2016 Group Project 5

From Embryology
2016 Student Projects 
Signalling: 1 Wnt | 2 Notch | 3 FGF Receptor | 4 Hedgehog | 5 T-box | 6 TGF-Beta
2016 Group Project Topic - Signaling in Development

OK you are now in a group, add a topic with your student signature to the group page.

This page is an undergraduate science embryology student project and may contain inaccuracies in either descriptions or acknowledgements.
Group Assessment Criteria  
Mark Hill.jpg Science Student Projects
  1. The key points relating to the topic that your group allocated are clearly described.
  2. The choice of content, headings and sub-headings, diagrams, tables, graphs show a good understanding of the topic area.
  3. Content is correctly cited and referenced.
  4. The wiki has an element of teaching at a peer level using the student's own innovative diagrams, tables or figures and/or using interesting examples or explanations.
  5. Evidence of significant research relating to basic and applied sciences that goes beyond the formal teaching activities.
  6. Relates the topic and content of the Wiki entry to learning aims of embryology.
  7. Clearly reflects on editing/feedback from group peers and articulates how the Wiki could be improved (or not) based on peer comments/feedback. Demonstrates an ability to review own work when criticised in an open edited wiki format. Reflects on what was learned from the process of editing a peer's wiki.
  8. Evaluates own performance and that of group peers to give a rounded summary of this wiki process in terms of group effort and achievement.
  9. The content of the wiki should demonstrate to the reader that your group has researched adequately on this topic and covered the key areas necessary to inform your peers in their learning.
  10. Develops and edits the wiki entries in accordance with the above guidelines.
More Information on Assessment Criteria | Science Student Projects

T-box genes and their signalling pathway

Tbx5 3D structure [1]


  • The T-Box genes encode for a series of T-box proteins, a family of transcription factors that with more than 20 members identified in humans so far, and homologues in many other organisms including different vertebrates. These T-box proteins are termed as transcription factors because of their ability to regulate the expression and subsequent activity of other genes by binding to DNA. T-box proteins are characterised by a DNA-binding motif known as the T-box that binds DNA. Many researchers have identified that the T-box genes play an important roles of the development of the heart, respiratory system and limbs. Since these genes are involved in the development of certain important regions of human body, mutations of them leads into human gene disorders including Di-George Syndrome and Holt-Oram syndrome. [2]

This page will give a broad overview of how the T-box signalling pathway works, as well as its importance, it's discovery, abnormalities associated with this transcription factor, and animal models that have been used to study these genes. It is important to note that T-box genes have also been found to regulate patterning and cell fate, cell survival, and/or proliferation. This however will not be covered in this web page. This web page will focus on the importance of T-box genes in embryological limb development. For more information, click here

T-Box gene and embryology

The T-box gene family plays an essential role in controlling embryogenesis in a wide variety of organisms, including many invertebrates, amphibians and mammals) [3] . The box-gene family encodes related DNA-binding transcriptional regulators and the genes exhibit diverse patterns of both spatial and temporal expression in the developing embryo. Studies both in genetic and molecular embryology have shown the importance of these genes in regulating cell fate decisions which, during embryological development, are important in establishing the early body plan and later are important in the organogenesis process. [3]

Origins of the T-box name

The founding member of the T-box family is brachyura which comes from the greek meaning short tail. Brakhus means short in greek and oura meaning tail. [4]. This gene was discovered through experimental studies with a short tailed mouse that harboured a mutation which affected it's tail length and embryonic development [5].

Nadezhda Alexandrovna Dobrovolskaïa-Zavadskaïa first described the brachyury mutation in 1927 as a mutation that affected tail length and sacral vertebrae in heterozygous mice [5]. Unfortunately, the original article had been lost and only the paraphrased version is subsisted (see below for more information on the discovery).

This image is a photograph of Nadezhda Alexandrovna Dobrovolskaïa-Zavadskaïa in 1948, taken from [6]

The brachyury gene (which is also known as T) was soon studied in great detail due to its important role in the development of the notochord and posterior mesoderm. Mutations in T are shown to cause embryonic lethality in homozygote mice and short tails in heterozygote mice [4]. Now, in human and mouse genomes, the gene brachyura is represented by the symbol T and gene name T. However the gene is described as brachyury.

The discovery of T-box genes

In 1927, a Russian female scientist, Nadine Dobrovolskaïa-Zavadskaïa, successfully isolated a strain from a mouse sample with short tail, which caused by a semidominant heterozygous mutation in a locus. After that she named this mutated locus as T and this experiment is trusted that is the first successful mammalian genetic screening. This blaze a trail of further investigation about the human embryonic genetic coordination and its importance [6]. In follow up experiment, some samples were treated with homozygous T locus and ended in mid-gestational stage with unorganized development of mesoderm and notochord. This shows the T locus is a fundamental gene during gastrulation and gives the very first concepts of notochord on neural tube and somite development. 60 years later T, now also known as brachyury, meaning ‘short tail’ in Greek to pay tribute to the earliest finding of this gene[7]. However the scientist could not figure out its biochemical role since lack of the researches and evidences about the T-gene products until in 1993, T-gene was revealed as a sequence-specific DNA-binding protein [8]. Crystallographic determination of the structure of the DNA-binding domain, now called the Tbox, a modern name according to more scientific findings which proteins recognize DNA[9].

Timeline of the discovery of the T-Box gene

In 1927, the Brachyury (T) locus was introduced to the scientific world in a report describing the effects of a mutation at this locus on both embryonic viability in homozygotes and the development of the tail in heterozygotes. [5]

Over the following decades, further embryological defects caused by the T mutation were studied, as well as the importance of the T-box genes in normal signalling pathways and embryonic development.

1990 - The T gene itself was cloned. [7]
1994 - Bollag and his colleagues showed the existence of a family of T-related genes in the mouse genome, which was christened the T-box gene family. [10]
1995 - The discovery of sequence homology between the mouse T gene and a newly cloned Drosophila gene called "omg". [11]

The location of tbx-2 was found, 17q21-22 which means in the long arm (q) of chromosome 17, from region 2, band 1 to region 2, band 2. [12]

1997 - The mapping of the Holt-Oram Syndrome locus was refined to 12q24.1 by fluorescence in situ hybridization, which was tightly linked to Holt-Oram Syndrome.[13].
1998 - Alison Isaac and the team confirmed that in chicken embryo, Tbx-2 & Tbx-3 are related to both forelimb and hindlimb development, and Tbx-4 & Tbx-5 have limited expression domains in leg and wing respectively. [14]
2001 - It was proposed that TBX1 in humans is a key gene in the etiology of DiGeorge syndrome [15].
2003 - 3 mouse Tbx20 splice variants, were cloned and called Tbx20a, Tbx20b, and Tbx20c, and by database analysis they identified a fourth variant, Tbx20d.[16].
2004 - With collaboration of other signalling factor, tbx-3 is involved of mammary gland development in mouse model.[17]
2005 - A deletion of Tbx20 in mouse was found to be embryonic lethal. [18].
2006 - Tbx6 was found to be essential for Mesp2 expression during somitogenesis in mouse.[19].
2007 - A clinical human case shown tbx-5 is related to human pericardium agenesis and verified as one of the symptoms of Holt-Oram Syndrome. [20]
2009 - A Drosophila heart model involving mutation of pannier (pnr) was used to examine the function of GATA4 in adult heart physiology. [21].
2010 - Tbx3 showed to significantly improve the quality of induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells [22].
2011 - TBX6-dependent regulation of SOX2 was demonstrated to determine the fate of axial stem cells [23].

Features of the T-box family

The defining feature of the T-box gene family is a conserved domain that was first uncovered in the sequence of the mouse T locus, or Brachyury gene[7]. This homology domain encodes a polypeptide region that has been named the T-box. [24]

Typical tbx protein structure.png

Summary of the main T-box genes

The following table outlines the functions of some important T-box genes, including their location and associated human diseases.

T-box gene Main expression sites during embryogenesis Function Abnormalities
Tbx1 Pharyngeal endoderm, mesoderm core of the first pharyngeal arch, head mesoderm ventral to hindbrain, sclerotome Pharyngeal arch arteries development, governs the transition between stem cell quiescence and proliferation in hair follicles, associated with developmental abnormalities with the ear, facial and cardiac outflow DiGeorge syndrome, Velocardiofacial syndrome, Conotruncal anomaly face syndrome, Tetralogy of Fallot
Tbx2 Allantois, non-chanmber myocardium, optic and otic vesicles, naso-facial mesenchyme, limbs, lungs, genitalia Potent immortalizing gene that acts by downregulating CDKN2A, regulates Anf expression in chamber myocardium development None identified
Tbx3 Non-chamber myocardium (sinoatrial region, AV canal and interventricular ring), expressed with TBX2, TBX3, and TBX5 in the embryonic neural retina, mammary gland Provides positional information important for topographic mapping in differentiation of distinct cell types across the laminar axis of the retina, development of functional ectopic pacemakers, stimulates Nanog, Tbx3 specifies digit III and the combination of Tbx2 and Tbx3 specifies digit IV, acting together with the interdigital BMP signaling cascade. The fetal lung, kidney, heart, liver, and spleen in humans expresses this gene Ulnar-mammary syndrome
Tbx4 Hindlimb, mandibular and lung mesenchyme, atrium and body wall Developmental pathways of the lower limbs and the pelvis in humans Ischiocoxopodopatellar syndrome, Small patella syndrome
Tbx5 Cardiac cresent, heart tube, sinus venous, common atrium, left ventricle (LV) and right ventricle (RV) forelimb, eye Promotes cardiomyocyte differentiation, interaction with GATA4 cause of human cardiac septal defects Holt-Oram syndrome
Tbx18 Splanchnic mesoderm, septum traversum, epicardium Maintain the separation of anterior and posterior somite compartments, specification of ureteral mesenchyme and SMC differentiation in the ureter Congenital anomalies of kidney and urinary tract 2
Tbx20 Allantois, lateral plate mesoderm, cardiac crescent, heart tube, hindbrain, eye Cardiac development and yolk sac vascular remodeling Atrial septal defect 4

Table 1. adapted from: Table 1. Embryonic expression and mutant phenotypes of mouse cardiac T-box genes [25]

Quiz 1

<quiz display=simple>

{The founding member of the T-box family is brachyura which comes from the greek meaning short tail. |type="()"} + true - false || True. Brakhus means short in greek and oura means tail.

{How was the brachyury mutation first described in 1927 by Nadezhda Alexandrovna Dobrovolskaïa-Zavadskaïa? |type="()"} - A mutation that affected bone formation in birds + A mutation that affected tail length and sacral vertebrae in mice - A mutation of phalangeal formation in mammals - A mutation that affected several areas of embryological development. These areas had not yet been identified. || Nadezhda Alexandrovna Dobrovolskaïa-Zavadskaïa first described the brachyury mutation in 1927 as a mutation that affected tail length and sacral vertebrae in heterozygous mice

{ The T gene was cloned in 1990. |type="()"} -False +True || True

{Where is the Tbx1 gene expressed in embryological development? |type="()"} + Pharyngeal endoderm, mesoderm core of the first pharyngeal arch, head mesoderm ventral to hindbrain, sclerotome - Hindlimb, mandibular and lung mesenchyme, atrium and body wall - Splanchnic mesoderm, septum traversum, epicardium || The Tbx1 gene is expressed in: Pharyngeal endoderm, mesoderm core of the first pharyngeal arch, head mesoderm ventral to hindbrain, sclerotome

{The mutation of which Tbx gene causes Ulnar-mammary syndrome? |type="()"} + Tbx3 - Tbx4 - Tbx18 || The mutation of Tbx 3 results in this syndrome.

{The function of Tbx20 is the development the lower limbs and the pelvis in humans |type="()"} - true + false || False.Tbx20 is responsible for Cardiac development and yolk sac vascular remodeling.


Functions of T-box in development

T-box genes are a growing family of transcription factors that are expressed in diverse patterns throughout vertebrate development. They have emerged as key players in embryonic patterning, tissue differentiation and morphogenesis, particularly in vertebrates and some specific examples have been described in the following sections.

Cardiac development

The heart is one of the first organs to develop and function in vertebrate embryos. Its formation is a complex process and requires contributions from multiple transcription factors, including GATA4, eHAND, dHAND, Irx4, and TBX genes [26].

In the developing heart, Tbx5 expression can be first detected at stage 12 along the entire rostrocaudal length of the fused heart tube[27]. Although it is expressed very early in cardiac embryogenesis, Tbx5 is not essential for cardiac crescent formation or for development of the early heart tube. The growth of the posterior segment (atria and left ventricle) of the heart is what requires Tbx5, and does not occur in embryos that do not have Tbx5. In contrast, right ventricle and outflow tract development have been shown to be Tbx5-independent[26]. It is interesting to note that the role of TBX5 in the growth and maturation of posterior heart is evolutionarily conserved from amphibia (Xenopus) to mammals[28].

The signalling mechanism of TBX5 involves interaction with the cardiac homeobox protein NKX2-5 which synergistically promotes cardiomyocyte differentiation. Both these molecules bind directly to the promoter of the gene encoding cardiac-specific natriuretic peptide precursor type A (NPPA) alongside each other, and the 2 transcription factors induce activation. Hiroi et al. (2001) proved this by showing that cell lines over-expressing wild-type Tbx5 gene started to expressed more cardiac-specific genes and started to contract earlier. However, cell lines that expressed a mutation in Tbx5 gene did not differentiate into beating cardiomyocytes which indicates that Tbx5 is crucial in cardiomyocyte differentiation.[29].

GATA4 is a transcription factor essential for heart formation has been known to interact with TBX5 to induce normal cardiac septation. An article by Misra et al. (2014), showed that Gata4 and Tbx5 are co-expressed in the embryonic atria and ventricle and that a disruption of myocardial Gata4 and Tbx5 results in defects in cardiomyocyte proliferation and atrioventricular septation. [30] A mutation of GATA4 can result in human congenital heart defects where functional separation of the four cardiac chambers is perturbed[31]. Therefore Tbx5 is involved in directing gene expression in morphogenetic processes associated with specific chamber formation and any mutations can cause heart septal defects as seen in Holt–Oram syndrome[28] (See 'Abnormalities' section below for further info).

Moreover, cardiac genes Myh6+ and Tnnt2+ cell induction rate was investigated by Zhou et al. (2012) using combining the expression of various genes. The results of the article are summarised below:

Table 2. Multigene transfection efficiency and cardiac genes Myh6+ and Tnnt2+ cell induction rate.

The results from this table demonstrates that cardiac marker protein expression of Myh6 and Tnnt2 was only induced by Tbx5+Myocd (T+M) and Tbx5+Gata4+Myocd (T+G+M) combinations in 10T1/2 non-myoblastic cells . This further supports previous findings that Tbx5 and Gata4 interactions are vital activators of cardiac genes and activated the fewest genes associated with non-cardiac processes[32].

In embryonic development, arteries form within pharangeal arches, and subsequently undergo extensive remodeling that ensures proper outflow connection between the heart and systemic and pulmonary circulation. Tbx1 has been implicated in regulating formation and growth of the pharyngeal arch arteries, growth and septation of the outflow tract of the heart, interventricular septation, and conal alignment. Vitelli et al. (2002) showed that homozygous loss of Tbx1 gene can cause severe vascular and heart defects[33] . This is evidenced through the study done by Lindsey et al. (2001) demonstrated that homozygous Tbx1 mutant embryos do not form pharyngeal arch arteries 3, 4, and 6 [34]. Another study by Jerome and Papaioannou (2001) revealed that mice with a heterozygous Tbx1 mutation had a high incidence of cardiac outflow tract anomalies. They noticed that this modelled one of the major abnormalities of the human DiGeorge Syndrome/Velocardiofacial syndrome and proposed that TBX1 in humans is a key gene in the etiology of this human disorder (See 'Abnormalities' section below for further info) [15].

Limb Development

The initiation of limb outgrowth involves T-box genes as well as Homeobox (Hox) genes. Specific Hox genes are upregulated by retinoic acid in limb fields which then initiates downstream signaling cascades that ensures correct limb growth along its three axes: anterio-posterior, dorso-ventral and proximo-distal [35] [36]. An interesting study conducted by Mohanty et al. (1992) amputated the tails of tadpoles to demonstrate that when their tail stumps were treated with retinoic acid they regenerated legs instead of a tails at the site of amputation [37]. The role of β-catenin in forelimb initiation, however, has not been studied in detail[38].

The initiation of limb outgrowth other transcription factors are expressed to control specific areas of patterning, i.e. forelimb versus hindlimb. Various vertebrate limb models have identified three genes that determine the identity of the developing limb i.e. forelimb or hindlimb. Tbx5 and Tbx4 are T-box family transcription factors specifically expressed in the forelimb and hindlimb, respectively[39][40]. Pitx1, another transcription factor, is expressed in the developing hindlimb, but not the forelimb[41]. From a recent research, April 2016, found that tbx3 also take parts in the limb bud formation and followed by the signalling by the expression of tbx4 and tbx5[42] . The video below shows tbx3 absences in a mice forelimb and that forelimb has no joints.

Adult Tbx3;PrxCre mutant mouse is healthy and mobile despite forelimb deformities. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.07897.007 [42]

Tbx4 and Tbx5 are essential regulators of limb outgrowth whose roles seem to be tightly linked to the Fibroblast Growth Factor (FGF) and Wnt signaling pathways (more information on these two signalling pathways are described in 2016 Group Project 3 and 2016 Group Project 1 respectively). Initial activation of fibroblast growth factor-10 (Fgf10) in the lateral plate mesoderm of the forelimb and hindlimb is regulated by Tbx5 and Tbx4 respectively [43]. It has also been found that Tbx5 binding sites have been identified in the Fgf10 promoter sequence in mice and humans [44]. The Fgf10 signals the overlying distal ectoderm to induce Fgf8, which is crucial for the formation of the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) at the tip of the developing limb bud. A positive feedback loop, regulated by the Wnt signalling pathway, is then established between Fgf8 and Fgf10, such that Fgf10 promotes Fgf8 expression and Fgf8 promotes Fgf10 expression. If Fgf10 is flanked in mice the resultant embryos develop without limbs, indicating the importance of this fibroblast growth factor. A deletion of either Tbx5 or Tbx4 will also cause outgrowth defects of limb buds and the the FGF and Wnt regulatory loops required for limb bud outgrowth are not established, including initiation of Fgf10 expression [45][46].

The important role of Tbx trancription factors is highlighted in experiments where Tbx5 is knocked out or inactivated. In these studies the embryos that develop do so with complete failure of formation of any elements of the forelimb. These studies further support that Tbx5 interacts with Fgf and Wnt to initiate outgrowth of the limb bud. [47][48][40]

A schematic representation of T-box involvement in limb development is outlined in the image below:

Close up of Tbx5 role in the Initiation of Limb Bud Formation[38]

Respiratory Development

Tbx in lung and trachea development[49]

Members of the T-box gene family (Tbx2/Tbx3 and Tbx4/Tbx5) have been found to be expressed in embryonic lung mesenchyme [50] and have implicated in several developmental events: 1) lung bud and trachea specification, 2) lung branching morphogenesis, and 3) tracheal/bronchial cartilage formation [49].

In chick embryos, Tbx4 and Fgf10 have been found to co-express in the foregut mesoderm (in a lung field), in a domain that coincides with that of Nkx2.1 in the endoderm (except in its most anterior portion)[50]. Studies show that abnormal expression of Tbx4 induces ectopic Fgf10 expression and ectopic buds that express Nkx 2.1 molecules. This suggests that Tbx-Fgf10 interaction plays a role in lung morphogenesis as the Nkx2.1 gene encodes a transcription factor that is expressed during early development of thyroid, lung, and forebrain regions, particularly the basal ganglia and hypothalamus [51].

Moreover, Fgf10 genetically interacts with Tbx4 and Tbx5 in lung branching morphogenesis. In an article by Ripla et al. (2012), they demonstrated that both Tbx4 and Tbx5 are expressed throughout the mesenchyme of the developing lung and trachea[49]. They showed that a loss of Tbx5 leads to a one-sided loss of lung bud specification and absence of tracheal specification in organ culture. Furthermore, mesenchymal markers Wnt2 and Fgf10 expression, and Fgf10 target genes Bmp4 and Spry2, in the epithelium is downregulated. This suggests that Fgf10 signaling pathway is activated downstream of Tbx4 and Tbx5 in the developing lung[52]. This is consistent with findings from Sakiyama et al. (2003) that found out that the Tbx4-Fgf10 system controls lung bud formation during chicken embryonic development. Tbx4 was found to trigger Fgf10 expression in the lung primordium mesoderm which then acquires the ability for the initial budding morphogenesis of primary lung buds[53]. Of significance, lung-specific Tbx4 heterozygous;Tbx5 deficient mice died soon after birth due to respiratory distress. These offspring have small lungs and show severe abnormalities in tracheal and bronchial cartilage rings, highlighting the important role of Tbx4 and Tbx5 in respiratory development[49].

Other developmental events

TBX signalling is also involved in many other developmental processes. 2 examples are palate development and skeletal muscle fibre-type determination.

In humans, TBX1 mutation is responsible for the major phenotypes of 22q11.2 deletion syndrome (Velo-cardio-facial/DiGeorge syndrome, discussed in Abnormalities section) as well as non-syndromic submucous cleft palate, suggesting that Tbx1 is a regulator of palatogenesis. A study by Funato et al. (2012) demonstrated that Tbx1 regulates oral epithelial adhesion and palatal development and showed that Tbx1 deficient mice had abnormal epithelial adhesion between the palate and mandible which led to several forms of cleft palate phenotypes, including submucosal cleft palate and soft palate cleft similar to human conditions[54][55].

Skeletal muscle comprises of a mosaic pattern of slow oxidative myofibres and fast glycolytic myofibres that influences muscle function and whole body metabolism. The mesodermal transcription factor Tbx15 is specifically expressed in glycolytic myofibres. Inactivation of Tbx15 leads to muscle size reduction due to a decrease in the number of glycolytic fibres, associated with a small increase in the number of oxidative fibres. This shift in fibre composition results in a subsequent shift of substrates from muscle to fat and liver where they are stored as lipids, leading to increased adiposity and glucose intolerance. The mechanism by which this occurs involves the activation of AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) signalling and a decrease in insulin growth factor 2 (Igf2) expression. Tbx15 is one of the few known transcription factors that are critical regulators of fibre-type distribution and skeletal muscle metabolism in the embryonic and post-natal period [56][57].

Quiz 2

<quiz display=simple>

{In the developing heart, Tbx5 expression can detected as early as stage 12 |type="()"} + true - false || True. Tbx5 is detected along the entire rostrocaudal length of the fused heart tube

{Which pathways are the Tbx4 and Tbx5 genes linked to in limb outgrowth regulation? |type="()"} - The Notch signalling pathway + Fibroblast growth factor and Wnt signalling pathways - Sonic Hedgehog - Wnt and sonic hedgehog signalling pathways || Fibroblast growth factor and Wnt signalling pathways are closely associated to the signalling associated with Tbx 4 and 5 in limb outgrowth regulation.

{ Fgf10 genetically interacts with Tbx4 and Tbx5 in lung branching morphogenesis |type="()"} -False +True || True

{Which parts of lung development do the Tbx genes regulate? |type="()"} + lung bud and trachea specification, lunch branching and tracheal/bronchial cartilage formation - Formation of the tracheal bifurcation only - Development of intercostal muscles and the respiratory diaphragm || The Tbx genes are respobsible for the regulation of lung bud and trachea specification, lung branching morphogenesis, and tracheal/bronchial cartilage formation

{Is the Fgf10 signalling pathway activated upstream or downstream of Tbx4 and 5 in the developing lung? |type="()"} - Upstream + Downstream || Downstream. The Fgf10 signaling pathway is activated downstream of Tbx4 and Tbx5 in the developing lung



A number of human disorders have been linked to mutations in T-box genes, confirming their medical importance. They include Holt– Oram syndrome/TBX5, Ulnar-Mammary syndrome/TBX3, and more recently DiGeorge syndrome/TBX1, ACTH deficiency/TBX19 and cleft palate with ankyloglossia/TBX22 and it is trusted that more disease would be found. [40] [58] [59]

TBX1/DiGeorge Syndrome

The TBX1 gene can be mapped on chromosome 21 within the DiGeorge syndrome region. Studies using mice, have shown that the TBX1 gene is haploinsufficient.[60] This means that while although mice are diploid organisms, only one functional copy of the gene exists, while the other copy has undergone a mutation, making it inactivated. This single gene is unable to produce sufficient amounts of the protein needed for TBX1 to carry out its function- the development of pouches and pharyngeal arches in these mice. In this study of mice, a deficiency of the TBx1 gene resulted in heart defects, hence suggesting the close association between the TBx1 gene and cardiovascular development.

In this study, a mouse model was used where the relevant region on chromosome 16 of the mice species, corresponding to chromosome 22q11.2, or del22q11, in humans, was deleted. [61] These 'mutated' mice exhibited a range of cardiovascular abnormalities and defects, as well as behavioural changes. They also revealed incomplete or mutated pharangeal arch and pouch development. Tbx 1 (7-9) was identified as the gene responsible for these cardiovascular malformations. The normal development of the cochlear and vestibular organs was also observed in these mice. Thus, Tbx1 was also identified as crucial for the development of otic epithelial cells, which then later contribute to the development of these inner ear organs. These defects are also exhibited in the birth defects in humans, hence making this mouse model highly effective and suitable. [60] For more information see here

TBX3/Ulnar-Mammary Syndrome

Mutations of the TBX3 gene leads to ulnar-mammary syndrome, caused by a reduce in the levels of the functional proteins needed for normal development of limbs, mammary glands and other structures. Like DiGeorge Syndrome, this syndrome is a result of the haploinsufficiency of TBX3. This disorder is expressed in abnormalities of the limbs, teeth, genitals and mammary glands. [62] Again, animal models of mice have shown abnormalities in mammary glands, limbs and genitalia, often dying before birth. These abnormalities are often characterised by short, stunted growth of the hindlimbs of mice, as well as missing elements to the forelimb. Images of these can be seen on the right.

On the other hand, when this gene is abundant and over-expressed, cancers in the breast, liver and skin have been seen to develop, as high levels of this gene assist in the development of tumours. Lung cancers, breast cancers, ovarian cancers, bladder cancers and liver tumours have been shown to have high levels of the TBX3 gene. [62] For more information see here

a-c: ums patient and d-f: mother of patient, normal [63]

TBX5/Holt– Oram Syndrome

shortened thumb (Fig. 1A). radial flexion (Fig. 1B). enlarged heart (Fig. 1C). [64]
Mutations of the TBX5 gene has been shown to cause defects in cardiac septation and the production of isomers in humans affected with holt-oran syndrome. [65] The TBX5 gene is mutated in affected individuals, on chromosome 12q24. [66] Holt-Oram syndrome is an autosomal-dominant disorder, and in humans, is expressed by deformities of the upper limb, the shoulder girdle as well as defects in the septa of the heart. Animal models such as chicks have been used, where the overexpression of this gene in chicken embryos has resulted in incomplete growth of the myocardium and the trabeculae and septa of the heart. In humans, the overexpression and mutation of this gene has also been shown to inhibit normal cardiac development. This is because TBX5 is responsible for the normal proliferation of cells during cardiac development. [67]Thumb anomaly is another expression of holt-oran syndrome, where the thumb may be completely absent, or may develop as another finger-like digit, not different from the other digits of the finger. Other indicators of this disease are heart and skeletal lesions, patent ductus arteriosus (PDA), malformation of the ventricles in the heart, mitral valve prolapse and superior vena cava anomaly. [66] These thumb abnormalities can be seen in the images on the left.

For more information see here

TBX19/Isolated Adrenocorticotropic Hormone (ACTH) Deficiency

The TBx19 gene initiates the transcription process of the Proopiomelanocortin (POMC) gene. [60] This gene contains the instructions for the synthesis of the proopiomelanocortin protein. This protein is further transformed into smaller peptides which bind to proteins in the body, initiating various signalling pathways throughout the body. When this gene is mutated, congenital isolated adrenocorticotropic hormone deficiency develops, caused by the reduction of the secretion of Isolated adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) from the anterior pituitary gland. This is because ACTH-producing cells of the pituitary gland are damaged and cannot secrete sufficient amounts of adrenocorticotropic hormone. [68] This results in severe hypoglycaemia and seizures in neonates. Cholestatic Liver disease also arises from this mutation, blocking or reducing the normal flow of bile through the liver. [68]This disease has also been seen to cause a range of other clinical symptoms, including urinary incontinence, gait disturbance and dementia in older patients. Ventricular enlargement in the brain, loss of appetite and vomiting are other symptoms associated with isolated ACTH deficiency. The main treatment for this disease is hormone replacement therapy. [60] For more information see here

(A) Normal lip and palate. (B) Unilateral cleft palate. (C) Bilateral cleft palate. (D) Cleft uvula. (E) Submucous cleft palate. [69]

TBX22/Cleft Palate

Studies on mice with cleft palate have shown that the mutations of the gene encoding TBX22, causing the gene to no longer function. Tbx22 is involved in the development of the intramembranous bone formation of the posterior hard palate, rather than palate closure, and hence a mutation of this gene results in cleft palate. These mutations of the TBX22 gene included frame shifts of the gene, splices, nonsense and missense changes to the gene sequence. TBX22 is regulated by the Mn1 transcription factor, working together to achieve normal palate development. Mutations of Tbx1 and Tbx10 are also responsible for cleft palate. The mutation of this gene also causes ankyloglossia, the development of a short and thick lingual frenulum under the tongue, limiting tongue movement. This can be corrected by surgery. Choanal atresia, a blockage of the nasal airway, was also seen in affected mice. Other developmental mutations can be seen in the incomplete formation of the vomer bone in the skull. [70] [71] [72] For more information see here

Quiz 3

<quiz display=simple>

{TBX3 mutations result in Holt– Oram Syndrome |type="()"} + false -true || False. Mutations of the TBX3 gene leads to ulnar-mammary syndrome.

{Mutations in which gene causes DiGeorge Syndrome |type="()"} - Tbx 3 + Tbx 1 - Tbx 5 - Tbx18 || Tbx 1

{ Thumb anomaly is an expression of holt-oran syndrome. |type="()"} -False +True || True. Other expressions include malformation of the ventricles in the heart, mitral valve prolapse and superior vena cava anomaly.

{Which parts of lung development do the Tbx genes regulate? |type="()"} + lung bud and trachea specification, lunch branching and tracheal/bronchial cartilage formation - Formation of the tracheal bifurcation only - Development of intercostal muscles and the respiratory diaphragm || The Tbx genes are respobsible for the regulation of lung bud and trachea specification, lung branching morphogenesis, and tracheal/bronchial cartilage formation

{Tbx22 is responsible for palate closure, and hence a mutation of this gene leads to cleft palate formation. |type="()"} - True + False || False. Tbx22 is involved in the development of the intramembranous bone formation of the posterior hard palate, rather than palate closure, and hence a mutation of this gene results in cleft palate.


Ancient origins and evolution of the T-box gene family

T-box gene family is ancient in origin and it is thought to be found in all metazoans [24]. Due to the increasing availability of sequenced genomes from a diverse group of animal taxa we now know that the origin of the T-box family has been pushed back to unicellular organisms and fungi, in which contain only one or two T-box genes ancestors , including T, have been identified. [73]

With the analysis of the genomes of bilaterian organisms and representatives of the different phyla, four basal metazoan phyla indicate that T is the most ancient member of the T-box family and that the family has expanded throughout metazoan evolution. [4] In Metazoan evolution it seems that genes were added progressively one by one by gene or genome duplication and some of these genes were lost and gained in specific lineages [4]. In present day or extant vertebrates we now know that the T-box family has radiated throughout the vast vertebrate linages and can be grouped into five subfamilies T, Tbx1, Tbx2, Tbx6 and Tbr1 [4]. In the common ancestor of vertebrates and sponges, four of these five subfamilies were already present [73].

Brachyury expression in 7.5dpc CD1 mouse embryos.jpg

Brachyury expression in 7.5dpc CD1 mouse embryos Image from here

Animal models

The gene brachyury is important in all bilateral organisms (vertebrates- chordates and invertebrates such as mollusca). The brachyury gene is believed to have a conserved role in defining the midline of a bilateral organism [74] and is also fundamental in the establishment of the anterior-posterior axis [75]

It is thought to play a role in the development of organisms in the Phylum Cnidaria, and appears to be in defining the blastopore during early development[76]. It is also important during gastrulation where it defines the mesoderm [77], and experiments using tissue culture have demonstrated that the gene brachyury is also important in controlling the velocity of cells as they leave the primitive streak. [78]

Another important role that brachyury has also been shown to have is to help establish the cervical vertebral blueprint during (human) fetal development. In mammals the number of cervical vertebrae is highly conserved; however a spontaneous vertebral and spinal dysplasia (VSD) mutation in this gene has been associated with the development of six or fewer cervical vertebrae instead of the usual seven. [79]

The T-box gene family have been identified in organisms ranging from hydra to humans and due to extensive research by many investigators , we now know that T-box is important in metazoan development including transcriptional activity, genetic targets, developmental regulatory functions, and associated disease mechanisms (reviewed in Papaioannou, 2001).

Organisms used in animal models for T-Box

Animal model studies have been performed in a number of organisms including: Drosophila (the fruit fly), Xenopus (a genus of aquatic clawed frog native to sub-Saharan Africa) zebrafish, avians, and mice. These different animals are used to examine T-box gene regulation in the developmental and disease process [2] since their genome had been mapped out and in order to perform ethically experiments.

T-box genes are involved in the development and patterning of many organ systems and embryonic structures including the heart, limb, eye, central axis, and face. In addition, T-box genes are subject to regulation by singling molecules and also induce the expression of developmentally important signaling molecules, such as retinoic acid (RA), bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs), fibroblast growth factors (FGFs), and Wnts, in different organ systems [2]. T-box proteins can act as transcriptional activators or repressors with a variety of cofactors to regulate expression of genes involved in cell lineage determination, differentiation, and maturation [80]. Overall, T-box genes are integrated into regulatory networks that control patterning, growth, and maturation of many cell types and tissues in the developing embryo.

File:Evolution of T box gene Family.jpg
This figure is modified from Papaioannou (2014) [4]and shows the subfamilies or classes of genes that have been identified in the different animal groups that are indicated in green in the boxes. What can be demonstrated is that there has been a remarkable conservation of transcription factors between lineages that have been evolving independently since the last common ancestor to metazoans, and many of the T-box gene families have their origin at the base of the tree. However, diversification at the onset of metazoan evolution is evident. T, which is the most ancient T-box gene, is represented in unicellular organisms, as is Tbx7/8, a class not present in Bilateria. Sponges have a diverse set of T-box genes including several that have not been retained in Bilateria, whereas Tbx6 subfamily genes apparently arose in Bilateria. Note that this diagram represents one possible order of divergence of phyla.

T-box in Placental Mammals: Mouse

Mus musculus

Brachyury was the first T-box gene to be discovered, and is the most studied gene so far in the T-box gene family. As mentioned above it was discovered in the mouse through a semi-dominant mutation in which heterozygotes have short tails and the homozygotes are distinguished by embryonic lethality. That short tailed heterozygotes have the hall mark short tail and this is why the whole family of T-Box gene family bears the T for tail. The brachyury gene is responsible for the development of the posterior mesoderm during the gastrulation phase. In homozygote mice, the anterior part of the embryo develops normally, however the axial and posterior mesoderm structures develop abnormally. There is no connection with the allantois and chorion and without a vascular connection between the embryo and the placental and the embryo does not survive [81]. See more information on Mouse development

T-box in Fish: Zebra fish

Danio rerio

T-box orthologs have been recognised in different species. Brachyura expression using genetic analysis was found to be confined to tissues that showed developmental defects in mutants. In the Zebrafish ortholog the zf-T is expressed as a nuclear protein in a pattern that resembles mouse T. A mutant in this gene in the zebrafish is called "no tail" and has a similar phenotype that seen in mouse mutations. See more information on Zebrafish Development

T-box in Insects: Fruit fly

Drosophila melanogaster

The Drosophila ortholog of Brachyury is dm-Trg and mutations in the Drosophila ortholog shows effects in the posterior structures of the fly, which are possibly analogous to the posterior structures found in mammals. See more information on Fly Development

T-Box in Amphibia: Clawed frog

Xenopus leaves

Using molecular developmental techniques the role of Brachyury was further examined in the frog Xenopus laevis The Xenopus homologue of Brachyury, Xbra, was cloned by Smith and coworkers in 1991 [82] . This study was based on sequence homology between the frog and mouse sequences, and its expression has shown to represent a true orthologue of the mouse gene with a high degree of similarity in both sequence and expression pattern. In the unfertilised egg, low levels of maternal Xbra are found, but the gene is expressed predominantly at the mid-blastula to neurula stages[82]. Studies in Xenopus have contributed significantly in understanding the mechanism of action of Xbra and the Brachyury gene and have shown that the activation of Xbra in response to mesoderm inducing factors. See more information on Frog Development

T-Box in Aves: Chick

Gallus gallus domesticus

In the avian model (the chick) the following T-box genes have been isolated Tbx-2, Tbx-3, Tbx-4, and Tbx-5 and, like the mouse homologues, are expressed in the limb regions [14]. Other Tbox genes cTbx2, cTbx3, and cTbx5 have been found to also be involved in the chick embryo heart development. See more information on Chicken Development

File:T box in chick.jpg
This image above demonstrates Tbx4 and Tbx5 genes Expression (marked by arrows) of Tbx4 (a, b) and Tbx5 (c, d) in the developing chick embryo at early (a, c) and late (b, d) limb-bud stages. Note that Tbx4 is expressed in the hindlimb and Tbx5 in the forelimb. Image taken from[83]

T-box gene in Marsupial forelimb development: Wallaby

Macropus eugenii

A study [84] published in 2012 describes for the first time the T Box gene expression in marsupials in the Tammar wallaby (Macropus eugenii). This study describes how these genes are also responsible for limb and digit formation in marsupials. Marsupials mammals differ from placental mammals because at birth, neonates are born highly altricial and not very developed. They lack fur, their eyes and ears are not developed and most of the skeleton is still cartilaginous. Another interesting feature that is observed in all marsupial neonates is that the forelimbs are more "developed" than the hindlimb. This is believed to be an adaptation to aid the tiny neonate after birth to climb from the urogenital opening to the pouch or the mammary area. The neonate can attach to the teat where it completes its development.

This image above demonstrates the development of tammar fetal limbs at selected stages before birth. (A) day 19, (B) day 20, (C) day 22, (D) day 24 and (E) day 25 (one day before birth). High magnification of the fore- and hindlimb are from samples stored in methanol whilst wholemounts were stored in 70% ethanol. A diagrammatic representation of the fore and hindlimb at day 24 and day 25 is provided showing dorsal and ventral views. All limbs are viewed from the dorsal aspect unless indicated. NB: images not to scale. [84]

At birth marsupials are born with a more developed forelimb than hindlimb. The more developed forelimb can be observed in the tammar wallaby (Macropus eugenii) which clearly demonstrates that the hindlimb development clearly lags behind the forelimb development. However some other marsupials such as the South American didelphid Monodelphis domestica also known as grey short-tailed opossum, has significantly less difference between forelimb and hindlimb development at birth, however there is still more development in the forelimbs than the hindlimb. This may be because Mondelphis domestica does not have to climb such a distance to the pouch as the tammar wallaby, and also because gestation is less for didelphid marsupials than for macropods. This recent study [84] has demonstrated that the key patterning T box genes TBX4, TBX5, PITX1, FGF8, and SHH are also involved in the developing limb buds in the tammar wallaby. The results show that all the T box genes examined were highly conserved in the tammar wallaby with orthologues from opossum and mouse. TBX4 expression appeared earlier in development in the tammar wallaby than in the mouse, but appeared later in the tammar wallaby than in the opossum. Other results demonstrate that SHH expression is restricted to the zone of polarising activity, while TBX5 (forelimb) and PITX1 (hindlimb) showed diffuse mRNA expression. FGF8 is specifically localised to the apical ectodermal ridge, which is more prominent than in the opossum. The conclusions of this study demonstrate that in kangaroos and wallabies there is a very marked difference in limb size when the forelimb is compared to the hindlimb. The faster development of the fore limb compared to that of the hind limb correlates with the early timing of the expression of the key patterning genes in these limbs. See also See more information on Kangaroo development

T-Box in Amphioxus

Branchiostoma lanceolatum

The lancelets ( also known as amphioxus -singular or amphioxi- plural) consist of 32 species of fish-like marine chordates and all are placed in the order Amphioxiformes. They have a distribution in shallow temperate and tropical seas. The amphioxus is a bilaterian cephalochordate and is considered a close relative of vertebrates. They are important in the study of zoology as they provide indications of the evolutionary origin of vertebrates and how vertebrate organisms have evolved. Lancelets have split from vertebrate more than 520 million years ago, however their genomes give us insite on how vertebrates evolved and how vertebrates have employed old genes for new functions.They are regarded as similar to the archetypal vertebrate form.

In amphioxus two brachyury like genes have been found and are referred to as paralogous genes which are orthologous to vertebrate Brachyury [81]. Phylogenetic analyses indicate that two genome duplications have occurred in the vertebrate linage after cephalochordates diverged so that each amphioxus gene corresponds to two or three vertebrate genes [4] For example the amphioxus gene AmphiTbx1/10 corresponds to two vertebrate T box genes Tbx1 and Tbx10 so these have arose presumably during genome duplications. AmphiTbx1/10 is expressed in amphioxus during gastrulation in the ventral somites and branchial arches [85] and this corresponds to the mammalian mouse T box gene Tbx1 and the expression of this gene in the ventromedial somites and pharyngeal arches. While the mouse Tbx10 is only expressed in the developing hindbrain [86] Therefore the function of Tbx1/10 in chordates might originally have been involved in branchial arch patterning and ventral somite specification. These functions are retained by the Tbx1 gene while the Tbx10 has lost its role in pharyngeal arch patterning and instead have gained a novel new role in hindbrain development.

This image above demonstrates an overview of amphioxus development and the stages examined in the study by [87] Amphioxus are classified in the Subphylum Cephalochordate and are approximately 22 mm long and are chordates, and considered to be one of the closest living relatives to all vertebrates.


AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK): plays a key role as a master regulator of cellular energy homeostasis. Regarded as a cellular energy sensor responding to changing ATP levels. When ATP is low, AMPK activation positively regulates signaling pathways that replenish cellular ATP supplies, including fatty acid oxidation and autophagy.

Apical ectodermal ridge (AER): a thickened area of pseudo-stratified columnar epithelium at the tip of the developing limb bud. It is a major signaling centre for the developing limb.

Congenital: a condition attributable to events prior to birth, could be related to a baby born with disease.

Dementia : severe impairment or loss of intellectual capacity and personality integration, due to the loss of or damage to neurons in the brain.

Heterozygotes: a hybrid containing genes for two unlike forms of a characteristic, and therefore not breeding true to type.

Homologous: existence of shared ancestry between a pair of structures, or genes, in different taxa.

Homologue: something homologous (definition above).

Homozygote: an organism with identical pairs of genes with respect to any given pair of hereditary characters, and therefore breeding true for that character.

Hypoglycaemia: an abnormally dropped amount of sugar in the blood

Insulin-like growth factor 2 (IGF-2): Shares structural similarity to insulin.

Limb fields: areas where the limb buds will develop.

Morphogenetic: the development of structural features of an organism or part.

Motif : a pattern or recurring design

Nkx2-5: a cardiac homeobox protein essential in cardiac development, and mutations in Csx (which encodes Nkx2-5) cause various congenital heart diseases.

Phylogenetic: is the study of the evolutionary history and relationships among individuals or groups of organisms.

Transcription factor: a transcription factor is a protein that binds to specific DNA sequences, thereby controlling the rate of transcription of genetic information from DNA to messenger RNA.

Wild-type: refers to having the gene that encodes the phenotype most common in a particular natural population.

Zone of Polarising Activity (ZPA): a collection of cells at the posterior border of the limb close to the AER, adjacent to the body wall.


  1. Pubmed structure (2010) Crystal Structure of Human Tbx5 in the DNA-free Form, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/Structure/mmdb/mmdbsrv.cgi?uid=81644, accessed 21/10/16
  2. 2.0 2.1 2.2 <pubmed>16285859</pubmed>
  3. 3.0 3.1 <pubmed>14699590</pubmed>
  4. 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 <pubmed>25294936</pubmed>
  5. 5.0 5.1 5.2 Dobrovolskaïa-Zavadskaïa, N. (1927). Sur la mortification spontanée de la queue che la souris nouveau-née et sur l'existence d'un caractère (facteur) héréditaire “non viable”. C. R. Seanc. Soc. Biol. 97, 114-116.
  6. 6.0 6.1 <pubmed>11268043 </pubmed>
  7. 7.0 7.1 7.2 <pubmed>2154694</pubmed> Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; name "PMID2154694" defined multiple times with different content
  8. <pubmed>8344258</pubmed>
  9. <pubmed>9349824</pubmed>
  10. <pubmed>7774921</pubmed>
  11. <pubmed>8530034 </pubmed>
  12. <pubmed>8597636</pubmed>
  13. <pubmed>8988165</pubmed>
  14. 14.0 14.1 <pubmed>9550719</pubmed>
  15. 15.0 15.1 <pubmed>11242110 </pubmed>
  16. <pubmed>14550786</pubmed>
  17. <pubmed>15255957 </pubmed>
  18. <pubmed>15843414</pubmed>
  19. <pubmed>16505380</pubmed>
  20. <pubmed>16376438</pubmed>
  21. <pubmed>19494035</pubmed>
  22. <pubmed>20139965</pubmed>
  23. <pubmed>21331042</pubmed>
  24. 24.0 24.1 <pubmed>7920656</pubmed>
  25. <pubmed>16258075</pubmed>
  26. 26.0 26.1 <pubmed>11572777</pubmed>
  27. <pubmed>9651516</pubmed>
  28. 28.0 28.1 <pubmed>10079235</pubmed>
  29. <pubmed>11431700</pubmed>
  30. <pubmed>24858909</pubmed>
  31. <pubmed>12845333</pubmed>
  32. <pubmed>23144723</pubmed>
  33. <pubmed>11971873</pubmed>
  34. <pubmed>11242049</pubmed>
  35. <pubmed>9655805</pubmed>
  36. <pubmed>8625833</pubmed>
  37. <pubmed>1731249 </pubmed>
  38. 38.0 38.1 <pubmed>26212321</pubmed>
  39. <pubmed>9609833</pubmed>
  40. 40.0 40.1 40.2 <pubmed>10235263</pubmed>
  41. <pubmed>22071103</pubmed>
  42. 42.0 42.1 <pubmed>27046536</pubmed>
  43. <pubmed>9187149</pubmed>
  44. <pubmed>12490567</pubmed>
  45. <pubmed>7889567</pubmed>
  46. <pubmed>9435295</pubmed>
  47. <pubmed>24626928</pubmed>
  48. <pubmed>12736217</pubmed>
  49. 49.0 49.1 49.2 49.3 <pubmed>22876201</pubmed>
  50. 50.0 50.1 <pubmed>8853987</pubmed>
  51. <pubmed>24714694</pubmed>
  52. <pubmed>9916808</pubmed>
  53. <pubmed>12588840</pubmed>
  54. <pubmed>22371266</pubmed>
  55. <pubmed>14585638</pubmed>
  56. <pubmed>26299309</pubmed>
  57. <pubmed>18403917</pubmed>
  58. <pubmed>18505863</pubmed>
  59. <pubmed>15066124</pubmed>
  60. 60.0 60.1 60.2 60.3 <pubmed>1197183</pubmed> Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; name "PMID1197183" defined multiple times with different content Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; name "PMID1197183" defined multiple times with different content
  61. McKusick, V. (1997). T-BOX 1; TBX1, OMIM, accessed 3rd October 2016
  62. 62.0 62.1 <pubmed>3374754</pubmed>
  63. <pubmed>19938096</pubmed>
  64. <pubmed>27652283</pubmed>
  65. <pubmed>11161571</pubmed>
  66. 66.0 66.1 McKusick, V. (1986). HOLT-ORAM SYNDROME, OMIM, accessed 3rd October 2016
  67. <pubmed>17534187 </pubmed>
  68. 68.0 68.1 Genetics Home Reference (2016). POMC Gene. https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/gene/POMC. accessed 3rd October 2016
  69. <pubmed>26973535 </pubmed>
  70. <pubmed>19648291</pubmed>
  71. <pubmed>18948418</pubmed>
  72. <pubmed>17846996</pubmed>
  73. 73.0 73.1 <pubmed>24043797</pubmed>
  74. <pubmed>15034714</pubmed>
  75. <pubmed>11880350</pubmed>
  76. <pubmed>12536320</pubmed>
  77. <pubmed>12921737</pubmed>
  78. <pubmed>3327671</pubmed>
  79. <pubmed>25614605</pubmed>
  80. <pubmed>11148447</pubmed>
  81. 81.0 81.1 <pubmed>9504043</pubmed>
  82. 82.0 82.1 <pubmed>1717160</pubmed>
  83. <pubmed>10203826</pubmed>
  84. 84.0 84.1 84.2 <pubmed>22235805</pubmed>
  85. <pubmed>15372236</pubmed>
  86. <pubmed>12915323</pubmed>
  87. <pubmed>26052418</pubmed>