Book - Vertebrate Embryology (1913) 4: Difference between revisions

From Embryology
(Created page with "{{Jenkinson1913 header}} ==Chapter VI The Germinal Layers== By the germ-layers we understand certain groups of cells which contain in themselves the materials for certain de...")
 
m (Blanked the page)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Jenkinson1913 header}}
==Chapter VI The Germinal Layers==


By the germ-layers we understand certain groups of cells which
contain in themselves the materials for certain definite groups
of organs and tissues. These groups of cells are definitely
separated from one another at an early period of development,
and the process of their separation is spoken of as the formation
of the germinal layers.
The germinal layers in a Vertebrate are three in number, the
ectoderm, the endoderm, and the mesoderm. The ectoderm is
that group of cells which contains within itself the material for
the formation of the epidermis and epidermal derivatives like
hair, feather, skin-glands, the enamel of the teeth, the nervous
system both central and peripheral, and the sense organs, and
further the stomodaeum and proctodaeum, or entrances to the
mouth and anus ; the endoderm contains the material for the
lining epithelium of the alimentary canal and its outgrowths,
such as gill-slits, thyroid, thymus, lungs, liver, pancreas, bladder ;
while from the mesoderm-  with which we include the notochord
- skeleton and connective tissues, muscles, blood and vascular
system, coelom and urogenital organs will be derived.
The germ-layers are thus definable by thek fate in development. They may also be defined with reference to their position
in the embryonic body when they have been definitely segregated
from one another, for then the ectoderm is the outside layer,
the endoderm the inside layer, while the mesoderm with the
notochord is in between. Prior to that moment, however, it is
difficult if not impossible, to give generaUy valid definitions of
these sets of cells by their position, since the method of theur
origin from the different cells into which the substance of the
ovum is divided by cleavage varies in the several groups.
In a Vertebrate the germinal layers are segregated durmg
a process which is known as the formation and closure of the blastopore, or in an older terminology ' gastrulation the ' gastrula ' being the name bestowed on this stage in which a new
cavity, the ' archenteron ' or primitive gut, is formed and is in
communication with the exterior by an aperture, the blastopore.
This opening, and -ndth it the germinal layers, is from the first
bilaterally symmetrical. This is true of all Vertebrates, but in
the method of its origin the phylum must be divided into two
great groups, those in which the blastopore arises at the edge
of the blastoderm -  ^the Anamnia -  and those in which it appears
inside the blastoderm -  the Amniota. By the help of the Gymnophiona, however, the gap between the two may be bridged.
Anamnia
We shall begin with the Anamnia, in which the conditions are much simpler.
As a type we shall take the common English frog {Eana
iemporaria) .
The first sign of the formation of the germ-layers is given as
soon as segmentation is at an end by the appearance of the
structure known as the dorsal lip of the blastopore (Fig. 61).
This is a short, deeply-pigmented rim bounding a groove, placed
parallel to the equator, and a little below it (about 25°) at that
point in the boundary between the pigmented and unpigmented
regions of the egg where the latter area is most extensive. This
is the side on which the grey crescent was formed and the original
unpigmented area so increased. The plane which includes the
egg-axis and the dorsal lip will shortly become the median
longitudinal or sagittal plane of the embryo ; it coincides evidently with the plane of symmetry of the unsegmented ovum.
The egg is still in the position into which it turned at the time
of insemination with its axis vertical, and the heavy white pole
below. The changes that now take place as seen from this
vegetative pole are as follows. The rim of the groove begins
to travel downwards over the surface of the egg towards the
vegetative pole, the area over which it passes becoming covered
by cells which are as deeply pigmented as those of the animal
portion of the egg. At the same time the rim elongates, becoming
crescentic ; in other words, the processes of rim formation and overgrowth are extended to the right and left along the margin
of the pigmented area, and the lateral lips of the blastopore come into being. As the dorsal lip (the middle region of the rim)
continues on its course towards the vegetative pole, and as
continually fresh parts are drawn into the process at the sides,
the blastoporic lip becomes first semicircular, and then three parts of a circle, until finally, when that part which is diametrically opposite to the dorsal lip, namely the ventral lip, also
begins to grow down, it attains the form of a circle enclosing
the still uncovered portion of the vegetative hemisphere, the
yolk-plug. The dorsal lip has now moved down to or a little
beyond the vegetative pole.
Fig. 61. -  Diagrams of the closure of the blastopore in the egg of the
common frog {R. temporaria). In a-d the egg is viewed from the vegetative pole, in E, F from below. The dorsal lip is at the top of the figures.
In D the ventral lip has just been formed and the blastopore is circular.
In E the rotation of the whole egg has begun, and in f is complete.
At this moment the whole egg begins to rotate about a horizontal axis in the opposite direction to that in which the dorsal
lip moved ; and this rotation continues -  the circle of the blastopore becoming smaller all the time -  until the dorsal lip has
returned, rather beyond the point from which it started, to the
new equator, or horizontal plane through the centre of the egg.
The end now occupied by the blastopore is posterior. The angle
subtended by the arc traversed by the dorsal lip -  both before
and during the rotation -  is 75°, and the angle through which
the whole egg rotates is 100°. It follows that the vertical line
now drawn through the centre of the egg, which will be the
dorso-ventral line of the embryo, makes the same angle of 100°
with the original egg-axis ; that the animal pole is situated below
what will be the anterior end of the embryo (Fig. 62, f), since
the blastopore is posterior ; and that the antero -ventral haK of
the embryo is developed over the animal, the postero -dorsal half
over the vegetative hemisphere of the egg. The dorsal and ventral
lips are now actually dorsal and ventral.
It is clear that the lip of the blastopore which is thus formed
and closed arises along the whole of the boundary between small
pigmented and large yolk-cells, and that the process is bilateral,
taking place, as it does, first and most rapidly at the dorsal lip,
last and least rapidly at the ventral lip, and at an intermediate
rate at the lateral lips in between.
The examination of sections (Fig. 62) will now show us that
the closure involves (1) a movement of the yolk-cells into the
segmentation cavity together with (2) an overgrowth and ingrowi^h of cells at the blastoporic lip, resulting in the formation
of a new cavity, the ' archenteron ' ; and that during the process
the material for the germinal layers is brought into position and
laid down.
A sagittal section of the egg passing through the dorsal lip at its first appearance shows the groove placed about 25° below
the equator in the zone of intermediate cells. The radial disposition of the cells immediately about the groove marks the
beginning of a process of overgrowth and ingrowth which becomes
more obvious a little later, when it is seen that a fold of small
cells has grown over a certain area of yolk-cells. This fold consists naturally of two sheets, an outer and an inner. The cells
of the outer sheet resemble closely the small pigmented cells of
the animal hemisphere into which they are uninterruptedly continued ; like the latter, they are arranged in about four layers,
the outermost of which is epithelial. At the lip of the blastopore
the outer passes into the inner sheet, the cells in the outermost
layer of the former being gradually turned over into the innermost layer of the latter. This inner sheet also consists of several
layers of cells, the innermost of which is pigmented and epitheUal, the remainder being more irregularly disposed. The inner
sheet forms the outer, or, as it will be when the egg has rotated,
the upper wall of the slit-like cavity between itself and the yolksurface now covered up. This cavity is the archenteron and the
inner sheet of the fold is its roof ; the original vegetative surface
of the egg forms its floor.
This overgrowth and ingrowth of cells, with consequent formation of an archenteric cavity, takes place in an exactly similar
fashion at the lateral (Fig. 63, a) and ventral lips. By the time
the latter has appeared the archenteric cavity is much enlarged,
first by its being extended in an anterior direction into the yolkcells that have meanwhile been pushed up into the segmentation
cavity on the dorsal side, and secondly in a lateral and finaUy
a ventral direction by a movement of the mass of yolk-cells
towards these regions of the egg also. The segmentation cavity
is thus first reduced to a small space upon the ventral side and
then obliterated altogether. In a small percentage of cases
however, the segmentation cavity communicates with the front
end of the archenteron, is surrounded by yolk-cells, and mcorTiorated in the front end of the gut.
' t the shifting of the heavy yolk-cells to the ventral s.d
tZ alters the eentre of gravity and so ca,.es the rotafou of
the egg until equilibrium is regained.
arch
mes
mes. Y.
Fig, After rotation ^'*''^°P°'^'^- before rotation ; e, During rotation ;
archenteron; y p! yolk fri^f/-'^ segmentation cavity; arcL,
formed below th;;^! ^ ^'^"'^ = mesoderm
pushed into the segment; Sty."""^"'" ''""^'^ '^'^"^ "^'^ ^-^k-cella
With the exception of the yolk-plug the outer surface of the
egg is now covered by a sheet of small cells, disposed in about
four layers, the outermost of which is epithelial and pigmented.
This sheet is the ectoderm. In part it comes from the original
animal cells which formed the roof of the segmentation cavi. r â–  but
part of it is derived from the outer sheet of the blastoporic fold.
Fig 63 - Transverse sections of the frog's egg. A, During the closure
of The blastopJie • B, After, mes. 2, mesoderm differentiated from the
yoM Tus^^^^^^^ segmentation cavity (in B these are seen to be
Central); U., lateral lip of the blastopore; n.c/^., notoehord.
The notochord and the dorsal mesoderm are differentiated out
of the roof of the archenteron (Figs. 63 B, 64). The latter sheet
of cells becomes split into (1) a thin layer next the cavity (this
will be the roof of the ahmentary canal) and (2) a layer next
the outside. This outer layer is divided into (a) a median strip
or rod, which is the notochord, and (6) two lateral shee s, the
dorsal mesoderm. The notochord is not separated miti after
the sheets of mesoderm have been detached. The separation o
both notochord and mesoderm begins at the anterior end and
proceeds backwards. At the lip of the blastopore there is thus
for a time an undiiferentiated mass of tissue in which ectoderm
notochord, mesoderm, and roof of the alimentary ^canal are all
continuous (Fig. 62, e). It will be remembered that the front
end of the archenteron arises by an extension of that cavity
into the yolk-cells ; here, therefore, yolk-cells form the roof, and
it is from them that the anterior portions of notochord and dorsal mesoderm are formed. The posterior portions, however,
arise in that part of the archenteric roof which comes into position
as the inner sheet of the blastoporic fold.
The ventral mesoderm (Fig. 63, b) has a similar double origin.
In front the floor of the archenteron is formed of the yolk-cells
pushed into the segmentation cavity ; the cells next the ecto
Fig. 64.-  Three stages in the differentiation of the roof of the archenteron
in the irog. arch, archenteron; n.ch., notochord ; mes., dorsal mesoderm.
derm subdivide and become mesoderm. Behind mesoderm arises
from the inner sheet of the fold at the ventral lip. At the sides
of the embryo dorsal and ventral mesoderm pass continually
into one another. The middle layer, therefore, taken as a whole,
arises anteriorly and ventrally from the yolk-cells, posteriorly
and dorsally from the blastoporic overgrowth ; the former is in the
onginal animal, the latter in the original vegetative hemisphere.
Smce mesoderm is formed also at the lateral lips, the two
sheets of this tissue which flank the notochord aje necessarily continuous, around the blastopore (Fig. 64*), with the mesoderm
at the ventral lip (Fig. 62, e) ; only at the dorsal lip, where the
notochord is formed, is there an interruption in the middle layer.
The endoderm or lining of the gut cavity is what is left of the
roof and floor of the archenteron, the roof of the gut being
the thin layer left when the notochord and mesoderm have been
detached, the floor the bulky mass of yolk-cells after the separation of the ventral mesoderm.
It must be remembered that though the differentiation of
these germ-layers is only completed when the blastopore has
closed, it has in reality been in progress during the earlier stages.
Fro 64* - Horizontal section of an older stage showing the sheets of
mesoderm passing back into the lateral Ups of the blastopore (b.j).).
It still remains for us to discuss very briefly the origm of
the cells from which the blastoporic fold is derived, that is, the
origin of parts of each of the three germ-layers. The inner layer
of the fold is certainly derived neither wholly from the smaU
cells of the animal hemisphere, nor whoUy from the large cells
of the vegetative hemisphere, but from the region about the
egg-equator, in which the cells are of a character intermediate
between these two (Fig. 62, i, z.). The outer layer of the fold
comes from the same source, and from an extension of the roof
of the segmentation cavity. These intermediate cells divide
rapidly and give rise to the fold, which, as we have seen, contains ectodermal, endodermal, and mesodermal elements.
To sum up, the ectoderm of the frog comes partly from the
cells of the animal hemisphere, partly from the intermediate
cells ; the endoderm in part from the latter, in part from the
yolk-cells, while the mesoderm and notochord have a similar
double origin ; and the materials for these layers are brought
into their definitive positions during the bilateral closure of the
blastopore, which arises all along the line separating animal from
vegetative cells.
We shall see that a similar statement may be made for the
remaining Anamnia.
Fig. 65. -  ^Formation of the germ-layers in Petrornyzon. (After Scott.)
A, Sagittal section ; b, c. Transverse sections of two stages ; arch., archenteron ; d.l., dorsal lip of the blastopore ; n.ch., notochord ; d.m., dorsal
mesoderm ; v.m., ventral mesoderm ; m.t., medxillary tube (here a solid
wedge of cells).
==Cyclostomata==
In Petrornyzon (Fig. 65) the formation and closure of the
blastopore, the origin and extension of the archenteron, resemble
the same processes in the frog, with the exception that a ventral
lip is never developed. The ventral mesoderm is diflferentiated
from the yolk-cells pushed into the segmentation cavity, as in
the frog, and these latter cells form the floor of the gut. They
give rise, however, to much more than that, since the roof of
the archenteron is converted wholly into the notochord and the
gut is then completed by the upgrowt.h of yolk-cells from the
sides and underneath the notochord. The dorsal mesoderm arisea
m connexion with the overgrowth at the lip of the blastopore
In the Myxinoids (Fig. 66) segmentation produces a blastoderm at one end of the elHpsoid egg. At one point in the edge
of this blastoderm a dorsal blastoporic lip appears, and the
material for the germ-layers of the embryo is laid down during
the bilateral overgrowth and ingrowth of cells in this region.
The yolk is not wholly covered by this process, but as soon as
Fig, 66-  Bdellostoma. Overgrowth of the posterior edge or dorsal lip
of the blastoderm over the yolk, d.l, dorsal lip (posterior edge) ; v.l,
ventral lip (anterior edge) ; op.r., operculum of the shell. (After Bashford
Dean.)
the body of the embryo is formed all parts of the edge of the
blastoderm grow down and the blastopore eventually closes at
the vegetative pole.
Elasm obe anohh
Germ-layer formation begins with the appearance at one point
in the edge of the blastoderm of a fold or overturning of cells
of the superficial layer. This point is, as will appear, in the
middle line and at the posterior end. The fold, the rim of which
is the dorsal lip of the blastopore, is slightly raised and covers
over a space-  the beginning of the archenteron-  between itself
and the yolk (Figs. 67, 68). By the continued backward growth
of the fold and by the ingrowth of its under layer the archenteron
attains a considerable length. The floor of the archenteron is formed of yolk, into which yolk-nuclei subsequently make their
way ; its roof consists of a columnar epithelium derived in
part from the overturning of cells at the lip of the blastopore,
in part possibly from the posterior marginal cells of the lower
layer.
Fig. 67. -  Overgrowth of the lip of the blastopore and formation of the
embryo in Elasmobranchs. (a-c after Riickert, d-f after Ziegler.) c.s.,
caudal swelling ; l.L, lateral lip. In r the formation of a lip has extended
almost to the anterior edge. In d, e, the medullary folds are still open, in
r they are closed.
But while this process is taking place at the dorsal lip, that is,
at the median posterior margin of the blastoderm's edge, it is
also being extended, though in a far less degree, to the neighbouring regions, the lateral lips, on the right and on the left.
The archenteron thus comes to assume a crescentic shape, with
a median anterior prolongation ; the latter underlies the embryonic portion of the blastoderm, while the crescentic part is
wholly extra-embryonic, and remains very shallow, though it is
subsequently prolonged to the right and left round the edges of
the blastoderm until a slight overgrowth is formed even at the
anterior margin.
With the overgrowth at the lips of the blastopore the material
for the germinal layers is laid down (Fig. 69). The superficial
layer is now the ectoderm. The mesoderm consists of two
parts : (1) two sheets of cells lying one on each side of the
middle line over the embryonic portion of the archenteron ;
posteriorly these sheets pass into the caudal swellings-  two
thickenings at the edge of the blastoderm, one on each side of
the middle line -  where they are continuous with the roof of the
archenteron, out of which they have been differentiated ; (2) the
formation of mesoderm is, however, not limited to the parts
immediately adjacent to the dorsal lip, but is carried on at the
lateral lips, and, as these extend forwards round the whole edge
of the blastoderm, at the anterior edge as well. This extraembryonic mesoderm is naturally continuous in the caudal
swellings with the embryonic mesoderm first described ; it takes
part only in the formation of the area vasculosa.
The notochord is formed from a median strip of cells which
is cut out of the roof of the archenteron ; the process, like the
differentiation of the mesoderm, takes place from before backwards. With the separation of the notochord and mesoderm
the remainder of the archenteric roof is endoderm, and gives rise
to the alimentary canal, the front end and sides bending dovm
VJ
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
123
Fig. 69.-  Five successive transverse sections through the hinder
(embryonic) portion of the blastoderm of the dog-fish during tlie formation
ot the germinal layers a is posterior, cutting the two caudal sweUings ;
E, Anterior through the head of the embryo, arch., archenteron; mes
mesoderm; e.m., embryonic mesoderm; ex.m., extra-embryonic mesoderm ; w.c^., notochord ; lateral lip of the blastopore
124
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
VI
and meeting to form the ventral wall. The yolk in the floor of
the archenteron plays no part in this process (Fig. 70).
Up to the present it is the posterior edge or dorsal lip which
has been principally active, but now the anterior and lateral
margins of the blastoderm become exceedingly vigorous and
begin to grow over the yolk, the overgrowth being accompanied,
as stated above, by a slight marginal invagination ; and eventu
y.n.
Fig. 70.-  Two stages in the formation of the gut of the dog-fish by the
bending down and fusion of the edges of the roof of the archenteron.
y.n., yolk-nuclei.
ally the anterior edge makes the whole ckcuit of the yolk, passmg
round the vegetative pole and reappearmg behind the embryo
as the ventral lip of the small ' yolk-blastopore ' (Fig. 71). At
the dorsal hp backgrowth of the caudal sweUings is responsible
for the posterior elongation of the body of the embryo alone,
the body being raised above the surface of the yolk. Where the
body passes into the hinder edge of the blastoderm growth of
the latter ceases, but the lateral edges immediately adjacent
to this point swing backwards untU they bound a narrow
median strip of yolk by which alone the aperture at the dorsal
lip now communicates with the rest of the blastopore.
as
B
a.e = i/.l.
C. D.
f M^*^" Extension of the blastoderm over the yolk after formation and
loldmg ofiE of the embryo in an Elasmobranch. a, The lateral lips liave
swung back parallel to one another behind the dorsal lip, so enclosino- a
narrow strip of yolk. B, Side view of the same, c, The anterior ed-o
(«.e.) has passed beyond the vegetative pole, and in d it appears behind the
embryo as the ventral lip (yi.) ; y.b., yolk- blastopore.
P. 124
VI
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
125
Teleostei
The processes are essentially the same as in the Elasmobranchs.
Blastopore formation begins at the posterior edge, where the
Fig. 72.-  Growth of the blastoderm over the yolk after the formation of
the material for the embryo in the Teleostean fish Serramis. (After Wilson )
d.L, dorsal hp of the blastopore (posterior edge of the blastoderm) â–  a e
anterior edge of the blastoderm or ventral lip {v.l.) of the blastopore •
s.c, segmentation cavity ; o.g., oil-globulc. '
backward growth of the dorsal lip with concomitant development of an archenteric cavity gives rise to the body of the
embryo, but the process is extended to the lateral and anterior
edges, where there is a slight invagination. By the growth of
Fig. 73.-  Sagittal sections through the blastoderm of Serranm during
the formation of the germinal layers. (After Wilson.)
A, Beginning of overgrowth at dorsal lip {d.l.).
B, Overgrowth at anterior edge.
c, Later stage of posterior edge. t u i
D, The anterior edge has become theventraUip {v.l.); n.cA., notochord ;
end., endodorm ; m.p., medullary plate ; par., parablast (periblast) ; y.f.,
yolk-plug ; K.v., Kuppfer's vesicle.
Fig. li.- Serra^ms. Transverse sections showing differentiation of the
roof of the archenteron into notochord
(n.ch.), mesoderm (mes.), and cndodprm
{end.); j^ar., parablast (periblast). (After
Wilson.)
aic. 3
Fig. 75. -  Serranus. Formation of the gut (a/.c.) by the
bending down of tlie sides of the
roof of the archenteron. s.n.ch.,
sub-notocliordal rod; aid., cndoderm. (After Wilson.)
VI
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
127
these extra-embryonic edges the yolk is finally enclosed and the
anterior margin is then the ventral lip (Fig. 72). Notochord
and mesoderm are differentiated in the roof of the embryonic
part of the archenteron, the rest of this layer giving rise to
the alimentary canal, as in Elasmobranchs. Extra-embryonic
mesoderm arises at the remaining edges of the blastoderm
(Figs. 73-75).
v.l.
Fig. 76.-  Formation of the germ-layers in Ganoid fishes, a, b, in the
Sturgeon {Acipenser) (after Bashford Dean) ; c, d, in Amia (after Sobotta) ;
arch.^ archenteron ; d.l, dorsal lip ; v.l., ventral lip ; n.ch., notochord ;
mes., mesoderm.
Ganoidei
Our knowledge of the differentiation of the germinal layers is
very slight, but it is known that the closure of the blastopore
is bilateral, and that mesoderm is formed at its lips, the notochord in the middle dorsal line (Fig. 76).
128 THE GERMINAL LAYERS VI
DrPNOi
The holoblastic egg of Ceralodus resembles that of the frog
very closely in the development of its archenteron. The roof
Fig. 77. -  Formation of the germ-layers in Dipnoi. A, B, in Ceralodus
(after Semon) ; c, D, in Lepidosiren (after Graham Kerr), arch., archenteron-; d.l, dorsal lip ; n.ch., notochord ; ines., dorsal mesoderm.
of this cavity, however, takes no part in the formation of the gut,
but is differentiated simply into median notochord and lateral
plates of mesoderm. The yolk-cells then grow up to complete
the dorsal wall of the aUmeutarx, canal (Fig. 77, A, u).
VI
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
129
Lepidosiren resembles the frog in all respects, except that the
yolk is more vokimmous and that a ventral lip is never developed
(Fig. 77, c, D).
Urobelotjs Amphibia
The method of germ-layer separation is here practically identical with that which is observed in the frog, except in one
important respect. In the bilateral closure of the blastopore,
the presence of a ventral as well as of a dorsal lip (Fig. 78, A)
and the formation of the mesoderm from a double source, the
two groups closely resemble one another ; but while in the frog
the under layer of the roof of the archenteron persists as the
dorsal lining of the alimentary tract, in the Urodeles the roof
of the archenteron becomes wholly converted into the notochord,
as in Petromyzon, and the gut must be completed dorsally by
an ingrowth of yolk-cells from the sides (Fig. 78, b, c).
The Anurous Amphibia, such as the toad, generally resemble
the frog in this matter, but in one case the notochord is described
as being formed from the middle streak of the whole thickness
of the roof, and even in the frog such a procedure may be
experimentally instigated by subjecting the embryos to the
influence of cane sugar and other substances.
A comparison of these processes in the small-yolked and the
large-yolked types shows that :
1. The blastoderm of the large-yolked corresponds to the
animal region of the small-yolked egg, the yolk to the vegetative
part, and that the edge of the blastoderm in the former is equivalent to the boundary between animal and yolk cells in the latter.
2. In both this bounding line becomes in its entirety the lip
of the blastopore (except where the ventral lip is absent), the
posterior point of the edge in the large-yolked being equivalent
to the dorsal lip of the small-yolked, the anterior point to the
ventral lip.
3. In both the germinal layers are laid down during the
bilateral closure of this blastopore, the notochord stretching in
front of the dorsal lip, the mesoderm springing from the lateral
lips in two sheets which are continuous with one another behind
the ventral lip.
1355 T
130
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
VI
4. The principal points of difference are two. First, the closure
of the blastopore in Elasmobranchs, Myxinoids, and Teleostei,
is effected in two periods ; during the first the overgrowth is
almost confined to the dorsal lip and produces the material for
-piQ. 78 - Formation of the germ-layers in the Axolotl.
A, Sagittal section after completion of the blastopore and rotation of
the egg.
B, Transverse section of the same stage. i. u a
c Dorsal part of a transverse section of a later stage, n.ch., notochord;
d.l.', dorsal hp ; v.l, ventral lip ; mes.v., mesoderm formed ^Wentral hp ;
mei.l, dorsal mesoderm ; mes.2, ventral mesoderm (from the yolk-cellh
pushed into the segmentation cavity) ; end., endoderm.
the formation of the embryo ; in the second the yolk is gradually
covered by an extension of the blastoderm in which the lateral
and anterior margins are alone concerned. Secondly, in these
cases a part only of the blastoporic hp is involved in the formation of the embryo, the lateral and ventral lips remaining wholly
extra-embryonic.
VI
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
131
Gymnophiona
In this group the egg is so laden with yolk that in it segmentation nearly approaches the meroblastic type and results in a
blastoderm lying on a partially divided yolk. This blastoderm
consists of a superficial epithelium of columnar cells, covering
Fig. 79.-  Formation and closure of the blastopore in the Gymnophiona.
A-D, Surface views of the blastoderm of Hypogeophis. The lateral lips are
seen to meet behind, and so form the ventral lip ; y.p., yolk-plug (after
Brauer). e. Embryo of Ichthyophis lying on the partially segmented yolk
which is still uncovered by the blastoderm. (After the brothers Sarasin.)
several irregular layers of scattered cells which are more abundantly supplied with yolk. The cavities between these cells are
equivalent to the ordinary segmentation cavity. Below these
again is the yolk, divided at its surface into cells, and containing
nuclei scattered through its substance. Immediately round the
blastoderm the surface of the yolk is also partially segmented.
At one point-  the posterior middle point-  of the edge of this
I 2
132
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
VI
blastoderm the dorsal lip appears (Fig. 80) ; it exhibits the
usual radiate arrangement of cells. The lip quickly grows back
and so produces a long archenteron which comes to open into
80.-  Formation of the germ-layers in Hyi)0!7eoi)te. (After Br auer.)
A-c Sagittal sections of three successive stages, d, Transverse section
Lough^he blastopore and yolk-plug {y-v.) ; s.c, ^^tlX /f
into which in B and o the archenteron {aroh.) opens ; U., dorsal hp , l.L,
lateral lip ; and vX., ventral Up.
the segmentation cavity in front. The roof of the archenteron
which seems to be derived entirely from the superficial layer of
the blastoderm, consists of a plate of columnar cells, its floor of
the partially segmented yolk.
VI
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
133
The process of overgrowth is not limited to the dorsal lip,
but extends to the immediate right and left. Surface views
(Fig. 79, a-d) show that the transversely placed li]p soon becomes
crescentic, and that the horns of the crescent then grow not
only backwards, but towards the middle line as well, approaching
one another until they meet and so form what is the ventral
lip of the now circular blastopore. In section it is seen that
there is a slight ingrowth at the lateral and at the ventral lips
of a plate of cells continuous with the similarly formed jolate
Â¥iG. 81.-  Transverse sections of HypogeopMs showing the differentiation
ot the root of the archenteron into notochorcl (nxh.) and mesoderm, and
Z fXf (Iftttrarxg"' ^"'^-^
which forms the roof of the archenteron in front ; beneath the
plate is a slit-like space, also, of course, archenteric ; in the midst
of the blastopore is the projecting typically Amphibian yolk-plug.
But m spite of this resemblance there is a very serious difference between the ventral lip of the Gymnopliiona and that of
ail other Anamnia. For while in the latter the whole of the edge of
the blastoderm or small-celled area is converted into a blastoporic
hp, the posterior point being the dorsal, the diametrically
opposite anterior point becoming sooner (in small-yolked eggs)
or la er (m large-yolked eggs) the ventral lip, and while consequently the whole of the vegetative surface of the egg is covered
up when the blastopore closes, in the former the anterior and
134
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
VI
a large part of the two lateral edges take no iiart in this process,
which is confined to the posterior and immediately adjacent
portions of the edge ; this small portion gives rise to the dorsal
and two lateral lips, which latter by their fusion produce the â– 
remarkable similitude of the ventral lip of other forms. As
a result the vegetative hemisphere is still uncovered when the
blastopore has become circular (Fig. 79, d, e). The importance
of this fact for the correct understanding of the relations of the
blastopore to the blastoderm in the Amniota cannot possibly be
over-emphasized.
To return to the germinal layers. The superficial layer is now
the ectoderm. The roof of the archenteron becomes divided
into a median strip-  the notochord, and two lateral sheets-  the
mesoderm which are continuous with one another behind the
yolk-plug by means of the cell-plate invaginated at the lateral
and ventral hps (Fig. 81). The mesoderm has in fact precisely
the same relations as in other Anamnia at this stage. The
notochord passes back into the dorsal lip. No additions are
made to either notochord or mesoderm from any other source.
The roof of the gut (endoderm) is completed by upgrowth and
ingrowth of vegetative cells underneath the midcUe layer.
Amniota
Whereas in the Anamnia the blastoporic lip appears at the
edge of the blastoderm, in the Amniota it hes wholly within the
latter. The blastopore leads into an archenteron, and with the
formation of these structures the materials for the germinal
layers are laid down. Only in the more primitive forms is the
archenteric cavity well developed ; usually it is much reduced
and represented only by the ' neurenteric ' passage or ' chordacanal In primitive forms the upper and lower layers are still
united at the point where the blastopore and archenteron arise,
and both layers may perhaps be said to share in their formation ;
but in most cases all these parts are derived from the upper
layer of the blastoderm alone, the subsequent fusion with the
lower layer being purely secondary. The edge of the blastoderm,
which is entirely independent of the blastopore, grows steadily over
the surface of the yolk, finally enclosing it at the vegetative pole.
i
IPiG 82 - Three stages in the formation of the blastopore at the hinder
end of the embryonic shield of a Reptile {PlaUjdacUjlus). Sm'face views.
(After Will.)
P. 1S5
II
VI
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
136
The Reptiles will be considered first as the whole process is
far clearer in them than in the other two groups.
Rbptilia
There is distinguishable in the blastoderm at the close of
segmentation a circular or oval area placed excentrically towards
the posterior end ; this area is the embryonic shield. The upper
layer of the blastoderm consists of cyHndrical cells in the embryonic shield, of flat cells in the surrounding region ; below it
is the segmentation cavity. The lower layer is an irregular sheet
of scattered rounded cells, not arranged at present in an epithelium, and is constantly being reinforced by the addition of
cells from the nucleated yolk beneath. Between the lower layer
and the yolk is a shallow cavity, the subgerminal cavity. In
some forms, such as Platydactylus and Lacerta, there is one point
in the margin of the embryonic shield where upper and lower
layers are continuous ; this is the primitive plate, and it is
situate at what will be the hinder end (Fig. 83, a). The lower
layer cells before long arrange themselves in a flat epithelium.
Meanwhile a depression has appeared in the primitive plate ;
this is the beginning of the archenteron, and its anterior margin
is the dorsal lip of the blastopore. Seen from the surface (Fig. 82)
the dorsal lip presents the appearance of a transverse rim bounding a groove at the hinder edge of the embryonic shield. The
rim rapidly becomes crescentic, the horns of the crescent turn
back, meet, and fuse behind the primitive plate which now
corresponds exactly to the Gymnophionan yolk-plug.
During the backgrowth of the horns of the crescent, which
are the lateral blastoporic lips, the cavity of the archenteron
has rapidly extended until it reaches the anterior end of the
embryonic shield (Fig. 83) ; the cavity is broad. The roof consists of a layer of columnar cells which at the dorsal lip turn
over in the ordinary way into the cells of the upper layer. The
floor is in front distinct from the lower layer, and here it consists of a single layer of cubical cells ; behind the dorsal lip -  in
the primitive plate-  it is much thickened, and from this thickenmg there proceeds backwards a narrow tongue of cells between
the upper and the lower layers.
136
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
VI
A transverse sectign (Figs. 84, a ; 86) through the blastopore
shows the mass of cells of the primitive plate flanked on each
side by a projecting blastoporic lip and sending out between
the upper and lower layers two lateral sheets of cells.
Fig. 83. -  Sagittal sections of the blastopore and archenteron in the
Gecko Platydadylus. (After Will.) a-e, Successive stages ; jj.^p., primitive
plate ; pd., lower layer or paraderm ; s.g.c, subgerminal cavity ; arch.,
archenteron ; d.l, dorsal lip ; y.p., yolk-plug ; mes.v., mesoderm formed
at the ventral lip.
The resemblance between these structures and those in the
Amphibian, and particularly the Gymnophionan egg when the
blastopore has become circular, is sufficiently obvious. The
dorsal and lateral lips (there is no ventral lip in the Reptiles)
clearly correspond in the two cases ; the mass of cells in the
primitive plate embraced by these lips is the yolk-plug ; the
Fio. 84. -  Four successive transverse sections through the blastopore
and archenteron of Plalydactylus. (After Will. )
A, Posterior section through the yolk-plug {y.f.) ; l.l, lateral lip ; 2^(1. ,
lower layer ; mes., mesoderm springing from the lateral lips.
B is more anterior, just behind the dorsal lip.
c is just in front of the dorsal lip, where the floor of the archenteron
{arch.) is still intact, and
D more anterior, where the archenteron communicates with the subgerminal cavity.
c
arc?-..
c
138
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
VI
cavity of invagination is the archenteron in which floor corresponds to floor and roof to roof ; lastly, the sheets of cells
projecting beneath the upper layer at the sides of and behind
the blastopore are the equivalents of the mesoderm formed at
the lateral and ventral lips in the Amphibia.
From this comparison it follows of course that cells which are
the morphological equivalents of the yolk-cells of the Amphibia
are to be found in the upper layer of the Reptihan blastoderm.
That layer, therefore, cannot be termed the ectoderm until the
process of invagination is complete.
The floor of the archenteron now fuses throughout with the
lower layer, and as soon as the fusion is completed perforations
-PTP 86 - Transverse section of the blastopore and yolk-plug (y.p.) of
thTS^itoise (Trionyx). (After Mitsukuri.) U., lateral lip ; > m/so^erm
produeed at the lateral lips ; pel., lower layer not yet detaehed from the
yolk (stippled).
begin to appear in tte fused layers (Figs. 83, E ; 84, e). They
seem to be unable to keep pace with the general gro^vth of the
blastoderm and to become first stretched and then fenestrated.
But to whatever causes the perforation may be due, the floor
of the archenteron with the underlying lower layer completely
disappears, and the archenteron then communicates freely with
the subgerminal cavity. The roof of the archenteron is now
inserted by its edges into the surrounding lower layer.
The median strip of the roof next thickens to form the notochord (Fig 85), and separates from the two lateral portions which
then become the mesoderm. The notochord passes posteriorly
into the dorsal lip. the plates of mesoderm into the latei^hps
of the blastopore, and here the latter are perfectly contmuous
with the mesoderm produced at the sides of and behind the
I
Fig 87*.-  Area pellucida of the lien's egg. a, After 12 hours , b, After
18 hours' incubation, as seen by transmitted light. J5r.£/., prnnitive groove ;
n.ch., notochord ; pr.am., pro-amnion.
P. 139
VI THE GERMINAL LAYERS 139
blastopore (Figs. 84, a, b ; 86). The mesoderm thus exhibits
all the relations which it has in the Anamnia.
The Uning epithelium of the alimentary canal (endoderm) is
derived from the lower layer, which grows in from the sides
below the mesoderm and notochord (Fig. 85, c, d). From this
layer the gut is subsequently folded off, the remainder being
yolk-sac epithelium. In several cases the lip of the blastopore
is not the only source of origin of notochord and mesoderm,
both receiving additions in front, and the mesoderm at the sides
also, from the lower layer.
Fig. 87. -  ^Formation of the primitive streak and groove of the chick by
proliferation of cells of the upper layer. Transverse sections.
A, At 10 hours. There is at present no sign of the primitive groove ;
the lower layer {'pd.) takes no part in the proliferation.
B, At 15 hoiu's. The primitive groove has appeared. It is occupied
by a projecting mass of cells, tlie yolk-plug {y.'p.), and bounded by the
lateral hps {U.). The proliferated cells spread out on cacli side as the
lateral sheets of mesoderm {mes.).
The conditions observed in the Birds are very readily derived
from and very easily understood in the light of those which
obtain in the Reptiles.
There appears in the posterior region of the blastoderm a proliferation of cells in the upper layer (Fig. 87, a) ; this rapidly
extends in the median line, and along it there appears a narrow
groove. The cell proliferation is the ' primitive streak ', the groove the "primitive groove" (Fig. 87*).
Fig. 90. -  ^Anterior (a) and posterior (b) halves of a sagittal section
through the primitive streak and associated structures of the sparrow.
(After Schauinsland.) There is a sUght cavity, archenteron, below the
dorsal Hp (d.i.), and a well-marked ventral lip {vL). n.ch., notochord ;
p.s., primitive streak ; 7nes.v., mesoderm behind the ventral lip ; p.a.,
lower layer.
Fig. 91. - Transverse section of the anterior end of the blastoderm of the chick "at 15 hours showing the formation of anterior notochord (n.ch.) and
mesoderm (mes.) directly from the lower layer {end.) ; ec., ectoderm.
This primitive groove is simply an elongated and laterally
compressed blastopore. In front of the anterior end -  the dorsal
lip -  the notochord is produced (Figs. 88, 89) ; to right and left
of the notochord are the sheets of mesoderm which, springing
from the sides -  the lateral lips -  of the groove (Fig. 87, b), are
continued into one another behind its posterior end, where there
may be an actual ventral lip (Fig. 90). The archenteric cavity has, however, in most cases disappeared, though a vestige of it is
sometimes to be seen (Fig. 90) . Between the sides of the groove- 
which still exhibit the structure characteristic of blastoporic hps, is
merely a mass of cells-  representative of the yolk-plug (Fig. 87, b)
- fused with the lower layer. The so-called ' neurenteric canal ' ,
which appears later, is the sole remnant of the archenteron
together with the communication which we have seen to become
established between it and the subgerminal cavity in Reptiles.
The primitive streak and groove invariably originate in the upper Icayer, fusion with the lower layer being merely secondary ;
only after the germ-layers have been formed can the upper layer
be described as ectoderm.
The notochord and mesoderm receive increments in front from
the lower layer (Fig. 91).
The gut (endoderm) is formed as in Reptiles.
Mammaiaa
In the Monotremata there is a long archenteron with a much
reduced lumen produced from the upper layer. The blastopore
is an elongated ' primitive groove '. The notochord and mesoderm have the usual relations to these structures. The interpretation put by Wilson and Hill on their observations -  namely,
that the dorsal lip and archenteron are derived from the ' primitive plate ' while the primitive streak and groove are of distinct
origin -  is probably erroneous. We may accept Assheton's
explanation that the ' primitive plate ' of the authors is simply
the point of final enclosure of the yolk by the blastoderm,
a precociously rapid process in this form, and that archenteron
and primitive groove are, as everywhere else, parts of one and
the same structure (Fig. 92).
We are still in ignorance of the formation of the germinal layers
in Marsupials, though we may hazard the conjecture that the embryonic area of the blastocyst wall will be found to behave like the
embryonic shield in Reptilia, that a blastopore and archenteron will
be developed near its posterior edge in connexion with which the
notochord and mesoderm will arise in the usual way, that the
archenteron will break through into the subgerminal cavity below
the lower layer, and that this layer will give rise to the gut.
This indeed is what occiurs in the Placental Mammals, the
only diflference being that here the embryonic area is from the
first enclosed in the sac of the trophoblast as part of the embryonic knob. This knob, as we have already seen, is, together
with the lower layer, differentiated from the original inner mass.
The embryonic area (Fig. 92*), derived from the embryonic
knob, behaves precisely as the embryonic shield of the upper layer
in Reptiles, giving rise to an archenteron and blastopore ; this event
is, however, postponed until after the amnion has been formed.
trek a
Fig. 132. Diagiain of the egg of Ornithorhynchus after formation of the germinal layers. (After Assheton's modification of Wilson and Hill.) x, the
point at which the blastoderm has finally enclosed the yolk ; here the
upper layer (double line) and lower layer (broken line) are continuous with
one another and with the yolk. This is the ' primitive plate ' of Wilson and
Hill, a to p, primitive streak ; a, anterior end (dorsal lip) ; p., posterior
end. In front of a. is the archenteron (arch.), behind p. the mesoderm of
the ventral lip {mes.v.).
Fig. 92.-  Embryonic shield of the dog. (After Bomiet.) In the embryonic shield, where the cells are columnar, the nuclei are more closely packed
than in the surrounding trophoblast, where the cells are flat. At tne
posterior end is a notch, the blastopore (lower end in the fagure).
When the archenteron has been developed it behaves in the
manner we are already acquainted with. Its floor fuses with
the lower layer, and then the two break away so that the archenteron comes to communicate with the subgerminal or yolk-sac
cavity (Fig. 93). The notochord is differentiated out of its
roof, the mesodermal sheets pass into the lateral lips and are
Fig. 93. -  a. Longitudinal section of the embryonic shield and blastopore
of the bat, VesperlUio. (After Van Beneden.) The archenteron (arch.) has
broken through into the subgerminal cavity [s.g.c.) or cavity of the blastocyst. Below tlie dorsal lip (d.l.) is the blastopore (so-called neurcnteric
canal), and behind this the yolk- plug {ij.j}.). (With this should be compared
Fig. 138, which shows a human embryo in the same stage.)
B, Transverse section showing the origin of the notochord [n.cli.) from
the roof of the rudimentary archenteron in the mouse. The floor of the
archenteron has already disappeared, mes., mesoderm ; 'pd., lower layer.
Above is the ectoderm of the medullar}^ plate.
continuous with one another behind the blastopore. Accessory
notochordal and mesoblastic material is proliferated in front from
the lower layer. After this the lower layer is endoderm, and
gives rise to the gut and yolk-sac, after growing in from the
sides underneath the notochord.
The archenteron may be well developed (as in VesperUlio), but
more usually is reduced to a narrow canal, the ' chorda-canal '
or, so called, ' ncurenteric ' passage.^
^ Neurenteric passage means properly the communication between the
medullary tube and the hmd end of the archenteron. See below, chap. vii.
The Relation between the Amniote and the Anamnian Blastopore
The facts we have now reviewed will have made it evident
that there are certain features common to the separation of the
germinal layers in all Vertebrates.
Thus in all cases the material for the germ-layers is laid down
during an overgrowth and ingrowth of cells which takes place
at the lip of the blastopore during the formation and closure
of the latter. This closure is always bilaterally symmetrical,
beginning at the dorsal lip and taking place most actively there,
less actively at the lateral lips, and least of all at the ventral
lip. It leads to the formation of a bilateral archenteron, the
extent of which is greatest anteriorly, least posteriorly. The
layer that now remains outside is the ectoderm. The notochord
is differentiated out of the roof of the archenteron in the middle
line in front of the dorsal lip, while the mesoderm sheets which
flank the notochord pass back to the lateral lips and are confluent with one another behind the ventral lip.
A, 1-3, The closure of the blastopore in such a form as the frog ; 1, 2,
before, 3, after rotation of the egg. The blastoderm, or small-celled area,
is heavily stippled. Its whole edge, which becomes the lip of the blastopore, is represented by a thick continuous line, d.l., dorsal, v.l., ventral lip.
B, 1-3, Three similar stages in such a form as Lepidosiren, where the
ventral lip is absent. Only that part of the edge of the blastoderm which
becomes converted into a blastoporic lip -  namely, the posterior and immediately adjacent parts -  is indicated by the thick continuous line, d.l,
dorsal lip. '
c, 1, 2, The condition seen in the Gymnophiona, where still less of the
edge of the blastoderm-  only a small part at the posterior end, represented
by the thick line-  becomes the lip of the blastopore, but the lateral lips
swing back, meet, and fuse to form the ventral lip, v.l. Thus the yolk
(white) remains uncovered.
D, 1, 2, The Amniote blastopore. The heavily stippled area is the
embryomc shield, the central portion only of the Amniote blastoderm
but the equivalent of the whole blastoderm of the Anamnia. From the
posterior part of its margin a blastoporic lip is formed (d.l, dorsal lip)
and by the bending back and union of the lateral lips a ventral lip (v I )
as m the Gymnophiona. i' v
The lightly stippled area outside this represents the extra- embryonic
Fâ„¢,"? blastoderm; which is equivalent to the yolk-cells immediately
surrounding the blastoderm of the Gymnophiona ^
xlr^l^^-^l the unsegmented yolk (white). Thus the blastopore of the
f^t lTfC formed inside its blastoderm, but at the edge of what is equiva
Th« blastoderm, namely, the embryonic shield. ^
lUe yolk is finally covered later on by the growth of the blastoderm
k2
148
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
VI
So far there is general agreement. There is, however, a very
serious difference between the two great groups of Vertebrates
in respect of the reh^.tion of the blastoporic lip to the blastoderm
-  the cap of cells produced at the end of segmentation in a largeyolked egg or the area of small cells in a small-yolked egg -  for
in the Anamnia the blastopore arises from the edge of this
blastoderm (Fig. 94, a), while in the Amniota it arises inside it
(Fig 94, d). By the help of the Gymnophiona, however, the
second condition may without difficulty be derived from the first.
In the Gymnophiona (Fig. 94, c) (1) the blastoderm is an
oval area of columnar cells resting upon and surrounded by
a partially segmented yolk. (2) Only a part of the edge of the
blastoderm is converted into a blastoporic lip, namely, a small
region at the posterior end. Here a dorsal lip is formed and
lateral lips quickly follow ; the lateral lips then turn back,
encircling a small area of the yolk, behind which they meet and
fuse to form a ventral lip to the now circular blastopore. In
this process the anterior margin of the blastoderm is wholly
unconcerned. (3) The archenteron opens into the segmentation
cavity, notochord and mesoderm are derived from its roof, the
endoderm from the yolk-cells which lie in its floor. The notochord stretches in front of the dorsal lip ; the mesoderm sheets
springing from the lateral lips are continuous with one another
behind the ventral lip.
As a result of this peculiarity in the formation of the ventral
lip the yolk remains uncovered. In all other Anamnia, however,
where the ventral lip is developed from the anterior edge of the
blastoderm, the yolk is necessarily covered up by the closure of
the blastopore.
We turn now to the Amniota, to the Reptiles for instance,
and find (1) that the embryonic shield is a circular or oval
area of columnar cells resting upon a lower layer, and surrounded
by a zone of flattened cells. (2) At the posterior margin of this
embryonic shield upper and lower layers are continuous. Here
a dorsal lip is formed and lateral lips quickly follow ; the lateral
lips turn back encircling a small area of the outer zone of cells- 
where these are continuous ^\'ith the lower layer-  behind which
they meet and fuse to form (a virtual, in some cases an actual)
VI
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
149
ventral lip to the now circular blastopore. In this process the
anterior margiji of the embryonic shield is wholly unconcerned.
(3) The archenteron opens into the subgerminal cavity, notochord
and mesoderm are derived from its roof, the endoderm from the
lower layer. The notochord stretches in front of the dorsal lip,
the sheets of mesoderm springing from the lateral lips are continuous with one another behind the ventral lip.
It seems clear, then, that the embryonic shield of the Amniota
is the representative of the blastoderm of the Gymnophiona
(and of all Anamnia), while the marginal zone of the upper
layer, together with the lower layer with which it is at one
point -  ^the primitive plate -  still united, represents the yolk-cells
or nucleated yolk.
In passing from the Gjrmnophiona to the higher Vertebrates
we have therefore to suppose that with the further increase of
yolk segmentation has become restricted not to the blastoderm
alone (as in Fishes), but to the blastoderm and those circumjacent and subjacent cells which in the Gymnophiona are partially
segmented from the yolk. In the most primitive Reptiles the
lower layer cells are still crowded with yolk and still retain
a connexion, in the primitive plate, with the marginal cells of
the upper layer. In other Reptiles, in Birds, and in Mammals this
primitive connexion is lost, and it is only secondarily, after the
formation of the primitive groove and streak, that the upper
fuses with the lower layer.
The Gymnophionan condition must in turn be derived from
some Anamnian blastopore in the formation of which the anterior
edge takes no part, in which consequently no ventral lip is formed.
Such a form may be found in Lepidosiren (Fig. 94, b), in which
the yolk is less abundant than in the Gymnophiona, but more
abundant than in the typical smaU-yolked egg. Here the formation of a blastopore is restricted to the dorsal and lateral Jips.
The absence of a ventral lip may be a very primitive feature,
smce none is found in Petromyzon.
It may also be noticed that the union of segmentation cavity
with archenteron occurs here and there in various Anamnia,
sometimes in Eana, and in Petromyzon, thus foreshadowing the
condition seen in Gymnophiona and the Amniota.
150
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
VI
In the Anamnia, indeed, the archenteron has a direct relation
to the endoderm in that, after notochord and mesoderm have
been differentiated, the aUmentary canal is formed from its roof,
or floor, or both. But as we pass up the series the archenteric
cavity loses this significance, its lumen dwindles and finally
disappears, and its function is reduced to the differentiation of
notochord and mesoderm alone. The endoderm is then derived
from the lower layer cells -  ^representative of yolk-cells -  ^which
line the segmentation cavity.
The same lower layer cells may contribute to the notochord
and mesoderm anteriorly, and this, as we have seen, is of constant occurrence in such small-yolked Anamnian types as the
Amphibia, and Petromyzon ; not, however, in the large-yolked
eggs of Fishes.
The Significance of the Gebminal Layers
It will have been repeatedly noticed that the same elementary
organ or germ-layer may come into being by different processes.
This is true of the front end of the notochord and mesoderm,
and still more obviously of the endoderm, for the lining epithehum
of the alimentary canal may be derived from the roof only of
the archenteron (Elasmobranchs and Teleostei), from the floor
only {Petromyzon, Urodela, Ceratodus), from both roof and floor
{Rana, Lepidosiren), from the yolk-cells in the floor and from
those in the segmentation cavity (Gymnophiona, occasionally
Rana), or from the lower layer (yolk-) cells of the segmentation
cavity alone (Amniota).
In considering such discrepancies in the mode of origin of
homologous structures-  and discrepancies of this kind are of
common occurrence, not only in development from the egg but
also in budding and regeneration-  it must be borne in mind
that experiment has shown the formation of the embryonic
organs-  such as the germ-layers-  to be dependent on the
presence of certain stuffs in the cytoplasm of the ovum, but
that these stuffs are not necessarily deposited in the situations
which will eventually be occupied by the organs to which they
give rise, nor even in the same position in the ova of animals
belonging to the same group. Thus they may occupy dissimilar
VI THE GERMINAL LAYERS 151
positions also in the segmented ovum, and again in the later
stage which we speak of as gastrulation or the closure of the
blastopore. The necessary materials -  now cut up into cells - 
have then to move into their definite positions, and thus we
witness the roof of the gut being formed by an upgrowth of
yolk-cells, or its floor by a bending down of the roof of the
archenteron.
The way in which an organ is developed is not, therefore,
necessarily a criterion of its homologies. Homologous structures,
that is, those derived, like the alimentary tract of the Vertebrate, from some common ancestral structure, may differ in their
origin during individual development. The stuffs on which their
differentiation depends are doubtless comparable, but the paths
by which that differentiation is achieved may be diverse.
LITERATURE
R. AsSHETON. Professor Hubrecht's paper on the early ontogenetic
phenomena in Mammals. Quart. Jotirn. Micr. Sci., 1909.
E. VAN Beneden. Untersuchungen iiber die Blatterbildung, den
Chordakanal und die Gastrulation bei Siiugetieren. Anat. Am. iii, 1888.
R. Bonnet. Beitrage zur Embryologie des Hundes. Anat. Hefte,
Abt. ix, 1897.
A. Beaueh. Beitrage zur Entwickelungsgeschichte der Gymnophionen.
Zool. Jahrb. x, 1897.
Bashfoed Dean. The early development of gar-pike and sturgeon.
Journ. Morph. xi, 1895.
Bashfoed Dean. On the embryology of Bdellostoma stouti. Festschr.
f. C. von Kupffer, Jena, 1899.
L. F. Hennequy. Embryog6nie de la truite. Journ. de VAnat. et de la
Phys. xxiv, 1888.
J. W. Jenkinson. Remarks on the germinal layers of Vertebrates and
on the significance of germinal layers in general. Mem,. Manchester Lit.
and Phil. Soc. I, 1906.
J. Geaham Keeb. The development of Lepidosiren paradoxa. Quart.
Journ. Micr. Sci. xlv, 1901.
K. MiTSUKUEi and C. IsmKAWA. On the formation of the germinal layers
in Chelonia. Quart. Journ. Micr. Sci. xxvii, 1886.
J. Ruckeet. Die erste Entwickelung des Eies der Elasmobranchier.
Festschr. f. C. von Kupffer, Jena, 1899.
H. ScHAUiNSLAND. Studien zur Entwickelungsgeschichte der Sauropsiden. Zoologica, xvi, 1903.
162
THE GERMINAL LAYERS
VI
11. Semon. Die Furchung und Entwickelung dcr Keimbliitter bei
Ceralodiis forstcri. Zool. Forschiivgsreise in Anslralien, 1901.
A. E. Shipley. The development of Pctromyzon jluvialilis. Quart.
Joum. Micr. Sci. xxvii, 1887.
J. SoBOTTA. Die Gastrulation von .4»n{aaZw. VerJtaiidl. Anat. Geaellsch.
Berlin, 1896.
C. O. Whitman and A. C. Eycleshymer. The egg of Aviia and its
cleavage. Journ. Mor]}h. xii, 1897.
L. Will. Die Entwickelungsgescliichte der Ileptilien. Zool. Jahrh. vi, ix.
H. V. Wilson. The embryology of the sea- bass {Scrramts alrarius).
Bull. U. S. Fish Commission, ix, 1889.
J. T. Wilson and J. P. Hill. Observations on the development of
Ornilhorhynchus. Phil. Trails. Roy. Soc, Series B, cxcix, 1907.
H. E. ZiEGLEE. Beitrage zur Entwickelungsgeschichte von Torpedo.
Arch. mikr. -Anal, xxxix, 1892.
i
Fig. 95. -  External features of the development of the tadpole of the
Frog.
a. Medullary plate, anterior end : the three divisions of the brain are
apparent.
h. The same embryo from the posterior end : the sides of the medullary
plate pass back on either side of the blastopore. The blastopore is now
reduced to a narrow slit by the approximation of the lateral lips ; at the
dorsal and ventral lips the aperture is rather wider.
c. Medullary folds and groove, anterior end : the three divisions of the
brain are readily seen, and the anterior part of what will be the spinal
cord. External to the inner medullary folds are the outer, and these pass
in front into the broad gill-plates, in front of which again are the senseplates.
d. Closure of medullary folds, but the suture is still visible : the gill-plate
is divided on each side into two, and in front of it is the sense-plate ; behind
the gill-plate is a slight constriction.
e. Anterior view of the same embryo : the medullary folds have not
quite closed in front. Beneath their anterior end is a depression, the
stomodaeum, and on either side of this the sense-plates ; the gill-plates can
just be seen behind these.
f. Posterior view of the same embryo : the medullary folds have closed
over the dorsal division of the blastopore (neurenteric canal) while the
ventral remains as the proctodaeum. The middle region of the blastopore
is marked by a very narrow suture.
g. Later embryo from below showing the stomodaeum, in front of the
V-shaped sucker, and posteriorly the proctodaeum at the base of the tailstump.
h. Older embryo from the right side. The tail is rather longer, the
proctodaeum at its base : the stomodaeum can be seen in front between
the two halves of the sucker. At the side of the head in front is the
nostril, behind the gill-slits.
i. Older embryo (ready to hatch) with well-developed tail and external
gills.
Betweenl52 andlG")
{{Jenkinson1913 footer}}

Revision as of 17:53, 17 July 2015