the ontogeny of Holothuria floridana Pourtales. For the identification of the species I relied at that time upon the labelled specimen in the Museum of the Biological Department of the Johns Hopkins University, and thus in my preliminary notice (1889) the form appeared under the name of Miilleria agassizii Selenka. In recent papers (1905, 1908) I have shown that this sea-cucumber, common from Florida through the Bahaman, West Indian, and Caribbean regions to the northern coast of South America, is Holothuria floridana Pourtales, with which Holothuria mexicana Ludwig, and Holothuria africana Theel, are identical. In addition I have established the fact that Holothuria atra Jager, generally distributed throughout the Indo-Pacific regions, is a distinct species, and I defined for each of these species the differential characters, some of which had not been previously described.

The JouenaIj of MORrHOLOOT. — Vol. XX, No. 2.

212 Charles Lincoln Edwards

Holothuria floridana is found in large numbers in the shallow bays and sounds on either the white coralline sand, or more generally where the bottom is covered with green and brown vegetation. These holothurians, sometimes uniformly seal-brown in color, but more frequently particolored in varying mixtures of browns, creams, and grays, are well protected both by their coloration, and by the habit of covering themselves more or less completely with pieces of plants, shells and sand held fast by the suckers of the pedicels.

This species breeds during July and August, albeit some individuals may be found with mature gonads both before and after this season. A number of attempts to artificially fertilize the eggs failed. The live-box method employed by Selenka, 1876, was very successful. About one hundred of the holothurids were collected within an hour or two, and placed in a large box, the cracks of which had been covered Avith cheese-cloth. The box was anchored to the bottom in a shallow bay where at low tide the sea-water barely covered it. In from four to ten hours eggs and sperms were extruded. The oosperms, heavier than water, sank to the bottom and were gathered through a rubber tube into shallow glass dishes. Pour lots of oosperms were obtained in the summer of 1888, but in two succeeding Bahaman expeditions I have not been able to secure the embryos.

Holothuria floridana does not develop a free Auricularia larva, but the embryonic stages are passed within the vitelline membrane during the first five days after fertilization of the egg. On the sixth day the embryo hatches as a larva with five primary tentacles, four developed and one as a bud, and also with one posterior pedicel.

In ray study of the order of development of the tentacles, pedicels and papillae, embryos of each stage were reconstructed by plotting the serial sections on paper. In this manner appendages were found that could not be seen from a surface view of the whole embryo, and the exact origin of each appendage from one side, or the other, of a given radial canal, was determined. The interpretation of the origin of an appendage based upon a surface view is sometimes misleading, for the ambulacral canal may grow around in the body-wall, pass over the radial canal and thus the appendage will emerge from the skin upon the opposite side from which it leaves the radial canal.

Development of Holothiiria Floridana Pourtales 213

In my preliminary communication (1907), I had not completed this study by reconstruction from serial sections and thus a few discrepancies were then published. I have called all appendages developed, which clearly project from the skin and seem to be functional, even if much contracted and very short. Those still buried in the body-wall, often merely initial evaginations from the radial canal, and then determinable only in sections, I have called huds.

II. K^OTES o:^ THE General, Embryology.

The formation of the polar bodies and fertilization are followed by a total and approximately equal cleavage. The stage with four blastomeres is reached at three hours, with sixteen blastomeres at four hours and the blastula by the fourteenth hour. Then the formation of mesenchyme begins by cell-proliferation at the vegetative pole, while at the same time gastrulation takes place. By the twentysecond hour a plug of cells has gro^\ai out toward the blastopore, from the blind end of the archenteron, dividing this sac into two diverging diverticula of which the ventral constitutes the enteron, and the dorsal, the vaso-peritoneal vesicle. In the second day the vaso-peritoneal vesicle grows larger and begins to show the division into hydrocele and enteroceie (PI. I, Fig. 2). During this day a crescentic depression on the ventral surface marks out the initiation of the peristome (PI. I, Fig. 1). This depression gradually deepens and straightens, growing out to either side until it extends entirely across the ventral surface of the embryo (PL I, Fig. 3). The plane of the peristomial groove is at an angle of fifty degrees with the sagittal plane of the adult holothurid.

At this time spots of green pigment appear in groups, but later are evenly distributed over the whole surface. Thus the broAvn embryo gradually becomes greenish in color. During the second and third days the ectoderm is ciliated and the embryo revolves within the vitelline membrane.

At the time of hatching the mouth has become established medianly in the peristome, while the enteric canal has the characteristic dorsal, left, and right loops (PI. II-III, Figs. 7-14). As the young holothurid creeps about, it begins to eat the protoplasmic fragments in

214 Charles Lincoln Edwards

the slime and the living organisms which have been allowed to remain on the bottom of the dish and form a culture for food when the stale water has been decanted at each period. As the young animal feeds, the mid-enteron enlarges into the prominent larval stomach, occupying the middle third of the coelom. By the ninth day the divisions of the enteric canal are clearly sho"wn. The first or dorsal loop is suspended by its mesentery from the mid-dorsal interradius. It includes the cesophagus and stomach, and terminates ventrad of the anus. From the posterior end of the stomach the intestine turns down in the left ventral interradius, and runs forward as the second or left loop. This portion gradually goes over to the right ventral interradius, until just in front of the stomach, where it turns again posteriorly, and as the third, or right loop, goes in the right ventral interradius to the posterior end of the stomach. Here the intestine makes a sharp bend dorsad along the right side of the stomach, and terminates in the anus, which is now near the posterior end of the mid-dorsal region of the body. The large larval stomach thus crowds the second loop ventrad alongside of the third loop, and, at the same time, the large Polian vesicle lying in the left half of the coelom, pushes the first loop of the enteron to the right. This position is maintained together with the relatively large size of the stomach, in a general way, during the developmental stages of my series, but following about the fortieth day the second loop comes gradually dorsad toward its adult position.

The stone-canal has a peripheral expansion, the madreporic vesicle, similar to that described in Cucumaria planci by Ludwig, 1891. In Holothuria floridana the stone-canal is found in the embryo of four days. Later it lies in the dorsal mesentery and the madreporic vesicle is at the surface in the mid-dorsal line of the median plane. The outer wall of the vesicle at first is continuous with the surface of the body-wall, but later the vesicle lies deeper in toward the coelom. In Cucumaria planci, Ludwig says that the dorsal pore is obliterated in eighteen to twenty days, and that the madreporic vesicle opens into the coelom on the ninety-eighth day. In Holothuria floridana, in the sixth day, the dorsal pore is not open at the surface, and in my oldest stage, eighty-seven days, the madreporite is still continuous with the tissues of the body-wall.

Development of Holothnria Floridana Pourtales 215

By the time of hatching, the Polian vesicle has arisen from the circular canal in the left ventral interradins. It is well marked in the seventh day, and by the ninth, extends posteriorly one-half the length of the ccelom. Joh. Miihler, 1852, in the "Auricularia mit Kugeln" and Ludwig, 1891, in Cucumaria planci, describe the origin of the Polian vesicle in the left dorsal interradins. However, Thompson, 1862, in Synapta inhserens, states that the Polian vesicle arises in the left ventral interradins, as I have found it in Holothnria floridana.

The Polian vesicle enlarges rapidly and nearly fills the left half of the ccelom. By the sixty-seventh day it extends three-fourths of the way to the posterior end of the body. During this time the anlagen of the radialia and interradialia of the calcareous ring are being established.

From observation of the living holothurids it is apparent that the respiratory movements of the cloaca begin quite early in the free larvae. However, sections of my stages do not clearly reveal the presence of respiratory trees until the fortieth day, although at that time they are well developed, the left being the larger. Hence, it is probable that they arise in an earlier stage. In some cases only one resj)iratory tree is to be found. The radiating cloacal dilator muscles, which cause the respiratory movements of the cloaca, are also well established at an early date.

On the third day, the anlagen of the first calcareous spicules appear. Beginning with a simple short rod, the ends bifurcate to form a four-rayed base. Sometimes only three rays are developed. The outer ends of the rays fork. From the central part of the bar arise the four vertical rods which are joined together by cross-beams to form the spire. The ends of the branches of the rays again fork, and the apposed terminal branches from neighboring rays gTow together to form the four central holes of the disk. Then the circle of peripheral holes is developed in the same manner. The rosettes and perforated plates are formed just as the disks of the tables.

In the tentacles, along with the tables and perforated plates, by the fourteenth day, circular and spiral supporting rods are developed. The spiral rods extend from three-fourths to one, two, or even three

216 Charles Lincoln Edwards

turns around the tentacle. At the base of the sucker is a supporting ring giving off branches running out at right angles into the wall of the sucker. Guarding the anus are two lateral and one posterior, broadly based, fan-shaped perforated plates (PL I, Fig. 6 ; Pis. II-III, Figs. 9, 10, 12, 14, vv, y) which wave in and out with the contractions of the cloacal muscles. I have interpreted these as structures similar to vestigial anal teeth (1909).

III. Tentacles.

In the fourth day, four of the five primary tentacles grow out from the bases of the radial canals, two before and two behind, the peristomial groove. During this day the tentacles extend, pushingahead of themselves the overlying ectoderm of the peristome, together with the intervening mesenchyme. The lip of the peristome, divided by the groove into anterior and posterior halves, is moved in and out by the contractions of the developing tentacles within. At this time four of the primary tentacles are well marked (PI. I, Figs. 4-5), one arising from the mid-ventral radial canal to the right (MVrl), and one dorsad from the right (RVdl) and left ventral (LVdl) and the left dorsal (LDdl) radial canals respectively. In addition, the hud of the fifth primary tentacle appears, arising from the mid-ventral radial canal to the left. Thus the four-day embryo presents a w^ell marked tentacle in each interradius except the right ventral, which, however, contains the bud of the fifth primary tentacle. Since MVrl and LDdl are larger than RVdl and LVdl (PI. I, Fig. 4), it is probable that the two former arise first. The ventral radial canal has grown much faster than the others and ends posteriorly in the bud of the first pedicel (PI. I, Figs. 4-5, pvp).

During the fifth day, while the embryo is still within the vitelline membrane, the tentacles grow but slightly. At this time the tentacles contract comparatively rapidly. They push out against the vitelline membrane now covered on the outside by slime, which contains diatoms and other protists and their debris. Once in a while a tentacle adheres to the unbroken egg-shell, pulling it in. By the sixth day the embryo has succeeded, by constant manipulalation with the tentacles, in breaking the vitelline membrane. The

Development of Holothuria Floridana Pourtales 217

larval holothurid gradually pushes away the remnants of the old egg-shell and begins to creep about by means of the suckers terminating the four primary tentacles first developed, and the one posterior mid-ventral pedicel. It will fix itself by the pedicel and extend the tentacles in hydra-like attitude (PL II, Fig. 7). Now it will turn onto the tentacles with the released pedicel waving aloft, and again it will creep about by means of all of its appendages, assuming curious elephantine postures. Securing food by the suckers, the holothurid bends the tentacles until the ends reach the mouth, when the food is pushed into the pharynx. The outer lip of the peristome embraces the proximal halves of the tentacles, forming a web between them which is drawn out when the tentacles are extended.

During the fourth, fifth and sixth days, the fifth primary tentacle remains as a bud from the mid-ventral radial canal to the left. By the seventh day the bud has appeared externally as a small tentacle and with the exception of an occasional precocious individual it is not until after the seventh day that the fifth primary tentacle develops to the size of the first four (PI. II, Fig. 7, MVll). The lip of the peristome persists as a collar around the bases of the tentacles.

In the scheme for the adult symmetry of the twenty tentacles (Diagram 1), the origin of the thirteen shown in my series is indicated. Each of the first four of the primary tentacles, so Avell inaugurated in the fourth day, is marked A, and the fifth, budding in the fourth day, A5. Following this scheme of symmetry. Table I present the details in the development of the tentacles from the sixth to the eighty-seventh days. After the seventh tentacle, the order of appearance sometimes varies, but the serial numbers, given in DiagTam 1, follow the usual ontogeny.

By the fortieth day, the sixth tentacle, small but developed (PL II, Fig. 10, KVd2) is clearly seen in the living holothurid. It has evaginated from tho tentacular canal of the primary tentacle dorsad from the right ventral radial canal just after it leaves the radial canal (Diagram 1, E. 6). One specimen of this age has also the bud of the seventh tentacle from the canal of the primary tentacle dorsad from the left ventral radial canal (L 7). The day when the bud of the sixth tentacle may have first appeared, I was not


Charles Lincoln Edwards


A ^^ [^ A5

^11 12

Diagram I. Order of development of thirteen of the twenty tentacles constituting the adult symmetry. The vertically hatched central oesophagus is surrounded by the circular canal of the water-vascular system, from which the five radial canals arise. The five radialia, and the five interradialia, are hatched diagonally. At the base of each radiale, the radial canal gives off two tentacular canals to each side and then proceeds anteriorly, turning through the notch into the body- wall. The first tentacular canal to be developed runs along the inner surface of the radiale-interradiale joint and the second, having been evaginated from the base of the first, goes alongside of the radial canal. At the anterior margin of the calcareous ring, the tentacular canals give off the ampullse and then terminate in the peltate tentacles. The ampulhie hang down behind the calcareous pieces, and, as they come into view, are seen outlined against the cross-hatching which represents the ccBlom.

D. Dorsal. V. Ventral. R. Right. L. Left, dl, d2, vl, v2. Tentacles dorsad and ventrad respectively, in the order of development from' a given radial canal, rl, r2, 11, 12. Tentacles to the right, and to the left, respectively, in the order of development from the mid-ventral radial canal. A. One of the first four primary tentacles. A5. The fifth primary tentacle. 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13. Secondary tentacles in serial order of development.


E 2;







a •< S o



! i

























Serial Nt OF Sec










































<! m K O « 

1-1 >




1 1

























1 1


















Z 1-1






































































































































•sXbq ui aSy









^ ^







•s]'Bnpti JO J3q










- '



QO 03

m o IS 53


lu ca


. o

l-H ^


I- >

S CD ■*^ HJ ID —

•^(2 2

g^P 'S'g .

o .« 

ojT3 oj

"^ ^ — bO^ c^

S5? a


i-i oj a)

220 Charles Lincoln Edwards

able to determine because of the lack of stages between the thirtythird day, with no trace of the sixth tentacle, and the fortieth day with the sixth developed and the seventh budded. A second forty-day specimen, showing precocious development, has in addition, the buds of the eighth tentacle dorsad from the right dorsal radial canal (D 8) and the ninth and tenth (R and L, 9, 10), ventrad from the right and left ventral radial canals. Thus for the first time, at the fortieth day, is a tentacle (D8) given off from the right dorsal radial canal, although so early as the twenty-fourth day this canal has evaginated a j)apilla. In some specimens the ninth tentacle first appears on the left, in others, on the right, but in most cases these two appear at the same time. In the forty-second day the eighth tentacle is found externally (PL III, Figs. 11-14, RDdl). A forty-nine day specimen presents the bud of the eleventh tentacle from the primary tentacular canal to the right of the mid-ventral radial canal (Diagram 1, V 11) one at seventy-one days shows a small tentacle, the twelfth, from the canal of the primary tentacle to the left of the mid-ventral radial canal (V 12), and one at seventy-five days, the thirteenth (D 13), from the primary tentacular canal dorsad from the left dorsal radial canal (PL III, Figs. 13-14, LDd2). Thus, in the development of the adult symmetry, as represented in Diagram 1, by the end of my ontogenetic series, the following tentacles have appeared, albeit not all in any one holotliurid ; the four from the midventral radial canal, the two dorsal and one of the ventral from each of the lateral ventral radial canals, the two dorsal from the left dorsal radial canal and only one from the right dorsal radial canal. In general, beginning with the fifth, the tentacles develop in alternation from left to right.

By the eighth day the suckers of one or more of the tentacles are divided. Later these halves divide and the dichotomous branching of the adult tentacle is established. (Pis. II-III, Figs. 7-14).

By the sixty-seventh day the tentacle ampullae have become developed and can be followed in cross-sections from their place of origin from the bases of the tentacular canals at the anterior end of the calcareous ring to about one-half the distance back to the circular canal. The origin of the tentacle ampullas does not seem to have been previously noted.

Development of Holothuria Floridana Poiirtales 221

A. Discussion of Litekatuke.

Kowalevsky, 1867, describes in Cucumaria kirchsbergii and Cucumaria planci and Selenka, 1876, also in Cucumaria planci, the formation, at first of three dorsal, and then later, of two ventral tentacles. Ludwig, 1891a, states that in Cucumaria planci and, 1898, in Phyllophorus urna and Clark, 1898, that in Synaptula hydriformis, all of the five primary tentacles appear at the same time. Ludwig, 1891, also describes in Cucumaria planci an asymmetrical develop ment of the tentacles but of a somewhat difterent pattern from that which I find in Holothuria floridana. In agreement with my results, Ludwig shows that two of the five j)rimary tentacles are given off from the mid-ventral radial canal, one to either side, but, of the three others, two arise from the left dorsal radial canal, dorsad and ventrad respectively, and one ventrad from the right dorsal radial canal. Thus each of the right and left ventral radial canals gives rise to a primary tentacle in Holothuria floridana and does not in Cucumaria planci. Up to this time the determination of the exact origin of the tentacles from definite radial canals has been made only in Cucumaria planci and Phyllophorus urna by Ludwig and in Holothuria floridana by myself, with the above divergent findings. When other holothurians are studied in a similar manner, it will be of interest to see whether these differences are generic, or specific, and if yet other such peculiar asymmetrical distributions of the tentacles prevail. So it would appear that the generalization of Becher, 1907, 1908, that in addition to the midventral radial canal the left, and to a less degree the right dorsal radial canals were the more important in the primitive ancestral holothurian, is scarcely justifiable at present. The simple primitive pedicel-like structure and function of the tentacles in the early larvse of Holothuria floridana is like that described by Becher, 1907, in the adult Ehabdomolgus ruber.

Relative to the increase in number of the tentacles beyond the primary five, we have but few observations. Danielssen and Koren, 1856, describe the appearance of distinct traces of five new tentacles in Holothuria tremula on the forty-seventh day. In nine days these buds grow to about the full size of the primary tentacles. In view

222 Charles Lincoln Edwards

of the results obtained by Ludwig and myself, it is much to be desired that Holothuria tremula be reinvestigated through the careful study of serial sections of each stage.

Becher, 1907, describes the simultaneous appearance of the three first secondary tentacles in the three dorsal interradii of Ehabdomolgus ruber, Thompson, 1862, merely states that in Leptosynapta inhserens, at about three months, the sixth and seventh tentacles arise on opposite sides of the circular canal. Baur, 1864, with equal lack of exactness, tells of an eight tentacled stage in Labidoplax digitata, as intermediate between the primary five, and the adult twelve, tentacles. Clark, 1898, notes the first five accessory tentacles as appearing at the same time in Synaptula hydriformis and agreeing in location with those of Cucumaria planci as described by Ludwig. The eleventh tentacle arises ventrad from the left, and the twelfth, ventrad from the right dorsal "secondary outgrowth." While Clark does not suggest the homology, it is possible to regard these "secondary outgrowths" as the last vestiges in the degeneration of the protoholothuroid radial canals, thus supporting the phylogenetic theories of Ludwig, 1889-92, and Oestergren, 1907. Ludwig, 1891, does not note an increase in the number of tentacles in Cucumaria planci until the hundred and sixteenth day, when some of the young animals have the sixth and seventh tentacles dorsad of the right and left ventral radial canals. On the sixteenth day- the primary tentacles develop branches and inaugurate the arborescent form. The same author, 1881, observes that in young Chiridota rotifera, 1898, in Taeniogyrus contortus, and, 1898a, in Phyllophorus urna, two secondary tentacles have arisen, one dorsad from each of the right and left ventral radial canals. Semon, 1883, believes that, in Labidoplax digitata, the secondary tentacles will prove to be evaginated from the radial canals, at the point where the latter bend over the calcareous ring. Semon emphasizes that his conclusion is theoretical, and not based on direct observation.

IV. Pedicels and Papillae. As related above, in Holothuria floridana the first pedicel is found as a bud terminating the posterior end of the mid-ventral radial

Development of Holothiiria Floridana Pourtales 223

canal in the fourth day (PL I, Figs. 4-5, pvp). After hatching in the sixth day, this pedicel develops a sucker, and by the eighth day it exceeds the tentacles in length. On the seventh day, the bud of the second pedicel evaginates from the mid-ventral radial canal to the left. On the ninth day this pedicel appears externally (PI. II, Pig. 7, b). On the twenty-second day the third mid-ventral pedicel arises between the first and second, and on the thirty-third day, the fourth, behind the third (PL II, Fig. 8, c, d). On the fortieth day, the fifth mid-ventral pedicel appears behind the fourth (PL II, Fig. 10, e). After the primary posterior mid-ventral pedicel, the next four develop to the left from the mid-ventral radial canal. It is not until the fortieth day that the bud of a pedicel appears to the right from the mid-ventral radial canal (PL II, Fig. 10, MVrp). The ventral pedicels are thus inaugurated in an asymmetry beginning with development to the left of the mid-ventral radial canal. In one lot of embryos of which I have now only sketches from life, the development was more rapid than given above, since a specimen of the fourteenth day has three, and one of the nineteenth day, four, left mid-ventral pedicels.

In Table II, the appendages of the young of my alcoholic series, from four to eighty-seven days old, are seriated with reference to their place of origin. In the stages later than nine days, variation in the number of appendages will be noted in the individuals. In part, this is to be associated with accelerated or retarded growth, and in part, with natural variation. As noted above in connection with the tentacles, at least in one lot of embryos, individuals developed more precociously.

On the twenty-fourth day, the buds of the first pair of papillae appear ventrad from the anterior parts of the dorsal radial canals, inaugurating the bilateral symmetry later shown, in a general way, in the distribution of the appendages. By the thirtieth day these buds have developed, and by the thirty-third day the buds of five more dorsal papillae have appeared (PL II, Fig. 9). From the first, these papillae are especially developed and prominent (Pis. II-III, Figs. 9, 10, 12, 14; rdpa 1, 2, 3, Idpa 1, 2, 3). Later the ventral series of the dorsal papillae become the lateral warts so characteristic

■tuniAia o^ uiniAux — ox^B"^


1 1



O "5


o o


CO 00

CO 00


1 CO


1 «o

1 N





1 »^




OS .










t- CO 1 t^ lO

05 IN


CO (N 1 ifl ■* U5 00



O 05 00 00




3 I-!- i-l

u 1

1 i


CM 1 >o o>

1 CO 1 CO



00 CO «5 CM

05 1 -H 1 CM 1 00 1 »H ■* 1 >0 1 CO CO N< <

= 1

1 1




CO la


IC « 00

1 05 CO


(N 00 1 r^

IN -H (N

CD 1 CO 1 OS CO 1 Ol 1 CM

(^ 1 O rH

CM CO (y»


-« 1 1 II ® 1 1 II

1 1 1 1

-H N 1 ■* CO

II 11

1 ■* >0 1 IN 1 1^

"5 1 00 1 t^ O



< o


< P <





> P

1 1



1 1 1 1 1 1

1 uu 1 1 1

CO U ICM -H U !w


•snipBy uj

s ! ! « 1 1

1 1 1 1

1 1 1 1

1 1

1 u 1

^\ Ul 1 1 1




s 1 1

1 1

Ul 1 1

1 1-1 "l-l"

1 IN 1 ■* 1 CO

CM 1 CD 1

lO 1 l> IC Tf

5 1

1 1

T 1 1 1

^ ^

.-1 rt 1^ 1 rH (N CO

J J 1




•* CO 1 CO CO •*


hi m

a o





T5 1 1

« 1 1


1 1 1 1

■* OS

CO 00 I> 1 00 1 05

1 1


1 1

1 1 1

1 1 1 u

1 1 1 1

1 1

' -h

CM 1 ^ 01

•snrpBjj uj

-o 1

« 1



^ ^

1 1 1

'6 1



1 1

rH 1 <N 1 (N .-H

1 1

1-1 CO 1 ^^ 1

CM CD "3 O 1 00 1 ■>*

" 1 1





- U U U U, 1 CO

1 1 1 1 1



CO 1 ■*



CO 1 CO 1 "t

1 1


< <A






o P



1 1









X 1 CO



1 1




•smpB^ uj




1 1

1 a





1 1

1 1

T-H 1 IN 1 (N


(M 1 .H 1


rH CM CM Tji tH 1 1 1 1



^ 1 ^ (N 1 ■*

1 1

•* CO


IC 1 CO IC 1 ^ 1 lO 1 •*








o P

-d « 




1 1 1 1

1 1

U Ico

1 1

(N ■* r- 1 CO 1 lO

t^ 1 t> 1 CM i >0

1 l-^l

> P

1 1

1 1





•snipB^ nj




-1 u 1 1

^ 1

-a 1 « 1





rH 1 <N



CO 1 CM CO 1 CO'




1-1 rH (N








U5 1 CO 1 CO

1 1

Ventral Radial Canal.




1 1


1 1

^ ^Ico 1

CM 1 ^ CM "O 1 CM 1 C< 1 1 1


1 1


rH (N 1 <N





CO 1 CO 1 ■*

1 1

■* 1 iC


CO 1 •*




■* 1 >0 1 CO 1 -"j* 1 ■*

1 1 1 1






1 1 1 1

1 1

> p















^ y-l


•a w



iH (N


CM CO rH rH .H U5 CM







•H Tt< 1 CM CM •* CM 1 1 1 1

rf IN

BitBQ at agy




1 CO




















I JO Jaqtnn^j











Development of Holothiiria Floridana Pourtales 225

of the adult Holothuria floridana (Edwards, 1908). However, most of the dorsal appendages will become pedicels since in the adult only about twenty per cent are papillae.

On the thirtieth day a pedicel buds ventrad from the right and left ventral radial canals. By the thirty-third day these lateral pedicels have developed (PL II, Fig. 8, rvp, Ivp), and by the fortieth day two additional buds have appeared below each lateral ventral radial canal (PI. II, Fig. 10). On the forty-second day one bud arises dorsad from each lateral ventral radial canal. From this time on the number of appendages increases with comparative rapidity and an approximate bilateral symmetry is established (PL III, Figs. 11-14). For the details of distribution I refer to Table II.

In one specimen of the fortieth day, nine developed appendages and sixteen buds have appeared ; by the forty-fifth day, twenty-seven developed and twenty-three buds ; by the fifty-fifth day, thirty-six developed and twenty-six buds and by the seventy-fifth day a total of ninety-eight (Pis. II-III, Figs. 10-14). The largest number of developed appendages, thirty-six, is found in a fifty-five day holothurid, while among the smallest specimens of my collection not raised from the embryo, the least number of developed appendages shown is seventy-seven. If studied in sections, these small individuals would doubtless be found to have buds and show a considerable increase in the total number of appendages. Since the seventy-five day young presents a total of ninety-eight appendages, developed and buds, it may be assumed that the later stages in my holothurids from the embiyo, connect this series with the adult and that appendages will continue to bud from each radial canal in a manner similar to that described up to the eighty-seventh day.

There is a tendency, perfectly demonstrated in part of the specimens, for one or another radial canal to terminate posteriorly in the bud of an appendage, either lying in the radius, or turned slightly dorsally or ventrally. As the radial canal grows on posteriorly, such a terminal appendage becomes either ventral, or dorsal, to the canal in position. At first the ordinary larval appendages gTOw off to the sides of the radial canals and, hence, the lines of the radii are bare. This is especially true of the mid-ventral radius.

226 Charles Lincoln Edwards

and may characterize the young of the usual collection as Pourtales, 1851, notes. The ambulacral vessels of a number of the appendages, particularly in the later stages, as may be seen in the sections, grow within the body-wall for some distance from the radial canal and consequently the appendage is superficially interradial in location. Gn the other hand, the ambulacral vessels of some appendages turn into the mid-line of the radius. Hence, through the varying lengths of ambulacral vessels within the body-wall the fairly even distribution of appendages over the trivium, and in smaller numbers, over the bivium, of the adult is established.

From the larva of twenty-four days, with the first dorsal papillae, to the eighty-seven day stage, there are eighteen cases detailed in Table II, of which seventy-two per cent have the larger number of appendages from the radial canals of the trivium. In making the ratio of appendages in the trivium to those in the bivium, the appendages given off dorsad from the right and left ventral radial canals were counted among those of the trivium, with which they seem to function, albeit some of them later in the adult might be placed in the bivium. The average of all the ratios gives one and three-tenths as many appendages in the trivium as in the bivium. The proportionate number ventrally increases with further growth, for, as I have demonstrated elsewhere (1908), in the average young of the ordinary collection series there are one and seven-tenths, and in the average adult, one and nine-tenths, as many appendages per square centimeter in the trivium as in the bivium. Since, on the average, in this series, there are half again as many appendages per square centimeter in the young as in the adult the increase in the number of appendages does not keep pace with the general growth of the body-wall. In every stage from larva to adult, all of the ventral appendages are pedicels. Of the dorsal appendages of the adult, eighty per cent are pedicels, and not all of the remaining twenty per cent are true papillae. In each ambulacral appendage a valve develops at the entrance by the time the appendage is functional. The last stages of my series fail to exhibit any clearly marked ampullae for the pedicels and papillae. The relatively large Polian vesicle, therefore, functions as a general reservoir for the lan^al ambulacral system.

Development of Holothuria Floridana Pourtales 227

A. Discussion of Literature.

Joh. Miiller, 1853, reports the first pedicel in the "Auricularia mit Kugeln," as from the mid-ventral radial canal posteriorly and to the right. Previous to my work (1889, 1907) all other authors, Krohn, 1851, in Cucumaria planci; Danielssen and Koren, 1856, in Holothuria tremula ; Agassiz, 1864, in Psolus fabricii ; Kowalevsky, 1867, in Cucumaria kirchsbergii, Cucumaria planci and Phyllophorus uma; Selenka, 1876, and Ludwig, 1891a, in Cucumaria planci, and Ludwig, 1898, in Phyllophorus urna, describe the first two pedicels as developing in a pair from the posterior end of the mid-ventral radial canal. Ludwig notes the origin of the first pair in the fourth day and that these pedicels are truly developed on the eighteenth day. Danielssen and Koren, 1856, record in an embryo of Holothuria tremula of the thirty-fourth day, the appearance of the second pair of pedicels above the first, and on the fifty-sixth day, the third pair. In the last stage also, dorsal papillse are seen here and there. Ludwig, 1891, describes in Cucumaria planci, the third pedicel arising to the left of the mid-ventral radial canal, in front of the two primary, on the forty-fifth day. The fourth pedicel does not appear until the eighty-fourth day and then still further forward, but to the right. The fifth pedicel arises on the hundred and eleventh day anteriorly and ventrad from the left dorsal radial canal. Therefore, the same radial canals from which the primary tentacles developed serve for the budding of the first pedicels. Ludwig, 1898, states that in Phyllophorus urna the third pedicel appears before, and the fourth pedicel behind the first two. In this fashion a zigzag line is formed. At two and one-half months the larva possesses two more mid-ventral pedicels, and two from each lateral ventral radial canal, but none in the bivium.

Becher, 1908, makes various suggestions as to the possible phylogenetic significance of this marked precocity in the ontogeny of the pedicels from the mid-ventral radial canal, without, however, coming to any satisfactory conclusion. Because the appendages increase with growth, Herourard, 1901, believes that a single species passes successively through stages characteristic of Ocnus, Cucumaria and Semperia, and, therefore, the first and last are synonyms of Cucumaria.

228 Charles Lincoln Edwards

LITERATURE CITED. Agassiz, a., 1864. On the Embryology of Echiuoderms. Mem. Am. Acad.,

V. 9, 4 pis., 4°. Baur, A., 1SG4. Beitrage zur Naturgescbichte der Synapta digitata. Nov.

Act. Acad. nat. curios. Leop. Carol., v. 31, 8 pis., 4°, Dresden. Becher, S., 1907. Rhabdomolgus ruber Keferstein und die Stammform der

Holothurien. Zeitschr. wiss. Zool., v. 88, pp. 545-689, pis. 32-36, 12

figs, Leipz. Becher, S., 1908. Die Stanimesgescbit-bte der Seewalzeu. Erg. u. Fortscbr.

d. Zool., V. 1 (3), 88 pp.. 12 txt. figs. Clark, H. L., 1898. Synapta Vivlpara : A contribution to tbe Morphology of

Echinoderms. Mem. Bost. Soc, v. 5, pp. 58-88, pis. 11-15, Jan. Danielssen, D. C, and Koren, J., 185G. Observations sur le developpement

des Holotburies. Fauna littoralls Norvegiae. 2. Livr., Bergen. Edwards, C. L., 1889. Notes on the Embryology of Miilleria Agassizii Sel., a

Holotburiau common at Green Turtle Cay, Bahamas. Johns Hopkins

Univ. Circ, Bait., v. 8, p. 37. Edwards, C. L.. 1905. A Quantitative Study of Holothuria atra Jiiger and the

Reestablishment of Holothuria floridana Pourtales (^ Holothuria

mexicana Ludwig). Science, v. 21 (532), pp. 383-384, Mar. 10. Edwards, C. L., 1907. Tbe Order of Appearance of the Ambulacral Appendages

in Holothuria floridana Pourtales. Science, v. 25, (646). pp. 775-776,

May 17. Edwards, C. L., 1908. Variation, Development and (irowtli in Holothuria

floridana Pourtales and in Plolothuria atra Jiiger. Biometrika, v. 6,

(2 and 3), Sept. Edwards, C. L., 1909. Some Holothurian Structures. Science, v. 29 (741), p.

437, March 12. Herouard, E., 1901. Note preliniinaire sur les Holotburies rapportSes par

I'Expedition Antarctique Beige. Arch. Zool. exp. Notes 3, v. 9, pp.

39-48, June. KowALEVSKY, A., 1807. Beitrage zur Entwickelungsgescbicbte der Holothurien.

Mem. Aciul. imp. sc de St. Petersb., 7 Ser., v. 11, (6), I pi. 4°, St.

Petersb. Krohn, a., 1851. Beobacbtungen aus der Entwickelungsgescbicbte der Holothurien und Seeigel. Miiller's Archiv, pp. 344-352, pi. 14, figs. 2-5, Ludwig, H., 1881. rfeber eine lebendiggebarende Synaptide und zwei andere

neue Holothurienarten der brasilianischen Kiiste. Archv. de Biol.,

Gand., v. 2, pp. 41-58, pi. 3. Ludwig, H., 1889-92. (I) Buch. Die Seewalzer. In Bronn's Klassen und

Ordnungen des Thierreichs, v. 2, 3 Abth., Leipzig. Ludwig, H., 1891. Zur Entwickelungsgescbicbte der Holothurien. Sitzungsb.

Akad., Berlin, pp. 179-192. (Translation in Ann. Mag. N. H., v. 8, (6),

pp. 413-427.)

Developnu'iit of ITolotliuria Floridana Poiirtales 229

LUDWiG, H., 1891a. Zur Eutwickelungsgeschichte der Holotliurieu. 2. Mit tbeiluug. Sitzuugsb. Akad., Berlin, pp. 603-612. LuDwiG, H.. 1898. Holotlnirien in Ergebnisse d. Haniburger Magalhaensiscben

Samnielrei.se. (3), 98, pp. 3 pis. June. lADwiG, H., lS98a. Brutpflege und Entwickelung von PbyllopUorus urna

Grube. Vorlaufige Mittbeiluug. Zool. Anz.. v. 21, pp. 9.5-99. Jan. 31. MCt.i.kr, Joh., 1852. Ueber die Larven nnd die iNIetamorpbose der Eehinoder nieu. 4. Abbandlung. Abbandl. Berliner Akad. d. Wissen.scb. aus

d. Jabren 1850-1851. MiLLEB. Joh., 1853. Ueber die Larven und die Metamorpbose der Ecbinoder men. 6. Abbandlung. Abbandl. Berliner Akad. d. Wissenscb. aus

d. Jabre 1852. Okstergren, II.. 1907. Zur Pbylo.^enie und Systeniatik der Seewalzen. Zoo logiska Studier Tillagn. Professor T. Tullberg. pp. 191-215, Naturvet.

Studentsilllsk. Upsala, Oct. 12. PouRTALES, L. F., 1851. On tbe Holotburia^ of tbe Atlantic Coast of tbe United

States. Proc. Amer. Ass. Adv. Sci., 5 Meet., pp. 8-16, Wasb. Selenka. E., 1876. Zur Entwickelung der Holotburien (Ilolntburia tubulosa

u. Cucumaria doliolum). Zeitscbr. wiss. Zool., v. 27, pp. 155-178,

pis. 9-13. Semon, R., 1888. Die Entwickelung der Synapta digitata und die Stammes gescbicbte der Echinodermen. Sonder-Abdrnck a. d. Jenaiscbe

Zeitscbr. f. Naturw., v. 22, pp. 135, 7 pis., 8°, Jena. Thompson, W.. 1862. On tbe development of Synapta inbj>?rens. Quart. J.

Micr. Sci. (N. S.), v. 2, pp. 131-146, pis. .5-6.

230 Charles Lincoln Edwards

EXPLANATION OF PLATES. All figures were drawn with the aid of an AbbS camera lucida, from preparations of Holothuria floridana Pourtal6s.


a, b, c, d, e, first, second, third, fourth and fifth pedicels from the midventral radial canal.

bl., blastopore.

dl, d2, first, and second, tentacles developed dorsad from a given radial canal.

D., dorsal.

ect., ectoderm.

ent., enteron.

11, 12, first and second tentacles developed to the left from the mid-ventral radial canal.

LD., left dorsal radial canal.

Idpal, ldpa2, ldpa3, first, second, and third, left dorsal papillae.

Ivp., first pedicel developed ventrad from the' left ventral radial canal.

LV., left ventral radial canal.

m., mouth.

mes., mesoderm

MV., mid-ventral radial canal.

MVrp., first pedicel developed to the right from the mid-ventral radial canal.

p., peristome.

pvp., posterior ventral pedicel.

rl, r2, first and second tentacles developed to the right from the mid-ventral radial canal.

RD.. right dorsal radial canal.

rdpal, rdpa2, rdpa3, first, second, and third, right dorsal papilke.

rvp., first pedicel developed ventrad from the right ventral radial canal.

RV., right ventral radial canal.

t, larval table.

v., ventral.

vl, v2, first, and second, tentacles developed ventrad from a given radial canal.

vra., vitelline membrane.

vpv., vaso-peritoneal vesicle.

vv., lateral anal plates.

XX., anterior papillae, developed dorsad from the right and left dorsal radial canals.

y., posterior anal plate.


Figs. 1, 3, 4, and 5. Surface views of embryos, represented as opaque objects within the vitelline membrane. The nuclei of the ectoderm cells, and the scattered mesenchyme cells beneath, are indicated.

Fig. 1. Posterior view of forty-four hour embryo, showing the peristome in front of the blastopore and the vaso-peritoneal vesicle within, x 175.

Fig. 2. Sagittal section of embryo represented in Fig. 1. The vaso-peritoneal vesicle is divided into anterior hydrocele and posterior enterocele. The enteron is growing toward the bottom of the peristome. X 175.

Fig. 3. Ventral view of embryo showing the peristome as a straight groove across the ventral surface, x 175.

Fig. 4. Ventral view of an embryo of four days. The four of the primary tentacles first developed and the bud of the posterior mid-ventral first pedicel, are well marked, x 175.

Fig. 5. Embryo represented in Fig. 4, seen from the right side. X 175.

Fig. 6. One of the three calcareous perforated anal plates, x 135.




vpv —

Fig. 2.

IiV<ll gfeo'


Fig. 3.


-/_. I.Vtll

LDdl LVdl



Fig. 5.





Fig. 6.

IE Jul u.NAL OF Mor.rHOLOGY. — Vol. XX, No, 2.


Figs. 7, 8, 9, 10 show the larval tables (t), the terminal branching of the tentacles, the radial canals and the enterou, with its enlarged stomach and three loops.

Fig. 7. Ventral view of a larva of nine days showing the five primary tentacles, the posterior mid-ventral first pedicel, and the second pedicel, developed to the left from the mid-ventral radial canal. X 55.

Fig. 8. A^entral view of a larva of thirty-three days, in which the five primary tentacles, the posterior pedicel, and the second, third, and fom'th pedicels, to the left from the mid-ventral radial canal, are prominent. The first pedicels from the right and left ventral radial canals have appeared. X 29.

Fig. 9. Dorsal view of embryo represented in Fig. 8, showing the three pairs of dorsal papillte. The first two, at the anterior end of the body, are relatively large. The anus is guarded by two lateral, and one posterior, valves. X29.

Fig. 10. View from the right side of a larva of forty days, showing five primary tentacles, the posterior pedicel, four well-developed pedicels to the left from the mid-ventral radial canal, and the three dorsal papillae. In addition, the sixth tentacle, and the first pedicel to the right from the mid-ventral radial canal are now developed. X 29.




LDdl .




Fig. 10. 40 Davs.


MVrl . J.



FlG. 8.


Fig. 9.

^3 Days.

IB Journal of Morphology. — Vcil. XX. No. 2.


Figs. 11, 12, 13. 14, show increased numbers of tentacles, pedicels, and papillae. The terminal branches of the tentacles are well marked.

Fig. 11. Ventral view of larva of fifty-three days. In addition to the five primary tentacles, the sixth, seventh, eighth, ninth, and tenth, tentacles are shown. Four pedicels and three buds are now found on each side of the midventral radial canal, forming a more or less zigzag line. Five developed pedicels and one bud arise ventrad from each lateral ventral radial canal. X 17^.

Fig. 12. Dorsal view of larva represented in Fig. 11. The two posterior pairs of dorsal papillae have grown larger. An anterior pair of papillte is developed dorsad from the right and left dorsal radial canals. X nV2 Fig. 13. Ventral view of larva of seventy-live days, showing the additional thirteenth tentacle (LDd 2) and only a slight increase in the number of pedicels and buds over the fifty-three day holothurid. The mouth is well shown.

X 141/0.

Fig. 14. Dorsal view of larva represented in Fig. 13. The anus and anal plates are prominent. X 14%.







Fig. 11.

Fig. 12.

53 Days.



Fig. 14.

75 Days.





With 4 Plates. CONTENTS


I. Introduction 231

II. Review of tlie Literature upon the Origin of the Germ-cells in

the Insecta 2.32

Introduction 232

1. Lepidoptera 2.33

2. Diptera 230

3. Heniiptera 243

4. Hynienoptera 24.5

5. Orthop.era 248

G. Coleopt^ra 2.51

7. Neuroptera 2.54

8. Dermaptera 255

0. Aptera 2.55

III. Observations 2.57

1. The role-Disc 2.57

2. The Genesis of the Pole-Cells 258

3. The History of the Pole-Cells until the Sex of the Em bryo can be Recognized 205

IV. General Considerations 270

1. The Granules of the Pole-Disc 270

2. The Migration of tlie Primitive Germ-Cells in the Insecta. . 270

A. The INIigration of the Pole-Cells through the Pole Cells Canal 270

B. Vhe Migration of the Germ-Cells within the Embryo 278

C. The Method of Locomotion of the Germ-Cells ". . 280

.3. The Origin and Early History of the Germ-Cells in the

Insecta 283

V. Summary 288

VI. Material and Methods 290

VI I. Literature List 291

VIII. Explanatli.n of Plates 290

I. Introduction. The £rerni-eells of the ]\Ietozoa have been in recent years a favorite subject for investigators. The theory of the continuity of the germplasm expressed by Galton in 1872 and Later (1885) elaborated

The .TotiiXAr. of Morpholooy. — Vol. XX, No. 2.

232 Kobert Wilhelm Hemer,


by Weismann has focused tlife attention of em,bryologists upon the reproductive cells. Many remarkable discoveries have been made in the late stages of the history of these cells, but comparatively little effort has been directed toward their early embryonic development. The work which forms the basis of the present paper was undertaken in an attempt to clear up some of the problems which have resulted from a large number of disconnected studies on the embryology of the Insecta. The lineage of the germ-cells of Calligraplia 7nuUijyuncfata is described in the following pages from a preblastodermic stage until the sex of the embryo can be recognized. Two other Chrysomelid beetles, Calligrapha lunata and Leptinotarsa decemlineata, are referred to in the course of the paper, but C. multlpunctata has received the largest share of attention.

The work was begun at the University of Chicago and was continued at the Marine Biological Laboratory at Woods Holl, Mass., and at the University of Wisconsin. I wish to thank the members of the zoological staffs of these institutions for their kindness and for the facilities granted to me. I am greatly indebted to Professor Wm. S. Marshall for his valuable and generous aid and the use of his extensive library ; and I am also under obligations to Professor C. O. Wliitman for his helpful suggestions and advice. I wish to express my gratitude to my wife for her assistance in cutting sections and in preparing the manuscript for the publishers.

II. Review of tub Literature upon the Origin of the Germ-Cells in the Insecta.


Only a few papers have been devoted exclusively to the origin and early development of the germ-cells of the Insecta. These contributions do not represent by any means our knowledge of this subject, for alm,ost every work on general insect embryology contains observations on the primitive germ-cells, although usually in a subordinate degree.

Brandt (1878), Heymons (1891), Graber (1891) and others have ])r()vid('d a more or less complete historical account of this phase

Germ-Colls in Chrysomelid Beetles. 233

of embryology, but the great number of recent papers dealing with the subject makes it advisable to give the following descriptions which attempt to present, in a brief manner, the numerous fragmentary sketches of the various authors.

1. Lepidoptera.

The earliest worker whose results are worthy of consideration is Herold (1815). He has given a remarkably good description of the gross aspects of both ovaries and testes in several species of Lepidoptera, principally Papilio hrassica, from a late embryonic period to the adult stage. For us the chief value of his results lies in his discovery that the sex of the larva is already determined before hatching. He foiuid the ovary to consist of four tubules, and the testis of four small sacs; the former with a duct at its posterior end and the latter with a duct extending from the center of its side.

In Bombyx pint, according to Heymons (1891), Suckow (1828), disting-uished the male from the female before the larva hatched, thus confirming Ilerold's results. This author described the rudiment of the germ-glands as an outgrowth from the hind-intestine "das sich spaterhin durch eine Furche theilt und nach und nach vom Darmkanale abgestossen als zwei seitlich verlaufende hohle Fadchen die Geschlechtsorgane im ersten Entwnrf darstellt."

The reproductive organs could not be found by Meyer (1849) in Liparis auriflua until the caterpillars were over three weeks old, and he wrongly pronounced the young larvse sexless. He was the first, however, to make finer histological examinations of the developing germ-glands.

Bessels (1867) made a more accurate microscopical examination of the embryonic germ-cells than did Meyer (1849), and, contrary to the results of the latter, he found that "Die Anlage der Sexualdriisen findet bei den Lepidopteren im Ei statt, und es wird bereits hier die Verschiedenheit des Geschlechts vollkommen deutlich." In a late embryonic stage of Zeuzera cesculi he found the rudimentary fferm-fflands at either side in the eighth abdominal segment embedded

234 Kobert Wilhelm Ilegner.

in the fat-body. They consisted of many transparent nucleated cells which separated to form the testicular follicles or ovarian tubules, about which a structureless membrane formed.

In Tinea crinella, Balbiani (1869-72) found that "I'organe sexuel est deja parfaiteraent perceptible a une epoque on Tembryon n'est encore represente que par son rudiment ventral, et n'offre encore aucune trace de ses autres appareils organiques. A cette phase pen aA'ancee de son existence, I'organe reproducteur forme une petite masse ovalaire simple, composee de minimes cellules rondes et transparentes. . . Cette masse est appliquee a la face interne de I'extremite inferieure du rudiment ventral. . . " This unpaired oval mass later divided, one-half going to either side of the body.

Brandt (1878) did not study the early development of the germcells but described both ovaries and testes in embryos of Pierls hrassica just before hatching. Die Anlagen der Genitaldriisen selbst fanden sich im Embryo an der Riickenwandung der Leibesh()hle, etwa im achten Korpersegmente, rechts und links dicht am Ilerzen, dessen Peritonealliberzug auf sie iiberging. In ihrem jiingsten Entwicklungsstadium stellten si5 je eincn niehr oder weniger elliptischen Korper dar, welcher durchweg aus rundlichen Embryoludzellen mit amoboid gestalteten Kernen bestand." He found, as did Ilerold (1815), that the female germ-gland could be distingnislud from the male by its duct which extended from the posteri(n' end, while in the latter the duct is attached to the side.

O. and R. ITertwig (1881) found the rudiments of the germglands of Zygcena minos lying between the somatic and splanchnic layers of the mesoderm (Taf. II, Fig. 4).

According to Graber (1891), both Tichomiroff (1882) and Selvatico (1882) identified the germ-glands of Bomhyx inori in comparatively early embryonic stages. The earliest embryo examined contained a germ-gland composed of a group of cells surrounded by mesoderm. It lay between the "Proctodseum und dem Mescnteron" in close connection "mit dem Faserblatt des Mitteldarmes."

The male germ-glands of Zygcena filipendulco and other Lepidoptcra were found by Spichard (1886) to arise from the mesoderm and

Germ-Cells in Chrysonielid Beetles. 235

not from a muscle fiber (Schneider, 1885). In late embryonic life each o-erm-gland consisted of four large Urzellen der Geschlechtsanlagc" with small cells lying Ix'tween them, the Avhok' mass being s\ivroundetl by a tlat-cellcd ei)irli('lium. As the four Urzellen" increased by mitosis, the surrounding sheath grew inward, thus establishing the four testicular follicles.

The earliest appearance of the primitive germ-glands of Lepidoptera was recorded by Woodworth (1889) in EiCvanessa antlopa. About the time the blastoderm was completed, a group of cells became cut off from the ventral plate near its posterior end ; these cells remained in contact with the ventral plate at the place where they are produced. Later stages show that these cells produce the generative organs. The generative organs thus appear to be produced by an infolding of the ectoderm, or possibly of the blastoderm before the ectoderm is produced but from a position which is later to become ectoderm."

In a nine and a half day embryo of Pieris craiwgi, Graber (1801) figured the "Anlagen der Samendriisen" on either side of and dorsal to the intestine, thus occupying a position similar to that found by Selvatico (1882) in Bomhyx mori. Each Anlage" consisted of a few large cells and was surrounded by a small celled epithelium, the whole being embedded in fat-body.

Silk worm embryos, having appendages well developed, were found by Toyama (1002) to contain the rudiments of germ-glands. Although the clusters of germ-cells are normally seen to occur in the third and sixth abdominal segments, we oft^n observed them in all other abdominal segments with the exception of the anal ; and in one case, we observed them even in the mesothoracic segment. We are thus in a position to say that the genital ce-lls originally arise in each body segment." They differentiated from the cells of the mesoblastic somites.

The most recent account of the origin of the germ-cells in Lepidoptera was published by Schwangart (1905). He found in Eiulrotnifi rersiroloin \]\c first indication of a germ-gland two to four hours after blastoderm formation. A part of the blastoderm in the posterior region of the egg, but not at the posterior end, became

236 Eobert Willielin Ilejnier,


several layers thick ; here the inner cells were large, richer in yolk, and their nuclei had one or two nucleoli, but less chromatin than the (overlying) blastoderm cells. These inner, primitive genn-cells soon became amoeboid, and, several hours before mesoderm formation, separated into groups ^^'hieh moved forward through the yolk. Each group divided, half of the cells migrating to either side of the body, where they lay near the coelom in the fourth to sixth abdominal segments. Their history was not carried further.

2. Diptera.

The Diptera have received their full share of attention from insect embryologists and the works relating to species of this order are very numerous. They are also the first, and for a long time the only insects in whose eggs pole-cells were discovered; this group is, therefore, of great interest to us since pole-cells are also present in the development of the Chrysomelid beetles considered in this paper.

Robin (1862) unknowingly discovered the early segregation of germ-cells from somatic cells in the nearly transparent eggs of Tipulides culiciformes. Before the blastoderm Avas formed there appeared "par gemmation de la substance hyaline du vitellus" a number of "globules polaires" which he likened to the polar bodies of other animals. These four to eight buds each developed a nucleus which gave to it the character of a true cell. These cells Avere supposed to take part in the formation of the blastoderm near the spot where they were protruded. Robin did not orient the eggs correctly for he says "C'est aussi le point oii apparaitre plus tard I'extremite cephalique," a statement that Weismann corrected the following year.

Although Weismann (1863) had observed these "globules polaires" in the eggs of Gliironomus nigro-viridis and Musca vomitoria several years l^efore Robin's papers appeared, he did not publish his results until 1863. Weismann noticed at the pointed posterior end of the egg four indefinite, bright spots lying in the "Keimhautblastem." These developed into four bud-like protrusions which were entirely cut off from the egg and lay in the space between the vitelline membrane and the surface of the egg. These "globules polaires" or "Pol

Gorin-Cclls in Clirysoiiielid Beetles. 237

zellen," as Weismann called them, consisted of homogeneous protoplasm containing a nucleus and one or two yolk-granules. Weismann thought ^'dass der Modus ihrer Genese innerhalb des Begriffes von der freicii Zcllcuhildung tallt, wie ilui die iUtcre liistologische Schule aufgestellt hat." The four primitive pole-cells divided each into two, sometimes even before they were entirely separated from the egg; these resultant eight pole-cells became confused with the developing blastoderm-cells, and Weismann could not follow them further.

Neither Robin nor Weismann realized the importance of these pole-cells and it remained for Metschnikoff (1865) and Leuckart (1865) to announce their true significance. Leuckart (1865) described their formation in the p^edogenetic larva of Miastor and confirmed Mctschnikoff's (1865) statement that they were really the primitive genn-cells and entered into the constitution of the pseudovarium. Leuckart could distinguish the single nucleus of the primitive pole-cell when there were only eight to ten nuclei in the pseudovum.

A year later Metschnikoff (1866) gave a more detailed account of the history of the pole-cells in Simula sp. and Miastor. In Simula four to 'five pole-cells were present at the posterior end of the egg, each containing a nucleus and very fine yolk-granules. In Miastor the genesis of the pole-cells was traced more accurately than in Simula. Eggs were found containing only two nuclei which were supposed to result from the division of the germinal vesicle. These nuclei continued to give rise to others by division until twelve to fifteen were produced, one of which, lying at the pointed pole of the pseudovum, became surrounded by a thick, dark yolk mass and with it separated as a distinct membraneless cell, the first pole-cell. This then divided into two and later into four cells. These four then separated into two groups of two cells each and were recognized as the primitive reproductive organs lying in their definite positions. The two large pole-cells of each gTOup were already divided and enclosed in an epithelial layer of embryonic cells at the time of hatching.

Grimm (18Y0) described in the parthenogenetic eggs of a species of Chiro'n omits, a membraneless cell which divided into two, then

238 liobert Wilhelm Hegner.

four pol('-e(^]ls. He recorded tins interesting variation. "Manchnial ahei- theilt sicli der Kern der ersten Polzelle nocli in der Schieht des IJikUingsdottcrs liegend, so dass in dem Polraume auf einmal zwei Polzellen erscheinen." The division of these pole cells into two groups, each of which became surrounded by embryonic cells and constituttd the germ-glands, confirmed Metschnikoff's (188G) account.

According to Packard (1872) the eggs of Pulex canis, one or two hours after deposition, contained "four distinct polar cells apparently immersed in protoplasm, and a small indistinct one in addition." They were distinctly nucleated and held in place by the vitelline membrane. Thirty hours later the blastoderm was fully formed and "Soon after this the polar cells break down and disappear."

In another flea, Pulex fells, Balbiani (1875) found that the "Anlage" of the reproductive organs was already visible after the formation of the embryonic envelopes. It was a small naked mass of clear cells lying in the posterior inner side of the abdomen.

In a later work Weismann (1882) described events in the polecell development of Chironoruiis sp. which diifered from those found in C. nirjro-viridis in 1863. In Cliirouonws sp. the primitive polecell nucleus was thought to have probably originated from elements of the cleavage nucleus in the yolk nuiss and migrated to the surface of the egg; there it entered a protoplasmic process of the "Keimhautblastem" together with a number of yolk-granules which flowed in with it. This nucleus often divided, as Grimm (1870) had previously recorded, before the protrusion was entirely cut off from the egg, resulting in two pole-cells. A second bud arose in the same place as the first and passed through a similar process of separation and division. Thus four cells were produced; these increased by division to eight, and finally to twelve, which lay on the surface of the posterior pole. They did not become indistinguishable from the blastoderm-cells, as was described for Chiivnomus 7iigro-viridis, but "spater wenn sich die Keimhaut gebildet hat, lagern sie sich deren Oberfliiche loeker auf, oft zu zwei Gruppen formirt." After the germ-band was formed two to four similar cells were found in many eggs outside of the embryonic membrane, but their derivation from pole-cells could not be determined.

Germ-Cells in Clirysoinelid Beetles. 239

Weismann described in one egg of Chironomus sp. a nucleated protrusion at the anterior end Avliicli was capable of amoeboid movements and probably migrated upon the surface and was lost to view. In another case no nucleus was visible, but the anterior ball of protoplasm divided into eight bodies of different sizes, which after fifteen minutes dissolved. These were thought to be polar bodies, but might easily have been mistaken for pole-cells.

The pole-cells were accurately traced to the definitive germ-glands by Balbiani (1882, 1885) in Chivonoinns. One pole-cell usually appeared first; but, as previously observed by Grimm (1870) and Weismann (1882), sometimes two were protruded simultaneously. These two divided to form four and then eight pole-cells. Snmll non-nucleated protoplasmic globules were pushed ont of the egg at both anterior and posterior ends, disintegrating later into a mass of granules in the polar cavities. Balbiani claimed that Robin (1862) and Weismann (1863), both of whom recorded twelve or more polecells, were deceived by these globules, as there should have been only eight pole-cells. These droplets would also explain the protrusion discovered by Weismann (1882) at the anterior end of the egg. Balbiani, however, did not find the anterior nucle:ited globides which Weismann considered polar bodies. He agreed with previous workers that the pole-cells did not arise by free formatiou during or after germination (Robin, 1862, Weismann, 1863), l)ut were derivatives of the cleavage nucleus (Leuckart, 1865, Metschnikoff, 1866, Grimm, 1870). After the first division of the segmentation nucleus the anterior daughter nucleus ])rol)ably gave rise to the blastodermic nuclei of that region, while the posterior furnished the two pole-cell nuclei and those of the posterior blastoderm-cells. After the eight pole-cells were formed, an elongation of the vitcllus forced the group against the egg membrane causing a blastodermic depression.

In the next stage the pole-cells were found inside of the blastoderm, but Balbiani did not determine whether they passed through it, or a clear space was left in the blastoderm for their entrance. They now consisted of two separate nmssc'^, each containing two quadrinucleatcd cells. This wa< su]iposed to have come about in the following manner. The eight original pole-cells fused in pairs,

240 Robert Wilhelm Hegner.

producing four binucleated cells ; then the nuclei in these four cells each divided producing four quadrinuclcated cells, two of which then moved to either side of the body. No further change took place within the two germ-glands until the time of hatching. Their position was altered by the contraction of the ventral plate and, in the young larva, they lay in the ninth abdominal segment level with the union of the mid- with the hind-intestine. Each germ-gland now acquired an epithelium of flattened cells. The testes could, at the end of embryonic life, be distinguished by their narrowness, attenuated ends, and many celled constitution, from the ovary, which was broad, obtuse, and composed of only a few large cells. One of ]>albiani's conclusions was that "les giandes genitales des deux sexes out une origine absolument identique, naissant de la meme substance et au meme point de I'ocuf."

Cliironomus was also studied by Jaworowski (1882). This author Avas led to believe that the germ-glands of insects developed from a single mother cell, which gave rise by division to daughter cells, these in turn became mother cells and produced daughter cells. In this way the Kammern," "Endfaden" and "Ausfiihnmgsgang" were all supposed to have arisen.

Three papers record the results of Schneider's (1885) observations "iiber die Anlage der Geschlechtsorgane der Insecten." Although his work was done chiefly on Chironom/ns plumosus, C plumicornis, and a viviparous Cecidomyian, nevertheless he has made the following unique generalization : "Die erste Anlage der Geschlechtsorgane der Insecten besteht, soweit ich dicselbe verfolgt habe, in einer Muskelfaser, welche sich von einem Fliigelmuskel abzweigt. Sie sitzt also vorn und hinten an der Hypodermis. In der Mitte derselben entsteht eine Anhiiufung von Iverncn durch Avelche die Muskelfaser erst spindelformig, dann eiformig aufschwillt. Wir wollen sie als die Geschlechtsanlage bezeichnen."

Kowalevsky (1886) observed in Musca that the division of the cleavage nucleus into two took place near the pointed end of the Q^^. The nuclei produced by these two reached the posterior end first and formed pole-cells which entered the cavity between the egg and the yolk membrane. The further history of these cells was not followed.

Germ-Cells in Chrysomelid Beetles. 241

Voeltzkow (1880) stated that in Musca the pole-cells pressed the blastoderm-cells inward forming a wedge which projected into the yolk. Blastoderm-cells separated from this wedge, wandered into the interior, and became the so-called yolk-nuclei. He further stated that "die Polzellen wandern mit dem Keimstrcifen auf die Dorsalseite und in den Enddarm hinein."

In his work on Calliphora, Graber (1889) described the polecells, but not until the blastoderm had formed. They were found outside of the blastoderm-cells and were smaller than the latter, .and stained more intensely. "Ihre Zahl ist eine ziemlich constante und betragi ca 25-35." They were figured in a cross section (Taf. VII, Fig. 91) where they occurred in the amniotic cavity. Graber seldom saw them in Calliphora and never observed them in Lucilia.

The section method was used by Bitter (1890) in studying the development of the germ-glands in Clii7'onomus. He found that the first pole-cell differentiated at the posterior end of the egg when there were a large number of nuclei scattered about in the yolk. A second pole-cell was protruded close behind the first. Each carried out of the egg part of a flat mass of protoplasmic granules, the "Keimwulst," which, in section, formed a wreath around the nucleus. The two original pole-cells increased by division to four and then to eight. Two divisions of each pole-cell nucleus now occurred, resulting in eight quadrinucleated cells ; these seemed to move of their own accord through the blastoderm which closed after them. They now lay at the posterior end of the germ-band from whence they were possibly moved anteriorly by the growing forward of the entomesoderm. The mass of pole-cells finally divided into two groups w^hich occupied a position on either side of and dorsal to the hind-intestine; there they remained until after the larva hatched, when they became the definitive sex-organs. A more detailed account of Bitter's results will be found in Part IV on the pole-disc.

The germ-glands were found by Pratt (1893) in Mclopliagus ovinus during the entire larval period. They were small paired structures lying on either side of the abdomen embedded in the fat-body.

Lowne (1890-95) did not find the pole-cells in the Blow-fly,

242 Robert AVilhelm Ilejnicr.


probably, because of their small size, and similar appearance to other embryonic cells. In a 1 cm. larva he described as rudimentary germ-glands two pairs of encapsulated groups of small embryonic cells, situated in the fifth abdcmiinal segment embedded in the fatbodies on either side of, and dorsal to, the alimentary canal." The pole-cells were considered by Lowne as the segmentation spheres of the vegetative pole of the egg."

Escherich (1900) began his study of the embryonic development of Musca vomitoria and Lucilia cccsar after the formation of the blastoderm. He traced the history of the pole-cells from this time, until the germ layers were completely separated. The pole-cells were first discovered as a group lying in a posterior enlargement of the ventral groove. From here they were carried around upon the dorsal side by the growth of the "Mittelplatte." The pole-cells migrated from here into the embryo through a "Pokellencanal ;" they were last observed in the lumen of the '^'hinterer Entodermkeim" which Avas connected with the inner end of the proctodeal cavity.

Lecaillon (1900) has made the following general statement concerning the origin of the germ-cells in Culex pipiens. "L'etude du developpement embryonnaire des insectes montre que, chez ces animaux, les cellules sexuelles, les (jonadcs, se sei)arent de tres bonne lieure des cellules somatiques et seuddent ctre toujours de nature ectodermique. Elles se groupent bientot en deux petites masses pleines s'entourant chacune d'une enveloppe fonnee de cellules mesodermique aplaties. Souvent ces deux petites masses ne se modifient plus, an moins dans leur structure intime, et restent telles quelles jusqu' a la fin du developpement embryonnaire; ce sont les rudiments ou ebauches des organes genitaux. . . Pendant toute la duree de la vie larvaire, les organes genitaux demeurent a I'etat d'ebauche. Celle-ci consiste en deux petits massifs cellulaires situes dans la sixicme anneau abdominal."

The most recent and best contriljution to the genesis of the polecells of Diptera is that of Woack (1901). He found a dark granidated layer Dotterplatte" at the posterior end of the q^^ of CalUphora erylhroccphala similar to that discovered by Ritter (1890) in Cliironomns. Each pole-cell took part of this layer of granules

Germ-Colls in Chrysomelid Beetles. 243

with it as it passed through the "Keirahautblastem." This was the first cell. differentiation. At this time there were fifteen to twenty pole-cells present, and not one to twelve, as Weismann (1863) and others have claimed; these pole-cells divided forming a single layer. This layer became several cells thick and formed the polar mass characteristic of Dipterous eggs at this stage of development. This mass of pole-cells was then passively carried into the dorsal groove of the germ-band where it was connected with the tissue destined to become the mid-intestine as Escherich (1900) had described it in Musca vomHoria. The pole-cells always remained connected with the yolk ; they later began to wander through the entoderm, not by means of a definite canal (Escherich, 1900), but through an indefinite gap. After this migration had taken place, the pole-cells were found lying isolated among the entoderm cells from which they were distinguished by their darker pigmentation and smaller size. Soon, however, these distinguishing features became obliterated and the further history of the pole-cells could not be followed.

3. Hemiptera.

Until recently the Hemiptera have held a position next to the Diptera regarding the early appearance of germ-cells. As we shall see later germ-cells have been found by modern methods of study at a much earlier stage in the Ilymenoptcra and Coleoptera than thus far reported in the Hemiptera.

Huxley (1858) was the first to stud}^ the development of the psendovarium in Aphis. He thought that the reproductive organs arose from the inner layer of the two-layered blastoderm.

Metschnikoff (1860) found in the viviparous Aphid, A pit is rosae, sliorth' after blastoderm formation, a group of cells, "Keimhiigel," projecting into the central yolk mass at the posterior end of the egg. These cells could not be distinguished from those constituting the blastoderm. The anterioi- part of this "Keimhugel" separated from the remainder and became an oval mass, the rudiment of the reproductive organs, Genitalhiigel." This rudiment, which lay within the tail fold, was carried by the latter into the position of the definitive germ-glands. Meanwhile, the nuclei increased in number, the

244 Robert Willielm Hegner.


whole mass divided into horseshoe shaped halves which migrated to either side of the body. No "Genitalhiigel" was found in Aspidiotus nerii, Corixa and Psylla. In the larva of Psylla, however, Metschnikoff described the germ-glands as follows : "Dicht neben den Lappen des secundiiren Dotters beiinden sich jederseits bei den Larven und Imagines von Psylla, die Geschlechtsorgane — ein Umstand, welcher fiir meine Meinung iiber die Rolle des secundiiren Dotters als Fortpflanzungsmaterial zu sprechen scheint."

The development of both the parthenogenetic and the fertilized eggs of the Aphids was studied by Balbiani (18GG-1872). In the eggs of the viviparous Aphids this author (1866) was able to see "un noyau granuleux fort pale dans la vesicule posterieure, moins nettement dans I'anterieuro, celle-ci presentent done tons les caracteres de veritables cellules. Ce sont ces vesicules ou ces cellules qui vont etre I'origine des elements gencrateurs males et femelles du futur animal, . . ." In the developing winter egg the first germ-cells were found by Balbiani (1869-1872) at a later stage. They formed an oval structure which lay in the median line of the body and soon divided lengthwise into halves.

Witlaczil (1884), in viviparous x\phids, also recorded a single primitive germ-cell which separated from the inner surface of the blastoderm at the posterior end of the egg. This single cell grew rapidly, producing by division a group of round clear cells each containing a large nucleus. This mass of cells was attached to the tail-fold, and moved with this until it reached a position in the posterior dorsal region of the body. During the revolution of the embryo, the rudiment of the germ-glands divided, half going to either side of the alxlomen.

The origin of the germ-cells of viviparous Aphids was investigated by Will (1888). This author found that a thickening took place in the lateral wall of the blastoderm. "Bald aber sieht man die obersten Zellen der verdickten Cylinderseite sich in besonderer Weise differenziren ; sie wachsen sehr schnell zu ansehnlicher Grosse heran, nchmen polyedrische Gestalt an und zeichnen sich durch eine geringere Tinctionsfahigkeit ihres Plasmaleibes sowie eine andre Beschaffenheit des Kernes aus. Durch rcge Theilung vermehren sie

Germ-Cells in Chrysomclid Beetles. 245

sich selir lebliaft uiid stellen bald einen rundlichen Zellenhaufen, die Geschlechtsanlage, dar, welcbe in dieser Gestalt wahrend der nachsten Entwicklungsstadien verharrt.

"Die Gesclileclitszellen liegen aiif der Grenze zwiscben dem Entoderm, dem Ectoderm der Baucbplatte imd dem gleicb sich bildenden Mesoderm. Ueber ibre Zugehorigkeit zii einem der drei Keimblatter liisst sicb streiten; mir geniigt es vollkommen, zu constatiren, dass wir in ibnen indifferente Gebilde vor uns habcn, die gerade dort entsteben, wo die drei Keimbliitter an einander stossen."

4. Hymenoptera.

The Hymenoptera are represented in tbe literatnre of insect embryology by numerous papers chiefly on tbe bee. With the exception of the male of Apis (Petrunkewitsch, 1901) tbe germ-cells have not been traced back to as early a stage as in several other orders of insects.

Ganin (1869) was the first to investigate the germ-glands of the Hymenoptera. In Platygaster the rudiments of tbe germ-glands were described at the end of the first larval instar as separate thickenings on either side of the posterior end of tbe germ-band near the hindintestine ; between them arose a temporary unpaired elevation, "Geschlecbtshugel," which disappeared during the second larval instar. In another Hymenopteron Polynema, Ganin found that tbe germglands developed from tbe undifferentiated cell mass of tbe tail-fold, and lay in the cavities of the last abdominal segments, where they remained during the larval period.

Biitschli (1870), in his work on the bee, described in a well developed embryo "niebt weit von den Rlickenrandern der Leibeswandung jederseits eine durch ungcfiihr 5 Segmente sich erstreckende langlicbe Zcllenmasse aus dicht gedriingten rundlichen mit grossen Kernen ausgestatteten Zellen bestehend," which be considered tbe iiidiments of the germ-glands. Biitschli distinguished two layers in tbe germband of tbe bee, from the inner one of which, the entomesoderm, the primitive germ-cells Avere supposed to be derived.

Uljanin (1872), according to Brandt (1878), found in tbe larva

246 Robert Wilhelm licgner.

of the 1)0(', two kidney-shaped bodies lying on either side of the dorsal vessel ; he considered these to be the female sexual organs.

In several species of Hymenoptera Dohrn (1876) "fand in jungen Larven die Anlagen der Ovarien als einen breiten birnformigen Korper, dessen breite Flache in acht fingerformige Fortsiitze ansgezogen Avar, deren vier oben nnd vier darnnter liegen."

Ayers (1883) studied Teleas, a parasite in the egg of Oecantlius niveus. Here the germ-cells were budded off from the dorsal side of a posterior enlargement of the nerve cord which curved upward around the end of the mesenteron. A varying number of cells (two to six) were thus produced embedded in homogeneous protoplasm. They appear in sections of hardened specimens as though formed endogenously within the substance of the still persisting mother cells. . . These are shortly separated from the nervous cord, but are connected to the blind end of the mesenteron by protoplasmic filaments, usually one to each mother cell."

The embryonic germ-glands of the bee were described by Grassi (1884) as two solid strands, extending from the fourth to the eighth abdominal segment. "Sono formazione mesodermica ; nascono press' a poco ai confini tra il foglietto superficiale e il foglietto profondo del mesoderma. . . ."

The rudiments of the germ-glands were found by C^arriere (1890) in Clialicodoma nivrwria at about the time when the first pair of Malpighian tubules appeared. They lay near the dorsal wall of the "Urhohle" in the fifth and sixth abdominal segments.

Bugnion (1891) studied the postembryonic development of Encyrfiis fuscicoUis. The rudiments of the reproductive organs were found in the middle of larval life; they were oval structures lying on either side of the hind-intestine. During the second half of larval life the sexes could be distinguished ; the testis remained small and round, while the ovaries became oval and hirger.

The "Anlage" of the germ-glands were found by Kulagin (1897) in the parasitic Ilymenopteron, Platygaster lierrickii, lying near the hind-intestine of an embryo in which the mesodermal somites were forming. This rudiment was a paired structure composed of cells similar to those of the mesentoderm, tlie only difference being their

Germ-Colls in Chrvsomelid Beetles. 247

tendency to stain more intensely. Dafiir spricht erstens die friihe Absonderung der Geschlechtszellen, schon zu einer Zeit, wo das Meso- und Entoderm nicht scliarf getrennt ist, nnd ferner die sebr grosse Aolmlielikeit bei den Zellelementen in den ersten Stadien ihrer Entstebnng."

According to Carriere and Burger (1897) tbe primitive germcells of Ch-allcodoma muraria were probably derived from cells of tbe mesodermal layer shortly after its appearance. A few cells in the dorsal wall of the somites of the third, fourth and fifth abdominal segments on either side of the body proliferated to form egg-shaped bodies. In further growth these germ-cells decreased in size as a result of multiplication. Later, they wandered from the third and fourth segments into the fifrh, where they lay behind one another in their original succession.

In an endeavor to test the ^'Dzierzon theory," that the eggs which produce drone bees are normally unfertilized, Petrunkewitsch (190103) discovered some unusual maturation divisions. In "drone eggs" the first polar body passed through an equatorial division, each of its daughter nuclei containing one-half of the somatic number of chromosomes. The inner one of these daughter nuclei fused with the second polar body, which also contained one-half of the somatic number of chromosomes ; the resultant nucleus with sixteen chromosomes, the "Richtungscopulationskern" passed through three divisions giving rise to eight "doppelkernige Zellen." After the blastoderm was completed, the products of these eight cells were found in the middle line near the dorsal surface of the egg, where the formation of the amnion had already begun ; the nuclei of these cells were small, and lay embedded in dark staining cytoplasm. Later they were found just beneath the dorsal surface near the point of union of the amnion with the head-fold of the embryonic rudiment. They were next discovered Ix^tween the epithelium of the midintestine and the ectoderm ; from here they migrated into the coelomic cavities, and finally, at the time of hatching, formed a "welleiiartigen" strand, the germ-gland, extending through the third, fourth, fifth and sixth abdominal segments. The fertilized eggs of the bee were also examined by Petrunkewitsch, but no "Richtungsoopula

248 Robert Wilhelm Ilegner.

tionskcrn" was present. In these eggs "entstehen die Genitaldriisen aus Mesodennzellen, die in die Mesodermrohren von der Banchseite hereindringen."

5. Orthoptera.

Many papers have appeared contributing to onr knowledge of the germ-cells of the Orthoptera. Unfortunately, a large number of them are based on a study of one species, Blatta germanica, which is not favorable for this particular phase of embryological research.

We owe the first account of the primitive germ-cells of the Orthoptera to Ayers (1883). He found the rudiments of the germglands in Oecantlius niveus at a late embryonic stage after revolution of the embryo had taken place. "They are first seen as two irregular groups of amoeboid cells, belonging to the splanchnic layer of the mesoderm on either side of the dorsal vessel." These groups of cells were transformed into ovaries in their primitive position.

Nusbaum (1886) considered the reproductive organs of Periplaneta orienialis of mesodermal origin.

Heymons (1890-91) made a detailed study of the origin and development of the germ-glands of Blatta germanica. He found in this insect a segmental origin of the germ-cells. They w^ere identified as large cells, in the second to the seventh abdominal segments, which arose from the splanchnic layer of the mesoderm; new genital cells were continually added. Later a migration of the germ-cells took place into the coelomic cavities, and afterward between the cells of the dorsal walls of the coelomic sacs. Here a continuous strand of germ-cells was formed on either side of the body ; these were situated in the dorsal wall of the primitive somites extending from the second into the eighth abdominal segment. Undifferentiated mesoderm cells were added to these strands from the dorsal wall of the coelomic sacs, to form the epithelium of the germ-glands. The strands now shortened, and, by the lateral pushing of the germ-band around the yolk, were carried to the dorsal side of the egg where they continued their growth.

Heymons (1890) claimed to have discovered an hermaphroditic condition in the male genital organs of Blatta {Phyllodromia) . "Es geht hieraus unzweifelhaft hervor, dass jencr Theil der Genitalanlage

Germ-Cells in Chrysomelid Beetles. 249

beim Miinnchen, welclier nicht mit zur Bildung der Hodenfollikel verbrauclit wird, die Aulage zu einer weiblichen Genitaldriise darstellt." Other workers have not sustained Ileymon's interpretation.

Several papers on the embryology of Blatta (^Phyllodromia) germanica were published by Cholodkovsky (1890-91). This author differed in some points from Heymons (1890-91). He found the primitive germ-cells always lying in the dorsal wall of the coelomic cavities pre-eminently if not exclusively in the fifth and sixth abdominal segments. The number of germ-cells increased either by division or by the addition of new cells which penetrated into the coelom. As the embryo grew dorsalward around the yolk, the germ-glands were carried to a point on either side of and dorsal to the midintestine. Cholodkovsky did not agi-ee with Heymons that the germcells differentiated from mesoderm-cells, but held that they probably were derived from yolk-cells.

Stenobothrus variabilis was studied by Graber (1891). The first distinct rudiments of the gefm-giands were found as two large faintly stained cells differentiated from the visceral layer of the dorsal "Mesoblastdivertikel." At the end of the embryonic period the sexual organs appeared as two strands lying close to one another on the dorsal side of the posterior region of the mid-intestine.

The germ-glands of Mantis rcligiosa seemed to Graber delayed in their development as compared with those of Stenobothrus, for, in the former, they still retained their lateral position at the end of embryonic life.

Wheeler's (1893) paper on Xipliidium ensiferum and other Orthoptera contains a short account of the development of the germglands. In the above named species the first sign of the primitive germ-cells was not discovered until the somites were established as distinct sacs. The germ-cells at this time lay in the splanchnic walls of the somites of the first to the sixth abdominal segments ; one group was found in the tenth abdominal segment. They were larger and paler than the mesoderm-cells and were thought to have been derived from the latter. A cluster of cells was formed by the mitotic division of these primary germ-cells. The somites that bore germ-cells each sent out a solid diverticulum which connected with

250 Robert, Wilhelm Ilegner.

the antcecdeiit somite, thus })n)dncing a continuous strand. The hexanietanieric arrangement of the germ-cells disappeared as this strand shortened to form the ovary or testis. Wheeler noted the presence of germ-cells in the first abdominal segment of Blatta germanica in opposition to Ileymon's statement that *'Im ersten Abdominalsegment treten niemals Genitalzellen auf."

Ileymons' earlier papers were supplemented by a re-examination (1895) of Blatta {Phyllodronila) germanica and a clear account of the develoj)ment of other Orthoptera, Periplaneta orientalis, Gryllus caynpestris, Grylliis domestica and Gryllotalpa vulgaris.

In Blaita he was able to trace the germ-cells back to an earlier stage than recorded in his former paper (1891). When the posterior amniotic fold arose, a groove, ^'Geschlechtsgrube," appeared in the posterior end of the germ-band. Many cells became detached from the bottom of this groove and wandered into the interior; they moved singly and "sicli teils zwischen den Mesodermzellen, teils liber sie hinweg nacli vorn bewegen." They assumed the character of the germ-cells only when they arrived at the visceral walls of the somites where the}' behaved just as previously stated (Ileymons, 1891).

In Periplaneta a Geschlechtsgrube" also appeared similar to that found in Blatta; cells separated from it and migrated by amoeboid movements toward the anterior abdominal segments where they arranged themselves intersegmentally forming wedge-shaped accumulations between the crelomic sacs. Contrary to the condition in Blatta, these could be distinguished as germ-cells shortly after they became detached from the ectoderm. Later these germ-cells separated to form two strands lying on either side of the body in the visceral walls of the second to the seventh abdominal segments ; they acquired an epithelial layer derived from mesoderm-cells.

A "Geschlechtsgrube" was found by Ileymons (1895) in both Gryllus catnpestris and G. doniesticus, and the germ-cells arose in a manner similar to that in the Orthoptera previously described. These two species differed only in the fact that the germ-cells differentiated earlier in the former than in the latter. A long oval structure was produced by the accumulation of the primitive germ

Germ-Cells in Chrysomelid Beetles, 251

cells ; this body divided during the segmentation of the germ-band, one half going to either side, where it lay in the dorsal region of the second and third abdominal segiiients. Here the germ-gland was enclosed in an epithelium of mesoderm-cells.

GryUotalpa vidians was not so thoroughly studied as the other species. Heymons, in this Orthopteron, found "nur sehr flache Einstiilpung. Von dem Boden der Letzteren losen sicli Zellen los und wandern ein. Ich bin geneigt, diese Zellen als Gesehlechtszellen anzusehen, obwohl sie das Aussehen von Mesodermzellen haben und ich ihr weiteres Schicksal nicht verfolgt halx^."

6. Coleopiera.

The Coleoptera are represented in the literature on the embryology of insects by only a few papers ; of these eight contain fragmentary accounts of the origin and early development of the germ-glands.

Heider (1889) found that in Hydrophilus piceus the germ-glands originated from the inner wall of the primitive abdominal segments on either side of the body. They arose as solid outgrowths from that part of the wall of the somites which lay between the place of origin of the Fettkorperband" and the splanchnic layer of the mesoderm.

The germ-glands of Leptinotarsa {Diwypliora) decemlineata were described by "Wheeler (1889) as follows: ^'These organs originate as two elongated thickenings of splanchnic mesoderm, one on each side projecting into the body cavity. Later they become rounded and are attached ])y a thin band of splanchnic mesoderm only." Wheeler found several cells in the posterior anmiotic cavity of an embryo of Leptinotarsa which he concluded might be comparable to the pole-cells of Diptera. The origin and fate of these cells was not determined.

In Melolontha vulgaris, the sexual organs were found by Yoeltzkow, (1889) "zu der Zeit, wo die Darmwulste sich am Bauch zu schliessen beginnen und die Leibeshohle sich fertig gebildet hat. Sie werden vom Mesoderm aus gebildet und liegen am hinteren Ende des Eies als ein Paar birntThnnige Gebilde, umgebcn von einer starken, ringformigen Zellenmasse mit grossen Kernen. . . Spater riicken

252 Robert Wilhclm ITegner.

sio ctwas iiacli dem Riicken binaiif unci liegen rechts und links vom Riickengefass."

Three species of beetles, Ilydropliilus piceus, Melolontha vulgaris and Lina tremulw received brief mention by Graber 0891). In Hydrophilus the two germ-glands were found lying near each other on the dorsal w^all of the intestine, close to the proctodeum. In Melolontha "Die Gonaden erscheinen bier sehr frlihzeitig als mit dem Visceralblatt verbundene gestielte Korper, an denen man wieder ein Zellepithel und mchrere grossere und kleinere Inhaltszellen unterscheiden kann." In Lina the reproductive organs were discovered anterior to the proctodeum in connection with the "Darmfaserblatt." They appeared very similar to the corresponding organs described by Wheeler (1889) in Leptinotarsa.

In a Russian paper, ISTusbaum (1891) has figured at the posterior pole of the egg of the oil beetle, Meloe proscarahcvns, a wedge-shaped structure designated as an "accumulatio plasmatis et nucleorum in posteriore polo ovi." This nucleated mass occupied the position of, and is very similar in appearance to, the group of pole-cells and pseudoblastodermic nuclei shown in Fig. 25 ; in this species there probably occurred an early development of the germ-cells, such as has been found in Chrysomelid beetles.

The embryological development of the following species of Chrysomelidce was studied by Lecaillon (1898) ; Clytra Iceviuscula, Gasirophysa raphani, Clwysomela menthastri, Lina popidi, L. fremiilce Agelastica alni. In Clytra, the principal form examined, Lecaillon found the first nuclei which arrived at the posterior pole of the egg to become the primitive germ-cells ; these could be distinguished from neighboring cells by their large size, larger nuclei, and darker cytoplasm. The germ-cell nuclei did not stop when they reached the surface of the egg, but passed outside and became separated from it; their number increased "pen a pen par suite de I'arrivee de nouvelles cellules peripheriques et aussi sans doute de la division des premieres cellules detachees du pole de I'oeuf." The germ-cell? then started to re-enter the egg, retarding, by this migration, the formation of the blastoderm at this point. 'Tinalement, le blastoderme achcve de se former au pole posterieur de Tauf, et alors

Germ-Cells in Chrysomelid Beetles, 253

les cellules sexuelles se trouveut groupees . . . entre le vitellus el" I'enveloppe blastodermiqiie." At the end of segmentation, the germ-cells were found pressed against the inner surface of the germband, just in front of the posterior end of the egg; here they remained during the formation of the mesoderm. After the mesodermal somites were completed, the germ-cells penetrated into them, and formed two cylindrical groups, the germ-glands. These were then carried by the lateral growth of the embryo to a point near the median dorsal line.

The above described processes also took place in Chrysome-la menthastvi, Lina populi and L. tremulw. The primitive germ-cells of Gastrophysa arose as in Clytra, but many of them remained outside of the egg and w^ere later found in the posterior amniotic cavity, "dans le sillon profond qui se trouve sur le milieu de sa parol interne. Avant la fermeture du sillon, les cellules y penetrant et scs trouvent ensuite en dedans de la couche ectodermique." N^o observations were made by Lecaillon upon the precocious appearance of the germ-oells in Agelastica alni.

Several species of Chrysomelid beetles were studied by Friederichs (1906). This author discovered that the cleavage nuclei in Donacia crassipes reached the posterior later than the anterior end of the egg ; the reverse is the rule in species of allied genera. After the blastoderm was formed "an der Ventralseite unmittelbar seitlich vor dem Pol, findet eine besonders lebhafte Zellvermehnmg statt, so dass einzelne Zellen aus dem Blastodermverband heraus und ins Innere gedrang-t werden." These, the primitive germ-cells, were not very different in Donacia from blastoderm-oells, but in Timarcha nicceends and Chrysomela marg'mata they were distingiiished by the larger size and darker color of their nuclei. The blastoderm (Ectoderm) became interrupted at the point of origin of the germ-cells, an invagination being found similar to the "Geschlechtsgrube" of Orthoptera (Heymons, 1895). The germ-cells remained just inside of this groove; by the lengthening of the embryonic rudiment they were carried to a point near the mid-dorsal region of the egg. Here they were found at the end of the tail-fold, lying between the ectoderm and the volk. The germ-cells, as well as the other cells of the embryo,

254 Robert Wilhelm Hefner.


gave off "Paracytoide" Avhich helped dissolve the yolk. These Paracytoide" arose either from degenerated nuclei or from "Kernzerlegimg" and contained "keine Chromosomcn, sondern nur Trophachromatin (Chromidialkerne)".

The most recent contribution to the development of the germglands of the Coleoptera is that of Saling (1907). This paper deals exclusively with the origin and growth of the reproductive organs of Tenebrio molitor. Saling did not find in this species such a precocious differentiation of germ-cells as Lecaillon (1898) recorded for Chrysomelid beetles, but says: "Dagegen halte ich fiir wahrscheinlich, dass ihre Loslosung vom Ectoderm am hinteren Keimstreifende erfolgt, sobald sich die hintere Amnionfalte erhebt und die Mesodermbildung im Gauge ist. Beim Vorvvartsdringen der sich segmental anordnenden Mesodermmasse schiebt sich auch die noch unpaare Genitalanlage weiter nach vorn und gelangt vor Ausbildung der Ursegmente an die Grenze des sechsten und siebenten Abdominalsegments. Durch eine Teilung in lateraler Richtung wird sie paarig und tritt mit den inzwischen ausgebildeten Colomsacken des siebenten Abdominalscgments in Verbindung. Erst von diesem Zeitpunkt an ist die Genitalanlage bei Tenebrio molitor mit Sicherheit zu erkennen." The germ-cells penetrated through the median wall of the abdominal segments to the ccelomic cavities gathering a mesodermal epithelium during this migration. Sex-differentiation took place shortly before the end of the embryonic period.

7. Neuroptcra. The origin of the germ-glands in the Odonata and Ephemerida is still unknown. Heymons (1896) was unable to find the germglands in the embryos of the dragon-fly, but in the larva discovered them lying on either side of the intestine. They were spindle-shaped and composed of only a few cells. It was also impossible to find the germ-glands of Ephermera during embryonic life. Heymons concluded dass bei den Odonaten und Ephemeriden die Differenzirung der Geschlechtsdriisen nicht beim Embryo, sondern erst bei der Larve sich abspielt."

Genn-CV'lls in Chrysomclid Beetles. 255

8. Dermaptera. The primitive germ-cells were identified by Heymons (1895) in Forficula auricidaria soon after the blastoderm was completed, forming- a group at the posterior pole of the egg. At this time they could not be distinguished from the blastoderm-cells, but soon their nuclei became larger and clearer. The germ-cells increased rapidly by division and formed a spherical Ixidy, the genital rudiment. Paracytcn" wore abundant near the germ-cells, and Audi einzelne Genitalzellen pflegen iiicht selten zu degeneriren, und zwar unter denselben Erscheinungen, die wir an den Paracyten kennen gelemt haben." The genital rudiment was pushed anteriorly near the dorsal surface of the body, l)y the lengthening of the germ-band, AVlien the primitive seg-ments a})peared, the germ-cells, which lay in the tenth to the eleventh segments, were, by the bending of the posterior end of the body, forced into the ninth segment. They now separated from one another and migrated anteriorly by means of amoeboid movements until they reached the sixth and seventh abdominal segments. Sometimes a few germ-cells were left behind in segments eight, nine, ten, or eleven. Now the germ-cells separated, half going to either side of the embryo, and moved anteriorly into the third to the seventh abdominal segments. ]\[ost of the germ-cells of the male remained in seg-ments five, six and seven ; those of the female were distributed approximately uniformly through segments three to seven.

9. Altera.

Heymons (1897) has given a clear account of the primitive germcells in a Thysanuran, Lepisma saccliarina. In this insect a knoblike projection was observed at the hinder end of the germ-band; this projection was composed of cells with large nuclei containing less chromatin than the nuclei of the mesoderm-cells, which had also begun to appear. These larger nuclei were interpreted as germcells and arose from the ectoderm. The primitive germ-cells migrated just as they were found to do in Orthoptora (Heymons, 1895), "Stets gelangen die Geschlechtszellen an die dorsalen Ursegmentwandungen, dringen in dieselben ein und bilden zusammeu mit den

256 Robert Wilhelm Hegner.

Mesodermzellen der letzteren die Genitalfollikel." A strand of cells was fonned on either side of the body and from each, in the female, five pairs of follicles arose and were distributed in segmental order from the second to the sixth abdominal segment. In the male, double pairs of follicles occurred in the fourth to the sixth abdominal segments. There were thus produced twelve Hodenfollikel" and ten egg-tubes.

Verj little attention has been directed to the early development of the germ-glands in the Collembola^ but several embryologists have, however, made observations on the later stages of these organs.

Claypole (1898) described two methods of origin of the germcells in Anurida ^naritima. In the first case a germ-cell was found lying in the cavity of the mesoblastic somite of the second abdominal segment ; this gave rise to a mass of cells, the germ-gland, situated between the splanchnic and somatic layers of the mesoderm. Later, the germ-gland appeared to break through the mesoderm and come in contact with the yolk. The ovaries which developed in this way were found to contain many yolk globules lying among the germ-cells.

In the second case, Claypole states that a single germ-cell passed out from the wall of the mesoblastic somite into the yolk ; it produced an irregular mass of cells lying partly in the mesoderm and partly in the yolk. The cells of this group migrated inward becoming scattered among the yolk-globules. The next period in the history of these cells was not found. The final stage found by this author represented the germ-gland of the male ; it was an oblong structure directly connected with a large irregular sac of yolk.

The ovaries of ten species of Collembola were studied by Lecaillon (1901). In Sira nigromaculata, just after hatching, the female sexorgans were described as "deux petites masses ovoides placees dans la cavite generale du corps, a pen pres a egale distance de I'extremite anterieure et de I'extremite posterieure de 1' abdomen." They were situated ventrally between the third and fourth abdominal segments. The germ-glands of Tomocerus plumheus and Templetonia nitida were found to occupy a position similar to that described above. In Templetonia, however, "les dimensions de la chambre gonadiale surpassent notablement celles du meme organe chez les deux cspcces precedentes."

Germ-Cells in Chrysomelid Beetles. 257

III. Observations. 1. The Pole Disc.

A disc-shaped mass of dark staining granules is present at the posterior end of the freshly laid eggs of both Calligrapha and Leptinotarsa; these granules lie suspended in the inner stratum of the "Keimhautblastcm." This layer of granules, which I shall call the pole-disc, plays one of the most important roles in the genesis of the pole-cells ; on this account I shall in this place describe its early characteristics, leaving its later history to the succeeding chapter.

Unfortunately, material was not at hand with which to trace the origin of this pole-disc, the earliest stage in my preparation (Fig. 2) l>eing the eggs of Leptinotarsa taken from the oviduct just before deposition. At this time the pole-disc is present in the position it occupies throughout the entire course of the early cleavage of the egg. Under low magnification it appears in longitudinal sections as a dark irregular line lying just within the surface at the posterior end of the egg; under high powers, however, it is seen to be granular in structure. In the section figured (Fig. 2) it occupies the innermost portion of the "Keimhautblastem ;" its granules are grouped together in small masses giving the entire pole-disc the appearance of a broken strand. These granules are easily distinguished from the cytoplasm in which they are suspended, by their large size and susceptibility to various stains ; they appear to be arranged around small vacuoles which vary in size in the different preparations examined, irrespective of the age of the egg. Thus the granules in the pole-disc under consideration (Fig. 2) are crowded as closely together as they ever become, while in other eggs taken from the same batch they were widely separated.

Fig. 1 represents the posterior end of an egg of Calligrapha; here we see that the pole-disc occupies about one-eighth of the total area. The central part of the disc is denser than it is in any other region of it except the periphery, where an irregular margin is produced by numerous dark projections. Longitudinal sections of the poledisc (Fig. 3) explain this difference in density, as it is found to be thickest in the center, and to be thrown into irregular folds at

258 Robert Wilhclm Hcgner.

tlu; ends oausing these portions to appear darker when seen in surface view.

The condition exhibited by most of the discs examined is represented in Fig. 3 ; the grannies are not crowded closely together as in the disc described above (Fig. 2), but lie distinct from one another, forming an alveolar-like strnctnre (a network in longitudinal section). Large vacuoles occur near the outer and inner surfaces of the disc, and in some cases yolk-globules come almost in contact with its upper side. Scattered about in the cytoplasm near the margin of the disc, are a number of its granules which have become separated from the main structure.

A third disc (Fig. 4) illustrates another condition which is not unusual, especially in the later cleavage stages of the egg. The granules have apparently lost their alveolar arrangement, now being diffused throughout a greater portion of the Keimhautblastem." Within this disc are several large vacuoles surrounded by regular layers of granules.

The granules of the pole-disc are very susceptible to stains ; in hsematoxylin, thionin and gentian violet a color was obtained as deep as that of the chromatin in either dividing nuclei or those in a resting condition ; they stained in orange G more intensely than the surrounding cytoplasm and almost as deeply as the yolk-globules. Other stains failed to bring out any further variations in I he results.

2. The Genesis of the Pole-Cells.

Before describing the genesis of the pole-cells of Calligrapha multipunctata it seems desirable to give a brief account of the maturation, fertilization and early cleavage of the egg.

Eggs that have just been laid contain polar bodies in various phases of formation ; these are given off into a thickening of the "Keimhautblastem" at a point slightly anterior to the median transverse axis of the egg. Here they remain and lator disintegrate.

The female pronucleus lies in an amoeboid accumulation of cytoplasm among the yolk-globules. It moves inward and conjugates with the male ])ronucleus at a point level with the polar bodies.

Goi-m-Cells ill Clirvsoiiiolid Hoetles. 259

Here the first cleavage divisions take place. A number of the earliest cleavage stages were found (2, 4, 6, 16, etc.) in all of which the majority of the nuclei were nearer the anterior than the posterior pole. This anterior position of the early cleavage nuclei has already been described- for Coleoptera in Hydrophilus (Ileidei', 1889), and in many insects belonging to other orders.

As cleavage progresses a separation of the nuclei into two sections takes place. The nuclei of one group form a more or less regular layer equidistant from the periphery at all points except the posterior end ; here a space wider than elsewhere separates them from the surface of the egg. This layer is composed of preblastodermic nuclei (by nucleus is meant the nucleus plus its accompanying cytoplasm) which move outward, fuse with the "Keimhautblastem" and produce the blastoderm. The nuclei of the other group (vitellophags) remain behind scattered throughout the yolk.

When the preblastodermic nuclei have almost reached the peripheral layer of cytoplasm (Fig. 5) it is possible to distinguish those whose descendants will come in contact with the pole-disc from the neighboring nuclei which will produce ordinary blastoderm-cells. This distinction can be made more easily in a polar surface view (Fig. 12) which shows the entire pole-disc. Such a view discloses eight nuclei lying directly under the central area of dark granules. These nuclei, as we shall show later, divide twice before reaching the periphery of the egg. Some of the nuclei thus produced will, however, pass outside the margin of the disc and take part in blastoderm formation; the others, which will enter this granular area and become the pole-cells, can be traced back to the row of four nuclei which lie in the center of the pole-disc nearest the surface of the egg. At this stage (Fig. 5) all of the nuclei within the egg are similar, the various stains used (see the chapter on methods) failing to bring out any differences in structure. Differentiation takes place only when those nuclei in the posterior region fuse with tlie "Keimhautblastem." Continued division brings the preblastoderm-nuclei into the position shown in Fig. 0, where they again increase in number by mitosis. In the section figured (Fig. 0) all of the nuclei are in the prophases of mitosis, and each of those nearest the pole-disc (Fig. G, a) has its

260 Robert Wilhelm Hegner.

chromatin partially arranged in an equatorial plate. An enlarged \dew of the two nuclei which lie nearest the posterior pole (Fig. 18) shows that each is surrounded by an auKEboid mass of cytoplasm with many fine pseudopodia-like processes extending outward in all directions, finally becoming lost among the yolk-globules. The nuclear membrane of each nucleus has disappeared, but its former position is clearly marked by the difference in density between the cytoplasm and the nuclear sap ; a fusion of these two substances has not yet taken place. 'No nucleolus is visible.

After this division is completed, the daughter nuclei are closer together and nearer the surface of the egg (Fig, 7, a). The two nuclei with their accompanying cytoplasm, which now lie closest to the posterior pole (Fig. 19), have finally come in contact by means of their pseudopodia, with the ^'Keimhautblastem." These two nuclei are in a resting condition; their chromatin is evenly distributed throughout, the chromomeres lying in a linin reticulum singly or in groups of from two to six or more. One small nucleolus is present. All the other nuclei in the egg are similar in appearance at this time, and no differences in size or structure could be distinguished. It is not unusual to find all of the nuclei within the egg in repose at the same time, as mitosis is very rapid, and the subsequent resting period relatively long; thus, although nuclei in different regions are often found to be in different phases of division, nearly all of the sections made from eggs in preblastodermic stages show every nucleus in a resting condition. Each nucleus is in repose at this time (Fig. 19), but the cytoplasm accompanying it is still actively engaged in its migration toward the periphery. The cytoplasm surrounding the nuclei reaches the "Keimhautblastem" and the granular pole-disc simultaneously, the latter at this point occupying the inner portion of the former as already described in the preceding chapter.

Each nucleated mass of cytoplasm that comes within the limits of the pole-disc presses outward a mass of granules equal to the area of its fore-end. The whole disc is thus indented in as many places as there are protoplasmic masses striking it (Fig. 8 and Stage A). Fig. 20 illustrates two stages (a and b) in the early genesis of the pole-cells, and also sliows at the extreme right a third nucleus (c)

Germ-Cells in Chrysonielid Beetles. 261

wliieh lies outside of the pole-disc and is destined to become a part of the blastoderm. The central nucleus of this trio (6) has pushed a part of the pole-disc outward and forced the granules into a cap (a half -moon in section) which extends half-way up its sides. The granules are now not as widely separated from one another as we found them in a previous stage (Fig. 3) ; they have become more densely packed due to the pressure exerted by the migrating polecell nucleus in its effort to break through the "Keimhautblastem" (compare Figs. 4, 18 and 19). The neighboring pole-cell nucleus (Fig. 20, a) is in a somewhat more advanced stage; it shows that the granules covering its outer surface become, in part, pushed away from this region and gradually extend around its sides until they cover all of the surface except the innermost portion. All of the granules of the pole-disc do not adhere to the pole-cells, some being left behind within the remains of the "Keimhautblastem."

A surface view of the posterior end of the egg at this stage shows plainly eight pairs of pole-cell nuclei (Fig. 13) ; an enclosing layer of the dark staining granules is suspended within each of these enabling one to distinguish easily the pole-cell nuclei from the adjacent blastoderm-nuclei. This paired condition of the pole-cell nuclei is accounted for by the fact that since the division of the eight nuclei of the previous generation, the daughter nuclei have not yet separated. In one case where the daughter nuclei have drawn some distance apart from each other (Fig. 13, h) a wide strand of cytoplasm is seen connecting the two. A few of the neighboring blastoderm nuclei, which have passed near the edge of the pole-disc, have also carried with them some of the granules which are seen embedded in their adjacent sides (Fig. 13, a). The nuclei of the blastoderm are slower than the pole-cell nuclei in reaching the surface, and have hardly begun to protrude when the latter have almost, or, in some cases, entirely separated from the egg (Fig. 9). Each pole-cell nucleus is now completely surrounded by a layer of granules more dense at the side than at either end (Fig. 21). After reaching the position last described (Fig. 9) all of the pole-cell nuclei, except in a few cases where one of them has been delayed (Figs. 26 and 22) become entirely separated from the egg, and lie in a single

2G2 Robert Williclm Ilegiier.

layer between the remains of the Keimhautblastem" and the vitelline membrane. They now vary from one another both in the size of the entire cell and in that of the nucleus. The long cytoplasmic processes which were characteristic of the pole-cell nuclei while within the egg have disappeared; they have undoubtedly been retracted until they now form a few blunt projections still suggestive of pseudopodia (Fig. 22, h, c). The peripheral portion of each cell consists of a lightly staining vacuolated layer, which was formerly, before the pole-cell nuclei separated from the egg, the outermost stratum of the Keimhautblastem" (Fig. 20, vac. st.). This layer has spread completely over the surface of the protruded pole-cells, and in consequence of this increase in area covered, has become thinner; its stiiicture, however, is still the same as when it constituted a part of the egg (Fig. 3, vac. st.). This is doubtless due to the granular layer which, by its intervention, impedes the fusion of the vacuolated portion with the denser cytoplasm within the cell.

Just within the outer stratum is the granular layer ; this no longer appears evenly distributed (Fig. 21), but now seems to be massed in certain places and absent elsewhere, as shown in Fig. 23, pdg. A close examination of sections (Fig. 22, jjdg) shows, however, that the granules completely surround the nucleus as before but have accumulated in the regions of the pseudopodia. These acciunulations are often found in the granular layer of other stages and may even be present in the pole-disc before the pole-cells are protruded (see also Ritter, 1890, Taf. XVI, Fig. 3, and Noack, 1901, Taf. II, Fig. 19).

Between the granular layer .and the nucleus is a homogeneous stratum of cytoplasm; this consists of all the protoplasm that surrounded the nucleus before it reached the periphery plus that layer of the 'Tveimhautblastem" in which the granules were suspended. The nuclei of one of these cells (Fig. 22, h) shows a spireme, the other (Fig. 22, c) a later stage in which the spireme has already segmented into a number of chromosomes.

As stated above, it sometimes happens that the pole-cell nuclei do not all reach the "Keindiautblastem" simultaneously; those which are delayed have difficulty in collecting enough cytoplasm for their

Germ-Cells in Clii*ysomelid Beetles. 263

needs since most of the peripheral layer has already been carried away by the nuclei that first reach the surface. One of these delayed nuclei (Fig. 22, a) shows, embedded in its accompanying cytoplasm, a number of small yolk-globules which have not yet been dissolved.

I have already said that eight pairs of pole-cells protrude from the posterior end of the egg and from a single layer there (Fig. 13) ; these I shall speak of as the primary pole-cells. It has also been shown that when these sixteen primary pole-cells have become completely separated from the egg they are in the prophases of mitosis (Fig. 22). These now undergo their first division, giving rise to the secondary pole-cells which immediately divide again. However, before this second division is completed an accurate count of the number of pole-cells is possible as the presence of granules easily distinguishes them from those of the blastoderm. The number of pole-cells ranges from thirty-two to forty at this stage, thirty-four being present in the specimen illustrated (Fig. 14) ; only one of these is dividing (Fig. 17) showing that mitosis does not occur in all at the same time. A longitudinal section through an egg taken from the same batch as that just described also shows one pole-cell in a similar condition (Fig. 23, a). We conclude from this that the sixteen primary pole-cells have divided, resulting in thirty-two, and that two of these secondary pole-cells have produced daughter cells, thus- bringing the total number to thirty-four. During the division of the pole-cells (Fig. 17) all of the granules separate into two approximately equal groups, which form a thin layer closely applied to the cell boundary at either end.

The pole-cells just previous to their second and final division, can, as already mentioned, be distinguished from the adjacent blasto^ derm-cells by the presence within the cytoplasm of the dark-staining granules of the pole-disc ; they also at this stage show a difference in the structure of their nuclei. One cell of each kind, pole and blastoderm, is shown highly magnified in Fig. 28. Here we see that the nucleus of the pole-cell (p.c) is the larger; it contains a relatively few rod-like pieces of chromatin which are most abundant near the nuclear membrane. In contrast to this, the smaller nucleus

264 Robert Wilheliii liegiior.

of the blastoderm-ecll (bl.c.) is closely packed with chromomeres, and no nucleolus, such as is present in the pole-cell nticleus, is visible.

When the second mitosis is completed, it is difficult to determine the exact number of pole-cells, owing to their irregnlar arrangement. A superficial view of the posterior end of the egg discloses (Fig. 15) sixty-three pole-cells, one, the sixty-fourth, probably being hidden from sight by overlying cells. In lateral surface view (Fig. IG) the pole-cells are seen as a cap closely applied to the postei'ior end of the egg. Longitudinal sections (Figs. 23-25) demonstrate that they do not lie free in the polar cavity as described in Chironomus (Ritter, 1890, and others), but that those nearest the egg occupy an indentation in its end, in which position they are probably held by the vitelline membrane and the chorion (Balbiani, 1885, in Chironotnus) .

The entire surface of the egg, in the stage just described, is found to be covered by the blastoderm, except the area at the posterior end through which the primary pole-cells passed. Just within this area are seen (Fig. 25) a number of nuclei similar to those of the neighboring blastoderm-cells ; they are not, as the latter, separated from one another by cell boundaries, but form an irregular mass, a syncytium. A group of nuclei similar in position and appearance has been noted by Ritter (1890) in Chironomus and by Noack (1901) in CaUiphora; both authors maintain that these are yolk-nuclei. Lecaillon (1898) figures them in an egg of Lina populi, but does not mention them in the text (his Fig. 16). Voeltzkow (1889) found a few nuclei in eggs of Musca lying in the same region. He calls them inwandering blastoderm-cells. I hope to prove that they are the nuclei of blastoderm-cells, which, owing to the presence of the pole-cells, have been prevented from taking part in the formation of the blastoderm. In the stages figured (Figs. 6-11) no vitellophags are present near the posterior end of the egg from which this group could h,ave arisen. Furthermore, no similar groups of nuclei are tO' be found at other places in the egg until a much later periled of development ; then, there may be found irregularly scattered throughout the yolk, small masses of cytoplasm, each containing thre(> or four yolk-nuclei. A comparison of Figs. 23 and 24- shows that in the younger stages

Germ-Cells in Chrysomelicl Beetles. 2G5

(Fig. 23) the blastoderm ends abruptly at the place where it meets the pole-cells; in the older stage (Fig. 24) it has apparently pushed past the latter on all sides, and now projects obliquely upward into the yolk. A still later stage (Fig. 25) shows that these projecting ends of the blastoderm finally meet, thus forming a structure which in longitudinal section appears as an inverted V, but in reality is a cone-shaped ping extending into the yolk. At first the nuclei are arranged near the surface of this cone in a fairly regular row; some of them, however, soon become displawd. By the time the genesis of the pole-cells is completed, these nuclei form an irregular group, just within the egg opposite the pole-cells with which they are connected by a mass of cytoplasm. We shall see later that they remain thus in communication with the pole-cells for a long period of embryonic growth. In toto preparations show this group lying within the yolk in the above described position (Fig. 16, ps. hi. n.).

3. Tlie History of the Pole-Cells Until the Sex of the Embryo Can he Recognized.

In order to follow the history of the pole-cells, it is necessary to describe the development of the germ-band. The blastoderm, as stated in the last chapter, is present at the conclusion of the polecell formation, as a single layer of regularly arranged cells covering the entire surface of the egg, except a small area at the posterior end. The first change noticed in the blastoderm is a crowding together of the cells on the ventral surface of the egg. This results in the formation of a broad longitudinal band of closely aggregated cells, the ventral plate (Stage C). The edges of this plate are thrown up into two folds ; these spread out in the posterior region extending to the end of the egg (Stage D), where they pass around the pole-cells and meet on the dorsal surface (Fig. 31). The entire ventral plate now decreases both in length and in breadth ; during this contraction a longitudinal concavit}, the ventral groove, appears (Stage E). By this shortening of the germ-band, the pole-cells are carried from their former position at the end of the egg (Stage B) to a point slightly anterior, on the ventral surface (Stage E) ; bore they occupy

266 Robert Wilhelm Hesrner.


a cup-shaped depression in the ventral groove. The ventral plate continues to decrease in length ; this contraction combined with the above mentioned depression, produces a deep cavity at the posterior end of the groove in which the pole-cells lie (Fig. 29). A lateral view of the same egg (Fig. 30) shows part of the pole-cells concealed within this cavity.

The germ-band can now be recognized ; it covers the entire ventral surface of tlie egg except a wedge-shaped area anterior to the groove (Fig. 29). A lateral view of an in toto preparation shows the cephalic region of the germ-band already clearly indicated as a large lateral lobe (Fig. 30). The ventral groove now becomes narrower except at its posterior end ; here a comparatively large opening remains (Fig. 32, «; Stage F), which, since the last stage (Fig. 29), has moved some distance forward. The floor of the groove has at this point invaginated to produce a cavity which extends obliquely upward into the yolk (Stage G). At the bottom of this cavity we find the pole-cells. They now lie entirely below the surface of the egg, partly hidden under the closely opposed lateral folds (Fig. 32 If.)

A sagittal section of an egg in this stage gives a good idea of the structure of the ventral plate (Fig. 33). ISTear the anterior end we can distinguish the beginning of an invagination (a) which will' become the stomodseum. At the posterior end is noticed a much deeper depression which contains the pole-cells lying at the bottom near the entrance of a distinct canal, the "Polzellencanal" of Escherich (1900). This canal is that opening in the blastoderm at the posterior end of the Qgg, which was caused at an earlier period (see preceding chapter. Figs. 23 and 25) by the protrusion of the pole-cells. It can be determined from transverse sections that a posterior depression in the ventral groove is formed by the arching over of the lateral folds, thus producing a flask-shaped cavity (Fig. 34, a). The pole-cells lie near the pole-cell canal which contains a mass of cytoplasm connecting them with the pseudoblastodermic nuclei within the egg.

The next stage of development (Stage H) shows a still narrower germ-band already displaying signs of segmentation. The posterior

Genu-Cells in Chr}'somelid Beetles. 267

amnioserosal fold lias grown forward to cover almost half of the embryo, and is mucli further advanced than the anterior fold which has just begun to appear at the lateral edges of the cephalic lobes. The flask-shaped depression in the floor of the ventral groo^'^, which was noticed in the preceding stage (Stage G) has increased in depth, forming the posterior amniotic cavity. The posterior end of the germ-band has forced its way through the yolk in this region, becoming a distinct tail-fold (Stage H).

Sufficient CaUlgraplia niiiterial was not at hand for a study of sections of this stage (Stage H), but eggs of Leptinoiarsa, which pass through a similar course of development, were obtained in great abundance; Figs. 35 and 36 were made from eggs of the latter species. A sagittal section of the tail-fold (Fig. 36) shows five polecells situated at the end of the amniotic cavity ; three other polecells have already passed through the pole-cell canal, while another has just commenced its journey. This is the first evidence we have found of the migration of the pole-cells from the outside into the embryo.

A transverse section of another egg {Leptinoiarsa, Fig. 35) shows a similar migration of the pole-cells ; in this preparation a number of pole-cells are lying at the bottom of what was formerly the ventral groove, a few having already entered the pole-cell canal. In both this and the preceding section, the pseudoblastodermic nuclei are fewer in number than in eggs of Calligraplia.

An embryo (Stage J) slightly older than that just described exhibits the following changes: first, the amnioserosal folds have almost completely overgrown the gevm-l)and ; second, segmentation has become more noticeable ; and third, the tail-fold has penetrated still farther forward into the yolk. A sagittal section through the tailfold (Fig. 3Y) reveals a well developed mesodermal layer just inside of the ectoderm. A number of pole-cells still remain in the posterior amniotic cavity, although more of them have passed through the polecell canal than in the embryo last figured (Stage II). The pseudoblastodermic nuclei which are still present show signs of disintegration.

Such great differences in structure are now apparent between

268 Robert Wilhelm Hegner.

the pole- and ectoderm-cells that one of each taken from Fig, 37 has been drawn much enlarged (Fig. 55), The pole-cell is nearly spherical ; its homogeneous cytoplasm stains lightly ; and its nucleus contains besides a nucleolus a number of small groups of cliromomeres. The ectoderm-cell, on the other hand, is considerably larger; its cytoplasm stains more deeply and contains several vacuoles, and its nucleus, which is without a visible nucleolus, is completely filled with chromomeres. The relations of the parts of the tail-fold are at this stage most easily understood in transverse sections. In Fig. 38 we can still distinctly see the lateral folds (If) of the ventral plate; these enclose the flask-shaped ventral groove (a) within which are the pole-cells luigrating through the pole-cell canal. The amnion which arches over the structures is separated from the dorsal serosa by a thin layer of yolk. The pseudoblastodermic nuclei are still present within the egg.

The segmentation of the germ-band and the lengthening of the entire embryo now progresses rapidly (Stage K). The cephalic extremity extends completely over the anterior end of the egg, and may be seen covering part of the dorsal surface. The tail-fold has extended a little more than half way up on the dorsal surface of the egg. The segments of the head, thorax and abdomen are visible at this time. The pole-cells have changed their position very little, but a larger number of them are now found inside of the embryo scattered among the mesoderm-cells. A transverse section (Fig. 47) now shows a fairly regular row of pole-cells migrating through the pole-cell canal. The pseudoblastodermic nuclei which have decreased in numl)er by disintegration are represented from this time on only by an occasional nucleus, finally disappearing altogether.

Our next stage (Stage L) is an important one in the history of the pole-cells. The embryo has become more deeply segmented and its appendages are now evident. The tail-fold which has begun to recede is shown in sagittal section in Fig. 40. In most cases all of the pole-cells have by this time migrated within the embryo, but in the section figured two of them are just entering the polecell canal which has become much shortened. A transverse section through the last abdominal segment (Fig. 48) reveals the fact that

Germ-Cells in Chrysomelid Beetles. 269

the pole-eells, as soon as they have entered the embryo, begin to separate into two groups ; three of them, in the figure, are present at either side of the median line. A reconstruction made from several series of transverse, sagittal and frontal sections, shows the polecells distributed on either side of the last two segments of the tailfold (Stage L).

The next embryo I shall describe (Stage M) has broadened throughout its entire length ; it has also shortened, this being especially noticeable in the posterior portion. This contraction brings the tail-fold nearer the posterior end of the egg than we found it in the previous stage (Stage L). N'ow that the pole-cells have become an integral part of the embryo I shall call them germ-cells. These still lie in the last two abdominal segments, but have become partially surrounded by mesodermal-cells (Fig. 49). They appear in sagittal section (Fig. 41) to be closer to one another than we found them in Stage L (Fig. 40). In transverse section (Fig. 49) they are shown more clearly separated than before into two groups lying on either side of the tail-fold. Part of them have reached the inner end of the coelomic cavity, while the others are apparently moving in that direction. Three kinds of cell (germ-, mesoderm- and ectodermcells) from Fig. 41 are shown much enlarged in Fig. 57. The germ-cells still exhibit all the characteristics that the pole-cells formerly possessed, and, in addition, contain a second nucleolus. The cells of the mesoderm are smaller ; they appear darker than the germ-cells due to a greater susceptibility of their cytoplasm to stains, and the larger relative number of chromomeres in their nuclei. The columnar ectoderm-cells contain cytoplasm which is even darker than that of the mesodemvcells, and their oval nuclei possess a smaller number of chromomeres, regularly distributed. The ease with which these difi'erent cells can be distingiiished is evident from a glance at the illustration (Fig. 57).

A transverse section of an embryo slightly older than Stage ]\r (Fig. 50) shows four germ-cells lying in a single row close to one another; they all have now reached a point near the inner margin of the coelom and have acquired an epithelial covering of mesodermcells. A further shdrtening of the embryo brings the tail-fold close

270 Robert Wilhelm Ilegner.

to the posterior end of the egg (Stage IST). The germ-cells, still situated in the last two labdoniinal segments (Fig. 42), have crowded close together ; they do not form, as in younger stages, a loose strand on either side of the body, but now constitute a distinct organ, the germ-gland.

After the contraction of the embryo is completed, the tail-fold no longer exists as such ; what was formerly the end of it is now coincident with the end of the egg (Stage O). The posterior abdominal portion of this embryo is shown in sagittal section in Fig. 43. The gerai-gland lies between the splanchnic and somatic layers of the mesoderm: its cells have moved closer together forming a more compact organ than before. A frontal section clearly shows its position relative to the other parts of the body (Fig. 54).

Figs. 51, 52 and 53 are from transverse sections of embryos seventy-five hours, eighty-six hours and one hundred five hours old respectively; these illustrate three stages in the path of the germglands as they are carried from the ventral to the dorsal side of the body by the lateral growth of the embryo around the yolk. A sagittal section of an eighty-six hour old embryo (Fig. 44) when compared with that of an earlier stage (Fig. 43) also demonstrates the same phenomena.

Tn the oldest stage figured (one hundred five hours, Fig. 45) it is possible to distinguish the sexes; the male gland is recognized by a constriction which, appearing in its middle region, gives to it a dumb-bell shape ; the female organ is distinguished both in transverse (Fig. 53) and in sagittal (Fig. 46) sections by the presence of the developing terminal filaments (tf.).

IV. General Considerations, 1. The Granules of the Pole-Disc.

So far as I have been able to learn, no author has described in the eggs of Coleoptera a structure in any way corresponding to the pole-disc. Wheeler (1889) failed to note its presence in Leptinotarsa; Lecaillon (1898) makes no mention of it in the chrysomelid beetles he studied (see historical part), although in several species

Germ-Cells in Chrysomelid Beetles. 271

"cellules sexuelles" (pole-cells) were found at the posterior end of the egg. In Hydropliilus piceus no record has been made of polecells (Heider, 1885, 1889; Deegener, 1900), and, since the primitive germ-cells in this beetle appear at a much later period of development, Ave should not expect to find a posterior pole-disc in this series. Friedcrichs (1906) distinguished the primordial germ-cells in Donacia shortly after the blastoderm was formed, but found no poledisc. Saling (1907), who likewise fails to mention these granules, in Tenebi'io, could not discover as early a segregation of genn-cells as has been found in species of the Chrysomelidse.

Several other orders of insects have received more attention from embryologists than the Coleoptera, but in only two species, both Diptera, have structures similar to the pole-disc been described. In CJiironomus Ritter (1890), after giving a brief sketch of the polar bodies and male and female pronuclei, thus continues : "In dem nachsten Stadium sind in dem Dotter keine Zellen mehr zu sehen ; dagegen tritt an demjenigen Pol, an welchem spiiter die Polzellen erscheinen, also an dem hinteren, ein eigenthiimlicher Avulstartiger Korper auf, welcher dureh das llama toxyl in selir dunkel gcfarbt wird. Er erscheint auf mehreren Schnitten und stellt eine etwas nach oben vorgewolbte Platte dar, welche vielfach runde Fortsatze zeigt und aus feinkornigem Protoplasma besteht. Er bleibt bi-^ zum Austritt der Polzellen an derselben Stelle. Da auf diesem Stadium im Inneren des Dotters keine Zelle mehr zu sehen ist, so kann man nicht umhin anzunehmen, dass dieser Korper den ersten Furchungskern enthalt; die dunkle Farbung verhindert aber, dass man denselben mit Sicherhcit erkenne.

"Es ist offenbar, dass nach der Theilung des Furchungskernes die Theilprodukte theils in dem dunklen wulstformigen Korper verbleiben, theils aus demselben herausrlicken." Ritter then gives a fragmentary account of the early cleavage divisions of the eigg nucleus, at the end of which, the two first pole-cells appear each to contain a "grossen Kern und um denselben herum kranzformig einen Theil des obengenannton dunklen wulstformigen Korpers." This author maintains that the "wulstformige Korper" is intimately concerned with the difi^erentiation of germ-cells from somatic-cells;

272 Robert Wilhelm Ilegncr.

he calls this structure the "Keimwulst," a term which had been used bj earlier authors to designate very different organs (e. g., Zaddack, 1854), and is too broad in its significance to be appropriate for the pole-disc.

A decade later Noack (1901) figured a similar structure "Polplatte," at the posterior end of the egg of another Dipteron, Callipliora, which he designated as the '^Dottcrplatte." This author holds that at the time the pole-cells appear all the nuclei in the egg are similar. "Es scheint auch thatsachlich die Platte am hinteren Pol die einzige Ursache zur ersten Zelldifferenzirung zu sein." Contrary to what is found in Calligrapha this Dotterplatte" appears in CaUipJiora to impede the progress of the nuclei that encounter it. "Im niichsten Stadium haben die Kerne eine runde Gestalt angenommen, die Platte hat sich in so viol Theile getrennt, als Kerne in ihren Bereich eingetreten sind, und bildet nun um jeden dieser Kerne einen peripher gelegenen feinkornigen Ilalbmond. Iliermit ist die erste Zelldifferenzirung eingeleitct." Those cells which now contain granules from the "Dotterplatte" are recognized as pole-cells, while the remaining cells which have reached the periphery of the egg constitute the blastoderm. The "Halbmond" of granules w^hich surrounds the nucleus of each pole-cell now "schlicsst sich allmahlich zu einem Kreise, welcher um so mehr auffiillt, wcil die von ihm eingeschlossene und den Kern einbettende Protoplasmamasse fast farblos erscheint (Fig. 25 u. 26, pz.). Bei der Fortentwicklung der Polzellen schwindet allmahlich die scharfe Grenze zwischen Zellprotoplasma und Polplatte. Letztere l()st sich auf und es entsteht eine gleichmassige Pigmentirung, welche den Polzellen nocli auf lange Zeit ein g.anz charakteristisches Aussehen verleiht." Concerning the nature of this "Dotterplate" IS^oack says "dass die Platte am hinteren Pole des Muscidcn-Eles sich aus Dotterelementen zusammensetzt. Sie scheint den Zweck zu haben, das Wachsthum am hinteren Pol zu beschleunigen, ferner durch Eintritt in die Polzellen es diesen zu ermoglichen, sich auch weiterhin lebhaft zu vermehren, obgleich sie vom Dotter her keine l^ahrung mehr erhalten. Schlicsslich verursacht sie die charaktcristische Pigmentirung dieser Zellen."

Germ-Cells in Clirysomelid Beetles. 273

Granular inclusions have also been found in the eggs of other insects, but show only a remote resemblance to the pole-disc granules of Calligraplia. Thus Blockmann (1887) discovered a number of bacteria-like rods in the undeveloped eggs of Blatta germanica. These rods multiplied by division and were considered true symbiotic bacteria. The same author later described similar Stabchen" in several siDecies of Hymenoptera (Camponotus Ugniperdus and Formica fiisca. The eggs of Periplaneta orientalis and Ectohia livlda also contain accumulations of bacterienartige Stabchen" which later sink into the yolk and disappear (Heymons, 1895).

At the present time, the nature of the pole-disc granules is unknown; one of the two authors quoted above (Ritter, 1890, in Chironomus) claims that the pole-disc ("Keimwulst") consists of protoplasm, while the other (ISToack, 1901, in Calliphora) considers it ("Dotterplatte") to be formed of yolk elements. I hold that the disc is probably derived from the nucleus during the growth of the oogonia.

The origin of these granules may be difficult to determine, although it seems not an impossible undertaking. Lack of material has prevented me from tracing them in stages earlier than eggs of Leptinotarsa just previous to laying, at which time the polar bodies are being formed (Fig. 2) ; here, however, the pole-disc is as large as in later stages of development and it could doubtless be found in younger eggs.

A number of facts discovered in other invertebrates may be mentioned in favor of the nuclear origin of the granules of the poledisc. Blochmann (1886), Stnhlman (1886) and others have described for various species of Hymenoptera a budding of the nucleus in the oocytes;, these buds result in the formation of many small "nuclei" ("Nebenkerne," Blochmann; "Dotterconcretionen," Stuhlmann) each containing small dark-staining granules. The "nuclei" thus derived from the nucleus of the oocytes pass out to the periphery of the cell and are lost to view. No pole-disc has been recorded in any of these species of Hymenoptera, but in the Dipteron, Musca vomUoria, where a pole-disc probably does occur, Korschelt (1886) has described bodies in the oocytes similar to the "ISTebenkerne" of

274: Robert Wilhelm Hegner.

Blochniann. It is liighly probable that a 5imib\r expulsion of nuclear material and corresponding decrease in the size of the germinal vesicle takes place in the oocytes of Chrjsomelid beetles, and that the particles of chromatin thus set free gather at the posterior end of the egg to form the pole-disc/

Wheeler's (1897) theory to account for the presence of darkstaining granular inclusions within the eggs of Myzostoma glabrum suggests that the granules of the pole-disc may be derived from the nuclei of the nurse-cells which, in many insects, pass into the early oocytes.

The results that Hacker (1897) obtained from a study of the "Keimbahn" in Cyclops also point to a nuclear origin of the poledisc granules. According to this author "Ausseukornchen" arise at one pole of the first cleavage spindle ; these are derived from disintegrated nucleolar material and are attracted thus to one pole of the spindle by a dissimilar influence of the centrosomes. During the first four cleavage divisions the granules are segregated always in one cell ; at the end of the fourth division these "Ausscnkornchen" disappear, but the cell which contained them can be traced by its delayed mitotic phase into the primitive germ-cells. The "Aussenkornchen" found in the germ-cell antecedents of Oy clops show a remarkable resemblance to the pole-disc granules of Calligrapha; one important difference, however, may be pointed out, i. p., the fact that in the formPT the granules arise from the nu'^leolar material

'Since this paper was sent to press an account of the origin of the primordial germ-cells in some parasitic Hymenoptera has appeared which furnishes proof of the nuclear origin of a structure similar to the pole-disc. I refer to the work of F. Silvestri, entitled Gontribiizioni alia cnnosccnza hiologica degli imenotteri parassiti, published in the Bollettino del LaJwratorio di soologia gcnerale e agraria della R. Scuola Superiore d' Agricoltura di Portici, Vol. 3, April, 190S. The following qinotation gives some of the results of his study of Ageitkispis fuscicoUis. "Che il nucleolo durante la formazione dei globuli polari si conserva inunutato nella parte posteriore deir ovo e che passa interoi ad una delle prime due cellule di segmentazione. Tale nucleolo, come nel Litomastix trwicatelliis, ha un' azione ritarda trice della divisione della cellula, in cui si trova ed e da ritenersi, per quanto ho anche osservato nello sviluppo delle due specie, di cui appresso tratto, un dot'erminante della celulle germinali" (p. 53).

Germ-Cells in Chrysomelid Beetles. 275

of both male and female pronuclei, after, or during their conjugation, while in Chrysomelid beetles the pole-disc is already fully formed before fertilization.

Another interesting variation in the origin of the germ-cells was described by Boveri (1892) in Ascaris. After the first cleavage division of the egg of this Nematode one cell preserves its chromosomes intact, while the other casts off the swollen ends of its chromosomes into the cytoplasm. During the first five cleavage divisions, one cell retains the two full chromosomes, while all the others contain the reduced amount. At the thirty-two cell stage, the cell containing the two full chromosomes is given up entirely to the production of the reproductive organs; the other cell gives rise only to somatic tissue.

The value of the pole-disc in the development of the insect egg can only be surmised. Bitter (1890) maintains that the first cleavage nucleus is hidden among the granules of the Keimwulst," and he is inclined to believe that the first cleavage division separates the primitive germ-cell substance from the somatic material, although he could not demonstrate this. ISToack (1901) suggests that the yolk elements of the "Dotterplatte" may hasten the growth at the posterior pole of the egg, and that later they may possibly increase the vigor of the pole-cells. That the pole-cells need special means of nourishment is doubtless the case, for contrary to the condition in the blastoderm-cells they are, at an early period, entirely separated from the yolk, and later use up energy in their migration.

Primary pole-cells are evidently characterized by the presence of yolk material, as may be illustrated by the following citations. In Chironomiis nigro-viridis Weismann (1863) found four oval nuclei lying in the "Keimhautblastem" at the posterior end of the egg', each of these, he says, '^besassen einen kreisrunden, klaren, etwas rothlich schimmernden Kera, und in einigen Lagen ausserdem noch ein oder zwei Dotterkornchen." These are the "Polzellen." In another Dipteron, Simula sp., Metschnikoff (1866) records four or five pole-cells which "bestehen ausser einem Kerne noch aus einer die feinsten Dotterkornchen enthaltenden Zellsubstanz." The same author (1866) also states that when the pseudovum in the

276 Robert Willielm Hegner.

psedogenftic larva of Miastor contains twelve to fifteen nnclei, "Man bcmerkt znniichst, class der am spitzen Pole des Pseudovums liegende Keimkern von einer dicken dunkeln Dottermasse scharfer umgeben wird und niit dieser znsammen bald in eine besondere, 0.017 mm. grosse, membranlose Zelle sich abschniirt." This gives rise to the pole-cells. Schwangart (1905) fonnd that the primitive germ-cells of Endromis "sind grosser und dotterreicher" than the blastodermcells.

The theory that the yolk contained in the germ-cells is transformed by them into the energy of motion is strengthened by the fact that the migrating germ-cells of many species of vertebrates also contain yolk-globules (Beard, 1902, in Elasmobranchs ; Eigenman, 1892, in Teleosts; Nnssbanm, 1880, in Amphibia; Allen, 1906, in Reptilia).

2. The Migration of the Priinitive Germ-Cells in the Insecta. A. The Migration of the Pole-Cells through the Pole-Cell Canal.

The authors who first described the pole-cells of insects (Robin, 1862; Weismann, 1863) supposed that they took part in the formation of the blastoderm. This interpretation was corrected by Metschnikoff (1865) and Leuckart (1865) who maintained that the polecells develop into the germ-gland. These two authors, however, did not tell us how the primitive germ-cells got back into the egg after their complete separation at the posterior end. Balbiani (1882-5) added the evidence necessary to prove that the pole-cells really become the reproductive organs, but he was unable to determine whether they force their way through the blastoderm, or pass into the egg by way of a clear space left for their entrance. Sections of the eggs of Cliironomiis led Ritter .(1890) to believe that the pole-cells move of their own accord through a gap in the blastoderm which then closes after them.

Escherich (1900) in Musca made the first accurate study of the passage of the pole-cells from the posterior amniotic cavity into the embryo. Many of his figures show conclusively not only '^die Wanderung der Polzellen durch die Iveimplatte" but also an "intercellular

Germ-Cells in Chiysomelid Beetles. 2Y7

Canal der den Polzellen den Dnrclitritt ermoglichte." In his Fig. 55 several pole-cells are seen lying in the groove outside of the germband, seveiial are present within it and a number are represented half way through the opening in the Entoderm/' the "Polzellencanal." This migration of the pole-cells extends over a considerable period. Escherich claimed that since the region of the ventral plate containing the "Polzellencanal" later constituted a part of the "ventrale Wand des Urdarmes, . . . somit ist es uns dadurch moglich, die Mittelplatte als erste Anlage des Entoderm zu erkennen." In the last embryonic stage examined by this author, all of the pole-cells had not yet completed their migration.

I^oack (1901), in Calliyliora, also records the migration of the pole-cells from the dorsal groove of the germ-band into the embryo. This author, contrary to what Escherich found, could not satisfy himself that a definite canal exists, but decided that the pole-cells during their migration produce an adventitious gap in the Entoderm." Noack followed the history of the pole-cells until they liecame scattered among the entoderm cells within the embryo.

Lecaillon (1898) is the only author who has described pole-cells in the Coleoptera. He states that after the "cellules sexuelles" are separated from the posterior end of the egg they "ne restent d'ailleurs pas longlemps en dehors de la masse ovulaire ; a mesure que la segmentation progresse et que I'enveloppe blastodermique se complete, elles commencent Ji rentrer dans I'oeuf . Pour cela, elles refoulent le vitellus devant elles et s'insinuent entre les cellules peripheriques dvi pole posterieur de I'oeuf, au fur et a mesure que celles-ci emergent de la masse vitelline." A^Tien the blastoderm is finally completed, the "cellules sexuelles" for a group "entre le vitellus et I'enveloppe blastodermique," as indicated in his Eig. 10. In oidy one of the species studied, Oastrophysa raphani. did a variation from this order of events occur ; in this form the "cellules sexuelles," although tending to re-enter the egg, remain outside, as we have found the polecells to do in Calligrapha and Leptinoiarsa. Their migration was not carefully followed by Lecaillon in Gastropliysa. He found them lying at the end of the posterior amniotic cavity, and shows two of them in his Eig. 22, "dans le sillon profond qui se trouve sur le

278 Robert Wilhelm Hegner.

milieu de sa jDaroi interne ;" these "penetreront au milieu des cellules mesodermique au moment ou le sillon se fermera." 'No pole-cell canal is figured, nor does lie mention in the text by what means this penetration takes place.

Although Friederichs (1906) did not observe the formation of pole-cells in Donacia crassipes he found a group of germ-cells lying just within the egg at the posterior pole; these, he thinks, are derived from the blastoderm. Beneath this group is an opening in the blastoderm similar to the pole-cell canal found in Calligrapha, and one cannot but suspect that pole-cells arise in Donacia as in other Chrysomelidse, but were overlooked by this author. The opening in the blastoderm is considered the blastopore. Friederichs says of it, "Der Blastoporus der Chrysomeliden liegt am hinteren Pol und wird verschlossen durch die Genitalanlage, welche an dieser Stelle bereits ensteht, sobald das Entoderm (die primiiren Dotterzellen) und das primare Ektoderm gesondert sind, Der Blastoporus wird spater zum After des Insekts."

In CalUgrapJia and Leptinotarsa, a definite pole-cell canal is present, homologous to the "Polzellen canal" found by Escherich in Musca. The origin of this canal has been described in a previous chapter (III) and the progress of the pole-cells through it was there followed in detail. It undoubtedly is the opening in the blastoderm caused by the pole-cells during their formation ; this opening is kept free from cells by a plug of cytoplasm connecting the group of pole-cells lying in the posterior amniotic cavity with the pseudoblastodermic nuclei just within the egg (Fig. 25). The canal closes only after all the pole-cells have passed through it (Fig. 40). It will be shown later that in Calligrapha the pole-cells migrate into the embryo by means of amoeboid movements.

B. Tlie Migration of the Germ-Cells witliin the Embryo.

It is difficult to ascertain in many cases whether the germ-cells described by the earlier authors changed their position within the embryo by means of an active migration, or were passively moved about by the shifting of the other embryonic tissues. Metschnikoff

Gcnu-Cclls in Chrysomelid Beetles. 279

(18GU), lialbiani (lbS5) and Kitter (1890), in the Diptera, and Huxley (1858), Metsclmikuff (1866), Balbiani (1866), Witlaczil (1884) and Will (1888), in the Hemiptera, describe a precocious segregation of the germ-cells. In the Diptera no active migration is reported after the pole-cells re-enter the egg; in the Hemiptera no movements have been noted at any stage in the history of the germ-cells.

The primitive germ-cells of several species of Orthoptera are, when first seen, in the act of penetrating the walls of the coelomic cavities {Blaita, Cholodkovsky, 1891, and Heymons, 1891; Xiphldium. Wheeler, 1893). As noted elsewhere in this paper, Heymons (1895) has established a much more extensive migration of the germ-cells in Blatta and other allied forms than was described by the authors named. A migration similar to that found in Blatta occurs in Forficula (Heymons, 1895).

The migration of the germ-cells in the Aptera has been recorded by two observers, Heymons (1897) and Claypole (1898). The former found that the germ-cells in Lepisnm have an ectodermal origin at the posterior end of the germ-band. They soon '"sich zerstreuen und einzeln, zwischen und neben den Mesodermzellen nach vom wandern." The germ-cells are less favorable for study in Lepisma than in Periplaneta, but Heymons nevertheless convinced himself "dass die Wanderung der Ge^chleehtszellen sich ganz ahnlich wie bei den Orthopteren voUzieht." According to Claypole (1898) the germ-cells of Anurida move into the yolk at a late embryonic stage and begin to mingle with its globules. Under high magnification "the peculiarly 'succulent' character of the ceys" could be seen.

Carriere and Burger (1897) describe in the Hymenopteron, ChalicodonKt, the migration of the germ-cells from the third and fourth abdominal segiuents into the fifth.

In the "drone eggs" of the hee, the germ-cells penetrate the walls of the primitive somites and congregate in the coelomic cavities. (Petrunkewitsch, 1908).

Although Woodward (1889) correctly observed the place of origin of the germ-cells in the Lepidopteron, Vanessa, it remained for Schwangart (1905) to follow their further history. In Endromis

280 Robert Wilhelm Hegnor.

the germ-cells separate into groups which migrate from a point near the posterior end of the egg, to the fourth, fifth, and sixth abdominal segments.

As soon as the pole-cells of CalUgrapJta have passed through the pole-cell canal, they loose their pronounced pseudopodia-like processes and become nearly spherical (Fig. 55) ; nevertheless, they undergo a decided change in position. They move away from the inner end of the pole-cell canal, and creep along between the yolk and the germ-band (Figs. 47-49). Thus two groups are formed near the developing coelomic sacs ; each group probably contains an equal number of cells. The smallest number I have counted in one group at this time (Stage M) is thirty; the largest number, thirty-four. As there is some difficulty in obtaining an accurate count, it seems probable that the sixty-four germ-cells are equally divided and that each germ-gland receives thirty-two. Some of the germ-cells migrate not only laterally along the germ-band but also back toward the posterior end of the egg, where we find tbem forming narrow strands in the last abdominal segments (Figs. 39-41). From this stage on, the germ-cells are not very active ; they move closer to one another to form the compact germ-glands. I was unable to determine whether the later movements of the germ-cells are due to an active migration, or to the tensions created by the growth of the surrounding tissues ; the latter seems the more probable.

C. The Method of Locomotion of the Germ-Cells. Nearly all of the authors, who have observed the migration of the germ-cells in the Insecta, have failed to describe their method of locomotion. Thus Robin (1862) and many of his contemporaries state that in the Diptera, the pole-cells, shortly after their appearance, move back into the egg. These authors, however, give no explanation to account for these movements, and one is not enlightened as to whether the pole-cells are passively carried from place to place, or whether they undergo an active migration. That amceboid movements might possibly explain the re-entering of the egg by the polecells, was first suggested by Weismann (1882). He was unable to follow the history of these cells in Chironomvs, because they dis

Germ-Cells in Chrysomelid Beetles. 281

appeared from view beneath tlie egg. One cell lying near the anterior end of the egg was capable of amoeboid movements, bnt its identity was not established. Ritter (1890), after finding that the polecells in Clilronomus penetrate the blastoderm, concludes that "anders als durch aktive Bewegnng konnen sie wohl kaum in die Lage kommen, in welcher wir sie Fig. 10 finden." The cells in the figure mentioned have, however, a spherical form exhibiting no pseudopodialike processes.

Turning now to the Coleoptera, we find sufiicient evidence , to prove that the pole-cells migrate by means of amoeboid movements. Although Wheeler (1889) failed to find the pole-cells in the very early stages of Leptinotarsa, he figures several of them (his Fig. 82) in a sagittal section of an egg carrying a segmented germ-band. Here are shown three cells "which are on the surface of the embryo in the amniotic cavity. They are very large and clear and the more anterior is apparently creeping in the manner of an Amoeba, along the surface of the abdominal ectoderm. These cells, the ultimate fate of which I have been unable to determine, probably escape from the anal orifice of the gastrula before it closes." This author also shows in transverse section (his Fig. 87) a cell which, he says, is "about to wander through the blastopore into the amniotic cavity." He suggests that this may be the homologue of the "Polzellen." My sections prove that these are really pole-cells and that they creep along the surface of the ectoderm by amoeboid movements, but the direction of their migration is the reverse of that stated by Wheeler, i. e., they are not wandering outward into the amniotic cavity but are on their way into the embryo.

In Clytra and other species of Chrysomelid beetles, Lecaillon (1898) finds that the "cellules sexuelles," as he designates the polecells, migrate back into the egg shortly after their appearance. In another species (Gastrophysa rapliani) studied by this author, these cells remain outside of the egg until a later stage oi development, and then they penetrate the "ectoderm." Lecaillon does not present any evidence to account for this migration, he says, however, that these cells "se montrent en general moins bien fixees que les autres cellules." In my material no difiiculty was experienced in obtaining

282 Kobert Wilhelm Hegner.

perfectly fixed pole-cells, and I conclude that Lecaillon was deceived by the irregular outline of the '^cellules sexuelles," and tliat in Clytra the apparent distortion of these cells was due, not to poor fixation, but to their amoeboid character.

Several authors have described the locomotion of primitive germcells in other orders of insects. Ayers (1883) states that the germglands of Oecanthus "are first seen as two irregular groups of amoeboid cells." In Forficiila (Heymons, 1895) the germ-cells arise near the posterior end of the egg >and migrate anteriorly. "Die Bewegung diirfte hierbei durch Aussenden amoboider Fortsiitze erfolgen, die man jetzt an den Zellen gar nicht selten beobachten kann."

Heymons (1895) says of Periplaneta, Aehnlich wie in gewissen Stadien von Forficula scheint die Fortbewegungsart der Zellen hierbei eine amoboide zu sein, es kann dies wenigstens aus den zahlreichen Gestaltsveranderungen der Geschlechtszellen geschlossen werden, die bald rundlich, bald langgestreckt sind oder lappige Fortsiitze aussenden."

The pole-cells of both Calligrapha and Leptinotarsa not only migrate by their own activity, but their movements are distinctly amoeboid. It has been noted above that every preblastodermic nucleus has long cytoplasmic processes extending out on all sides into the yolk. It has also been shown that these processes become blunt in the case of the pole-cells when separation from the egg takes place (Fig. 22). If we examine the pole-cells from the time they are protruded until they become aggregated into a distinct germ-gland, we discover a series of stages which establish their amoeboid character as well as it is possible to do in fixed material.

During their protrusion, the pole-cells have still an irregular outline, but their cytoplasmic processes are no longer present on their outer surface ; this is probably due to being pressed against the "Keimhautblastem" (Figs. 20 and 21). After complete separation, however, they again acquire an amoeboid shape, their blunt psevidopodia containing most of the granules taken from the poledisc (Fig. 22). This appearance is retained until the pole-cells begin to migrate through the pole-cell oanal; then the pseudopodia

Germ-Cells in Clirysomelicl Beetles. 283

are no longer found on all sides of the cell, bnt are definitely directed toward the entrance to the canal. This may be seen in a transverse section of an egg of Lrpthwtarm similar to Stage 11 (Fig. 35). In this figure two pole-cells are near the inner end of the pole-cell canal, two are creeping along one side of the groove in the germ-band, while three others are still in the amniotic cavity, evidently moving toward the canal. A greater magnification brings out more clearly the shape of the pole-cells and the direction of their migration. Fig. 56 shows two of these cells taken from a transverse section (Fig. 38) of the tail-fold of an embryo similar to Stage J. The psendopodia are here unmistakable; they are extended toward the entrance to the pole-cell canal. The hyaline cytoplasm at the tips of the psendopodia resembles the ectoplasm of Amoeba; it will be recognized as the vacuolated layer which was carried away from the "Keimhautblastem," where the pole-cells were extruded from the egg (Fig. 21, vac. St.). The pole-cells seem to be thigmotactic, few of them being found free in the amniotic cavity ; they are usually observed close to the germ-band or crowded one against another.

Fig. 55 shows a pole-cell and an adjacent blastoderm-cell enlarged from the sagittal section shown in Fig. 37. Here we find little or no evidence of psendopodia. This is the -usual condition of the pole-cells after they have reached the interior of the egg. Their method of progression from this stage on is not easily made out. In a later stage (Stage M) the germ-cells are partly surrounded by mesoderm-cells ; their outline is still irregular, as is shown in the enlarged draAving (Fig. 57), but no long psendopodia such iis are present in the younger embiyos can be seen. It may be that the pole-cells cease to move actively after they reach the interior of the embryo, and that they are pushed into place by the rapidly proliferating mesoderm-cells.

3. The Origin and Early ILisionj of ilic Gevm-Cells in the Insecia. No general statement can be made regarding the time and place of origin of the primitive germ-cells in the Insecta, as the species which have Ix-en examined represent only a small proportion of the tvpes necessary fur a thorough understanding of this subject.

284 Robert Wilhelm Heffncr.


Pctriinkewitscli (1901 and 1903) has described the origin of the primitive germ-cells in the drone eggs" of the bee at a period earlier than has been recorded for any other insect. The inner half of the first polar body of these nnfertilized eggs nnites with the second polar body to form the "Richtungscopulationskern which is the primordial germ-cell. Weismann (1904) vouches for the exactness of Petrunkewitsch's results. In other Hymenoptera no germ-cells have been found previous to the appearance of the mesoderm (Carriere and Burger, 1897).

The primitive germ-cells (pole-cells) of several species of Diptera have a very early origin. Weismann (1904), discussing the development of the reproductive cells in connection with his germ-plasm theory," says: "If we could assume that the ovum, just l)eginning to develop, divides at its first cleavage into two cells, one of which gives rise to the whole body (soma) and the other only to the germcells lying in this body, the matter would be theoretically simple. As yet, however, only one group of animals is known to behave demonstral)ly in this manner, the Diptera among insects. . ." I have been unable to find in embryological literature any account of such a phenomenon in this order of insects. The pole-cells of Diptera are always found at the posterior end of the egg. The time of their first appearance varies in the different species described. In Miastor the primordial pole-cell nucleus can l)e distinguished when there are only eight to fifteen nuclei in the pseudovum (Leuckart, 1865; Metschnikoff, 1865). In Chiroiiomns the single primordial pole-cell appears before the blastoderm is formed and is closely followed by a second, these two then divide, re-enter the egg, and develop into the germ-glands (Grimm, 1870; Weismann, 1882; Jaworowski, 1882; Balbiani, 1885; Ritter, 1890). The first polecell nucleus in this species may divide before it separates from the <'gg. Weismann (1863) noted four pole-cell nuclei lying in the "Keimhautl)lastem," wliile several authors have described the appearance of two, before separation takes place (Grimm, 1870; Weismann, 1882).

In other species of Diptera the primordial pole-cell nucleus apf)arently divides several times before it reaches the surface of the

Germ-Cells in Clirysonielid Beetles. 285

egi>'; there arc fifteen to twenty in Calliphora (JSToack, 1001), and four to five in Simula (Metschnikoff, 1866) and in Pulex (Packard, 18Y2), althongli neither of the latter was examined carefully.

Pole-cells are also found in several Chrysomelid beetles. Lecaillon (1898) made no attempt to count the number of "cellules sexuelles" in Glytra, but states that they are the cells which first reach the "Keimhautblastem" at the posterior end of the Qgg. In Callujrapha I have shown that the primitive pole-cell nuclei may be recognized when they are four in number, but that these divide twice before they separate from the Qgg, i. e., there are sixteen which pass through the pole-disc. After separation these divide twic^', giving rise to sixtyfour. This number remains constant until the embryo is nearly ready to hatch (Fig. 45) ; then the germ-cells increase rapidly by mitosis.

The very early stages of pole-cell formation were not observed by me in Lepti)wtarsa. When the pole-cells were first seen in this species, they formed a group lying at the posterior end of the egg (Fig. 26) ; they are in every way similar in appearance to those found in CaUigrapha (Fig. 24, Stage B), l)eing amoeboid in shape and containing a layer of granules which they have gathered from the pole-disc (Fig. 2). Embryos similar to Stages A to O were examined and in every case the germ-cells w-ere discovered occupying a position which corresponds almost exactly to that found in CalUgrapha. Wheeler (1889), in his work on Leptinotarsa, not only failed to find the pole-disc, but also overlooked the pole-cells at the posterior end of the egg. His Figs. 66, 67 and YO represent surface views of embryos like my Stages C, D and F, of CaUigrapha. The group of pole-cells is present in every one of these stages in Lepinotarsa, and I cannot understand why Wheeler failed to find them. On page 321 Wheeler (1889) says: "Sections taken in all directions through the egg show the blastoderm to be of even thickness over the whole surface (Fig. 63)." This is not true of the eggs of Leptinotarsa I have examined, as there are two or three layers of cells at the posterior end at the stage to which he refers. The space beneath the pole-cells remains free from blastoderm-cells, and later becomes the pole-cell canal just as we found in CaUigrapha,

28G Kolx^rt Willi elm Ilegner.

The i)i'imitive genn-cells may be recognized in the parthenogenetic eggs of Aphids shortly after the blastoderm is completely formed. Some anthors were able to trace them back to a single cell which separates from the inner surface of the blastoderm near the posterior end of the egg (Balbiani, 1SG6 ; Witlaczil, 1884; Will, 1888).

The only investigators who have recorded an early appearance of the primitive germ-cells in the Leptidoptera are Balbiani (1869-72), Woodworth (1889) and Schwangart (1905). These authors found a thickening of the blastoderm near the posterior end of the egg. The inner cells of this thickening differentiate into germ-cells; later these migrate singly into the fourth to the eighth abdominal segments (Schwangart, 1905).

The foregoing accounts show that those embryologists who hold that the germ-cells in the Insecta have a mesodermal origin are not in harmony with the results obtained by recent investigators. Heymons (1891), Korschelt and Ileider (1892), and Wheeler (1893) all regarded the primitive germ-cells of Diptera and Ilemiptera as derived by a process of precocious segregation from metameric gonads like those of the Orthoptera-" (Wheeler, 1893). The germcells in the Orthoptera (Blatta and Feri plane ta), however, do not arise metamerically from the mesoderm and later migTate into the primitive somites (Heymons, 1895).

As noted above, the stage of embryonic development in which the germ-cells can first be recognized varies considerably in different species of insects. By the majority of authors the reproductive cells have been considered of mesodermal origin, by others they are supposed to arise from ectoderm-cells, blastoderm-cells, yolk-nuclei, or early cleavage nuclei. I believe with Woodworth (1889) that "the germinal cells do not belong to any layer, but are the products of the first divisions of the egg cell; they take part generally in the formation of the blastoderm and then migrate into the mesoderm. In all cases where they are supposed to come from the mesoderm, the later stages comparatively are the only ones kno\vii." Ileymons (1893) four years later was led to similar conclusions. This author states "dass die Geschlechtszellen der Insekten liberhaupt nicht von diesem oder jenem 'Keirablatte' abzuleiten sind, sondern

Germ-Cells in Chiysoiuelicl Beetles. 28Y

niir scheiiibar je iiacli clem Zeitpuiikt ilires Ilervortretens Laid dieser, bald jener Zelleiiscliieht angelioren.

Wenn aiieh die Treiinung zwiscben somatiscben Zellen und Gcscblecbtszelleu bei den meisten Insekten erst spat bemerkbar wird, so werden wir somit docli annehmen miissen, dass ein solcber Untersebied bereits vom Beginne der Entwicklung an vorhanden ist.

"Es mag nocli bervorgeboben werden, dass die Gescblecbtszcllen der Insekten iiicbt, wie man bisber geglaubt bat, in metamerer Anordnnng in den einzelnen anf einander folgenden Abdominalsegmenten znr Anlage kommen, sondern dass ibr Ursprnng am hintersten Ende des Keimstreifs zn sucben ist, von wo aus erst im Laufe der Entwicklnng eine Wandernng oder Verscbiebnng nacb vorn bin erfolgt. Dies trifft zunacbst fiir die bier bescbriebenen Formen zn, bat moglicherweise aber fiir sammtlicbe Insekten Giiltigkeit." Heymons is an investigator wbo bas not been content to work on a few widely separated types of insects, but bas made comparative studies of nearly allied species. Tbe value of tbis kind of researcb is strikingly sbown by the results be obtained from a study of Blatta and Periplaneta.

In an early paper. Ileymons (1891) stated tbat tbe germ-cells of Blatta are derived from tbe mesoderm just previous to tbe segmentation of tbe germ-band. Later (1895) Periplaneta was also examined. In tbis Ortbopteron tbe germ-cells were found to arise from tbe ectoderm at tbe posterior end of tbe egg ; tbey separate from one another, migrate anteriorly, and arrange themselves intcrsegmentally. A re-examination of Blatta convinced Heymons tbat tbe germ-cells originate in tbis cockroach as they do in Periplaneta, but can be distinguished from the mesoderm-cells only when tbey reach the primitive somites. This is made more certain by the discoveiy of a similar origin and migration in Forficida (Heymons, 1895) and Lepisma (Heymons, 1897).

In C allirjraplia all the nuclei of the egg are apparently alike, potentially, until in their migration toward the surface tbey reach the '^Keimbautblastem;" then those which chance to encounter the granules of the pole-disc are differentiated by their environment, i. e., tbe granules, into germ-cells. In other words, whether or

288 Rolx3rt Wilhelm Hegner.

not a cell will become a genu-cell depends on its position in the egg just previous to the formation of the blastoderm. The cleavage nuclei of the beetle's eggs are not separated by cell boundaries, as are those of several other animals (e. g. Cyclops and Ascaris), where an earlier differentiation of the primordial germ-cells takes place, but are intimately connected by the cytoplasm which is present throughout the egg in the interdeutoplasmic spaces. We have thus a syncytium in which the nuclei are widely separated from one another by the enormous mass of yolk. The various substances (e. g., the granules of the pole-disc) are, therefore, less easily segregated into a single cell in the egg of Calligrapha than are similar structures (e. g., the '^Aussenkornchen" of Cyclops, Hacker, 189Y) in alecithal eggs. This fact may account for the relatively late stage at which the primitive germ-cells of Calligrapha and allied forms can be recognized as such.

V. Summary.

1. A layer of dark-staining granules, the pole-disc, is present at the posterior end of the eggs of Calligrapha and Leptinotarsa before fertilization takes place; this layer is later intimately associated with the development of the pole-cells.

2. The genesis of the pole-cells is as follows: (1) four nuclei lying near the posterior end of the egg are recognized by their position as pole-cell antecedents (Figs. 5 and 12) ; (2) these four nuclei divide producing eight daughter nuclei which move closer to the periphery of the egg (Fig. 7) ; (3) these in turn divide resulting in sixteen nuclei, arranged in pairs, each of which separates entirely from the egg, carrying with it a portion of the Keimhautblastem" containing pole-disc granules (Figs, lo and 19-22) ; (4) the sixteen primary pole-cells divide to form thirty-two secondary polecells (Fig. 14) ; these divide resulting in sixty-four tertiary polecells (Figs. 15-16) which do not increase in number until a late period of embryonic life (Fig. 45) ; (5) in mitosis the pole-disc granules are, approximately, equally distributed between the two daughter cells (Figs. 17 and 27 a).

Germ-Cells in Chrysoinelid Beetles. 289

H. That area of the egg tliroiigh which the pole-cells pass is not closed hj the hlastoderm but becomes the pole-cell canal, through which the pole-cells later migrate into the embryo (Figs. 33-40).

•4. The blastoderm-cells which fail to cover this area form a syncytium containing pseudoblastodermic nuclei ; these nuclei for a long period lie just within the egg near the polc-ccU canal, and finally disintegrate (Figs. 24-25 and 33-39).

5. After their se})aration from the egg the history of the polecells is as folloAvs :

(1) The pole-cells are carried slightly forward un the ventral surface of the egg by the contraction of the ventral plate (Fig. 29, Stage E) ; (2) they sink into the posterior depression of the ventral groove, which is the beginning of the posterior amniotic cavity (Figs. 33-34, Stages F-G) ; (3) they are carried along by the developing tail-fold, which penetrates dorso-anteriorly into the yolk (Stages H-K) ; (4) they migrate through the pole-cell canal into the embryo by means of amoeboid movements (Figs. 35-40, 47, 56) ; (5) upon reaching the interior of the embryo they separate into two groups, which come to lie as a strand on either side of the body, in the last two abdominal segments (Figs. 40, 47-49 and Stages K-L) ; (6) these two strands become shorter by a crow^ding together of the germ-cells (Fig. 41, Stage M) ; (7) each of the two germ-glands thus produced acquires an epithelial covering of mesoderm-cells (Figs. 42, 50) ;

(8) the germ-glands, situated as before in the last two abdominal segments, are carried, by the shortening of the embryo, to a ventral position on either side of the body (Figs. 42-43, Stages M-0) ;

(9) by its lateral growth around the yolk, the embryo carries the germ-glands to a point near the dorsal surface on either side of the mid-intestine (Figs. 51-53, 43-45) ; (10) the sexes can be distinguished at this time by the shape of the germ-glands, that of the male being dumb-bell shaped (Fig. 45), while the female reproductive organ is pear-shaped, and shows the development of terminal filaments (Figs 46 and 53).

290 Kobcrt Wilhelm Hefner.


VI. Matp^rial and Methods. 2

The eggs of Chrjsomelid beetles are usually laid on the leaves of the plants, which serve as food for the larvfe. Callagraplia nmltipunctaia deposits its eggs in batches of from two to twenty on the under surface of willow leaves (8aUx longifolia). A number of these beetles were kept in stender dishes and their eggs as soon as laid were transferred to watch glasses. All the eggs laid at one time were found to be in practically the same stage of development, and the batches were, therefore, carefully separated from one another. The age of the eggs proved to be no exact criterion of their developmental progress as external factors (temperature, humidity, etc.) play an important part in the rapidity of embryonic growth. Thus, two eggs of the same age which are kept under different environmental conditions, may on examination be found in very different stages of development. For this reason the various embryos figiired are not designated by the number of hours since the eggs were laid, but are classed arbitrarily according to their stage of development.

Eggs of Calligrapha lunata were found on leaves of the wild rose (Rosa hlanda) ; those of Leptinotarsa were taken in abundance from potato plants {Solamnn tuherosum). The eggs were preserved at intervals of from fifteen minutes to one hour and a complete series was obtained from those just laid to those containing embryos ready to hatch. A few eggs of Leptinotarsa were dissected out from the oviducts of the adult beetles.

A large number of fixing fluids were tried ; the one which gave the best results was a modification of Petrunkewitsch's fluid. The mixture was heated to a temperature of about 80° C, and poured over the eggs ; this fluid was followed after half an hour by seventy per cent alcohol containing a small amount of iodine. After the above fixation, the chorion stood away from the egg so that it could easily be removed with needles under the binocular microscope. Sections were cut 6V3 microns thick and were stained on the slide; Mayer's acid-hsemalum followed by Bordeaux red, was used more than any other combination, although most of the commoner methods

=For an accoimt of tbe breeding habits of these beetles see Heguer, 1908.

Germ-Cells in Chrysomelid Beetles. 291

were employed in checking the results. The germ-cells stained deeply in orange G, and in picric acid, and could be distinguished without difficulty by their affinities for these colors. Entire embryos were stained in Conklin's picro-hsematoxylin, Mayer's acid-hsemalum or Partsch's alum cochineal; some remarkably clear preparations of the posterior end of the egg were procured by overstaining in acidhsemalum, decolorizing in absolute alcohol containing one per cent IICl, and then immediately clearing in xylol, and mounting. By this method the density of the hsematoxylin was reduced and a transparent reddish hue remained ; the granules of the pole-disc and nuclear structures could be clearly distinguished in thick preparations after this treatment.

Zoological Laboratory,

The University of Wisconsin,

April 7, 1908.

LITERATURE LIST. Allen, B., lOOG. Tlie Origin of the Sex-Cells of Chrysemys. Anat. Anz. Bd. 29. Ayers, 188.3. On the Development of Oecanthus niveus and its parasite

Teleas. Memoirs of the Boston Society of Natural History. Boston.

Vol. 3. Balbiani, ISGG. Snr la reproduction et Tembryogenie des Pucerons. Conipt.

Rend. Acad. Science Paris. Tom. G2. , 18G9-72. Memoire snr la generation des Aphides. Ann. Sci. Nat.

Paris. 5 s^rie. Tom. 11, 18G9 ; Tom. 14, 1870; Tom. 15, 1872. , 187."i. Sur I'enibryogenie de la Puce. Compt. Rend. Acad. Sci. Paris.

Tom. 81. , 1882. Sur la signification des cellules polaires des insects. Compt.

Rend. Acad. Sci. Paris. Tom. 95. , .1885. Contribution a I'etude de la formation des organes sexuelles

Chez les insectes. Receuil Zool. Suisse. Tom. 2. Beard, ,T., 1902. The Ocrm-Cells. Part 1. Raja Batis. Zool. .Tahrb., Abth. f.

Anat. Bd. IG. Bessels, P]., 18G7. Studien iiber die Entwicklung dor Scxualdriisen bei den

Lepidopteren. Zeit. f. wiss. Zool. Bd. 17. Blochmann, F., 188G. Ueber die Reifung der Eier bei Ameisen und Wespen.

Festschr. Nat-med. Vereins. Heidelberg. , 1887. Ueber das regelmiissige Vorkonnnen von bakterienilhnlichen

Gebilden in den (Jeweben und den Eiern verschiedener Insekten.

Zeit. f. Biol. Bd. 24.

292 Robert Wilhelm Hegner.

UovKRi. T., 1802. Die Entstehung des Gegensatzes zwischen den Geschlechts zellen uiid den soniatisclien Zellen bei Ascaris niegaloeepluila. Sitz.

Ges. f. Morph. Physiol. Miincben. Bd. 8. Brandt, A., 1878. Ueber das Ei und seine Bildungsstiitte. Leipzig. BuGNioN, E.. 1891. Rechercbes sur le Developpement Posteuibvyo«uaire,

I'anatomie et les moeurs de I'Encyrtus fuscicollis. Recueil Zool.

Suisse. Tom. 5. BiJTSCHLi, O., 1870. Znr Entwickhuigsgescbiebte der Biene. Zeit. f. wiss.

Zool. Bd. 20. Carriere, J., 1890. Die Entwioklung der Maurerbiene (Chalieodonia muraria

Fabr.) liu Ei. Arch. f. mikr. Auat. Bd. 35. Carriers u. Birger, 1897. Entwlcklungsgescbicbte der Maurerbiene. Nova

Acta Abb. Leop. Carol, deutscb. Akad. Nat. Bd. ()9. Cholodkovsky, N., 1890. Zur Embryologie von Blatta gernianioa. Zool. Anz.

Jabrg. 13. , 1891 Die Enibryonaleutwicklung von Pbyllodroiuia (Blatta) ger manica. Mem. Acad. St. Petersburg. Tom. 38. Claypole, a., 1898. The Embryology and Oogenesis of Anurida maritima

(Guer.). Journ. Morph. Vol. 14. Deegener, p.. ]90(). Kntwieklnng der :Mund\verkzeuge und des Darmkanals

von Hydrophilus. Zeit. f. wiss. Zool. Bd. G8. DoiiRN, A., 187(>. Notizen zur Kenntnis der Insektenentwicklung. Zeit. f.

wiss. Zool. Bd. 2('). EiGENMAN, C, 1892. On the precocious Segregation of the Sex-Cells of

Micronietrus aggregatus. Journ. Morph. Vol. 5. EscHERicH, K., 1900. Ueber die Bildung der Keimbliltter bei den Musciden.

Nova Acta Abb. Leop. Carol, deutscb. Akad. Nat. Bd. 77. Feiedericks, 190G. Untersuchungen liber die Entstehung der KeimblJitter und

Bildung des Mitteldarm bei Kafern. Nova Acta Abb. Leop. Carol.

deutscb. Akad. Nat. Bd. 85. Ganin, IL, 18G9. Beitriige zur Erkemitnis der Entwicklungsgescbichte der

Insekten. Zeit. f. wiss. Zool. Bd. 19. Graiser, v., 1889. Vergleicbende Studien iiber die Embryologie der Insekten

insbesondere der Musciden. Denkschr. d. k. Akad. d. Wiss. Bd. 5G. , 1891. Beitriige zur vergleichenden Embryologie der Insekten,

Denkschr. d. k. Acad. d. Wiss. Bd. 58. Grassi, B.. 1884. Studi sugli arthropodi intorno alio sviluppo delle api nell'

novo. Atti Accad, Gioeina Sci. Nat. Catania. Vol. 18. Grimm, O. V., 1870. Die ungeschlechtliche Fortpflanzung einer Chironomusart

und deren Entvvickelung aus dem unbefruchteten Ei. Mem. Acad. Sc.

St. Petersbiu'g. 7 ser. Tom. 15. Hacker, V., 1897. Die Keimbahn von Cyclops. Arch. Mikr. Anat. Bd. 45.

Germ-Cells in Clirysonielid Beetles. 293

IlEGNER, R., VMH. Observatiuiis on the Breeding Habits of Tliree Chrysomelid

Beetles, Calligrapha blgsbyaiia, C. multipunctata, and C. lunata.

rsyche. Vol. 15. IIp:inER, K., 1885. Ueber die Anlage der Keinibliitter von Ilydrophilns pieens L.

Abb. preuss. Akad. Wiss. Berlin.

, 1880. Die Embryonalentwickelung von Ilydrophilns picens L. Jena.

IIerold, M., 1815. Eutwicklungsgeschichte der Schmetterlinge, anatomisch und

physiologisch bearbeitet. Kassel mid Marburg. IIertwig, O. n. R., 1881. Die Coelomtheorie. Jena. Zeit. f. Natnrw. Bd. 15. IIeymons, R., 1890. Ueber die herniaphrodit'isehe Anlage der Sexnaldriisen

beini JNIiinnchen von IMiyllodroniia (Blatta) germanica. Zool. Anz.

Jahrg. 13. , 1801. Die Entwicklung der weiblicben Geschlechtsorgane von Phyl lodrouiia (Blatta) germanica L. Zeit. f. wiss. Zool. Bd. 5.3. —, 1893. Ueber die Eutstehung der Geschlechtszellen bei den Insek ten. Sitzlier. Ges. Natf. Frennde. Berlin. Jahrg. 1893. , 1895. Die Embryonalentwicklimg von Dermapteren und Orthop teren. Jena. , 189G. (Irundziige der Entwicklung und des Korperbaues von

Odonaten und Eplienieriden. Abb. d. k. Akad. d. Wiss. Berlin. , 1897. Eutwicklungsgeschichtliche Untersucbungen an Lepisma sac charina L. Zeit. f. wiss. Zool. Bd. fl2. IIuxLEV, T., 1858. On the agamic reproduction and morphology Oif Aphis,

Trans. Linn. Soc. London. Pt. 3. Jaworowski, a., 1882. Vorlaufige Resultate entwicklungsgeschicbtlicher und

anatomischer Untersucbungen iiber den Elerstock bei Chironomus

und einigen anderen Inseckten. Zool. Anz. Bd. 5. Korschelt, E.. 188G. Ueber die Eutstehung und Bedeutung der verschiedenen

Elemente des Insektenovariums. Zeit. f. wiss. Zool. Bd. 43. KoRSCHEET, E.. UND IIeider, K., 1802. Lehrbuch der vergleichenden Eutwicklungsgeschichte der wirbell'Oseu Thiere. Spez. Theil, 2 Heft. KowALEVSKY, A.. 188(1. Zur Emln-yonal Entwicklung der INIusciden. Biol.

Centralbl. Bd. G.

KuLAfiiN. N., 1897. Beitrag zur Kenntnis der Entwicklnugsgeschichte von

Platygaster. Zeit. f. wiss. Zool. Bd. G3. r>ECAiLEON, A., 1808. Recherches sur I'ceuf et sur le developpement embryon naire de quehiues Chrysomelides. Thesis. Paris. , 1900. Recherches sur la structure et le developpement post enibryoimaire de I'ovaire des insectes. Bull. Soc. Ent. France. Annee


, 1901. Recherches sur I'ovaire des Collenboles. Arch. Anat. Micr.

Paris. Tom. 4.

LErcKART, R., 18<i5. Die ungeschlechtliclie Fortpflanzung der Cecidomyien. larven. Arch. f. Naturg. Berlin. Bd. 1.

294 Robert Willi elm Hegner.

LowNE, B., 1890. The Anatomy, Physiology, Morphology and Development of

the Blow-Fly (Calliphora erythrocephala). Ivondon, 1890-5. Metschnikoff, E., 18G5. Ueber die Entwicklung der Cecidomyienlarven aus

dem Pseudovum. Arch. f. Naturg. Bd. 1. , 18GG. Embi-yologische Stvidien an Insekten. Zeit. f. wiss. Zool.

Bd. 16. Meyer, H., 1849. Ueber die Entwicklung des Fettkorpers, der Tracheen und der

keimbereitenden Geschlechtstheile bei den Lepidopteren. Zeit. f. wiss>

Zool. Bd. 1. NoACK, W., 1901. Beitriige zur Entwicklungsgeschichte der Mnsciden. Zeit.

f. wiss. Zool. Bd. 70. NusBAUM, J., 188G. The embryonic development of the Cockroach (Blatta ger manica). In: The Structure and Life History of the Cockroach, by

L. Miall and A. Denny. London. • , 1891. Zur Embryologie des Melue proscarabaeus (Polish). Lem berg. NussBAUM, M., 1880. Zur Differenzirung des Geschlechts im Thieri'eich. Arch.

Mikr. Anat. Bd. 18. Packard, A., 1872. Embryological Studies in Hexapodus Insects. Mem.

Peabody Acad. Sci. Vol. 1. Petrunkewitsch, a., 1901. Die Richtungskc'irper luid ihr Schicksal im be fruchteten und unbefrucliteten Bienenei. Zool. Jahrb. Abth. f. Anat.

Bd. 14. , 1903. Das Schicksal der PiichtungskJlrper im Drohnenei. Zool. Jahrb.,

Abth. f. Anat. Bd. 17. Pratt, II., 189o. Beitriige zur Keuntnis der Pupipnren. Arch. f. Naturg.

Vol. 59. RiTTER, R., 1890. Die Entwicklung der (iescblechtsorgane und des Darmes

bei Chironomus. Zeit. f. wiss. Zool. Bd. 50. Robin, C, 1862. Memoire sur les globules polaires de I'ovale et sur le mode

de lenr production. Conipt. Rend. Acad. Sci. Paris. Tom. 54. , 18G2a. Memoire sur la production des cellules du blastoderme sans

segmentation du vitellus chez quelques articules. Comi)t. Rend. Acad.

Sci. Paris. Tom. 54. Saling, R., 1907. Zur Keuntnis der Entwicklung der Keimdriisen von Tene brio molitor L. Zeit. f. wiss. Zool. Bd. 8G. Schneider, A., 1SS5. Die Entwicklung der Goschlechtsorgane bei den Insekten.

Zool. Beitriige. Bd. 1. SciiwANOART, F., 1905. Zur Entwicklungsgeschichte der Ijeiudoploren. Biol.

Centra Ibl. Bd. 25. Sct-vatico, O., 1882. Sullo sviluppo embrionale bei Bombicini. Ann. d. R.

stazione bacologica di Padova. Spichard, C. 188G. Beitrag zu der Entwicklung der niiiimlichen Genitalien bei

Lepidopteren. Thesis. Bonn.

Germ-Cells in Chrysomelid Beetles. 295

Stuhlmann, F., 1886. Die Reifung des Arthropodeneis. Ber. d. nat. Ges.

Freiburg. Vol. I. SucKow, F., 1828. Geschleclitsorgane der Insekten. Hensinger's Zeit. f. d.

organ. Physik. Bd. 2. TiCHOMiROF, A., 1882. Zur Entwickluugsgeschiclite des Seiden-spinners (Bom byx mori) im Ei. (Russian). Arb. d. Lab. d. Zool. Mus. Moscow. Bd. 1. TOYAMA, K., 1902. On the embryology of t'lie silkworm. Bull. Coll. Agri.

Tokio Univ. Vol. 5. Uljanin, W., 1872. Notizen iiber die postembryonale Entwicklung der Biene.

(Russian). In: Iswilstija Imp. Obschtsch. Ljubit. Estestwosn. Bd.

10. INIoscow. VoELTZKOW, A., 1889. Entwicklung im Ei von Musca Vomitoria. Arb. Zool. Zoot. Inst. Wiirzburg. Bd. 9. , lSS9a. Melolontba vulgaris. Ein Beitrag zur Entwicklung im

Ei bei Insekten. Arb. Zool.-Zoot. Inst. Wiirzburg. Bd. 9. Weismann, a., 1863. Die Entwicklung der Dipteren im Ei. Zeit. f. wiss.

Zool. Bd. 13. , 1882. Beitrage zur Kenutnis der ersten Entwicklungsvorgange

im Insektenei. Festschrift fiir J. Henle. , 1904. The Evolution Theory. Translated by J. A. Thomson. London.

Wheeler, W., 1889. The Embryology of Blatta germanica and Doryphora decemlineata. Journ. Morph. Vol. 3.

, 1893. A Contribution to Insect Embryology. Journ. Morph. Vol. 8.

, 1897. The Maturation, Fecundation and early Cleavage in Myzos toma. Arch, de Biol. Tom. 15.

Will, L., 1888. Entwicklungsgeschichte der viviparen Aphiden. Zool. Jahrb. Bd. 3. Anat.

WiTLACziL, E., 1884. Entwicklungsgeschichte der Aphiden. Zeit. f. wiss. Zool. Bd. 40.

WooDWOETH, C, 1889. studies on the embryological development of Buvanessa Antiopa. In : The butterflies of the Eastern United States and Canada, by S. H. Scudder.

Zaddack, G., 1854. Die Entwicklung des Phryganiden-Eis. Berlin.

296 Eobert Willi elm Hegner.


Reference Letters, am., amnion, am.s., amnioserosal fold, ap., appendage, bl., blastoderm. bl.c, blastoderm-cell, bl.c.n., blastoderm-cell nucleus. eh., chorion, coe., coelomic cavity. d.v., disintegrating yolk-globule, ec, ectoderm.

e.m.i., epithelium of mid-intestine, f.b., fat-body, g.bd., germ-band, g.c, germ-cell, g.gl., germ-gland. K.h.bl., "Keimhautblastem." l.f., lateral fold of ventral groove, mp.t., Malpighian tubule, ms., mesoderm, m.t., muscular tissue. U.S., nervous system, p.am.c, posterior amniotic cavity, p.bl.n., preblastodei'm nucleus, p.c, pole-cell, p.c.c. pole-cell canal, p.c.n., pole-cell nucleus, p.d., poie-disc p.d.g., pole disc granule, ps.bl.n., pseudo-blastodermic nucleus, s.m., splanchnic mesoderm, so.m., somatic mesoderm, sr., serosa.

t.f., terminal filament, tr., tracheal invagination. v., yolk. vac, vacuole.

vac.st., vacuolated stratum of the "Keimhautblastem." vit, vitellophag. vt. g., ventral groove.


Unless otherwise stated all the figures on this and succeeding plates were drawn from eggs or embryos of Calligrapha multipunctata. Lines drawn through figures on this plate indicate where sections were made, and refer by number to more highly magnified illustrations on the following plates. The germ-cells (pole-cells) are represented by small rings. All are magnified 35 diameters.

Stage A. The pole-cell nuclei are protruding at posterior end. No blastoderm-cell nuclei have yet reached the surface.

Stage B. All the pole-cells (64) lie in a group outside of the egg at the posterior end.

Stage C. Ventral surface of egg. The lateral folds of the ventral plate have appeared.

Stage D. View of ventral surface. The group of pole-cells has been carried part way up on the ventral surface.

Stage E. Ventral view of egg. Pole-cells lie in posterior depression of ventral groove. First appearance of germ-band.

Stage F. Ventral groove narrower than in Stage E. Pole-cells partly covered by lateral folds.

Stage O. Lateral view of same egg as in Stage F. Dotted line shows depth or ventral groove. Pole-cells lie at entrance to pole-cell canal.

Stage H. Lateral view. Amnioserosal fold partly covers germ-band. Polecells lie at end of posterior amniotic cavity ; a few have passed through the pole-cell canal.

Stage J. Germ-band, in lateral view, almost covered by amnioserosal fold. More pole-cells are inside of germ-band than in younger stage (H).

Stage K. View of lateral surface of segmented germ-band. Nearly all of the pole-cells are now inside the embryo.

Stage L. Lateral view after appearance of appendages. Tail-fold shorter than in preceding stage (K). Germ-cells have separated to form a group on either side of tail-fold in last two abdominal segments.

Stage M. Upper figure represents ventral surface of embryo ; lower figure, the posterior portion on dorsal surface. Tail-fold is short and broad. Germcells are closer to one another than in Stage L.

Stage N. Upper figure represents ventral surface of embryo ; lower figure, the tail-fold on the dorsal surface. Germ-cells form two definite compact germ-glands.

Stage O. Ventral view of embryo. End of tail-fold now coincident with posterior pole of egg. Germ-glands lie near ventral surface on either side of median line.




HE Journal of Morphology. — Vol. XX, No. 2.


A miiiiber in brackets refers to the figure from which the cells have been enlarged.

Fig. 1. Surface view of posterior end of an egg 2l^ hovu's after deposition. The pole-disc occupies about % of the entire area. Only those yolk-globules adjacent to the pole-disc are shown, a, circumference of egg indicated by single line. X 200.

Figs. 2 to 4 represent portions of the posterior end of eggs in longitudinal section showing the arrangement of the pole-disc granules, x 850.

Fig. 2. Egg taken from the oviduct of Leptinotarsa. Granules of pole-disc are here very close together forming a broken strand.

Fig. 3. Egg 13 hours after laying. This egg contained about 133 nuclei. Granules of pole-disc suspended in the inner stratum of the "Keimhautblastem" forming a network.

Fig. 4. Egg 11 hours after laying. Pole-disc granules widely separated from one another.

Figs. 5 to 11 represent longitudinal sections through the posterior end (except figure 8) of eggs, showing early stages in pole-cell formation. Granules of poledisc represented by dots, x 60.

Fig. 5. One of the 4 pole-cell antecedents (a) is shown in this figui-e.

Fig. 6. Three of the nuclei (a) in this figure divide once giving rise to pole-cells.

Fig. 7. The three nuclei indicated at a will become pole-cells.

Fig. 8. Longitudinal section through an egg in Stage A. Seven pole-cell nuclei are protruding from the posterior end of the egg.

Fig. 9. Three of the six pole-cell nuclei represented in this figure have entirely separated from the egg.

Fig. 10. Blastoderm completed. Pole-cells form two layers.

Fig. 11. Pole-cells form an irregular group, a, pole-cell in anaphase of division.

Figs. 12 to 15 represent surface views of the posterior end of eggs, showing successive stages in pole-cell formation, x 200.

Fig. 12. The four nuclei (a) under the center of the pole-disc will give rise to all of the pole-cells.

Fig. 13. Eight pairs of pole-cell nuclei may be recognized by their dark granules. Eleven of the blastoderm-cell nuclei (a) contain a few pole-disc granules, b, strand of cytoplasm connecting a pair of pole-cells.

Fig. 14. Thirty-four pole-cells are present, each containing granules from the pole-disc. One pole-cell (17) is in the late anaphase of mitosis.

Fig. 15. Sixty-three pole-cells are visible. The blastoderm is fully formed.

Fig. 16. Lateral surface view of the posterior end of egg in Stage B. Part of the pole-cells occupy an Indentation in the end of the egg. The pseudoblastodermic nuclei appear as a dark mass in the interior, x 200.

Fig. 17. Pole-cell in anaphase of mitosis. Enlarged from Fig. 14, position 17. The pole-disc granules have been equally distributed to the two ends of the cell. X 850.


--^ *


(S «. Si

3 © ^

s ®



&« i i

■' Q

v^^^. 'S

sj a


Fig. 18. Two nuclei which will give rise to four pole-cells ; enlarged from Fig. 6, position 18. a, boundary between nucleus and cytoplasm ; b, chromosomes partiallj^ arranged in equatorial plate. X ^50.

Fig. 10. Two nuclei which will become pole-cells; enlarged from Fig. 7, position 10. a, pole-disc granules accumulated in compact mass. Compare pole-disc in Fig. 2. X 850.

Fig. 20. Two pole-cell nuclei (a and b) and one blastoderm cell nucleus (c) ; enlarged from Fig. 8, position 20. d, pole-disc granules which remain in "Kelmhautblastem" after the pole-cells are protruded. X 850.

Fig. 21. One pole-cell nucleus enlarged from Fig. 9, position 21. The poledisc graniiles entirely surround the nucleus, x 850.

Figs. 23 to 27 represent longitudinal sections of portions of the posterior end of eggs, showing the arrangement of the pole-cells, and the formation of the pseudoblastodermic nuclei and the pole-cell canal, x 200.

Fig. 23. Blastoderm ends abruptly where it encounters the pole-cells, a, pole-cell in anaphase of mitosis.

Fig. 24. A few blastoderm-nuclei have been pushed upward past the polecells into the yolk to form pseudoblastodermic nuclei.

Fig. 25. Pseudoblastodermic nuclei now form a funnel shaped syncytium just above the pole-cells.

Fig. 26. In this figure (Leptinotarsa) the pole-cells are larger and have larger nuclei than the blastoderm-cells. A few pseudoblastodermic nuclei (ps.bl.n.) are present.

Fig. 27. The pole-cells in C. lunata here show an arrangement similar to those in C. multipunctata (Fig. 24). a, one pole-cell in tlie last stage of division.

Fig. 28. A pole-cell and an adjacent blastoderm-cell enlarged from Fig. 25, (28). X 850.

Figs. 29 to 32 represent surface views of eggs showing how the group of pole-cells is carried into the posterior amniotic cavity. X 50.

Fig. 29. A'entral view (Stage E). A shortening of the germ-band has carried the pole-cells into the posterior depression of the ventral groove.

Fig. 30. Lateral view of same egg as Fig. 29. a, cephalic lobe of germband ; b, invagination which will give rise to the stomodeum.

Fig. 31. View of posterior end of same egg as Fig. 29.

Fig. 32. Ventral view (Stage F). Pole-cells, partly covered by lateral folds, lie in the posterior depression of ventral groove (a). This depression is now the posterior amniotic cavity.

(Continued on next page)

{Contintied from 'preceding page)

Fig. 33. Sagittal section through an egg similar to that shown in Fig. 32 (Stage F). The relations of pole-cells, pole-cell canal and pseudoblastodermic nuclei are here well illustrated, a, invagination which will give rise to stomodeum. x 60.

Fig. 34. Transverse section through posterior depression in ventral groove, Fig. 32 (Stage F). a, flask-shaped depression in ventral groove, x 105.

Fig. 35. Transverse section near the end of the tail-fold of an embryo of Leptinotarsa similar to Stage H, position 35. The pole-cells are creeping from the posterior amniotic cavity through the pole-cell canal, x 140.

Fig. 36. Sagittal section through the posterior end of an egg of Leptinotarsa like Stage H, position 36. One pole-cell is part way through the pole-cell canal, x 105.

Fig. 37. Sagittal section through the tail-fold of an embryo in Stage J, position 37. Mesoderm has appeared. A few pseudoblastodermic nuclei show signs of disintegration, x 105.

Fig. 38. Transverse section of tail-fold of embryo in Stage J, (38), showing passage of pole-cells through pole-cell canal, a, flask-shaped depression in ventral groove, x 105.




Figs. 39 to 45. Sagittal sections tlirougli the tail-fold or posterior end of embryos, showing the migration of the germ-cells within the body, and their crowding together to form the germ-glands. Figs. 39 and 42, x 1^5; the others, x 140.

Fig. 39. Embryo to Stage K (39). Almost all of the pole-cells have penetrated into the embryo.

Fig. 40. Embryo in Stage L (40). a, two pole-cells lying in the much shortened pole-cell canal.

Fig. 41. Embryo in Stage M (41). The germ-cells are closer together than in a younger embryo (Fig. 40).

Fig. 42. Embryo in Stage N (42). The germ-cells form a distinct germgland with epithelium of mesoderm-cells.

Fig. 43. Embryo in Stage O (43). One of the germ-glands lies at the side of the median line near ventral surface of embryo.

Fig. 44. Embryo of 86 hours slightly older than Stage O. Germ-gland has been carried near dorsal surface by lateral growth of embryo around the yolk.

Fig. 45. Embryo of 105 hours (male). The germ-gland has become constricted, forming a dumb-bell-shaped structure.

Fig. 4G. ^Sagittal section through germ-gland (female) of an embryo 105 hours old, showing the developing terminal filaments, x 3-0.

Figs. 47 to 53. Transverse sections through the tail-fold or posterior end of embryos, showing the separation of the germ-cells into two germ-glands which are carried near the dorsal surface by the lateral gi'owth of the embiyo around the yolk. ' Fig. 47, x 1^5 ; all the others, x 140.

Fig. 47. Embryo in Stage K (47). Part of the pole-cells are still on their way through the pole-cell canal. (For sagittal section of this stage see Fig. 39.)

Fig. 48. Embryo in Stage L (48). Three pole-cells on each side of the tailfold. Sagittal section in Fig. 40.

Fig. 49. Embryo in Stage M (49). Germ-cells lie close to coelomic cavity on either side of tail-fold. Sagittal section in Fig. 41.

Fig. 50. Embryo slightly older than Stage M. Germ-cells have acquired an epithelium of mesoderm-cells.

Fig. 51. Embryo in Stage O. Germ-gland on one side of median ventral line. Sagittal section in Fig. 43.

Fig. 52. Embryo 86 hours old. Germ-gland has been carried near dorsal surface. Sagittal section in Fig. 44.

Fig. 53. Embryo 105 hours old, showing germ-gland (female) near median dorsal line. The terminal filaments of the ovary are developing.

Fig. 54. Frontal section of an embryo in Stage O. X 140.

Fig. 55. A pole-cell and adjacent ectoderm-cell enlarged from Fig. 37 (55). X850.

Fig. 56. Two pole-cells showing amoeboid processes, enlarged from Fig. 38 (56). X 850.

Fig. 57. Two pole-cells (a), two mesoderm-cells (b), and two ectodermcells (c), enlarged from Fig. 41 (57). x 850.




-y.o\'ji ^.14


<;., ,_.;

•■st^jii^' ,


^!.!^*8'"6l" ®®9';








, • Mr/ ' * . '^'m. : '

, "l **"'~

■'..V •;-'"*j^'^-'-' mp--': "



■Jn .

\.. .J^'^^W " ^w^




With Eight Plates.



Introduction and :Methods 298

I. Ob.servations 299

1. The Cleavage up to Gastrulation 299

2. The Earlier Part of the Gastrulation 302

3. The Later Part of the Gastrulation 303

4. Stage of the Protozonites 308

5. Stage of 1 to 2 Abdominal Segments 310

6. Stage of 3 to 5 Abdominal Segments 311

7. Stage of the Early Abdominal Appendages 312

8. Stages Immediately Preceding Reversion 310

9. The Stage of Reversion 320

10. The Germ Cells ■ 32.5

II. Summary of Observations with Comparison of the Literature 326

11. Cleavage up to Gastrulation 326

12. Gastrulation and Formation of the Germ Layers 328

13. Segmentation and Appendages of the Cephalothorax 3.32

14. Segmentation and Appendages of the Abdomen 336

15. GroAvth Differences of Cephalothorax and Abdomen ,339

10. Central Nervous System 340

17. Blood Cells and Heart 342

18. The Germ Cells 344

19. Movement of Parts during Differentiation 344

Literature List 349

Explanation of Plates I-VIII 3.51

The JouiiXAL of Moiti-iioLooy. — Vol. XX, No. 2.

298 Tlios. H. Montgomery.

Introduction and Methods.

This paper presents an account of the morphological changes during the ontogeny of Theridium tepidariorum C. Koch, from the time of cleavage to the reversion of the embryo. The considerable gaps in our knowledge of this period of development of the spider and the conflicts of opinion of previous observers, particularly with regard to the formation of the germ layers, seemed to make this study worthy of the undertaking. In the comparisons drawn with the results of others I have limited myself almost entirely to the literature on araneads and have not considered that bearing on other arachnids, for I have had more interest in the ontogenetic processes than in the phylogenetic. Further, I have not treated the literature previous to the classical memoir of Claparede in 1862. Those papers published by Salensky and Morin in Russian I could not read, but have had to rely upon reviews, so that I may not have done full justice to these writers.

All my embryological material I have secured from spiders kept in captivity at the Woods Hole Marine Biological Laboratory during the summer of 1906, and have been able to get complete and accurately timed series of stages with comparative ease.

All the eggs within a given cocoon are of approximately the same age. The fixing fluid that proved the most satisfactory was that introduced by Camoy : glacial acetic acid, absolute alcohol and chloroform in equal parts, with corrosive sublimate to excess. The cocoons were opened, the eggs dropped into this mixture and left in it from one to two hours. By this method nuclear structure and mitotic figures are generally excellently preserved, as well as the cytoplasmic structure. The yolk, on the other hand, becomes generally coagulated, sometimes into a homogeneous mass, also from the stage of about nineteen hours up to about the reversion a yolk extraovat is generally produced in the extraembryonic area. These disadvantages mattered little, however, for I have not given particular attention to the yolk changes. After the preservation *the eggs can be cut with relative ease, for the yolk does not become brittle.

Stained mounts of whole eggs are most necessary, and beautifully clear preparations were made as follows : After fixation and hardening

The Development of Theridium. 299

the chorion was removed with needles, the egg then overstained in Delafield's haematoxyline. Destaining was then carried out in acid alcohol until the egg became a pale pink color, with all stain removed from the yolk and cytoplasm ; xylol was used for clearing and Canada balsam for mounting. When the ectoblast has secreted a cuticula, as at the time of reversion, it is necessary either to stain longer or else to remove a portion of the embryo with a scalpel, so as to allow satisfactory penetration of the stain. For sectioning the chorion was removed, the embryo stained in eosin in the absolute alcohol used for dehydration (so as to make it clearly discernible in the paraffine), and cleared in xylol. Serial sections were cut 7 micra thick, and these stained with either Delafield's haemotoxyline or iron haemotoxyline followed by eosin. The embryos were so imbedded in rows that several could be cut at once, whereby sections in all desirable planes could be quickly secured. I have mentioned these methods somewhat in detail, for eggs of spiders have generally been considered difficult to treat.

Theridium tepidariorum is an exceptionally favorable form for study, because timed stages are secured with facility, the females being easily kept, and the eggs are conveniently small.

1. Observations. 1. The Cleavage Up to Gastrulation.

The first cleavage spindle is found at from 3 to 4 hours after oviposition; the two-cell stage at from 4 to 5^ hours, and the four-cell stage at from 6 to 7 hours.

In PI. I, Fig. 1, is seen the anaphase of the first cleavage, the commencement of the two-cell stage. The daughter nuclei lie each adcentral within a mass of cytoplasm, and these central cytoplasmic masses are connected with the thin peripheral layer (blastema) by a network of delicate strands coursing between the yolk columns. In the figure indicated only a few of the coarser of these strands are shown, for most of them are too delicate to be shown at this scale of magnification. My account of the fertilization (1907) explained how this protoplasmic arrangement comes about; how the young oocyte contains dense cytoplasm from the center to the periphery, and how

300 Thos. II. Montgomery.

by the deposition of the yolk the cytoplasm becomes forced into those positions not occupied by the yolk. Accordingly, in the stage of Fig. 1 cytoplasm is probably present everywhere between yolk spheres, though for the most part in minimal amount. The peripheral blastema is present throughout cleavage and does not become marked into cell territories until all the cleavage cells have moved into it; the areas it exhibits on surface views are simply impressions due to the underlying yolk spherules.

The early four-cell stage is presented in Fig. 2, with the nuclei a little further apart from the centre of the egg. Fig. 3 shows an eightcell stage (71/2 hours) ; this drawing is a combination from a series of sections, and only the superficial blastema (Cyt), the eight cleavage cells and certain supernumerary sperm nuclei (Sp) are shown; those cells in the upper half of the egg are shaded, those of the lower hemisphere shown in profile only. Fig. 4 represents a portion of one section of the same egg. Polyspermy is frequent, as I described in my account of the fertilization, though only one sperm nucleus passes to the center of the egg to become a male pronucleus, the others always remaining at the periphery. Later than the stage when the cleavage nuclei have reached the surface I have been unable to distinguish such accessory sperm nuclei with certainty, and cannot tell ^\^hether they take part in the formation of the blastoderm.

The sixteen-cell stage occurs in eggs aged from 8 to IOV2 hours after oviposition. All the nuclei of such a stage, each in the metaphase of mitosis, are shown in Fig. 5, a reconstruction from a series of sections (like Fig. 3). The cleavage cells have moved still nearer the surface, as shown best in Fig. 6, apportion of a single section. I ha^'e not attempted to draw the separate yolk globules from this stage on, for after the action of the fixative employed the yolk generally coagulates into a more or less homogeneous mass. Still another action of this fixative is to be seen from this stage on, the formation of a central fluid cavity {Cav., Fig. 6), but since this is found at only a particular stage it is probably not an artifact. But, though, after this method of preservation the yolk often ,becomes greatly changed from the natural condition, the cellular structures are shown with the greater clearness and fidelity. As the cleavage progresses the cells on near

The Development of Theridiuin. 301

ing the egg surface draw with them the intravitellar cytophismic network.

The thirty-two-cell stage (11. Lours) is reiDresented in Fig. 7, a reconstruction from serial sections (made like Figs. 3 and 5) ; some of the sections were broken and only thirty nuclei could be found. None of the cleavage cells have yet reached the egg surface. Inequality in the rate of cell division is commencing, for while a few nuclei are in the rest stage most of them are in mitosis.

A stage of 12 hours with from sixty to seveJity cells is shown in Fig. S, a surface view of one hemisphere of the egg. Few of the cells are quite at the surface, but all of them close to it; this is the earliest cleavage stage at which the cleavage cells can be distinctly seen on whole mounts. The heavy line, Cav. B, marks the boundary of the central fluid cavity. The cells, still without separating walls, are connected by delicate branching processes.

The next stage is that of the early blastoderm with all the cleavage cells at the surface. The one figured is of the age of ll^/^ hours, but from this time on the age is no true gauge of the stage. A surface view of one hemisiihere is drawai in Fig. 10, and a segment of a single section in Fig. 9. The cells are fairly evenly distributed on the periphery, not noticeably more numerous on any one pole than at another, and number about 140. It is to be noted that no cleavage cells remain within the yolk.

The movement of cells toward the surface is a peripheral movement of the whole intravitellar cytoplasm, so that when the cell bodies have merged with the blastema cytoplasmic threads penetrate for only a short distance into the yolk (Fig. 9).

Fig. 11 exhibits on surface view a hemisphere of an egg of 14 hours, a stage of about 300 cells. The cell bodies are beginning to project slightly above the surface of the egg.

• The next stage shows the beginning of the segregation of the ventral germ disc or embryonic region (ventral plate), which is characterized by a greater number of cells, while the extraembrj'-onic (dorsal) area possesses fewer cells. PI. II, Fig. 12, is a lateral surface view showing 173 cells on this side, the total number of cells being about 250; and Fig. 13 is a section of the germ disc. ISTow

302 Thos. H. Montgomery.

for the first time appear distinct cell membranes, for heretofore the cleavage cells lacked them ; these membranes arise by the cells coming into mutual contact coincident with the shortening of their fibers. Consequently, cell membranes are produced first at the ventral pole, gradually they develop upon all cells of the germ disc as these cells multiply and become more crowded. But the extraembryonic cells remain membraneless until well past the gastrulation period, thus retaining the character of early cleavage cells.

The establishment of the germ disc seems due to two factors: (1) Mainly to a more rapid multiplication of cells at the ventral pole, as shown by their becoming progressively smaller there; and (2), to less extent, by movement of cells toward that pole, shown by the cells becoming less numerous on the dorsal hemisphere.

2. The Earlier Part of the Gastrulation.

The beginnings of the blastopore are found in eggs aged from 21 to 30 hours, when the blastoderm contains from 400 to 500 cells. On unstained germ discs viewed in alcohol there appears an eccentric whitish spot {Cum. A, PL II, Fig. 18), and this spot later includes a small pit (Fig. 23) ; on stained preparations this shows darker than the remainder of the germ disc (Figs. 15, 22). This spot is the first region of cell immigration, whereas the remainder of the germ disc is one-layered. It is always eccentric, and the margin of the germ disc nearest to it will become the posterior or caudal region of the embryo ; therefore, with its appearance there can be distinguished for the first time anterior and posterior, as well as right and left. For convenience this may be called the "anterior cumulus" {Cum. A of the figures), since a second or "posterior cumulus" will later arise behind it.

A section of the earliest stage of the anterior cumulus of an egg of 21 hours is shown in PI. II, Fig. 14; two cells have moved beneath the blastoderm in consequence of vertical mitosis. In an egg of 24 hours about eight cells have invaginated; Fig. 15 is a ventral view of the germ disc with about 417 cells (but its total number of cells is somewhat greater, for a portion of the disc lies on the other surface of the egg) ; Figs, 16 and 17 exhibit the anterior cumulus

The Development of Theridium. 303

on cross sections. From the start this cmnulus shows a pit-like depression, not a linear groove, the gastrocoel {Gast., Fig. 16) ; this deepens as the gastriilation proceeds. Fig. 19 is a cross section of a stage in which twelve to thirteen cells have pushed in ; Figs. 20 and 21, of one with about twenty-five invaginated cells, and Figs. 22-25 of a still later stage, when the germ disc contains more than 500 cells. This gastrulation process is a double one: (1) By vertical mitoses of cells of the region of the cumulus, and (2) by inrolling of cells, else a gastrocoel could not be formed. The pressure of the yolk causes the gastrocoel to remain a rather shallow pit.

All the cells of the germ disc retain short processes penetrating into the yolk, these being the last remnants of the former intravitellar mesh. But those cells that invaginate develop longer processes and become more irregular in form (Figs. 17, 19, 21, 24, 25). The innermost of the invaginated cells begin to separate from the others and, as the earliest yolk cells, vitellocytes, to wander into the yolk (Figs. 21, 24, 25). These cells are larger than those on the surface of the germ disc, they are assimilating yolk more rapidly, and for the most part possess also larger nuclei.

At its periphery the germ disc is not sharply delimited from the extraembryonic area (Figs. 15, 22) ; as its cells increase by mitosis they become more crowded together, whereby their cell membranes appear more distinct, their intercellular processes shorter and thicker, and they come to project more above the surface of the yolk. Where these cells are most numerous they have completely merged with the blastema, consequently this blastema remains distinct from cell masses only at the periphery of the germ disc and in the extraembryonic area (Fig. 16).

The extraembryonic cells are not dividing, are widely separated from each other, membraneless and much branched; they stain less deeply than those of the germ disc. When a yolk extraovat is produced by the action of the fixative it is formed in the extraembryonic region.

3. The Later Pari of the Gastrulation.

The stages now to be described are found in eggs from 30 to 55 hours, with from 1000 to 1500 superficial cells on the germ disc.

304 Thos. H. Montgomery.

There is to be noted particularly the origin of the posterior cumulus, the rapid proliferation of vitellocytes and the segregation of the early mesentoblast.

On unstained germ discs examined in alcohol is to be found' behind tJie anterior cumulus a second, smaller prominence, the posterior cumulus (Cum. P, PI. II, Fig. 29; PL III, 32, 33; PL IV, 44). This is variable in position, placed sometimes at the margin of the germ disc, sometimes nearer the anterior cumulus (an extreme case of which is shown in Fig. 32). Both cumuli are shown on profile on a stained germ disc in Fig. 26, PL II. The two cumuli, at first generally se^Darated, become later connected by vitellocytes moving between them beneath the germ disc; this is well shown on a surface view in Fig. 34, PL III, where the shaded portion marks the band of vitellocytes. A line connecting the two cumuli marks the later mid axis of the embryo, though, as we have seen, this could be foretold from the eccentric position of the anterior cumulus alone.

The posterior cumulus difi'ers from the anterior, besides its later development, in being a prominence from the start, in forming no gastrocoel, and in producing only vitellocytes. But since it is a region of inner cell proliferation it may well be considered one part of a blastopore, the other part of which would be the anterior cumulus; probably the blastopore was phyletically first a longitudinal groove, the middle portion of which later disappeared. The earliest stage found of the jDosterior cumulus, one of 30^/2 hours, is shown on surface view in Fig. 26, PL II, and on median section in Fig. 27; it is then composed of a few large cells ingesting yolk. Later stages of it are illustrated in Figs. 30a, 36, 41a, PL III ; 42a, 42b, PL IV, on median section, and in Figs. 35, PL III, and 43c, PL IV, on cross section. Even in the late stage of Fig. 43c there are only about twelve vitellocytes at the posterior cumulus, though these are unusually large; and Figs. 42a and 43c indicate that such cells are produced not only by invagination, but also by direct metamorphosis of superficial cells of the germ disc at that point. It is by the presence of this group of large yolk cells that one is enabled to identify the position of the posterior cumulus with the posterior end of the embryo of the succeeding protozonite stage.

The Development of Theridiiim. 305

Besides fixing the axes of the embryonic region the development of the posterior cumulus determines an important boundary. Just anterior to the posterior cumulus the cells of the germ disc are thinner than elsewhere {Th. Ah, Figs. 41a, PI. Ill; 42a, PI. IV); this will become the boundary of the cephalothorax and abdomen.

We may next consider the more important processes that are progressing at the anterior cumulus. This has become larger and more irregular in outline {Cum. A, Fig. 29, PI. II; 32, 33, PI. Ill; 44, PI. IV), and is slightly elevated above the surface of the germ disc (Fig. 26, PI. II). It maintains its pitlike gastrocoel (Gast., Figs. 27, 28, PI. II; 37b, 38 A, B, PL III), that closes at the stage illustrated by Figs. 40A, B, 41A, C, PI. III. It is still somewhat variable in position, though always behind the center of the germ disc. At the stage of 0OY2 bours it is shown on median section in Figs. 27 and 28, PI. II ; the invaginated cells have increased in number and size, and those in contact with the yolk have become greatly branched and coarsely vacuolar with ingested yolk particles. These large cells are vitellocytes, and they undergo a continuous emigration from their point of origin, which is in part a movement into the yolk, but to greater extent a passage from the periphery of the cumulus outward between the yolk and the germ disc; this is what causes the outline of the cumulus to become larger and more irregular. At a little later stage this wandering becomes more pronounced, as shown in the middle of Fig. 31, PI. Ill (a cross section through the anterior edge of the anterior cumulus), and Fig. 30a (where only a lateral edge of this cumulus is cut).

A more advanced stage of the anterior cumulus, 37^/2 hours, is represented in Figs. 34-39, PL III. Fig. 34 is a ventral surface view of a germ disc containing 1222 superficial cells; the shaded region marks the area where vitellocvtes lie, in a broad band extending from a little anterior to the centre of the germ disc back to the posterior cumulus {Cum. P) ; the two cumuli have become interconnected by vitellocytes arising mainly from the anterior one. Fig. 38a, an oblique longitudinal section of the whole germ disc, and Fig. 38b, an enlarged drawing of the anterior cumulus alone, show the gastrocoel to be a pit bounded immediately by a group of large unbranched

306 Thos, H. Montgomery.

cells, around which are the large vitellocytes (Vit. C). But a more interesting change is found in the egg, of which two transverse sections are deiiictcd in Figs. 37a and 37b. Fig. 37b is through the gastrocoel. Fig. 37a, a few sections distant from the preceding, shows just beneath the snperlicial cells of the germ disc a compact group of from six to eight rounded cells {Mes. E., only four of them visible in this section), which resemble the outer ectoblast cells. These are evidently the earliest cells of the mesentoblast, because they have the same situation and appearance as cells which later can be rccog-nized with certainty as mesentoblast. But whence they originated I have not been able to determine, the question being whether they are direct derivatives of the ectoblast or from some particular invaginated cell of the anterior cumulus. The latter view would seem the more probable, judging from their position within the anterior cumulus.

At the next stage seen, one of about 49 hours, both vitellocytes and mesentoblastic cells have increased in number and come to occupy a wider area. Fig. 40a, PL III, shows all the superficial nuclei of the germ disc on ventral view, and they number 1441 ; at the posterior cumulus {Cum. P.) the nuclei are larger because there the vitellocytes reach the surface. Fig. 40b is a drawing of the same egg, but at a deeper focus, exhibiting only the nuclei of vitellocytes beneath the superficial cells ; this figure demonstrates that the vitellocytes are now scattered beneath the whole of the germ disc ; this figure does not reproduce all of the vitellocytes, but only those whose nuclei could by their superior size be readily distinguished from the nuclei of the surface cells. Sections further illustrate this migration of vitellocytes; thus Figs. 41a, PI. Ill, and 42a, PI. IV, show their position on median sections; Figs. 41b and 41c, PI. Ill, on longitudinal sections of the middle of the germ disc ; Fig. 43a, PL IV, on transverse section of the disc anterior to the anterior cumulus ; and Fig. 43b on cross section lateral to this cumulus. Accordingly, in this stage the large, markedly branched and richly vacuolated vitellocytes are still most abundant in the vicinity of the anterior cumulus, but many of them have emigrated thence, some into the yolk, a greater number in all directions beneath the germ disc, while there remains at the

The Development of Theridium. 307

posterior cumulus the group of them that formed there. This movement of vitellocytes from their point of origin comes to lower the elevation of the anterior cumulus and to cause it to become flush with the surface of the germ disc.

At the same time mesentoblast cells are scattered beneath the germ disc except at its posterior pole (for they do not appear to arise there). These are polygonal and relatively small, placed between the outer cell layer and the yolk or yolk cells ; they are lettered Mes. E. in Figs. 41bc, PI. Ill, and 42b, 43a and 43b, PL IV. They do not compose a continuous layer and are only one cell deep except at one point, where they are two deep (Fig. 41c, PL III). I have searched carefully but in vain to find indications that these mesentoblast cells develop in situ from the overlying ectoblast ; all the mitotic spindles of the ectoblast seem to be placed horizontally and none vertically at this stage. Therefore, it is probable that the mesentoblastic elements of this stage are emigrated descendants of that group of six to eight cells of the previous stage {Mes. E., Fig. 37a, PL III) which formed part of the anterior cumulus. They seem to have wandered from a single point of origin, just as the vitellocytes have done. Definitive entoblast and mesoblast will later form from this mesentoblast, as will be described in due time. There is closure of the gastrocoel at this period, one of several indications that gastrulation is ending and consequently cellular invagination, and there is no indication at any later stage that either mesoblast or entoblast forms from the outer cell layer; therefore, the latter from now on may be termed ectoblast. The ectoblast cells are becoming higher than wide. Thus, the germ disc is at many points two-layered, consisting of outer ectoblast and inner mesentoblast, both placed outside of the vitellocytes.

Still another process is under way, namely, formation of vitellocytes from the anterior and lateral margins of the germ disc, an origin quite independent of the centers of formation represented by the two cumuli. Their formation from the anterior margin of the germ disc is shown in Figs. 30a, b, 38a, 41a, PL III, and from the lateral margin in Figs. 31 (an unusually pronounced case) and 39. Whether this is effected by vertical mitoses or by inrolling of the edge of the germ disc I have not positively determined, but there are indi

308 Thos, H. Montgomery.

cations of the former process (note the position of the mitotic spindle at the left edge of Fig. 31). This process results in a heightening of the margins of the germ disc, which is well exhibited on alcoholic surface views (Figs. 29, PI. II; 33, PI. Ill; 44, PI. IV). The vitellocytes produced thereby do not differ in appearance from the others. Branched vitellocytes rarely show signs of division, and it is probable that those which have become large and ramified do not divide ; they do not wander beneath the extraembryonic blastoderm.

The germ disc has not increased perceptibly in extent, but has become sharply delimited from the extraembryonic area (Fig. 34, PI. III). Its cells are closely apposed and have lost their intercellular branches. In the extraembryonic region the blastoderm still consists of membraneless branched cells.

4. 8tage of the Protozonites.

This stage is evidently of short duration, for I found it in only two lots of eggs, of the age of 60 hours. Fig. 45, PI. IV, exhibits the earliest condition seen, one with four rather indistinct protozonites, and Figs. 46 and 47 (lateral and ventral views, respectively) with five protozonites. The germ disc has changed from a circular to an ovoid outline, with one end broader than the other; the broader end marks the beginning of the cephalic lobe, and the narrower, the caudal. There are no longer projecting cumuli, but on median section the caudal end {Gaud., Fig. 48) is seen to correspond in position with the earlier posterior cumulus by the continuance of the group of large vitellocytes at that point ( Vit. C. ) . The five protozonites of Figs. 46 and 47 appear on stained whole mounts darker than the intermediate regions because they are thicker, show no signs of appendages and represent the beginnings of the segments of the pedipalps and the four pairs of legs, while the protozonites of Fig. 45 represent the segments of the pedipalps and the three anterior pairs of legs. The boundary between cephalothorax and abdomen is that point where the ectoblastic cells are somewhat flattened (Th. Ah., Figs. 48, 50b) ; previously this region had lain just anterior to the posterior cumulus (Figs. 41a, PI. Ill; 42a, PI. IV). On comparison of Fig. 41a with Fig. 48 it follows that the elongation of the germ disc pro

The Development of Theridium. 309

ducing the abdomen is due to a rapid growth between this thin region of the ectoblast and the posterior edge of the germ disc (region of the posterior cumulus), and not to growth cephalad from the posterior end of the germ disc. The abdominal region is therefore extending teloblastically, by cell multiplication, in its anterior portion. It results that the thin region of the ectoblast (T/i. Ah., Fig. 48) is rapidly separating from the group of vitelloeytes at the posterior end (caudal lobe, Caud.). It will be noted that the thoracal segments develop in situ and almost if not quite simultaneously, teloblastic growth occurring only in the abdomen. The extension of the embryo around the yolk, shown in Fig. 47, is due mainly to growth of the abdominal region, dorsal extension of the head lobe being much less in amount.

The middle cell layer, that between ectoblast and vitelloeytes, is still one cell deep (Fig. 48), and its cells are smaller than those of the ectoblast. This layer within the cephalothoracal region is true mesoblast (Mes., Figs. 50 a-c), for there is at no time any indication that entoblast arises within the cephalothorax ; it is only much later than the stage of reversion that entoblast enters the cephalothorax, and then by growth of the midgut from the abdomen into the posterior part of the thorax. This cephalothoracal mesoblast is segmented, each of its transverse masses confluent with and, indeed, occasioning a protozonite, while it is absent between protozonites ; Fig. 48 shows this condition on median section of the whole embryo, and Fig. 49b on transverse section of one-half of a protozonite. This segmented condition of the mesoblast is a secondary one, for in the preceding stages it showed no such distribution. In the head region (Fig. 50a) there is a layer of mesoblast, as in the thorax, and here also it is segmented, for it shows a division into a more anterior rostral mesoblast (B. Mes.) and a more posterior cheliceral mesoblast (Chcl. Mes.) ; this is important as indicating that in this early stage there are two mesoblastic sacs within the cephalic lobe, one anterior to and distinct from the cheliceral segment.

In the abdominal region there is a single unsegmented layer of cells beneath the ectol)last, extending from the thoraco-abdominal boundary (Th. Ah., Fig. 50b) not quite to the posterior margin (G. B.) of the germ disc. This layer is mesentoblast, as its later history shows.

310 Thos. H. Montgomery,

The ectoblast consists of cells that are mainly columnar, and in some places it is becoming two cell layers deep (Figs. 49b, 50a-c).

The vitellocytes have become relatively enormous (Vit. C, Figs. 48, 49b, 50a-c), and most of them lie in the more superficial portion of the yolk, few having reached its center. For the first time the extraembryonic blastoderm is beginning to proliferate vitellocytes by direct metamorj^hosis of some of its cells (Fig. 49a). The extraembryonic blastodermic cells are also increasing in number.

5. Stage of One to Tivo Ahdominal Segmenis.

Fig. 51, PL IV, is an oblique latero-ventral view of the stage, 60 V^ hours, immediately following that of the protozonites. It shows the pedi palpal segment (Fed.) and the segments of the legs {L. 1-L. 4), all with the first traces of limb buds. Fig. 52, an embryo of ca. 62 hours, illustrates a lateral view of the later stage with six pairs of cephalothoracal appendages (the cheliceral segment, Cltel., now separated from the head lobe, Cepli.), and the appearance of the first abdominal segment (Ah. 1). Then Fig. 53 illustrates a still later stage, where there are two abdominal segments (Ah. 1, Ah. 2) and a trace of a third. On comparing Fig. 52 with Fig. 53 it will be seen that it is the abdominal region that is lengthening most rapidly, which results in the caudal lobe {Gaud.) pushing dorso-cephalad until it nearly meets the head lobe. The nuclei of the extraembryonic region are marked by stippling.

The stage of Fig. 53 merits a more detailed description.

The mesoblast of the cephalothorax is now arranged in the form of a series of paired pouches, discontinuous longitudinally and transversely ; this segregation is the mechanical cause of the limb buds. In the chelicera {Clid., Fig. 56c, PI. V) and the fourth leg pair (L. 4, Fig. 56a) it is only one layer deep, for in these segments it has developed more slowly than in the others ; but beneath the other thoracal appendages it is two cells deep (Figs. 55, 56d). When this two-layered condition has been reached the layer next the ectoblast may be called somatic mesoblast {8o. Mes., Fig. 55), and the other layer, splanchnic mesoblast (Sp. Mes.). The way in which the splanchnic layer becomes separated from the somatic is shown in Fig. 56d, indicating

The Development of Theridium, 311

its formation by inrolling of the edge of the somatic rather than by vertical mitosis or delamination. At first the two layers are closely apposed, but they later partially separate to produce the coelom (Coel.j Fig. 55). At no time do yolk globules enter any of the coelomic cavities.

In the cephalic region the mesoblast of the cheliceral segment (Chel. Mes., Fig. 56c) is separated from the more anterior rostral mesoblast {R. Mes.).

In the abdominal segments (Ah. 1, Ah. 2, Fig. 56a) the mesentoblast is transversely and longitudinally segmented into paired bands, but is still one-layered. Posterior to these segments, within the caudal lobe proper (Fig. 56b), the mesentoblast (Mes. E.) is a continuous layer. On transverse section of the caudal lobe are found at occasional intervals in the midline masses of small branched cells (G. C. ?, Fig. 54, compare also Fig. 56b) ; these are much smaller and stain more deeply than vitellocytes, and may represent either genital cells or early definitive entoblast.

Vitellocytes are still forming by metamorphosis of cells of the extraembryonic blastoderm.

0. Stage of Three to Five Ahdominal Segments (73 to 75 Hours).

Fig. 57, PI. V, shows a stage with three abdominal segments. Fig. 58 one with four, and Fig. 59 one with five. The abdomen has increased in length until the caudal lobe meets the head lobe on the dorso-anterior surface of the yolk. The posterior unsegmented portion of the abdomen is the caudal lobe of the authors, comparable with the telson of other animals having teloblastic gro^vth. While the abdominal segments still lack limb buds the appendages of the cephalothorax have become short and blunt cylinders directed caudad. The head lobe (Oeph., Fig. 59) shows as yet no particular organ regions, but extending from it backwards along the thorax is a light median line, the ventral sulcus (Sul. v.), which marks the region where the ectoblast is thinnest and from which the mesoblast sacs have withdrawn laterally.

The first traces of the central nervous system now appear, paired thickenings of the ectoblast mesial from the appendages in that

312 Thos. H. Montgomery.

region from the jDcdipalpal to the fourth ambulatory segment. In such ganglionic thickenings {Gang., Fig. 62) the ectoblast is twolayered, while in the ventral sulcus {Sul. v.) between them it has become thinner; therefore, cells have probably moved away from that ventral midline to aid in the production of the ganglia. Such ganglia cannot yet be distinctly seen upon surface views, and those of the chelicera are not yet differentiated.

In the head lobe the posterior cheliceral mesoblast (CJiel. Mes., Fig. 60b) is distinct from the more anterior rostral (R. Mes., Fig. 60a). A slight elevation on the surface of the head lobe seems to indicate the first appearance of the cerebral ridges. In the thorax each appendage has its mesoblast sac, but these sacs extend neither mesial nor lateral of the appendages (Fig. 62, transverse section).

The abdomen where it is segmented exhibits its mesentoblast in segmented two-layered masses, but in the caudal lobe in a single layer. Each segment has a right and left mesentoblastic mass separated in the midline from each other (Fig. 61). Where this cell mass is two layers deep the outer layer is somatic mesoblast. {So. Mes.), while the inner is still mesentoblast {Mes. E.). At various points in the median axis of the abdomen are groups of small cells {G. 0. ?, Fig. 61), which had been remarked in the preceding stage.

Fig. 61 shows that vitellocytes are still forming from the extraembryonic blastoderm.

7. Stage of the Early Ahdominal Appendages (86 Hours). The external characteristics of embryos of this period are shown in Figs. 63-66, PI. V. The caudal lobe {Caud.) has reached the head lobe, the ventral sulcus {Sid. v.) is widening and extends posteriorly to the seventh abdominal segment (Fig. QQ), which is one factor in the lateral expansion of the body, and in consequence the extraembryonic area has decreased in amount (the stippling represents the nuclei of this area in their actual number). The lateral view. Fig. 63, shows how the embryonic region has encroached upon the extraembryonic as compared Avith the preceding stage, Fig. 57. Of the cephalothoracal appendages the cheliceral {Chel., Figs 63, 65) are the shortest, while the others {L. 1-L. i) have become three

The Development of Theridmm. 313

jointed. The abdomen possesses eight segments (Ah. 1-Ab. 8, Figs. 63, 66) anterior to the caudal lobe (CaucL), the full number that it will have in this species ; and of these the second to the fifth inclusive bear each a pair of limb buds (Ah. 2h-Ah. 5h). For each of the thoracal segments (Fig. 65) and to each of the abdominal except the eighth (Figs. 63, 66) there is a pair of nerve ganglia.

On the head lobe appears the stomodaeum (Sto., Figs. 64, 65), a shallow pit with somewhat turgid lips (8to. L.). It is an ectoblastic invagination shown on median section in Fig. 67b, PL VI, and on cross section in Fig. 68b. Just at its anterior border is a pair of small, basally contiguous prominences, the rostral appendages (Eos., Figs. 64, 65, PI. V) ; later these will fuse to form the rostrum. They are shown on longitudinal section in Fig. 67b, PI. VI, and on transverse section in Figs. 68a and 68d. Beneath these appendages lie the rostral mesoblast sacs, which occupy more than the anterior half of the head lobe, meet in the midline anterior to the ventral sulcus, and are continued in the lateral lips of the stomodaeum. The upper portion of Fig. 68d shows how these sacs extend laterally almost as far as the head lobe itself; Fig. 67b shows that they extend mesially back to the posterior border of the stomodaeum; and Fig. 67a shows one rostral sac on longitudinal section in the plane of a cheliceron (CJiel.), this demonstrating how much more extensive the rostral sacs are than the cheliccral. Each rostral sac now consists of somatic and splanchnic layers, and these layers separate from each other to form coelomic spaces beneath the rostral appendages (Ros.. Figs. 67b, 68a and 68d) at the lateral margins of the head lobe (R. Coe I. J, Figs. 68c-f), and beneath the cerebral ridges (Ce. IL, Figs. 67a, 68f). The only prominences of the head lobe anterior to the chelicera that can be properly considered prestomial appendages are these rostral tubercles ; and they may be rightly adjudged cephalic appendages to which belong the rostral mesoblast sacs, and the ganglia of which would be the cerebral. Though they develop later than the chelicera it will be recalled that the chelicera arise later than the pedipalps and the legs, and the rostral mesoblast sacs develop simultaneously with the cheliceral. Fusion of these rostral appendages with the lips of the stomodaeiun follows later, the two are

314 Thos. H. Montgomery.

separate in origin, and the stomodaeal lips {Sto. L., Eig. 67b) are simply ectoblastic thickenings into which extends the rostral mesoblast.

Other differentiations of the head lobe are the following: A short distance anterior to the rostral appendages the head lobe is mesially broadly indented, probably by its lateral borders growing more rajDidly than its median, this constituting the anterior sulcus (Sul. A., Fig. 64, PI. V). Behind this is the stomodaeum (Sto.) and behind that the ventral sulcus (Sul. !>.), so that the head lobe is nearly completely divided into right and left halves. The antero-median margin of each half is somewhat elevated and thickened, and each such transverse prominence, which may be called a cerebral ridge (Ce. R., Figs. 63, 64) is bordered posteriorly by a groove, the fovea (Fov.). A longitudinal section through a cerebral ridge and fovea is given in Fig. G7a, PL VI. Fig. 68f shows a transverse section of the two cerebral ridges ; in the midline lies the apex of the caud al lobe (Caud.) and immediately above that the extraembryonic blastoderm (Ex., this being the plane of the anterior sulcus) ; right and left of this sulcus are the halves of the head lobe, the mesial portions of which are the cerebral ridges (Ce. R.). These ridges cannot be considered separate appendages because they do not possess peculiar miesoblast, but are bordered by the rostral mesoblast. Lateral from and on a line with the fovea of each side is a transversely elongated pit which may be termed the antero-lateral vesicle (A. L. Y., Fig. 63, PI. V) ; this is difficult to find on surface views, but on transverse sections (A. L. Y., Figs. 68c, d, PI. VI) each is found to be an ectoblastic groove. In most of the head region the ectoblast is several layers deep.

The chelicera (Chel., Figs. 64, 65, PI. V) are at the posterior border of the head lobe, as are their ganglia (Chel. G.), far behind the stomodaeum (8to.). Their mesoblast sacs (Fig. 67a, PI. VI) are separated from and much smaller than the rostral sacs.

Each thoracal limb behind the chelicera possesses a distinct coelom, bounded by somatic mesoblast extending into the limb and a splanchnic layer upon the yolk (Figs. 68d, e, 70). These mesoblast sacs do not as. yet extend laterad of the limbs, but have grown some distance

The Development of Theridium. 315

mesiad beneath the ganglia (Fig. 68d) ; they are discontinuous transversely and longitudinally.

In the abdomen each of the eight segments has beneath the ectoblast {Ed., Fig. G9) a layer of somatic mesoblast {So. Mes.) and one of mesentoblast {Mes. E.) ; and at the base of each limb bud {Ab. 5.B) there is a coelom {Coel.) formed, as in the thorax, by secondary separation of the layers ; right and left sacs of the two sides are separated by the ventral sulcus, but on each side of this groove the mesoblast sacs are longitudinally connected. The first segment, overlooked by so many observers, also has two layers of mesoblast {Ab. 1, Fig. 70), which is separated from that of the hindmost thoracal segment {L. 4) ; it has also its own pair of nerve ganglia {Ab. G. 1, Figs. 63, 66). Within the caudal lobe {Caud., Fig. 69, PI. VI) the mesentoblast is still for the most part one-layered.

At this stage appears distinctly, and for the first time, a portion of the definitive entoblast. Its cells lie in the abdominal region between the mesoblast and the vitellocytes, are at first smaller than the vitellocytes, but soon increase in size and develop ramifying processes so as to resemble minature vitellocytes. They are to be found from the first abdominal segment {Ent., Fig. YO) posterior to the caudal lobe {Ent., Fig. 69), and would appear to arise disconnectedly from the mesentoblast in its whole extent. At present the entoblast cells occur sparingly and in small groups. Where they are present three layers can be distinguished between the ectoblast and the vitellocytes: somatic mesoblast {So. Mes., Fig. 70), splanchnic mesoblast {Sp. Mes.) and entoblast {Ent.). From the account of this and other stages it will be seen that the vitellocytes take no part in producing the entoblast.

Still another process is commencing, the production of blood cells. The extraembryonic blastoderm (Fig. 68d) consists of only one layer, ectoblast, for mesoblast is formed only within the embryonic body, and not until later stages does it grow outward from this body. These extraembryonic cells remained quiescent during the gastrulation period, later proliferated some of the vitellocytes, and now are giving rise to blood cells. Such cells are marked Bl in Figs. 68d and 6 Be, scattered groups or islands of cells produced by multif>lica

316 Thos. H. Montgomery.

tion and enlargement of extraembryonic blastodermic cells in a region where there is no mesoblast. Fig. 67c shows the details of this process on higher magnification, the border of the embryonic body being at the jDoint marked G. B; while Eig. 68g shows another group of them in statu nascendi just lateral from the head lobe. Their formation is very characteristic and not to be confounded with that of any other cells : at certain points the extraembryonic cells multiply, the nucleus of each enlarges and the cytoplasm still more rapidly, then from the large and dense nucleus strings of chromatin substance pass into the cell body until the latter contains a heavy chromidial net (Figs. 67c, 68g). Thus, the cells come to assume the appearance of those blood cells later found within the heart cavity. These cells are unquestionably ectoblastic, for they arise in regions where there is no mesoblast, and are at the start on the surface of the blastoderm. On the other hand, there are no indications whatsoever of blood cell formation from the mesoblast at this or later stages. 'As they enlarge they sink below the blastoderm, and the stage following this one will show how they move into the embryonic body by migration. The point of origin of the blood is, accordingly, that extraembryonic area indicated in Figs. 63-66 by stippling.

8. Stages Immediately Preceding Reversion.

Here may be considered two slightly different stages, one of about 97 hours (Figs. 71-74, PI. VI), the other of about 108 hours (Figs. 78, 79, PL VII).

The rostral appendages have fused to compose the rostrum {Ros., Figs. 71, 72, PI. VI; 79, PI. VII), which is broad with its free end directed anteriorly. Fig. 80b {Ros. ) shows it on median section and Fig. 75b cut a little to one side of the midline, these figures elucidate also the extent of its rostral mesoblast {R. Mes.) in antero-posterior direction; and Figs. 76a (anterior to the rostrum) and 76b (in the plane of the stomodaeum, Sto.) in transverse direction. The rostral mesoblast sac (R. Mes., Fig. 80b) is much more extensive than the cheliceral {Chel. Mes.). The unpaired rostrum has been produced by the fusion of the paired rostral tubercles of earlier stages.

The stomodaeum (Sto., Figs. 71, 72, PI. VT ; 79, PL VII) has

The Development of Theridiiim. 317

become a hemispherical cup, seen on longitudinal section in Figs. 75b and 80b, and on transverse section in Fig. 7Cb; it is immediately lined by rostral mesoblast. Its bordering lip is circular, an ectoblastic ring into which projects rostral mesoblast (Fig. 76b).

The cerebral ridges have become more complicated, and on surface views (C'e. R., Figs. 71, 72, PI. VI; 70, PL VII) each is seen to have grown from the stomodaeal region postero-lateral to the antero-lateral vesicle {A. L. 7.). Posteriorly (toward the stomodaeal side) each ridge is bounded by the fovea {Fov., Figs. 72, 73, PI. VI; 79, PI. VII). The fovea has become a deep groove, deej)ening first mesially, and successive stages of its insinking are shown in Figs. 75b and 80d, PI. VII {Fov). The cerebral ridge is the commencement of the cerebral ganglion, and the fovea, which is its posterior bordering groove, the ventricle of this ganglion. At this stage the cerebral ganglia are therefore invaginating and sinking below the surface.

Lateral and somewhat posterior to each of the preceding ganglionic anlages lies a still deeper and more complicated pit, the antero-lateral vesicle (A. L. Y., Figs. 71, 72, PL VI; 79, PL VII). The cavity of this vesicle is mesially continuous with the fovea (Fov.). Where this pit is deepest {A. L. V., Fig. 80c, PL VII) its ectoblastic wall {Ect.) is greatly thickened. When the antero-lateral vesicle is looked at from the surface in a favorable position (as in Fig. 71, PL VI, A. L. y.), and before it has joined with the postero-lateral vesicle (P. L. v.), it may be described as bounded laterally by a semicircular ridge and mesially by an elevated prominence {Ft'.). The prominences of both right and left vesicles are lettered Pr. in the transverse section represented in Fig. 76a^ cut anterior to the rostrum; each prominence is a greatly heightened ridge, with folded outer surface, lying between the fovea and the pit {A. L. F.) of the antero-lateral vesicle. This relation is somewhat difficult to describe, but may be understood by comparing the surface view of Fig. 71, PL VI, with the section. Fig. 76a, PL VII. These projecting knobs of the median walls of the antero-lateral vesicles might suggest, from the examination of surface views alone, that they are additional cephalic appendages; but that they cannot be, for each is simply an ectoblastic elevation that has no special coelomic sac.

318 Thos. II. Montgomery.

The postero-lateral vesicles are exhibited in Fig. 71, PI. VI (P. L. V.) at the earlier stage when they are still separate from the anterolateral vesicles (.1. L. V.) ; a transverse section of them in this stage is show^n in Fig. 7Gb, PI. VII. Later their anterior margins and the posterior margins of the antero-lateral vesicles grow to meet each other, as shown in Figs. 79 and 80c; Fig. 80a indicates the method of closnre of each postero-lateral vesicle by overgrowth of its margin. The antero-lateral and postero-lateral vesicles are the beginnings of the optic ganglia.

Another change is the gradual widening of the ventral sulcus {8ul. v., Figs. 71-74, PL VI; 79, PI. VII), illustrated best, perhaps, by comparison of Figs. 74 and 78. This sulcus has become somewhat diamond-shaped, widest at the juncture of thorax and abdomen, narrowing cephalad as well as caudad. It extends from the stomodaeum to about the caudal lobe, and marks the region where there is no mesoblast. By its widening it occasions a still greater reduction of the extraembryonic area (that part in Figs. 71-73 of which the nuclei are indicated by stippling) ; and it is the clearest anticipation of the reversion process soon to follow.

The chelicera {Chel., Fig. 72, PI. VI) and their ganglia {Chel. 0.) are still poststomial; subsequently each chelieeron acquires a slight maxillary process on its mesial border (Fig. 79, PL VII). The maxillary plates of the pedipalps are well marked (Figs. 71, 72, PL VI; 79, PL VII). The other thoracal appendages {L. 1-L.4, Figs. 71-74, 78, 79) are becoming longer and more bent, with four or five joints apiece; in the stage of Figs. 78 and 79 those of opposite sides meet ventrally.

The four pairs of abdominal appendages {Ah. 2b-Ab. bh, Figs. 71, 73, 74, PL VI; 78, PL VII) have gTown larger and the two more posterior pairs (prospective spinnerets) are the largest; all are somewhat blunt and rectangular in form; the most posterior pair are shown on section in Fig. 77. The caudal lobe {Caud., Figs. 71-73, PL VI; 78, PL VII) is short, apically rounded and slightly projecting above the extraembryonic area (Fig. 80e). While the seventh and eighth abdominal segments are at first still distinguishable {Ah. 7, Ah. 8, Fig. 71, PL VI), they later fuse with the caudal lobe (Fig. 78, PL VII).

The Development of Theridium. 319

The mesoblast of the cephalic region shows the same general disposition as in the preceding stage (rostral mesoblast, R. Mes., and cheliceral, Chel. Mes., Figs. 75b-76c, 80a-d). The cheliceral mesoblast has grown laterad to some degree and also to some extent beneath the cheliceral ganglia (Fig. 76c), but is still separated from the stomodaeum. The thoracal mesoblastic sacs have grown little save that^ owing to the widening of the ventral sulcus, those of the right side have separated further from those of the left, and that those of the same side have come to meet each other longitudinally. Each abdominal appendage has a mesoblast sac with coelom {Ah. 5.b, Fig. 77) and so does the caudal lobe (Caud., Figs. 75a, 80e).

The entoblast in the stage of 97 hours has increased and is arranged in scattered groups of cells in the region of the abdominal appendages {Ent., Fig. 77) as well as in the caudal lobe (Ent., Fig. 75a) ; its disposition indicates continuing formation from the mesentoblast. In the stage of 108 hours it forms a nearly continuous sheet beneath the caudal lobe and the segments immediately anterior to this, seen best on median section {Ent., Fig. 80e) ; its nuclei are smaller and flatter than those of the splanchnic mesoblast {8 p. Mes.).

The extraembryonic blastoderm is continuing the process of proliferating blood cells, and as these cells separate from the blastoderm they migTate upon the yolk to get into the embryonic body. Figs. 75a and 75b show some blood cells {Bl.) still extraembryonic, and other larger ones that have moved beneath the caudal lobe. Fig. 80a exhibits a group of them developing just anterior to the head lobe, and Figs. 76a and 80c just lateral to it. Those that have reached the embryonic body lie for the most part between it and the yolk (or vitellocytes), but occasionally some occur within the mesoblast or even the coelom. There is no indication that any of the blood cells are mesoblastic or embryonic in orgin ; on the contrary, the centers of formation lie exclusively in the extraembryonic blastoderm, and the latter has now ceased to produce vitellocytes and is forming blood cells only.

The nerve ganglia of the stage of 97 hours are little diiferent fromthose of the preceding stage, but at 108 hours (Figs. 78, 79) they are hardly distinguishable on surface views. The cheliceral ganglia

320 Thos. H. Montgomery.

are to be seen in Figs. 7 Go, 80a, 80b, Cliel. G., and lie behind the mouth. The pair of the first abdominal segment are transversely wider than those of the other abdominal segments (Figs. 73, 74, PI. VI; 78, PL VII).

9. TJie Stage of Reversion.

Details of this stage are illustrated on PI. VIII, and the upper row of figures (81-86) represent the external conditions that may be described first.

On comparing Figs. 81-86 of this plate with Figs. 78, 79, PL VII, and Figs. 71-74, PL VI, it will be seen that reversion consists to great extent in a movement of the caudal lobe to a ventral position almost in line with the fourth pair of legs, together with a shortening of the abdomen. An earlier stage of the process is exhibited in Fig. 81, and a later in Fig. 82, while the amount of the movement may be appreciated by comparing Fig. 84 wdth Fig. 73. Several other changes are concomitant, to wit: (1) All the abdominal appendages come to lie in approximately the same transverse line with the caudal lobe (Fig. 82) ; (2) the ventral sulcus (Sul v.. Figs. 81, 82, 84) is much shortened and widened so as to be roughly triangular in outline with the base of the triangle resting against the abdomen; (3) the bases of the thoracal limbs are pushed much further dorsad; (4) the extraembryonic region has become obliterated save in the dorso-median line {H., Figs. 84-86).

The mechanical causes of reversion will be discussed under the heading, "Summary of Observations."

Previous to reversion the chelicera lay postoral, but now they are anterior even to the rostrum (Figs. 82, 83), as are their ganglia (Cliel. G., Figs. 83, 85). The relations of these ganglia to the stomodaeum is shown on longitudinal sections in Figs. 89, 90, 91a, and on transverse sections in Figs. 87a, b ; they embrace the stomodaeal tube laterally, are continued anteriorly (dorsally) to it, and are sinking below the ectoblast.

Other notable changes have been efi^eeted in the cephalic region. The mouth opening is reduced to a slit (^^o.^Fig. 82) ; the stomodaeum has grown inwards still deeper, it is shown in its full extent in Fig. 90, and its blind inner end is somewhat dilated. The rostrum is to be

The Development of Theridium. 321

seen on longitudinal section in Figs. 89-9 la and on surface views in Figs. 82, 83, 85 ; it has maintained its former position while the chelicera have pushed forward to its leve]. The cerebral ridges of the earlier stages have sunk beneath the surface to constitute the cerebral ganglia (C'e. G., Figs. 83, 85, 87a, b, 89-91a) ; they lie further dorso-posterior than the other parts of the brain, and each of them is curved, as best shown in Figs. 85 and 91a. Between them and the rostral surface lie the optic ganglia (Op/. G'., Figs. 83, 85, 89, 90) that have been formed by the union of the antero-lateral and postero-lateral vesicles (A. L. v., P. L. v., Fig. 87b). It is somewhat difficult to be sure of the precise relations of these cephalic ganglia on account of the folding and invagination they have undergone, and on the surface views rejiresented in Figs. 83 and 85 they are below the surface, and consequently somewhat obscured. But Fig. 89 indicates their relations on a longitudinal section, and Figs. 87a (in the j^lane of the stomodaeum) and 87b (anterior to this plane) on two oblique transverse sections of one embryo ; the latter two figures show that the cheliceral ganglia (Chel. G.) are nearest the midline and embrace the stomodaeum anteriorly and laterally, that the cerebral ganglia (Ce. G.) adjoin these dorso-laterally, and that the optic ganglia (A. L. V., P. L. F.) touch them ventro-laterally. All these ganglia, as those of the thorax, are developing neuropile (shown in the drawings by stippling).

At this stage appear the antero-median eyes, as ectoblastic infoldings above the rostrum (il/. E., Figs. 89, 91a).

In the thoracal region the legs exhibit about five joints apiece (Figs. 81-86), and the maxillary j)rocess of the pedipalps is well developed {Ped. M., Fig. 83). The dorsal surface view. Fig. 85, shows how the bases of these extremities have moved much further dorsad, and how by an ectoblastic dorsad growth the extraembryonic region has become reduced to the narrow band of the heart (//).

The abdominal region is shown on surface views in Figs. 81-80. Boundary lines between its component segments are seen as divisions in its lateral areas (Figs. 81, 84, 80) demarcating the anterior five segments. Of the four pairs of abdominal appendages (Figs. 81, 82, 84, 80) the third and fourth pairs {Ah. 41), Ah. 5h) are much the

322 Tbos. II. Montgomery.

largest, and these will form the spinnerets, but have not yet produced glandular ingrowths. The second pair of appendages are the smallest and are connected on each side by an oblique ridge with the first pair (Fig. 8G). The first pair of abdominal appendages, those of the second segment, are beginning to invaginate as the lung books ; it is interesting to note that primaiy lamellae arise simultaneously with the deepening of the lung sac, shown on surface view in Fig. 86, and on sections in Figs. 91c, 92, 93, Pul. C. denoting the lung cavity and Pul. L. the primary lamellae. Fig. 93 is a section through the fourth leg {L. 4), the first abdominal ganglion {Ab. 1 G.), the lung book and the third and fourth abdominal appendages {Ab. db. Ah. 4.b) ; and Fig. 91c through the lung book and a portion of the third abdominal segment (Ab. 3). Figs. 89 and 91a also exhibit the early lung books. Each lung book has three lamellae composed of ectoblast. The tail lobe at the earlier part of the reversion {Caud., Fig. 81) is still somewhat posterior to the appendages, but subsequently (Figs. 82, 84, 86) it moves forward to about their level. Its shape is seen best in Figs. 84 and 85, and its terminal apex is elevated above the surface of the embryo (Fig. 91b). This tail lobe represents the fusion of the caudal lobe proper (telson) with the three posterior abdominal segments. There is still no proctoda^al invagination.

The nerve ganglia of the thorax (Figs. 89, 91a) are contiguous, a composite of those of the pedipalps {Fed. G.) and the four legs (L. 1 G.-L. 4 G.). The first abdominal ganglion {Ah. 1 G., Fig. 89) seems to be fused with the other abdominal ganglia forming a compound ganglion united with the most posterior thoracal. All these ganglia are still connected with the superficial ectoblast.

All cephalic and thoracal mesoblast sacs are shown in Fig. 91a. The rostral sacs are the largest in the embryo {R. Coel., Figs. 87a, b, 89-91a), they bound the cerebral ganglia {Ce. G., Figs. 89, 91a) posteriorly and these and the cheliceral ganglia laterally (Fig. 87a), are continued into the rostrum {Bos., Figs. 89-91a) and along the dorso-anterior aspect of the stomodaeum. These are very voluminous sacs, but much folded by the invagination of the several parts of the brain. They meet in the midline within the rostrum and along the antero-dorsal border of the stomodaeum (Fig. 90), also dorso-posterior

The Development of Theritlium. 323

to the cerebral ganglia (Fig. 87a), where a cleft between them marks the cephalic end of the heart. In comparison with them the cheliceral sacs are small, but little larger than those of the thorax; they are seen on median section in Fig. Ola {Chel. Coel.) postero-lateral to the stomodaeum (Sto.) and they show a cellular thickening of the wall next this; what this thickening may represent I do not know, unless it be a portion of the poison gland. They are continuous with the rostral sacs only along the stomodaeum. Within the abdomen there are separate coelomic cavities for segments one to five inclusive, but with the fusion of the more posterior abdominal segments their mesoblast sacs have fused to compose a pair that extend into the caudal lobe; these may be detected on surface view (Caud., Fig. 82) and more clearly on transverse section (Coel., Fig. 87c).

With the movement of the caudal lobe and its consequent elevation above the abdominal area {Caud., Figs. 84, 86) it has come to include an axial tube of definitive entoblast. Fig. 87c, M. G., shows this mesenteron on transverse section bounded on either side by mesoblast, and Fig. 91b on longitudinal section. The latter figure illustrates how the inner end of this tube is continuous with a layer of entoblast (Ent.) next to the yolk (Vit.). The commencement of the mesenteron as a tubular structure is within the caudal lobe, and this tube is anteriorly continuous with a single interrupted entoblastic layer situated at the postero-ventral border of the yolk mass. At no other point in the embryo is there definitive entoblast, but at all places save in a portion of the head region the yolk is bordered by mesoblast ; in the head (Fig. 87a) the yolk is divided anteriorly by the rostral mesoblast sacs into a right and left moiety, each placed between a (more mesial) rostral sac and the (more lateral) thoracal sacs, and anteriorly each yolk moiety comes in contact with ectoblast (see the right side of Fig. 87b). Entoblast appears to be absent in the dorsal abdominal region.

The reversion of the embryo with the rapid growth of the dorsal margins of thorax and abdomen have produced the heart. This is lettered H in Figs. 82, 84-86, and is a dorso-median tube extending from the cerebral ganglia to the base of the caudal lobe. Intersegmental boundaries represent the beginning of its vessels, and these

324 Thos. H. Montgomery.

are to be seen in Figs. 84-86. At its anterior end, which will become the cephalic artery of the adult, it is bounded by the mesial walls of the rostral mesoblast sacs (Fig. 87a). In the embryo at reversion the pairs of ostia are more numerous than in the adult — about seven or eight in number. An earlier and a later stage in the heart development are shown in Figs. 88 and 87d, respectively, both being portions of transverse sections of the dorsal region. In Fig. 88 right and left coelomic sacs (Coel.), each with somatic {So. Mes.) and splanchnic layer (Sp. Mes.) have approximated, and in the midline between them is an archicoelic space, the heart (//), bounded ventrally by yolk (Vit.). This early heart space contains blood cells (Bl.) ; and the splanchnic mesoblast on each side of it is thickened to make the beginning of the walls of the heart tube. The later condition is shown in Fig. 87d; the heart cavity (H.) is now completely enclosed by splanchnic mesoblast, this being the heart wall, while the coelomic space on either side of it is the pericardial cavity. There is no doubt that at this stage the heart cavity is archicoelic, its wall of splanchnic mesoblast, and the pericardial cavity coelomic in origin. Within the heart lie two kinds of blood cells ; smaller cells, the origin of which I have not traced, though there seems to be no evidence of mesoblastic origin, and the large cells with chromidial nets whose history we have learned. Most of these larger cells are now, as before, archicoelic in position, placed between the yolk and the splanchnic mesoblast or between the ectoblast and the somatic mesoblast (Fig. 88). But occasionally they are found within the coelom, as is the case with the most right-hand one of Fig. 87d; this is not surprising, for the mesoblast is discontinuous at many points, and at any one of them a blood cell could pass from the archicoel into the coelom. These blood cells are for the most part dorso-median, within the heart, but many lie right and left of it (Figs. 88, 87d), at the anterior end of the heart there is a crowded mass of them (Fig. 87a) and others also in more lateral positions (Figs. 87a, b, 89-91a) between ectoblast and yolk. But anterior to the caudal lobe there are none in ventral position and relatively few far lateral from the dorso-median line, hence the reversion process has translocated most of them dorsad. The posterior end of the heart is drawn in Fig. 91b, where some of the blood

The Development of Theridium. 325

cells lie between the entoblast and the mesoblast. With the disappearance of the extraembryonic area formation of blood cells seems to end, or at least I found no new centers of proliferation, probably therefore new blood cells are from now on produced by division of the old ; perhaps the small cells within the heart have been formed in this way.

10. The Germ Cells.

I have given much time in the attempt to trace the origin of the germ cells, but have reached only inconclusive results. In my paper on the fertilization (1907) I described an extranuclear mass near one of the nuclei of the four-cell stage, and suggested that such a body might represent either abnormally placed chromosomes or else a normal chromatin exclusion. '"In no other cells of the two-cell, fourcell or eight-cell stage, either in the anaphase or the rest condition, were bodies like these found, so that it is fair to conclude that the two eggs first mentioned were abnormal." ISTow, I find extruded chromatin masses in most of the cells invaginating at the anterior cumulus, and some of these cells appear to originate within the cytoi^lasm structures somewhat similar to nuclei, a phenomenon that I propose to treat specially at another time; but similar bodies occur in what appear to be germ cells, so that their presence is not a sign of somatic differentiation.

No evidence of germ cell segregation could be found until the later portion of the gastrulation process, and then in the region of the blastopore of the anterior cumulus. In Fig. 28, PI. II, is exhibited a cell with a nucleus much larger than those of any other cells (G. C. ?) ; it borders on the gastrocoel, and may be the first definitive germ cell, but the only reason for so supposing is the great size of its nucleus. In the same situation is found a little later a gi'oup of eight cells immediately lining the gastrocoel {G. C. ?, Figs. 37b, 38b, PI. Ill) ; these are unbranched, thus differing from the early vitellocytes, they possess relatively clear nuclei and are much larger than the early mesentoblastic cells (Mes. E., Fig. 37a). With the obliteration of the gastrocoel and the flattening of the anterior cumulus these cells become indistinguishable, so that they either become branched like vitellocytes or else by division become as small as the mesento

326 Thos. H. Montgomery.

blast cells. At the stage of the early abdominal segments are found in the abdominal midline separated patches of small cells ( G. C. ?, Figs. 54, 56b, 61, PL V) ; these may be definitive entoblast, but differ from the entoblast of later stages in being branched and from the vitellocytes in their much smaller size, therefore they may be germ cells. In later stages I could not distinguish germ cells from entoblast, and the genital organs arise considerably later than the stage of reversion.

II. Summary of Observations With Comparison of the Literature.

11. Cleavage Up to Gastrulation.

The egg before segmentation show^s cytoplasm around the central pronuclei, and a delicate netw^ork, placed betw^een the yolk globules, connecting this central cytoplasmic mass with a fine peripheral layer. The yolk consists of an outer layer of radial pyramids and an inner layer of large granules not so disposed ; I have not specially studied the segmentation of the yolk during cleavage because the fixation employed coagulated the yolk in the earlier stages. Cleavage consists in repeated nuclear divisions, the nuclei as they become more numerous move nearer and nearer to the surface of the egg, vrhereby the central cytoplasmic mass divides into as many portions as there are nuclei and the intravitellar cytoplasmic network shortens until all nuclei and all cytoplasm become placed on the surface. During the earlier cleavage a central fluid mass forms in the egg. Inequality in rate of nuclear division commences at the 32-cell stage. At the stage of 140 cells all the nuclei have become superficial, equally numerous at all points on the surface, thus forming the early blastoderm. No nuclei remain in the yolk and no polarity of the egg can be distinguished up to this stage. On the blastoderm the ventral embryonic area (germ disc) becomes established by more rapid multiplication of nuclei in that region and by migration of other nuclei toward that pole; then for the first time appear distinct cell membranes, and these form gradually as the separate cytoplasmic masses come in apposition. The superficial cytoplasmic layer is not divided into cell areas before this period.

In much of the preceding work more attention had been given to

The Development of Thcridiiim. 327

the changes in the yolk pyramids than to the cytoplasm and nuclei. Claparede (1862) found the blastoderm to be at first a single layer of cells; and Salensky (1871, Theridium) and Ludwig (1876, Pliilodromiis) described the yolk pyramids and movement of the cleavage nuclei to the surface. Then Balbiani (1873, Agelena, Tegenaria, Epeira) studied the cleavage and concluded that the cleavage nuclei move into particular preformed cell territories of the superficial cytoplasmic layer (couche germinative) ; this particular conclusion of Balbiani's careful memoir has not been substantiated by subsequent students. Balfour (1880) believed each yolk segment to be a cell and the cytoplasm to consist of an envelope for each nucleus and a reticulum around the yolk granules. Sabatier (1881) has added nothing of importance to our knowledge. Locy (1886, Agelena) showed that the supposed cell territories of Balbiani are the result of the pressure of yolk columns upon the superficial blastema, and that these do not come to coincide with the later blastoderm cells; he found also that the cleavage nuclei reach one pole of the egg first, that called by him the "animal-pole," and that all the nuclei are derivatives of a single original one. He is the only observer to note a polarity of the egg before cleavage : "One hemisphere is characterized by small yolk corpuscles packed closely together, though not joined in masses, and the other by agglomerations of larger yolk corpuscles."

Morin (1887) described a central cytoplasmic mass with fine strands radiating from it, showed that at the eight-cell stage the yolk divides into eight equal masses placed around a cleavage cavity ; then these divide further following division of their nuclei, forming rosettes, and ultimately all the cells reach the surface of the egg. Schimkewitsch (1887) corroborated in some points Ludwig and Locy, found that the number of yolk pyramids at the end of the cleavage varies with the species; there is no independent superficial layer of cytoplasm, but the protoplasm occupies the center of the egg; later (1898) he showed, correcting his conclusions of 1887, that all the cleavage nuclei reach the surface to form the blastoderm, none remaining within the yolk. Kishinouye (1890) calls the central cytoplasm the "centroplasm," and the peripheral, the "periplasm,"

328 Tlios. II. Montgomery.

lie finds that tlie yolk columns are as numerous as the nuclei, and that at a stage of about 30 cells all the cells reach the surface to constitute the blastoderm, their cytoplasm masses then fusing with the periplasm.

12. Gastrulation and Formation of the Germ Layers. There first forms a thickening of the germ disc at a point slightly posterior to its center, this is the anterior cumulus, and it becomes only slightly elevated above the surface of the egg. It is at first circular, with a shallow circular gastrocoel, and rapid cell proliferation takes place from it. This anterior cumulus proliferates first vitellocytes, branched highly vacuolated cells that ingest yolk rapidly and some of which sink into the yolk, while most wander along its surface just beneath the germ disc; and second, mesoblast and mesentoblast cells that scatter upon the surface of the yolk. A second or posterior cumulus arises j)osterior to the former and somewhat later in time, usually at the posterior edge of the germ disc ; it is more elevated and prominent, and its thin anterior border marks the future thoracoabdominal boundary; it has no gastrocoel and proliferates only vitellocytes. The two cumuli become later connected by movement of vitellocytes between them. Still other vitellocytes arise at the anterior anie Entwickelung des Spinnapparates bei Trochosa siii.i;:()ri(Misis Laxiii. niit Beriiclisicbtigung der Abdoiiuiialanliiige und der Fliigel bei den Insekten. Jena. Zeit. Natnrw., 30.

KiSHiNOUYE, K., 1890. On tbe Development of Araneina. Jonni. Coll. Sc. Japan 4.

1894. Note on tbe Coelomic Cavity of tbe Spider. Ibid., G.

KoKSCHELT, E., and Heider, K.. 1891. Lebrbncb der vergleicbenden Entwicklungsgescbicbte der wirbellosen Tliiere. Specieller Tbeil. 2tes Heft. Jena.

Lendl. a., 1886. Ueber die morpbologiscbe Bedeutmig der Gliedmassen bei den Spinueu. Math. Nat. Ber. Ungarn, 4.

LocY, W. A., 1886. Observations on tbe Development of Agelena naevia. Bull. Univ. Harvard, 12.

LuDWiG, 1876. Ueber Bildiuig des Blastoderms bei den Spinnen. Zeit. wiss. Zool., 26.

Montgomery, T. H., Jr., 1906. The Oviposition, Cocooning and Hatching of an Aranead, Tberidivim tepidariorimn, C. Kocb. Biol. Bull., 12.

— 1907. On tbe Maturation Mitoses and Fertilization of tbe Egg

of Tberidium. Zool. Jabrb., 25.

MoRiN, J., 1887. Zur Iilntwicklungsgescbicbte der Spinnen. Biol. Centralbl., 6.

1888. (Studien iiber Entwicklung der Spinnen) Abb. (Sapiski)

Neuriiss. Ges. Naturf. Odessa, 1.3. (Russian.)

Pappenheim, p. 1903. Beitrjige sur Kenntnis der Entwicklungsgescbicbte von Dolomedes fimbriatus Clerck., etc. Zeit. wiss. Zool., 74.

Plateau, F., 1866. Observations sur I'Argyronete aquatique. Ann. Sci. Nat, 7.

PoKROwsKY, 1899. Nocb oln I'aar Kopflifk-ker bei den Spinnenembi-yonen. Zool. Anz., 22.

Purcell, F., 1895. Note on tbe Development of tbe Lungs, Entapopbyses, Traclie:e and Genital Dvicts in Spiders. Zool. Anz., 18.

Sabatier, A., 1881. Formation du blastoderme cbez les Araneides. C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris, 92.

Salensky, W., 1871. (Developpement des Araneides) Abb. (Sapiski) Ges. Naturf. Kiew, 2. (Russian.)

ScHiMKEWiTSCH, W., 1884. Zur Entwicklungsgescbicbte der Araneen. Zool. Anz., 7.

1887. Etude sur le developpement des Araignees. Arcb. Biol., 6.

- 1890. Sur la signification des cellules vitellines cbez les Tracbeates. Zool. Anz., 13.

The Development of Theridium. 351

SciiiMKEWiTSCH, W., 1897. Ueber die Eutwicklung cles Dariiicanals bei einigeii Arachniden. Trav. Soe. Natural. Petersburg.

1906. Ueber die Entwickluug vou Thelyplionus caudatus (L) ver glichen iiiit derjenigeu eiuiger auderer Aracliniden. Zeit. wiss. Zool., SI.

Simmons, O. L., 1S94. Developmeut of the Lungs of Spiders. Amer. Journ. Sci. (2), 48. Ann. Mag. N. H. (G), 14. Tufts Coll. Studies, 2.

Wallstabe, p., 1908. Beitriige zur Kenntnis der Entwicklungsgeschichte der Araneinen, etc. Zool. Jalirb., 26.


All the drawings are made with the camera lucida, and in the greater number the yolk has been represented by simple shading. The arrow on some of the figures points to the anterior (cephalic) pole. The following abbreviations Iiave been employed :

Ab. 1-Ab. 8, Abdominal segments 1-8.

Ab. 2. B-Ab. 5, B., limb buds of abdominal segments 2-5.

Ab. G. 1-Ab. G. 6, abdominal ganglia 1-6.

A. L. v., antero-lateral vesicle.

Bl, blood-cell.

Gaud., caudal lobe (telson).

Cav., central fluid cavity within yolk.

Cav. B., outer boundary of this cavity.

Ce. G., cerebral ganglion.

Ceph., cephalic lobe.

Ce. R., cerebral ridge.

Chel., cheliceron.

Chel. Coel., cheliceral coelom.

Chel. G., cheliceral ganglion.

Chel. Mes., cheliceral mesoblast.

Coel., coelom.

Cum. A., anterior cumulus.

Cum. P., posterior cumulus.

Cyt., cytoplasm.

Ect., ectoblast.

Ent., definite entoblast.

Ex., extraembryonic blastoderm.

Fov., fovea semicircularig.

Gang., ganglion.

Gast., gastrocoel.

G. B., peripheral boundary of germ disc.

G. C? germ cell.

H., heart.

L. 1-L. 4., ambulatory appendages (or their segments).

352 Thos. II. Montgomery.

L. 1. G.-L. 4. G., ganglia of ambulatory appendages.

M. E., median eye.

Med. L., median line.

Mes., mesoblast.

Mes. E., mesentoblast.

M. G., midgut.

Opt. O., optic ganglion.

Peel., pedipalp.

Ped. G., pedipalpal ganglion.

Ped M., maxillary plate of pedipalp.

P. L. v., postero-lateral vesicle.

Pr., prominence of antero-lateral vesicle.

Pill. C, invagination cavity of lung book.

Pul. L., lamellae of lung book.

R. Coel., rostral coelom.

R. Mes.. rostral mesoblast.

Ros., rostrum.

So. Mes., somatic mesoblast.

8p., accessory sperm nuclei.

8p. Mes., splanchnic mesoblast.

8to., stomodaeum.

Sto. L., lateral lip of stomodaeum.

8ul. A., sulcus anterior.

Sul. v., ventral sulcus.

Th. Ab., boundary of thorax and abdtmien.

Vit., vitellus (yolk).

Vit. C, vltellocyte (yolk cell).


Fig. 1. — Section of egg of 5 hours, 2-oell stage, only a portion of cytoplasmic meshwork shown. X 142.

Fig. 2. — Segment of section of egg, 5i/i hours, early 4-cell stage, meshwork of cytoplasm not shown. X 142.

Fig. 3. — Composite drawing from sections of egg of 7Mj hours, S-cell stage, yolk not shown. X 142.

Fig. 4. — Segment of one section of the preceding egg. X 142.

Fig. 5. — Composite drawing from section of egg of ca. 10% hours, 16-cell stage, yolk not shown, peripheral layer only of cytoplasm reproduced. X 142.

Fjg. 0. — Segment of one section of preceding egg. X 142.

Fig. 7. — Composite drawing from section of egg of 11 hours, about 32-cell stage, yolk not shown, peripheral layeft- only of cytoplasm reproduced. X 142.

Fig. 8. — Surface view of one hemisphere of an egg of 12 hours, stage of (JO-70 cells ; few of the cells have reached the superficial layer of cytoplasm. X 142.

Fig. 9. — Segment of a section of an egg of the stage of Fig. 10. X 142.

Fig. 10. — Surface view of one hemisphere of an egg of 11% hours, stage of ca. 130-140 cells in superficial position, x 142.

Fig. 11. — Similar view of an egg of 14 hours, stage of ca. 300 cells. X 142.

The Development ok 'J'iierioium.


,:^i^^fy "'







The .TotiiNAi. fir MDni'iioi.om-.— Vol, XX, Xd. 2,





a '■'




- Sp.









■ * -•*-




Fig. 12. — Surface view of one side of egg of 1914 hours, 173 cells shown on this surface. X 142.

Fig. 13. — Portion of section through an egg of the same stage as the preceding, showing the ventral pole. X 142.

Fig. 14. — Section through anterior cumulus of an egg of 21 hours, only 2 cells invaginated. X 360.

Fig. 15. — Surface view of ventral pole of an egg of 24 hours, 417 cells shown on this surface, at the lower part of the figure the cells appear most crowded because that portion of the germ disc is most convex. The cells have short intercellular processes that are not drawn. X 142.

Fig. 16. — Somewhat oblique cross section of egg of 24 hours, through the anterior cumulus, less than 12 cells invaginated. X 142.

Fig. 17. — Somewhat oblique cross section through anterior cumulus of egg of 24 hours, about 8 cells invaginated. X 300.

Fig. 18. — Ventral view of unstained germ disc seen in alcohol, 22 hours. X 30.

Fig. 19. — Cross section of anterior cumulus of an egg of 22 hours, 12-13 cells invaginated. X 360.

Fig. 20. — Cross section of an egg of ca. 26 hours. X 142.

Fig. 21. — Cross section through anterior cumulus of an egg of ca. 26 hours, about 25 cells invaginated. X 360.

Fig. 22. — Somewhat oblique ventral view of germ disc of 28 hours, somewhat more than 500 cells shown. X 142.

Fig. 23. — Surface view of unstained germ disc of 30 hours, seen in alcohol. X 30.

Fig. 24. — Cross section of anterior cumulus of an egg of 30 hours. X 360,

Fig. 25. — Oblique cross section of anterior cumulus, egg of 30 houi's. X 360.

Fig. 20. — Surface latero-ventral view of germ disc, of 30i/^ hours, with two artificial breaks in its side ; the inner bounding line of each cumulus shows how deep its cells project into the yolk ; 268 cells shown, x 142.

Fig. 27 Median section through both cumuli of germ disc, 30^^ hours.

X 142. Fig. 28. — Median section through anterior cumulus, 30^/^ hours. X 360.

Fig. 29. — Surface view of unstained germ disc, seen in alcohol, 54 hours (same stage as Fig. 30). X 30.

The Develoi'mk.nt of Tiieridum.


Cum A

C.tm A

l/'f VitC





G C f r

TiiK Jurii.s.u, OK 5Iuiii'iic.r,M,;v.— Voi,. xx, Nu




Cum. A


C 3

Cum. P ' ■':■ y'^'^'i: .

Cum. A



Gaff 25.



.^ Cyt


Oasf VitC. Vit

Cum 4












Cum P

V :> 1^.^ ».

28 ^'C.


luin A

Cum A - ■ ■

Cu'i, P '. ^ _ J



PLATE III. Figs. 30, A, B. — Oblique longitudinal section, of germ disc of ca. 54 hours, A, through posterior cumulus (but to one side of anterior cumulus), B, lateral from both cumuli. X 142.

Fig. 31. — Cross section through middle of germ disc of egg of ca. 54 hours ; vitellocytes forming from anterior cumulus and from lateral marginal germ disc. X 142.

Fig. 32. — Surface view of germ disc of ca. 54 hours, seen in alcohol. X 30. Fig. 33. — Similar view of germ disc of ca. 50 hours, x 30.

Fig. 34.— Ventral surface view of egg of ca. 37 hours, the shaded area marking the region of axial cell invagination ; 1222 cells on surface of the germ disc. X 142.

Fig. 35. — Cross section of posterior cumulus ca. 37 hours. X 360.

Fig. 36. — Longitudinal section of posterior cumulus ca. 37 hours, x 360.

Figs. 37 A. B. — Oblique cross sections of anterior cumulus of an egg of ca. 37 hours. X 360.

Fig. 38 A. — Oblique longitudinal section of germ disc through the anterior cumulus, ca. 37 liours. x 142.

Fig. 38 B. — Section of the anterior cumulus of the egg shown in the preceding figure, drawn to larger scale. X 360.

Fig. 39. — Cross section of germ disc at anterior edge of anterior cumulus, ca. 37 hours. X 142.

Figs. 40 A, B. — Ventral surface views of a germ disc of ca. 49 hours ; A, shows the nuclei of the superficial cells (1441 in number) ; and B, the nuclei of the larger cells (69 in number) that have sunk below the former and spread out upon the surface of the yolk. X 142.

Fig. 41 A. — Exact median section of an egg of ca. 49 hours. X 142.

Figs. 41 B, C. — Two other longitudinal sections of the preceding egg, both in the region of the anterior cumulus. X 360.




r, B



c . ". /

30 B

17/ C


37 A ■ /Vf.f.




39. i//yc



Cum J

33. ^ CumP




37 B.




^•* '










38 B


XT, ..!■ M"iiriioLor.Y.— Vol.. Nx, Nn. ;


Cum P' f-fes-E

40 B



Cum A





Cum P




Th Ad ■■:■ \

". !■• '. *■*

Cum A


t Vi-^C

,■■/,- 5 f


PLATE IV. Fig. 42 A. — Median section of germ disc of ca. 49 hours. X l^-Fig. 42 B. — Posterior portion of the same section. X 300.

Figs. 43 A-C. — Portions of cross sections of an egg of ca. 49 hours ; A, in midline anterior to anterior cumulus ; B, in lateral region ; C, at posterior cumulus. X 360.

Fig. 44. — Surface view of unstained germ disc of ca. 49 hours, seen in alcohol. X 30.

Fig. 45. — Ventral view of germ disc with 4 protozonites, 60l^ hours. X ^0. Fig. 46. — Ventral view of germ disc with 5 protozonites, 60 hours. X 60. Fig. 47. — Lateral view of embryo with 5 protozonites, 60 hours. X 30.

Fig. 48. — Oblique longitudinal section of embryo with 5 protozonites, 00 hours. X 142.

Figs. 49 A, B. — Portions of cross sections of an embryo of 60i/4 hours; A. through extraembryonic area ; B, through half of the germ disc in the plane of a protozonite. X 360.

Figs. 50 A-C. — Portions of median sections of germ disc of 00% hours. A, cephalic lobe region ; B, caudal lobe region ; C, through two of the anterior protozonites. X 300.

Fig. 51. — Oblique latero-ventral surface view, 00^^ hours, first appearance of appendages, x 60.

Fig. 52. — Oblique latero-ventral surface view, ca. 02 hours, x 60.

Fig. 53. — Lateral surface view, ca. 02 hours, x ^

The DE\ELOP.\rK.\r of Thkkiihim.

TiH's 1!, .\n»NTi;o,\[i:i;v.

v,tc V,fX



C<.w P



yif.L •'/'.'■■ . Caud



//> Ah 4-8 L 3




42. B.



Vif.C. LA



49 A

■ • • * •




fc^ 43 B


v,fc 43. c.

Cum R 4.4._



49. B, A'^iT./^ MedL

G.b ■ •:.

/p/Vw ■ '^

50 A.







The .IniiiN.\L of Moi!pnoi,oi;v,— Yiil. XX Ky •'>

^J z.- .53 50.C.


/7; 4b

50. B ^c^ ^p.f


Fig. 54. — Cross section of caudal lobe in it's posterior half, ca. 62 hours. X 360.

Fig. 55. — Portion of cross section through third or fourth pair of thoracal lihibs, ca. 62 hours. X 360.

Figs. 50 A, B. — Median section of posterior region of embryo of ca. 62 hours, the posterior end of the caudal lobe represented in B continuous with the right end of the portion of the section of A. x 360.

Fig. 56 C. — Median section of cephalic region of the embryo shown in Figs. 56 A, B. X 360.

Fig. 56 D.— Longitudinal section of pedipalp of the same embryo. X 360.

Fig. 57. — Lateral surface view, 73 hours, x CO.

Fig. 58. — Oblique dorso-lateral view, ca. 75 hours, x ^^■

Fig. 59. — Oblique antero-lateral surface view, ca. 75 hours, x ^0.

Fig. 60 A. — Longitudinal section of the region where cephalic and caudal lobes meet, 73 hours. X 360.

Fig. 60 B.— Longitudinal section of portion of head lobe, chelicerou and pedipalp, of the same embryo. X 360.

Fig. 61.— Cross section of a little more than one-half of an abdominal segment, ca. 75 hours. X 360.

Fig. 62. — Portion of cross section of thorax, showing one limb and its ganglion, ca. 75 hours. X 360.

Fig. 63. — Lateral surface view, ca. 80i^ hours, x 60.

Fig. 64. — Oblique dorso-anterior surface view, ca. 86 1^ hours, x 60.

Fig. 65. — Oblique ventral surface view of cephalothorax, ca. 86^2 hours. X CO.

Fig. 66. — Ventral view of abdomen, ca. S6i^ hours, x GO.

TlIK PkVKI.OI'MKM- ok TriKRlDUJl. TllOS. II. MONreO.Mi;i!V,



JD Mes

y- ^ *'.v?y>v-,^-;. '• jt>^

54 6T' ^^^

. ilest


., 3'*'

Med ,






.'Vh \-^^


57 L^ L,



Let •■•/.-., •,-2w/» ir*^^

56. D.

/5i5^. 4ii).j



Cod Sc'--^^


VifC Me%E £cf


bC ?


/? A/i



Ped ■



Caud f

^^-* /1A3






L 4.







' I 2.


L 3.

Chel. pg.'

/ ,



Che: Mes

56 C

Chel Mes o I ISp^es- r,

60. B. ^^^ls.//e. ^


60.A.i Ri^g^


Ab.iAb.zB -■■■ /lb.3B-rSb4S. ': '







4b S,

',C ■ neJL

Suli Chel

hel Ci. ■ Ceph.


Ceph L 46.6

^'^ 66

Ce.R. '^b.s. Tin: JdciiN.vi. ,,1- .M,,i:n :v \-.., XN N,

Sul I


CeR.. ■■ ;





s.u 5

Ped. ciu'l.G

Ah 7 AbsB Abe • ihe., ^iOs Coud^ ' 4b4.3..r,

Ab3.ll .-Ab.6.3

•■: • , . ■.-■■r^b^&

fcf nesE So. Mes





/ A /. ^ L 3



lb 0.1. Sul V Cuii<^


6 6

So Ales

PLATE VI. Fig. 67 A. — Somewhat oblique longitudinal section of cephalic region, ca. 861/2 hours. X 360.

Fig. 67 B. — Longitudinal section of the same embryo through the lateral edge of the stomodaeum. X 360.

Fig. 67 C- — Longitudinal section through extraembi*yonic blood-forming area of the same stage. X 720.

Figs. 68 A-C. — Transverse sections of cephalic lobe of embryo of 86% hours ; A; through rostral extremities ; B, through stomodaeum ; C, through anterolateral vesicle in the same plane as Fig. A. x 360.

Fig. 68 D.^ — Transverse section of the same embryo, the rostral appendages above, a pair of thoracal legs below. X 142.

Fig. 68 E. — Portion of left half of preceding drawing, on higher scale. X 360.

Fig. 68. F. — Cross section of same embryo, cephalic lobe anterior to the rostrum. X 142,

Fig. 68 G. — Cross section of the same embryo, lateral margin of head lobe and blood-forming region of extraembryonic area, x 720.

Fig. 69. — Longitudinal section through abdomen, 86% hours. X 360.

Fig. 70. — Longitudinal section of the fourth leg and first abdominal segment, 86% hours. X 360.

Fig. 71. — Oblique antero-lateral surface view, ca. 97 hours, x ^■

Fig. 72. — Anterior surface view, ca. 97 hours, x 60.

Fig. 73. — Lat'ero-posterior surface view, ca. 97 hours. X 60.

Fig. 74. — Ventro-posterior surface view, ca. 97 hours, x 60.

Tut: DKVKLor.MKxr of ■J'iiKuir)iiM.

Tims. II. .MO.M-liO.MEKV.




art' ■'» ^V»,

w ^^-'"'V'^ ^cvw^^-. \^^'^:^»i^

i/) f'ies

SoMes Ce.fi f-o,j






Vif.C R.Ccel

' Cot'

R if Si



So A/fi

■L\ Gb

68. B. 5/v /p,, 68. A.

Spflea j-.







Sl/v ' 6or><^ 68 D


6 P

58 E '*

i^c/ 5.1 ;Vm

Leu f. n Coad Ce^f^

68. F

i,c ,7« 


■C OS.

• .■■.»■«'» » 69 ^b?


'■les E ^'*S



(fe./f -^


V/V« 5o./Vf, f"


Ect SoNes.

Ped Li

Ceph l-P

L3 , '

Ab- 1








■ ^ ' Sul I


/'A 6"/,


Z4 Zj

L e

Z / AbAB ^^^!^^^ Ab6.3.

Ab^B ^ Ab.G.4

Ab6 Ab.G.e.AbGs

The .loiiiNAi. „i.- .M„iriMioi.,„;Y..-VoL. .\.\, Nu. :;.

PLATE VII. Fig. 75 A.- — Somewhat oblique lougitudiual section of posterior portion of abdomen, ca. 97 hours, x 360.

Fig. 75 B. — Similar section of head region and caudal lobe of the same embrj'o. X 142.

Figs. 76 A-C- — Cross sections of embryo of ca. 97 hours ; A, through head lobe anterior to rostrum ; B, through stomodaeum ; C, through chelicera. X 142.

Fig. 77. — Cross secction of abdomen in plane of the fifth segment, ca. 97 hours. X 360.

Fig. 78. — Postero-ventral surface view, ca. 108 hours. X 60.

Fig. 79. — Antero-ventral surface view, ca. 108 hours, x 60.

Figs. 80 A-E.^ — Oblique longitudinal sections of an embrj'o of ca. 108 hours ; A, through cheliceron and postero-lateral vesicle. X 300. B, through stomodaeum. x 142. C, through antero-lateral vesicle. X 142. D, through fovea and lateral wall of stomodaeum. X 142. E, through posterior end of abdomen. X 360.

Tm; DKVKi.oi'.NfKM OK TniKinuM.

•riii>s. 11, ,M(i.vTi;(jjiKirv.

i/lfC. Bl ^"'^"^ 'f'"' ^'^^

)3 Mk

Caud , '•*




^pMes . ^' ^'^-^ M MC


77. >?4 6 5 . . ■ /J^tf5 ^•'^^


i a

i 3



Ab?b- 1^

Ab^B--^ Absb Abe

Chel Me% Che/ o:

/^^ ^,f Fov^ ^'-^

V« '■" Sh


-aud 78

79 '^^---^'■■'*^

Z -; Sulv



75 B.


CMQ^" 76 C

\ Li




-O.B £cf. AL.V.




I / ^ ,'




^^ sfo.L sto Sfo.L 76. B.

W/C, CA./^., f^^es ^^0^' SI.

'^•'.fi^\'^ti:if^'i^r 80 A



So lies

■"' ///.(f.

G5. '.-* Cop/

r,^ ^ •//Cm"!!'*',.**

fiOE ,,,,^

Cof/ VuT.. XX. N„

^i 6.6

5/0 '^.^^

80.D ^^'



R flu '■' ^

P/ 1/

fcA 80.C.



r/7f/c 5/-0 I 80 B.



Fig. 81. — Obliqne ventro-posterior surface view, ca. 98 hours, x 60.

Fig. 82. — Ventral surface view, ca. 98 hours, x GO.

Fig. 83. — Cephalic surface view, 120 hours. X 60.

Fig. 84. — Oblique lateral surface view, ca. 98 hours, x 60.

Fig. 85. — Dorsal surface view, ca. 98 hours, x ^0.

Fig. 86. — Oblique dorso-posferior view, ca. 127 hours, x 60.

Fig. 87 A. — Oblique cross section of cephalic region, ca. 98 hours. X ^42.

Fig. 87 B. — Oblique cross section of the same embryo, on the right in the plane of a cheliceron, on the left anterior to the cheliceron. x 142,

Fig. 87 C. — Oblique cross section of the caudal lobe of the same embryo. X 360.

Fig. 87 D. — Oblique cross-section of the heart (dorsal) region of the same embryo; the left-hand edge of the figure is near the base of a thoracal limb. X 360.

Fig. 88. — Cross section of heart region, ca., 98 hours. X 360.

Fig. 89. — Longitudinal section of an embryo of ca. 127 hours, x 142.

Fig. 90. — Oblique longitudinal section through cephalic region, ca. 98 hours. X 142. Fig. 91 A Longitudinal section, ca, 98 hours. X 142.

Fig. 91 B. — Longitudinal section of caudal lobe of the same embryo. X 360.

Fig. 91 C. — Longitudinal section of lung book region of the same embryo. X 360.

Fig. 92. — Longitudinal section of lung book cut to one side of its mesoblast sac, ca. 127 hours. X 360.

Fig. 93. — Section through the posterior thoracal and the first four abdominal segments, 120 hours. X 142.

The Devci.oi'mkxt tn' Tiikkiuilm.

Tims. II. .Mi..\TK(i.Mi;i;v.


Ped ^^'- ^f



Hh ] A Ahs6 81 '^"'^

»^ L.z '



PedM L











L 2.


L ^


Ab.38 L3

-Su! .



Ab.s B



S,;, 83.



li- 85





CheiG R.Coel

87 D.

Vit VitC -S>'fe Coel ^'




14. B

Vit : 37 C.

Bl SoMes Coel



QQ V-^« ;^ J/'W^ ^'1

PulC PuLL 4oG.:^

Sf'ries 91 C,

87 B

Pu/ L PulC

.•I Coel

R.Cot, Pfid'



■46 6? *'/*!*•'*".'/.'<♦..

92 Ate


5^ C/,^/ Ped Q7.A


til f> Cue/

CeG O/jf.C

/ib.sR Pul.C j^,^





Ab G !


Ped G


OptG V

Chel 6

P.Co>:, Pus ■

del Ped

i/'h^-'._, ■ Ce.G

St-o Coel Coel Cr.t^ ^oe,

- ■ CheIG '■\ Pgd.Q



■ d62

13 l-iG.

93. C,e/.




ScHes —





91 B ^"^

B! tni

TnK Jill nxAL OF iluid'HoLoui.-^ Vol. XX, No.




I. Introduction 354

II. Structure of the egg 354

a. Cytoplasm 354

b. Nuclear fluid 350

c. Nucleolus and chromatin diminution 358

III. Centriole and centrosome 3<il

a. Centriole 301

b. Centrosome 302

c. History of the centriole in fertilization and in cleavage. . . . .'!i!T

1. Sperm centriole 307

a. Observations 307

b. Literature and general remarks 371

2. Cleavage centriole 373

d. Division of the centrosome 374

1. Observations 374

2. Types of centrosome division 370)

3. Cycle of centrosome 379

IV. Rays and spindle 380

a. Terminology 380

b. Observations 381

V. Cytodieresis 384

a. Observations 384

1. Movement of chromosomes and centres 384 •

2. Spindle 385

3. Centrosome 385

^I wish to express my obligation to Professor Wilson for his advice and suggestion during the progress of this work and the preparation of this paper,

and to Professor Kingsley, Director of the Ilarpswell Laboratory, for his continued kindness during my stay at his laboratory.

The .Toiirnal of MonnioLOCY.— Vol. XX. No. 3.

■{54 Naoliide Yatsii.

4. Rays 387

r». Cell c'oiistructiou and uiid-body o87

b. General remarks 388

VI. Formation of the polocytes , 392

VII. Summary 393

VIII. Literatm-e 396

I. Introduction. It is nine years since Coe ('99) wrote bis excellent paper on the maturation and fertilization of the egg of Cerebratulus marginatus Renier. The remarkable advance of our knowledge of the achromatic structure of the cell attained during this time has made it desirable to re-examine some of the most important phenomena in the nemertine egg; for it is one of the most favorable objects for cjtological study. Five years ago Professor Wilson suggested to me to make a careful study of maturation, fertilization and early cleavage stages of the egg of Cerebratulus lacteus, partly in order to clear up some disputed cytological problems and partly to give a morphological basis for my work on experimental cytology and embryology.

The materia], from which the results of the present paper were obtained, consists of several complete series of the early developmental stages of the egg of Cerchraluhis lacteus put up by Professor Wilson and Dr. Sutton in the summer of 1902, at South Harpswell, Maine. A few lots treated with some salt solutions were fixed by the writer, and were made use of for the sake of comparison. To supplement the general discussion a few results obtained from the study of the e^g of Asterias forhesii have been incorporated.^

II. Structure of the Egg.

(a) Cytoplasm. The cytoplasm of the egg of C. lacteus, as in maiiy other forms, shows an alveolar structure, consisting of fine yolk drops of fairly

-I am under sreat obligation to Dr. H. M. Smitli and other members of the Biological Laboratory of the United States Fisli Commission at Wood's Hole, where my cytological woi-k on the starfish egg was partly carried out in the sunnner of 1902.

Ookinesis in Ccrebratiilus Lacteus. 355

constant size snspended in hyaloplasm. The former can readily be seen in the living egg, while the latter can bo observed only in sections stained either with Delafield's hsematoxylin (which stains hyaloplasm only) or with iron-hsematoxylin, thoroughly extracted, and erythrosin as a counter-stain. Very young eggs stain dark, since they are made up almost entirely of hyaloplasm (cf. Wilson '99, p. 11). As I have not been able to make out any space between the yolk drop and hyaloplasm, the yolk drop itself represents alveolar substance, and is not contained in a distinct alveolar substance as Coe maintains ('99, p. 434). The yolk drop of the nemertine egg has, I think, a much greater power of withstanding the action of acetic-sublimate than that of the echinoderm egg, in which, under the same treatment, the alveolar substance is found completely dissolved. It is extremely difficult to determine the relative viscosity of the yolk drops and hyaloplasm. The latter, however, seems to me more fluid than the former, for the reason that, when the egg is crushed, the hyaloplasm flows out more readily than the yolk drops (Mrs. Andrews, '97, p. 82; Wilson, '99, p. 7, and his PI. T, Fig. 7), and the polocytes do not contain in our case any yolk drops at all.

In the egg prior to the dissolution of the germinal vesicle one observes very readily, in sections as well as in the living state, that the yolk drops are disposed radially (PL I, Fig. 1) (cf. Bambeke, '98, Fig. 7, PI. 25, p. 537 ; Giardina, '02, pp. 564-565 ; Gerould, '06, p. 82). This arrangement may indicate some nuclear activity upon the cytoplasm. After the germinal vesicle has faded this is disturbed by the mixture of the nuclear fluids and cytoplasm; some of the yolk drops pass into the nuclear area, while the nuclear fluid flows out into the cytoplasm. Thus the cytoplasm becomes richer in hyaloplasm even as far as the periphery, the yolk granules being less crowded than they were before. The amount of hyaloplasm in

^lu the living egg of ecliinodernis Mathews observed that the cytoplasm is not alveolar but granular ('O(i). The term "alveole" has not been understood as a "hole," as he defines it, (p. 143), and its contents, the alveolar substance, differs markedly in the degree of viscosity ranging from thin watery drops to highly viscous yolk granules, (cf. Mrs. Andrews, '97, p. 14). The term alveolar may, therefore, be apijlied to the echinoderm egg without causing any inconvenience.

356 Naohide Yatsii.

the cytoplasm is consequently much greater than is needed to maintain the alveolar structure. The cytoplasmic maturation of Delage, ('01), may mean that the cytoplasm becomes overloaded with the hyaloplasm. This is a favorable, if not absolutely necessary, condition for the formation of astral rays as correctly recognized by Mathews ('07, p. 5)7). In this connection one interesting fact may be mentioned, that is, before the dissolution of the germinal vesicle the spermatozoon remains as such in the egg, either the formation of the sperm aster or the swelling of the sperm head being suspended (Fol, '79). Ziegler observed in the egg of a nematode that the spermatozoon degenerates, when it enters an enucleated fragment from the egg with the germinal vesicle intact ('95, p. 363). Flemming's observation ('91) that the dividing cells of the salamander epithelium stain darker than the resting ones may show that before the reconstruction of the nucleus the cytoplasm is richer in hyaloplasm.'*

(b) Nuclear Fluid.

In the living egg the nuclear fluid appears as a homogeneous liquid, not an emulsion of the difFerent fluids as in the cytoplasm. Neither reticular nor alveolar structure is visible. In sections, however, the nuclear substance gives an entirely different aspect from what is seen in the living state. As is shown in Fig 10 (PI. I) the germinal vesicle is traversed by an irregular network. The meshes are not complete ; many free ends of the branches can be observed. The apparent reticular structure of the nuclear fluid is, I think, simply an artifact produced by coagulation. Although there are many cases in which the nucleus actually contains reticulum or alveoles, e. g., in the protozoan nucleus, yet in a good many cases the homogeneity of the nuclear fluid has not been correctly recognized (cf. Henneguy, '96, p. 106, Rhumbler, '96).

It is interesting to note that the nuclear fluid changes its nature the moment the nucleus begins to fade (cf. Lillie, '06, p. 166). Fig. 2 and 3 (PI. I) show this relation very clearly. The nuclear fluid

^Throughout the present paper the figures are from the preparations of Cerehratulus lactciis, luiless otherwise mentioned.

Ookinesis in Cerebratuhis l.actons. 357

is now fonnd precipitated in the form of floccnlent masses, as though another kind of proteid had entered the nuclear area, and had mixed with the nuclear fluid. The precipitated granules are of fairly largo size. They take a strong haimatoxylin stain, and in this respect they resemble chromatin (basichromatin). Yet that they do not contain any basichromatin at all, is demonstrated by Auerbach's method, with which they take a strong fuchsin stain. There are several instances in which a chromatin diminution is said to take place at the formation of the first maturation figure (Wilson and Mathews, '95; Gardiner, '98; Griffin, '99; Coe, '99; Conklin, '02). But in these cases the writers may have taken the precipitated nuclear fluid for chromatin, simply because it is stained with hsematoxylin. This phenomenon, I think, can hardly be called chromatin diminution.

The mass of precipitated nuclear fluid (residual substance of germinal vesicle, Lillie, '06) moves towards the animal pole taking a columnar shape around the first maturation figure (PI. IV, Fig. 59). In the eggs kept unfertilized for several hours this plasm spreads out at the animal region, forming a layer thick at the middle and thinning towards the periphery (Kostanecki and Wierzejski, '96, p. 370; Kostanecki, '02, p. 272; Wilson, '03, p. 446, foot-note, Yatsu, '04, p. 134). In the cleavage stages the precipitated nuclear fluid, which is found outside the spindle at the metaphase, is absorbed to the equatorial plane at the anaphases (Text Fig. C, 1 and 2). The portion of the fibres included within this plasm is thicker and stains darker than the rest. This nuclear plasm seems to play an important role in the formation of the diastem {vide infra) and the midbody. I can, however, find no evidence that it is directly converted into the cell membrane as Ehumbler maintains ('97, pp. 696-697; '9S, pp. 549-552; '99, p. 200).

It is noteworthy that at the pro])hase of the cleavage mitoses the rays Avhich grow towards the nucleus from the astral centres (the rays which give rise to both the spindle and the chromosomal fibres) are after the dissolution of the nuclear walls, composed of two portions ; namely, an extranuclear and an intranuclear part. The latter are thicker and stain more deeply (PI. I, Fig. 4). The similar dif

358 Naohide Yatsu.

ference between these two portions was recently noticed by Bonnevie ('00, p. 282). This seems to show on the one hand that the nuclear fluid contributes to the growth of rays (cf. Mark, '81, p. 53Y), and on the other that a ray may be formed in the nonalveolar plasm {vide infra). The seeminii,' pushing-iu of the nuclear walls at the poles may indicate a passing out of the unclear fluid, at the expense of which the rays grow.

The nuclear fluid after ^tlie dissolution of the nuclear membrane has a strong resemblance to hyaloplasm, both in its staining reaction and in the power of producing rays. While the nuclear fluid is not as a whole identical with the hyaloplasm, one may- say in a general way that the nucleus is a storehouse of hyaloplasm.

(c) Nucleolus.

In the germinal vesicle three elements can be seen (PI. I, Fig.l) ; a large plasmosome (principal nucleolus), smaller peripheral plasmosomes (accessory nucleoli'"') and chromatin masses.

The larger, plasmosome is usually single, seldom two to four are present (PI. I, Pigs. 1 and 8), and is situated in most cases half way between the nuclear membrane and the centre of the germinal vesicle. In the living state the plasmosome is a drop consisting in most cases of two portions ; one a lenticular or crescentic refractive part, with a reddish tint suggesting the contractile vacuole of some ciliates, and the other a watery part, or "vacuole." The latter is rarely wanting.

In sections only the denser part comes into view as a solid body, the thinner part being represented either as a clear space containing irregular precipitated masses having the form of small discs resembling mammalian-blood corpuscles (PI. I, Fig. 6), or entangled threads Avliicli stain green with l)leii de lyon (PI. I, Fig. 8). The denser part is usually lenticular or s])horical, but sometimes it gives the appearance of a basket (PL I, Fig. 7). It is homogeneous and takes a deep plasma stain — dark yellowish green with Delafield's

'^According to Flenuiiing ('82, p. 14(i) the terminology is based simpiy on size, not on chemical nature.

Ookinesis in Cerebratiilus Lacteiis. 359

hsematoxylin or iron-hsematoxylin. After the germinal vesicle has faded the denser part becomes a hollow sphere (PI. I, Figs. 12, 14; PI. IV, Fig. 60). It usually disappears at a late prophase of the first maturation mitosis, although sometimes it may be seen as late as the metaphase, it being taken up into the equatorial plate like the chromosomes.

The smalk'r ])]asni()S()nu's \ary in number, usually three or four, sometimes as many as nine (PI. I, Fig. 1). These nucleoli are situated just beneath the nuclear membrane. They are about one-fifth of the larger in diameter, and sometimes are composed of denser and thinner parts as in the larger one (PI. I, Fig. 11). They gradually dwindle (PI. I, Fig. 10) and, when the germinal vesicle has faded, no trace of them can be found.

A chromatin mass, composed of chromatin spherules, is always found close by each of the smaller nucleoli and three or four of them are associated with the larger one. Sometimes one or two chromatin spherules are found imbedded in the latter (PI. I, Fig. 12).^

The chromatin mass stains purple with Auerbach's fluid. At the beginning of the maturation, when the nuclear membrane is fading, pa7-i passu with the dwindling of the smaller nucleoli, the chromatin masses resolve into smaller spherules. They become greener and greener when stained with Auerbach's fluid. After the smaller nucleoli have completely disappeared there are found some two dozen of chromatin granules of irregular shape staining brilliant green with the above fluid (PI. I, Fig. 14). The number of the chromatin blocks is not constant. Of these only eighteen (PI. I, Fig. 15) go to the equatorial place of the first maturation figure and become the definite chromosomes. The rest of the granules disa]")pcar without giving rise to the chromosomes (chromatin diminution) J The rest of

In the egg treated with a solution of CaCl^ (Yatsn, '05, p. 2i¥)) the chroiuosomes arise in the germinal vesicle as fine threads resembling those found in the segmentation nucleus {V\. I. Tig. 1.3) (cf. Wilson '07a, pp. 572-.575).

'In Cei-edratnlus murglnutuH the reduced number is sixteen (Coe. '99, p. 441; Kostanecki. '02. p. 272). It should ho noted that in some eggs nineteen chromosomes are found instead of oigliteen (PI. 1. Fig. 10). There are three possibilities to account for this irregularity in the number of chromosomes: a,

360 IsTaoliitle Yatsu.

the history of the chromosomes agrees in the main with what has been described by Griffin in the egg of Thalassema ('99).

In passing it might be mentioned that the plasmosomes occur only in the germinal vesicle, chromatic nucleoli alone being present in the other nuclei. Both in the segmentation nucleus and those of the blastomeres the chromosomes arise as fine threads irregularly curved and sometimes attenuated towards the ends.

^^'hat is the relation between the plasmosomes and the chromatin masses in the germinal vesicle ? As I have not studied the genesis of these elements I am not able to give any definite answer to this question. That each chromatin mass is constantly associated with a plasmosome makes us think that the relation between these cannot be merely a casual one. In all probability the plasmosome gives off some substance to the chromatin masses for the growth of the latter. It is extremely difficult to analyze the cause of the change of the staining capacity of the chromatin masses, because two phenomena take place almost simultaneously; namely, the disappearance of the smaller plasmosomes and the fading of the nuclear membrane. It is, however, probable that the dissolution of the nucleoli is in some way or other connected with the change of the staining reaction of the chromosomes ; for the latter phenomenon takes place only in the germinal vesicle, and not at every dissolution of the nuclear membrane in later stages. Although one or two chromatin spherules are found in the larger plasmosome, the relation of the nucleoli and chromosomes is in C. lacteus not so close as in the egg of echinoderms, in which all the chromosomes in one j^eriod take shelter in the nucleolus. At any rate our case does not

failure of conjugation of a homologous pair of chromosomes at synizesis ; b, persistence of idant-free chromosomes (vide infra) as late as the meta phase, and c. separation of one chromosome into two. Of these the second nmy not he the ex|»lanation of om- case, because of the fact that in some eggs there are thirty-eight chromosomes in a daughter plate at tlu; anaphase of the first cleavage mitosis instead of thirty-six. In all probability our case may be due to the third possibility, although I have no reason to exclude the first. At any rate separation of one chromosome into two or more and fusion of two or more chromosomes into one may have taken place in the course of phylogeny of organisms. Without this assumption we cannot understand how such diversity in nunilxM" of clu'omosonics in animals and ])lants has come about.

Ookinesis in Cerebratiihis Lactcns. 361

seem to sn})i)oi't the secretion theory of the nncleohis advocated by Hacker ('99) and recently by Bonnevie ('06)^ bnt is in favor of the transportation theory as has been maintained by Rhumbler ('93, p. 351); Lnbosch ('02); Hcrtwig ('02); Ilartman ('02); Giinther ('03) and others.


(a) Centi-iule.

In a general way the centriole may be said to be a cell-organ, which undergoes very little change during the complicated processes of karyokinesis. The centrioles show, however, in normal as well as in abnormal cases some variation in size, shape, number and position in the centrosome.

{a) The centriole usually lies at the spot to which the astral rays converge, but sometimes it is found eccentrically in the aster. The segmentation centriole seems to drift about in the degenerating aster, since it is situated at no definite place (PL III, Figs. 43 and 45). In an enlarged centrosome the position of the centriole is very variable (PL III, Figs. 50 and 51).

(h) The size of the centriole seems to be fairly constant in all the cells of a given species, although a slight change in its size can be noticed (Boveri's view of proportionality between the size of cell and that of centriole may not be universally applicable, 'Ofi, p. 96). In fact at its first appearance, it is a little smaller than in a full-grown aster. A considerable diminution takes place in the young cleavage-centriole found near the conjugating germ-nuclei (PL III, Fig. 45). In abnormally treated eggs, e. g., in the CaClo eggs, the centrioles vary in size in an extraordinary degree, ranging from the smallest one but a little larger than the vanishing ])oint up to those almost three times as large as the normal size (Yatsu, '05, Fig. 10). Only a few cases have hitherto been recorded, in which the centriole actually enlarges and becomes hollow. Hacker observed in 8ida the growth of the centriole ('93) ; Conklin in Crepiditla ('01, '02), and in Ciona and Cynthia ('05) ; Small wood in TTamwea ('01, '04) ; Bonnevie in Enf.eroxenos ('06).

3G2 Naoliide Yatsu.

(c) The centriole is usually a smooth sphere, but often has a rough surface. Sometiuies it elongates into a thin rod, while in other cases a process is sent off from it. In Asterias eggs treated with ether, I often meet with Y-shaped centrioles. Besides these abnormal cases, rod and Y-shaped centrioles occur normally in some forms, e. g., in Folystoitmin (Halkin, '0-4, pp. 298-299) ; Pygaera (Meves, '02) ; Blatta (Wassilieff, '04) ; Zoogomis (Goldschmidt, '05, p. 619) ; Didyota (Mottier, '98) ; Stypocaulon (Swingle, '9Y). The centriole usually divides after amitotic fashion. The Schreiners ('05) have observed in Myxine a budding of the rod-like centrioles as has been described by Heidenhain ('96). Mattiesen ('03) seems to have seen that the rod-like centrioles in the egg of a fresh water dendrocoel are divided longitudinally (p. 37).

{d) The centriole is usually single or double in the aster of dividing cells and double in the resting tissue-cells and germ-cells before their growing period ("diplosome," Zimmermann, '98). When double, they lie close together, excepting those in enlarged centrosomes (PI. Ill, Fig. 52) and in abnormal eggs. Three or four centrioles in an aster have been described in Paludina and Pygaera (Meves, '02) in Haminea (Smallwood, '04, PI. Y, Figs. 25 and 28). Lillie draws six centrioles at the central end of the first maturation spindle of Chcetopterus egg ('06, p. 208, Fig. 39). The egg of Cerebratuhis treated with CaClg shows an enormous increase in number of the centrioles (cf. Yatsu, '05, Fig. 10).

We may define the centriole as follows: the centriole is a welldefined cell-organ comparable to the chromosome in its inherent power to grow and to multiply by binary fission. It never grows beyond a certain limit (exceptionally enlarges and becomes hollow). It is either single or do\d)le, but more than two form abnormal cases (Boveri, '95, p. 60, ct seq.). We are as yet unable to discern what happens when the centriole passes out of sight during the resting stage and in some centrosomes, just as we do not understand the achromatic state of "chromosomes."

(h) Centrosome. The centrosome is very insignificant in the resting asters of Cere

Ookinesis in Cerebratiilus Lacteus. 363

hratulus. Indeed it is even wanting in (a) the sperm-, maturationand segmentation-asters, when just appeared; (&) in any asters immediately after division; (c) in the asters found in the pilidium (Text Fig. A, j and k). In other cases the rays change their nature near the centriole, and give rise to a special zone of archi])lasm as is seen in Fig. 58 (PL IV). In other eases a homogeneous area is found between the archiplasm and the centriole. This zone is the centroplasm (= centrosome). A remarkable difference can be noticed after different fixing fluids in its sharpness of outline and its affinity for stain. In still other cases the archiplasm layer is lacking, and the rays radiate directly from the centrosome. In the last cases the centroplasm usually contains the central end of the rays (PI. Ill, Fig. 56). In large cells the centroplasm, at the division of an aster, enlarges and becomes alveolar, as we shall see later (PI. Ill, Figs. 49-53).

In all probability the centriole has the power of transforming either the cytoplasm, or the archiplasm or rays into centroplasm. The r,ay-system is also beyond doubt produced by the action of the centriole. Some other structures may also be the centre of raysystem as "we shall see later, but in what manner is not kno\vn. Boveri thinks that the centrosome is the producer of the rays ('00, p. 117). Biitschli ('92) and Ehumbler ('96) tried to explain the ray formation as caused by the hygroscopic nature of the centrosome, and, moreover, according to the latter, the disharmony of the growth of the centrosome and the ray-system is due to a peculiar character of certain colloid substance, such that swelling takes place suddenly when a certain amount of water has been absorbed. But the fact that the rays are formed even when there is no centrosome around the centriole and that the centriole^ does not change its physical nature throughout the whole process of ray formation makes it difficult to accept the views of the above cytologists. The ray-forming activity of the centriole, however, seems to cease in the latter part of the growth of the aster, as is shown by the eccentric position of the centriole in old asters. It may, therefore, be safely said that

Mauy cytologists call centriole ceiitrosonie.


Naohide Yatsii.




f g k


Fig. a. Diagram showing tlio size relation between tbe cell and centrosome. The vertical lines represent diameters of cells taken from embryos of various stages (all at tbe nietapbase). X 1*506. Below, tbe outlines of tbe centrosome of corresponding cells are indicated. X 1666. a — 1-cell stage, b — 4-cell stage, c — 8-cell stage, d — 64-cell stage, e — 32-cell stage, f — "placula" stage, g — blastula, h — gastrua (a cell of the apical organ), i — young pilidium (an entoderm cell), n — pilidium (an entoderm cell), k — pilidium (an entoderm cell near tbe mouth). During the process of reproduction tbe centriole of e has become smaller and that of k larger than those in the original drawing.

Ookinesis in ( Jorebratulus Lacteiis. 3G5

the ceiitriole initiates the formation of both the centrosome and ray-system.

In a general way the size of the centrosome is proportional to that of the cell in the same species, as has been pointed out by Boveri ('01, p. 94) and Goldsehmidt ('02, pp. 400 and 424). The acconijDanying diagram (Text Fig. A) shows this relation in Cerebratulus. The sections of cells of various sizes (all at the uietaphase) were taken at random, their diameters and the size of centrosomes were measured, and were arranged in order. One notices at once the proportional decrease in size of the controsomes as the cells become smaller, while the centrioles remain without perceptible change throughout. Furthermore it should be noted that in the cells of pilidium the centrosome no longer exists. As the centroplasm is present at any place of the cytojjlasm (as is seen in the normal fertilization and in artificial production of cytasters) it is clear that the larger the cell the more centroplasm, and consfcpiently ceteris paribus, the centrosome can grow much more in larger cells than in smaller ones. But the question why the large cells need large centrosomes will remain unsolved until we come to know the function of the latter.

From what has been said it will be seen that the centrosome is an ephemeral structure ]iroduced by the accumulation of centrojilasm around the centriole, and "nur von den Centriolen, nicht aher von (lev Centvosomen, l-ana daliev gelten, dass sie allgemeine und dauernde Zellorcjane siud," as has been maintained by Meves ('02, a and h) ; Bouin ('04) and the Schreiners ('06, p. 448). Although Boveri hinted at this conclusion as a mere possibility ('01, p. 185), he seems to lay more stress on the centrosome than the centriole.^ ^Nevertheless the centrosome theory does not lose its validity for the reason that the centriole physiologically represents what was called centrosome when the theory was first formulated.

In her excellent paper on Enteroxenos ('06) Bonnevie advances

"Vejdovsky's and MrAzek's ground of denying Boveri's idea of continuity of the centrosome is soniewliat different from tlie above authors, they empliasizing more the rwir formnlinn of a new centrosome in tlie old, than its perioiVioal coinplctc disappearance ('03, p. 555).

366 Naohide Yatsu.

a view quite different from what has been said above. The diplosome, found in the tisaue-cells and in the germ-cells before their growing period, she identifies as the centrosome.^'^ This structure divides bodily into two in spermatogenesis and during the oogonial divisions, while in oocytic divisions "durch inner e Dijferenzierung'^^ wird das zuerst kompakte Cytocentrum (=diplosome) in eine Hohlkugel umgebildet, und in der Mitte derselben, kommt ganz allmahlich ein winziges Kornchen zum Vorschein, das sich wahrend der Metamorphose in zwei Kornchen teilt" (pp. 302-303). These granules she calls centrioles. From this she concludes that the centrosome is a permanent cell-organ and the centriole is not, because it is not present in all the division stages and occurs only in large cells. If one studies her paper critically, it will not be difficult to see that this conclusion rests first upon the fact that in Enteroxenos the common type of aster-division is peculiarly modified by the growth of the centriole; and second, upon a misinterj)retation of the nature of the diplosome. It cannot be denied that the small granules in her Figs. 7 and 13 (text Fig. D on p. 315) are morphologically as well as physiologically the same as those at the centre of the centrosome of Fig. 1. Tlic distinction hetiveen the centrosome and centriole is, after all, not a question of position, hut 'of morphological structure. But, on the other hand, it may be argued,

'"It is interesting to note tliat Boveri admits tliat in some oases tlie diplosome may represent centrioles and not centrosome ('00, p. 201). Meves ('02) and ttie Shreiners ('00, p. 348) seem to have misinterpreted Boveri.

"The centriole must have arisen in the centrosome or division centre during the course of phylogeny. Yet from this it does not necessarily follow that at the present time the centriole is formed from the centrosome. As a matter of fact there exists a naked centriole, and in no cases ever described does the centrosome precede in its formation the centriole. The appearance of the segmentation centrioles after temporary disappearance cannot be called inner differentiation, because they keep their identity during this period. The question naturally arises as to whether or not there is a centrosome destitute of centriole. Excepting the cases in which the absence of the centriole is due to a failure in technique and the centrosome from which the cleavage centriole has gone out of sight, the centrosome without centriole has actually been observed in a few forms at one or both ends of the maturation spindles, such as Entroxcnos. Zooffnm(ft. The disappearance of the centriole in these cases, however, may be due to its precocious degeneration.

Ookinesis in Cerebratulus Laetens. 367

that the diiDlosome is a compound structure, i. e., a centrosome containing a centriole in it (cf. Boveri, '00, p. 93). This argument is not valid, since the same can be said of the ordinary centriole in the centrosome. Who can demonstrate that the centriole in the latter case does not have a thin coating of centroplasm about it ?

(c) History of the Centriole in Fertilization and in Cleavage.

I have demonstrated elsewhere (Yatsu, '04, '05) that centrioles can be artificially produced by a salt solution and verified the conclusion reached by Wilson ('01) that the centrioles can be formed de novo in cytoplasm. In other words, after the dissolution of the germinal vesicle the protoplasm has an inherent power of producing centrioles, Avhich is inhibited under normal conditions, and is called forth only by a favorable stimulus.

The results of my study of the fertilization of C. lacteus excludes, however, the view that the sperm-centriole is of egg-origin and is produced de novo by the action of the spermatozoon (cf. Morgan, '00, p. 506). The spermatozoon in oar case actually brings into the egg the sperm-centriole, which later gives rise to the cleavag& centres and those of suhsequent divisions.

1. Sperm Centkiole. (a) Observation.

A mature spermatozoon is represented in PI. II, Fig. 20. A slender slightly curved head is followed by a tail a little less than six times as long as the head. In well extracted preparations one observes that the middle piece is a vesicle containing a dark staining axis and a distinct granule near the posterior end (PL II, Fig. 21).^^ The subsequent history of the granule shows that it is really a centriole and not a structure produced by concentric extraction, as I ascertained by watching every stage of the differentiation by iron-alum. The granule, it should be noted, resists extraction even until the time the head becomes light blue. In a young spermato "Retzius ('04) failed to differentiate tills grannie in the spermatozoon of MalacolydeUa grossa (his Figs. 20-27).

368 IvTaoliide Yatsn.

zoon (PI. II, Fig. 10) the head is composed of two parts; a fine anterior pi-ocess and a posterior broader part. The middle-piece is much more vesicular than that of the full grown ones. In still younger ones (PI. II, Figs. 17 and 18) the head is almost spherical and is prolonged anteriorly into a short process. The centriole is present at the posterior end of the protoplasmic covering. After piercing through the egg-membrane the spermatozoon bores into the egg, where a little depression is seen. Then the head shoots into the ooplasm with a whip-like movement of the tail'" and the latter is quickly drawn in.^"* In many cases the spermatozoon rotates nearly 180°. Very little locomotion takes place within the egg, judging from the fact that all the stages of the formation of the spermnucleus,^"^ and of the sperm-asters are found near the periphery of the egg.

"One may observe a sawing movement of the head, as it gradually pushes in before its final shooting-in. After piercing through the egg membrane, quite often the spermatozoa are found again boring into the membrane from inside instead of into the egg. It sliould also be noted that spermatozoa are sometimes found boring into the fertilized eggs or even the blastomeres of the two-cell stage. This clearly shows that the spermatozoon has no power of distinguishing the non-fertilized from the fertilized eggs, and that the attraction of the spermatozoon to the egg, at least in the vicinity of the egg, is not due to chemotaxis.

"In sections the tail is seen in the egg as described by Kostanecki '02, p. 273). One notices that it has shortened a great deal. Whether a part of the tail is lost at the entrance or is dissolved in the egg, or whether it contracts I have not been able to determine. But it is noteworthy that it increases in its staining capacity after entering the egg (Kostanecki and Wlerzejski, '90, p. 336). The tail is sometimes straight (PI. II, Fig. 27), sometimes it bends on itself (PI. II, Fig. 2G). From this and the fact that in some molluscau eggs the spermatzoon is found coiled up, it may be inferred that the sperm may move in the egg. In fact, by careful watching of the egg of Ccrehratulus, it may be observed by the disturbance of the yolk granules that the spermatozoon wriggles for a little while before it becomes quiescent.

"The sperm head shortens after its entrance into the egg (PI. II, Fig 24). A construction appears between the head proper and anterior process (PI. II, Fig. 25). Then the chromatin seems to be drawn into the head proper from the anterior process, which gradually loses its staining cai)acity. The head proper becomes more and more spherical as the anterior process becomes thinner (PI. II, Figs. 20-28). Finally the latter disappears (PI. II, Fig. 29>. It may be i)ointed out that in the egg the sperm-head repeats in reversed order what it did during the later stages of its growth. The curved slender head.

Ookinesis in CVrebratnlus Lacteus. 369

With iron-hsematoxylin the middle piece of the si^ermatozoon in the egg stains as deep as the head. In thoroughly extracted preparations, however, the centriole coiner into view very distinctly (PI. II, Fig. 21). A somewhat advanced spermatozoon is represented in Fig. 27 (PI. II) ; the middle piece is here rhomboidal. Fig. 28 (PI. II) shows the same section subjected to further, extraction. The centriole has been brought out more clearly into view; the outline of the middle piece has disapjieared. It is striking that a fine radiation (non-fibrous rays) converging to the middle piece has been brought to light by extraction. Wilson states that at the formation of the s])erm-aster the r,adial arrangement of alveoles precedes the true rays ('90, ]). 13). The same preparation was re-stained with rubin S ; the outline of the middle-piece was restored as it had been seen before extraction. The next stage is shown in Figs. 29 and 30 (PL II). The vesicular nature of the middle-piece is now more pronounced. The centriole is found at the same place where it previously was. In case the germinal vesicle fails to fade the spermatozoon remains at this stage (TIertwig, O. and P., '87, p. 199; Wilson, '96, p. 149, '00, p. 201; Boveri, '02, p. 44). In eggs in which the germinal vesicle has faded faint rays are next seen around the middle-piece^" (PI. II, Fig. 31). Another sperm of about the same stage is shown in Fig. 32 (PI. II). Here the middle-piece has the outline of a pentagon. Further extracted, a sharply-defined centriole with elongated rays was seen (PI. II, Fig. 33). The outline of the middle-piece was restored by re-staining with rubin S. The next stage is represented in Fig. 34 (PI. II). The tail had disap]ieared and the sperm-rays have increased

therefore, seems to have developed for the purpose of piercing through the egg membrane and of boring into the egg. Later the sperm-head (now sperm nucleus) becomes vacuolated (PI. II. Fig. .30) and chromatin collects on the walls. Then the chromatin assumes a sphere-like form, which soon breaks up into the chromosomes. As the sperm-nucleus grows, the chromosomes disappear as such, leaving behind a few chromatin nucleoli.

'"I met with a few cases, in which the sperm-rays have developed before the shortening of the head. Fig. 23 (PI. II) shows this abnormal case. One notices that the sperm-rays centre in the centriole in the middle piece. Fig. 24 (PI. II) represents another rase, in which rays have preeoeiously formed and the throwing-off of the middle iiiece vesicle has also taken place.

870 JSTaohide Yatsu.

both ill number and in longtli. Soon afterwards the middle-piece is found thrown off into the cytoplasm, where it eventually fades (PL II, Figs. 35 and 36). Now the ccntriole surrounded by astral rays lies free in the egg close by the spcrni-nucleus. How the centriole escapes from the middle-piece I do not know. It may be due to the movement of the sperm-nucleus and aster, the middle-piece being left behind. As a matter of fact I have a few cases in which the middle-piece and the tail together are found detached from the sperm-nucleus at the stage represented in Fig. 29 (PI. II). (Wilson, '97; Foot and Strobell, '03, their Fig. 9.)

When the centriole escapes from the middle-piece, the centroplasm has not made its api^earance, the rays reaching the centriole. Soon after, the central ends of the rays become obscure and the centroplasm is formed. In it the centriole divides into two. The division i^lane has no definite relation to the egg radius (cf. PL II, Figs. 36 and 37). From this stage on two different types may be distinguished in the formation of two daughter asters: (A) in many eggs the centrosome disappears immediately afttu" this. The two naked centrioles are found surrounded by new short rays. As they are separated farther and farther from each other, the rays (fertilization rays) grow to a considerable length (PL II, Figs. 37 and 38). A spindle is formed by a secondary connection of the rays between the two asters. (B) In a few cases I find the sperm-aster Avith much centroplasm (PL II, Fig. 39). The rays are coarse and not so numerous as in type A. The centroplasm increases in quantity and eventually becomes spongy (PL II, Fig. 40). In it the two daughter centrioles acquire new r,ay-systems and the old rays gradually fade away. These two types differ from each other simply in the period of aster division owing to different amounts of centroplasm ; in type A the aster division is completed very early, while in type B it has not yet finished even as late as a stage shown in Fig. 40 (PL II). It should be remarked that type A resembles what was observed by Coe on C. marginatus, differing only in one point; that is, in the I^eapolitan species a large number of old rays directly pass into the daughter systems ('99, p. 446). Type A resembles the formation of the asters for the second maturation

Ookinesis in Coreliratnlns Lactens. 371

mitosis described by van der Stricbt ('98), Byrnes ('99) and others, Avhile type B conforms in every respect to the mode of aster-division in large blastomeres of onr form, which I shall deal with later on.

(6) Literature and General Remarhs.

Despite the fact that numerous studies on spermatogenesis have been carried out, and that the fate of the spermatid-centriole in the formation of the spermatozoon has been followed with great accuracy, yet surprisingly few cases are known, in which the centriole of the spermatozoon has been uninterruptedly traced to the sperm-centriole in the egg during the fertilization processes.

Thanks to the older investigators such as Flemming, Fol, O. Hertwig, it has long been known that the sperm-rays centre towards the middle-piece. At one time it was thought that the middle-piece as a whole was the sperm-centrosome (Doflein, '97, p. 206; R. Hertwig, '98; Boveri, '00). The relation between the middle piece and the centre of the sperm aster was*made clearer in the works of Henking, ('90), Fick ('93), Wilson and Mathews ('95), Wilson ('97, '99), van der Stricht ('02, '04). There are, however, but five forms in which the centriole has satisfactorily been traced. Hill ('95) observed the centriole in the middle-piece in PJiaUiisia mammilata and traced it to the centre of the sperm aster (PI. 17, Figs. 13a, 21a-f). His description and figures are, however, insufficient to give a clear idea of his observations. Kostanecki and Wierzejski ('96) saw a centriole in the middle-piece of the spermatozoon in the gonad of Pliysa fontanaJis, and in a few cases they found the same granule in the egg with rays around it (pp. 338-339). Erlanger ('97) demonstrated the centriole in the spermatozoorT of Ascaris megalocephala and traced it to the fertilization stages (pp. 316-320). Boveri ('00) states that one or two granules are found in the middle-piece of the spermatozoon of Strogylocentrotiis liriduft (his PI. 1, Figs. 14d, e, f, h; PI. A., Figs. 55 a, b; PI. 5, Figs. 71, 72). The same granule (centriole) he ol)serves in the conti"o of the s]ierm aster (his PI. 4, Figs. 55b, PI. 5, Figs. 71, 72). Foot and Strobell ('02, '03) found

372 ISTaohide Yatsii.

that the sperinatozooii of Alldohoplioni foetida contains two centrioles at each end of the middle piece, and the posterior one persists as the sperm centriole ('03, p. 300). In Cerchmtulus lacteus, as we have already seen, it is rather easy to trace uninterruptedly the centriole from the young spermatozoon to that of the sperm aster, owing to the fairly large size of the centriole and the vesicular nature of the middle-piece (Yatsu, '07).

As to the fate of the middle piece in the egg. In most forms, I think, the middle-piece fades in situ as soon as it enters the egg, thus leaving the centriole free in the ooplasm. The rapid degeneration of the middle-piece nudges it in most cases almost impossible to follow its history in the egg. The throwing-off of the middle-piece or, in other words, the escape of the centriole from the middle-piece, seems to me a very rare phenomenon. Besides C. lacteus this has been observed in only one form.^^ In Toxopneustes variegatus Wilson, ('97, '99, '00, p. 188, Fig. 12) observed that the middle-piece becomes detached from the nucleus and is cast to one side, as a dark staining granule that degenerates in situ. The rays focus at the basal point of the nucleus, where the centriole appears ('99, p. 14). Whether the centriole lies in the middle-piece or between it and the nucleus he was not able to determine ('97, p. 371).

The question naturally arises as to whether the centriole or the centriole and centrosome together are brought into the egg by the spermatozoon. -"^^ But in Cerehratulus lacteus the condition is quite different. The granvde found in the middle-piece is a little larger than the ordinary centriole, it is true, but just after its escape from the middle-piece it has no centrosome at all. Even if the centrosome be present in the middle-piece, it must degenerate in the ooplasm. In our case at least, it may safely be concluded that the centi'osome in the sperm aster is derived from the egg substance.

"Field ('95) states that in Asterias llie separation of the middle piece (mitosome) near the place of entrance into the egg as was observed by Pictet and Cuenot (p. 22.5). But judging from his statement that the spermatozoon devoid of the mitosome is capable of fertilization, the nature of this body can be questioned.

Boveri's figures represent spermatozoa already rotated. The sperm-htjad with naked centrioles might be found before its rotation.

Ookinesis in Cerebratulus Lacteus. 373

2. Cleavage Centriole.

After the format ion of the cii'i;' nucleus, the egg ceutriole lingers for a little while in a niche of the nucleus, but it soon disappears, (PI. IV, Fig. GS). The sperm nucleus, with two asters connected by a spindle comes in contact with the egg nucleus not far from the place where the latter was formed. The asters sometimes precede (PI. Ill, Fig. 41), sometimes follow the spenn nucleus (PL III, Fig. 42) (cf. Coe, '1)9, p. 447, Kostanecki, '06, p. 17). At the time of the conjugation of the germ-nuclei or a little later, the sperm asters become irregular, the rays curving like a fountain (PI. IV, Fig. 08). Singularly enough no considerable increase of the centroplasm takes place. The ceutriole may take any place in the degenerating centrosome — in many cases away from the centre of the rays ; sometimes close to the nuclear walls, sometimes quite far from it. This fact suggests strongly that there may have been a current in the cytoplasm at the conjugation of the germ-nuclei.

In order to decide the origin of the cleavage centrioles, I have studied serial sections of t^venty-three eggs at the stage when previous observers lost the centrioles in the egg of C. maifjlnatus (Coe, '99, Kostanecki, '02). The result was that six eggs show two centrioles, fourteen eggs one ceutriole and three eggs none. Figs. 43 and 44 show the sections of the egg in which two centrioles are found at the critical period. Xve the two centrioles new formations or the same ones as those in the sperm astern ? It is extremely difficult to decide this question owing to the fact that one cannot follow the history of the centrioles in the living eggs. But it is clear that these centrioles are not on their way to degeneration, but they have recently acquired new activity since they have a small ray system around them. Prior to the conjugation of the germ nuclei, the centrioles are invariably present (PL III, Figs. 41 and 42), and in some cases the centrioles have come to possess a new ray system even before the coming together of the germ nuclei (PL III, Fig. 45^ (Coe, '99, pp. 451 and 457). From this it may be concluded that in some cases the spenn centrioles survive throufjJi the critical period, v^hile in many they disappear during this stafje. It should here be noted that the centrioles dwindle considerably in size just before the conjugation

3T4 ISTaohide Yatsu.

of tlio germ nuclei, and that at this particular period the centroplasm is fixed always very poorly. i\ny one who has had experience in fixing has surely noticed that the same treatment acts differently upon different lots of eggs according to their "physiological state" so to speak. (Mrs. Andrews, '97, pp. 16, 31.) Even in one and the same lot one finds eggs excellently fixed side by side with poor ones. Especially at the moulting stage the centriole is extremely sensitive towards fixing fluids. Wilson ('Ola) expresses the difficulty in fixing the centrioles at the division stage of the aster. Vejdovsky and Mrazek ('03) state that they could not follow the division of the sperm centriole owing, I imagine, to the impossibility of getting satisfactory fixation at his particular stage (pp. 502-503). Taking into account the above difficulty in fixation it is certain that the sperm centrioles pass through a stage when they are liable to be destroyed by fixing fiuids. Only such centrioles as happen to regain their activity at an earlier period, and come to be less susceptible to the fixing fluid, can escape from l)oiug dissolved (cf. Wilson, '00, p. 214). Despite the temporary disappearance of the sperm centriole, I conclude, therefore, that tlie cleavage centrioles are identical tuitli the sperm centrioles (Kostanecki, '06, p. 60).

(cZ) Division of the Centrosome. 1. Observations.

For the study of the moulting of the centrosome, no stages can be better than the formation of the second cleavage centrosomes. This process begins in C. lacteus at a late prophase of the first cleavage mitosis. The centriole becomes double at the end of the spindle. The centrosome at this stage has not increased in size (PL III, Fig. 47). It should here be noted that the division of the centriole and the increase of the centrosome are two independent phenomena. The centriole divides irrespective of the spindle axis, e. g., perpendicular in Fig. 47 (PI. Til), and obliquely in Fig. 50 (PI. Ill) (cf. Boveri, '00, p. 43). Neither does the division ])lane coincide with the short axis of the centrosome (PI. Ill, Fig. 50). In the meanwhile en

Ookinesis in (Vrebratiiliis Laeteus. 375

largenieiit of tlie ceiitrosoine takes place. The direction of its growth is not determined by the centrioles, but by the general organization of the egg (cf. Mark, '81, p. 526, Boveri, '00, pp. 48, 107).

Then the centrioles move apart from each other in the centrosome (which differs from Coe's observation, '99, p. 459). The separation seems in some way correlated with the growth of the centrosome. As the centrioles move apart two dark staining fibres can be seen between them (PL III, Fig. 48), bnt no central spindle (netrum) is present (Schreiners, '06, p. 331, Fig. 179). One of the connecting fibres may remain a little longer than the other (PI. Ill, Fig. 51). The centrioles then take their definitive position, the line connecting two centrioles being perpendicular both to the vertical egg axis and to the spindle. Their position is, as already mentioned, governed by the shape of the centrosome, which is in turn dependent on the general organization of the egg. The centrosome is alveolar in structure (Vejdovsky, '88, p. 19, Wilson, '99) and has the form of a sausage flattened horizontally. It now grows very rapidly, partly at the expense of the chromosomal fibres, partly by modification of the archiplasm. The chromosomal fibres shorten without thickening, which suggests the hauling-in of a rope as Rhumbler states in the case of the polar rays ('96, p. 607), the fibres being gradually metamorphosed into the centroplasm (Wilson, '95, p. 2, '96, p. 77, '01, p. 387; Coe, '99, p. 459). The chromosomal fibres completely disappear, and the chromosomal vesicles are found actually in the centroplasm. The centrosome is now a flat sheet and the centrioles have moved to a point near the outer periphery of the centrosome. Here they acquire a ray system but are at first devoid of the centroplasm. Then the old centrosome begins to disintegrate. Hand in hand with this dissolution the rays around the centrioles become more and more distinct; often a spindle may be formed as the result of secondary connection of the rays. As the

"'In this coiiiiectioii it is interesting to mention that in the egg of Ar'hacia r-entrifugalizert anrl afterward fertilized, the second cleavage takes place always hoiMzontally. :is I was told l»y Professor Morgan. I think in the eggs thns treated n vei-lic-il movement of the egg material (which tends to restore the original structure) controls the definite shape of the first cleavage centrosome and this in turn the position of the centrioles for the next cleavage.

376 Naohide Yatsu.

aster enlarges the centrosome comes into view for the first time, and the mother rays gradnally fade away as the daughter rays grow stronger. When the old rays have entirely disappeared, the moulting of the aster is completed.

From the above observation on the formation of asters for the second cleavage of C. lacteus it will be seen that : (a) the centrosome does not divide; it being formed separately from

the beginning. (6) in no stages does a reduction of the centrosome take place, (c) the centriole retains its identity throughout the whole process;

neither disa]^])earance nor enlargement of the centriole takes


2. Types of Centrosome Division.

Three different views have been held regarding the formation of daughter centrosomes from a preceding one, if we except the direct division of the centrosome, which takes place in some small cells, e. g., the s])ermatocytes and cleavage cells of Ascaris. As we shall see later, none of the views expresses the general mode of the division, but there are actually three different types (Meves, '99, p. 499 et seq.).

A. Formation of daughter centrosomes by reduction (Boveri, '00). It is quite nniversal, Boveri believes, that the centrosome first enlarges (Text Fig. B. II cf. his Text Figs. pp. 102-103), and in it the centriole divides (this may happen long before). Suddenly the centrosome differentiates into two parts, a central "active" core and an outer disintegrating part. This process he calls a reduction of the centrosome ('00, pp. 97, 101). The reduced centrosome now divides into two. Here the division of centrosome actually takes place. The term "reduction" is, I think, not well chosen, since it does not express wdiat really happens. The grown centrosome does not all of a sudden separate into two parts, as Boveri thinks, but thicker centroplasm flows towards, and collects itself around, the centriole, and thus slowly the centrosome of the next genoraticm is foruied within the old. Example, formation of the second cleavage centrosomes in Cerehratvhis marginatus (Coi>,

Ookinesis in Ceivbratulus Lacteus.


'99), in Ulujuchchnis- (Vcjdovsky and Mrazek, '03); that of Thalassema (Griffin, '96, '99) may belong to this type {vide infra).


r A



^ :W'i



Fig. B. Diagram showing various types of the forniution of daughter centrosonies from a single original one.

B. Formation of daughter centrosome by moulting (Vejdovsky, '88, Vejdovsky and Mrazek, '03). Disagreeing with Boveri's view of reduction of the C£ntro5onio, \"ejdovsky and Mrazek maintain that a daughter centrosome arises within the old one, and a granddaughter centrosome within the daughter and so on. like a series of ring waves as aptly expressed by His ('98, p. 442-443). They deny Boveri's conclusion on the ground that the daughter centrosome is a

""In this form tlic centriolos acfinii-c new ray-syslems before tlie division of tile centrosome.

378 IsTaohide Yatsu. new formation and not due to reduction (p. 529, etc.). But it is certain that the material for the new centrosome must come from the old, as already mentioned. This endogenous formation of daughter centrosome may well be called "moulting," in lieu of Boveri's reduction. So much for the controversy in interpretation. Vejdovsky and Mrazek give another type besides that described under A. The centrosome enlarges and the centriole which had been divided into two acquires a ray system and a centrosome (Text Fig. B). The old centrosome degenerates. In this type the centrosome never divides, but is formed separate from the beginning. Example: formation of the second cleavage centrosomes in Glossiphonia (=Clepsine) (Vejdovsky and Mrazek, '03, in Cerebvatulus lactus, in SerpuJa (Soulier, '06, pp. 458-459). A critical study of the literature will convince one that this type of centrosome formation is the most prevalent of all ; in fact all the known cases, except those mentioned under A and C {vide infra) may, I think, be included under this type. Of course in very few cases is the process carried out with diagrammatic clearness as in Cerehmtulus. In most cases it is modified by various irregularities. Of these three may be mentioned.

(a) Owing to the precocious fading of the mother centrosome the centriole becomes naked and divides into two. Around these the daughter centrosomes are formed. Example, in the spermatocytic division of Geopliilus (Bouin, '04).

(&) The mother centrosome disappears after the centriole has divided. Two naked centrioles exist for a time, as shown in Text Fig. C. Example, the formation of the second maturation centrosomes in Thysanozoon (van dor Stricht, '9S) and in T/imax (Byrnes, '99).

(c) The centriole divides and before the separation of the daughter centriole a connnon centrosome is formed around them. After it has enlargel two grand-daughter centrosomes appear within it (Text Fig. Ill B.). Erlanger's account ('98) of the Q^g of Spliaerechi)ius may conform to this process. It is doubtful whether or not Griffin's case of Tlialassema re])reseuts tyi)e A, for the reason that he actually figures an enlargement of centrosome. Might it not be the case that the daughter centrosome disappears in the mother centre

Ookinesis in Cerebratulus Lacteus. 379

some before the grand-daughter ceutrosonie appears? (Cf. Griffin, '96, Fig. 13.)

(c) Formation of daughter centrosome by the enlargement of the centriole (Wilson, '95, Conklin, '04, Bonnevie, '06) (Text Fig. B. IV). The centriole enlarges in the centrosome and the two new centrioles are formed de novo within it. The centrosome is, therefore, a transformed centriole. Xo division of centrosome takes place. This view is characterized by the fact that at the division of the aster the cell passes a stage in which no centriole is present. Wilson expresses a similar view in the case of Toxopneustes ('95, p. 463, '01, p. 584). Boveri suggests this mode as a mere possibility at the formation of the second cleavage aster of Ascaris ('01, pp. 78 and 98). Example, CrepiduJa, Cynthia, and Ciena (Conklin, '01, '04, '05), in Enteroxenos (Bonnevie, '06).

Recapitulating the types :

(1) Direct division. — The centrosome is bodily divided into two daughter centrosomes (centrosome divides).

(2) Moulting.

(a) Division. — A new centrosome formed around the centrioles within the old one is bodily divided into two centrosomes (centrosome divides).

(6) Separate formation. — The centriole divides in the mother centrosome and around the products the daughter centrosomes appear separately (centrosome does not divide).

(3) Enlargement of the centriole. — The centriole grows and becomes the centrosome. Two new centrioles appear in it, and enlarge into centrosomes (centrosome does not divide).

3. Cycle of Centrosome.

As a summary ()f this section the cycle of the centrosome in Cerebratulus lacteus from the sperm-centre as far as the second cleavage center will be given. The centrosome I, i. e., that of the first generation, makes its ap])earance soon after the throwing-off of the middle piece vesicle. The centriole tlien divides into two, Ceiitrosome I fades away, and new ray systems are formed around the two

380 Naohide Yatsii.

centrioles. By this time the germ-iiuclei fuse. Ceiitrosome III (that is, the first cleavage centre) appears in the now degenerating centrosonie 11.^^ Centrosome III enlarges a great deal and in it centrosonie IV is formed. This becomes the centre of the second cleavage mitosis. This cycle agrees with Vejdovsky and Mrazek's observation on the egg of Glossiphonia (Clepsine). That the fourth centrosome hecomes the centre of the second cleavage, is, I think, an almost universal phenomenon during the early development of animal eggs.

IV. Rays and Spindle.

(a) Terminology.

Throughout the present paper, I shall use the terms in the following sense:

Pole rays — the entire group of rays radiating from the astral center (Rhumbler).

Polar rays — rays found in the region of the "cone antipode" (Rhumbler).

Intermediate rays — rays found between the polar and equatorial rays.

E(]uatorial rays — rays near the division plane of the cell (Rhumbler).

Sheath rays — spindlc-like sheath surrounding the spindle formed by the fusion of the equatorial and a part of the intermediate rays.

Sheaf rays — rays laid down parallel to the spindle in the future cleavage plane ("gerbe de separation," Bouin).

Spindle = central spindle ; "central" is dropped, because it is sometimes found outside the chromosomal fibers, e. g., Bhynchelmis (Vejdovsky and Mrazek, '03, Fig. 46).

Chromosomal fibers = "Zugfasern" = Mantle fibers.

^'Kost.inecki compares the foniiatlon of centrosome III after the "pause" with the reai»pearance of rays after the treatments of cooling, etherization, etc. ('00, p. 0.5). It might he worth pointing out that tliese two plienomena are of entirely different nature: in the former a newer aster ni)i)ears within the old, while in the latter the very same aster hecomes visihle.

Ookinesis in Cerebratnlus Lacteiis. 381

Interzonal fibers- — fibers found between the separating chromosomes at the anaphase and telophase. These should not be confounded with the spindle fibres exposed between two daughter chromosomal plates.^^

(b) Observations.

Many views have hitherto been expressed as to the nature, formation and function of the rays and spindle, yet, when they are critically examined, what we actually know at present is surprisingly little. Any attempt to formulate such a highly intricate mechanism l)ased on the body of evidence we have at hand seems premature. In the present section, therefore, 1 shall not go into the general discussion, but I shall confine myself to the description of a few observations, which have a direct bearing on this subject.

As has been maintained by some cytologists, the rays, I think, are physically modified hyaloplasm of fiuid consistency (^lark, '81, p. 528; Wilson, 'Ola, pp. 54-1, 549; '01b, p. 385). The effect of ether, cooling, etc., is to bring the rays quickly to the original hyaloplasmic state. Evanescent as they may seem, the rays are, under normal conditions, fairly persistent structures, as shown by the fact that at the moulting of the centrosome the old rays linger for a long while even after the central ends of the rays disappear. It is extremely difficult, therefore, to conceive that the rays represent raj)id constant currents of hyaloplasm as Teichmann ('03 j and Bonnevie ('06) maintain (Rhumbler, '96, p. 583). It might be mentioned in this connection that the pole rays of the first maturation mitosis remain unchanged for three or four hours unless fertilizctl.

In fixed material the rays may be divided into two classes according to their nature: (a) fibrous, and (b) non-fibrous (Fol, '91,. The former are actual fibers imbedded in hyaloplasm with microsomes attached to the surface. Tracing the fibrous rays peripherally, one always finds straightened alveolar walls forming non-fibrous rays or, as sometimes called, Dotterstrahlen."-" In Fig. 54 (PI. Ill)

"All the filn'cs seen between the two danghter chromosomal plates, including both the spindle and interzonal til>res, were called by Mark "interzonal tilaments" ("SI, p. 198).

^The "Dotterstrahlen" of older writers simply mean rays, since the cytoplasm was called "Dotter" in some cases.

382 Xaohide Yatsu.

the fibrous ray stops at X, while the non-tibrous ray reaches the perii^hery. The formation of any aster in the alveolar plasm shoAvs that non-hbrons rays nsually precede librous ones. I have already mentioned a case in which the rays (non-fibrons) of a very yonng sperm aster were brought to view only after thorough extraction (PL II, Figs. 27, 28 and 32, 33) (cf. Wilson, '99, p. 14).

Rays are formed not only under the influence of the centrioles but also under that of many other structures. In the blastomeres of a tel( ost, Coveyonus alhus, for instance, a special group of rays is formed along the inner side of the karyomere groups (PL III, Fig. 56). A section of an egg of Aster las accidentally crushed when alive shows distinct rays along the flow of alveoles (cf. Ziegler, '04, p. 550). Parasite asters on the rays have been seen in the egg of Asterias (PL III, Fig. 55).

The distribution of the pole rays seems to be influenced by that of the hyaloplasm in the cytoplasm as is seen in the fan figure ("Facherkern"). In etherized eggs of Asterias, one often observes funnel-shaped asters.

In many cases the rays are formed in homogeneous plasm^^ (quite different from Biitschli-Rhumbler's explanation). In Fig. 5G (PL III) the central ends of the rays are in a homogeneous hyaloplasmic area. Fig. 58 (PL IV) is the central aster of tire first maturation figure in the nuclear area (residual mass of the germinal vesicle). It is noteworthy that the sperm aster can enter the nuclear area without being distorted (PL IV, Fig. 59). Quite often one finds the sperm aster half in.

Rays have a peculiar tendency to elongate toward any formed body, such as chromosomes, or degenerating nucleoli. Fig. 60 (PL IV) shows a maturation aster. Three groups of rays are here, as it were, fishing chromosomes. In the middle one it should be noted that a ray is bent so as to meet the chromosome. Apparent splitting of rays may be due to the above characteristic as in the case of Fig. 61 (PL IV), where one of the asters has precociously divided.

"This is more likely intra-mieroscopioally or potontially alveolar (Veidovsky, '88; Wilson, '00), yet none the less it appears homogenous in the living and granular in the fixed state. Rhumhler calls this Protoplasnia ohne erkennbare Waben" ('00, pp. .^,44, r^A^^).

Ookinesis in ( Vivhnitnlns Laetcus. 383

Whatever the function of rays may be, they are the expression of an attraction toward the centre. Fig. (r2 (Ph IV) shows a case in which the rays of the sperm ast(n* have jnilled the chromosomes of the luaturatiou mitosis toward the centres (cf. Ilenneguy, '91, p. 417, Fig. 17, or, '9G, p. 350).

The spindle fibres are made u}) of hyalophism more highly modified than that of pole rays. The spindle may be removed as a whole by the currents and retains its entity even after the egg is crushed (Ziegler, '95, p. 385 ; Mathews, '07, p. 90). In the degenerating eggs of Cerebrat ulits (kept unfertilized for five or six hours) the spindle is found without perceptible change, while the pole rays fade always earlic]'. It is interesting to note that the rays of two asters, when they come near, have a tendency to take the form of a spindle, as in the case of the sheath rays. Figs. 03-65 (PL IV) show this relation very well. In the last figure a well developed spindle is seen between the two asters. Fig. 60 (PI. IV) shows a spindle between the sperm aster and maturation aster; Fig. 67 (PI. IV) represents that between two sperm asters.

Crossing of the rays takes place not only between two asters connected by a spindle but also between two separate asters. In Cerehratulus the rays of the degenerating egg aster and , those of the sperm aster do not form a spindle, but invariably cross one another, an accunuilation of granular })recipitation being present between the asters (PI. IV, Fig. 09). In this case the crossing may be interpreted as due to a non-simultaneous action of two asters and local disturbance (Khumbler, '98, p. 547, '03, pp. 520-522). But this explanation is far from satisfactory when one tries to apply it to the ordinary case of the crossing at the metaphase, which is a constant process and not an accidental one (Meves, '99, p. 524).

The fountain figiire is found in the egg of Cerebratulus in three places: (a) around the cleavage plane when the constriction is nearly completed (Text Fig. C. 5 on p. 380) ; (b) in the sperm rays immediately prior to the conjugation of the germ nuclei (PI. IV, Fig. 68), and (c) in the polar rays of the blastomere cleavages at a late anaphase and the teleophase (Polfontain" Rhumbler) (Text Fig. C. 3 and 4 on p. 380). The anti-spindle figure described by

384 :N'aoliidc Yatsu.

Coe ill the egg of C. marginatus at the anaphase of the iirst cleavage mitosis ('99, Fig. 31) is seldom met with in that of C. lacieus. It, however, occnrs so seldom that it would be more natural to look upon this figure as the result of fixation or some other abnormal conditions. Spiral asters are also seen at the poles of the maturation spindle, but their occurrence is so inconstant that the figure should be interpreted as due to some accidental disturbance rather than to any constant cause.

V. Cytodiebksis.

{a) Ohserralioiis.

In the hope of finding some key to the solution of the mechanism of cell division, the first and second cleavages of the egg of C. lacteus have been studied. For the sake of convenience the results will be described under five headings :

1. Movemoit of Chromosomes and Centres.

In order to determine the relative movement of the chromosomes and the centres, I have measured sections of twenty-five eggs at the metaphase and at the mid-anaphase."'

Metaphase — 46.73 microns from the equatorial plate to the periphery (through the center). 16.415 microns from the equatorial plate to the centriole. Midanaphase — 46.00 microns from the middle plane of the spindle to the periphery (through the center). 19.09 microns from the middle plane of the spindle

to the centriole. 10.78 microns from the middle point of tlu; chromosomes to the centriole. The movement of the chromosomes is 8,310 microns. The movement of the centriole is 2.675 microns.

"Only vertical seftinns wore made use of in which the plane passed the t.vo opposite centrioles.

OJikiiiosis ill ( 'crchral iiliis LiU-tens. 385

Difference is 5.0*^5 microns.

The eloniitition of the egg is 0,13 microns.

From this it will be seen that the chromosomes move much faster at this stage than the centrioles (cf. Ziegler, '95, p. 383). The lateral stretching of the karvokinetic axis takes place later on.

2. Spindle.

At an early anaphase the spindle is convex in outline at the middle. Approaching the telophase, however, the fibres straighten themselves, the width of the spindle being consequently reduced to one half or sometimes still less (Text Fig. C. 1-4). After the daughter nuclei are formed, the spindle fibres are bent toward the vegetative i^ole (Text Fig. C, 5). This bending is not due to the cell constriction, because this takes place long before the cleavage furrow reaches the spindle, and moreover against the pushing-in of the vegetative furrow. In later stages, of course, the animal furrow accentuates the bending. It may be pointed out, therefore, that this common phenomenon of spindle bending is an expression of protoplasmic movement."

3. Centrosome.

At the anaphase the centrosome is sausage-shape, placed horizontally perpendicular to the spindle. At a late anaphase it flattens and spreads out at the expense of the chromosomal fibres (Text Fig. C. 4 — horizontal section). The nature of the centroplasm changes from homogeneous to alveolar and now it does not appear so viscid as it has been. The centrosome is gradually bent downward so that the centrioles are no longer found on the same horizontal plane as the spindle, but far below the latter (Text Fig. C 3). As I have already mentioned, the spindle fibers by this time are curved toward the vegetative pole and the karyokinetic axis, therefore, takes the form of an inverted W (Text Fig. C. 5). Later the nucleus too yields to the shape of this curve. The centrioles go to the extreme end of the centrosome, where \hc\ acquire new ray systems. Often

■-"It is noteworthy that in the esg of PcdiceUina americana the spindle of the first cleavage is hent towards the animal jwle, as I was informed hy Dr. Dublin.


Naohide Yatsu.

Fig. C. Five stages of the first cleavage, x 400. 1. Anaphase of the first cleavage mitosis. Crossing of raj's, and the position of the spindle. Difference in distance between two centrioles at either end ; 2. Telophase of the first cleavage mitosis. The ceutrosome has enlarged and been bent downwards. The crossing of rays has begun to loosen. A faint indication of fountain figure is seen at the pole regions; 3. Telophase, a vertical section through the poles and a centriole. Constriction has begun on both the animal and vegetative sides. Sheath spindle has been formed. Fountain figures at the poles of the spindle have become more distinct ; 4. Telophase, a horizontal section through three centrioles (about the same stage as 3). Sheath spindle is very well formed. Centrosome has greatly enlarged. The distance between the rows of karyomeres is approximately the same as the original length of the spindle; 5. Late telophase (a vertical section). Sheaf rays have been formed. Fountain figure in the equatorial rays.

Ookinesis in Ccrebratuhis Lacteiis. 387

the new asters are formed outside the centrosomes. The centrosome in section gives a granular appearance as it degenerates, and remains for some time between the new aster and the nucleus. A similar change takes place during the second cleavage.

4. Rays. From the metaphase to the mid-anaphase the rays are straight and comparatively short; they are longer toward the vegetative pole than toward the animal pole (Text Fig. C. 1). Consequently, the rays cross one another much more in the vegetative region. At this stage careful focussing shows that the non-fibrous rays reach the j^eriphery. Through the transformation of these non-fibrous rays into fibrous a beautiful display of rays ensues. Some of the rays abut against the surface of the egg. Soon afterward the elongation of the centrosome takes place. The rays are no longer straight; the polar rays assume a fountain figure. The curvature of these rays is more and more marked in later stages. ISTow the rays at the "crossing" have a tendency to dissociate or draw themselves apart. Text Fig. C. 4 shows the next stage where the climax of the ray formation has been reached. One striking feature of this stage is the formation of the sheath rays around the spindle, due to the fusion of the equatorial rays and a part of the intermediate rays. These spindle-shaped sheath rays seem to occur in a good many forms (Wilson, 01b, p. 383, his Figs. 51-57). It should here be noted that the cleavage furrow, as it deepens, cuts apart the sheath rays in the middle. It is remarkable that these rays are cut without being bent inwards, and still more so, since the rays thus separated begin to turn away from the cleavage plane, taking a fountain figure (Text Fig. C. 5). This should not be confounded, as I have already mentioned, with the antispindle figure of the anaphase.

5. Cell Constriction and Mid-body. About an hour after fertilization,-^ soon after the formation of the second polocyte, a furrow appears along the animal hemisphere.

"In the eggs taken from individuals, which had been Ivept for two or three days in an aquarium, the maturation processes go on very slowly, and the cleavage furrows appear an hour and a half after fertilization.

388 T^Taohide Yatsn.

Immediately afterward the vegetative furrow cuts in at a rate two or three times slower than that of the animal one. Sometimes the vegetative furrow is very much reduced, and the constriction is accomplished almost entirely by the animal furrow. ^'^

In sections of the eg}X of a late prophase we see precipitated nuclear fluid around the spindle. At the metaphase this fluid takes its definitive position around the equator of the spindle (Biitschli's space/' Khund)ler) (Text Fig. (\ l-.'5). As the chromosomes move apart toward the poles, the nuclear fluid is taken into the spindle in the form of dark granules. The spindle fibres too seem to absorb the fluid into themselves, as shown by the fact that they are thicker and stain darker in the middle. Spread over the animal half of the egg is found a thin layer of cytoplasm rich in hyalo])lasm. This layer is thickest in the middle and gradually thins out toward the equator of the egg. This hyaloplasmic layer sends ofl" a vertical layer to meet the nuclear stuff of Blitschli's space (Text Fig, D 1 and 2). At later stages this hyaloplasmic cytoplasm is also found over the vegetative pole. Thus the future cleavage plane is foreshadowed with this plasm (Diastem" His). Now this vertical septum begins to become less dense. The cleavage furrows cut in along this thin hyaloplasmic cytoplasm. As the constriction proceeds a new ray system is formed parallel to the spindle (sheaf rays) (Text Fig. C. 5). Dark staining granules are laid down at the middle of both the sheaf rays and spindle fibres. Later both kinds of fibres are bundled into a sheaf. The chromatic granules fuse together and form a ring (midbody).

(b) General Remarks.

The methods which have hitherto been employed for the study of cell-division mechanism may be classified under three categories, namely, (a) observations on the normal processes of cell division either in the living state or in fixed material, (b) the study of cell division under modified conditions, (c) imitations of phenomena

^*This mode of cleavage takes place, as I have often noticed, in artificial parthenogenesis, since the egg nucleus usually lies near the animal pole (cf. Morgan, '99, p. 452).

Ookinesis in Cerebrutulus Lacteus.


Fig. D. Portion of vertical sections tiirouKli the ejis at a late anaphase and at the teloi»hase respectively, showing' the jteripheral plasm layer rich in hyaloplasm and vertical plasm layer mainly comi)osed of nuclear fluid. X 8^^

390 Naohide Yatsu.

of cell division bj means of inorganic objects. The last method is a rather dangerous one. Only with the greatest cantion should one apply the simulacra thus obtained to our problem. Another line of attack may be offered as a fourth method. This comprises cutting and compressing experiments performed on living cells at different periods of division. How important this method is, may be illustrated by Wilson's experiment on the egg of Dentalium. The formation of the polar lobe is naturally intei"}3reted as due to the action of the two centres in the egg (cf. Bomievie, '03, p. 101). Wilson ('04) found out by a simple cutting experiment that the polar lobe is formed in enucleated egg fragments free from asters (Carazzi, '05, p. 15). Simple as it is, by this method one can test the validity of interpretations hitherto proposed. Although this has been singularly neglected, yet I think the mechanism of cell division will in future be studied most advantageously along this line.

What actually happens during cell division is the rounding-up of the cytoplasm around the two centres (Rhumbler, '97, p. Y05, Morgan, '99, p. 521, Teichmann, '03, p. 316). This is undoubtedly the resultant of several factors. Of these the following may be mentioned : The surface tension is usually disturbed at the farthest point from the centre, causing pseudopodia or irregular outlines (Erlanger, '97c, p. 344, Rhumbler, '01, p. 63, 65 and 69, Conklin, '02, p. 94, Boveri, '03, pp. 3 and 5, Jolly, '04, pp. 504 and 505, e. g., Fig. 11 70h 38, Fig. 10 3h 40, 7h 48). As Boveri thinks, this phenomenon seems to be very important for the explanation of the formation of the constriction. By this factor alone the egg should divide by the vegetative furrow. But in reality the animal furrow is the first to appear and in some cases the vegetative furrow is very insignificant. This, as often has been pointed out, is due to the position of the nucleus. The nuclear fluid after the dissolution of its walls takes the form of Biitschli's space (Bonnevie, '06, Kornerhilllc, ]). 286.)"^

°°Conklin thinks that the nuclear fluid escapes from the poles at the fading of the nuclear nieiubrano. This is true for the formations of the rays which give rise to the spindle. Hut it cannot be doubted that the greater part of tL^i nuclear fluid remains m situ and later forms Biitschli's space as Rhumbler maintains.

Ookinesis in Ccrebratiihis Lacteus. 391

The nuclear stuff thus exuded, instead of forming the membrane as Rhumbler believes, plays a part in reducing the density of the cytoplasm along the future cleavage plane. The formation of the diastem cannot entirely be attributed to the nuclear fluid, since in some cases the quantity of the fluid is too small to modify the whole cleavage plane. There must be some other factor to })roduce the diastem. Whatever the cause may be, the diastem is of very common occurrence and any explanation of the mechanism of cell division will not be perfect, unless that solves the problem of its formation (Henneguy, '91, p. 408, Bambeke, '96, p. 34, His, '98, p. 14, Conklin, '02, p. 95, Khumbler, '03, p. 513, Gurwitsch, '04, p. 326). At the same time in certain kinds of cells it cannot be doubted that cytoplasmic currents play an important role in division processes (Conklin, '99, '02, Biitschli, '00).

Appendix : The explanations of cytodieresis hitherto proposed may be classified under five categories ; viz.

(a) Explanations based on the contraction of the rays.

(1) Contraction of permanent rays (Heidenhain, '95, Kostanecki, '96).

(2) Contraction of temporary rays (Boveri, Rhumbler et al.). (h) Explanations based on the expansion of rays: Meves "Expansion theory."

(c) Explanations based on changes of surface tension (those which are based on the change of surface tension alone without discussing its cause are not explanations but mere restatements of fact) :

(1) Change due to the rays, which represent flows in the cytoplasm (Biitschli, '76, p. 414, Giardina, '02, pp. 500, 576).

(2) Change due to the general currents, the rays being not important for cytodieresis (Platner, '86, Loeb, '95 a, b, Conklin, '99, '02, Biitschli, '00).

(d) Explanations based on the contraction of the peripheral jilasmlayer (rays are of little use) (Flemming, 'YY, Ziegler, '98, pp. 43,47, '01, p. 126, '04, pp. 552, 553).

(/) Explanations based on the general contraction of cytoplasm around the centres (rays are of little use) (Ziegler, '95, p. 70, Morgan '99, Gallardo, '02, p. 74, Teichmann, 03, Gurwitsch, '04, Bonnevie, '06).

392 Naoliide Yatsn.


In the living egg of Cerehratulus lacteus one observes at the animal pole a depression as soon as the first maturation figure reaches there (Kostanecki, '02, p. 272, cf. Rhumbler's polar depression, '96, p. (i07). In case the egg is fertilized before the dissolution of the geraninal vesicle the polocyte formation follows soon after the maturation figure comes to the animal pole. But otherwise the depression remains until the egg is fertilized. Immediately after fertilization a clear drop containing refringent chromosomes and destitute of yolk drops, flows out as though a portion of peripheral hyaloplasm gushed out through a hole. The spinning activity of the polocyte is beautiful as described by Andrews ('98) and C. B. Wilson ('00).

In sections of the nonnal egg accumulation of hyaloplasm is seen over the animal pole. As the polocyte bulges out, the chromosomes flow in, they being crowded at first in the narrow stalk of the polocyte and finally jiassiug into it. Xo alveoles can be seen in the polocyte. The second one is formed in the same way. A mid-body is formed only between the second polocyte and the egg.^"

As to the mechanism of the polocyte formation little has been discussed. The processes seem to be of entirely different nature from ordinary cell division. There are two types in the polocyte formation, namcdy, in one class the ])olocyte is formed before and in the other, after fertilizatiou. In the latter, the first maturation mitosis stops at a certain stage and (mlV after the entrance of the sperm is the polocyte formed. It is hardly necessary to enumerate the cases, in which the spermatozoon plays an important role in the reorganization and stimulation of cytoplasmic activity accompanying with it, e. g., contraction, amoeboid movements. An interesting experiment performed by Ilertwig nuiy, however, be worth mentioning here. Tie ])ricked the eggs of Rana tcm.pomria with a glass needle, but uothiug hajjpened until they were fertilized. The extraovates are furuied from the wounded eggs only ujion fertilization

■■'"Tlio nnclous of tlip first polorytc is ;i fonipiict clinmiatiii mass, while tliat of tlK' second is a vesicular one. tlie chi'oniatic l)an(l with Ja.ujied surface coiling .insl lieneatli t]H> nuclear nieniltrane. Division of the first polocyte sometimes 1al<('s place.

0(3kiiicsis ill C'crcbratuliis Liictcnis. 393

('•j;3, pp. 14, 15). Tins seems to show that the sperm causes the contraction of the egg.^^

The action of the centriole upon the ])oloeyte formation, on the other hand, should not he overlooked. The center seems to cause a sudden decrease of surface tension at the spot where the polocyte is to he formed, provided the cytoplasm he in the right state.

Tn the non-fertilized < gg of Ccvchmiiiliis laclcus treated with a solution of magnesium chlorid a pointed protuberance resembling somewhat the entrance cone of the sea-urchin oiX'J: is sometimes formed at the animal ])ole. This unsuccessful attem])t of polocvte formation may be due to untimely sinking of the maturation figure toward the center of the egg.^^

The number and size of the polocytes may vary according to the physiological state of the egg. In some of the unfertilized eggs treated with a mixture of ])otassium chlorid and calcium chlorid (Professor Wilson's material) the ])(»locytes have been produced.^ The number and size of the polocytes tlius produced showed great variation. Fig. 70 (PI. \X ) is an egg with a ]iolocvte about five hundred times as large as the normal one. Fig. 71 and 72 (PI. IV) are those with four and five polocytes res])ectively (Kostanecki describes the third ])ol()cyte, '02, p. 284).

VII. Summary.

A. Observations on the normal egg of C'erebratidiis ladeus: (1) Before the dissolution of the germinal vesicle the yolk granules are arranged radially.

='riert\vig adds to this oxpfriuicnt auotlHT i»nssiliilit.v wliicli is worth consideriug, /. c. this result may he diu' to the LTadunl cliaiij.'c in thi' iintnre of the o("iphisni. since there is a considerahJe interval between I he time ot injury and fertilization.

■■-The solution used is 20 S M M,!,'('l. and sea water in e(iual parls; this is twice as strong as thai used effectively for causing artificial ]>arthenogeiiesis in the sea-urchin egg. The latter solution has no noticealile effect on the egg of CrrrhnifiilKx.

'■•■The egg was put in a sohition of 2U/S M CaCl., (210 cc.) -f 20/8 M KCl (100 cc. ) -f Aq m (SOO cc.) and gradually transferred into sea water. They were fi.xed after three liours.

394 Naohide Yatsu.

(I) There are a few plasmosomes in the germinal vesicle. Each

of them is usually found associated with a chromatin granule.

(3) The reduced number of chromosomes is 18 or 19 ; the somatic

number, 30 or 38 (in C. marginatus the reduced number is 16 according to Coe and Kostanecki).

(4) Chromatin diminution is accomplished by the fading away

of some of the chromatin granules at the prophase of the first maturation mitosis.

(5) The spermatozoon contains a centriole in the middle piece.

(6) The middle piece swells into a vesicle and the centriole

escapes from it, giving rise to the centre of the sperm aster.

(7) The centrosome does not divide. The centriole divides in

the centrosome. Each daughter centriole acquires its own centrosome, and the mother centrosome fades away.

(8) The centrosome of the fourth generation becomes that of

the second cleavage.

(9) Crossing of rays takes place between the degenerating rays

of egg-nncleus and sperm-rays.

(10) An ;mtis])iiidle figure, such as occurs in C marginatus at

the aiui])hase of the first cleavage, takes place very seldom. Such a figure may be an artifact.

(II) Sheath rays are formed surrounding the spindle at the

anaphase of the cleavage mitoses.

(12) The first maturation figure remains unchanged for four or

five hours if the egg is not fertilized.

(13) The sperm aster may ])ass unchanged from the alveolar

into homogeneous plasm.

(14) A spindle may be formed between the maturation and

sperm aster.

(15) The cytoplasm along the future cleavage plane is rendered

less dense (partly by the nuclear fluid).

(10) Sheaf rays with the mid-body granules arc formed at the telophase of the cleavage mitoses.

Ookinesis in Cerebratulus Lacteus. 395

B. Observations on the abnormal eggs of Cerebratulus lacteus:

(17) In CaClo eggs the chromosomes arise in the germinal

vesicle in the form of thin threads.

(18) In unfertilized MgClg eggs a protuberance is sometimes

formed at the animal pole, as the maturation figure retreats toward the centre of the egg. (10) In unfertilized KCl -|- CaCP eggs the polocytes may be formed ; the number and size of them vary a great deal.

C. Observations of other forms :

(20) In the blastomeres of the Avhite fish {Coregoniis albu^)

rays are found around the karyomeres.

(21) In the egg of PediceUina americana the spindle of the

first cleavage mitosis is bent at the telophase toward the animal pole (Dr. Dublin's observation).

D. General conclusions:

(1) The nuclear fluid is similar to hyaloplasm.

(2) The nuclear fluid is usually neither alveolar nor reticular

but homogeneous.

(3) Diminution of chromatin (basichromatiu) does not take

place at the dissolution of the germinal vesicle.

(4) The centrosome is not a permanent organ, but is a tem porary accumulation of centroplasm around the centriole.

(5) The centriolc is a centre for the formation of rays.

(6) The size of the centrosome is proportional to that of the


(7) The middle piece of the spermatozoon contains a centriole.

The spermatozoon, therefore, carries a centriole into the egg at fertilization. The sperm centriole is not that of the cytasters produced by the egg.

(8) The cleavage centrioles are not new formations but those of

sperm aster.

(9) The position of tlie division centrioles is determined by the


396 :N"aoliide Yatsn.

(10) Rays may be formed in homogeneous as well as in alveolar


(11) In fixed material fibrous and non-fibrons rays can be


Note. — The writing of the preseut paper was tiuished on June 3, 1907, at the Zoological Laboratory of Columbia University. Very few^ altei'ations have been made since. Literature which lias come to the author's notice since the above date is not referred to in this paper.

Zoological Institute Tokyo Imperial University. Japan, May 2, 1909.


Andrews, E. A., '98. Activities of polar bodies of Cerebratuhis. Arch.

Entm., (5. Andrews, G. E., '97. The living substance as such and as organism. Jour.

Morph., 12, supplement. Bambeke, van C. '9G. Sur iin groupement de granules pigmentaires dans

I'oeuf en segmentation d'amphibiaus. Bull. Acad. Belg., 31. Bambeke, van C, '98. Recherches sur I'oocyte de PIiolcus phalangioides.

Arch. Biol., 15. Bonnevie, K., '03. Abnormitateu in der Furchung von Ascurls lunibricoides.

Jen. Zeitsch., 30. Bonnevie, K.. "(I(>. Untersuclumgen liber Keimzellen. I. Beobachtungen

an den Keimzellen von fUitcro.rciios (/stcrf/rciii. Jen. Zeitsch., -41. BouiN, r., "04. Recherches suv la figure achromatique de la cytodierese et

sur le centrosome. Arch, de zool. exp., ser. 4, t. 2, notes et revues 5. BovERi, T., "95. Ueber das A'erhalten der Centrosomen bei der Befruchtiuig

des Seeigeleies nebst allgemeinen Bemerkungen iiber Centrosomen und

Verwandtes. Verb. d. phys.-metllc. Gesell. Wiirzburg, N.F. 29. BovERr, T., '<J0. Zellen-Stmlien. Heft 4. Ueber die Natur der Centrosomen. Jen. Zeitsch., 25. BovEBi, T., '03. Ueber das Verba Iteu des Protoplasmas bei monocentrischen

Mitosen. S.B. phys.-medlc. Gesell. Wiirzburg. BovEKi, T., '04. Ergebnisso iil)er die Konstitution der chromatischen

Substanz des Zellkerns. Brauer, a., '93. Zur Keiintniss der Spermatogenese von Aficaris nictjalovcphala.

Arch. mikr. Anat., 42. BiJTSCHLi. O., '70. Studien iiber die ersten Entwickelungsvorgange der Eizelle,

die Zelltheilung und die Kon.jugation der Infusorien. Abb. d. Senkenberg.

Naturforsch. Gesell., 10. BuTSciiiJ, O., '92. Untersuchungeii iiber niicioscopische .Schaume und Qas


Ookinesis in CVvobratnlns Lactciis. 397

BuTStiiLi, O.. '(H>. lieiuerkuiigtMi iWnn- die Asterubildung iiu Plnsmn. Arch. Entui., 10.

Byrnes. E. F.. 'm. The maturation ami fertilization of the egg of Liinax (li/retttifi. Jour. Morph., IG.

Oarazzi, I)., '04. liicerclie enibryologiche e cytologicho nell' novo di

Mysostovia uJtihruiii. .Alonitoro zoologico italiano, 35. COE, W. R., '99. The maturation and fertilization of the egg of Cerehrnttilus.

Zool. Jahrb.. Abth. Anat. u. Out. 12.

CoNKLiN, E. G., '99. Protoplasmic movement a.s a factor in differentiation. Wood's Hole Lectures.

CoNKLiw, E. G., '01. Ceutrosomes and spheres in the maturation, fertilization and cleavage of Crepiduht. Ant. Anz., 19.

CoNKLiN, E. G., '02. Karyokinesis and cytokinesis in the maturation, fertilization and cleavage of Crcpidiila and other gastropoda. .Jour. Acad. Philadelphia, ser. 2, 12.

CoNKLiN, E. G., '04. Experiments on the origin of the cleavage centrosonies. Biol. Bull., 7.

CoNKLiN, E. G., '05. The organization and cell-lineage of the ascidian egg. Jour. Acad. Nat. Sc, Philadelphia, 1.3.

Delage, Y., '01. Etudes experimentales sur la maturation cytoplasmique chez les echinodermes. Arch. zool. exp. et gen., ser. 3,9.

DoFLEiN, F. J., '97. Karyokinesis des Spermakerns. Arch. mikr. Anat, 50.

Eklanger, von R., 97. Beitriige zur Kenntniss der Strukturen des Protoplasmas, der karyokinetischen Spindel und des Centrosomas. I. Ueber die Befruchtung und erste Theilung des Ascariseies. Arch. mikr. Anat., 49.

Ebianger. von It., '97. Beobachtungen iiber die Befruchtung und ersten zwei Theilimgen an den lebenden Eiern kleiner Nematoden. Biol. Centralb., 17.

pELANGER. VON R., '98. Ueber die Befruchtung des Seeigeleies. Biol. Centralb., 18.

FiCK, R., '93. Ueber die Reifung und Befruchtung des Axolotleies. Zeit. wiss. Zool., 5G.

Field, G. W., '95. On the morphology of the echinoderm spermatozoon. Jour. Morph., 11.

Flemming, W., '79. Beitrjige zur Kenntniss der Zelle und ihre Lebenserscheinungen I. Arch. mikr. Anat., 10.

Flemming, W., "82. Zellsubstanz, Kern und Zelltheilung.

Flemming, W., '91. Neue Beitriige zur Kenntniss der Zelle II. Arch. mikr. Anat., 37.

FoL, H., '79. Recherches sur la fecondation et la commencement de I'henogenie. Mem. soc. phy. uat. Geneve, 20.

FoL, II., '91. Le quadrille des centres. Arch, des sc. phys. et nat, de Geneve, 25.

Foot, K., and Strobell, C, '02. The spermatozoan of Allolohophora foetida. Amer. Jour. Anat, 1.

398 Naohide Yatsu.

Foot, K., ano Stroiiei.l. C, '03. The speriii-centrosoino ami aster of Allo loboi)hora ffetida. Anier. Jour. Anat, 2. Gallardo, a., '02. Interpretacion dinamica de la division celular. Gakdiner, E. G., '98. The growth of the ovum, formation of the polar bodies

and the fertilization of Polycceriis caudatus. Jour. Morph., 150 Geboulu, J. H., 'OG. The development of Phascolnsoma. Zool. Jahrb., 23. Giardina, a., '02. Note sul mecanismo della fecoudazione e della divisione

cellulare studiato prineipalmente in uova di echini. Anat. Anz., 21

and 22. GoLUScHMiDT, R., '02. Untersuchungeu iiber die Eireifung, Befruchtung uud

Zelltheihuig von Polystomum hitegrimuni. Zeit. wiss. Zool., 71. GoLDSCHMiDT, R., '04. Der Chromidialapparat lebhaft funktionierender Ge webszellen. Zool. Jahr., Abt. Anat. u. Ont., 21. GoLDSCHMiDT, R., '05. Reifuug, Befruchtung und Embryonalentwickelung des

Zoogonns minis. Zool. Jahr., Abt, Anat. u. Ont., 21. Griffin, B. B., '96. The history of the achromatic structures in the maturation and fertilization of Thalasscma. Trans. N. Y. Acad. Sc. Griffin, B. B., '90. Studies on the maturation, fertilization and cleavage of

Thalassema and Zipliea. Jour. Morph., 15. GiJNTHER, K., '03. Ueber den Nucleolus im reifenden Echinodermenei und

seine Bedeutung. Zool. Jahr., Abt. Anat. u. Ont., 19. GuRWiTSCH, A.. '04. Morphologie und Biologie der Zelle. Hacker, V., '93. Das Keimbliischen ; II Abth. Anhang — Ueber die Bedeutung

der Centrosomen. Arch, mikro. Anat., 42. Hacker, V., '99. Praxis und Theorie der Zellen und Befruchtungslehre. Halkin, H., '01. Recherches sur la maturation, la fecondation et developpe ment du Polystomum integrimum. Arch. Biol., 18. Hartmann, M., '02. Studien am thierischen Ei. I. Ovarialei und Eireifung

von Asterias glacial is. Zool. Jahrb., Anat. u. Ont., 15. Hartog, M. M., '98. Reduction und die Funktion des Chromatins. Biol. Cen tralb., 18. Heidenhain, M., '96. Ueber das Microcentrum mehrkerniger Riesenzellen,

sowie uber die Zentralkorperfrage im AUgemeinen. Morph. Jahrb., 7. Henking, H., '90. Untersuchungeu iiber die ersteu Entwickelungsvorgiinge in

den Eiern der Insekten. Zeit. wiss. Zool., 49. Henneguy, L. F., '91. Nouvelles recherches sur la division cellulaire indirecte.

Jour. Anat. et physiol., 27. Henneguy, L. F., '96. Legons sur la cellule. Hebtwig, O., '93. Die Zelle und die Gewebe.

Hertwig, R., '98. Ueber Kerntheilung, Rich tungskorperbil dung und Befruchtung von Actinospherium. Abh. Baier. Ak., II. Herwtig, R., '02. Die Protozoen und die Zelltheorie. Arch. Protist, I.

Ookinesis in Cerebratulus Lactens. 399

HiLX, M. D., '95. Notes on the fecundation of the egg of Sphaerechhuis granularis and on the maturation of the egg of PhaUiiNia tnanniiihtta. Quart. Jour., 38.

His, W., '98. Ueber Zellen- und Syncytienbildung. Studien am Salmoniden Iveim ; Abhand. math. phys. Klasse k. siichs. Gesell. d. Wiss., 24. Jolly, J., '04. Kecherches experimentales sur la division indirecte des globules

rouges. Arch. anat. micro.. (5. KosTANECKi. VON K., '02. Ueber die Reifung und Befruchtung des Eies von

Cerebratiilus niargiiiatus. Bull, de I'acad. des scien. de Cracovie. KosTANECKi, VON K., '00. Ueber die Herkunft der Theilungscentren der ersteu

Furehungsspindel im befruchteten Ei. Arch. mikr. Anat., 68. KOSTANECKI, VON K., AND WiERZEJSKi, A., '9G. Ueber das Verhalteu der

sogenannten achromatischen Substanzeu im befruchteten Ei. Nach Beob achtung an Physa fontanalis. Arch. mikr. Anat., 47. LiLLiE, F. II., '()»;. Observation and experiments concerning the elementary

phenomena of embryonic development in Chatopteriis. Jour. Exper.

Zool., 3. LoEB, J.. 'Oo. Ueber Kerntheilung ohne Zelltlieiluiig. Arch. Eutm. 2. LoEB, J., '95. Ueber die relative Empfindlichkeit von Fischembryonen gegeu

0-mangel und Wasserentziehuug. Pfliiger's Arch., 55. LuBoscH, W., '02. Ueber die Eireifung der Metazoen insbesondere iiber die

Rolle der Nucleolarsubstanz und die Erscheinung der Dotterbildung.

Ergeb. Merkel u. Bonnet, 11. Mark, E. L., '81. Maturation, fecundation and segmentation of Limax

campcstris. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., <!. Matthews, A. P., '07. A contribution to the chemistry of cell-division,

maturation and fertilization. Amer. Jour. Physiol., 18. Mattiesen, J., '03. Die Eireifung und Befruchtung der Siisswasserdendro coelen. Zool. Anz., 27. Meves, F., '99. Zelltheilung. Ergeb. Merkel u. Bonnet, 8. Meves, F., '02 a. Ueber oligopyrene und apyrene Spermien und iiber ihre

Entstehung, nach den Beobachtungen an Paludina und Pijgacra. Arch.

mikr. Anat, Gl. Meves, F., '02 b. Ueber die Frage, ob die Centrosomen Boveris als allgemeine

und dauernde Zellorgane aufzufassen. Mitth. f. Verein. Schles-Holst.

Aerzte, 10; Verhand. Anat. Gesell. zu Halle. Morgan, T. H., '99. The action of salt solutions on the unfertilized and fertilized eggs of Arbacia and of other animals. Arch. Entm., 8. Morgan, T. H., '00. Further studies in the action of salt solution and other

agents on the egg of Arbacia. Arch. Entm., 10. Mottier, D. M., '98. Das Centrosoma bei Dictyota. Berich. Deutsch. Bot.

Gesell., 16. Platner, G., '86. Die Karyokinese bei den Lepidopteren als Grundlage ftir

eine Theorie der Zelltheilung. Inter. Monat. f. Anat. u. Physiol., 3.

400 XiinlnMc Yatsn.

Retzius, G., '04. Znr Kenntnis der Speriiiieu dev Evertebraten. Biol. Unters.

N.F., 11. R HUMBLER, L., '93. Ueber Entstebnnj;; unci Bedeiitniig der in deui Kern vieler Protozoen vorkommenden Binnenkdrper (Nucleolen). Zeit. wiss. Zool., 5G. Rhumbleb, L., '9(>. Versuob einer niechanischen Erkliirung der indirecten

Zell- und Kerntbeilnng. Arch. Entui., 3. Rhumbler, L.. '97. Stennnen die Strahlen der Astrosphjire oder ziehen sie?

Arch. Eutm., 4. Rhumbler, L., '98. Die Mechanik der Zelldurchschniirung nach JMeves und

nach meiner Auffassung. Arch. Entm., 7. Rhumbleb, L., '99. Allgenieine Zelhnechanik. Ergeb. Merkel u. Bonnet. S. Rhumbleb, L., '01. Ueber ein eigentumliches periodisches Aufsteigen des Kerns an die Zelloberflache innerhalb der Blastomeren gewisser Nema toden. Auat. Anz., 19. Rhumbleb, L., '03. Mechanische Erkliirung der Aehnlichkeit zwischen mag netischem Kraftlinien-systeni und Zelltheilungsfiguren. Arch. Entm., IG. Smallwood, W. M., '01. The centrosome in the maturation of Biila solitaria.

Biol. Bull., 2. Smallwood, W. M., '04. The maturation, fertilization and early cleavage of

Haminea solltario. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., 45. Soulier, '00. La fecondatiou chez la serpule. Arch. zool. exp. et gen., ser. 47, Schreineb, a., and K. E., '00. Die Reifung der mannlichen Geschlechtszellen

von i^alaiiKtiKlru. i^puiax und Mji.riiic. Arch. Biol., 22. Swingle, W. T., '97. Zur Kenntnis der Kern- und Zelltheilungen bei den

Sphaecellariaceae. Jahr. wiss. Bot., 30. Teichmann, E., '03. Ueber Beziehung zwischen Astrosphiiren und Furchen.

Arch. Entm., IG. Van deb Stbicht, O., '98. La formation des deux globules polaires et I'appari tion des spermocentres dans I'oeuf de Thysanozooii. Arch. Biol., 15. Van deb Stbicht, O., '02. Le spermatozoide dans I'ceuf de chauve-souris (V.

noctula). Verhand. Anat. Gesell. in Halle. Van deb Stbicht. O.. '04. Une anomalie tres interessant concernant le devel oppement d'un (leuf mammifere. Ann. d. 1. Soc. d. ined. Gand., 84. Veidovsky. F., '98. Entwicklungsgeschichtliche Untersuchungeu, 1. VE.TDOVSKY. F., AND Mbazek, A., '03. Verwandeluugeu im Cytoplasm wahrend

der Reifung ulid Befruchtung des RJii/ncJichiiis-cics. Arch. mikr. Anat.. 02. Wassilieff, a., '04. Zur Spermatogenese bei Hhitt-■'

4 7 48 49 50 ^^



The Journal of MoiiPHOLOGY. — Vol. XX, No. 3

Plate IV.

58. Central aster of the first maturation figure, showiug archiplasmic differentiation of the rays. X 2000.

59. Sperm-aster in tlie nuclear area. In the next section is found the first maturation figure. X 860.

60. Kays of the maturation aster reaching chromatin masses, x ^^^^^'* 01. JNlitotic figure in an ether egg of Asterias, in which, one of the asters has divided into two. X 526.

62. Sperm-asters approaching the first maturation figure. Some of the chromosomes are attracted towards the sperm asters. X 806.

63. Two cytasters in an ether egg of Asterias. X 1566.

64. Two asters in an enucleated blastomere of an ether egg of Asterias. X 1566.

05. Two asters connected by a spindle in an enucleated blastomere of an ether egg of Asterias. X 860.

06. Spindle formed between the cenlral aster of the first maturation figure and the sperm-aster, x 800.

07. Spindle formed between two sperm-asters in a dispermic egg. X 800.

08. Sperm-nucleus approaching the egg-nucleus. The sperm-asters are behind the sperm-nucleus. One of the centrioles is under the nucleus. Fountain figure in the sperm-rays. Combination of four sections. X 800.

09. Crossing of rays between the sperm and egg-asters. Accumulation of the nuclear fluid between the asters. X 800.

70. First polocyte produced by KCl -f CaCL (unfertilized egg). X 866.

72. Five polocytes produced by KCl -f CaClj (unfertilized egg). X 806.



ijiil rmm.

The Jodrxal of Mokpuology. — Vol. XX, No. 3.



Since the physiology of the Limiilus heart has been so carefully investigated and that organ has been used so successfully in attacking many physiological problems, it has seemed desirable that something should be known concerning its histology. The chief objection to applying any of the results obtained on this form to the vertebrate heart has been that Limulus is a representative of a group unique in the animal kingdom and well removed even from its nearest relatives. This fact makes it all the more desirable to investigate the heart musculature in this form and to find what similarity, if any, it bears to the vertebrate type.

Material and Technique.

Heart tissue from adult Limuli was used. The most of the material was prepared at Wood's Hole where fresh tissue was also examined. The hearts from some animals that had been shipped to Chicago were also used. These animals were in good condition and nothing atypical was found in the tissues.

A number of fixatives were used, including Carnoy's solution, Perenyi's fluid, acetic-sublimate, and Zenker's solution. Of these Zenker's proved by far the most serviceable and satisfactory. The hearts were split open, washed in sea water to free them from blood

'I take pleasiu-e in thanking the Marine Biological Laboratory for material and also Dr. Rardeen and Dr. Erlanger, of the University of Wisconsin, for technical assistance. IMy thanks are also dne Dr. Carlson, of the University of riiicago. for advice concerning the work.

The .luiKNAr, ok Mi(i!rn<>l-0(iv. — Vol. XX, No. 3.

404 Walter J. Meek.

and leucocytes, and then small pieces immersed in the fixative. The usual methods of embedding in paraffin and sectioning were employed. Sections were made from 3 to 6 micra in thickness.

Several different stains were employed, Init iron hematoxylin followed by eosin was found to be the best for general study. The combination has been used largely by investigators and a comparison with their work therefore becomes easy. Orange G and fuchsin were frequently used as counter stains. In studying connective tissue distribution iron hsematoxylin followed by Van Gieson's picro-fuchsin gave good results. A stain equally good and used with success was Mallory's connective tissue stain. Vanadium hsematoxylin was also used in an attempt to demonstrate a sarcolemma. Fresh material was also treated with silver nitrate.

Fresh material was teased and studied in sea water or salt solution. Fresh tissue was also macerated in 20 per cent nitric acid, 40 per cent potassium hydroxide, oO per cent alcohol, and saturated ammonium carbonate, l^itric acid is especially good as a macerating agent, since the preparation may be washed, passed into glycerine, and preserved. Material fixed in Zenker's solution and preserved in 70 per cent alcohol was also found to tease easily. These preparations could be stained with htematoxylin and eosin and then showed nearly all the details clearly.

General Mokphology. The heart of Limidus is a hollow sack 15-20 centimeters long and 1.5-3 centimeters wide. It is swung in the pericardial sinus by eight pairs of connecti^'e tissue ligaments, the alary muscles, which form a lateral support for the heart and extend to the pericardium with which they fuse. On its dorsal surface the heart has eight pairs of ostia. The ostia are narrow slits connecting the i)ericardial cavity with the lumen of the heart, and they are supplied with inward projecting connective tissue lips which make efficient valves. Leaving the organ are eleven arteries; four pairs of lateral arteries from the four anterior segments, two aortic arches, and one median aorta. The aortic end of the heart is provided with a strong connective tissue valve around which the heart musculature curves concavely

Structure of Liinulus Heart Muscle. 405

on the dorsal side. The posterior end is attached to the carapace by a broad sheet of connective tissue. The outer surface of the heart looks as if it were longitudinally striated, an appearance which is due to a layer of elastic tissue strands.

Microscopic Histology.

In cross section the heart is somewhat triangular in outline and may be seen to consist of three layers. (See Fig. 1.) The median layer (Fig. 1, b) is a fine, dense, connective tissue support, termed the basement membrane (Patten and Redebaugh, 1899). Outside of this is the longitudinal layer of elastic tissue fibers mentioned above. Inside the basement membrane is the muscular layer which consists of branching, anastomosing strands, arising from the basement membrane and running mostly in a circular direction. The muscular layer is thickest at the angles of the heart and thins out over the aortic valve. It is with this layer that v/e are most concerned.

By reference to Fig. 1 the general characteristics of the muscular heart wall can be understood. Trabeculse of striated muscular tissue arise from the basement membrane, branching and anastomosing until a spongy heart wall is formed. 'Ro membrane limiting the lumen corresponding to the endocardium of the mammalian heart is present. In only one region is the lumen lined and that is at the aortic valve where for a short space the muscle layer lies between two connective tissue layers, the basement membrane above and the tissue of the valve beneath.

The blood circulates freely around the strands of the heart, passing into all the interstices and crevices, thus bathing the entire musculature. This arrangement for securing nutriment seems to be quite sufficient. A small amount of connective tissue appears between the trabecular, especially in the thicker parts of the heart wall. This can easily be traced back in origin to the basement membrane. It would seem that capillaries might enter along with this tissue, but as far as can be determined they do not do so, unless it bo in the deeper parts immediately adjacent to the basement membrane.

A small fragment of the heart wall macerated in 20 per cent nitric

406 Walter J. Meek.

acid and teased with needles gives such pictures as represented by Fig. 2. The trabeculse are at once apparent. They are of all sizes and run for the most part circularly around the lumen of the heart. These strands branch freely in all directions and join neighboring strands. Preparations teased in this way show even more plainly than the cross section described above, that the heart is a great network of muscle, whose strands form a spongy wall or a thick solid one according as they are mingled together. In the heavier heart walls the strands branch with rather acute angles, and in life the meshes between are no doubt mostly potential spaces. In the parts near the lumen the meshes are large. Often many trabeculse fuse and form large sheets of muscle, which are really only large trabeculse, since they again divide and the parts reunite with neighboring strands. (See Fig. 3.)

On teasing these trabecule with fine needles it is seen that they tend to split into smaller strands along lines fairly well determined at least for short distances. These smaller strands which may be regarded as the real heart fibers branch and anastomose with each other within the primary trabeculse. This arrangement is particularly visible in tissue macerated in Zenker's solution, stained, and examined in glycerine under high power. Fig. 4 shows this arrangement semi-diagrammatically.

So far as can be determined neither the trabeculae nor the secondary anastomosing strands composing the larger trabeculse, end freely. Marceau (1904) has described such a condition in the lower vertebrates. He finds a large number of heart fibers ending freely among the trabeculse in the Fishes, Batrachians, Saurians, and Ophidians. In the Chelonians and Crocodilians the free endings are quite rare, and in the higher vertebrates they do not occur at all. In teased specimens of Limulus heart muscle the endings found are always such as those shown in Fig. 2. The smaller branches here represent the heart fibers and it is very apparent that the blunt ends are due to transverse rupture by the needles. Conical or filiform terminations, which would be the characteristic shape or natural endings, have not been found. If they do occur they must be somewhat rare. In this particular the heart of Limulus is like the higher vertebrates.

Structure of Limulus Heart Muscle. 407

The structure thus far described has been made out by teasing in macerating fluids. For more definite work stained preparations are necessary. The chief interest centers in cross and longi sections of the trabecular. Such sections determine the accuracy of the ideas already obtained and also give the structure of the fibers making up the trabeculse.

When a specimen is sectioned parallel with the long axis of the heart most of the trabeculse are seen in cross section. The field is filled with oval, circular, triangular, or short ribbon-like areas. These are the trabeculse^ and it is apparent that they vary greatly in size and shape. The smallest are al)out 12 micra, and tlie largest observed were al)()ut 90 micra in diameter. Near the basement meml)rane the areas are closely appressed, while toward the lumen there is considerable ^pace lietween. The arrangement is irregular and the whole appearance is what one might expect from cutting across strands that form a spongy heart wall.

Figs. 5, 6, and 7 show four of these trabeculse in cross section. The greater portion of each area is mostly filled with the cross sections of the contractile fibrils which appear as black dots. These have no very definite arrangement. In some cases they seem to have a reticulated appearance, as in Fig. 7. Tn others they are in more solid masses, as in Figs. 5 and 6. Only in the smallest is the strand ever completely filled with fibrils. Between the fibrils sarcoplasm is of course present. Clear areas are nearly always present in the cross sections. Some of these may be due to vacuolization produced by the fixative, but a certain number probably represent the poorly staining protoplasmic columns of the muscle fibers. In these columns are found the nuclei of the muscle fibers. Surrounding the fibrillar area is a thin cylinder of protoplasm which is bounded externally by a fine but perfectly definite line. Within this boundary and lying in the protoplasmic cylinder are found nuclei which in cross section resemble those found in the protoplasmic cylinder. (See Fig, 7 for illustration of these details.)

The number of nuclei in the clear areas of the fibrillar portions is variable ; there may be of course none, and there may be as many as five or six in the larger trabeculre. When more than one nucleus

408 Walter J. Meek.

appears at a given level each one probably belongs to a separate so-called fiber. The territory of each fiber is, however, impossible to determine, a fact that is due to the irregular arrangement of the fibrils. Fig. G illustrates this point. Here two nuclei appear and one would judge that at least two fibers composed the trabecula, but it would be impossible to divide the fibrillar area into two very definite regions. This fact is due to the free branching and anastomosing of the fibers within the primary trabeculse. Since these secondary strands have no well defined boundaries, yet branch and fuse with each other, the heart muscle must be considered a syncytium. In a syncytic structure one can scarcely speak of definite cells or fibers and this is plainly borne out by the confused fibrillar areas in the cross sections of the trabecule. The contractile elements form strands which branch and fuse. These strands may be called fibers or cells for convenience, but they must not be confused in structure with such fibers as we have in skeletal muscle.

In longi sections, cross and longi striation is well brought out by the iron hsematoxylin method. As in the heart muscle of all other forms it is evident that each contractile fibril is continuous throughout the entire musculature, ending only where the muscle fiber itself takes its origin. The clear areas of the cross sections now appear as longitudinal clefts mostly filled with protoplasm. In these lie the muscle nuclei. Fig. 8 shows a trabecula illustrating these points. These muscle nuclei are long and narrow in diameter, with edges which curve out toward the membrane of Krause. There is a scant chromatin network and at least one nucleolus is usually visible. The fibrils are grouped into strands, which illustrates the inner syncytic structure already discussed. Outside of these strands is again seen the cylinder of protoplasm and outside of this the fine linear boundary (c and f in Fig. 8). The peripheral nuclei are now seen to be oval in shape. They equal the muscle nuclei in diameter, but otherwise do not resemble them closely. The boundary membrane appearing as a fine line (/ in Fig. 8) is attached to the Z line of the muscle fiber, the membrane of Krause, and for this reason it appears in a series of festoons rather than a straight line. It has proved quite a task to decide what relation this outer protoplasmic

Structure of Liniulus Heart Muscle. 409

cylinder with its limiting membrane and peripheral nuclei bears to the contractile portions within. The boundary line at first sight is strikingly similar to the membrane Ileidenhain figures as a sarcolemma (1901) in human heart muscle. There is the same protoplasmic area just outside the outermost fibril and the membrane arches in festoons to meet the Z line. This gives the same effect that McCallum describes in mammals (1897), where he says the rounded edge of the sarcoplasmic discs makes up the edge of the fiber. The presence of nuclei just beneath this membrane seems opposed to the view that a sarcolemma is present unless it is assumed that there are two kinds of nuclei present in the fiber, one being at the periphery to attend to the growth of the cell. The facts are without question, it being merely a matter of interpretation. Of course if the trabeculse were considered as having a sarcolemma the strands within could no longer be considered as the real heart fibers. The structure would still be a syncytium, but the significance of the secondary syncytium within the trabeculse would be changed.

Most observers, however, agree that the lower forms do not have a sarcolemma (Renaut et Mollard, 190-1), the heart fibers being bare. The simpler explanation would be that the trabeculae are provided with a connective tissue sheath. This Avas tested by using standard connective tissue stains, and it was found that the limiting membrane stained blue with Mallory's and pink with Van Gieson's. Van Gieson's was not entirely decisive, however, since the Z line also took the same color. By keeping sections twenty minutes in the acid fuschin solution of Mallory's stain and then reducing the time in the aniline blue solution to about three minutes, it was found that the limiting membrane always stained blue, while Krause's membrane often took a bright purple color. This differentiation in color would indicate that the two structures were different. Heidenhain (1901) found that vanadium hsematoxylin stained the sarcolemma and the Z line both blue, connective tissue taking a much lighter bluish color. In Limulus sections vanadium haematoxylin stained the basement membrane a faint blue and the muscle substance an orange, which seemed to indicate that the stain was ripe and working properly. The membrane in question, however, seemed little if at all

410 Walter J. Meek.

aifected by the stain, and this is what one would expect if the structure were connective tissue. Being thin it would stain so faintly that it would make but little impression.

These results enable us to formulate our conception of the heart musculature. The heart wall is made up of branching, anastomosing trabeculse which are individualized by connective tissue sheaths. Within these trabecule are the naked strands of muscle which also branch and fuse and thus form a true heart syncytium. Possibly the connective tissue sheath takes the place of a sarcolemma by functioning as a dialyzing membrane for the exchange of the nutriment. If it is related in any way to the development of the sarcolemma in higiier forms it must bo noted that the relation here is to the tralieculse and not directly to the iibers within.

In Limulus then we have the same general conditions that are found in the lower vertebrate heart. There are no free endings of muscle fibers, but these even disappear with the higher reptiles. The connective tissue sheath seems more closely appressed than in the case of most forms figured by Marceau. With these two differences, neither of which can be fundamental, the heart muscle can scarcely be told from that of the lower vertebrates. To convince oneself of this it is only necessary to compare Marccau's figures of the lower vertebrates, particularly the fishes, frog, and turtle, with those figured for Limulus.

Physiologically the important fact brought out by a study of the Limulus heart musculature is that it is a syncytium practically indistinguishable from that of the vertebrate heart. Carlson (1904) has shown conclusively that the normal myocardium of Limulus is incapable of physiological conduction. When the nerve ganglion is removed the muscle responds to a local stimulus by a local contraction and there is no conduction whatever of the contraction to a more distant part of the organ. We have here then a heart, syncytic in structure, with a protoplasmic continuity throughoiit, which nevertheless does not conduct under normal conditions. This fact, that muscular continuity may be associated with the absence of muscular conduction, renders invalid the argument drawn from the syncytic structure in favor of the myogenic theory of conduction in the vertebrate heart.

Strnetnre of Liimiliis IToart ^rnsole. 411

A few more points may be of interest. The trabeculse take their origin from the basement membrane. Here, and in the connective tissue guarding the ostia are the only places where fibers have been found to end. The ending is not often conical, as noticed in skeletal muscle. The fibers rather fray out and the connective tissue inserts itself between the fibrils. The connection is thus one of fibrils to connective tissue rather than that of an entire strand.

The trabeculse are often separated by narrow clefts into which the connective tissue sheath inserts itself, as may be seen in Eig. 9. This makes the trabecula;? on the average rather narrow in diameter. The function of the sheath in Fig. 9 may be a support, since the cross striation shows that the fibrils are not in synchrony.

Bands of Eberth are of course not found in the Limulus heart. These structures do not appear in man until after birth and are not found lower in the animal kingdom than in the birds. Their absence in Limulus is therefore of no significance.


The heart musculature of Limulus is a double syncytium. It consists of branching, anastomosing trabt^cula? individualized by connective tissue sheaths, within which heart fi\)cv^ l)raneli and anastomose, thus forming a continuous network of contractile tissue.

The heart tissue studied agrees with all heart tissue in these fundamental facts.

1. It has the regular cross striation.

2. Contractile fibrils are continuous throughout the musculature, ending only where the fibers take their origin.

3. The trabeculse are provided with a peripheral covering which may serve as a dialyzing membrane.

4. The heart muscle is a syncytium.

The fact that the heart musculature is- syncytic would show that a continuity of musculature is not decisive evidence for the myogenic theorv of conduction.

412 Wnltor J. Moek.


Carlson, A. J., 1904. The Nervous Origin of the Heart-beat in Limulus and the Nervous Nature of Coordination or Conduction in the Heart. Am. Jour. Phys., Vol. XII, p. 67.

Heidenhain, 1901. Ueber die Struetur des meusoblichen Herzmuskels. An.

Anz., Vol. XX, p. 33. MaCallum, 1897. On the Histology and the Histogenesis of the Heart

Muscle Cell. An. Anz., Vol. XII, p. 609. Mabceau, 1904. Recherches sur la structure et le developpement compare

des fibres cardiaque. Ann. des Sc. Nat. Zool., Vol. XIX, p. 245. Patten and Redebaugh, 1899. Studies on Limulus. Jour. Morph., Vol. XVI,

p. 129. Renaut et Mollabd, 1904. Le Myocard. Rev. Gen. d'Hist., Vol. I, p. 213.


Fig. 1. Semi-diagrammatic portion of entire heart wall, a — branching muscular layer, b — Basement membrane, c — Elastic tissue.

Fig. 2. Trabeculre teased in 20 per cent nitric acid. Drawn with camera lucida. Leitz Ob. 0, Oc. 4. a — Blunt end of small strand.

Fig. 3. Large flat trabecula. Teased from 20 per cent nitric acid and drawn under camera lucida as above.

Fig. 4. Semi-diagrammatic. Constructed from thick paraffin section. Anastomosing trabeculfe are shown with anastomosing strands of muscle within, a — Sheath around triibeculte. B — Strand of contractile tissue, d — Nucleus of contractile strand, c — Nucleus of sheath.



Fig. 2.

inn ini »//// iJTT am un jnii ffjf ///// iiu

ifj isu

HI L!i'

^1 tin m (777

,01/] Uu



Fig. 3.


Fig. 4.

EXPLANATION OF PLATE IL Fig. 5. Cross-section of two small trabeculae. Stained in iron hsematoxylin and followed by Van Gieson's. Leitz 01). 12, Oc. 3. Camera Incida. X 1,000. Lettering the same as Fig. 7.

Fig. 6. Cross-section of a trabecnla. Stained in iron htematoxylin and followed by Van Gieson's. Leitz Ob. 12, Oc. 3. Camera lucida. X 1,000. Lettering the same as Fig. 7. Shows two nuclei at same level, each in its axis of protoplasm.

Fig. 7. Cross-section of a large trabecula. Stained in iron hsematoxylin followed by eosin. Leitz Ob. 12, Oc. 3. Camera lucida. x 1,100. a— Nuclei of connective-tissue sheath, b — Connective-tissue sheath around trabecula. c — Protoplasm within sheath, d — Nucleus of muscle fiber, e — Axial protoplasmic region in which nuclei are embedded.

Fig. 8. Longi section of a trabecula. Iron hiematoxylin followed by Van Gieson's. Leitz Ob. 12, Oc. 3. Camera lucida. X 1,100. f — Connectivetissue membrane, g — Strand of contractile fibrils. Other letters the same as in Fig. 7.

Fig. 9. Longi section stained with Mallory's connective-tissue stain. Color shown as in preceding figures. Leitz Ob. 12, Oc. 3. X 1,100. a — Cleft dividing the trabecula into which the connective tissue sheath has entered. The appearance is similar to what Heidenhain figures as the "daughter sarcolemma."

Fig. 10. Longi section. Iron hsematoxylin followed by eosin. X 1,100. a — connective-tissue sheath which persists between the fusing trabeculae until the cross striation becomes synchronous.



FiQ. 5.




Fig. 9.




Fig. 7.


<i„' ',•«••-• • •,•••%■« ■?


uny ntt

Ut; , tut



tin Jill.


The Jouknal of Moephology. — Vol. XX. No. 3.

Fig. 10.

Fig. 8.



A Study in x\kachnid Embryology.




I. Historical Statement 413

II. Materials and Methods 419

III. Origin of the Germ Layers, and Formation of the Cephalic Plate 422

Part 1. Formation of the Blastoderm 422

Part 2. Formation of tlie Blastodisc 423

Part 3. Formation of the Primary Thickening, or Primitive

Cumulus 425

Part 4. Formation of the Secondary, or Caudal, Thickening 425

Part 5. The Ventral Plate 428

IV. Development of the Procephalic Lobes. Stages 1-11 429

V. Formation of the Adult Brain 445

VI. The Eyes of Epeira J^"

VII. Comparison of the Araneid Brain with that of other Arthropods 452

VIII. General Considerations 454

Acknowledgments 455

Bibliography 455

Plates 461

I. HiSTOTjicAL Statement.

Amoii^' the ol>jecls to attract tlic attention of the earliest workers in the field of invertebrate embryology, the stndy of the Arachnids occupied an interesting and important place.

The results of work done on the Araneina, however, have been very general in their character ; few investigators have undertaken special problems relating to the subject. Within a few years several excel Thb Jouknal of MoRrHOLOGY. — Vol. XX, No. 3.

414 Avery E. Lambert.

lent papers have been published which show that the trend of observation, in recent years, has been in that direction.

The earliest studies on the embryology of the Araneina were undertaken before the technical methods, now employed in such investigations, were known. For this reason, the earliest papers on the subject have little value for us apart from their historical interest.

The earliest paper to deal distinctively with the development of the spider was published by Herold (15) in 1824. In 18G2 Claparede (8) published the results of his studies on the earlier stages in the development of the spider. His observations were made with surface preparations only, and consequently failed to throw light on the segmentation of the nucleus and the formation of the germ layers.

He succeeded, however, in carrying his studies of the development of the external form of the embryo up to the period of reversion. He observed and figured the caudal thickening, to which he gave the name "primitive cumulus." This term has not been consistently applied, by those who have subsequently treated the subject, to the accumulation of cells which form a slight elevation in the caudal region of the embryo ; but has been more commonly used to designate the first accumulation of cells which occurs in the middle region of the blastodisc.

The division of the yolk of the spider's eggs into columns, and the subsequent arrangement of these columns in the form of rosettes,"^ was correctly reported by Ludwig (24) in his study of the formation of the blastoderm of spiders' eggs, published in 1878. He also noted the fact that the l)lastoderm arises at one end, instead of covering the entire egg.

In 18Y8, Barrios (3) published the results of his study of the development of the spider in which he called attention to what he termed a limnloid" stage, referring to the form of the embryo ])revious to the period of reversion.

Up to this time investigators had to content themselves with the study of the external form of Araneid embryos. Balfour (1), who first applied the section method to the study of Arachnid embryology,

Procopluilic Lobes of Epeira Cinerca. 415

published a paper in 1880 which contained several important contributions to the knowledge of the subject.

Owing to his failure to obtain sections of the pre-blastodermic stages he was led to attribute the formation of the mesoderm, in part, to cells which, he believed, migrated into this layer from the yolk. He observed, however, and correctly reported, that a portion of the mesoderm is derived from the blastoderm.

Schimkewitsch (38), in a paper published in 1887, maintained that all of the cells derived from the division of the segmentation nucleus do not migi-ate to the surface of the egg, but some remain in the yolk and contribute to the formation of the cndoderm; this conclusion later researches have failed to confirm. But this author w^as able to demonstrate that the rostrum, in spiders, arises as a pair of prominences on the anterior margin of the cephalic plate, these prominences uniting later to form the upper lip.

Morin (30) in a brief paper which appeared in 1886 followed the whole course of the development of the spider. Tn his study of the fate of the seginentation nucleus, he found that the nuclei, resulting from its division, rise to the surface of the egg, the greater number of them participating in the formation of the blastoderm. According to this author, the cells which appear in the yolk, after the formation of the first cellular layer, are not derived from cells that have been retained in the yolk, as had been stated by previous authors, but from the blastoderm itself.

The two most important contril)utions to the study of the embryology of the spider, and in many respects the most satisfactory, are those wdiich were made by Locy (23) in 1886, and Kishinouye (19) in 1890. Locy made a oom]ilete study of the embryology of Agalena naevia by the section inctliod. lie established the fact that a depression exists in the middle region of the primitive cumnlns, beneath which the multiplication of cells takes place very rapidly. Because of the relation which this depression bears to the mass of rapidly proliferating cells, he interpreted it as representing the blastopore.

The most imi)ortant pnrf of Locy's work is that which relates to the development of the anterior median eyes. He was able to show that these eyes arise by means of an infolding which causes an inver

/I H; Anctv K. I.;iiiil)('ii.

sioii of llic oplic clciiuMils; the eyes boeomiiig, by this means, a threclayend, instead of a two-hiyerod, structure. This fact had been |)oiiile(l out previously by Patten (<}2), in a iiiore <;cii<'ral paper on ilie eyes of JVlollusks and Arthropods.

Kishinonye's paper is one of the most imjjortant among the later colli ribiil ions to (he subject. V>y his observation Ihat the division of the so^'inontation nneleus is accompimicd Ity a (lixision ol thc^ yolk inio parts correspond ing to the nundicr (•!" th(^ products ol nuclear division, he has l>een abh' to throw important lii;ht, on the segmentation of this class of eggs, lie also fouiul, with regard to the body cavitv of the si)idcr, that the original c(eloin disappears except that portion which is enclosed in the heart, constituting the lumen of that organ, and in the stercoral ]X)cket ; the body-cavity of the adult s))ider being a secondary ac(]uirement. The dcNclopnient of the respiratory ap|)aratiis h(> assixdates Avith the lirst two pairs of abdominal appendages; the; nnuaining abdominiil appendages being invohcd in the fornialion of the spinning mainniilhc.

His description of tlie origin of the anterior — or as he calls them, \\\v postei-ior — median eyes agrei^s with the oi)sei'vat ions of Patten and r.ocv. He descrilx'S the otluu- paii" of median eyes and the lateral eyes as originating in simple tliickenings of the ectoderm in \\w 0|)tic area; a radical departure from the conditions of origin and development of the so-called accesscu'v eyes as stated by Locy.

Whil(> St. Ivemy (oO), in his excellent monogra|)h on the nervous system of Artliropods, has given an accurate desci-iptiou of the conditions in the adult brain of the spider, either on ai'count of the ditiiculties presented by the problem, or for want of intcu-est in it, very little work has been accomplished, in relation to th(> special ])robleTus of development, on the AraiuMd brain. Neither iJalfour, Locy, nor Ivishinouye, have giA-en satisfacttu-y acconuts of the origin and development of the cephalic lobes.

r>alfour found that \hc brain originates as a thickening of the cephalic plate, and that it presents a segmented condition. But he failed to state whether he regarded the segmentation of the cephalic ])\i\\o as having any spcn^ial significance. Tie folloAved the development of the brain through to its separation from thv. ectoderm, and

l'i'()('('|)Ii;ilic L(i|)cs (if M|)cir:i ( 'iiicrcii. 117

fouTul tliat, in its later condition, it consisted of a principal cerebral mass which is connected with the sub-ocsophageal ganglia by a pair of commissures consisting' of the two halves of the clu^liceral segment; the sub-<Psophageal mass consisting of the remaining thoracic ganglia.

Locy, in his pa]iei- <mi the dcnclopniciil of A(/aleria nwvia, fiiiled (o add mu(di l<> the cxisliiii;' knowledges of I lie cei-ebra! lobes; although he successfully foll(t\\<(l (he developiiieiil. of llic iinlei-ior median eyes which, in their foi-iimt ion, are iiil iiiuitely associated with the development of the anterior lobes of I lie brnin.

Kishinouye's acccjuiit of llie (le\'elo|»iiieiil of llie brain of the spider, while in some respects more satisfnctoi-y I ban that given by bis predecessors, still leaves much to be said, lie slates that the rudiment of the cxintral nervous system is laid down very shortly after the formation of the germ band, and that the ectodc^rm of tJui (cephalic plate is broken up into ridges by the for-iiial Ion of successive transvfirsc thickenings which are coiit iniious with simibir thickenings that aj)pear later on the inner margins (»f llie bileral bamls of llie end>ryo. '^Fhtise thickenings, wliich appear in llie eclodenn of llie cepludic plate, indicate the Ix'ginniMg of llie ganglia of tln' brain. Tliose which appear on the lateral halves of llie v(!iitral plate form the rudiment of the nerve cord.

Balfour, Locy aiul K isliinouye rec<)giii/,e llie relations which the crescentic invaginations, ^\■lliell iippear on the anterior margin of the ceplialic ])latc, bear to the formal ion of Ibe anlei-ior vesicles of the brain. They are able; to acc()unt for llu; formation of the lateral vesicles from similar, though smaller, invaginations which appear on the lateral mai-gins of the plalc K'ishinoiiye states that the anterior vesicles form the principal mass of tlu; bi-ain, but he failed to relatx' them, as Locy does, with the develof»ment of the antx'rior median eyes.

Patten (34, 35, and ;U'» ) called attention to the significance of the appearance of pre-oral segments in the cephalic plate of Arthropods, and ])ointed f)ut that such seginents wen; similar in charactfir to those which were j)ost-oral in position and bore appendages. IFo was able to show that the segments of the cxjphalic plate were divided by distinct thickenings of the ectoderm into c(>rebral and optic ganglia,

418 Avery E. Lambert.

a condition which he first obser\'ed in Acilius, and fonnd afterward in a more marked degree in scorpions and spiders. He was led to homologize the thickenings on the inner margins of the pre-oral segments, the cerebral ganglia, with the thickenings which occnpy a similar position on the inner margins of the segments of the lateral bands, and which form the neuromeres which later develop into the nerve cord.

According to Patten, the vesicles formed by the anterior and lateral invaginations do not furnish the principal mass of the brain, but form important lobes instead which become associated with the optic tracts.

In his discussion of the development of the brain of scorpions, this author pointed out the fact that the entire area of the fore-brain is covered by a fold which progressively extends inward from the l^eriphery of the lobes. This fold, he found, bears a most important relation to the formation of the median eyes, and also to what he calls the "vesicle" of the fore-brain.

The origin and development of the eyes have formed one of the most important subjects of investigation in Arachnid embryology, and furnish a problem which is closely associated with the study of the development of the brain.

The first contribution of importance to our knowledge of the subject was made by Grenacher, whose paper was published in 1879. Graber (13) immediately followed with an account of the morphology of the eyes of Arachnids, in which he failed to accept Grenadier's results.

Patten (32), in 1886, called attention to the fact that the median eyes of spiders consist of three layers, an outer, or corneal, a middle or retinal, and an inner or post-retinal, layer. He also pointed out that, in consequence of its manner of formation, the retinal layer became inverted so that its elements presented the same relation to the direction of the rays of light that we find in the vertebrate eye, a fact which was afterward established by Locy and Schimkewitsch, who made a careful study of their mode of development.

These observations were confirmed by Mark (25) in 1887, who discussed at length the morphological derivation and relations of the eyes of Arthropods.

Procoplialic Lobes of Epeiru Cinerea. 419

Patten, in 1898, in his paper on color vision, has given a more detailed account of the remarkable stnicture of the retinal elements in the eyes of Lycosa, calling- attention more especially to the relation the form of the retinal cells bear to their position in the head and to the direction of the rays of light falling npon them.

II. Materials and Methods.

In the following observations use was made of the eggs of Epeira clncrea; all of the materials being collected in, or about, Hanover, New Hampshire. This spider is one of the largest to be found in northern ISTew England, which, together with its habit of infesting houses and barns where, as a general thing, its nests are made in easily accessible places, and the fact that the eggs are relatively large and are, therefore, easily handled, renders this material well adapted for emhryological work.

The eggs are bound in a firm yellow mass in the cocoon, being held together by a kind of cementing substance which is probably secreted during their passage through the oviducts from the walls of the duct. They can be easily removed from the cocoon by cutting its walls away with scissors, and carefully manipulating the cut edges with forceps. Considerable care has to be exercised in isolating the eggs, as the membranes are easily ruptured. By cautiously forcing them out of the mass with needles, the majority of them may be removed without injury. This process is aided by their natural elasticity which is very great.

Three methods were employed in killing and fixing the eggs after they had been separated. The first was to plunge the eggs into water heated to Y0°-80° C, and afterwards transferring them to 95 per cent alcohol in which they were hardened. Then they were placed in 70 per cent alcohol in which they wore preserved. This is the method employed by Locy and Kishinouye. Unfortunately, however, it did not give good results except in the older stages ; the yolk, in the earlier stages, showing a tendency to crumble and fall to pieces.

The second method was to kill the eggs in hot Perenyi's fluid, the eggs being left in the fluid from twenty to thirty minutes, or long

420 Avery E. Lambert.

enough to ensure thorough penetration ; after which they were passed through the diflferent grades of alcohol to 95 per cent for hardening. The results ol)tained by this method were not entirely satisfactory, as eggs in both the younger and older stages showed a tendency to collapse. In those eases where collapse did not occur the preparations gave excellent results.

The third, and most successful method for all stages, was to plunge the eggs into picro-sulphuric acid (Kleinenberg's formula) heated to 70°-80° C, in which they were allowed to remain until the acid had cooled. They were then passed through the grades to the 95 per cent alcohol from which, after hardening, they were returned to the 70 per cent for preservation. By placing the specimen bottles on a water-bath at 50° C, the stain left the eggs more rapidly than at the ordinary temperature of the room, thus obviating one of the objections to the use of this reagent.

Fixing the eggs in hot fluids is of advantage in that it insures instant coagulation of the protoplasm, the rapid penetration of the reagent, and also helps to distend the closely-fitting egg-membranes. This makes the removal of the egg-membranes, which is necessary when the embryos are to be treated for surface preparations, a comparatively easy matter.

In preparing the embryos for study I have used a modification of Patten's method of staining and mounting. This method for obtaining permanent, detailed surface views of Arthropod embryos was first used in the preparation of the eggs of Acilius, Blatta, Limuliis and Buflius, by Patten in 1888. It has been made use of since by other investigators with only minor modifications.

The method consists of the emersion of the naked egg, or embryo, in a strong stain for a few seconds if the staining of only the superficial layers is desired, or for a longer period in a more dilute stain if the j)(Micf ration of the deeper cell layers is sought. By using strong, nuclear stains the yolk and cytoplasm of the cells absorbs but little of the coloring matter, and this may be readily removed by the use of acidulated alcohol, the result being that the surface contours of the embryo, and the distribution of the nuclei, are shown with the utmost clearness. The final mounting may be made in balsam or damar.

Procephalic Lobes of Epeira Cinerea. 421

After the embryo has become invested with a ehitinous cuticle, the process of staining is much slower; the cuticle being penetrated with difficulty. It is then necessary to keep the embryo in the stain several hours, or even for a day or two ; this is followed by a slow decoloration Avith acid alcohol until all traces of the extra-nuclear stain have been removed.

For the preparation of the embryos the investing membranes were removed with needles, and the eggs allowed to remain in acid hsemalum (Mayer's foinnula) from thirty seconds to a minute, in which time only the nuclei of the outer layers were affected by the stain. For staining the deeper layers the hsemalum was diluted one-half, the eggs remaining in it from fifteen to twenty minutes. By means of this latter method the more deeply lying portions of the embryo can be distinguished, especially in those areas in which there is a rapid proliferation of cells.

Borax carmine was also used, giving very satisfactory results. In using the carmine some excess of stain is sure to appear both in the plasma and yolk. This has to be removed with acid. In the older stages the acid causes the yolk to swell, frequently splitting the embryo, and thus rendering the preparation useless.

Very early stages are difficult to handle on account of the closeness with which the membranes cling to the qq;^, making it almost impossible for them to be removed without injuring the underlying parts. For the examination of these stages resort was made to a method suggested by Prof. Patten, and which he had employed successfully in the study of the eggs of Patella. The living egg was placed on a glass slide in a few drops of glycerine, to which a drop or two of concentrated acetic acid had been added. After a few minutes the egg-membranes are penetrated by the acid and glycerine, and become sufficiently clear to enable one to distinguish the cells and their nuclei on the surface of the egg. This method is an excellent one for determining the stage in which the eggs are found before proceeding with the fixation.

422 Avery E. Lambert.


Cephalic Plate.

The eggs of Epeira cinerea are slightly elliptical and of a golden yellow color. They are a little less than a inillimeter in diameter. The greater part of the egg consists of masses of yolk, separated from one another by thin sheets of protoplasm which radiate from the center of the egg. These protoplasmic sheets unite above the surface of the yolk where they form a thin layer called the periplasm.

The entire egg is surrounded by two membranes, an inner, vitelline membrane, which lies close to the periplasm, and an outer membrane, the chorion. The vitelline membrane is thin, delicate, and transparent. The chorion has a tougher texture, the egg bt^iiig seen through it with difficulty. ]joth membranes are supposed to be secreted by the oviducts (Korschelt and Heider, 21).

Numerous minute globules adhere to the outside of the chorion, giving to it a distinctly granular appearance. That these granules are not structurally a part of the membrane is seen by the fact that when the living egg is immersed in alcohol they float away from it freely.

Viewed from the surface the yolk masses appear as a group of more or less irregular polygons (Ludwig, 24; Locy, 23; Kishinouye, 19). At first there is a slight furrowing of the periplasm, the lines of the furrows coinciding with the edges of the polygonal yolk masses. Later, however, the yolk shifts so that the edges of the masses and the furrows no longer coincide (Kishinouye, 19).

1. The Formation of the Blastoderm. — It is not possible for me to make a satisfactory statement concerning the earlier stages in the development of the eggs of Epeira, as I was unable to secure enough material of this period for a thorough study ; and I am in doubt if the eggs I did obtain for the earlier stages were normal. Eggs which were killed immediately after being deposited in the cocoon, and sectioned, failed to reveal any traces of a nucleus, a condition also noted by Kishinouye in the material which he studied.

Shortly after this, however, according to Morin, Locy, and Kishinouye, a nucleus, surrounded by a mass of protoplasm, appears in the center of the egg. Kishinouye also reports the presence of a

Procephalic Lobes of Epeira Cinerea. 423

peculiar structure, located near the uueleus, which he calls the yolk nucleus.

Segmentation of the egg begins, according to these authors, by the division of the centrally located nucleus into two, four, eight, etc., parts. This affects the whole structure of the egg, the yolk splitting with each division of the nucleus into a corresponding number of parts, each part containing one of the products of nuclear division (Kishinouye, 19). In this manner the yolk becomes separated into the numerous, radially arranged masses already noted, to which the name "yolk columns" has been applied.

The separation of the yolk into columns discloses a cavity in the central part of the egg. This has been regarded by some investigators as representing the segmentation cavity. It is obliterated at a later period by the incrowding of the yolk masses.

The nuclei resulting from the repeated division of the segmentation nucleus gradually pass along the lines of protoplasm which radiate outward between the yolk columns, and finally appear on the surface of the egg. They are first seen at the points where the radiating strands of protoplasm unite with the periplasm, and are equally distributed over the entire surface of the egg (Morin, 30; Kishinouye, 19).

A certain amount of protoplasm accompanies the nuclei in their outward migration (Korschelt and Heider). This unites with the periplasm. In this manner the cellular elements are formed which lay the foundation of the blastoderm. Shortly after this period, by the shifting of the yolk, the nuclei are no longer seen at the points where the protoplasmic radii and the periplasm meet, but lie more or less directly in the areas formed l)y the surfaces of the yolk columns. Fig. 1, nu.

2. Formation of the Blastodisc. — Following the formation of the blastoderm as a single, uniform layer of cells surrounding the egg, there is a concentration of the nuclei on one surface, namely that on which the embryo arises and Avhich may be regarded as the ventral surface of the egg. This concentration of nuclei has been observed by most investigators ; but there is a variety of opinion as to the manner in which the additional cells originate.

424 Avorv E. LniTi])ert.

Both Balfour and Locy report the appearance of nuclei on the ventral surface of the egg at an earlier period than that at which they appear on the dorsal surface. Kishinouye, however, with whose observations my own accord in this respect, states that the nuclei appear simultaneously, at first, over the entire surface of the egg, and accumulate later, by division and migration, on the ventral surface.

Thus two distinct poles may be recognized in the egg of the spider ; a vegetative pole, irregular in form and characterized by large, irregularly projecting masses of yolk, its surface bearing relatively few nuclei, those present being noticeably large — Fig. 2, ylk. — and an animal pole where the yolk is compacted to form a comparatively smooth, spherical surface, the cellular layer which covers its surface being indicated by the presence of numerous, closely crowded nuclei.

After the nuclei have migrated from the other portions of the egg to the ventral region they continue to increase rapidly in number, ultimately forming a cap of cells which covers this part of the egg. This cap is called the blastodisc, Fig. 2, bid. In the meanwhile the nuclei of those cells which have not become incorporated in the blastodisc, but have remained on the vegetative pole of the egg, increase considerably in size.

Balfour states that the endoderm is derived from cells which do not accompany the other cells in their migration to the surface, but are left behind in the yolk mass. Locy, Morin, and Kishinouye, however, failed to find any nuclei in the yolk in sections of either the blastoderm or blastodisc stages. My earliest sections, which were made with eggs whose development was somewhat in advance of the blastoderm stage of the authors mentioned, bear out the latter observations. Figs. 10, 11, and 12, ylk. In Figs. 15 and 16, the yolk cells — y. c. — are migrating from the cells of the blastodisc, from which they have been derived, into the yolk. This condition appears not only to be true of this stage in the Araneina, but was found by Patten (31) in NeopTiylax, and by Wheeler (41) in Blatta.

A marked feature of the blastodisc is the occurrence of a depression in about the middle of its area. (Figs. 2 and 3, hip. Fig. 10, hip ) This depression is the center of an active proliferation of cells which

Procephalic Lobes of Epeira Ciuerea. 425

add to the thickness of the cellular layer in this region, and which contribute to the formation of the mesoderm. Accordingly it seems proper to regard the structure as a primitive blastopore (Korschelt and Heider).

3, Formatioit of (lie Frlmary Thickening, or Frlmiiive Cumulus. — Following the formation of the blastodisc, there is a rapid increase in the number of cells in the region about the blastopore. Cells arising by division from the blastodisc spread out underneath that structure and form a deep layer which has not yet become differentiated into ectodenn and mesoderm.

The cells sink to the greatest depth into the yolk just beneath the blastopore, which is the principal point of increase, and from which they spread out in all directions, extending even to the edge of the blastodisc.

In unstained preparations, when viewed by reflected light, the blastodisc now appears like a white cap covering the animal pole of the egg. In stained preparations it is seen to be a great accumulation of very closely packed cells. Figs. 4 and 5 ; hid.

There is some confusion among different authors as to how this accumulation of cells shall be designated. Balfour and Locy unite in calling it the "primitive cumulus," a name that was applied by Claparede to a structure which appears later, and which has been identified as the caudal thickening. Kishinouye, to avoid the confusion arising from applying the same name to different structures, has called it the "primary thickening," which name seems l:>est adapted to this purpose.

4. Formation of the Caudal, or Secondary, Thickening. — Shortly after the formation of the primary thickening, a second thickening is formed which appears as an elevation of the blastodisc near the edge of the blastopore. This elevation is caused by a rapid accumulation of cells at tliat point. Fig. 5, e. fJi. It is to this structure that Claparede refers in speaking of the "primitive cumulus." Balfour recognized its significance and called it the "caudal thickening.'"

The steps in the formation of the caudal thickening may be outlined as follows. The first result of the rapid multiplication of cells in the region of the blastopore has already been described as the for


•ect .msc







^,o_^o^G,o»» ©ecToder-m




Text-Figure 1. nmtic. )

Ilhistratiug the formation of the mesoderm. (Diagram


A. Early blastodisc stage, hi. p., the blastopore-like depression in the middle of the eetoblast, eet. msd., mesoderm cells, proliferating from the point just beneath the blastopore-like depression. The accumulation of these cells, and their accumulation beneath the eetoblast, forms the primitive cumulus, y. c, yolk cells ; certain of the proliferating cells which find their way into the yolk, ylk., yolk.

B. Longitudinal section through the caudal (secondary) thickening.

1)1. p., blastopore-like depression, c. th., the caudal thickening. The point of most rapid proliferation is in the region of the blastopore, cct., ectoderm. The eetoblast of the blastodisc has become a distinctive germ layer. msd., cells of the growing mesodermal layer spreading out under the ectoderm y. c, yolk cells.

C. Distribution of the mesodermal cieiuents viewed from the under side, c. ///.. caudal tbickeiiing.

Procephalic Lobes of Epeira Cinerea. 42Y

mation of a cone-shaped mass that extends beneath the blastopore downward into the yolk. Text-figure 1, A. The continued formation and growth of cells in this region soon causes the blastopore to disappear, as was pointed out by Morin ; the ultimate result being a pressure from underneath which causes the blastodisc to bulge outward.

The blastodisc increases in extent by the continued division of its cellular elements in radial planes. In the caudal thickening, however, many of the cells divide in tangential planes, and the new cells derived from this division are pushed forward under the blastodisc as well as downward into the yolk. Text-figure 1, B.

The caudal thickening, at this stage, has been likened to a comet, owing to the fact that the lengthening of the blastodisc, or, as it has been designated by Balfour and others, the ventral plate," gives it the appearance of passing backward over the surface of the yolk, leaving a constantly widening trail of nuclei in its path. Textfigure 1, C.

In surface views the nuclei are seen to be arranged in the form of a triangular area covering the ventral surface of the egg. Fig. 6, g. hd. The base of the triangle is a broad plate from which, in a later stage, the cerebral lobes are formed. This structure is the cephalic plate. Figs. 6, 8, and 9, c. pi.

Sections through the early blastodisc stages show that, from the beginning, there is a rapid increase in the number of cells in the region just beneath the blastopore. This proliferation results, as has been stated before, in the formation of an undifferentiated mass of cells which projects downward into the yolk, and also in the formation of the projecting caudal thickening. From the caudal thickening new cells are formed which spread out as a broad sheet under the blastodisc (w^hich may now be regarded as the ectoderm) thus forming the mesodermal layer.

Figs. 11, 12, 15, and 10 represent longitudinal sections made . through the blastodisc at this stage. In these figures the cells of the mesoderm (msd.), are seen to arise from the posterior region of the ventral plate, from which point they shift forward underneath the ectoderm. These cells continue to increase in number by division

428 Avery E. Lambert.

after they have left the region of the caudal thickening. In Fig. 15 some of these cells are seen to be passing into the yolk. This indicates the true origin of the so-called yolk-cells (y-c). Here they increase in size by absorbing nourishment from the yolk, and form the anlage of the endoderm.

Thus at tlie time when the ventral plate of Balfour — or as I shall call it, the germ band" (g.bd.) — is fully established, the three germ layers may be recognized in the embryo ; the ectoderm, which consists of the cells of the blastodisc, and their immediate derivatives, which lie on the surface of the egg ; the mesoderm, consisting of cells which have arisen in the region of the blastopore, and which lie immediately beneath the ectoderm ; the endoderm, which is represented by a number of scattered cells that have arisen coincidently with the cells of the mesoderm, and which have migrated into the yolk.

I can find no evidence that the middle layer is augmented by the addition of cells from the outer layer (Schimkewitsch and Balfour) further than has been stated. Whatever mitotic figures have been found in the cells of the blastodisc, outside of the region of the blastopore, their position indicates that division takes place in the cells of this layer in radial planes. Fig. 14; n.sp. Issue must also be taken with Balfour's statement that the endoderm also contributes to the foiTuation of the mesoderm. As later writers have shown, and as my own results indicate, the endoderm cells do not appear in the yolk until after the cells of the mesoderm have commenced to arise ; the cells of both layers being derived from the same point, namely the proliferating area of the caudal thickening; the cells which pass into the yolk being thrust into that position by the conditions attending their formation, after which they take upon themselves the character of endoderm cells.

5. 21ie Ventral Plate. — The germ band continues to increase in length by the rapid multiplication of its cellular elements until it covers more than two thirds of the circumference of the egg, thus forming the ventral plate. The caudal and cephalic ends of the plate ultimately come quite near one another on the dorsal surface of the egg. Fig. 9.

Procephnlie Lolws of Epeira Cinerea. 429

While this lengthening of the ventral plate is going on, some very important changes are occurring in its structure. The mesoderm cells which are, at first, spread out in a thin sheet under the ectodenn, now begin to arrange themselves in ridges which lie transversely across the band. (Fig. 8; seg.) These ridges, or primitive segments, are separated by furrows, each furrow being bridged by a thin sheet of ectoderm. A widening and lengthening of the cephalic plate is to be noted at this time, due to an increase in the number of its cells.

As the growth of the ventral plate continues there is a continued increase in the number of its segments. After seven or eight of these segments have been formed, small, rounded protul^e ranees appear on the first four. These are the rudiments of the thoracic appendages. (Fig. 9; ap.) Locy states that the fourth thoracic appendage is the first to appear in Agalen<i; the third, second, and first, appearing in order. In Epeira, also, the appendages follow this order in their appearance.

After the thoracic segments are formed two appendage-bearing segments arise in the posterior region of the cephalic plate. The first of these to appear is the segment which bears the pedipalpi, the second being the segment of the chelicerfc.

When the appendages of the head and thorax have arisen, and the ventral plate has lengthened until from ten to twelve segments can be counted, it may be fairly said that the first embryonic stage has been reached.

IV. Development of tpie Peocephalic Lobes.

Stage I. Fig. 19. — In its general development Epeira cinerea conforms very closely, in most points, to the development of other members of the Araneina as described by the authors already cited. Consequently, in the following study I shall confine myself to a discussion of the origin and development of the procephalic, or as they are frequently called, the cerebral, lobes and their associated sense organs.

A^Tlile free use has been made of sections for the ])urpose of confirming results, the major part of the observations recorded were

430 Avery E. Lambert.

directed to a study of the topography of the cerebral lobes in the different stages of tlieir development. Hence reference will be made to surface views, as figured, rather than to sections.

By the time all of the appendages of the head and thorax have arisen, at least eleven segments have been established in the ventral plate. This number may be regarded as being characteristic of this stage. The plate also has lengthened until it has nearly encircled the yolk. (Fig. 9.)

The nuclei of the cells composing the embryonic tissues are quite small, and are closely crowded together. The nuclei which lie outside the embryonic tissue?, and which are scattered irregularly over the surface of the yolk, are conspicuously larger.

The ventral plate is divided into two lateral halves by a broad median furrow (I. fr.) which begins at a point not far from the anterior margin of the cephalic plate, and extends posteriorly along the mid-ventral line to the margin of the caudal lobe. This furrow is bridged by a thin layer of ectoderm which connects the lateral halves of the embryo. The lateral halves of the ventral plate are composed of clearly defined segments.

Two segments lie anterior to those wliich bear the thoracic appendages. The posterior of these is associated with the rudimentary pedipalpi ; the other bearing the rudiments of the chelicerse. In this stage each of the segments of the thorax bears a pair of rudimentary appendages. The remaining segments belong to the abdomen, and increase in number as the embryo continues to lengthen. 'No appendages appear, however, on the abdominal segments during this stage.

That portion of the cephalic plate which lies anterior to the cheliceral segment does not present any marked differentiation at this time, except that the broad, lateral areas, where the optic ganglia (o. gl.) appear at a later period, are considerably thickened. In transverse sections of the cephalic ])late these lateral portions are seen to consist of ectoderm cells which lie several layers deep. A small groove a])])ears, on eacli side of the liend, in the posterior region of this thickened area (laf. gr.). These are the beginnings of the invaginations which form the lateral optic vesicles.

Proccphalic Lobes of Eperia Cinerea. 431

In this stage we find that the middle region of the cephalic plate, which lies close to the anterior margin, has become slightly raised bj the thickening of the ectoderm. This can be readily determined by manipulating the egg with needles so that the structure can be clearly seen by reflected light. The prominence formed by this elevation of the ectoderm is the foundation of the future rostrum, or upper lip (ros.)

Stage II. Fig. 20. — The second embryonic stage is marked by a slight advance in the development of the cephalic plate. The number of body segments may have increased, but there is no fixed number which can be regarded as characteristic of this period. The rudiments of the thoracic appendages have also become more prominent. Of the head appendages, the pedipalps especially have lengthened, and now show a tendency to bend toward the median line, a position which is characteristically maintained by all the appendages except the chelicer?e up to the time of hatching.

A characteristic feature of this stage, to which attention should be called, is the conspicuous furrow which separates the cheliceral segment from the pre-cheliceral part of the cephalic plate. It thus becomes evident that all of the appendage-bearing segments belong to the same series and can not be disting-uished from one another in the earlier stages as the use of the terms "thoracic" and cephalic" appendages w-ould seem to indicate. The union of the first two appendage-bearing segments with those portions of the embryonic plate which give rise to the cerebral structures is a distinctly later event.

The development of the lateral areas of the cephalic plate has continued until the ectoderm is deeper in this region than in any other portion of the plate. The appearance of the lateral tracts in surface views as a considerably darker area is due to the greater thickness of the ectoderm, and the closely crowded nuclei of its cells (o. gl.). The rudiment of the rostrum shows a slight advance by its more marked separation from the adjacent parts {ros.).

Stage III. Fir/. 21. — In this stage a distinct condition of advance is to be recognized in the development of the head region. The lateral, or optic, area is more certainly differentiated from the medially

4.'>2 Avery E. Liiinhcrt.

located cerebral area, the entire cephalic plate being raised into three transverse ridges which are particularly prominent in the optic region where they form the beginning of the optic ganglia (o. gl.).

Between these rudimentary optic ganglia and the longitudinal furrow on each side of the cephalic plate, the transverse ridges present less conspicuous elevations, which form, in a similar manner, the foundations of the cerebral ganglia (c. gl.). Thus we find in this stage that the pre-cheliceral portion of the cephalic plate bears three transverse segments, each segment consisting of a cerebral and an optic portion, a condition which Patten found in both Acilius and Buthvs (No. 35).

The lateral invaginations, or grooves {lat. gr.), now liecome deeper, folding inward until the result is the formation of a pit, the blind end of which lies toward the median line underneath the optic ganglia.

At this time a thickened rim (o. pi.) appears on the outer margin of the optic area on each side of the head. The sensory character of this structure was first established by Patten (33 and 35) who first observed it in Acilius, calling it the optic plate on account of its relation to the future formation of the eyes. Later the same author identified a similar structure in Buthvs and Mygale.

Thus it appears that the cephalic plate of Epeira, anterior to the cheliceral segment, from which it is still separated by a conspicuous furrow on each side of the head, is composed of three distinctly marked, longitudinal areas — a median area which constitutes the foundation of the cerebral ganglia ; a marginal area, forming the rudiment of the optic ganglia; and a thickened marginal rim, the optic plate, which forms, at a later period, the retinal portion of the anterior median eyes.

The broad elevation of the ectoderm which has been already recognized as the rudiment of the rostrum, has now formed two separate prominences {ros.). These prominences have shifted downward from the anterior margin of the head and lie between the cerebral ganglia. A slight depression of the ectoderm, or ectodermal pit, between the two rostral elevations indicates the beginning of the stomodseum {st.).

Proccplmlic l.dlx's of l']|)cii':i ( 'iiicrcii. 433

In sections these elevations are seen to be lined with mesoderm, and enclose a portion of the cffilomic cavity, a fact which indicates their appendage-like character. This double origin of the rostrnm was shown by Schimkewitsch, who also pointed out the fact that, as indicated by their structure, these prominences re])resent a pair of cephalic appendages.

About this time numerous pits appear in the ganglionic areas of the cephalic plate (?i. b.). Each pit arises as an independent structure, and is surrounded by a well-marked circle of nuclei. Tn surface views they appear to be like small, light cells, arranged with considerable r(>gularity in the ectoderm. Viewed superficially they appear to contain no nuclei ; but on close inspection nuclei may be discerned lying below the surface of the depression, thus indicating the position of the cells of which it is composed.

In sections these pits are seen to be surrounded by cells having a considerable regularity of arrangement. The hollow of the pit is filled with a clear substance, a])parently secreted from the surrounding cells.

At first sight these ])its l)car a chisc I'cscniblaiicc 1<» lli(^ structures wdiich Wheeler found in Xi pliidhnn . lo which he api)licd the name of "neuroblasts." The neuroblasts of Wheeler are described as being "numerous, large, light cells in the surface of the ectod(>rm" from which the elements entering into the strnctun; of the sense organs are derived by pn.lifcralion. In Eprh-a, however, the pit^ are, as has been indicated,, more or less regularly arranged depressions of the ectoderm; the cells snrrounding each depression being grouped together in a manner which strongly suggests the way the optic cells are arranged in a simple ocellus.

Patten has ex])i-essed the belief that these ])its represent primitive sense organs, rather than being, like the neuroblasts of Wheeler, the points of origin for numerous sensory elements. Patten has shown that these primitive sense organs form at a later period, by proliferation and transformation, special groups of ganglion cells. Moreover, since, as the same autlior has clearly shown, the minute structure of these pits is tlie same as that of true ])erii)beral sense organs which occnr at the base of the legs in scor])ions, one can scarcely avoid adopting his point of view.

434 Avery E. Lambert.

The sensory pits arise first in tlie ganglionic areas of the cephalic plate. Later, hoAvever, they appear in the thickened median portions, or neuromeres, of the thoracic and abdominal segments, as well as in other parts of the embryo which are destined to enter into the formation of the sense organs.

The appearance of these primitive sensory pits in the cephalic plate, in the rudiment of the nerve cord, and in other sensory structures of Epeira, strongly favors the view that the central nervous system arises, phylogenetically, not by the multiplication of simple neural elements, but by the transfonnation and aggregation of prhniiive sense organs into the parts from which the nervous system is derived.

Stage IV. Fig. 23.- — The first change to be noted in this stage is the increase in the size of the appendages which have become longer and thicker in a marked degree, the pedipalps having developed a distinct coxal portion. Slight transverse constrictions appear in the pedipalps and in the thoracic appendages, which are indicative of future segmentation.

In the body of the embryo the wide separation of the lateral plates has caused the thoracic appendages to be further removed from the median line than is the case with the ap])endages of the head. Small knob-like projections appear on the second, third, fourth, and fifth abdominal segments. These are rudimentaiy abdominal appendages. There has been some discussion concerning the appearance of a first, limbless abdominal segment in the Araneina. Schimkewitsch (38) and Bruce (5) report a segment which fails to bear any trace of an appendage, appearing between the last thoracic segment and the first limb-bearing segment of the abdomen. Kishinouye (19) also found that appendages were wanting on the first abdominal segment of the spiders which he studied.

On the other hand, Balfour (1) and Locy (23) show in their drawings appendages on the first segment of the abdomen. Korschelt and Heider in the '^Lehrbuch der vergleichenden Entwicklungsgeschichte" figure an Arancid embryo which has a pair of appendages on the first abdominal segment, as well as on the others, making five pairs of abdominal appendages in all. The accuracy of this

Proceplialic Lobes of Epeira Cinerea. 435

figure appears to me doubtful, since no other investigators have reported more than four pairs in all. In Epeira the first abdominal segment is verj distinct, but never at any time does the trace of an appendage appear upon it.

It is possible that in some species of the Araneina the first abdominal segment is not very clearly defined, and consequently has been overlooked by those who have failed to report it as a limbless segment. On the other hand it may have been obliterated by the strong tendency manifested by the most anterior of the abdominal segments to shift forward into the cephalo-thoracic region.

The yolk, in this stage, bulges out between the lateral plates, and is covered by a thin layer of ectoderm. The lateral plates are distinctly segmented, the segments extending to the dorsal margins of the plates. The neuromeres which form the foundation of the nerve cord are well foraied on the median margins of the plates.

Several important changes have taken place in the cephalic plate. The first of these is tlie formation of the semi-circular, or anterior, groove {ant. gr.). This groove appears as a crescentic invagination near the anterior margin of the head, and extends around the sides to a point a little in front of the lateral gTOOves. Longitudinal sections show that the groove is formed by the infolding of the ectoderm in this region, shallow at first, but becoming gradually deeper and deeper as the development of the embryo progresses. The lateral grooves, at the same time, have deepened considerably and form conspicuous pits on the lateral margins of the head (lat. gr.).

Each lobe of the pre-cheliceral portion of the cephalic plate consists of three segments, the first lying in the region of the anterior groove, not far from the margin of the head, the third being in close proximity to the cheliceral segment (cgP and cJil. seg.). In some instances, in embryos of this stage, the cheliceral and third cephalic segments lie directly against one another.

The thickened portions of each of these segments lying toward the median line (c. gl.) forms a neuromere-like structure which, as has already been pointed out, forms the foundation of a cerebral ganglion. The series of cerebral" ganglia, in each lobe of the cephalic plate, is continuous with the chain of neuromeres of the thoracic and abdom

436 Avery E. L;uiil)ert.

inal segments, from which the nen^e cord is derived. Thus the cerebral ganglia are seen to maintain the same relation to the precheliceral segments that the neuromeres which form the rudiment of the nerve cord hold to the thoracic and abdominal segments, and may be regarded as being serially homologous with them.

The first, second, and third optic ganglia now appear as thickened areas which lie between the cerebral ganglia and the outer margins of the lobes. The optic plate ( o. pi-), or thickened margin of the optic gauglia, consists of a continuous band of thickened ectoderm bordering the lateral edges of the cephalic plate.

Stage V. Fig. 34- — The dorsal flexure reaches its extreme limit during the preceding stage. After this period a remarkable change occurs, and, instead of the cephalic and caudal ends of the embryo approaching one another on the dorsal side, the embryo is gradually bent in the other direction so that the two ends approach each other on the ventral surface.

According to Balfour and Locy, with whom Kishinouye is in substantial agreement, this change of flexure from the dorsal to the ventral direction is due to the increasing growth of the dorsal surface and the shortening of the germ bands. Both of the authors referred to fail to mention what is, in, their opinion, the cause of this shortening of the lateral plates of the embryo.

Morin maintains that the change is due to the shifting of the yolk from the ventral to a more dorsal position. But it is to be observed in Epeira that the yolk never bulges ventrally in a more prominent manner than during the first stages of the reversion period, a condition which the greater extension of the lateral plates over the dorsal surface of the egg is well calculated to produce.

It seems probable that Balfour and Locy have given a correct answer to this problem in so far as Ave are to look for the cause of this change, not in the shifting of the yolk, but in the growth of the embryo itself. Since the position of the yolk is purely relative, any change in the growth of the lateral plates would result in a change in its position. The growth of the lateral plates continues dorsalwards until they meet in the mid-dorsnl line Avhere they enclose a portion of the original coelom which becomes the cavity of the heart.

Procephalic Lobes of Epeira Cinci'ea. 437

After the uniou of the two halves of the dorsum their continued growth produces a pressure upon the most posterior of the abdominal neuromeres which causes them to shift anteriorly ; a process which results in the shortening of the entire ventral surface of the embryo, the shifting neuromeres becoming associated with segments anterior to those with which they originated.

The results of the forward shifting of the neural elements are also evident in the cephalic plate. The cheliceral segment is among the first to respond to this crowding of the neuromeres in a forward direction, so that it becomes closely pressed against the segment in front, thus entirely obliterating the furrow which separated these two segments in the preceding stages.

The anterior groove is not greatly influenced by this pressure from the posterior direction in this stage, the lips of the invagination being quite widely separated. The optic and cerebral ganglia are quite distinct, and are easily distingiiished in surface views. The examination of these elevations of the ectoderm in the cephalic region is facilitated by rolling the egg from side to side, a process which brings the contours into more perfect relief.

The rostrum (ros.) which had shifted, in the preceding stage, from its first position near the anterior margin of the head, has moved still farther in the posterior direction.

One of the most marked advances which the embryo has made in this stage, is the beginning of the structure which Patten describes for the scorpion, and to which he has given the name '^cephalic fold" or "hood." As the growth of the cephalic lobes progresses, their margins, Avhich consist of the thickened limb of ectoderm, the optic plate, is raised slightly and turned in the medio-postcrior direction. The fold (o. f.) thus formed continues to advance in this direction as the development of the embryo continues, bearing the inverted optic plate on its margin. In this stage the fold progresses until it has come to lie above the opening of the anterior groove, and the more anterior portions of the cephalic lobes.

Stage VI. Fig. 26. — The parts of the cephalic lobes which, in the preceding stages, have been quite distinct, are now beginning to lose their identity by uniting with one another. The cerebral ganglia are

438 Avery E. Lambert.

fused into a large lobe, which has become considerably thickened by the continued increase in the number of its cells. The optic ganglia have united to form a considerabh^ broader plate, which occupies the greater part of the superficial area of the cephalic lobes.

The sensory pits in the optic lobes have become more obscure, while those of the cerebral ganglia are separated from one another, in a measure, by the breaking up of the ganglia into blocks, each block containing a sensory pit. This separation is brought about in such a way that the cerebral ganglia seem, in surface views, to have been fractured. The significance of this condition is not clear.

The rostrum has, in this stage, lost all evidence of its double origin; and is a broad, plate-like structure which entirely covers the stomodcRum, The different elements of the cephalic plate have shifted their positions in such a manner that the rostrum lies almost between the two halves of the chelieeral segment.

The anterior grooves (ant. gr.) have come together in the median line, forming a continuous, semi-circular depression which extends around the anterior margin of the cephalic plate. This groove has deepened considerably, and will be refeiTed to as the anterior optic invagination on account of the intimate connection w^hich exists between it and the innervation of tlie median eyes. The lateral grooves (lat. gr.) will be referred to as the lateral optic invaginations, holding the same relation to the lateral eyes that the anterior optic invagination holds to the median eyes. The anterior and lateral optic invaginations form important parts of the optic ganglia.

There is a shallow depression which appears between the lateral and anterior invaginations, on each side of the head (m. o. p.). That this pit may be regarded as the vestige of a more elaborate structure than it now is, probably a third invagination associated with the formation of the optic lobes, appears evident from the fact that it occurs constantly in the cephalic plate of embryos of this stage.

The shifting of the neuromeres of the nerve cord, and the related shortening of the ventral surface of the embryo, brings a certain amount of pressure to bear on the cerebral lobes which causes them to be pressed over the anterior optic invagination, thus forcing the lips of that infolding together. The edge of the cephalic fold (o. /.)

Procephalic Lobes of Epeira Cinerea, 439

also advances in the medio-posterior direction, its increased growth making its character somewhat more apparent.

The pedilaps and chelicerse have continued to enlarge ; a mandibular segment being formed by the growth of the l)asal joint of the pedipalps in the median direction. This segment is separated from the main portion of the pedipalp by a deep constriction at the point where the appendage and the coxa are united (md. pdp.).

It is to be observed, in all stages, that the development of the cephalic plate does not, in every case, keep pace with the progress made by the remaining parts of the embryo, tliis body frequently showing a state of development which is in advance of what may be regarded as the normal condition of the cephalic plate. Occasionally embryos are found in which the two halves of the brain do not keep pace with one another. Continued growth, in most cases, equalizes these irregularities ; although, in rare cases, the divergence becomes so great that an abnormal structure of the embryo is the result.

The most frequent of these al)normalities to be met with is the double ombr)^o, in which the anterior portion of the germ band grows in two directions, two cephalic plates being formed. A single caudal plate serves for the two embryonic bands which unite in the thoracic region.

Stage VII. Fig. 27. — From this point on the coalescence of the ganglionic elements of the cerebral lobes proceeds with great rapidity and regularity. The lips of the anterior optic invagination have closed so that the groove can l)e made- out with difficulty in surface views. The closure is apparently due, as are nearly all the important changes which are taking place in the form of the cephalic plate, to the forward migration, and to the general concrescence, of the neuromeres. This closure is more apparent in the lateral parts of the invagination, being less complete in the median portion of the lobes.

The anterior optic invagination has increased in depth to the extent that it now forms a lar^x^ vesicle which has come to lie underneath the anterior margin of the cerebral lobes. The anterior, or dorsal, lip of this vesicle is directly connected with the optic plate

440 Avery E. Ijiiiiibert.

by means of a sheet of ectoderm which forms the inner layer of the cephalic fold. (Text-figure 3, ret.) The posterior lip of the vesicle is directly continuous with the cephalic lobes.

The openings of the lateral invaginations are no longer to be seen in surface views. Sections show that vesicles have been formed by these invaginations which lie beneath the lateral margins of the optic lobes, each vesicle possessing a lumen of considerable size.

The cerebral lobes have continued to increase in thickness, partly by a continued increase in the number of their cells, and partly by the crowding of the neural elements of the lobes into a more compact mass.

The shifting of the neuromeres has placed the two halves of the cheliceral segment laterally to the stomodteum which is now a deep invagination of the ectodenn covered by a fiat, triangular rostrum. The lateral eyes first appear as thickenings of the ectoderm (I. c.) at a point on the margin of the cephalic plate somewhat posterior to the position of the lateral vesicles.

Immediately below the rostrum a small depression is to be seen in the ectoderm which bridges the longitudinal furrow (c. p.). Patten found a chain of such pits between the segmental neuromeres of the scorpion, and related them to the "'mittelstrang" of Hatscheck. According to Patten, this chain of pits gives rise to the bothroidal cord. In Epeira, however, I have been unable to discover more than the single pit.

A transverse section made through the region of the stomodaeum shows that structure to be flanked on either side by a lateral ganglion of considerable size. These ganglia arose in connection with the cheliceral segment, and they are now connected by a strand of nerve tissue which passes from one to the other beneath the stomodaeum (s. s. c). These ganglia, at a later period, become fused with the main portion of the brain, the connecting strands of nerve tissue forming the sul)-stomoda'al connectives which are present in the adult brain of the spider (St. Remy, 39).

Stage VIII. Fig. 28. — This stage shows many features of advance in the morphology of the cephalic plate. The cephalic fold has grown until it covers a little more than the anterior third of the brain (o. /.).

Procephalic Lobes of Epeira Cinerea. 441

111 following the development of this fold we find that it arises, as has been previously pointed out, as a thickening of the edge of the plate which becomes turned upward and backward over the lobes. Its continued growth causes it to advance toward the median line, and in a posterior direction over the lobes, the thickened portion remaining on the edge of the fold. The fold may consequently be described as an ectodermal mantle consisting of two parts, an inner and an outer. The outer portion of the mantle consists of a single sheet of cells which extends dorsalwards and becomes continuous with the ectoderm of the dorsum. The inner part is several layers of cells thick and lies close to the cerebral lobes, being continuous with the dorsal lip of the anterior optic invagination. On account of the infolding of the ectoderm to form the inner layer of this structure, the thickened optic plates come to lie in an inverted position near the edges of the fold, and form the retinas of the anterior median eyes.

The pressure of the neuromeres which have crowded into the region of the head and thorax has brought about a stiU greater concentration of the neural elements. In the head the various ganglia are compacted into a single mass of nerve tissue in which the individual l)arts can be distinguished with difficulty. The anterior optic invagination has also increased in size, its walls having become so much thicker that its lumen is completely obliterated and the entire structure has come to lie, to a greater extent, underneath the cerebral lobes.

Another marked feature of this stage is the lessening of the superficial area of the hea<l. During the first stages in the growth of the embryo, the cephalon lies as a broad plate on the surface of the yolk. As its development progresses, and the fusion of originally distinct parts occurs, accompanied by the sinking of certain of the superficial portions below the surface, a reduction of the superficial area of the head ensues. This process is particularly evident in the narrowing of the anterior portion of the head.

Stage IX. Fig. 30. — In surface views of this stage the optic fold is seen to cover the anterior half of the o])tic lobes. Its posterior margin forms an inverted \ , the arms of which diverge considerably. The more anterior portions of the fold have met in the median line.

442 Avery E. Lambert.

The fold, together with the optic and cerebral lobes, form a true cerebral vesicle; the roof of the vesicle consisting of the fold, itself, the floor being made up of the ganglionic portions of the cephalic plate. The lumen of this vesicle extends dorsalwards, its opening being in the ventral direction.

A considerable change has also taken place in the position of the ganglia of the head. As has already been indicated, the concentration of the neural elements, owing to the massing of the neuromeres in the head region, has resulted in pushing some of the ganglia below the surface. As a result of this two parts of the brain may now be distinguished according to the level in which they lie ; first, a superficial part which forms the optic portion of the brain, and, second, the large optic vesicle which lies beneath the anterior margin of the cerebral lobes (the oj-gan stratifie of St. Remy), together with the lateral optic vesicles, and a median portion, the cerebral ganglia which have, by this time, come to be overlaid by the optic ganglia.

The cephalon is divided into two distinct parts by the deepening of a constriction which appears at a somewhat earlier period (cf. Fig. 29) and separates the region in which the anterior optic vesicle lies from the more posterior portions of the cephalic plate (m. /.).

The chelicerse have been pushed dorsalwards until they lie above the rostrum, which they partially conceal. The segment bearing the pedipalps now lies immediately beneath the stomodseum.

The neviromeres of the thoracic segments appear as oblong masses of nerve tissue, each segment being separated from the one anterior to it by a small, but distinct, furrow. In this the Araneina repeats the condition which Patten (35) found in the scorpion, except that the neuromeres, themselves, fail to show any indication of a division into two parts.

At this stage in the development of the embryo the mittelstrang appears as a shallow, longitudinal furrow between the two halves of the nerve cord (ec. f.). This furrow is not extensive. Its point of origin, in the region of the stomod^um, is hidden by the lower margin of the rostrum. It ends in the structure which was noted in the previous stage as the "ectodermal pit" (Figs. 28, 29, and 30, e. p.), which is now^ located between the neuromeres of the first thoracic segment.

Procephalic Lobes of Epeira Cinerea. 443

Stage X. Fig. 31. — Progress toward tlie adult condition is well marked in the embryos which have been selected to represent this stage. The brain is seen to consist of two distinct parts, the procephalon, or supra-oesophageal (Fig. 34, hv.) mass, and the postcephalon, or snb-cesophageal mass (Fig. 34, s. o, g. 1-12). The lobes of the pro-cephalon do not become so perfectly fused that they lose their identity until a little later. The ganglia of the post-cephalon, although pressed closely together, are never fused.

Practically the entire area of the cephalic plate is covered by the optic fold, which now extends to, and partially covers, the base of the chelicerse. The parts of the fold which bear the rudiments of the anterior median eyes have come together in the median line. The ectodermal thickenings wdiich form the rudiments of the lateral eyes (Z. e.) are located on the lateral margins of the head, not far from the bases of the chelicerse.

The ganglia of the thoracic segments have crowded forward until they are packed closely together just beneath the stomodaeum ; the remainder of the thorax beneath the cesophagiis being filled with ganglia consisting of the neuromeres of those abdominal segments which have shifted forward into this position.

The formation of the mittelstrang is completed by having the lips of the ectodermal furrow unite to form a tube which lie? just beneath the ectoderm between the neuromeres of the first abdominal segment. This tube ends, posteriorly, in the region in which the ectodermal pit was located. In the method of their formation the furrow and the pit resemble very closely the infoldings which develop, in part, into the "limatochord," and, in part, into the intra-ganglionic commissures which Patten (35) mentions in connection with his description of Buthus.

In front of the antero-lateral margins of the head the ectoderm is raised into a slight fold (a. /.). This fold is probably to be compared with the so-called amniotic fold of insects.

Large cells with peripherally located nuclei, which are present near the margins of the embryonic plate in nearly all of the preceding stages, appear, in this stage, to he gradually sinking into the yolk. The precise nature of these cells is doubtful. They have been regarded

444 Avery E. Lambert.

variously as representing the anlage of the endoderm, and as being the cells from which the blood corpuscles are derived. That they are not blood cells is clearly evident from the fact that after the formation of the heart by the union of the two walls of the dorsum, no cells of this sort are to be found in its lumen. At the same time they are abundant at the posterior end of the stomodseum, and in the region of the proctodeum and stercoral pocket, as well as being noticeably abundant in the region where the genital organs of the spider are formed.

Stage XI. Fig. 32. — This is the earliest period in the development of the spider in which, the various parts of the brain have assumed approximately the position they will occupy throughout the life of the adult. In external form the young spider closely resembles the adult, although no pigment has appeared in either the eyes or the skin.

The internal organization of the embryo is, however, very incomplete. The lung-books have arisen ; the spinning glands have formed and are nearly functional. But the mid-gut is lacking (Fig. 34, oes. ) , the abdomen being filled with a mass of modified yolk which is traversed by rudimentary vessels, and by septa?, springing from the walls of the heart.

The anterior median eyes have advanced considerably in their development. The corneal layer of the eyes is directly continuous with the ectoderm which covers the outer portion of the head ; the infolded portion of the eyes bears the retina and, turning again, posteriorly, forms a third, or post-retinal layer. (Fig. 33, m. e.)

The posterior median eyes and the lateral eyes are also considerably advanced. Following Bertkau (4) these may be called accessory eyes (nebenaugen) , the anterior median eyes being called by this author the principal eyes (Jimiptaugen).

The accessory eyes do not arise in relation to any special infolding after the manner of the principal eyes. They first appear as thickuings of the ectoderm in the region of the optic plate, and are situated a little in advance of the bases of the chelicerse. As the optic fold advances the accessory eyes become located on its outer portion, the thickened area, in the case of each eye, forming the bottom of a

Procephalic Lobes of Epciru Ciiicrea. 445

cup-shaped depression, and becomes the retina of the eye (p. m. e. and I. e.).

The larger and more superficial regions of the procephalon consist of the optic ganglia which overlie the anterior and lateral optic vesicles, as well as the ganglia of the cerebral lobes.


The procephalic portion of the brain of Epcira is a structure of considerable complexity, consisting of two lateral, pear-shaped lobes which are separated by a deep longitudinal furrow. (Text-fig. 2; 0. I.). As we have seen, however, in following the development of the brain, each of these lobes consists of optic ganglia and optic vesicles, which constitute the greater part of their superficial area (Fig. 27; opt. g.). The lobes formed by the cerebral ganglia lie underneath the optic ganglia (Fig. 27; c. r/L). The short, thick, column-like connectives on either side of the oesophagus, which unite the procephalic and postcephalic portions of the brain, represent the contribution of the cheliceral segment to the cerebrum of the spider.

Below the oesophagus is a mass of ganglia consisting of neuromeres, some of which belonged originally to the abdominal segments (Fig. 34; s. 0. g. 1-12). Their position in the head region is one of the results of the reversion of the embryo, which caused them to be pushed forward into that place. These ganglia are imperfectly fused, even in the adult, a fact which facilitates their determination. The first four of these sub-oesophageal ganglia arose in connection with the thoracic segments, the rest having been crowded forward into the thoracic region from the places where they originated in connection with the segments of the abdomen.

These observations bring the brain of Epeira into close accord with the researches of St. Remy and Patten. St. Remy speaks of the procephalic portion of the brain as consisting of a rostro-mandibular part (cheliceral ganglia), and a much larger optic ganglion which consists of the principal i)ortion of the supra-oesophageal mass. Tn the optic ganglion he found three distinct divisions, the first of these he calls the optic lobe. The second he calls the cerehral Johe. Behind these lies the unpaired organ slratife which, together with the optic ganglia, comprises what I have called the optic lobe.


Avery E. Lambert.

The conditions which obtain in the development and structure of the brain of the Epeiroid spiders fulfil the conditions of this descrip

Textabove. nerve, mental nerves (supraganglia

Figure 2. Brain of the Epeiroid spider, Argiope riparia, viewed from n. ol — n. o2, optic nerves supplying the median eyes. cl\. n., cheliceral md. n., mandibular nerve, n. pd., pedipalpal nerve, ml — mlO, segnerves supplying the muscles and the body wall. n. a pi — n. ap4, to the thoracic appendages, v. c, nerve cord. o. h, optic lobes oesophageal brain mass), ocs., oesophagus, .s-. o. //., sub-cesophageal

tion perfectly. The commissures which St. Remy found uniting the lateral portions of the procephalic lobes, are present in the earlier stages of the brain as the supra- and sub-oesophageal commissures.

Procephalic Lobes of Epeira Cinerea. 447

The procephalic lobes lie not only above, but a little in front of, the postcephalic ganglia (text-fig. 2). A large, almost tube-like, pair of nerves, which are more dorsally placed than the others, extends from the brain to the anterior median eyes. The nerves supplying the posterior median eyes arise from the surface of the brain near those which supply the anterior median eyes, and follow almost parallel M'ith them, though occupying a somewhat lower level. The nerves which supply the lateral eyes arise from a more lateral position on the side of the brain, in conjunction with the lateral optic vesicles.

The remaining nerves are all given off from lower levels. They consist of a fine strand of nerve fibers which arises in the median line, between the optic lobes, and passes to the rostrum ; and the cheliceral nen^es, which arise from the upper part of the connectives, or ganglia of the cheliceral segment.

The mandibular and pedipalpal nerves arise from different levels of the pedipalpal segment. The remaining portions of the postcephalic ganglia give off, on each side, the four large nerves which pass to the appendages. The nen^e cord consists of two large, tubular nerves which arise from the dorsal surface of this portion of the brain.

Between the appendicular nerves are four pairs of fine, threadlike, accessory, or segmental, nerves on each side of the brain. These nerves supply the thoracic muscles and the body wall. The nerves comprising the first segmental pair are fused, although they separate into two branches a short distance from their point of origin.

The paired condition of the segmental nerves does not appear in the scorpion according to McClendon (26), although Patten, who studied the same species, seems to have had no difiiculty in making them out.

VI. The Eyes of ErEiRA.

No problem in Arthropod enilu'vcjlogy has attracted more attention, or yielded more interesting results, than the study of the development and relationships of the eyes of Arachnids. The most important of these observations are to be found in papers by Bertkau (4), Schimkewitsch (28), Locy (23), Mark (25), and Patten (33, 35).

448 Avery E. Lambert.

Schimkewitsch's paper deals accurately with the general morphology of the eyes, but fails to relate them properly with the optic ganglia. His statement that the optic nerves are derived from the cephalic ganglia is somewhat ambiguous, although he probably refers to the procephalic lobes.

One of the most important works relating to the subject is the paper by Loey on the development of A galena luvvia. Although he failed to understand the significance of the fold which forms the roof of what he calls the "optic vesicle" (the cerebral vesicle), he was the first to correctly describe the morphology of the anterior median eyes.

His conclusions concerning the mode of origin of the posterior median, and lateral, eyes need revision, as has l)een pointed out by Kishinouye. Locy holds that the accessory eyes arise in association with ectodermal infoldiiigs in a way somewhat similar to that in which the principal eyes are formed. The ectodermal invaginations with which the lateral eyes are associated in their formation, however, enter into the fonnation of the optic lobes, and form the point of origin from which the optic nerA'es, supplying the lateral eyes, arise. They do not, themselves, give rise to the eyes.

He calls attention to a very important point, that is, the inversion of the retinal elements which is brought about by the infolding of the optic fold, thus explaining how it occurs that "the way in which the light traverses the median anterior eyes of spiders is similar to the method by which light reaches the percipient elements in the retina of the vertebrate eye."

Another important paper which deals with the subject is that by Kishinouye. He recognizes the fact that the elements which enter into the formation of the anterior median eyes are originally located on the posterior margins of the covering of the cerebral vesicle; but he fails to note that these optic elements are brought into this position from thp lateral margins of the cephalic plate. He finds, foUoAVing Locy, that the inversion of the retinal elements of the median eyes is due to the "processes by which the eyes are formed."

Kishinouye also states concerning the origin of the optic nerves, that they arise as elongations of the retinal cells, forming fillers which

Proceplialic Lobes of Epeira Cincrca. 449

become secondarily connected with the optic ganglia, this connection taking place after the eyes are fully formed.

His observations on the manner on which the accessory eyes are formed appear to be confirmed by my own observations of the way in which they arise in Epeira, and probably hold true for all spiders. He finds that these eyes do not arise by a process of infolding, but as simple depressions of the ectoderm, which is thickened in the optic area to form the retina. The walls of this depression grow inward so that they finally cover the retinal portion of the eye.

Patten was the first to point out that the eyes of Arachnids consist of three layers, an outer, or corneal layer, a middle, or retinal layer, and an inner, or post-retinal layer. He also called attention to the fact that, not only in the manner in which light traverses the retinal elements, but in their mode of origin as well, the anterior median eyes of Arachnids bear a close resemblance to the pineal eyes of vertebrates, with which they are compared (35).

One of the most important contributions which this author has made to our knowledge of the morphology of the Arachnid eye, is his discovery that the optic elements do not arise originally in the median position, but first appear on the margins of the cephalic plate. Their ultimate median position is brought about by the reflexing of the margins of the cephalic plate over the optic ganglia and the cerebral lobes.

Mark's paper (25) is an important contribution to the discussion of the way in which the mode of the formation of the Arachnid eye bears on the question of the morphology of the eyes of Arthropods in general, following for his account of the Arachnid eye the work of Locy on A galena.

The Anterior Median Eyes of Epeira. — The anterior median eyes originate as sensory thickenings of the antero-lateral margins of the cephalic plate. (Figs. 19-29; o. r//.). As the development of the cephalic lobes progresses, that portion of the margin upon which the optic plate is located is tnrned upward and backward in such a manner that a fold is formed which covers the anterior portions of the brain (Figs. 27-31; o. /".). The edge of tliis fold advances over the cephalic plate in the medio-posterior direction, the two halves of the fold meeting, as they progress downward, in the median line.

450 Avery E. Lambert,

By means of this process the optic thickening comes to be turned toward the ganglia of the brain ; the retinal elements being literally turned upside down, which accounts for their inverted position in the adult eye.

The result of this growth of the fold is the formation of a sac-like vesicle which is open in the posterior direction. The fold, itself, forms the roof of this vesicle, while the floor consists of the optic and cerebral ganglia of the brain (text-fig. o, B; v. c). The lumen of this sac is continuous with that of the anterior optic vesicle. (Teixtfig. 3, B; lu.).

As the growth of the cerebral lobes continues, they overlie more completely the vesicle formed by the anterior optic invagination, the lumen of which is finally closed by the thickening of its walls, and by the pressure which is brought to bear upon it from above. (Textfig. 3, C and D; a. o. v.).

The formation of the nerves supplying the anterior median eyes has been accounted for in two ways ; first, as outgrowths from the optic tracts of the brain, and, second, as elongations of the retinal cells which become secondarily attached to the optic lobes.

There is a third way which a careful examination of my material has led me to believe may account for the formation of the optic nerves. As the growth of the optic fold progresses, its inner layer, connecting the retinal thickening with the dorsal lip of the optic vesicle, comes to lie close upon the optic lobes, and finally unites with them (text-fig. 3, B ; o. n.). The lower portion of this layer becomes separated from the upper portion by a process of delamination, and is turned ventralwards l)y the continued growth of the optic lobes. The upper portion of this layer maintains its connection with the retinal cells in the optic plate, and with the dorsal Avail of the anterior optic invagination ; the cells of this portion of the middle layer of the fold elongating as the retina is carried farther away from the anterior invagination by the growth of the fold, forming the fibers of the optic nerve.

I cannot claim that I have established the fact that the nerves of the anterior median eyes arise in this fashion ; but careful and repeated examination of my material leads me to believe that these

."•"• '^'"' -j-cX.


■ u--.


cor ret

^ ^-'-'--^ .'prl :c.l. ^ ■'^ Text-figure 3. Developineut of tlie anterior median eye. (Diagrammatic.)

A. Condition of the eye at an early stage in the development of the embryo.

a. 0. v., anterior optic vesicle. The lumen of the vesicle, lu., is still conspicuous and opens to the exterior as the semi-circular (crescentic) groove. 0. pi., the optic plate, c. f., edge of the ceplialic fold. The ectoderm forming the "hood" connects the optic plate with the anterior lip of the optic invagination, c. I., cerebral lobes.

B. At a more advanced stage.

ret., the retina, formed by the involuted optic plate, cor., corneal layer, formed by the ectoderm lying above the retinal portion of the eye. o. n., the optic nerve (rudiment) formed by the line of ectodermal cells which connect the retina with the lip of the anterior optic vesicle, v. e., vesicle of the median eye. The term vesicle is, at this stage, purely nominal, since the limien of the sac formed by the involution of the optic elements is contiguous with the lumen of the anterior vesicle.

C The eye at a considerably advanced stage.

The post-retinal layer, j)r. L, is formed by certain of the cells which belong to the layer uniting the retina with the anterior optic vesicle becoming connected with the cerebral lobe. By the increased growth of the lobe these cells are tin-ned outward until they come to lie directly beneath the retina, thus forming a third optic layer. The sac formed by the involution of the optic elements is now separated from the lumen of the anterior optic vesicle, which becomes practically obliterated.

That portion of the ectodermal layer which remains attached to the anterior optic vesicle, connecting it with the retinal portion of the eye, o. n. in C and D, becomes the optic nerve.

D. A still later stage.

The three layers of the anterior median eye l)econie more closely approximated as its development continues.

The lettering for C and D is the same as in the preceding figures.

452 Avery E. Lambert.

nerves can be accoimted for in this way. If this should prove to be the case, it will appear that the nerves supplying these eyes are simply modifications of the ectodermal cells which originally serve to connect the retina with the vesicle of the anterior optic sac; and, what is more significant, the anterior median eyes maintain their connection with the optic tracts of the brain throughout the whole process of their formation.

The Posterior Median, and Lateral Eyes. — The accessory eyes appear somewhat later than the principal eyes as simple ectodermal thickenings in the optic area (Fig. 32 ; p. m. e. and I. e.). A depression appears in the region of each optic thickening from which these eyes are formed, the walls of which grow inward in such a manner that the thickened portion, or retina, is completely covered. The cells which have grown over the retina in this manner secrete the lens, and have been called, in consequence, the corneal layer.

The manner in which the nerves supplying the accessory eyes are formed is not clear. The possibility that the connection of these eyes with the optic lobes is obtained secondarily has to be admitted, although there appears to be little doubt in the minds of those who have investigated the subject that the connection of the lateral eyes with the lateral optic tracts bears some relation to the formation of the lateral optic vesicle.

VII. Comparison of the Akaneid Brain with that of Other


Any effort to homologize the brain of Epeira with that of other Arachnids, or with the brains of Arthropods in general, is attended with a great deal of difficulty on account of the divergent statements of the different investigators who have studied the subject.

That there is a similarity between the brain of the scorpion and that of the spider is evident from the descriptions both of St. Remy and of Patten. This similarity is to be found not only in the form of the adult brain, but also in its method of development. Patten found three pre-cheliceral segments in the cephalic plate of the spider, each segment consisting of a cerebral ganglion, an optic ganglion, and an optic plate. He also found the same condition to hold true oi the cephalic plate of the scorpion.

Procephalic Lobes of Epeira Ciiierea. 453

The optic tracts in the spiders and in the scorpions arise in connection with an anterior optic, and two Literal optic, invaginations. In both forms these invaginations give rise to homologous parts of the optic lobes. In both the spiders and the scorpions the character of the two sets of eyes is similar ; the median eyes being formed by a process of infolding which results in the inversion of the retinal elements, in both forms the median eyes being formed, tirst as simple ectodermal thickenings on the outer borders of the cephalic plate, which, later, become folded over the head to form a cephalic fold that bears the anterior median eyes on its posterior margin.

Other investigators, however, do not all coincide with Patten in his statement concerning the presence of three pre-cheliceral segments in the scorpion. Brauer and Lankester, whose papers appeared before Patten's, report, the former, two such segments, and the latter, one. McClendon, working under the direction of Wheeler, found two segments in the species upon which Patten worked. Police seems to have established the presence of two pre-cheliceral segments in Euscorpius italicus.

This divergence of opinion makes the question of comparison one of great difficulty. In Epeira the three pre-cheliceral segments are clearly distinguished, particularly in the earlier stages. From the closeness of the relationship of the two forms, one would expect to find the same number in the scorpion. Patten's figures of the cephalic plate of Buthus would seem to make it evident that this number exists in that form.

An attempt to homologize the brain of the spider with that of insects is attended with even greater difficulty. Patten records the presence of three pre-oral segments in Acilius; the first of these segments is less distinct in this form than in either the spider or the scorpion. Wheeler, in his paper on Doryphora (41), believed that he had found three pre-oral segments in that form ; but he was led to change his conclusion in a later paper on the morphology of the insect brain (42), in which he states that only two such segments exist.

Viallanes, on the other hand, finds evidence that three pre-oral segments are present in the brain of Mantis; and Ilolingren, in his

454 Avery E. Lambert.

paper on the morphology of the insect head, states that, in his opinion, most of the recent investigators incline to recognize that the pre-oral portion of the cephalic plate of insects is composed of three parts, or segments.

Assuming this to be the case, it appears that there are certain lines of comparison by which the Arachnid brain can be homologized with the brains of insects.

1. The rudiment of the brain is laid down on the yolk as a broad cephalic plate in both Arachnids and Insects.

2. This plate, in both groups, presents three transverse segments, anterior to the stomodseal depression, which form the foundation of both the cerebral and optic ganglia.

3. Each of the pre-oral segments, in Insects and Arachnids, presents a cerebral and an optic ganglion, and a marginal limb which bears the retinal elements — the optic plate.

4. The simple eyes of insects arise, as do the lateral eyes of spiders and scorpions, in association with invaginations which appear on the lateral and anterior margins of the cephalic plate. These invaginations form important parts of the optic lobes in both groups.

VIII. Geneeal Considerations.

It would appear from the foregoing discussion that the brain of the Arachnida presents a decided advance in complexity of structure, and in the method of its development, over that of the Insecta ; or, indeed, any other group of the Arthropoda.

The method by which the cerebral vesicle is formed, and the relation of the anterior median eyes to this structure, bears a striking resemblance to the formation of the cerebral vesicle, and the growth of the pineal eye, in vertebrates, as has been pointed out by Patten in his paper on the Origin of the Vertebrates.

It has been objected that the presence of two median eyes, which are separate structures in the Arachnid head, would necessitate a double origin for the pineal organ in vertebrates, no trace of which can be said to exist. This objection has lost some of its force since the publication, by Locy, of a paper in which he shows that, in the Elasmobranchs, the pineal eye is formed by the union of two inde

Procephalic Lobes of E})eira Cinerea. 455

peudeut optic rudiments which arise ou the margin of the cephalic fold.

This question will not be settled by the study of the Araneid brain alone but by a very careful comparison of typical Arachnids on the one hand, and of the Vertebrata on the other. The suggestions coneerning the origin of the Vertebrata, which arise from these considerations, demand that th